Ai (Indic)

Last updated
Ai
Devanagari ai.svg
Example glyphs
Bengali-Assamese Bengali Letter Ai.svg
Tamil Tamil-alphabet-aiai.svg
Thai
Malayalam
Sinhala
Ashoka Brahmi Brahmi ai.svg
Devanagari Devanagari ai.svg
Cognates
Hebrew ע
Greek Ο, Ω
Latin O
Cyrillic О, Ѡ, Ѿ, Ꙋ, Ю
Properties
Phonemic representation /ɐi//ɔi//ɛː/
IAST transliteration ai Ai
ISCII code point AD (173)

Ai is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ai is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg . As an Indic vowel, Ai comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

Contents

Āryabhaṭa numeration

Aryabhata used Devanagari letters for numbers, very similar to the Greek numerals, even after the invention of Indian numerals. The ै sign was used to modify a consonant's value ×1012, but the vowel letter ऐ did not have an inherent value by itself. [1]

Historic Ai

There are three different general early historic scripts - Brahmi and its variants, Kharoṣṭhī, and Tocharian, the so-called slanting Brahmi. Ai as found in standard Brahmi, Brahmi ai.svg was a simple geometric shape, and retained the same basic form into later styles of Brahmi. Like all Brahmic scripts, Tocharian Ai Tocharian letter ai.gif has an accompanying vowel mark for modifying a base consonant. In Kharoṣṭhī, the only independent vowel letter is for the inherent A. All other independent vowels, including Ai are indicated with vowel marks added to the letter A.

Brahmi Ai

The Brahmi letter Ai Brahmi ai.svg , is probably derived from the altered Aramaic Ayin Ayin.svg , and is thus related to the modern Latin O and Greek Omicron. [2] Several identifiable styles of writing the Brahmi Ai can be found, most associated with a specific set of inscriptions from an artifact or diverse records from an historic period. [3] As the earliest and most geometric style of Brahmi, the letters found on the Edicts of Ashoka and other records from around that time are normally the reference form for Brahmi letters, with some vowel marks not attested until later forms of Brahmi back-formed to match the geometric writing style.

Brahmi Ai historic forms
Ashoka
(3rd-1st c. BCE)
Girnar
(~150 BCE)
Kushana
(~150-250 CE)
Gujarat
(~250 CE)
Gupta
(~350 CE)
Brahmi ai.svg Gupta girnar ai.svg

Tocharian Ai

The Tocharian letter Tocharian letter ai.gif is derived from the Brahmi Brahmi ai.svg . Unlike some of the consonants, Tocharian vowels do not have a Fremdzeichen form.

Tocharian consonants with Ai vowel marks
KaiKhaiGaiGhaiCaiChaiJaiJhaiNyaiṬaiṬhaiḌaiḌhaiṆai
Tocharian letter kai.gif Tocharian letter khai.gif Tocharian letter gai.gif Tocharian letter cai.gif Tocharian letter jai.gif Tocharian letter jhai.gif Tocharian letter nyai.gif Tocharian letter ttai.gif Tocharian letter ddai.gif Tocharian letter nnai.gif
TaiThaiDaiDhaiNaiPaiPhaiBaiBhaiMaiYaiRaiLaiVai
Tocharian letter tai.gif Tocharian letter thai.gif Tocharian letter dai.gif Tocharian letter dhai.gif Tocharian letter nai.gif Tocharian letter pai.gif Tocharian letter phai.gif Tocharian letter bhai.gif Tocharian letter mai.gif Tocharian letter yai.gif Tocharian letter rai.gif Tocharian letter lai.gif Tocharian letter vai.gif
ŚaiṢaiSaiHai
Tocharian letter shai.gif Tocharian letter ssai.gif Tocharian letter sai.gif Tocharian letter hai.gif

Kharoṣṭhī Ai

The Kharoṣṭhī letter Ai is indicated with the E vowel mark Bukva E (zalezhnii znak). Pis'mo kkharoshtkhi. Kharoshthi vowel sign E.svg plus the vowel length mark Dovgii golosnii (zalezhnii znak). Pis'mo kkharoshtkhi. Kharosthi vowel length mark.svg . As an independent vowel, Ai is indicated by adding the vowel marks to the independent vowel letter A Bukva A (nezalezhnii znak). Pis'mo kkharoshtkhi. Kharoshthi letter A.svg .

