Following is a list of justices of the Nebraska Supreme Court :
Indicates Territorial Chief Justice
| Judge | Began active service | Ended active service |
| Fenner Ferguson | 1854 | 1857 |
| Edward R. Harden | 1854 | 1860 |
| James Bradley | 1854 | 1857 |
| John Curtiss Underwood | 1857 [1] | 1857 |
| Samuel W. Black | 1857 | 1859 |
| Eleazer Wakeley | 1857 | 1861 |
| Augustus Hall | 1858 | 1861 |
| Joseph Miller | 1859 | 1860 |
| William Pitt Kellogg | 1861 | 1865 [2] |
| William F. Lockwood | 1861 | 1867 |
| Joseph E. Streeter | 1861 | 1863 |
| Elmer S. Dundy | 1863 | 1867 |
| William Kellogg | 1865 | 1867 |
Indicates Service as Chief Justice for All or Part of Tenure
Information Gathered from Slipping Backward: A History of the Nebraska Supreme Court, the Nebraska Blue Book, and History of Nebraska By Morton & Watkins