Swiss Cottage Library

Finchley Road Library as published in a 1900 architecture magazine

The Metropolitan Borough of Hampstead's first library, Kilburn Library, opened in 1894 and was soon succeeded by Finchley Road Library in 1897. Then known as Hampstead Central Library, this became Camden Arts Centre in 1965. ^{[3] [4]} By the 1950s, the Central Library was in need of expansion, having served the same role since establishment. ^[5] Soon after a refurbishment, it suffered severe damage during the Blitz in World War II, leaving it with only half the required capacity. ^{[6] [3]} The borough desperately needed more space for books, and incorporated a new library into its plans for a new civic centre to house its headquarters and other services. ^[5]

The Library Association reported in 1959 that, whilst hardly any new public library buildings had been built, library usage had risen by 75% since 1939, with most buildings being over 50 years old. ^[7] Post-war, the British government had prioritised housing and education, resulting in wartime restrictions remaining in force and many libraries being designed for fewer users than needed. ^{[8] [7]} With additional damage and destruction to other libraries, Hampstead lacked the infrastructure needed for storing and cataloguing media. ^[6]

History

Founding

Swiss Cottage Library was planned as part of the Hampstead Civic Centre development by the Metropolitan Borough of Hampstead in the 1950s, which was originally intended to offer a new master site for Hampstead's governance. ^{[9] [10]} In 1959, British architect Sir Basil Spence of Spence, Bonnington & Collins created a scheme for the Civic Centre, including a library and sports centre (which contained the swimming baths), ^[11] on land purchased from the Eyre and Eton College (Chalcots) estates in 1956 at a cost of £200,000 (equivalent to £5.7 million in 2023). ^[5] The Metropolitan Borough of Hampstead became part of the larger London Borough of Camden under the London Government Act 1963, bringing complications to the scheme: Camden Council instead wanted to focus on its Euston Road developments; ^[9] Spence described the fate of the project as being "in the lap of the Gods". ^[12]

As Hampstead's final major infrastructure project, the original "masterplan" was downgraded to include only a sports centre and a library, per demands from the Greater London Council and central government. ^[13] Furthermore, the library, which was originally intended to be built next to Winchester Road, was instead moved west to be beside Avenue Road, to accommodate the changes. ^[3]

Construction was undertaken by McAlpine & Sons and was accelerated by the use of a 164 ft (50 m) tower crane, the tallest in the UK at the time. ^[14] Construction began on 31 December 1962, ^{[15] [16]} with the mayor, Luigi Carlo Denza, shovelling the first pile of earth for the site. Succeeding weeks brought difficulties due to unusually heavy snow, leading to concrete needing additional protection. Later building strikes exacerbated the problem, and construction was delayed, but eventually finished in 1964. ^[14]

Soon after opening the University of Sussex's new library, also by Spence, ^[17] Queen Elizabeth II opened the library as Hampstead Public Library on 10 November 1964. ^[18] On opening, the library superseded Finchley Road Library as Hampstead's Central Library. ^[7] Present, amongst others, were Councillor Luigi Carlo Denza, then Mayor of Hampstead, Basil Spence and Sir Edwin McAlpine, acting head of the library's construction firm at the time. ^[14] Its title as Hampstead Central Library was later amended in light of the Hampstead's amalgamation and it was renamed as Swiss Cottage Central Library before its shortened name today. ^[19]

Refurbishment and expansion

Café added in the refurbishment

In 1989, Camden reported that the swimming baths were underperforming and that Swiss Cottage Library, then being the largest and most used in the borough, had structural issues that required immediate address, even after remedial works in 1984. ^[20] The council announced in the late 1990s that it intended to regenerate Swiss Cottage Centre, and in 2003 John McAslan & Partners finished a refurbishment of Swiss Cottage Library to include a children's library and improved accessibility facilities, ^[9] at a cost of £7.9 million (equivalent to £12.9 million in 2023). The overall centre redevelopment plan, including the demolition of Swiss Cottage Sports Centre (with the swimming baths) and the construction of Sir Terry Farrell's Swiss Cottage Leisure Centre on the demolished site, was finished in 2007 at a cost of £85 million. ^[9]

