History of the International Phonetic Alphabet

Last updated

The latest chart of the International Phonetic Alphabet, revised to 2020 IPA chart 2020.svg
The latest chart of the International Phonetic Alphabet, revised to 2020

The International Phonetic Alphabet was created soon after the International Phonetic Association was established in the late 19th century. It was intended as an international system of phonetic transcription for oral languages, originally for pedagogical purposes. The Association was established in Paris in 1886 by French and British language teachers led by Paul Passy. The prototype of the alphabet appeared in Phonetic Teachers' Association (1888b). The Association based their alphabet upon the Romic alphabet of Henry Sweet, which in turn was based on the Phonotypic Alphabet of Isaac Pitman and the Palæotype of Alexander John Ellis. [1]

Contents

The alphabet has undergone a number of revisions during its history, the most significant being the one put forth at the Kiel Convention in 1989. Changes to the alphabet are proposed and discussed in the Association's organ, Journal of the International Phonetic Association , previously known as Le Maître Phonétique and before that as The Phonetic Teacher, and then put to a vote by the Association's Council.

The extensions to the IPA for disordered speech were created in 1990, with a major revision in 2015. [2]

Early alphabets

The International Phonetic Association was founded in Paris in 1886 under the name Dhi Fonètik Tîtcerz' Asóciécon (The Phonetic Teachers' Association), a development of L'Association phonétique des professeurs d'Anglais ("The English Teachers' Phonetic Association"), to promote an international phonetic alphabet, designed primarily for English, French, and German, for use in schools to facilitate acquiring foreign pronunciation. [3]

Originally the letters had different phonetic values from language to language. For example, English [ʃ] was transcribed with c and French [ʃ] with x. [4]

As of May and November 1887, the alphabets were as follows: [5] [6]

1888 alphabet

In the August–September 1888 issue of its journal, the Phonetic Teachers' Association published a standardized alphabet intended for transcription of multiple languages, reflecting its members' consensus that only one set of alphabet ought to be used for all languages, [7] along with a set of six principles:

  1. There should be a separate sign for each distinctive sound; that is, for each sound which, being used instead of another, in the same language, can change the meaning of a word.
  2. When any sound is found in several languages, the same sign should be used in all. This applies also to very similar shades of sound.
  3. The alphabet should consist as much as possible of the ordinary letters of the roman alphabet; as few new letters as possible being used.
  4. In assigning values to the roman letters, international usage should decide.
  5. The new letters should be suggestive of the sounds they represent, by their resemblance to the old ones.
  6. Diacritic marks should be avoided, being trying for the eyes and troublesome to write. [8]

The principles would govern all future development of the alphabet, with the exception of #5 and in some cases #2, [9] until they were revised drastically in 1989. [10] #6 has also been loosened, as diacritics have been admitted for limited purposes. [11]

The devised alphabet was as follows. The letters marked with an asterisk were "provisional shapes", which were meant to be replaced "when circumstances will allow". [8]

ShapeValue
EnglishFrenchGermanOther languages
pas inputpaspferd
bbutbasboot
ttentanttot
ddendentda
kkindképikuh
ggoodgaigut
mmymamein
nnononnein
ɴgneItal. regno
*ɴthingdingItal. anche
llulllalang
*ʎfille (in the south)Sp. llano, Ital. gli
rredrarerot(tongue-point r)
ʀrarerot(back r). – Dan. træ
querFlem. wrocht, Span. bibir.
ɥbuis
wwelouiItal. questo
ffullfouvoll
vvainvinwein
θthinSpan. razon
ðthenDan. gade
ssealselweiss
zzealzèleweise
*cshechatfischSwed. skæl, Dan. sjæl, Ital. lascia
ʒleisurejeugenie
çich
jyouyakjaSwed. ja, Ital. jena
xachSpan. jota
qwagen
hhigh(haut)hoch
ufullcounuss
osoulpotsoll
ɔnotnoteItal. notte
pasvaterSwed. sal
*afatherItal. mano, Swed. mann.
aeye, howpattemann
æman
ɛairairbær
emennénett
ipitnimit
*œbut, fur
œseulkœnnen
*ɶpeusœhne
ynudünn
*üfür
əneverjegabe
ʼGlottal catch
˗u,Weak stressed uThese modifications apply to all letters
ꞏu,uꞏ,Strong stressed u
u꞉Long u
œ̃Nasal œ (or any other vowel)
ûLong and narrow u (or any other vowel)
hl,lhVoiceless l (or any other consonant)
Mark of length

1900 chart

During the 1890s, the alphabet was expanded to cover sounds of Arabic and other non-European languages which did not easily fit the Latin alphabet. [4]

Throughout the first half of the 1900s, the Association published a series of booklets outlining the specifications of the alphabet in several languages, the first being a French edition published in 1900. [12] In the book, the chart appeared as follows: [13]

Laryn-
gales
Guttu-
rales
Uvu-
laires
VélairesPalatalesLingualesLabiales
Consonnes
Plosivesʔq  ɢk  ɡc  ɟt  dp  b
Nasalesŋɲnm
Latéralesłʎl
Roulées  ʀr
Fricativeshʜ  ɦ  ʁ w)  x ǥ [b] (ɥ)  ç j
ɹ,  θ ð,  ʃ ʒ,  s z
 ʒ
[14]
f v
 ʋ
ʍ w  ɥ
Voyelles
Fermées
uɯüïyi
   ʏı
oöëøe
ə
ɔʌɔ̈ä [15] œɛ
 ɐæ
ɑa
(u ü y)
(o ö ø)
 ɔ̈ œ)
Mi-fermées
Moyennes
Mi-ouvertes
Ouvertes

Initially, the charts were arranged with laryngeal sounds on the left and labial ones on the right, following the convention of Alexander Melville Bell's Visible Speech. [16] Vowels and consonants were placed in a single chart, reflecting how sounds ranged in openness from stops (top) to open vowels (bottom). The voiced velar fricative was represented by IPA Unicode 0x0067.svg (distinct from ɡ, which represents a plosive) since 1895 until it was replaced by ǥ in 1900. [17] [18] ǥ too would be replaced by ɣ in 1931. [19]

Not all letters, especially those in the fricatives row which included both fricatives in the modern sense and approximants, were self-explanatory and could only be discerned in the notes following the chart, which redefined letters using the orthographies of languages wherein the sounds they represent occur. For example:

