Independent Commission on Funding and Finance for Wales

Last updated January 18, 2025

The Independent Commission on Funding and Finance for Wales, also known as The Holtham Commission, was established by Rhodri Morgan (First Minister for Wales), Ieuan Wyn Jones (Deputy First Minister for Wales) and Andrew Davies (Minister for Finance and Public Service Delivery), of the Welsh Assembly Government.^[1] The establishment of the Commission was a commitment in the One Wales coalition agreement between Labour and Plaid Cymru in June 2007.^[2] Based in Cathays Park, Cardiff, the Commission completed its work in July 2010, publishing its findings in a final report: Fairness and accountability: a new funding settlement for Wales.^[3]

Remit

The remit of the Commission was to look at the pros and cons of the present formula-based approach to the distribution of public expenditure resources to the Welsh Assembly Government; and identify possible alternative funding mechanisms including the scope for the Welsh Assembly Government to have tax varying powers as well as greater powers to borrow.^[4]

Members

The Commission comprised:

Gerald Holtham (Chair), Managing Partner of Cadwyn Capital LLP and a visiting professor at Cardiff Business School.
David Miles, Member of the Bank of England's Monetary Policy Committee and visiting Professor of Financial Economics at Imperial College London.
Paul Bernd Spahn, Professor Emeritus of Goethe University, Frankfurt am Main, Germany, and macro fiscal advisor to governments across the world.

Findings and recommendations

The Commission began its work in autumn 2008 and published its first report in July 2009.^[5] In its first report, the Commission concluded that the Barnett Formula lacked any objective justification and had survived for reasons of political and administrative convenience. The Commission argued that the formula has caused relative funding per capita for devolved activities in Wales to converge towards the average level of funding in England (the "Barnett squeeze") despite relatively higher Welsh needs. The Commission recommended that in the future funding arrangements for Wales should be based on relative needs. As an interim measure, it recommended a modification to the existing formula that would place a "floor" under the block grant, preventing any further convergence towards the average English level of funding per capita.^[6]

In its final report, published in July 2010, the Commission recommended that:

the Assembly Government should pursue the introduction of a needs-based formula for determining the Welsh block grant;^[7]
the Assembly Government should acquire limited powers to vary income tax rates in Wales;^[8]
the Assembly Government should seek a discussion with the UK Government about the feasibility of devolving corporation tax;^[9]
stamp duty should be devolved to Wales;
capital gains tax on property and land should be devolved to Wales, if the administrative costs are not prohibitive;
the Assembly Government should consider the reform of Council Tax;
local authorities should be given discretion to levy a higher council tax on second homes;^[10]
landfill tax, air passenger duty and aggregates levy should be devolved to Wales if deemed useful;^[11]
a procedure should be created to enable Parliament to confer power on the National Assembly to introduce new taxes in Wales when requested;^[12] and,
the Assembly Government should receive limited powers to borrow to finance capital expenditure;^[13]

Reception

Public Finance magazine reported that the Holtham Commission's final report was welcomed by Labour, Conservative and Plaid Cymru politicians – although Welsh Business and Budget Minister Jane Hutt was said to have given a more "muted" response to Holtham's recommendation that the Assembly Government should gain tax-varying powers.^[14] Former First Minister Rhodri Morgan opposed this idea, arguing that there was "no mandate" for tax-varying powers in the 1997 devolution referendum.^[15]

James Mitchell of Strathclyde University called the Holtham Commission's conclusions "remarkably bold... its proposals on income tax are, in important respects, bolder than those proposed by Calman" (the commission created in 2007 to review Scottish devolution). Mitchell noted that Holtham's critique of the Barnett formula, which he regards as advantageous to Scotland, "ought to be a wake-up call".^[16]

Related Research Articles

The West Lothian question, also known as the English question, is a political issue in the United Kingdom. It concerns the question of whether members of Parliament (MPs) from Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales who sit in the House of Commons should be able to vote on matters that affect only England, while neither they nor MPs from England are able to vote on matters that have been devolved to the Northern Ireland Assembly, the Scottish Parliament and the Senedd. The term West Lothian question was coined by Enoch Powell MP in 1977 after Tam Dalyell, the Labour MP for the Scottish constituency of West Lothian, raised the matter repeatedly in House of Commons debates on devolution.

