Comparison of operating systems

Last updated

These tables provide a comparison of operating systems, of computer devices, as listing general and technical information for a number of widely used and currently available PC or handheld (including smartphone and tablet computer) operating systems. The article "Usage share of operating systems" provides a broader, and more general, comparison of operating systems that includes servers, mainframes and supercomputers.

Contents

Because of the large number and variety of available Linux distributions, they are all grouped under a single entry; see comparison of Linux distributions for a detailed comparison. There is also a variety of BSD and DOS operating systems, covered in comparison of BSD operating systems and comparison of DOS operating systems.

Nomenclature

The nomenclature for operating systems varies among providers and sometimes within providers. For purposes of this article the terms used are;

kernel
In some operating systems, the OS is split into a low level region called the kernel and higher level code that relies on the kernel. Typically the kernel implements processes but its code does not run as part of a process.[ disputed ]
hybrid kernel
monolithic kernel
Nucleus
In some operating systems there is OS code permanently present in a contiguous region of memory addressable by unprivileged code; in IBM systems this is typically referred to as the nucleus. The nucleus typically contains both code that requires special privileges and code that can run in an unprivileged state. Typically some code in the nucleus runs in the context of a dispatching unit, e.g., address space, process, task, thread, while other code runs independent of any dispatching unit. In contemporary operating systems unprivileged applications cannot alter the nucleus.

License and pricing policies also vary among different systems. The tables below use the following terms:

BSD
BSD licenses are a family of permissive free software licenses, imposing minimal restrictions on the use and distribution of covered software.
bundled
The fee is included in the price of the hardware
bundled initially
The fee is included in the price of the hardware but upgrades require an additional fee.
GPL2
GPL3
Per user
The fee depends on the maximum number of users concurrently logged on.
MSU
The fee depends on the resources consumed by the user
MULC
MEASURED USAGE LICENSE CHARGES
PSLC
PARALLEL SYSPLEX SOFTWARE PRICING

General information

NameCreatorInitial public releasePredecessorCurrent stable versionRelease dateCost, availabilityPreferred license [g 1] Target system type
AIX IBM 1986 UNIX System V Release 37.3June 20, 2022Bundled with hardwarePer user Server, NAS, workstation
AIX/370 IBM 1989 IX/370 Release 2.1?Feb 22, 1991Non-free Proprietary IBM System/370

AIX/ESA V1 & V2

AIX/ESA IBM 1992 AIX/370, OSF/1 Version 2 Release 2Feb 26, 1993Non-free Proprietary ESA/370
IBM System/390
AmigaOS classic Commodore International, Haage & Partner, Hyperion Entertainment 1985 TRIPOS (as the disk operating component of AmigaOS) 3.2.2.1 April 23, 2023Bundled with hardware up to version 3.0 (Amiga International hardware came with 3.1); versions 2.1, 3.0, 3.1, 3.5, 3.9 and the more recent 3.2 (2021) also available as separate packages Proprietary, open source clone available under AROS Public License Workstation, personal computer
AmigaOS 4 Hyperion Entertainment2004AmigaOS classic4.1 Final Edition Update 2.1January 12, 20214.0 bundled with hardware; 4.0 for classic and 4.1 available as standalone package at €29 Proprietary Workstation, personal computer
Android Android, Inc., Google 2008None 14 October 2, 2022 No cost AOSP: Apache-2.0
Linux: GPL-2.0-only
Smartphone, tablet computer
ArcaOS Arca Noae, LLC2017OS/25.1.0August 27, 2023Personal edition US$129.00 (equivalent to $145.87 in 2022)
Commercial edition US$229.00 (equivalent to $258.95 in 2022)
Proprietary Server, workstation, personal computer
Classic Mac OS (retronym; had no name originally, later Macintosh System Software) Apple Computer, Inc. (now Apple Inc.)1984None [g 2] [g 3] 9.2.22000Discontinued; Was bundled with 68k and PowerPC Macs;

versions 7.1-9 sold as retail upgrades [1]