(ꞯ) [is] the Arabic ain [modern ʕ]. (ꜰ)(ʋ) is a simple bilabial fricative [modern ɸ β] ... (θ) is the English hard th, Spanish z, Romaic [Greek] θ, Icelandic þ; (ð) the English soft th, Icelandic ð, Romaic δ. (ɹ) is the non-rolled r of Southern British, and can also be used for the simple r of Spanish and Portuguese [modern ɾ] ... (x) is found in German in ach; (ǥ), in wagen, as often pronounced in the north of Germany [modern ɣ]. (ᴚ) is the Arabic kh as in khalifa [modern χ]; (ʁ) the Danish r; the Parisian r is intermediate between (ʀ) and (ʁ). — (ʜ) [modern ħ] and (ɦ) are the ha and he in Arabic. [20] (ᵷ) and (ʒ) are sounds in Circassian [approximately modern ɕ ʑ [21] ]. [22]

Nasalized vowels were marked with a tilde: ã, , etc. It was noted that ə may be used for "any vowel of obscure and intermediate quality found in weak syllables". [22] A long sound was distinguished by trailing ː. Stress may be marked by ´ before the stressed syllable, as necessary, and the Swedish and Norwegian 'compound tone' (double tone) with ˇ before the syllable. [22]

A voiced sound was marked by ◌̬ and a voiceless one by ◌̥. Retroflex consonants were marked by ◌̣, as in ṣ, ṭ, ṇ. Arabic emphatic consonants were marked by ◌̤: s̤, t̤, d̤. Consonants accompanied by a glottal stop (ejectives) were marked by ʼ: kʼ, pʼ. Tense and lax vowels were distinguished by acute and grave accents: naught[nɔ́ːt], not[nɔ̀t]. Non-syllabic vowels were marked by a breve, as in ŭ, and syllabic consonants by an acute below, as in . Following letters, stood for advanced tongue, for retracted tongue, ˕ for more open, ˔ for more close, ˒ for more rounded, and ˓ for more spread. It was also noted that a superscript letter may be used to indicate a tinge of that sound in the sound represented by the preceding letter, as in ʃᶜ̧. [23]

It was emphasized, however, that such details need not usually be repeated in transcription. [23] The equivalent part of the 1904 English edition said:

[I]t must remain a general principle to leave out everything self-evident, and everything that can be explained once for all. This allows us to dispense almost completely with the modifiers, and with a good many other signs, except in scientific works and in introductory explanations. We write English fill and French fil the same way fil; yet the English vowel is 'wide' and the French 'narrow', and the English l is formed much further back than the French. If we wanted to mark these differences, we should write English fìl꭪, French fíl꭫. But we need not do so: we know, once for all, that English short i is always ì, and French i always í; that English l is always l꭪ and French l always l꭫. [24]

1904 chart

In the 1904 Aim and Principles of the International Phonetic Association, the first of its kind in English, the chart appeared as: [25]

BronchsThroatUvulaBackFrontTongue-pointLip
Consonants
Stoppedˀq  ɢk  ɡc  ɟt  dp  b
Nasalŋɲnm
Sideɫʎl
Trilled  ʀr
Squeezedʜ  h  ɦ  ʁ w)  x ǥ [b] (ɥ)  ç jɹ,  θ ð,  ʃ ʒ,  s z
f v
 ʋ
ʍ w  ɥ
Vowels
Close
uɯüïyi
ʊ   ʏı
oöëøe
ə
ɔʌɔ̈äœɛ
 ɐæ
ɑa
(u ü y)
   ʏ)
(o ö ø)
 
 ɔ̈ œ)
Half-close
Mid
Half-open
Open

In comparison to the 1900 chart, the glottal stop appeared as a modifier letter ˀ rather than a full letter ʔ, ʊ replaced , and ɫ replaced ł. ᵷ, ʒ were removed from the chart and instead only mentioned as having "been suggested for a Circassian dental hiss [sibilant] and its voiced correspondent". [24] σ is suggested for the Bantu labialized sibilant, and * as a diacritic to mark click consonants. It is noted that some prefer iconic ɵ ʚ to ø œ, and that ı and ː are unsatisfactory letters.

Laryngeal consonants had also been moved around, reflecting little understanding about the mechanisms of laryngeal articulations at the time. [26] ʜ and were defined as the Arabic ح and ع. [27]

In the notes, the half-length mark ˑ is now mentioned, and it is noted that whispered sounds may be marked with a diacritical comma, as in u̦, i̦. A syllabic consonant is now marked by a vertical bar, as in , rather than . [28] It is noted, in this edition only, that "shifted vowels" may be indicated: ꭪꭪ for in-mixed or in-front, and ꭫꭫ for out-back. [29]

1912 chart

Following 1904, sets of specifications in French appeared in 1905 and 1908, with little to no changes. [30] [31] In 1912, the second English booklet appeared. For the first time, labial sounds were shown on the left and laryngeal ones on the right: [32]

LipsLip-teethPoint and BladeFrontBackUvulaThroat
Consonants
Plosivep  bt  dc  ɟk  ɡq  ɢˀ
Nasalmnɲŋɴ
Laterall  ɫʎ(ɫ)
Rolledr  řʀ
Fricative
  ʋ
ʍ w  ɥ
σ  ƍ
f  v
θ ð  s z
σ ƍ  ʃ ʒ  ɹ
ç j  (ɥ) w)  x ǥ [b]   ʁh  ɦ
Vowels
FrontMixedBack
Close
(u ü y)
 ʏ)
(o ö ø)
 
 ɔ̈ œ)
i  yï  üɯ  u
ɪ  ʏʊ
e  øë  ö  o
ə
ɛ  œɛ̈  ɔ̈ʌ  ɔ
æɐ 
aɑ
Half-close
Half-open
Open

ř was added for the Czech fricative trill, ɛ̈ replaced ä and ɪ replaced ı, following their approval in 1909. [33] Though not included in the chart, ɱ was mentioned as an optional letter for the labiodental nasal. ɹ was still designated as the "provisional" letter for the alveolar tap/flap. σ, ƍ were defined as the Bantu sounds with "tongue position of θ, ð, combined with strong lip-rounding". ʜ, ꞯ were still included though not in the chart. [34] was removed entirely.

For the first time, affricates, or "'[a]ssibilated' consonant groups, i. e. groups in which the two elements are so closely connected that the whole might be treated as a single sound", were noted as able to be represented with a tie bar, as in t͡ʃ, d͜z. Palatalized consonants could be marked by a dot above the letter, as in ṡ, ṅ, ṙ, "suggesting the connexion with the sounds i and j". [35]

꭫, ꭪ were no longer mentioned.