Whilst the accompanying sport centre's demolition was not controversial, it removed the library's complementing twin, which was factored into new designs. ^[1] Camden originally planned to demolish the library with Swiss Cottage Sports Centre, ^[1] but was forced to instead refurbish it as a result of English Heritage designating it with a Grade II listing in December 1997; ^{[21] [22]} following the library's refurbishment, the Council acknowledged that demolition "would have been a mistake". ^[1] The library was officially reopened by Tessa Jowell MP, the then Secretary of State for Culture, Media and Sport, who praised the building as "magnificently refurbished" and "an excellent example of the new face of public libraries". ^[23]

When Camden began irreversible works on the library in 1996, the then Department for National Heritage warned them of section 3 "spot-listing" powers they held, ^[24] allowing them to list a building under emergency procedures if it was being considered for listing and at risk of demolition: ^[25] English Heritage claimed their swift responses had been a result of a lack of notification for the developments in advance. ^[26] Subsequently, the library was included in English Heritage's "Something Worth Keeping" exhibition of 65 buildings for possible listing, with the public being encouraged to comment: Swiss Cottage Library was later listed alongside the Royal College of Physicians building. ^[27]

In late 1997, English Heritage controversially decided to list the library, against the council's wishes. ^[26] Camden Council opposed the listing vehemently from its first consideration in early 1996 and the Evening Standard described the building, alongside the Swimming Baths, as a "drab concrete complex", with the Ham & High additionally recording residents as calling the pair the "ugliest buildings in the borough", though most criticism was directed at the baths. ^{[28] [29]} Local councillors were dismayed and the Council argued it was more important to support private investors in funding a new library through the private finance initiative than the maintenance of a building with chronic issues, ^[30] whilst others argued listing would encourage a more preservative restoration. ^[31]

The refurbishment, despite being widely acclaimed, was subject to numerous delays and significantly overbudget, in part a result of the project's primary contractor going into administration; McAslan and Camden's relationship was described as "bumpy". ^[1] Later in 2006, Camden Council sued McAslan & Partners for £500,000 as a result of delays in supply and a cost increase in the contract by £1.5 million. ^[32] McAslan defended the delays, arguing "It was less than 10% late", a comparatively small delay in construction, and commenting on additional removals needing to be carried out. ^[32]

In spite of refurbishments, Camden began a major overhaul of its library service in 2011, looking to cut its budget by £2 million due to falling borrower numbers. ^[33] Swiss Cottage Library, costing the council £1.2 million per year at the time, was on a list of potential libraries to be closed, with McAslan remarking that the library's closure would be a "tragedy" for the community. ^[34] The library remained open and underwent a low-carbon retrofit in 2023. ^[35]

Details

"Fins" on the exterior of the library

Second floor, facing the reference library

Spiral staircases in the reference library

Built in the ubiquitous Modernist style of the 1960s, Spence took inspiration from the vast open-space and minimalism of Scandinavian libraries, ^[7] visiting them to take notes on the designs. ^{[12] [17]}

Exterior

The library measures 250 feet (76 m) by 75 feet (23 m) with three storeys, and features 238 narrow 2-tonne "fins" made from a Portland stone aggregate on a pill-shaped structure, resembling the leaves of a book. ^[18] The fins were designed to protect readers from strong sunlight and additionally block noise pollution, ^{[17] [12]} whilst the semi-circular structure was reminiscent of some of Spence's earlier home designs. ^[7] The library's location in Swiss Cottage, described by Spence as the "gateway to North London", ^[5] was criticised due to significant noise pollution from the arterial Finchley Road that it borders. ^[10]

The borough council complemented the library by commissioning a bronze sculpture by F. E. McWilliam, titled The Hampstead Figure , as part of the initial stages of landscaping, which was unveiled by the Queen following the library. ^{[36] [5]}

Interior

Entry is via a semi-circular foyer with the main staircase in front on entrance; ^[37] originally lending and return counters were positioned on either side, though these were moved to their respective libraries following the refurbishment. ^[1] Spence made use of a lowered ground floor roof to hide the upper floors, revealing the vast atrium as one ascends the terrazzo-lined staircase, with an initial view of the lending library: the upper floors are cantilevered to create the entrance area. ^[37] A private staff area from the ground floor leads to a two-storey bookstack, which has capacity for 200,000 books. ^[36] The wider atrium of the first floor is an exhibition space with the two lending and reference libraries positioned around it, on either pole of the structure. Along the length there is a children's library, with more open usage of colour to contrast with the mostly monotone grey throughout; ^[38] additionally there are study areas, a periodicals room and formerly the borough's local history department, now relocated to Holborn Library. ^[7] Nine study carrels were available for library users, including one typing carrel, soundproofed, and an artist's carrel with running water. ^[17]

