All-Malaya Council of Joint Action

Last updated

All-Malaya Council of Joint Action
Leader Tan Cheng Lock
Founded14 December 1946
Dissolved1948
HeadquartersSingapore

The All-Malaya Council of Joint Action (AMCJA) was a coalition of political and civic organisations in Malaya formed to participate in the development of a constitution for post-war Malaya in preparation for independence and to oppose the Constitutional Proposals for Malaya (also known as the Federation Proposals or the Anglo-Malay Proposals) which eventually formed the basis of the Federation of Malaya Agreement. [1]

Contents

History

Background

In seeking to solve some of the administrative incoherence in the pre-war British ruled Malaya, a policy of constitutional development which incorporated the twin goals of constitutional unity and a common citizenship within Malaya was developed as the basis for eventual self-rule and independence of the territory. [1] [2] The first proposal called for the Federated Malay States and Unfederated Malay States to be joined into a larger federation styled the Malayan Union. It was expected that Penang and Malacca would be severed from the Straits Settlements to join the new federation while Singapore remained a separate Crown Colony. [3]

Significant Malay opposition to the Union was spontaneous and widespread as it was seen as a departure from the traditional pro-Malay policies of the British and the removal of sovereignty of the Malay rulers while a significant majority of non-Malays were generally divided or indifferent to the proposals. [4] [5] The preoccupation with post-war rebuilding and the lack of an existing Malaya-centric political discourse meant that even the community most likely to view Malaya as their home like the Straits Chinese and second generation non-Malays failed to appreciate the implications of the Union until it was abandoned by the British. Only openly anti-colonial movements like the radical Malayan Communist Party (MCP) and the more moderate Malayan Democratic Union (MDU), established by English educated left-leaning middle-class intellectuals in Singapore in 1945, emerged to support the proposal with the caveat that Singapore was included in the Union. [1]

With the widespread opposition among the Malays, the British administration entered into secret negotiations with the Malay aristocracy and the United Malay National Organisation (UMNO) as they were unwilling to allow the Malay opposition to the Union develop into an anti-British attitude in the same way that had happened in the Dutch East Indies where the locals were engaged in an open armed rebellion against the Dutch. When news that the British had agreed to the demands of the conservative Malays and the Anglo-Malay Proposals included institutionalised handicaps against the non-Malay community and the absence of a road map towards Malayan independence, a united front was mulled to oppose the proposals.

United front proposed

On 19 November 1946, a meeting was held to discuss the formation of a united front. Attending this meeting were: [6]

NameAffiliation
Ahmad Boestamam Malay Nationalist Party
Musa Ahmad
Liew Yit Fun Malayan Communist Party
Chai Pek Siang
Gerald de Cruz Malayan Democratic Union
H. B. Talalla Unaffiliated
Khoo Teik Ee

Following a telegrammed suggestion by Tan Cheng Lock, three central principles were adopted: [6]

Formation

On 14 December 1946, the MDU sponsored a meeting in Singapore which was attended by the Malay Nationalist Party (known by its Malay acronym PKMM), the Malayan Indian Congress (MIC) and various other groups to:

"provide the machinery for the various communities, through their organisations and associations, to reach agreement on all points connected with the future constitution of Malaya, thus avoiding the dangers of separated and self-interested representation"

The immediate result of this meeting was the formation of the Council for Joint Action (CJA) comprising the MDU, PKMM, MIC, the General Labour Union (later to split into the Singapore Federation of Trade Unions or SFTU and the Pan Malayan Federation of Trade Unions or PMFTU), the Singapore Clerical Union, the Straits Chinese British Association (SBCA), the Singapore Indian Chamber of Commerce, the Singapore Tamil Association and the Singapore Women's Federation [5] [6] operating on the three principles adopted during the November meeting. Tan Cheng Lock was appointed the chairman with MDU's John Eber as secretary-general. A memorandum of protest was sent by the CJA to Arthur Creech Jones, a trade unionist who was then the Under-Secretary of State for the Colonies for the British government on 16 December of the same year with the announcement that the CJA intended to boycott the Consultative Committee established to discuss and implement the Anglo-Malay Proposals.