Devanagari Ai

Devanagari ai.svg
Devanagari ai sign.png
Devanagari independent Ai and Ai vowel sign.

Ai () is a vowel of the Devanagari abugida. It ultimately arose from the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg . Letters that derive from it are the Gujarati letter , and the Modi letter 𑘋.

Devanagari Using Languages

The Devanagari script is used to write the Hindi language, Sanskrit and the majority of Indo-Aryan languages. In most of these languages, ऐ is pronounced as [ai] . Like all Indic scripts, Devanagari vowels come in two forms: an independent vowel form for syllables that begin with a vowel sound, and a vowel sign attached to base consonant to override the inherent /ə/ vowel.

Bengali Ai

Bengali Letter Ai.svg
Bengali Ai vowel sign.svg
Bengali independent Ai and Ai vowel sign.

Ai () is a vowel of the Bengali abugida. It is derived from the Siddhaṃ letter Siddham ai.svg , and is marked by the lack of horizontal head line and less geometric shape than its Devanagari counterpart, ऐ.

Bengali Script Using Languages

The Bengali script is used to write several languages of eastern India, notably the Bengali language and Assamese. In most languages, ঐ is pronounced as [ai] . Like all Indic scripts, Bengali vowels come in two forms: an independent vowel form for syllables that begin with a vowel sound, and a vowel sign attached to base consonant to override the inherent /ɔ/ vowel.

Gujarati Ai

Gujarati vowel Ai.svg
Gujarati vowel sign Ai.svg
Gujarati independent Ai and Ai vowel sign.

Ai () is a vowel of the Gujarati abugida. It is derived from the Devanagari Ai Devanagari ai.svg , and ultimately the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg .

Gujarati-using Languages

The Gujarati script is used to write the Gujarati and Kutchi languages. In both languages, ઐ is pronounced as [ai] . Like all Indic scripts, Gujarati vowels come in two forms: an independent vowel form for syllables that begin with a vowel sound, and a vowel sign attached to base consonant to override the inherent /ə/ vowel.

Javanese Ai

Telugu Ai

Telugu vowel Ai.svg
Telugu Ai vowel sign.svg
Telugu independent vowel and vowel sign Ai.

Ai () is a vowel of the Telugu abugida. It ultimately arose from the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg . It is closely related to the Kannada letter . Like in other Indic scripts, Telugu vowels have two forms: and independent letter for word and syllable-initial vowel sounds, and a vowel sign for changing the inherent "a" of Telugu consonant letters. Vowel signs in Telugu can interact with a base consonant in one of three ways: 1) the vowel sign touches or sits adjacent to the base consonant without modifying the shape of either 2) the vowel sign sits directly above the consonant, replacing its v-shaped headline, 3) the vowel sign and consonant interact, forming a ligature.

Telugu Ai vowel sign on k, kh, g, gh & ng: Kai, Khai, Gai, Ghai and Ngai. Note that how the vowel sign interacts with the base consonant is dependent on the location of the headline, the absence of a headline, and the presence of a tail to attach to. Telugu Ai matra.svg
Telugu Ai vowel sign on క, ఖ, గ, ఘ & ఙ: Kai, Khai, Gai, Ghai and Ngai. Note that how the vowel sign interacts with the base consonant is dependent on the location of the headline, the absence of a headline, and the presence of a tail to attach to.

Malayalam Ai

Malayalam vowel Ai.svg
Malayalam vowel sign Ai.svg
Malayalam independent vowel and vowel sign Ai.

Ai () is a vowel of the Malayalam abugida. It ultimately arose from the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg , via the Grantha letter Grantha vowel Ai.svg ai. Like in other Indic scripts, Malayalam vowels have two forms: an independent letter for word and syllable-initial vowel sounds, and a vowel sign for changing the inherent "a" of consonant letters. Vowel signs in Malayalam usually sit adjacent to its base consonant - below, to the left, right, or both left and right, but are always pronounced after the consonant sound.