Proprietary Workstation, personal computer
ChromeOS Google 2011none114.0.5735.205October 7, 2021Bundled with hardware, 32-bit edition dropped Proprietary: Google OS Terms of Service. Open-source core system Chromebook, Chromebox, Chromebase and tablet
ChromiumOS Google 2009none Rolling release October 7, 2021 No cost BSD
Linux Kernel GPL-2.0-only
Personal computer
DragonFly BSD Matthew Dillon 2003FreeBSD6.4.0June 9, 2022 No cost BSD Server, workstation, NAS, embedded system
eComStation Serenity Systems, Mensys BV2001OS/22.1May 20, 2011Discontinued; Commercial Proprietary Server, workstation, personal computer
EPOC32 Psion PLC 1996ER51999Discontinued; Commercial Proprietary PDA
EulerOS Huawei 2021NoneV2.0SP82022 No cost Open source Server, workstation
FreeBSD The FreeBSD Project1993 386BSD 13.2April 11, 2023 No cost BSD Server, workstation, NAS, embedded system
Genode Genode Labs2008None23.11 [2]   OOjs UI icon edit-ltr-progressive.svg 30 November 2023;2 months ago No cost AGPL-3.0-only Desktop, embedded system, server
GhostBSD Eric Turgeon2009FreeBSD21.05 [3] May 13, 2021 No cost BSD Desktop, workstation
Linux Notable contributors include: Richard Stallman for GNU Project and Linus Torvalds for Linux and the Unixes they emulated; Red Hat, Debian Project See: Comparison of Linux distributions and Linux kernel#Development 1991 (kernel), See: Comparison of Linux distributions and History of Linux None6.7.6 [4]   OOjs UI icon edit-ltr-progressive.svg (kernel)23 February 2024; 25 February 2024;Error: first parameter cannot be parsed as a date or time. (kernel) No cost GPL-2.0-only (kernel)See: Comparison of Linux distributions
Haiku Haiku Inc.2002 BeOS R5 R1/Beta 4December 23, 2022 No cost MIT Personal computer
HP NonStop HP (now Hewlett Packard Enterprise)1974 Guardian H06.24/J06.132012Bundled with hardware? Proprietary HP Nonstop Servers
HP-UX HP (now Hewlett Packard Enterprise)1983 UNIX System V HP-UX 11i v3 2023 / May 2023May 2022US$400 Proprietary Server
HarmonyOS Huawei 2019 LiteOS, EMUI (Android)4.0.0.121September 26, 2023Bundled with hardware and updates at no cost given to most existing users, subject to hardware requirements Proprietary software except for open-source components Internet of things, Smartphone, tablet computer, education, embedded system, smart watches
IBM i IBM 1988 CPF, SSP 7.5May 10, 2022Bundled with hardware Proprietary Server
Inferno Bell Labs 1996 Plan 9 Fourth EditionJune 30, 2009 No cost MIT NAS, server, embedded
iOS (originally iPhone OS) Apple Inc. 2007macOS17.1.1November 7, 2023Bundled with hardware and updates at no cost given to most existing users, subject to hardware requirements Proprietary higher level API layers; open source core system (ARM versions): APSL, GNU GPL, others Smartphone, music player, tablet
IRIX SGI 1988UNIX System V6.5.302006Discontinued; Bundled with hardware Proprietary Server, workstation
IX/370 IBM 1985UNIX System VRelease 1.4?Sep 25, 1987Non-free Proprietary IBM System/370
macOS (originally Mac OS X) Apple Inc. 2001 NeXTSTEP, BSD 14.0 SonomaSeptember 26, 2023Bundled with hardware; No cost for updates and upgrades via Mac App Store for users of Mac OS X 10.6 or later Proprietary higher level API layers; open source core system (Apple Silicon-Intel-PowerPC versions): APSL, GNU GPL, others Workstation, personal computer, embedded
macOS Server (originally Mac OS X Server) Apple Inc. 2001NeXTSTEP, BSD5.12May 2, 2021Discontinued; Previously bundled with hardware; No longer a separate operating system, but a group of services installed atop any version of macOS Monterey; US$19.99 on the Mac App Store Proprietary higher level API layers; open source core system (Intel-PowerPC versions): APSL, GNU GPL, others Server
MCP Unisys 1961NoneCP OS 20.0May 2021Bundled with hardware Proprietary Server
MenuetOS Ville Turjanmaa and others2000None1.49.002023OS written in assembly language GPL or No cost Workstation
MINIX 3 Andrew S. Tanenbaum 2005Minix23.3.02014 No cost BSD-3-Clause Workstation
MPE HP 1974NoneMPE-V1988Discontinued; Was bundled with HP-3000 CISC hardware "Classic" Proprietary Server
MPE/XL HP 1987 MPE 7.52002Discontinued; Was bundled with HP-3000 PA-RISC hardware Proprietary Server
MVS
(OS/VS2 R2 through R3.8)
IBM 1972 OS/360 MVT, SVS Release 3.81974Free (discontinued)Open source IBM System/370
MVS
(MVS/SE through MVS/ESA)
IBM March 1978OS/VS2 R3.7 for MVS/SE R1
OS/VS2 R3.8 for MVS/SE R2 through MVS/ESA
z/OS Version 2.5 (V2R5)September 30, 2021Price tied to processor capacityOne Time Charge or monthly S/370