Both the lending and reference libraries retain their unique spiral staircases which in the reference library leads to an upper floor that includes 40 desks. ^[17] The second floor hosts music and philosophy libraries, the latter being the library's specialisation; ^[12] a café was added alongside in the 2000s refurbishment. ^[30] Throughout the library transparent partitions are used to create a more fluid and open feeling, in keeping with Spence's Scandinavian inspiration, ^[36] and consistency through colouring and flooring serves to join the different sections into one, rather than the feeling of a divided library. ^[39] Furniture was specially designed by Spence for the library, though most was controversially removed in the refurbishment and replaced with furnishings of a similar style. Whilst the RIBA Journal defended the new furniture, calling it "pretty good" for local authority standards, ^[1] Camden Arts Centre director Jenni Lomax, writing in The Guardian , argued that the removal "[destroyed] its initial integrity". ^[40] Spence's "floating" bookshelves additionally delineate the floor into casual studying areas: the library's fins also hide the bookcases' backs, preventing an unsatisfying effect from the outside. ^[36]

Commentary

May I say how pleased I am to come here to see these fine buildings[...]
There is ample opportunity to enrich the mind and exercise the body in surroundings as we can all see are architecturally most attractive.

Queen Elizabeth II,Opening Speech ^[41]

Speaking to thousands at the opening, the Queen acclaimed Spence's library as "really wonderful" and described Hampstead as "so interesting". ^[42] She heralded the specialised facilities available for readers in the library as well as accessibility measures for the disabled. ^[41]

The ground floor's lowered roof

The library was viewed positively by reviewers, with many commenting on the fluidity of the library's line work complementing the louvres of the adjacent swimming baths, bringing together two buildings with great differences in purpose. Concrete Quarterly called the building "spacious and well-equipped", ^[36] while the Library Association Record was also greatly appreciative, praising it as "another splendid library building", though in their conclusion they noted that it was an "architect's building first, and a librarian's second". ^[43]

In the Hampstead & Highgate Express however, some residents disapproved of the earlier opening hours compared to libraries in other boroughs like Greenwich, with others defending the older library as "perfectly adequate", with no need to waste the Borough's remaining funds on the project. ^[44] The library's entrance was criticised as "unimpressive" and the entrance "gloomy" and "uninviting", a side-effect of Spence's design to open up the floors as the visitor progresses up the stairs. ^[45]

The library's refurbishment was acclaimed by English Heritage as "a success in both architectural and heritage terms". ^[1] Elain Harwood, writing for Historic England, named it as one of the few post-war libraries that had been "sensitively refurbished", ^[8] and Historic England also highlighted it "amongst the most ambitious architectural designs for a library found anywhere" in its Grade II listing. ^[46] CILIP, the UK's professional body for librarians, awarded the refurbishment the Public Library Building Award in 2005, ^[47] and called the refurbishment "sensitive [and] intelligent" in its journal. ^[48]