This CJA was expanded on 22 December 1946 with the inclusion of the Pan Malayan Federation of Trade Unions, the Clerical Unions of Penang, Malacca, Selangor and Perak, the Selangor Indian Chamber of Commerce, the Selangor Women's Federation, the Malayan New Democratic Youth's League, the Malayan People's Anti-Japanese Ex-Comrades Association, the Singapore Chinese Association and the Peasant's Union. A press conference in Kuala Lumpur announced the formation of the Pan-Malayan Council of Joint Action (PMCJA) with Tan Cheng Lock re-elected chairman with MDU's Gerald de Cruz as secretary-general. [6] [7]

The PMCJA sought to gain recognition from to act as the sole representative body with which the British government would negotiate with a view to amending the constitution in accordance with the wishes of that part of the populace that has not been consulted so far. [7] Nonetheless, the negotiated Anglo-Malay proposals were published as a government White Paper on 24 December 1946 [8] together with a note from the Governor, Edward Gent, that the proposals were conditionally accepted by the British government provided that

"all interested communities in Malaya have had full and free opportunity of expressing their views" [5]

Major activities

People's Constitution

Opposition to the Anglo-Malay proposal increased with demonstrations being held across Malaya and consultations were held to prepare an alternative set of proposals to be tabled to the British government. On 22 February 1947, a coalition of Malay organisations opposed to the Anglo-Malay agreement and led by the MNP, Pusat Tenaga Ra'ayat (PUTERA), was formed [4] and by March of the same year the PMCJA had established a coalition with PUTERA known as PUTERA-PMCJA. The PUTERA-PMCJA adopted a total of 10 principles; including the three original principles of the CJA; as the basis of their constitutional proposals: [6]

  • A united Malaya including Singapore
  • A popularly elected Central Government and popularly elected State councils
  • A citizenship granting equal rights to all who made Malaya their permanent home and the object of their undivided loyalty
  • Malay Rulers to have real sovereign power responsible to the people through popularly elected Councils
  • Malay customs and religion to be fully controlled by the Malay people through special councils
  • Special provisions for the advancement of the Malays politically, economically and educationally
  • Malay to be the official language
  • A national flag and a national anthem
  • Melayu (Malay : Malay) to be the title of any proposed citizenship and nationality in Malaya
  • Foreign affairs and defence to be the joint responsibility of the government of Malaya and the government of Great Britain

Due to concerns about the implications of the term Pan-Malayan which groups like the Tan Kah Kee and Lee Kong Chian led Associated Chinese Chambers of Commerce (ACCC) considered to be indicative of communist domination and the MNP considered to include only non-Malays, the name of the PMCJA was changed to become the All Malaya Joint Council for Action or AMCJA in August 1947 and the PUTERA-PMCJA coalition became known as PUTERA-AMCJA. [6] [9]

The PUTERA-AMCJA constitutional proposals was adopted by the constituent members of both coalitions on 10 August 1947 and presented to the public on 21 September as the People's Constitutional Proposals. [10] A summary of the differences between the People's Constitutional Proposals and the Revised Constitutional Proposals [11] published in July 1947 based on the report of the Government Consultative Committee are: [12]