Odia Ai

Odia independent vowel and vowel sign Ai Odia alphabet ai.svg
Odia independent vowel and vowel sign Ai

Ai () is a vowel of the Odia abugida. It ultimately arose from the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg , via the Siddhaṃ letter Siddham ai.svg ai. Like in other Indic scripts, Odia vowels have two forms: an independent letter for word and syllable-initial vowel sounds, and a vowel sign for changing the inherent "a" of consonant letters. Vowel signs in Odia usually sit adjacent to its base consonant - below, to the left, right, or both left and right, but are always pronounced after the consonant sound. No base consonants are altered in form when adding a vowel sign, and there are no consonant+vowel ligatures in Odia.

Kaithi Ai

Kaithi Ai.svg
Kaithi Ai vowel sign.svg
Kaithi independent vowel and vowel sign Ai.

Ai (𑂊) is a vowel of the Kaithi abugida. It ultimately arose from the Brahmi letter Brahmi ai.svg , via the Siddhaṃ letter Siddham ai.svg Ai. Like in other Indic scripts, Kaithi vowels have two forms: an independent letter for word and syllable-initial vowel sounds, and a vowel sign for changing the inherent "a" of consonant letters. Vowel signs in Kaithi usually sit adjacent to its base consonant - below, to the left, right, or both left and right, but are always pronounced after the consonant sound. No base consonants are altered in form when adding a vowel sign, and there are no consonant+vowel ligatures in Kaithi.

Comparison of Ai

The various Indic scripts are generally related to each other through adaptation and borrowing, and as such the glyphs for cognate letters, including Ai, are related as well.

Comparison of Ai in different scripts
Aramaic
Ayin.svg
Kharoṣṭhī
-
Ashoka Brahmi
Brahmi ai.svg
Kushana Brahmi [lower-alpha 1]
𑀐
Tocharian [lower-alpha 2]
-
Gupta Brahmi
𑀐
Pallava
Pallava Ai.svg
Kadamba
-
Bhaiksuki
-
Siddhaṃ
Siddham ai.svg
Grantha
𑌐
Cham
Sinhala
Pyu /
Old Mon [lower-alpha 3]
-
Tibetan
-
Newa
-
Ahom
-
Malayalam
Telugu
Burmese
Lepcha
-
Ranjana
Ranjana ai.svg
Saurashtra
Dives Akuru
-
Kannada
Kayah Li
-
Limbu
Soyombo [lower-alpha 4]
-
Khmer
 / 
Tamil
Tamil-alphabet-aiai.svg
Chakma
𑄭
Tai Tham
 / 
Meitei Mayek
Gaudi
-
Thai
 / 
Lao
 / 
Tai Le
Marchen
-
Tirhuta
𑒌
New Tai Lue
Tai Viet
Aksara Kawi
-
'Phags-pa
-
Odia
Sharada
𑆎
Rejang
Batak
-
Buginese
Zanabazar Square
-
Bengali-Assamese
Bengali Letter Ai.svg
Takri
𑚇
Javanese
Balinese
Makasar
-
Hangul [lower-alpha 5]
-
Northern Nagari
-
Dogri
-
Laṇḍā
-
Sundanese
Baybayin
-
Modi
𑘋
Gujarati
Khojki
𑈅
Khudabadi
𑊷
Mahajani
-
Tagbanwa
-
Devanagari
Devanagari ai.svg
Nandinagari
-
Kaithi
Kaithi Ai.svg
Gurmukhi
Multani
-
Buhid
-
Canadian Syllabics [lower-alpha 6]
-
Soyombo [lower-alpha 7]
-
Sylheti Nagari
-
Gunjala Gondi
-
Masaram Gondi [lower-alpha 8]
-
Hanuno'o
-
Notes
  1. The middle "Kushana" form of Brahmi is a later style that emerged as Brahmi scripts were beginning to proliferate. Gupta Brahmi was definitely a stylistic descendant from Kushana, but other Brahmi-derived scripts may have descended from earlier forms.
  2. Tocharian is probably derived from the middle period "Kushana" form of Brahmi, although artifacts from that time are not plentiful enough to establish a definite succession.
  3. Pyu and Old Mon are probably the precursors of the Burmese script, and may be derived from either the Pallava or Kadamba script
  4. May also be derived from Devangari (see bottom left of table)
  5. The Origin of Hangul from 'Phags-pa is one of limited influence, inspiring at most a few basic letter shapes. Hangul does not function as an Indic abugida.
  6. Although the basic letter forms of the Canadian Aboriginal Syllabics were derived from handwritten Devanagari letters, this abugida indicates vowel sounds by rotations of the letter form, rather than the use of vowel diacritics as is standard in Indic abugidas.
  7. May also be derived from Ranjana (see above)
  8. Masaram Gondi acts as an Indic abugida, but its letterforms were not derived from any single precursor script.