References

Notes

1. Stungo, Naomi (August 2003). "Tome Capsule". RIBA Journal : 24–32.
2. "Illustrations". The American Architect and Building News . Vol. 68, no. 1275. Open Court Publishing Co. 2 June 1900 – via Internet Archive.
3. Drake, Robert (May 2013). Notes on Swiss Cottage Library. C20 Society.
4. Gorman, Michael (8 June 2011). Broken Pieces: A Library Life, 1941–1978. American Library Association. p. 52. ISBN   978-0-8389-1104-4.
5. Hampstead Civic Centre: Stage 1 (Report). Metropolitan Borough of Hampstead, The Development Committee. 1950s.
6. Lee, A. E. (1977). Wade, Christopher (ed.). "Saved by Two Minutes". Camden History Review. 5. Camden History Society: 27.
7. Black, Alistair (2014). "The design of Swiss Cottage Library". Camden History Review. 38. Camden History Society: 10–14.
8. Harwood, Elain (2016). "The English Public Library 1945–85". Introductions to Heritage Assets. Historic England. pp. 3, 13.
9. Denford, Steven (2009). The Hampstead Book: The A-Z of Its History and People. Historical Publications. pp. 119–120. ISBN   978-1905286331.
10. "Proposed civic centre for Hampstead" . The Architects' Journal . 129 (3335): 185. 29 January 1959 – via Internet Archive.
11. Black, Alistair (2017). "Hampstead Central Library: into the light" . Libraries of Light (1st ed.). Routledge. p. 172. doi:10.4324/9781315592336. ISBN   9781315592336.
12. Ham & High 1964a, p. 5.
13. Brockman, H. A. N. (10 November 1964). "Hampstead Civic Centre: the unfinished symphony". Financial Times . p. 19.
14. "Hampstead Civic Centre". The Green Man [magazine of McAlpine & Sons, developers]. January 1965. pp. 1–5.
15. LB Camden 1991, p. 3.
16. Blanchard, Tamsin (19 September 2004). "Learning curve". The Observer Magazine. ISSN   0029-7712 . Retrieved 1 July 2023.
17. Berriman, Sidney George; Harrison, Kenneth Cecil (1966). British Public Library Buildings. Grafton Books. p. 64. OCLC   251753182.
18. Wade, Christopher (2009). Streets of Belsize. Camden Historical Society. p. 39. ISBN   978-0904491777.
19. "Russians bar wife of Brooke: Want deal on Krogers". The Guardian Journal. 28 October 1967. p. 4. Retrieved 26 July 2023.
20. Future Development of Swiss Cottage Centre (Report). Leisure Services Committee, London Borough of Camden. 14 September 1989. pp. 1–4.
21. Harwood, Elain (2000). England: a guide to past-war listed buildings. Ellipsis. p. 498. ISBN   978-1-84166-037-0.
22. Historic England (2 December 1997). "Swiss Cottage Library (Grade II) (1272259)". National Heritage List for England . Retrieved 1 May 2021.
23. Ashcroft, Linda (2003). "Tessa Jowell hails LB Camden's Central Library as an excellent example of a "Fit for Purpose" Library". New Library World. 104 (1193): 436–437.
24. "Spence library may be listed to halt alterations". Building Design . 23 February 1996. p. 4.
25. Weaver, Matt (30 July 2003). "History of conflict". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 11 August 2023.
26. Bar-Hiller, Mira (28 February 1996). "Heritage lists Severn Bridge and a police station". Evening Standard . p. 5.
27. "Chalk and cheese, but both may end up listed". Ham & High. 8 March 1996.
28. "Camden eyesore set to gain list status". Ham & High . 23 February 1996.
29. "Heritage blocks Swiss Cottage arts centre plan". Camden New Journal . 22 February 1996.
30. Jackson, Stacey (April 2003). "Did they know what they were letting themselves in for?". Inside Camden. p. 4.
31. "Architect's Journal defends 'ugliest' building". Ham & High. 1 March 1996.
32. "McAslan sued over library". Building Design . 24 February 2006. ProQuest   274460484 . Retrieved 10 September 2022– via ProQuest.
33. Siddiq, Tulip (12 December 2013). "How a team of volunteers saved Camden's at risk libraries". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 7 August 2023.
34. Klettner, Andrea (11 February 2011). "Two landmark library buildings under threat". Building Design (1952): 3 – via EBSCO.
35. Carrier, Dan (6 January 2023). "Eco 2023: Swiss Cottage Library, the mission to retrofit an architectural gem". Camden New Journal . Retrieved 22 August 2023.
36. Campbell, Betty, ed. (October–December 1964). "Swimming baths and library: for the first stage of the new civic centre at Hampstead". Concrete Quarterly (63). London.
37. Library Association Record 1964, p. 508.
38. "Library". Architects' Journal. 140 (22): 1245–1255. 25 November 1964 – via Internet Archive.
39. Maidment, William R. (1 December 1965). "Spencerian Style for Hampstead". Library Journal .
40. Lomax, Jenni (3 May 2004). "Wonders and blunders". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 22 August 2023.
41. Ham & High 1964a, p. 2.
42. Ham & High 1964a, p. 1.
43. Library Association Record 1964, p. 509.
44. Ham & High 1964b, p. 5.
45. Library Association Record 1964, p. 504.
46. Historic England. "Swiss Cottage Library (1272259)". National Heritage List for England .
47. Dewe 2009, p. 10.
48. Harper, Philippa (July 2006). "Library design has arrived". CILIP Update.