1921 chart

The 1921 Écriture phonétique internationale introduced new letters, some of which were never to be seen in any other booklet: [36]

Laryn-
gales
Uvu-
laires
VélairesPalatalesLingualesLabiales
Consonnes
Plosivesʔ [37] q  ɢk  ɡc  ɟt  dp  b
Nasalesɴŋɲnm
Latéralesʎl
Roulées  ʀr
Fricativeshχ  ʁ w)  x ǥ [b] ( H turned H ligature.svg  ɥ)ç j
ʃ ʒ  s z
ɹ  θ ð
f v   ʋ
ƕ w   H turned H ligature.svg  ɥ
Voyelles
Fermées
u  ɯʉ  ɨy  i
 
o  ɤ [38] ɵ  ɘø  e
ə
ɔ  ʌʚ  œ  ɛ
ɐ
ɑa
(u ʉ y)
 
(o ɵ ø)
 
 ʚ œ)
Mi-fermées
Mi-ouvertes
Ouvertes

χ replaced and ɤ replaced , both of which would not officially be approved until 1928. [39] ƕ replaced ʍ and H turned H ligature.svg was added for a devoiced [ ɥ ], but neither has appeared in any other IPA chart and the latter is not supported by Unicode. Also added were dedicated letters for the central vowels, ɨ, ʉ, ɘ, ɵ, ᴈ, ʚ, which appeared again in Trofimov & Jones (1923) , p. 40 and in the chart in Le Maître Phonétique from 1926 to 1927, though without the Council's approval. [40] [41] Of these, only ɨ, ʉ, ᴈ, ɵ were approved in the 1928 revision, with a different value for , until ɘ, ʚ were revived and regained the 1921 value in 1993. The old convention of ï, ü, ë, ö, ɛ̈, ɔ̈ was retained for where central vowels were not phonemically distinct. ə, ɐ were still for obscure or indeterminate vowels, as opposed to the others, which would indicate clear pronunciations.

The book also mentioned letters "already commonly used in special works", some of which had long been part of the IPA but others which "have not yet been definitively adopted": [42]

It also introduced several new suprasegmental specifications: [44]

It recommended the use of a circumflex for the Swedish grave accent, as in [ˆandən] ("the spirit"). [44] It was mentioned that some authors prefer ˖, ˗ in place of ꭫, ꭪. Aspiration was marked as pʻ, tʻ, kʻ and stronger aspiration as ph, th, kh. [45]

The click letters ʇ, ʖ, ʞ, ʗ were conceived by Daniel Jones. In 1960, A. C. Gimson wrote to a colleague:

Paul Passy recognized the need for letters for the various clicks in the July–August 1914 number of Le Maître Phonétique and asked for suggestions. This number, however, was the last for some years because of the war. During this interval, Professor Daniel Jones himself invented the four letters, in consultation with Paul Passy and they were all four printed in the pamphlet L'Écriture Phonétique Internationale published in 1921. The letters were thus introduced in a somewhat unusual way, without the explicit consent of the whole Council of the Association. They were, however, generally accepted from then on, and, as you say, were used by Professor Doke in 1923. I have consulted Professor Jones in this matter, and he accepts responsibility for their invention, during the period of the First World War. [46]

ʇ, ʖ, ʗ would be approved by the Council in 1928. [39] ʞ would be included in all subsequent booklets, [47] [48] [49] [50] but not in the single-page charts. They would be replaced with the Lepsius/Bleek letters in the 1989 Kiel revision.

The 1921 book was the first in the series to mention the word phoneme (phonème). [45]

1925 Copenhagen Conference and 1927 revision

In April 1925, 12 linguists led by Otto Jespersen, including IPA Secretary Daniel Jones, attended a conference in Copenhagen and proposed specifications for a standardized system of phonetic notation. [51] The proposals were largely dismissed by the members of the IPA Council. [52] Nonetheless, the following additions recommended by the Conference were approved in 1927: [53]

1928 revisions

In 1928, the following letters were adopted: [39]

The following letters, which had appeared in earlier editions, were repeated or formalized: [39]

Jones (1928) also included ɱ for a labiodental nasal, ɾ for a dental or alveolar tap, ʞ for a palatal ('velar') click, and the tonal notation system seen in Association phonétique internationale (1921) , p. 9. For the Swedish and Norwegian compound tones he recommended "any arbitrarily chosen mark", with the illustration [˟andən] ("the spirit"). He used in place of ʊ. [54] Apart from and ʞ, these new specifications would be inherited in the subsequent charts and booklets. The diacritics for whispered, ◌̦, and for tense and lax, ◌́, ◌̀, were no longer mentioned.

1932 chart

An updated chart appeared as a supplement to Le Maître Phonétique in 1932. [55]

Bi-labialLabio-
dental
Dental and
Alveolar
RetroflexPalato-
alveolar
Alveolo-
palatal
PalatalVelarUvularPharyngalGlottal
Consonants
Plosivep  bt  dʈ  ɖc  ɟk  ɡq  ɢˀ
Nasalmɱnɳɲŋɴ
Lateral Fricativeɬ  ɮ
Lateral Non-fricativelɭʎ
Rolledrʀ
Flappedɾɽʀ
Fricativeɸ  βf  vθ ðs zɹʂ  ʐʃ ʒɕ  ʑç  jx  ɣχ  ʁħ  ʕh  ɦ
Frictionless Continuants
and Semi-vowels
wɥʋɹj  (ɥ)(w)ʁ
Vowels
FrontCentralBack
Close
(y ʉ u)
 
 o)
 
 ɔ)
 
(ɒ)
i  yɨ  ʉɯ  u
 
e  øɤ  o
 ə 
ɛ  œʌ  ɔ
æɐ 
aɑ  ɒ
Half-close
Half-open
Open

The vowels were now arranged in a right-angled trapezium as opposed to an isosceles trapezium, reflecting Daniel Jones's development of the Cardinal Vowel theory. A practically identical chart—with the exception of ɣ—in German had appeared in Jones (1928) , p. 23. The substitution of ɣ for ǥ was approved in 1931. [19]

The accompanying notes read:

Other Sounds.—Palatalized consonants: ƫ,, etc. Velarized or pharyngealized consonants: ɫ,,, etc. Ejective consonants (plosives[ sic ] with simultaneous glottal stop): ,, etc. Implosive voiced consonants: ɓ,ɗ, etc. ř fricative trill. σ,ƍ (labialized θ,ð, or s,z). ƪ,ƺ (labialized ʃ,ʒ). ʇ,ʗ,ʖ (clicks, Zulu c, q, x). ɺ (a sound between r and l). ʍ (voiceless w). ɪ,ʏ,ʊ (lowered varieties of i,y,u). (a variety of ə). ɵ (a vowel between ø and o).

Affricates are normally represented by groups of two consonants (ts,,, etc.), but, when necessary, ligatures are used (ʦ,ʧ,ʤ, etc.), or the marks  ͡    or  ͜    (t͡s or t͜s, etc.). c,ɟ may occasionally be used in place of ,. Aspirated plosives: ph,th, etc.