The Senedd, officially known as the Welsh Parliament in English and Senedd Cymru in Welsh, is the devolved, unicameral legislature of Wales. A democratically elected body, it makes laws for Wales, agrees to certain taxes, and scrutinises the Welsh Government. It is a bilingual institution, with both Welsh and English being the official languages of its business. From its creation in May 1999 until May 2020, the Senedd was officially known as the National Assembly for Wales and was often simply called the Welsh Assembly.

The Welsh Government is the executive arm of the devolved government of Wales. The government consists of cabinet secretaries and ministers. It is led by the first minister, usually the leader of the largest party in the Senedd, who selects ministers with the approval of the Senedd. The government is responsible for tabling policy in devolved areas for consideration by the Senedd and implementing policy that has been approved by it.

The Government of Wales Act 1998 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. Passed in 1998, the act created the National Assembly for Wales, Auditor General for Wales and transferred devolved powers to the assembly. The act followed the 1997 Welsh devolution referendum.

The Barnett formula is a mechanism used by the Treasury in the United Kingdom to automatically adjust the amounts of public expenditure allocated to Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales to reflect changes in spending levels allocated to public services in England, Scotland and Wales, as appropriate. The formula applies to a large proportion, but not the whole, of the devolved governments' budgets − in 2013–14 it applied to about 85% of the Scottish Parliament's total budget.

Politics in Wales forms a distinctive polity in the wider politics of the United Kingdom, with Wales as one of the four constituent countries of the United Kingdom (UK).

The economy of Wales is part of the wider economy of the United Kingdom, and encompasses the production and consumption of goods, services and the supply of money in Wales.

Welsh law is an autonomous part of the English law system composed of legislation made by the Senedd. Wales is part of the legal jurisdiction of England and Wales, one of the three legal jurisdictions of the United Kingdom. However, due to devolution, the law in Wales is increasingly distinct from the law in England, since the Senedd, the devolved parliament of Wales, can legislate on non-reserved matters.

A referendum on the powers of the National Assembly for Wales was held on 3 March 2011. Voters were asked whether the Assembly should have full law-making powers in the twenty subject areas where it has jurisdiction. The referendum asked the question: ‘Do you want the Assembly now to be able to make laws on all matters in the 20 subject areas it has powers for?’

The Commission on Scottish Devolution, also referred to as the Calman Commission or the Scottish Parliament Commission or Review, was established by an opposition Labour Party motion passed by the Scottish Parliament on 6 December 2007, with the support of the Conservatives and Liberal Democrats. The governing Scottish National Party opposed the creation of the commission.

Scottish devolution is the process of the UK Parliament granting powers to the devolved Scottish Parliament. Prior to the advent of devolution, some had argued for a Scottish Parliament within the United Kingdom – while others have since advocated for complete independence. The people of Scotland first got the opportunity to vote in a referendum on proposals for devolution in 1979 and, although a majority of those voting voted 'Yes', the referendum legislation also required 40% of the electorate to vote 'Yes' for the plans to be enacted and this was not achieved. A second referendum opportunity in 1997, this time on a strong proposal, resulted in an overwhelming 'Yes' victory, leading to the Scotland Act 1998 being passed and the Scottish Parliament being established in 1999.

In the United Kingdom, devolution is the Parliament of the United Kingdom's statutory granting of a greater level of self-government to the Scottish Parliament, the Senedd, the Northern Ireland Assembly and the London Assembly and to their associated executive bodies: the Scottish Government, the Welsh Government, the Northern Ireland Executive and in England, the Greater London Authority and combined authorities.

The Commission on Devolution in Wales, also known as the Silk Commission, was an independent commission established by Welsh Secretary Cheryl Gillan on 11 October 2011. The commission was based at the Wales Office Cardiff headquarters, at Cardiff Bay and met for the first time on 4 November 2011 at the Millennium Stadium, Cardiff. The commission reviewed the case for the devolution of fiscal powers to the Welsh Assembly, now the Senedd, and considered the case for increasing the powers of the assembly. It published its findings in two parts.

The Wales Act 2014 is an act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom.

