| Supreme Knight [1] | Deputy Supreme Knight [1] | Supreme Chaplain [1] |
|---|
| # | Office holder | Portrait | Term began | Term ended | Office holder | Term | Office holder | Term |
|---|
| 1 | James T. Mullen | | March 29, 1882 | May 17, 1886 | John T. Kerrigan | 1882–1884 | Rev. Patrick P. Lawlor | 1882–1884 |
| John F. Dowling | 1884–1886 | Rev. Michael J. McGivney | 1884–1890 |
| 2 | John J. Phelan | | May 17, 1886 | March 2, 1897 | William Hassett | 1886–1887 |
| James C. Roach | 1887–1895 |
| Rev. Hugh Treanor | 1891–1899 |
| James E. Hayes | 1895–1897 |
| 3 | James E. Hayes | | March 2, 1897 | February 8, 1898 | John J. Cone | 1897–1898 |
| 4 | John J. Cone | | March 2, 1898 | March 31, 1899 | Vacant | |
| 5 | Edward L. Hearn | | April 1, 1899 | August 31, 1909 | John W. Hogan [7] | April 1, 1899–June 3, 1903 | Rev. Garrett J. Barry | 1899–1901 |
| Rev. Patrick J. McGivney [8] | 1901–1928 |
| Patrick L. McArdle [7] | June 3, 1903 [7] –1905 |
| James A. Flaherty [11] | 1905–1909 |
| 6 | James A. Flaherty [12] | | September 1, 1909 | August 31, 1927 | Martin H. Carmody | 1909–1927 |
| 7 | Martin H. Carmody [13] | | September 1, 1927 | August 31, 1939 | John F. Martin | 1927–1933 |
| Rev. John J. McGivney | 1928–1939 |
| Francis P. Matthews [13] | 1933–1939 |
| 8 | Francis P. Matthews | | September 2, 1939 | October 14, 1945 | John E. Swift | 1939–1945 | Rev. Leo M. Finn | 1939–1960 |
| 9 | John E. Swift [17] | | October 24, 1945 | August 31, 1953 | Timothy P. Galvin | 1945–1949 |
| William J. Mulligan [17] [18] | 1949–1960 |
| 10 | Luke E. Hart | | September 1, 1953 | February 19, 1964 |
| John W. McDevitt [18] [19] | 1960–1964 | Bishop Charles P. Greco [20] | 1961–January 20, 1987 |
| 11 | John W. McDevitt | | February 22, 1964 | January 21, 1977 | John H. Griffin, MD [19] [21] | 1964–1966 |
| Charles J. Ducey [22] | 1966–April 1976 |
| Ernest J. Wolff | 1976–1977 |
| 12 | Virgil C. Dechant | | January 21, 1977 | September 30, 2000 | Frederick H. Pelletier [24] | 1977–1981 |
| John M. Murphy | 1981–1984 |
| Ellis D. Flinn [25] | 1984–February 1, 1997 |
| Bishop Thomas V. Daily [26] | February 13, 1987–April 1, 2005 |
| Robert F. Wade [27] | April 1, 1997–September 30, 2000 |
| 13 | Carl A. Anderson | | October 1, 2000 | February 28, 2021 | Jean B. Migneault [28] | October 1, 2000–October 27, 2006 |
| Archbishop William E. Lori [29] | April 2, 2005–present |
| Dennis A. Savoie [30] [31] | October 27, 2006–December 2013 |
| Logan T. Ludwig [32] | December 12, 2013–December 16, 2016 |
| Patrick E. Kelly [32] | January 1, 2017–February 28, 2021 |
| 14 | Patrick E. Kelly | | March 1, 2021 | present | Paul O'Sullivan [33] | June 9, 2021–July 1, 2023 |
| Arthur L. Peters [34] | July 1, 2023-present |