Length, Stress, Pitch.— ː (full length). ˑ (half length). ˈ (stress, placed at the beginning of the stressed syllable). ˌ (secondary stress). ˉ (high level pitch); ˍ (low level); ˊ (high rising); ˏ (low rising); ˋ (high falling); ˎ (low falling); ˆ (rise-fall); ˇ (fall-rise). See Écriture Phonétique Internationale, p. 9.

Modifiers.— ˜ nasality. ˳ breath ( = breathed l). ˬ voice ( = z). ʻ slight aspiration following p,t, etc.  ̣ specially close vowel ( = a very close e). specially open vowel (e = a rather open e).  ̫ labialization ( = labialized n).  ̪ dental articulation ( = dental t). ˙ palatalization (ż = ). ˔ tongue slightly raised. ˕ tongue slightly lowered. ˒ lips more rounded. ˓ lips more spread. Central vowels ï (= ɨ), ü (= ʉ), ë (= ə˔), ö (= ɵ), ɛ̈,ɔ̈. ˌ (e.g. ) syllabic consonant. ˘ consonantal vowel. ʃˢ variety of ʃ resembling s, etc. [55]

1938 chart

A new chart appeared in 1938, with a few modifications. ɮ was replaced by , which was approved earlier in the year with the form IPA Unicode 0x026E alt (narrow).svg approved as a compromise. [56] The use of tie bars ◌͡◌, ◌͜◌ was allowed for synchronous articulation in addition to affricates, as in m͡ŋ for simultaneous [m] and [ŋ], which was approved in 1937. [57] In the notes, the reference to Association phonétique internationale (1921) , p. 9, in regard to tonal notation was removed. [58]

1947 chart

A new chart appeared in 1947, reflecting minor developments up to the point. They were: [59]

The word "plosives" in the description of ejectives and the qualifier "slightly" in the definitions of ˔, ˕ were removed.

1949 Principles

The 1949 Principles of the International Phonetic Association was the last installment in the series until it was superseded by the Handbook of the IPA in 1999. [62] It introduced some new specifications: [63]

None of these specifications were inherited in the subsequent charts. ˌ was defined as an indicator of "medium stress". [64]

ʞ was defined as a velar click, whereas previously it had been identified as the Khoekhoe click not found in Xhosa (that is, as a palatal click).

In 1948, ɡ and IPA Unicode 0x0067.svg were approved as typographic alternatives, while it was also acknowledged that IPA Unicode 0x0067.svg may be used for a velar plosive and ɡ (or preferably ) for an advanced one in narrow transcription of a language where it is preferable to distinguish the two, such as Russian. [65] The 1949 Principles recommended this alternation of the letters but did not mention their typographic equivalency in other languages. [50] Nevertheless, the recommendation was hardly adopted, [66] not even by Jones & Ward (1969), who used ɡ and . [67]

1951 chart

The 1951 chart added ɚ as yet another alternative to an r-coloured [ə], [68] following its approval in 1950. [69] Conceived by John S. Kenyon, the letter was in itself a combination of ə and the hook for retroflex consonants approved by the IPA in 1927. Since its introduction in 1935, the letter was widely adopted by American linguists and the IPA had been asked to recognize it as part of the alphabet. [70] [71]

1979 chart

In 1979, a revised chart appeared, incorporating the developments in the alphabet which were made earlier in the decade: [72]

ɻ for a retroflex approximant was approved in 1973. On the same occasion, š, ž, č, and ǰ or ǧ as alternatives for [ʃ,ʒ,tʃ,dʒ] were proposed but the votes were inconclusive. Diacritics ◌̢ (subscript, not attached) for retroflexion, ◌̮ for palatalization, and ◌̯ for indicating non-fricative continuant were proposed but rejected. [74]

The following changes were approved in 1976: [75]

On the same occasion, the following letters and diacritics were removed because they had "fallen into disuse": [75]

On the other hand, ɘ for the close-mid central unrounded vowel, ɞ for the open-mid central rounded vowel, and for the open central unrounded vowel were proposed but rejected. [41] [75] The proposal of ɘ, ɞ was based on Abercrombie (1967) , p. 161. [77] ʝ for the voiced palatal fricative and ◌̰ for creaky voice were proposed but the votes were inconclusive. [75]

In the 1979 chart, ɩ, ʏ, ɷ, previously defined as "lowered varieties of i,y,u", appeared slightly centered rather than simply midway between [i,y,u] and [e,ø,o] as they did in the 1912 chart. ɪ, ʊ, the predecessors to ɩ, ɷ, were acknowledged as alternatives to ɩ, ɷ under the section "Other symbols". ɵ appeared as the rounded counterpart to [ə] rather than between [ø] and [o].

The name of the column "Dental and alveolar" was changed to "Dental, alveolar, or post-alveolar". "Pharyngeal", "trill", "tap or flap", and "approximant" replaced "pharyngal", "rolled", "flapped", and "frictionless continuants", respectively. ɹ, ʁ, which were listed twice in both the fricative and frictionless continuant rows in the previous charts, now appeared as an approximant and a fricative, respectively, while the line between the rows was erased, indicating certain fricative letters may represent approximants and vice versa, with the employment of the raised and lowered diacritics if necessary. ʍ, previously defined as "voiceless w", was specified as a fricative. j remained listed twice in the fricative and approximant rows. ɺ, previously defined merely as "a sound between r and l", was redefined as an alveolar lateral flap, in keeping with the use for which it had been originally approved, "a sound between l and d".

1989 Kiel Convention

The IPA in 1989 (recreated from the 2005 chart; some glyphs may not be accurate) IPA as of 1989.png
The IPA in 1989 (recreated from the 2005 chart; some glyphs may not be accurate)

By the 1980s, phonetic theories had developed so much since the inception of the alphabet that the framework of it had become outdated. [78] [79] [80] To resolve this, at the initiative of IPA President Peter Ladefoged, approximately 120 members of the IPA gathered at a convention held in Kiel, West Germany, in August 1989, to discuss revisions of both the alphabet and the principles it is founded upon. [10] It was at this convention that it was decided that the Handbook of the IPA( International Phonetic Association 1999 ) would be written and published to supersede the 1949 Principles. [81]

In addition to the revisions of the alphabet, two workgroups were set up, one on computer coding of IPA characters and computer representation of individual languages, and the other on pathological speech and voice quality. [10] [82] The former group concluded that each IPA character should be assigned a three-digit number for computer coding known as IPA Number, which was published as the Handbook of the International Phonetic Association. [83] The latter devised a set of recommendations for the transcription of disordered speech based on the IPA known as the Extensions to the International Phonetic Alphabet or extIPA, which was published in 1990 and adopted by the International Clinical Phonetics and Linguistics Association, which now maintains it, in 1994. [84]

A drastically renewed chart of the alphabet reflecting decisions made at the convention appeared later in the year. Additions were: [85]

Tone, which had been indicated with an iconic line preceding the syllable or above or below the vowel, was now written one of two ways: with a similar iconic line following the syllable and anchored to a vertical bar, as in ˥, ˦, ˧˩˨ (Chao's tone letters), or with more abstract diacritics written over the vowel (acute = high, macron = mid, grave = low), which could be compounded with each other, as in ə᷄, ə᷆, ə᷈, ə̋, ə̏.