People's Constitutional Proposals [10] Revised Constitutional Proposals [11]
A united Malaya including SingaporeA federation of the Malay states and the former Straits Settlements excluding Singapore
A popularly elected Central Government and popularly elected State councilsAn appointed Executive Council headed by a British High Commissioner in Malaya and an appointed Federal Legislative Council of fifty unofficial members, fourteen official members and eleven free members (the Menteri Besar of the 9 Malay states and 1 representative each from Penang and Malacca).
A citizenship granting equal rights to all who made Malaya their permanent home and the object of their undivided loyaltyBirth qualifications, language test, and long residential terms imposed, effectively restricting the access to citizenship of domiciled non-Malays [6]
Malay Rulers to have real sovereign power responsible to the people through popularly elected CouncilsMalay Rulers recognised as sovereign monarchs with inherent prerogatives, powers and privileges
Malay customs and religion to be fully controlled by the Malay people through special councilsMalay customs and religion placed within the sole jurisdiction of the Malay Rulers
Special provisions for the advancement of the Malays politically, economically and educationallySpecial provisions for the advancement of the Malays politically, economically and educationally
Malay to be the official languageMalay recognised as an official language together with English
A national flag and anthemA national flag was adopted with no provisions for a national anthem
Melayu to be the title of any proposed citizenship and nationality in MalayaNo provisions for a Malayan nationality was adopted
Foreign affairs and defence to be the joint responsibility of the government of Malaya and the government of Great BritainAll portfolios remained within the prerogative of the British High Commissioner and the government of Great Britain
A Council of Races to be set up to block any discriminatory legislation that is based on ethnicity or religionNo such provisions were provided for
Anglo-Malay sovereignty entrenched with the provision of a Conference of Rulers consisting of the Malay rulers presided over by the British High Commissioner, and a 55% reservation of Malay representation in the Federal legislature for the first 3 termsA Conference of Rulers was formalised. Ethnic representation in the Federal Legislative Council was set with no provisions for an elected legislature

All Malaya Hartal

The ACCC considered the Revised Constitutional Proposals as being autocratic and irresponsible and it threatened to delay the independence of Malaya indefinitely. A decision was made to co-operate with PUTERA-PMCJA (later PUTERA-AMCJA) because it had exhausted all constitutional channels of appeal (the ACCC was a participant in the Government Consultative Committee) and appeal to the British Parliament for the establishment of a Royal Commission to review and reverse the Revised Constitutional Proposals. [6]

Agitation against the Revised Constitutional Approvals grew throughout September with a successful hartal organised in Malacca and Ipoh in protest. Emboldened by the success, the ACCC decided to launch a country-wide strike and PUTERA-AMCJA was invited to support the strike. A decision was made to hold the strike, to be known as the All Malaya Hartal, on 20 October 1947 to coincide with the opening of the session of the British Parliament where the Revised Constitutional Proposals were to be tabled and debated. [6]

The hartal turned out to be a major success [13] although UMNO held counter demonstrations in the more rural areas like Senggaram and Bagan Datoh contributing to the rise in ethnic tensions and the cancellation of the planned strike in those areas. [6]

The hartal was also successfully carried out in Singapore, which received the prominent support of the Singapore Chinese Chamber of Commerce led by its chairman Lee Kong Chian. [14]

Decline and dissolution

Despite the success of the All Malaya Hartal, the government granted no concessions and differences began to emerge between the ACCC and PUTERA-AMCJA. A second Hartal was planned for 1 February 1948 but was aborted when financial support from the ACCC was not forthcoming and was reduced to isolated strikes by the PMFTU. [6] Kuomintang sympathizers had also begun to lobby for the withdrawal of ACCC support from the PUTERA-AMCJA due to the intensification of the Chinese civil war. [15]

The implementation of the Federation of Malaya constitution based on the Revised Constitutional Proposals on 1 February 1948 and the decision of the MCP to launch an armed rebellion marked the beginning of the end for the PUTERA-AMCJA coalition and AMCJA as a whole. With the declaration of the nationwide emergency, the constituent organisations either withdrew from the coalition, went underground, or in the case of the MDU, voluntarily dissolved itself [6] and the AMCJA ceased to exist as a body.