Character encodings of Ai

Most Indic scripts are encoded in the Unicode Standard, and as such the letter Ai in those scripts can be represented in plain text with unique codepoint. Ai from several modern-use scripts can also be found in legacy encodings, such as ISCII.

Character information
Preview Devanagari ai.svg Bengali Letter Ai.svg Tamil-alphabet-aiai.svg
Unicode nameDEVANAGARI LETTER AIBENGALI LETTER AITAMIL LETTER AITELUGU LETTER AIORIYA LETTER AIKANNADA LETTER AIMALAYALAM LETTER AIGUJARATI LETTER AIGURMUKHI LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechexdechexdechexdechexdechexdechexdechex
Unicode 2320U+09102448U+09902960U+0B903088U+0C102832U+0B103216U+0C903344U+0D102704U+0A902576U+0A10
UTF-8 224 164 144E0 A4 90224 166 144E0 A6 90224 174 144E0 AE 90224 176 144E0 B0 90224 172 144E0 AC 90224 178 144E0 B2 90224 180 144E0 B4 90224 170 144E0 AA 90224 168 144E0 A8 90
Numeric character reference ऐऐঐঐஐஐఐఐଐଐಐಐഐഐઐઐਐਐ
ISCII173AD173AD173AD173AD173AD173AD173AD173AD173AD


Character information
Preview
Ashoka Brahmi ai.svg
Kushana Brahmi ai.svg
Gupta Brahmi ai.svg
Siddham ai.svg 𑌐
Unicode nameBRAHMI LETTER AISIDDHAM LETTER AIGRANTHA LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechex
Unicode 69648U+1101071051U+1158B70416U+11310
UTF-8 240 145 128 144F0 91 80 90240 145 150 139F0 91 96 8B240 145 140 144F0 91 8C 90
UTF-16 55300 56336D804 DC1055301 56715D805 DD8B55300 57104D804 DF10
Numeric character reference 𑀐𑀐𑖋𑖋𑌐𑌐


Character information
Preview𑆎
Unicode nameSHARADA LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhex
Unicode 70030U+1118E
UTF-8 240 145 134 142F0 91 86 8E
UTF-16 55300 56718D804 DD8E
Numeric character reference 𑆎𑆎


Character information
Preview
Unicode nameNEW TAI LUE VOWEL SIGN AE
Encodingsdecimalhex
Unicode 6582U+19B6
UTF-8 225 166 182E1 A6 B6
Numeric character reference ᦶᦶ


Character information
Preview
Unicode nameKHMER INDEPENDENT VOWEL QAILAO VOWEL SIGN AILAO VOWEL SIGN AYTHAI CHARACTER SARA AI MAIMALAITHAI CHARACTER SARA AI MAIMUANTAI VIET VOWEL AY
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechexdechexdechexdechex
Unicode 6064U+17B03780U+0EC43779U+0EC33652U+0E443651U+0E4343708U+AABC
UTF-8 225 158 176E1 9E B0224 187 132E0 BB 84224 187 131E0 BB 83224 185 132E0 B9 84224 185 131E0 B9 83234 170 188EA AA BC
Numeric character reference ឰឰໄໄໃໃไไใใꪼꪼ


Character information
Preview
Unicode nameSINHALA LETTER AIYANNATAI LE LETTER AISAURASHTRA LETTER AICHAM LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechexdechex
Unicode 3475U+0D936509U+196D43150U+A88E43524U+AA04
UTF-8 224 182 147E0 B6 93225 165 173E1 A5 AD234 162 142EA A2 8E234 168 132EA A8 84
Numeric character reference ඓඓᥭᥭꢎꢎꨄꨄ