The palato-alveolar column was removed and ʃ, ʒ were listed alongside the postalveolars. ɹ appeared at the same horizontal position as the other alveolars rather than slightly more back as did in the previous charts. ʀ was specified as a trill rather than either a trill or flap. The alternative raised and lowered diacritics ◌̣, ◌ were eliminated in favour of ◌̝, ◌̞, which could now be attached to consonants to denote fricative or approximant, as in ɹ̝, β̞. Diacritics for relative articulation placed next to, rather than below, a letter, namely ◌˖, ◌˗ (◌I), ◌˔, ◌˕, were no longer mentioned. The diacritic for no audible release ◌̚ was finally mentioned in the chart.

ɩ, ɷ were eliminated in favour of ɪ, ʊ. The letter for the close-mid back unrounded vowel was modified from IPA Unicode 0x0264 baby gamma.svg ("baby gamma"), with a flat top, to IPA Unicode 0x0264.svg ("ram's horns"), with a rounded top, to better distinguish it from ɣ, which represents a voiced velar fricative. ɮ was revived in place of IPA Unicode 0x026E alt (narrow).svg . ɚ was no longer mentioned, and instead a right-hook diacritic ˞ was added for rhoticity; the superscript rhotic diacritics were retired.

ʆ, ʓ for palatalized [ʃ,ʒ] and ɼ for the alveolar fricative trill were withdrawn (now written ʃʲ, ʒʲ and ). The affricate ligatures were withdrawn. The tie bar below letters for affricates and doubly articulated consonants, as in t͜s, was no longer mentioned. The practice of placing a superscript letter to indicate the resemblance to a sound, previously illustrated by ʃˢ, was no longer explicitly recommended.

At the convention, proposals such as W with left hook.svg for a voiced labial–velar fricative, L with reversed belt.svg for a voiceless velar lateral fricative, ɮ for a voiced velar lateral fricative, Turned Y with reversed belt.svg for a voiceless palatal lateral fricative, ŝ, ẑ for "the 'hissing-hussing' fricatives of some Caucasian languages", and for an open central unrounded vowel were discussed but dismissed. [87]

New principles

The six principles set out in 1888 were replaced by a much longer text consisting of seven paragraphs. [10] The first two paragraphs established the alphabet's purpose, namely to be "a set of symbols for representing all the possible sounds of the world's languages" and "representing fine distinctions of sound quality, making the IPA well suited for use in all disciplines in which the representation of speech sounds is required". [88] The second paragraph also said, "[p] is a shorthand way of designating the intersection of the categories voiceless, bilabial, and plosive; [m] is the intersection of the categories voiced, bilabial, and nasal; and so on", [89] refining the previous, less clearly defined principle #2 with the application of the distinctive feature theory. [90] Discouragement of diacritics was relaxed, though recommending their use be limited: "(i) For denoting length, stress and pitch. (ii) For representing minute shades of sounds. (iii) When the introduction of a single, diacritic obviates the necessity for designing a number of new symbols (as, for instance, in the representation of nasalized vowels)". [89] The principles also adopted the recommendation of enclosing phonetic transcriptions in square brackets [ ] and phonemic ones in slashes / /, [89] a practice that emerged in the 1940s. [91] The principles were reprinted in the 1999 Handbook. [92]

1993 revision

Following the 1989 revision, a number of proposals for revisions appeared in the Journal of the IPA , which were submitted to the Council of the IPA. In 1993, the Council approved the following changes: [93]

On the same occasion, it was reaffirmed that ɡ and IPA Unicode 0x0067.svg are typographic alternatives. [93]

The revised chart was now portrait-oriented. ə and ɐ were moved to the centerline of the vowel chart, indicating that they are not necessarily unrounded. The word "voiced" was removed from the definition for ʡ, now simply "epiglottal plosive". "Other symbols" and diacritics were slightly rearranged. The outer stroke of the letter for a bilabial click ʘ was modified from a circle with a uniform line width to the shape of uppercase O. [94]

1996 update

In 1996, it was announced that the form of the open-mid central rounded vowel in the 1993 chart, ʚ, was a typographical error and should be changed to ɞ, stating the latter was the form that "J. C. Catford had in mind when he proposed the central vowel changes ... in 1990", also citing Abercrombie (1967) and Catford (1977), [95] who had ɞ. [96] [97] However, the letter Catford had proposed for the value in 1990 was in fact (a barred ɔ), with an alternative being ʚ, but not ɞ. [98] Errata for Catford (1990) appeared in 1992, but the printed form was again ʚ and the errata even acknowledged that ʚ was included in Association phonétique internationale (1921) , pp. 6–7, as pointed out by David Abercrombie. [99]

In the updated chart, which was published in the front matter of the 1999 Handbook of the IPA, the subsections were rearranged so that the left edge of the vowel chart appeared right beneath the palatal column, hinting at the palatal place of articulation for [i,y], as did in all pre-1989 charts, though the space did not allow the back vowels to appear beneath the velars. [100] A tie bar placed below letters, as in t͜s, was mentioned again. ˞ was now attached to the preceding letter, as in ə˞. A few illustrations in the chart were changed: was added for rhoticity, and i̠, ɹ̩ were replaced with e̠, n̩. The examples of "high rising" and "low rising" tone contours were changed from ˦˥ (4–5) and ˩˨ (1–2) to ˧˥ (3–5) and ˩˧ (1–3), respectively. The word "etc." was dropped from the list of contours, though the 1999 Handbook would continue to use contours that did not appear on the chart. [101]

1999 Handbook

The 1999 Handbook of the International Phonetic Association was the first book outlining the specifications of the alphabet in 50 years, superseding the 1949 Principles of the IPA. It consisted of just over 200 pages, four times as long as the Principles. In addition to what was seen in the 1996 chart, [101] the book included for mid central vowel release, ᶿ for voiceless dental fricative release, and ˣ for voiceless velar fricative release as part of the official IPA in the "Computer coding of IPA symbols" section. [102] The section also included for a voiced retroflex implosive, noting it was "not explicitly IPA approved". [103] The book also said "might be used" for "a secondary reduction of the lip opening accompanied by neither protrusion nor velar constriction". [104] It abandoned the 1949 Principles' recommendation of alternating IPA Unicode 0x0067.svg and ɡ for ordinary and advanced velar plosives, and acknowledged both shapes as acceptable variants. [105]

