Australian meat substitution scandal

Last updated

The Australian meat substitution scandal of 1981 involved the widespread substitution of horse meat and kangaroo meat for beef in Australia. [1] While the substitution primarily affected meat exported overseas, particularly to the United States, further investigations revealed that these, as well as donkey meat and pet food, had been packaged for human consumption and non-halal meat was sold as halal meat domestically in Australia. [2]

Contents

Background

Claims that meat processing companies in Victoria were substituting other types of meat for beef were brought before the Parliament of Australia by Cyril Primmer in 1977. Ian Sinclair, then Minister of Primary Industry, later announced that a police investigation of Primmer's claims found no evidence of meat substitution. [3] Allegations of meat substitution were made in both the Australian parliament and the Parliament of Victoria over the following years. However, these claims were not seriously investigated by police. [4]

Investigation

The scandal unraveled on 27 July 1981 after a food inspector in San Diego, California, became suspicious of three blocks of frozen Australian boneless beef that were "darker and stringier" than beef should be. Tests revealed that they were horse meat, not beef, and further testing elsewhere in the United States revealed that some Australian "beef" contained kangaroo meat. [5] Some of the meat had found its way into burgers at the Jack in the Box chain, [1] leading to jokes about "Skippy burgers". [6]

In response, the United States Department of Agriculture imposed stringent inspections on Australian beef imports. [1] In 1982, the Australian government launched the Royal Commission into Australian meat industry to investigate. [7] Exports of meat from processing plants in Victoria were also suspended for 30 days. [3] The commission investigated 35 companies [8] and released a report on its findings in September 1982. The commission found that "malpractices in the nature of commercial cheating have been widespread in the export industry." [9] The report stated that companies routinely falsified packing dates and description of meats. It also found that a perception existed in the industry that this was tolerated by inspectors. [8]

However, Appendix H of the report was not published at the time, and was only made available to the public in 2012, nearly 30 years later, after a Freedom of Information request first made by the Canberra Times in December 1982 was finally successful. The appendix noted that:

The flesh of donkeys, goats, kangaroos, buffaloes and horses, killed in the field and without regard to any consideration of hygiene ... was used indiscriminately to produce food for human consumption

Several meat distributors in Australia were found to have purchased low-grade cuts of meat intended for pet food, which they then repackaged and exported for human consumption. Non-halal meat was also substituted for halal meat. Justice Woodward noted that the scale of the operation could not be properly assessed due to attempts to cover it up, but said that the types of meat used as substitutes would be easily obtained in the eastern states of Australia. [2]

Meat substitution was confirmed to have been occurring for at least five years. [4] Sources within Victoria Police claimed that meat processors were being warned when to expect quality inspections by American officials. [3]

A 1981 article in The Washington Post noted that the condition of kangaroos processed for meat did not meet United States standards. In particular, it stated that kangaroos were typically hunted in the field, and then transported hundreds of miles by truck to be processed. [3] The royal commission's report also noted unhygienic conditions at slaughterhouses, including poor cleanliness and the presence of maggots at a slaughterhouse in Katherine, Northern Territory. [2]

Consequences

Ten companies referenced in the appendix had their food-export licenses revoked, effectively shutting nine of them down. Penalties for breaching export-license conditions were also increased from $2,000 to $100,000. [10] The maximum fine at the time, though, for the perpetrators themselves was only $100. [10] Richard V. Hammon, a principal at Profreeze, was convicted of "forging documents issued by or deliverable to Commonwealth authorities" and sentenced to four years in prison. [10]

The scandal led to widespread criticism in Australia of the government and federal police. [4] Critics of Prime Minister Malcolm Fraser claimed that his administration had failed to respond to the scandal until it reached international proportions. [3] Australian Labor Party called for the resignation of Peter Nixon, the Minister of Primary Industry at the time of the scandal. [3] Detractors of Nixon nicknamed the scandal "Slaughtergate", a reference to the Watergate scandal involving US President Richard Nixon. [11] [3]

At the time, concerns arose that the scandal would affect the beef-exporting industry, as the United States was the largest importer of Australian beef. [12] [13] It also affected Australian exports to Singapore and countries in the Middle East. [4] This led to a series of reforms in Australian industry regulations. The 1982 Export Control Act was introduced to regulate the export of meat in the aftermath of the scandal. [14] It introduced new legal requirements for meat-processing operations and required exporters to meet the food standards of countries importing their meat, in addition to Australian standards. [7] The Australian Bureau of Animal Health was replaced by the Export Inspection Service (EIS) in 1982, eventually becoming part of the current Australian Quarantine and Inspection Service. [10]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Beef</span> Meat from cattle