S/370-XA S/370-ESA ESA/390

NetBSD The NetBSD Project1993 386BSD 9.3August 4, 2022 No cost BSD NAS, server, workstation, embedded
NetWare Novell 1985 S-Net 6.5 SP8May 6, 2009Superseded by Novell Open Enterprise Server; Was US$184 (equivalent to $250.98 in 2022) (one-user) Proprietary Server
NeXTSTEP NeXT 1989Unix3.31995Discontinued; Was bundled with hardware, then sold separately Proprietary Workstation
OpenBSD The OpenBSD Project1996NetBSD 1.07.4October 16, 2023 No cost ISC Server, NAS, workstation, embedded
OpenIndiana Many, based on software developed by Sun Microsystems and many others2010 OpenSolaris 2023.04April 30, 2021 No cost CDDL Server, workstation
OpenVMS DEC (now VSI)1977 RSX-11MV9.2-2January 25, 2024Commercial, no cost for non-commercial use Proprietary Server, workstation
OpenHarmony Various (OpenAtom Foundation, Huawei and others)2020 LiteOS 4.0October 26, 2023 No cost Apache-2.0 Internet of things, embedded system, smart watches
OS/2 IBM and Microsoft 1987 MS-DOS 4.522001Discontinued (see ArcaOS successor); Was US$300 (equivalent to $495.81 in 2022) Proprietary Personal computer, server
OS/360 IBM 1966NoneOperating System/360 R21.8August 1972Free (discontinued)Open source S/360
S/370
OS/390 IBM 1995 MVS/ESA OS/390 version 2 R10September 29, 2000Price tied to processor capacityOne Time Charge or monthly S/390
OS 2200 Unisys 1967 as Exec 8e Exec 8, OS 1100CP OS 18 (Exec 49.2)July 18, 2018Bundled with hardware Proprietary Server
OS/VS1 IBM 1972 OS/360 MFT IIRelease 7.0?Free (discontinued) IBM System/370
OS/VS2 SVS IBM 1972 OS/360 MVTRelease 1.7Free (discontinued) IBM System/370
Plan 9 Bell Labs 1992UnixFourth Edition2003 (except for minor later updates) No cost MIT [5] Workstation, server, embedded system, HPC
QNX QNX Software Systems1982 Unix, POSIX 7.1.0July 2020Bundled with BlackBerry 10 and PlayBook devices. Commercial; an academic version exists that needs authorization code before installing Proprietary Automotive, medical, smartphone, consumer, industrial, embedded system, safety
ReactOS ReactOS development team1998 Windows NT (clone of)0.4.14April 9, 2020 No cost GPL-2.0-or-later Workstation, personal computer
Redox Jeremy Soller2015-0.7.0April 28, 2022 No cost MIT Desktop, workstation, server
RISC iX Acorn Computers 1988BSD 4.31.21c1993Discontinued; Was bundled with hardware Proprietary Workstation
RISC OS Acorn Computers1987 Arthur 3.711997Discontinued; Was bundled with hardware Proprietary Education, personal computer
RISC OS 4 RISCOS Ltd, Pace plc 1999RISC OS4.392004Bundled with hardware, then sold separately at £70 (US$127) Proprietary Education, personal computer
RISC OS 5 Castle Technology, RISC OS Open 2002RISC OS 45.28 [6] 2020 No cost Apache-2.0 Education, personal computer
RISC OS 6RISCOS Ltd2006RISC OS 46.202009Bundled with hardware, then sold separately at £70 (US$127) Proprietary Education, personal computer
SerenityOS Andreas Kling2018None Continuous integration N/A No cost BSD-2-Clause Workstation, personal computer
Solaris Sun (now Oracle Corporation)1992 SunOS 11.4August 28, 2018Commercial; (a perpetual license at no cost when used "for the purpose of developing, testing, prototyping and demonstrating your applications" [7] ) CDDL Server, workstation
STOP 6, XTS-400 BAE Systems 2003STOP 5, XTS-3008.2August 2008US$60,000 (equivalent to $81,552 in 2022)+; bundled with XTS hardware and OEM licensed Proprietary Server, workstation
Symbian Symbian Ltd. 1998EPOC329.52009Discontinued; Commercial Proprietary Phone
Symbian platform Symbian Foundation 2010 (initially 1998 as Symbian)Symbian3.0.42010 No cost EPL Embedded system
TempleOS Terry Davis 2005 (as J Operating System)None5.032017 No cost Public domain Personal computer
Tru64 Digital Equipment Corporation January 1992 OSF/1 5.1B-6October 1, 2010Bundled with hardware Proprietary Server, workstation, HPC
VME ICL 1974NoneSV2941994Bundled with hardware Proprietary ICL mainframe
VSEn 21st Century Software1979 (as DOS/VSE) DOS/360
DOS/VS
6.3May 17, 2022Monthly license fee Proprietary IBM Z
VxWorks Wind River Systems 1987 VRTX 7March 2014Paid Proprietary Embedded real-time system
Windows (classic 9x family) Microsoft 1995 MS-DOS Windows Me (Win 4.90.3000)2000Discontinued Proprietary Personal computer, media center
Windows (NT family) Microsoft 1993 OS/2 and Windows 3.1x Windows 11 (version 23H2)December 12, 2023One time license fee Proprietary; Source-available Workstation, personal computer, media center, Tablet PC , embedded system
Windows Server (NT family) Microsoft 1993 OS/2 Windows Server 2022 (version 10.0.20348)August 18, 2021US$1050 5 CALs server; other editions dependent on number of CALs purchased Proprietary; Source-available Server, NAS, embedded system
z/OS IBM 2000 OS/390 Version 2.5 (V2R5)September 30, 2021Price tied to processor capacityOne Time Charge or monthly IBM Z
z/VM IBM 2000 VM/ESA 7.3September 16, 2022 [8] Monthly license fee Proprietary IBM Z
ZETA yellowTAB 2005 BeOS R5 1.52007Discontinued Proprietary Personal computer, media center, workstation
NameCreatorInitial public releasePredecessorCurrent stable versionRelease dateCost, availabilityPreferred license [g 1] Target system type
  1. 1 2 Most OS distributions include bundled software with various other licenses.
  2. "Hungarian". The Original Macintosh Anecdotes.. Although Lisa OS ran on the same, but a slower variant, microprocessor and was developed by Apple Computer Inc. at the same time as Classic Mac OS, they were developed as different projects, only sharing a similar GUI between them.
  3. Mac OS 7.6 was the first Macintosh system software to be labeled Mac OS. Operating systems before this were named Macintosh System Software through System Software 7.5, and known as System #.# for short.

Technical information

Name Computer architectures supported File systems supported Kernel type Source lines of code GUI default is on [t 1] Package management Update managementNative APIs [t 2] Non-native APIs supported through subsystems
AIX POWER, PowerPC-AS, PowerPC, Power ISA JFS, JFS2, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, SMBFS, GPFS Monolithic with modules Noinstallp, RPM Service Update Management Assistant (SUMA) SysV/POSIX
AmigaOS classic 68k, PowerPC Proprietary (OFS, FFS, SFS, PFS), FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, many others via 3rd party drivers, such as SMBFS, etc. Microkernel Yes Installer [t 3] (almost not needed) [t 4] Proprietary BSD subset (available through 3rd party ixemul.library)
AmigaOS 4 PowerPCProprietary (OFS, FFS, SFS, PFS), JXFS, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, many others via 3rd party drivers, such as SMBFS, etc.MicrokernelYesInstaller [t 3] (almost not needed) [t 4] AmiUpdate (almost not needed) [t 5] ProprietaryBSD subset (available through 3rd party ixemul.library)
ArcaOS IA-32 JFS (default), HPFS, ISO 9660, UDF, FAT32, NTFS HybridYesANPM (based on YUM and RPM)Update FacilityOS/2POSIX, Win16, DOS, Win32, Java
ChromeOS ARM, IA-32, x86-64 eCryptfs, NTFS, FAT, FAT16, FAT32, exFAT, ext2, ext3, ext4, HFS+, MTP (read and write), ISO9660 (read-only), UDF (read-only)Monolithic with modules≈17 million [9] Yes Portage Linux/POSIX
DragonFly BSD x86-64 UFS1, MFS, ext2, FAT (16/32), HAMMER, ISO 9660 Hybrid No dports, pkggit, cvsup, rsync, pkg BSD/POSIXMono, Java, Win16, [t 6] Win32, [t 6] Linux
eComStation IA-32 HPFS (default), FAT, JFS, UDF, FAT32, NTFS (read only)HybridYesWarpIN, Feature Install, othersMaintenance ToolProprietary, DOS API, Win16POSIX, Java, others
FreeBSD IA-32, x86-64, ARM, MIPS, PowerPC, others UFS2, ZFS, ext2, ext3, ext4, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, othersMonolithic with modules6.25 million [10] No Ports collection, packagesby source, network binary update (freebsdupdate) BSD/POSIXMono, Java, Win16, [t 6] Win32, [t 6] Linux
Genode ARM, RISC-V, IA-32, x86-64 ext2, ext3, FAT32, ISO9660 Microkernel or Monolithic kernel ≈300,000 [ citation needed ]NoCustomNoneGenodePOSIX, Qt, SDL, MirageOS [11]
GhostBSD IA-32, x86-64 UFS2, ext2, ext3, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, ReiserFS (read only), XFS (experimental), ZFS, othersMonolithic with modulesYes Ports collection, packagesby source, network binary update (freebsdupdate) BSD/POSIXMono, Java, Win16, [t 6] Win32, [t 6] Linux
Linux IA-32, x86-64, ARM, PowerPC, SPARC, others ext2, ext3, ext4, btrfs, ReiserFS, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, and othersMonolithic with modules≈15 million (kernel) [12]