21st-century developments

The 2005 chart IPA chart (C)2005.pdf
The 2005 chart

In 2005, was added for the labiodental flap. [106]

In 2011, it was proposed that be added to represent the open central unrounded vowel, but this was declined by the Council the following year. [107]

In 2012, the IPA chart and its subparts were released under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License. [108]

In 2016, three versions of a revised chart dated 2015 were released online, each with the characters rendered in a different typeface (IPA Kiel/LS Uni developed by Linguist's Software, Doulos SIL, and DejaVu Sans). [109] [110] No character was added or withdrawn, but some notes and the shapes of a few were slightly modified. In particular, ə˞ was replaced by ɚ, with a continuous, slanted stroke, and the example of a "rising–falling" tone contour was changed from ˦˥˦ (4–5–4) to ˧˦˧ (3–4–3). [110]

In 2018, another slightly modified chart in different fonts was released, this time also in TeX TIPA Roman developed by Rei Fukui, which was selected as best representing the IPA symbol set by the Association's Alphabet, Charts and Fonts committee, established the previous year. [111] [112] [113] The example of a "rising–falling" tone contour was again changed from ˧˦˧ (3–4–3) to ˧˦˨ (3–4–2). [111]

In 2020, another set of charts was released, with the only changes being minor adjustments in the layout, and Creative Commons icons replacing the copyright sign. [114]

Summary

Values that have been represented by different characters

Consonants
Value1900190419121921193219381947197919891993
Glottal stop ʔˀʔ
Voiceless bilabial fricative ɸ
Voiced bilabial fricative ʋβ
Voiced velar fricative G with open slanted tail and stroke.svg Unicode 0x01E5 open-tail character variant.svg ɣ
Voiceless uvular fricative χ
Voiceless pharyngeal fricative (or Arabic ح)ʜħ
Voiced pharyngeal fricative (or Arabic ع)ʕ
Voiceless labial–velar fricative ʍƕʍ
Voiced alveolar lateral fricative ɮ IPA Unicode 0x026E alt.svg ɮ
Voiced alveolar fricative trill řɼ
Retroflex consonants ṭ,, etc.𝼪,𝼥, etc.ʈ,ɖ,ɳ,ɽ,ʂ,ʐ,ɭʈ,ɖ,ɳ,ɽ,ʂ,ʐ,ɻ,ɭ
Bilabial click ʘ
Dental click ʇǀ [short]ǀ [long]
Alveolar click ʗǃ
Alveolar lateral click ʖǁ [short]ǁ [long]
Palatal click ʞǂ [short]ǂ [long]
Vowels
Value1900190419121921193219471979198919931996
Close-mid back unrounded vowel IPA Unicode 0x0264 baby gamma.svg IPA Unicode 0x0264.svg
Close central unrounded vowel ïɨ,ïɨ
Close central rounded vowel üʉ,üʉ
Close-mid central unrounded vowel ëɘ,ëɘ
Close-mid central rounded vowel öɵ,öɵɵ
Open-mid central unrounded vowel äɛ̈ɜ,ɛ̈ɜ
Open-mid central rounded vowel ɔ̈ʚ,ɔ̈ʚɞ
Near-close (near-)front unrounded vowel ıɪɩɩ,ɪɪ
Near-close (near-)back rounded vowel ʊʊɷɷ,ʊʊ
Modifiers and suprasegmentals
Value19001904191219211932194719491951197919891993199620152018
Aspirated ◌ʻ,◌h◌ʰ
More rounded ◌˒◌̹◌̹,◌͗
Less rounded◌˓◌̜◌̜,◌͑
Advanced◌꭫◌˖,◌̟◌̟
Retracted◌꭪◌˗,◌̠,I◌̠
Raised (vowel)◌˔◌̣,◌˔,◌̝◌̝
Raised (consonant)◌̣
Lowered (vowel)◌˕,◌˕,◌̞◌̞
Lowered (consonant)
Syllabic◌̗◌̩◌̩,◌̍
Non-syllabic ◌̆◌̯◌̯,◌̑
Rhoticity ◌ɹ,◌ʴ,◌̢◌ʴ,◌ʵ,◌ʶ˞◌˞
R-coloured [ə]əɹ,əʴ,ɹ,əɹ,əʴ,ɹ,ᶕ,ɚɚə˞ə˞ɚ
Breathy voice ◌h,◌̒◌̤
Labialized ◌̫◌ʷ
Palatalized ◌̇◌̡◌̡,◌̇◌̡◌ʲ
Primary stress´ˈ
High levelˉ◌,◌̄◌́,◌˦
Mid levelˉ◌̄,◌˧
Low levelˍ◌,◌̠◌̀,◌˨
High rising´◌,◌́◌᷄,◌˦˥◌᷄,◌˧˥
Low risingˏ◌,◌̗◌᷅,◌˩˨◌᷅,◌˩˧
Rising–fallingˆ◌,◌̂◌᷈,◌˦˥˦◌᷈,◌˧˦˧◌᷈,◌˧˦˨
Falling–risingˇ◌,◌̌◌᷈,◌˨˩˨◌᷈,◌˧˨˧◌᷈,◌˧˨˦

Characters that have been given different values

Character1900190419121921193219471949197919891993
ʀ Voiced uvular trill Voiced uvular trill or flap Voiced uvular trill
ʜ Voiceless pharyngeal fricative (or Arabic ح) Voiceless epiglottal fricative
ʁ Voiced uvular fricative Voiced uvular fricative or approximantVoiced uvular fricative
ɹ Voiced postalveolar fricative or approximant Postalveolar approximant Alveolar approximant
ʋ Voiced bilabial fricative Labiodental approximant
ɺA sound between [r] and [l]A sound between [d] and [l] Alveolar lateral flap
ä Open-mid central unrounded vowel Open central unrounded vowel Centralized open front unrounded vowel
ɐ Near-open central vowel (unroundedness implicit) Near-open central unrounded vowel Near-open central vowel
ə Mid central vowel (unroundedness implicit) Mid central unrounded vowel Mid central vowel
ɜ Open-mid central unrounded vowel Variety of [ə]Open-mid central unrounded vowel
ɵ Close-mid central rounded vowel Mid central rounded vowel Close-mid central rounded vowel
ɪNear-close front unrounded vowel Near-close near-front unrounded vowel
ʏNear-close front rounded vowel Near-close near-front rounded vowel
ʊNear-close back rounded vowelNear-close back rounded vowel Near-close near-back rounded vowel
◌̈CentralCentralized
◌̆ Non-syllabic Extra-short
◌́ Tense High risingHigh level
◌̀ Lax High fallingLow level
◌̄High levelMid level
◌̌Fall-riseRising
◌̂Rise-fallFalling
◌̣ Retroflex Raised

See also

Notes

  1. œ for English is omitted in the key but nonetheless seen in transcriptions in the May 1887 article.
  2. 1 2 3 4 To be precise, the shape of ǥ is close to G with open slanted tail and stroke.svg in the 1900, 1904, and 1912 charts, and to Unicode 0x01E5 open-tail character variant.svg in the 1921 chart and Jones (1928).