Sources

• Swiss Cottage Sports Centre and Library: investigation and assessment of the primary structure of the buildings with options and recommendations for the future (Report). Leisure Services Committee, London Borough of Camden. 25 June 1991.
• "New library for Hampstead". Library Association Record . 66: 502–509. December 1964.
• "The Queen's Comment: It's Wonderful: Royal opening of new baths and library". Hampstead & Highgate Express. No. 5425. 13 November 1964a.
• "Letters to the editor: For and against the civic centre". Hampstead & Highgate Express. No. 5426. 20 November 1964b.
• Dewe, Michael (2009). Renewing our libraries: case studies in re-planning and refurbishment . Ashgate. ISBN   978-0-7546-7339-2 – via Internet Archive.

  † Many of these resources are solely available from Holborn Library.

Further reading

• Black, Alistair (2017). "Hampstead Central Library: into the light" . Libraries of Light (1st ed.). Routledge. doi:10.4324/9781315592336. ISBN   9781315592336.

External links

• Media related to Swiss Cottage Library at Wikimedia Commons
• Official website
• grid reference TQ275841

Swiss Cottage Library
Clockwise from top: length as viewed from Finchley Road; ground floor of the reference library; south-facing aerial view
51°32′33″N0°10′24″W / 51.5424°N 0.1733°W / 51.5424; -0.1733
Type	public library
Established	10 November 1964;60 years ago (1964-11-10) as Hampstead Central Library
Architect(s)	Basil Spence
Service area	London Borough of Camden
Collection
Size	128,650
Other information
Website	www.camden.gov.uk/swiss-cottage-library
Building details
General information
Address	88 Avenue Road London NW3 3HA
Construction started	31 December 1962;61 years ago (1962-12-31)
Cost	£200,000 (equivalent to £5.7 million in 2023)
Owner	London Borough of Camden
Technical details
Floor count	3
Floor area	5,470 square metres (58,880 sq ft) [1]

v t e London Borough of Camden
Districts	Bloomsbury Camden Town Chalk Farm and Haverstock ward Fortune Green Gospel Oak Hampstead (inc. Belsize Park, Frognal, Finchley Road, South Hampstead and Swiss Cottage) Hatton Garden (inc. Saffron Hill) Kentish Town Primrose Hill Regent's Park Estate St Giles St Pancras Somers Town West Hampstead Partly in Camden Brondesbury / Kilburn Covent Garden Cricklewood Dartmouth Park Fitzrovia Highgate Holborn Kings Cross Tufnell Park St John's Wood (less than 2% in Camden)
Attractions	Ben Uri Gallery & Museum Bloomsbury Theatre British Library British Museum Brunswick Centre BT Tower Camden Arts Centre Charles Dickens Museum Dominion Theatre Donmar Warehouse Fenton House Foundling Museum Freud Museum Highgate Cemetery Keats House Kenwood House The Jewish Museum O2 Forum Kentish Town Petrie Museum of Egyptian Archaeology Roundhouse Shaftesbury Theatre Sir John Soane's Museum Wellcome Collection West End theatre
Street markets	Camden Market Chalton Street Market Goodge Place Market Inverness Street Market Leather Lane Market Plender Street Market Queen's Crescent Market Swiss Cottage Market
Parks and open spaces	Adelaide Nature Reserve Bloomsbury Square Camden Highline (proposed) Hampstead Heath Kilburn Grange Park Lincoln's Inn Fields Phoenix Garden Primrose Hill Regent's Park Russell Square Waterlow Park Westbere Copse
Constituencies	Hampstead and Kilburn Holborn and St Pancras
Tube and rail stations	Belsize Park   Camden Road   Camden Town   Chalk Farm   Chancery Lane   Euston   Euston tube   Euston Square   Finchley Road   Finchley Road & Frognal   Goodge Street   Gospel Oak   Hampstead   Hampstead Heath   Holborn   Kentish Town   Kentish Town West   Kilburn High Road   King's Cross   King's Cross St Pancras   Mornington Crescent   Russell Square   St Pancras South Hampstead   Swiss Cottage   Tottenham Court Road   Warren Street   West Hampstead   West Hampstead (Overground)   West Hampstead Thameslink
Public libraries	Swiss Cottage Library Holborn Library Pancras Square Library Camden Town Library Kilburn Library
Other topics	Blue plaques Coat of arms Council Listed buildings Grade I Grade II* People Public art Schools
Category Commons