lines of code for userland libraries and applications vary depending on the distribution

YesDepends on the distributionLinux/POSIXMono, Java, Win16, [t 6] Win32 [t 6]
Haiku IA-32, PowerPC, x86-64 BFS (default), FAT, ISO 9660, ext3, NTFSHybrid≈5.2 million[ citation needed ]YesPorts collection (haikuport)pkgman, HaikuDepotPOSIX, BeOS API Java, Qt
HP-UX PA-RISC, IA-64 VxFS, HFS, CDFS, EVFS, NFS, CIFS Monolithic with modulesNo SD, swinstallswa (HP-UX Software Assistant)SysV/POSIX
HarmonyOS 64-bit ARM, RISC-V, x86, x64 and LoongArchHDFS, EROFS, NFS, RAMFS, FAT, JFFS2Multikernel with Monolithic kernel and Microkernel ≈239.6 million [13] (100 Deterministic Latency Engine) [14] Yes.app with HAP filesSoftware UpdateProprietary (Unix-like) Java until 3.0.0
Inferno IA-32, PowerPC, SPARC, Alpha, MIPS, others Styx/9P2000, kfs, FAT, ISO 9660Monolithic with modules, user space file systemsYes??Proprietary
iOS ARMv8-A (iOS 7–present), ARMv7-A (iPhone OS 3–iOS 10), ARMv6 (iPhone OS 1–iOS 4.2.1) HFS+ (prior to version 10.3), APFS (since version 10.3)Hybrid≈80 million[ citation needed ]Yes ?Software Update Cocoa, BSD-POSIX ?
Classic Mac OS 68k, PowerPC HFS+, HFS, MFS (Mac OS 8.0 and before), AFP, ISO 9660, FAT(System 7 and later), UDFMonolithic with modulesYesNone Software Update (only in Mac OS 9) Toolbox, Carbon (from version 8.1)
macOS Apple silicon (11-present), x86-64 (10.4.7–present), IA-32 (10.4.4–10.6.8), PowerPC (10.0–10.5.8)
(see also iOS for ARM)
HFS+ (default on hard drives, and on flash drives up to Sierra), APFS (default on flash drives in High Sierra), HFS, UFS, AFP, ISO 9660, FAT, UDF, NFS, SMBFS, NTFS (read only), FTP, WebDAV, ZFS (experimental)Hybrid with modules≈86 million [15] Yes macOS Installer Software UpdateCarbon, Cocoa, Java, BSD-POSIXToolbox (only in versions up to Mac OS X 10.4, not supported on x86 architecture), Win16, [t 6] Win32 [t 6]
MINIX 3 IA-32Microkernel≈12,000 (C) + ≈1,400 (Assembly) [16] NoPOSIX
NetBSD IA-32, x86-64, ARM, MIPS, PowerPC, sparc64, others UFS, UFS2, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660, NFS, LFS, and othersMonolithic with modulesNo [t 7] pkgsrc by source or binary (using sysinst)BSD-POSIXLinux, others
NetWare 16-bit x86, IA-32 NSS, NWFS, FAT, NFS, AFP, UDF, CIFS, ISO 9660HybridYesNWCONFIG.NLM, RPM, X11-based GUI installerbinary updates, ZENWorks for Servers, Red Carpet Proprietary
OpenBSD IA-32, x86-64, SPARC, 68k, Alpha, others ffs, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660, NFS, some othersMonolithicNo [t 7] Ports collection, packagesby source or binary (packages via pkg_add)BSD-POSIX
OpenVMS VAX, Alpha, IA-64, x86-64 Files-11 (ODS), ISO 9660, NFS, CIFS Monolithic with modulesNoPCSI, VMSINSTAL?ProprietaryPOSIX, RSX-11M
OS/2 16-bit x86 (1.x only), IA-32HPFS, JFS, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFSMonolithic with modulesYesFeature Install and others?Proprietary, DOS API, Win16Win32
OpenHarmony 64-bit ARM, RISC-V, x86, x64 and LoongArchHDFS, EROFS, NFS, RAMFS, FAT, JFFS2 Microkernel ≈4.6 million [17] Yes.app with HAP filesSoftware UpdateOpen-source (Unix-like) Java until 3.0.0
Plan 9 IA-32, Alpha, MIPS, PowerPC, SPARC, others fossil/venti, 9P2000, kfs, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660Hybrid, user space file systems≈2.5 Million /sys/src (complete source of all supported architectures, kernels, commands and libraries)YesNone replica Proprietary (Unix-like)POSIX compatibility layer
QNX x86, SH-4, PowerPC, ARM, MIPS QNX4FS, QNX6, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660, Joliet, NFS, CIFS, ETFS, UDF, HFS, HFS+, NTFS, othersMicrokernelPOSIX, Java
ReactOS IA-32, PowerPC, ARMFAT, BTRFS, and NTFS (read only)Hybridnearly 8 million [18] Yes ReactOS Applications Manager, MSI, custom installersNoneWin32, NT API DOS API
Redox x86-64 RedoxFS, TFS Microkernel Yespkgutils POSIX
RISC OS ARM (both 26 and 32-bit addressing modes) Acorn ADFS, Econet ANFS, FAT, ISO 9660, many others as loadable filesystemsMonolithic with modules. Cooperative multitasking with limited memory protection. [19] YesApplications self-contained; hardware drivers often in ROM!IyoUpWtchHuge number of SWI calls; extensive C libraries
SerenityOS x86, x86-64ext2Microkernel≈750,000YesNoneNonePOSIX, propertiary
Solaris IA-32, x86-64, SPARCUFS, ZFS, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, QFS, some othersMonolithic with modulesYes SysV packages (pkgadd)
Image Packaging System (pkg) (Solaris 11 and later)
Image Packaging System (Solaris 11 and later)SysV/POSIX, GTK, JavaWin16, [t 6] Win32, [t 6] Mono, Linux [t 8]
OpenSolaris IA-32, x86-64, SPARC(AI)UFS, ZFS, ext2, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, QFS, some othersMonolithic with modules≈18.8 million [20] Yes Image Packaging System (pkg), SysV packages (pkgadd)Image Packaging SystemSysV/POSIX, GTK, JavaWin16, [t 6] Win32, [t 6] Mono, Linux [t 8]