Beef is the culinary name for meat from cattle. Beef can be prepared in various ways; cuts are often used for steak, which can be cooked to varying degrees of doneness, while trimmings are often ground or minced, as found in most hamburgers. Beef contains protein, iron, and vitamin B12. Along with other kinds of red meat, high consumption is associated with an increased risk of colorectal cancer and coronary heart disease, especially when processed. Beef has a high environmental impact, being a primary driver of deforestation with the highest greenhouse gas emissions of any agricultural product.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hamburger</span> Culinary dish consisting of a beef patty between rounded buns

A hamburger, or simply a burger, is a dish consisting of fillings—usually a patty of ground meat, typically beef—placed inside a sliced bun or bread roll. The patties are often served with cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, pickles, bacon, or chilis with condiments such as ketchup, mustard, mayonnaise, relish or a "special sauce", often a variation of Thousand Island dressing, and are frequently placed on sesame seed buns. A hamburger patty topped with cheese is called a cheeseburger. Under some definitions, and in some cultures, a burger is considered a sandwich.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Australian cuisine</span> Culinary traditions of Australia

Australian cuisine is the food and cooking practices of Australia and its inhabitants. Australia has absorbed culinary contributions and adaptations from various cultures around the world, including British, European, Asian and Middle Eastern.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Quorn</span> Meat substitute based on mycoprotein

Quorn is a brand of meat substitute products. Quorn originated in the UK and is sold primarily in Europe, but is available in 11 countries. The brand is owned by parent company Monde Nissin.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Veggie burger</span> Non-meat hamburger

A veggie burger or meatless burger is a hamburger made with a patty that does not contain meat, or the patty of such a hamburger. The patty may be made from ingredients like beans, nuts, grains, seeds, or fungi such as mushrooms or mycoprotein.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Horse meat</span> Consumable meat from horses

Horse meat forms a significant part of the culinary traditions of many countries, particularly in the Americas and in Eurasia. The eight countries that consume the most horse meat consume about 4.3 million horses a year. For the majority of humanity's early existence, wild horses were hunted as a source of protein.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Agriculture in Australia</span> Overview of agriculture in Australia

Although Australia is mostly arid, the nation is a major agricultural producer and exporter, with around 421,000 people employed in agriculture, forestry and fishing as of 2023. Agriculture and its closely related sectors earn $155 billion a year for a 12% share of GDP. Farmers and grazers own 135,997 farms, covering 61% of Australia's landmass. Across the country, there is a mix of irrigation and dry-land farming. The success of Australia in becoming a major agricultural power despite the odds is facilitated by its policies of long-term visions and promotion of agricultural reforms that greatly increased the country's agricultural industry.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Meat-packing industry</span> Industrial production of food and by-products from animals

The meat-packing industry handles the slaughtering, processing, packaging, and distribution of meat from animals such as cattle, pigs, sheep and other livestock. Poultry is generally not included. This greater part of the entire meat industry is primarily focused on producing meat for human consumption, but it also yields a variety of by-products including hides, dried blood, protein meals such as meat & bone meal, and, through the process of rendering, fats.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Peter Nixon</span> Australian politician

Peter James Nixon is an Australian former politician and businessman. He served in the House of Representatives from 1961 to 1983, representing the Division of Gippsland as a member of the National Country Party (NCP). He held ministerial office as Minister for the Interior (1967–1971), Shipping and Transport (1971–1972), Postmaster-General (1975), Transport (1975–1979), and Primary Industry (1979–1983).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ramly Group</span> Malaysian food company

Ramly Processing Sdn. Bhd. is a Malaysian frozen and fast food company founded by Ramly bin Mokni through Pemasaran Ramly Mokni Sdn. Bhd.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bush tucker</span> Food used as sustenance by Indigenous Australians

Bush tucker, also called bush food, is any food native to Australia and historically eaten by Indigenous Australians, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, but it can also describe any native flora, fauna, or fungi used for culinary or medicinal purposes, regardless of the continent or culture. Animal native foods include kangaroo, emu, witchetty grubs and crocodile, and plant foods include fruits such as quandong, kutjera, spices such as lemon myrtle and vegetables such as warrigal greens and various native yams.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kangaroo meat</span>

Kangaroo meat is produced in Australia from wild kangaroos and is exported to over 61 overseas markets.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pink slime</span> Meat by-product

Lean finely textured beef (LFTB)—also called finely textured beef, boneless lean beef trimmings (BLBT), and colloquially known as pink slime—is a meat by-product used as a food additive to ground beef and beef-based processed meats, as a filler, or to reduce the overall fat content of ground beef. As part of the production process, heat and centrifuges remove the fat from the meat in beef trimmings. The resulting paste, without the fat, is exposed to ammonia gas or citric acid to kill bacteria. In 2001, the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) approved the product for limited human consumption. The product, when prepared using ammonia gas, is banned for human consumption in the European Union and Canada.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Steak</span> Flat cut of meat