The St David's Day Agreement, also known as the St David's Command Paper, is a command paper which set out the proposals of the UK coalition government. It was published in the command paper Powers for a purpose: Towards a lasting devolution settlement for Wales. The document was announced on 27 February 2015, by Prime Minister David Cameron and Deputy Prime Minister Nick Clegg at the Millennium Stadium in Cardiff, Wales.

The Wales Act 2017 is an Act of the Parliament of the United Kingdom. It sets out amendments to the Government of Wales Act 2006 and devolves further powers to Wales. The legislation is based on the proposals of the St David's Day Command Paper.

Federalism in the United Kingdom aims at constitutional reform to achieve a federal UK or a British federation, where there is a division of legislative powers between two or more levels of government, so that sovereignty is decentralised between a federal government and autonomous governments in a federal system.

The Institute of Welsh Affairs (IWA) is an independent charity and membership-based think-tank based Cardiff, Wales, which specialises in public policy and debate around the economy, education, environment and health sectors in Wales.

Welsh devolution is the transfer of legislative powers for self-governance to Wales by the Parliament of the United Kingdom. The current system of devolution began following the enactment of the Government of Wales Act 1998, with the responsibility of various devolved powers granted to the Welsh Government rather than being the responsibility of the Government of the United Kingdom.

There have been calls for further Welsh devolution, increasing the autonomy for Wales, since the Welsh legislature of the Senedd was founded following the 1997 Welsh devolution referendum.

References

↑ Welsh Assembly Government press notice announcing the Commission ^{[ permanent dead link ‍]}
↑ "One Wales agreement" (PDF). BBC News. Retrieved 14 July 2010.
↑ "Final report Fairness and accountability: a new funding settlement for Wales" (PDF). Independent Commission on Funding and Finance for Wales website. July 2010. Archived from the original (pdf) on 16 August 2010. Retrieved 16 July 2010.
↑ "Independent Commission on Funding & Finance for Wales – About us". Welsh Assembly Government. Archived from the original on 15 February 2011. Retrieved 27 July 2010.
↑ Press notice announcing the first report
↑ Final Report Summary, page 5
↑ Final Report Summary, page 20
↑ Final Report Summary, page 32
↑ Final Report Summary, page 35
↑ Final Report Summary, page 39
↑ Final Report Summary, page 40
↑ Final Report Summary, page 41
↑ Final Report Summary, page 45
↑ Dicken, Paul (15 July 2010). "Holtham review calls for Welsh tax powers". Public Finance. Retrieved 22 July 2010.
↑ "Rhodri Morgan opposes tax-varying powers for assembly". BBC News. 7 July 2010. Retrieved 22 July 2010.
↑ Mitchell, James (9 July 2010). "A perfect example of how devolution should operate". The Herald. Glasgow. Retrieved 23 July 2010.

External links

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.

[1] Welsh Assembly Government press notice announcing the Commission ^{[ permanent dead link ‍]}

[2] "One Wales agreement" (PDF). BBC News. Retrieved 14 July 2010.

[3] "Final report Fairness and accountability: a new funding settlement for Wales" (PDF). Independent Commission on Funding and Finance for Wales website. July 2010. Archived from the original (pdf) on 16 August 2010. Retrieved 16 July 2010.

[4] "Independent Commission on Funding & Finance for Wales – About us". Welsh Assembly Government. Archived from the original on 15 February 2011. Retrieved 27 July 2010.

[5] Press notice announcing the first report

[6] Final Report Summary, page 5

[7] Final Report Summary, page 20

[8] Final Report Summary, page 32

[9] Final Report Summary, page 35

[10] Final Report Summary, page 39

[11] Final Report Summary, page 40

[12] Final Report Summary, page 41

[13] Final Report Summary, page 45

[Public_Finance_15-7-10-14] Dicken, Paul (15 July 2010). "Holtham review calls for Welsh tax powers". Public Finance. Retrieved 22 July 2010.

[15] "Rhodri Morgan opposes tax-varying powers for assembly". BBC News. 7 July 2010. Retrieved 22 July 2010.

[16] Mitchell, James (9 July 2010). "A perfect example of how devolution should operate". The Herald. Glasgow. Retrieved 23 July 2010.

[1]

[2]

[3]

[4]

[5]

[6]

[7]

[8]

[9]

[10]

[11]

[12]

[13]

[14]

[15]

[16]