Character information
Preview𑘋 Kaithi Ai.svg
Unicode nameMODI LETTER AIKAITHI LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechex
Unicode 71179U+1160B69770U+1108A
UTF-8 240 145 152 139F0 91 98 8B240 145 130 138F0 91 82 8A
UTF-16 55301 56843D805 DE0B55300 56458D804 DC8A
Numeric character reference 𑘋𑘋𑂊𑂊


Character information
Preview𑒌
Unicode nameTIRHUTA LETTER AILIMBU VOWEL SIGN AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechex
Unicode 70796U+1148C6436U+1924
UTF-8 240 145 146 140F0 91 92 8C225 164 164E1 A4 A4
UTF-16 55301 56460D805 DC8C64361924
Numeric character reference 𑒌𑒌ᤤᤤ


Character information
Preview𑚇𑈅𑊷
Unicode nameTAKRI LETTER AIKHOJKI LETTER AIKHUDAWADI LETTER AI
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechex
Unicode 71303U+1168770149U+1120570327U+112B7
UTF-8 240 145 154 135F0 91 9A 87240 145 136 133F0 91 88 85240 145 138 183F0 91 8A B7
UTF-16 55301 56967D805 DE8755300 56837D804 DE0555300 57015D804 DEB7
Numeric character reference 𑚇𑚇𑈅𑈅𑊷𑊷


Character information
Preview
Unicode nameBALINESE LETTER AIKARAJAVANESE LETTER AISUNDANESE LETTER AE
Encodingsdecimalhexdechexdechex
Unicode 6928U+1B1043405U+A98D7046U+1B86
UTF-8 225 172 144E1 AC 90234 166 141EA A6 8D225 174 134E1 AE 86
Numeric character reference ᬐᬐꦍꦍᮆᮆ



Related Research Articles

Jha is the ninth consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, jha is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

Ṇa is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ṇa is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As with the other cerebral consonants, ṇa is not found in most scripts for Tai, Sino-Tibetan, and other non-Indic languages, except for a few scripts, which retain these letters for transcribing Sanskrit religious terms.

Ba is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ba is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

Bha is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Bha is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

La is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, La is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

Śa or Sha is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Śa is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

Ha is a consonant of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ha is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter .

A is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, A is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the "A" vowel inherently, and thus there is no modifier sign for "A" in Indic scripts.

Ā is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Aa is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, "Ā" comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent short "A" vowel.

I is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, I is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, "I" comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

Ī is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ii is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter . As an Indic vowel, Ī comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

U is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, U is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, U comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

Ū is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ū is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter . As an Indic vowel, Ū comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

is a vowel symbol, or vocalic consonant, of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ṛ is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, Ṛ comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

is a vowel-like letter of Indic abugidas, often referred to as a "vocalic R̄". In modern Indic scripts, Ṝ is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter . As an ostensible Indic vowel, Ṝ comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

or Vocalic L is a vowel symbol of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ḷ is derived from the Brahmi letter . As an Indic vowel, Ḷ comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Ḹ is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter . As an Indic vowel, Ḹ comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

E is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, E is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, E comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

O is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, O is derived from the early "Ashoka" Brahmi letter after having gone through the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, O comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

Au is a vowel of Indic abugidas. In modern Indic scripts, Au is derived from the middle "Kushana" Brahmi letter , and the Gupta letter . As an Indic vowel, Au comes in two normally distinct forms: 1) as an independent letter, and 2) as a vowel sign for modifying a base consonant. Bare consonants without a modifying vowel sign have the inherent "A" vowel.

References

  1. Ifrah, Georges (2000). The Universal History of Numbers. From Prehistory to the Invention of the Computer. New York: John Wiley & Sons. pp. 447–450. ISBN   0-471-39340-1.
  2. Bühler, Georg (1898). "On the Origin of the Indian Brahmi Alphabet". archive.org. Karl J. Trübner. Retrieved 10 June 2020.
  3. Evolutionary chart, Journal of the Asiatic Society of Bengal Vol 7, 1838