Related Research Articles

Approximants are speech sounds that involve the articulators approaching each other but not narrowly enough nor with enough articulatory precision to create turbulent airflow. Therefore, approximants fall between fricatives, which do produce a turbulent airstream, and vowels, which produce no turbulence. This class is composed of sounds like and semivowels like and, as well as lateral approximants like.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">G</span> 7th letter of the Latin alphabet

G, or g, is the seventh letter of the Latin alphabet, used in the modern English alphabet, the alphabets of other western European languages, and others worldwide. Its name in English is gee, plural gees.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">International Phonetic Alphabet</span> System of phonetic notation

The International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) is an alphabetic system of phonetic notation based primarily on the Latin script. It was devised by the International Phonetic Association in the late 19th century as a standard written representation for the sounds of speech. The IPA is used by lexicographers, foreign language students and teachers, linguists, speech–language pathologists, singers, actors, constructed language creators, and translators.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pharyngealization</span> Articulation of consonants or vowels

Pharyngealization is a secondary articulation of consonants or vowels by which the pharynx or epiglottis is constricted during the articulation of the sound.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Digraph (orthography)</span> Pair of characters used to write one phoneme

A digraph or digram is a pair of characters used in the orthography of a language to write either a single phoneme, or a sequence of phonemes that does not correspond to the normal values of the two characters combined.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Voiced dental and alveolar lateral flaps</span> Consonantal sounds represented by ⟨ɺ⟩ in IPA

The voiced alveolar lateral flap is a type of consonantal sound, used in some spoken languages. The symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet that represents this sound is ⟨ɺ⟩, a fusion of a rotated lowercase letter ⟨r⟩ with a letter ⟨l⟩. Approved in 1928, the symbol represented a sound intermediate between and or between and until 1979 when its value was redefined as an alveolar lateral flap.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Voiced velar approximant</span> Consonantal sound represented by ⟨ɰ⟩ in IPA

The voiced velar approximant is a type of consonantal sound, used in some spoken languages. The symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet that represents this sound is ⟨ɰ⟩, and the equivalent X-SAMPA symbol is M\.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Voiced velar fricative</span> Consonantal sound represented by ⟨ɣ⟩ in IPA

The voiced velar fricative is a type of consonantal sound that is used in various spoken languages. It is not found in most varieties of Modern English but existed in Old English. The symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet that represents this sound is ⟨ɣ⟩, a Latinized variant of the Greek letter gamma, ⟨γ⟩, which has this sound in Modern Greek. It should not be confused with the graphically-similar ⟨ɤ⟩, the IPA symbol for a close-mid back unrounded vowel, which some writings use for the voiced velar fricative.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Voiceless labial–velar fricative</span> Consonantal sound

The voiceless labial–velar fricative is a type of consonantal sound, used in spoken languages. The symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet that represents this sound is ⟨⟩ or occasionally ⟨ʍ⟩. The letter ⟨ʍ⟩ was defined as a "voiceless " until 1979, when it was defined as a fricative with the place of articulation of the same way that is an approximant with the place of articulation of. The IPA Handbook describes ⟨ʍ⟩ as a "fricative" in the introduction while a chapter within characterizes it as an "approximate".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Voiceless palatal fricative</span> Consonantal sound represented by ⟨ç⟩ in IPA

The voiceless palatal fricative is a type of consonantal sound used in some spoken languages. The symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet that represents this sound is ⟨ç⟩, and the equivalent X-SAMPA symbol is C. It is the non-sibilant equivalent of the voiceless alveolo-palatal fricative.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Close-mid back unrounded vowel</span> Vowel sound represented by ⟨ɤ⟩ in IPA

The close-mid back unrounded vowel, or high-mid back unrounded vowel, is a type of vowel sound, used in some spoken languages. Its symbol in the International Phonetic Alphabet is ⟨ɤ⟩, called "ram's horn." This symbol is distinct from the symbol for the voiced velar fricative, ⟨ɣ⟩, which has a descender, but some texts use this symbol for the voiced velar fricative.

In phonetics, nasalization is the production of a sound while the velum is lowered, so that some air escapes through the nose during the production of the sound by the mouth. An archetypal nasal sound is.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">R-colored vowel</span> Phonetic sound in some languages

An r-colored or rhotic vowel is a vowel that is modified in a way that results in a lowering in frequency of the third formant. R-colored vowels can be articulated in various ways: the tip or blade of the tongue may be turned up during at least part of the articulation of the vowel or the back of the tongue may be bunched. In addition, the vocal tract may often be constricted in the region of the epiglottis.

Americanist phonetic notation, also known as the North American Phonetic Alphabet (NAPA), the Americanist Phonetic Alphabet or the American Phonetic Alphabet (APA), is a system of phonetic notation originally developed by European and American anthropologists and language scientists for the phonetic and phonemic transcription of indigenous languages of the Americas and for languages of Europe. It is still commonly used by linguists working on, among others, Slavic, Uralic, Semitic languages and for the languages of the Caucasus, of India, and of much of Africa; however, Uralicists commonly use a variant known as the Uralic Phonetic Alphabet.

Finno-Ugric transcription (FUT) or the Uralic Phonetic Alphabet (UPA) is a phonetic transcription or notational system used predominantly for the transcription and reconstruction of Uralic languages. It was first published in 1901 by Eemil Nestor Setälä, a Finnish linguist; it was somewhat modified in the 1970s.

In phonetics, secondary articulation occurs when the articulation of a consonant is equivalent to the combined articulations of two or three simpler consonants, at least one of which is an approximant. The secondary articulation of such co-articulated consonants is the approximant-like articulation. It "colors" the primary articulation rather than obscuring it. Maledo (2011) defines secondary articulation as the superimposition of lesser stricture upon a primary articulation.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Extensions to the International Phonetic Alphabet</span> Disordered speech additions to the phonetic alphabet

The Extensions to the International Phonetic Alphabet for Disordered Speech, commonly abbreviated extIPA, are a set of letters and diacritics devised by the International Clinical Phonetics and Linguistics Association to augment the International Phonetic Alphabet for the phonetic transcription of disordered speech. Some of the symbols are used for transcribing features of normal speech in IPA transcription, and are accepted as such by the International Phonetic Association.