STOP 6, XTS-400 x86ProprietaryMonolithicNo RPM for some untrusted applicationsBinary updates via postal mail and proprietary toolsSome: SysV, POSIX, Linux, proprietary
Symbian ARMFATMicrokernelYes SIS files FOTA ProprietaryPOSIX compatibility layer
TrueOS IA-32, x86-64 [t 9] UFS2, ext2, ext3, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, NFS, ReiserFS (read only), XFS (experimental) and othersMonolithic with modulesYesPorts collection, packages, PBI Graphical Installersby PBI updates, source, network binary update (freebsdupdate)BSD-POSIXWin16, [t 6] Win32 [t 6]
Windows Server (NT family)IA-32, x86-64, IA-64NTFS, FAT, ISO 9660, UDF; 3rd-party drivers support ext2, ext3, ReiserFS, [t 10] and HFSHybrid with modules≈45 million [21] Yes MSI, custom installers Windows Update Win32, NT API DOS API, Win16 (only in 32-bit versions), POSIX, .NET
Windows (NT family)IA-32, x86-64, ARM, IA-64, Alpha, MIPS, PowerPCNTFS, FAT exFAT ISO 9660, UDF; 3rd-party drivers support btrfs, ext2, ext3, ReiserFS, [t 10] HFS+, FATX, and HFS (with third party driver)Hybrid with modules≈40 (XP)/64 (Vista and later) million[ citation needed ]YesMSI, custom installersWindows UpdateWin32, NT API DOS API, Win16 (only in 32-bit versions), POSIX, .NET
ZETA IA-32BFS (default), FAT, ISO 9660, UDF, HFS, AFP, ext2, CIFS, NTFS (read only), ReiserFS (read only, up to v3.6)HybridYes SoftwareValet, script-based installersNonePOSIX, BeOS API
z/OS z/Architecture VSAM, BDAM, QSAM, BPAM, HFS, zFS, etc.Protected, multithreading, multitasking nucleus with programmable/user replaceable extensions. Not kernel-based.[ clarification needed ]NoNone, SMP/E SMP/E Filesystem access methods, Systems Services, etc.POSIX, many others.
NameComputer architectures supportedFile systems supportedKernel typeSource lines of codeGUI default is on [t 1] Package managementUpdate managementNative APIs [t 2] Non-native APIs supported through subsystems
  1. 1 2 Operating systems where the GUI is not installed and turned on by default are often bundled with an implementation of the X Window System, installation of which is usually optional.
  2. 1 2 Most operating systems use proprietary APIs in addition to any supported standards.
  3. 1 2 Amiga OS features since OS 2.0 version a standard centralized Install utility called Installer, which could be used by any software house to install programs. It works as a Lisp language interpreter, and install procedures could be listed as simple text. AmigaOS can also benefit from a 3rd party copyrighted library called XAD that is available for all POSIX (Unix, Linux, BSD, and for AmigaOS, MorphOS, etc.). This library is freely distributable and publicly available on Aminet Amiga centralized repository of all Open Source or Free programs and utilities. XAD.Library, complete with GUI Voodoo-X, is based on modules and capable to manage over 300 compression methods and package systems (Voodoo-X GUI supports 80 package systems), including those widely accepted as standards such as .ZIP, .CAB, .LHA, .LZX, .RPM, etc.
  4. 1 2 A standard AmigaOS installation requires usually only few files (typically 3 to 10 files) to be copied in their appropriate directory, and libraries and language files for national localization to be put in their standard OS directories. Any Amiga user with some minimal experience knows where these files should be copied and could perform programs installations by hand.
  5. AmiUpdate can update AmigaOS files and all Amiga programs which are registered to use the same update program that is standard for Amiga. Updating AmigaOS requires only few libraries to be put in standard OS location (for example all libraries are stored in Libs: standard virtual device and absolute path finder for Libs directory, Fonts are all in Fonts: absolute locator, the files for language localization are all stored in Locale: and so on). This leaves Amiga users with a minimal knowledge of the system almost free to perform by hand the update of the system files.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 using Wine
  7. 1 2 NetBSD and OpenBSD include the X Window System as base install sets, managed in their respective main source repository, including local modifications. Packages are also provided for more up-to-date versions which may be less tested.
  8. 1 2 "BrandZ (Community Group brandz.WebHome) - XWiki". Opensolaris.org. October 26, 2009. Archived from the original on September 29, 2009. Retrieved December 18, 2011.
  9. only i686 CPU
  10. 1 2 Windows can read and write with Ext2 and Ext3 file systems only when a driver from FS-driver or Ext2Fsd is installed. However, using Explore2fs, Windows can read from, but not write to, Ext2 and Ext3 file systems. Windows can also access ReiserFS through rfstool and related programs.