A steak is a thick cut of meat sliced across the muscle fibers, sometimes including a bone. It is normally grilled or fried. Steak can be diced, or cooked in sauce, as in steak and kidney pie.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">2013 horse meat scandal</span> Food scandal in Europe

On 15 January 2013 it was reported that foods advertised in the European Union as containing beef were found to contain undeclared or improperly declared horse meat—as much as 100% of the meat content in some cases. A smaller number of products also contained other undeclared meats, such as pork. The issue was discovered through DNA testing on frozen beefburgers and lasagna sold in several Irish and British supermarkets.

Laurence Goodman is an Irish businessman, chiefly involved in the beef processing industry. He is the 6th generation of a livestock and meat exporting family and founded what is now ABP Food Group in 1954. He is the Executive Chairman of the company which has grown to become one of Europe’s largest agri-business companies with 51 processing plants in Ireland, the United Kingdom, Spain, France, Denmark, Netherlands, Austria, Poland. ABP employs over 11,000 people. Separately, the Goodman family office has business interests in property, healthcare and productive arable and beef farming.

Halal literally means "permissible" in Arabic and refers to food items that are permissible to consume under Sharia law, whereas haram refers to any substance not permitted to consume. According to the Australian Food and Grocery Council, halal foods must be "free from any substance taken or extracted from a haram animal or ingredient ; [be] made, processed, manufactured and/or stored by using utensils, equipment and/or machinery that has been cleaned according to Islamic law ; and [be] free from contact with, or being close to, a haram substance during preparation, manufacture, processing and storage ."

Impossible Foods Inc. is a company that develops plant-based substitutes for meat products. The company's signature product, the Impossible Burger, was launched in July 2016 as a vegan alternative to a beef hamburger.

<i>Operation Weak Meat</i> Brazilian police investigation

The Operation Carne Fraca is an operation started on March 17, 2017, and enforced by the Federal Police of Brazil, that country's federal police force, which investigated some of the country's largest meat processing companies. The name is a pun between the operation's concern with meat and the Bible verse about "weak flesh" – as a result, it is sometimes translated "Operation Weak Flesh".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on the meat industry in Canada</span> Impact of COVID-19

During the COVID-19 pandemic in Canada, outbreaks of the virus took place in factories operated by the meat packing industry and the poultry processing industry. These outbreaks affected multiple plants, leading to closures of some factories and disruption of others, and posing a threat to the food supply in Canada.

References

  1. 1 2 3 "AUSTRALIAN MEAT WILL BE INSPECTED". The New York Times. 26 August 1981 via NYTimes.com.
  2. 1 2 3 Kretowicz, Ewa (18 November 2012). "How they fed us donkey burgers". The Canberra Times.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Branigin, William (4 October 1981). "Let Them Eat 'Roo". The Washington Post. ISSN   0190-8286 . Retrieved 26 February 2023.
  4. 1 2 3 4 "Australians are hopping mad over kangaroo-for-beef scandal". The Christian Science Monitor. ISSN   0882-7729 . Retrieved 26 February 2023.
  5. Kretowicz, Ewa (17 November 2012). "'Skippy meat' scandal became global joke". The Canberra Times.
  6. "'Skippy meat' scandal became global joke". 17 November 2012.
  7. 1 2 Spriggs, John; Isaac, Grant (2001). Food Safety and International Competitiveness: The Case of Beef. CABI. p. 109. ISBN   978-0-85199-858-9.
  8. 1 2 Curll, Janine (1 January 2015). "The significance of food fraud in Australia". Australian Business Law Review.
  9. Australian Meat Industry - Royal Commission - Report, dated September 1982
  10. 1 2 3 4 Grabosky P & Sutton A 1989. Stains on a white collar: fourteen studies in corporate crime or corporate harm. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology.
  11. Croly, Herbert David (1981). The New Republic. Republic Publishing Company. pp. 8–10.
  12. "An Australian meat company owner said Wednesday he replaced... - UPI Archives". UPI. Retrieved 26 February 2023.
  13. Fitzgerald, Ross (1984). From 1915 to the Early 1980s: A History of Queensland. University of Queensland Press. p. 416. ISBN   978-0-7022-1734-0.
  14. Hooker, Neal H.; Murano, Elsa A. (8 March 2001). Interdisciplinary Food Safety Research. CRC Press. p. 57. ISBN   978-1-4200-3909-2.