In phonetics and phonology, relative articulation is description of the manner and place of articulation of a speech sound relative to some reference point. Typically, the comparison is made with a default, unmarked articulation of the same phoneme in a neutral sound environment. For example, the English velar consonant is fronted before the vowel compared to articulation of before other vowels. This fronting is called palatalization.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dania transcription</span> Phonetic transcription

Dania is the traditional linguistic transcription system used in Denmark to describe the Danish language. It was invented by Danish linguist Otto Jespersen and published in 1890 in the Dania, Tidsskrift for folkemål og folkeminder magazine from which the system was named.

References

  1. Kelly (1981).
  2. Ball, Howard & Miller (2018).
  3. International Phonetic Association (1999), pp. 194–7.
  4. 1 2 International Phonetic Association (1999), p. 196.
  5. Phonetic Teachers' Association (1887a).
  6. Phonetic Teachers' Association (1887b).
  7. Phonetic Teachers' Association (1888a).
  8. 1 2 Phonetic Teachers' Association (1888b).
  9. International Phonetic Association (1949), back endpaper.
  10. 1 2 3 4 International Phonetic Association (1989a).
  11. Kemp (2006), p. 407.
  12. MacMahon (1986), pp. 35, 38 n. 20.
  13. Association phonétique internationale (1900b), p. 7.
  14. ʒ (turned ezh) is not supported by Unicode. It may be substituted with (turned three).
  15. Although ä may seem to be a typo for expected ɛ̈, it was not corrected in the next edition of the IPA and so is more likely to derive from German ä.
  16. Esling (2010), p. 681.
  17. Association phonétique internationale (1895).
  18. Association phonétique internationale (1900a).
  19. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1931).
  20. The 1904 English edition says that ɦ is the Arabic and English voiced h -- its use for English, though Arabic has no such sound.
  21. The 1904 English edition describes these sounds as the "Circassian dental hiss". See [ŝ,ẑ] for details on these sounds, which do not currently have IPA support.
  22. 1 2 3 Association phonétique internationale (1900b), p. 8.
  23. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1900b), p. 9.
  24. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1904), p. 10.
  25. Association phonétique internationale (1904), p. 7.
  26. Heselwood (2013), pp. 112–3.
  27. Association phonétique internationale (1904), p. 8.
  28. Association phonétique internationale (1904), p. 9.
  29. Association phonétique internationale (1904) , p. 9, citing Sweet (1902) , p. 37.
  30. Association phonétique internationale (1905).
  31. Association phonétique internationale (1908).
  32. Association phonétique internationale (1912), p. 10.
  33. Passy (1909).
  34. Association phonétique internationale (1912), p. 12.
  35. Association phonétique internationale (1912), p. 13.
  36. Association phonétique internationale (1921), p. 8.
  37. The typographic form of ʔ, which was now sized as a full letter, was a question mark ? with the dot removed.
  38. ɤ had the typographic form IPA Unicode 0x0264 baby gamma.svg , sometimes called "baby gamma", that would later be modified to prevent confusion with actual gamma.
  39. 1 2 3 4 Association phonétique internationale (1928).
  40. Esling (2010), pp. 681–2.
  41. 1 2 3 Wells (1975).
  42. Association phonétique internationale (1921), pp. 8–9.
  43. Unicode supports 𝼪 𝼥 𝼧 𝼦 𝼩 and 𝼨 for 'r', but not the 'z'
  44. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1921), p. 9.
  45. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1921), p. 10.
  46. Breckwoldt (1972), p. 285.
  47. Jones (1928), p. 26.
  48. Jones & Camilli (1933), p. 11.
  49. Jones & Dahl (1944), p. 12.
  50. 1 2 International Phonetic Association (1949), p. 14.
  51. Jespersen & Pedersen (1926).
  52. Collins & Mees (1998), p. 315.
  53. Association phonétique internationale (1927).
  54. Jones (1928), pp. 23, 25–7.
  55. 1 2 Association phonétique internationale (1932).
  56. 1 2 Jones (1938).
  57. Association phonétique internationale (1937).
  58. Association phonétique internationale (1938).
  59. Association phonétique internationale (1947).
  60. Jones (1945).
  61. Jones (1943).
  62. International Phonetic Association (1999), p. vii.
  63. International Phonetic Association (1949), pp. 15–9.
  64. International Phonetic Association (1949), p. 18.
  65. Jones (1948).
  66. Wells (2006).
  67. Jones & Ward (1969), p. 115.
  68. Association phonétique internationale (1952).
  69. Gimson (1950).
  70. Kenyon (1951), pp. 315–7.
  71. Editors of American Speech (1939).
  72. International Phonetic Association (1978).
  73. At some point, rotated of the 1957 chart was replaced with reversed (mirror-image) ɜ of the Kiel convention.
  74. Gimson (1973).
  75. 1 2 3 4 Wells (1976).
  76. Jones (1956), pp. 12–3, 15.
  77. McClure (1972), p. 20.
  78. Ladefoged & Roach (1986).
  79. Ladefoged (1987a).
  80. Ladefoged (1987b).
  81. International Phonetic Association (1989a), p. 69.
  82. International Phonetic Association (1999), pp. 165, 185.
  83. International Phonetic Association 1999, pp. 161–185.
  84. International Phonetic Association (1999), p. 186.
  85. International Phonetic Association (1989b).
  86. Köhler et al. (1988).
  87. International Phonetic Association (1989a), pp. 72, 74.
  88. International Phonetic Association (1989a), p. 67.
  89. 1 2 3 International Phonetic Association (1989a), p. 68.
  90. International Phonetic Association (1999), pp. 37–8.
  91. Heitner (2003), p. 326 n. 6.
  92. International Phonetic Association (1999), pp. 159–60.
  93. 1 2 International Phonetic Association (1993a).
  94. International Phonetic Association (1993b).
  95. Esling (1995).
  96. Abercrombie (1967), p. 161.
  97. Catford (1977), pp. 178–9.
  98. Catford (1990).
  99. International Phonetic Association (1991).
  100. Esling (2010), p. 697.
  101. 1 2 International Phonetic Association (1999), p. ix.
  102. International Phonetic Association (1999), pp. 167, 170–1, 179.
  103. International Phonetic Association (1999), p. 166.
  104. International Phonetic Association (1999), p. 17.
  105. International Phonetic Association (1999), p. 19.
  106. Nicolaidis (2005).
  107. Keating (2012).
  108. International Phonetic Association (2012).
  109. Keating (2016).
  110. 1 2 International Phonetic Association (2016).
  111. 1 2 Keating (2018).
  112. International Phonetic Association (2018).
  113. Keating (2017).
  114. International Phonetic Association (2020).

Bibliography

Further reading