Security

NameResource
access
control
Subsystem
isolation
mechanisms
Integrated
firewall
Encrypted
file
systems
No execute (NX)
page flag
Manufacturer acknowledged unpatched vulnerabilities (by severity) [s 1]
SecuniaSecurity-
Focus
Hard-
ware
Emula-
tion
Extremely critical
(number / oldest)
Highly
critical
(number / oldest)
Moderately critical
(number / oldest)
Less
critical
(number / oldest)
Not
critical
(number / oldest)
Total
(number / oldest)
AIX 7.1 POSIX, ACLs, MAC, Trusted AIX - MLS, RBAC chroot IPFilter, IPsec VPNs, basic IDSYesYes [s 2] Un­known 0
FreeBSD 10.1 POSIX, ACLs, MAC chroot, Jails, MAC partitions, multilevel security, Biba Model, BSD file flags set using chflags, Capsicum Capability-based security IPFW2, IPFilter, PF, IPsec YesYesYes [s 3] 0 0 0 0 0 >0
GhostBSD 3.1POSIX, ACLs, MACchroot, jail, MAC partitions, BSD file flags set using chflags IPFW2, IPFilter, PF YesYesYes 0 0 0 0 0 >0
Genode Hierarchal, [22] least privilege capability-based security Virtual switch and NAPT controls in user-spaceNokernel dependentNoUn­known
HP-UX 11.31POSIX, ACLschrootIPFilterYes?? 0 0 3
June 30, 2004;
19 years ago
 (2004-06-30)
2
December 12, 2002;
21 years ago
 (2002-12-12)
0 >0
Inferno POSIX Namespaces, [23] capability-based security, no superuser or setuid bit??NoNoUn­known >0
Linux-based 2.6.39POSIX, ACLs, [s 4] MACchroot, [s 5] seccomp, Namespaces, SELinux, AppArmor Netfilter, varied by distributionYesYesYes 0 0 0 6
June 24, 2004;
19 years ago
 (2004-06-24)
11
April 4, 2005;
18 years ago
 (2005-04-04)
>0
Mac OS 9.2.2NoNoNoNoNoNo 0 0 0 0 0 >0
OS X 10.10.5POSIX, ACLs [s 6] chroot, BSD file flags set using chflags ipfw YesYes (as of 10.5, X64 only)Yes (Intel only) 0 0 1
April 14, 2009;
14 years ago
 (2009-04-14)
2
January 8, 2007;
17 years ago
 (2007-01-08)
5
November 22, 2006;
17 years ago
 (2006-11-22)
>0
NetBSD 6.1.2POSIX, Veriexec, PaX, kauthchroot, kauth, BSD file flags set using chflagsIPFilter, NPF, PFYesYesNoUn­known >0
NetWare 6.5 SP8 Directory-enabled ACLsProtected address spacesIPFLT.NLMYesYesNo 0 0 1
August 31, 2010;
13 years ago
 (2010-08-31)
2
October 30, 2003;
20 years ago
 (2003-10-30)
0 0
OES-Linux Directory-enabled ACLschrootIPFilterYesYesNoUn­known >0
OpenBSD 4.8POSIXchroot, systrace, BSD file flags set using chflagsPFYesYesYesUn­known >0
OpenVMS 9.2ACLs, privileges logical name tables ??Yes? 0 0 0 0 0 Unknown
OS/2, eComStation, ArcaOS ACLs [s 7] NoIPFilterNo?? 0 0 0 0 0 0
TrueOS 8.1POSIX, ACLs, MACchroot, jail, MAC partitionsIPFW2, IPFilter, PFYes [s 8] ?? 0 0 0 0 0 >0
Plan 9 POSIX ?Namespaces, [23] capability-based security, no superuser or setuid bitipmuxYesNoNoUn­known >0
QNX 6.5.0POSIX?PF, from NetBSD??? 0 0 0 5
November 20, 2002;
21 years ago
 (2002-11-20)
1
November 7, 2002;
21 years ago
 (2002-11-07)
Unknown
RISC OS NoNoIPFilterNoNoNoUn­known
Solaris 10 POSIX, RBAC, ACLs, least privilege, Trusted Extensions chroot, Containers, [s 9] Logical Domains IPFilterYes [s 10] YesNo 0 2
October 31, 2007;
16 years ago
 (2007-10-31)
5
October 23, 2007;
16 years ago
 (2007-10-23)
3
September 10, 2009;
14 years ago
 (2009-09-10)
2
November 6, 2006;
17 years ago
 (2006-11-06)
>0
OpenSolaris 2009.06POSIX, RBAC, ACLs, least privilege, Trusted Extensionschroot, Containers, [s 9] Logical DomainsIPFilterYes [s 10] YesNo 0 0 0 0 0 >0
Windows Server 2012 ACLs, privileges, RBACWin32 WindowStation, desktop, job objects Windows Firewall YesYesYes 0 0 0 0 0 [Unknown]
Windows 8.1 ACLs, privileges, RBACWin32 WindowStation, desktop, job objects Windows Firewall YesYesYes 0 0 0 0 1
May 30, 2014;
9 years ago
 (2014-05-30)
[Unknown]
ZETA POSIX [s 11] NoNoNoNoNoUn­known
STOP 6, XTS-400 [s 12] POSIX, multilevel security, Biba Model mandatory integrity, ACLs, privileges, subtype mechanismMultilevel security, Biba Model, subtype mechanismNoNoNoNoUn­known
z/OS 1.11 RACF RACF, low storage protection, page protection, storage protect key, execution key, subspace group facility, APF, ACR (alternate CPU recovery), morez/OS IPSecurityOptionalYes (storage protect key, execution key, APF, more)Yes 0 0 0 0 0 Unknown
NameResource
access
control
Subsystem
isolation
mechanisms
Integrated
firewall
Encrypted
file
systems
Hard-
ware
Emula-
tion
Extremely critical
(number / oldest)
Highly
critical
(number / oldest)
Moderately critical
(number / oldest)
Less
critical
(number / oldest)
Not
critical
(number / oldest)
Total
(number / oldest)
No execute (NX)
page flag
SecuniaSecurity-
Focus
Known unpatched vulnerabilities (severity is accounted for) [s 1]
  1. 1 2 Comparison of known unpatched vulnerabilities based on Secunia & SecurityFocus reports with severity of Not critical & above. Update lists manually with oldest published date(s).
  2. AIX use the PowerPC architecture which offer page-level protection mechanism. Since AIX version 5300-03 (5.3), this feature can be activated using the sedmgr command.
  3. The GCC stack protection (a.k.a. ProPolice stack-smashing protector) has been enabled in base system since FreeBSD 8.0-release.
  4. Support for the 1997 withdrawn POSIX ACL draft is included in Linux 2.6, but requires a file system able to store them (such as ext3, XFS or ReiserFS).
  5. A jail mechanism is available separately in the Linux-VServer project, but is not integrated into any mainline Linux kernel.
  6. ACLs were added to Mac OS X starting with version 10.4.
  7. ACLs are available only in OS/2 Server versions with HPFS386 filesystem.
  8. Additionally swap space may be encrypted during installation, uses memory based tmp file storage by default.
  9. 1 2 "Solaris Containers" (including "Zones") are a jail-type mechanism introduced with Solaris 10.
  10. 1 2 Through ZFS
  11. Zeta has full Unix file permissions, but the OS is single user, and users always run as superuser.
  12. STOP 6 is certified under Common Criteria at EAL5+.

Commands

For POSIX compliant (or partly compliant) systems like FreeBSD, Linux, macOS or Solaris, the basic commands are the same because they are standardized.

Feature AROS FreeBSD Linux-based HP-UX OpenVMS macOS Solaris Windows (cmd)Windows (PowerShell)
List directorylist, dirlslslsdirlslsdirGet-ChildItem
Clear consoleclearclearclearclearty/pa nl:clearclearclsClear-Host
Copy file(s)copycpcpcpcopycpcpcopyCopy-Item
Move file(s)movemvmvmvrenmvmvmoveMove-Item
Rename file(s)renamemvmv, renamemvrenmvmvren (rename)Rename-Item
Delete file(s)deletermrmrmdelrmrmdel (erase)Remove-Item
Delete directorydeletermdirrmdirrmdirdelrmdirrmdirrd (rmdir)Remove-Item
Create directorymakedirmkdirmkdirmkdircreate/dirmkdirmkdirmd (mkdir)New-Item
Change current directorycd [c 1] cdcdcdset defcdcdcd (chdir)Set-Location
Run shell script with new shellshell file.shellsh file.shsh file.shsh file.sh@ file.comsh file.shsh file.shcmd /c file.cmdpowershell file.ps1
Kill processes?kill, killallkillall, pkill, kill, skillkillstopkill, killallkill, pkilltaskkillStop-Process
Change process prioritychangetaskprinicenice, chrtniceset proc/prionicenicestart /low, start /normal, start /high, start /realtimeStart-Process, wmic
Change I/O priority? [c 2] ionice?set proc/prionice [c 3] ???
Create file systemformatnewfsmkfsnewfsinitmkfsnewfs, zpool /zfs createformatFormat-Volume
File system check and recovery?fsckfsckfsckanalyze/diskfsckfsckchkdskRepair-Volume
Create software raid?atacontrol, gmirror, zfs createmdadm -C??diskutil appleRAIDmetainit, zpool creatediskpart (mirror only)diskpart (mirror only)
Mount devicemountmountmountmountmountmount, diskutil mountmountmountvolNew-PSDrive
Unmount deviceassign drivename: dismountumountumountumountdismountumount, diskutil unmount(disk)umountmountvol /dRemove-PSDrive
Mount file as block device?mdconfig + mountmount -o loop??hdidlofiadm + mount??
Show network configuration?ifconfigip addr, ifconfigifconfig, lanadmintcpip sh net (sh net)ifconfigifconfigipconfigGet-NetIPInterface, ipconfig
Show network route?netstat -r, route get, route monitorip route, routenetstat -rtcpip sh routenetstat -r, route get, route monitornetstat -rrouteGet-NetRoute
Trace network route?traceroutetraceroutetraceroutetcptracetraceroutetraceroutetracertTest-NetConnection
Trace network route with pings?traceroute -Itraceroute -I, mtr?tcptracetraceroute -Itraceroute -Ipathpingpathping
FeatureAROSFreeBSDLinux-basedHP-UXOpenVMSmacOSSolarisWindows (cmd)Windows (PowerShell)

NOTE: Linux systems may vary by distribution which specific program, or even 'command' is called, via the POSIX alias function. For example, if you wanted to use the DOS dir to give you a directory listing with one detailed file listing per line you could use {{{1}}} (e.g. in a session configuration file).

  1. May be omitted. Simply entering the directory name will change to it.
  2. This feature is still in development, see .
  3. The nice command utilizes the setpriority() system call, which affects I/O priority, see OS X man page .

See also

Operating system comparisons

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Operating system</span> Software that manages computer hardware resources

An operating system (OS) is system software that manages computer hardware and software resources, and provides common services for computer programs.

The Portable Operating System Interface is a family of standards specified by the IEEE Computer Society for maintaining compatibility between operating systems. POSIX defines both the system and user-level application programming interfaces (APIs), along with command line shells and utility interfaces, for software compatibility (portability) with variants of Unix and other operating systems. POSIX is also a trademark of the IEEE. POSIX is intended to be used by both application and system developers.

Darwin is the core Unix operating system of macOS, iOS, watchOS, tvOS, iPadOS, visionOS, and bridgeOS. It previously existed as an independent open-source operating system, first released by Apple Inc. in 2000. It is composed of code derived from NeXTSTEP, FreeBSD, other BSD operating systems, Mach, and other free software projects' code, as well as code developed by Apple.

In computer security, an access-control list (ACL) is a list of permissions associated with a system resource. An ACL specifies which users or system processes are granted access to resources, as well as what operations are allowed on given resources. Each entry in a typical ACL specifies a subject and an operation. For instance,

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Live CD</span> Complete, bootable computer installation that runs directly from a CD-ROM

A live CD is a complete bootable computer installation including operating system which runs directly from a CD-ROM or similar storage device into a computer's memory, rather than loading from a hard disk drive. A live CD allows users to run an operating system for any purpose without installing it or making any changes to the computer's configuration. Live CDs can run on a computer without secondary storage, such as a hard disk drive, or with a corrupted hard disk drive or file system, allowing data recovery.

Filesystem in Userspace (FUSE) is a software interface for Unix and Unix-like computer operating systems that lets non-privileged users create their own file systems without editing kernel code. This is achieved by running file system code in user space while the FUSE module provides only a bridge to the actual kernel interfaces.

Unix-like operating systems identify a user by a value called a user identifier, often abbreviated to user ID or UID. The UID, along with the group identifier (GID) and other access control criteria, is used to determine which system resources a user can access. The password file maps textual user names to UIDs. UIDs are stored in the inodes of the Unix file system, running processes, tar archives, and the now-obsolete Network Information Service. In POSIX-compliant environments, the shell command id gives the current user's UID, as well as more information such as the user name, primary user group and group identifier (GID).

Extended file attributes are file system features that enable users to associate computer files with metadata not interpreted by the filesystem, whereas regular attributes have a purpose strictly defined by the filesystem. Unlike forks, which can usually be as large as the maximum file size, extended attributes are usually limited in size to a value significantly smaller than the maximum file size. Typical uses include storing the author of a document, the character encoding of a plain-text document, or a checksum, cryptographic hash or digital certificate, and discretionary access control information.

A kernel is a component of a computer operating system. A comparison of system kernels can provide insight into the design and architectural choices made by the developers of particular operating systems.

The following tables compare general and technical information for a number of file systems.

GNU variants are operating systems based upon the GNU operating system. According to the GNU project and others, these also include most operating systems using the Linux kernel and a few others using BSD-based kernels.

chattr is the command in Linux that allows a user to set certain attributes of a file. lsattr is the command that displays the attributes of a file.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Unix-like</span> Operating system that behaves similarly to Unix, e.g. Linux

A Unix-like operating system is one that behaves in a manner similar to a Unix system, although not necessarily conforming to or being certified to any version of the Single UNIX Specification. A Unix-like application is one that behaves like the corresponding Unix command or shell. Although there are general philosophies for Unix design, there is no technical standard defining the term, and opinions can differ about the degree to which a particular operating system or application is Unix-like.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Unix</span> Family of computer operating systems

Unix is a family of multitasking, multi-user computer operating systems that derive from the original AT&T Unix, whose development started in 1969 at the Bell Labs research center by Ken Thompson, Dennis Ritchie, and others.

Comparison of user features of operating systems refers to a comparison of the general user features of major operating systems in a narrative format. It does not encompass a full exhaustive comparison or description of all technical details of all operating systems. It is a comparison of basic roles and the most prominent features. It also includes the most important features of the operating system's origins, historical development, and role.

References

  1. Pogue, David (January 1997). MacWorld Macintosh Secrets 4th edition - Chapter 6: The System Software Museum (PDF). p. 225. Archived (PDF) from the original on October 17, 2017. Retrieved October 18, 2017.
  2. "Release 23.11". November 30, 2023. Retrieved December 19, 2023.
  3. "GhostBSD 21.05.11 ISO now available" . Retrieved June 25, 2021.
  4. Greg Kroah-Hartman (February 23, 2024). "Linux 6.7.6" . Retrieved February 23, 2024.
  5. "'[9fans] Transfer of Plan 9 to the Plan 9 Foundation' - MARC".
  6. Revill, Steve (October 24, 2020). "RISC OS 5.28 now available". RISC OS Open . Retrieved October 24, 2020.
  7. "Oracle Solaris OTN License". Oracle.com. Retrieved October 4, 2013.
  8. "Introducing IBM z/VM 7.3". March 18, 2023.
  9. "The Chromium (Google Chrome) Open Source Project on Open Hub". openhub.net.
  10. Arno Wagner (December 11, 2009). "(S)LOC Count Evolution for Selected OSS Projects" (PDF). data for 2009, fig 1.
  11. "Release notes for the Genode OS Framework 18.11".
  12. Ryan Paul (April 4, 2012). "Linux kernel in 2011: 15 million total lines of code and Microsoft is a top contributor". arstechnica.com. Retrieved August 21, 2012.
  13. Amit (November 5, 2022). "HarmonyOS 3.1: Huawei written 239.6 million lines of code and 16000 own APIs". Huawei Update. Retrieved November 5, 2022.
  14. Hellard, Bobby. "What is HarmonyOS? A guide to Huawei's operating system". IT PRO. IT PRO. Retrieved August 27, 2022.
  15. Jobs, Steve (August 7, 2006). "Live from WWDC 2006: Steve Jobs Keynote" . Retrieved February 16, 2007. 86 million lines of source code that was ported to run on an entirely new architecture with zero hiccups.
  16. Tanenbaum, Andrew S. (2015). Modern Operating Systems: Global Edition. Pearson Education Limited. ISBN   9781292061955.
  17. "Hongmeng OpenHarmony 2.0 has 4.6 million lines of key code, which is equal to 30 percent of Android 10 (15.25 million lines)". Huawei Update. Huawei Update. May 17, 2021. Retrieved August 27, 2022.
  18. "ReactOS Change Log". Archived from the original on May 18, 2015. Retrieved May 8, 2015.
  19. "RISC OS Memory Protection - Drobe.co.uk archives". drobe.co.uk. Archived from the original on March 31, 2014. Retrieved March 4, 2013.
  20. find usr/src -type f -exec wc -l {} + | grep total | awk '{ sum += $1 } END {print sum }' on results in 18793105
  21. Ben Liblit; Andrew Begel; Eve Sweetser. "Cognitive Perspectives on the Role of Naming in Computer Programs" (PDF). Retrieved December 26, 2007.
  22. "Genode organizational structure".
  23. 1 2 Rob Pike; Dave Presotto; Ken Thompson; Howard Trickey; Phil Winterbottom. "The Use of Name Spaces in Plan 9".