Mainstream political developments in Malaya in the following decade came to be dominated by conservative and pro-British groups with a distinctive impact on the historical development of independent Malaya, and later Malaysia, for the next few decades. [4] [5]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malaysian Indian Congress</span> Malaysian political party

The Malaysian Indian Congress,formerly known as Malayan Indian Congress, is a Malaysian political party. It is one of the founding members of the coalition Barisan Nasional, previously known as the Alliance, which was in power from when the country achieved independence in 1957 until the elections in 2018. The party was among the first to fight for Malayan Independence and is one of the oldest parties in Malaysia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malayan Union</span> Post-war federation of the Malay states and the Straits Settlements of Penang and Malacca

The Malayan Union was a union of the Malay states and the Straits Settlements of Penang and Malacca. It was the successor to British Malaya and was conceived to unify the Malay Peninsula under a single government to simplify administration. Following opposition by the ethnic Malays, the union was reorganised as the Federation of Malaya in 1948.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Federation of Malaya</span> Federation of British territories from 1948–57; independent country from 1957–63

The Federation of Malaya, more commonly known as Malaya, was a country of what previously had been the Malayan Union and, before that, British Malaya. It comprised eleven states – nine Malay states and two of the Straits Settlements, Penang and Malacca. It was established on 1 February 1948.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parti Rakyat Malaysia</span> Political party in Malaysia

The Malaysian People's Party is a political party in Malaysia. Founded on 11 November 1955 as Partai Ra'ayat, it is one of the older political parties in Malaysia and traces its pedigree to the anti-colonial movements from the pre World War II period like the Kesatuan Melayu Muda.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Malayan Communist Party</span> Far-left political party in Malaya

The Malayan Communist Party (MCP), officially the Communist Party of Malaya (CPM), was a Marxist–Leninist and anti-imperialist communist party which was active in British Malaya and later, the modern states of Malaysia and Singapore from 1930 to 1989. It was responsible for the creation of both the Malayan Peoples' Anti-Japanese Army and the Malayan National Liberation Army.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Malaya</span> Former set of states on Malay Peninsula

The term "British Malaya" loosely describes a set of states on the Malay Peninsula and the island of Singapore that were brought under British hegemony or control between the late 18th and the mid-20th century. Unlike the term "British India", which excludes the Indian princely states, British Malaya is often used to refer to the Federated and the Unfederated Malay States, which were British protectorates with their own local rulers, as well as the Straits Settlements, which were under the sovereignty and direct rule of the British Crown, after a period of control by the East India Company.

This article lists important figures and events in the public affairs of British Malaya during the year 1946, together with births and deaths of prominent Malayans. Malaya remained under British Military Administration until the establishment of the Malayan Union on 1 April.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Self-governance of Singapore</span> Historical progress from UK colony (1819) to sovereign state (1965)

The self-governance of Singapore was carried out in several stages. Since the founding of Singapore in 1819, Singapore had been under the colonial rule of the British. The first local elections on a limited scale for several positions in the government of Singapore started in 1948 following an amendment to the Constitution of Singapore.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Early Malay nationalism</span>

Malay nationalism refers to the nationalism that focused overwhelmingly on the Malay anticolonial struggle, motivated by the nationalist ideal of creating a Bangsa Melayu. Its central objectives were the advancement and protection of Malayness: religion (Islam), language (Malay), and royalty. Such pre-occupation is a direct response to the European colonial presence and the influx of a foreign migrant population in Malaya since the mid-nineteenth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Crown Colony of Malacca</span> British colony from 1946 to 1957

Malacca was a British Crown colony from 1946 to 1957. It came under British sovereignty after the signing of the Anglo-Dutch Treaty of 1824, and had been part of the Straits Settlements until 1946.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">British Military Administration (Malaya)</span> Postwar administration of Malaya before its independence

The British Military Administration (BMA) was the interim administrator of British Malaya from August 1945, the end of World War II, to the establishment of the Malayan Union in April 1946. The BMA was under the direct command of the Supreme Allied Commander South East Asia, Lord Louis Mountbatten. The administration had the dual function of maintaining basic subsistence during the period of reoccupation, and also of imposing the state structure upon which post-war imperial power would rest.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Background and causes of the Malayan Emergency</span> Background and Causes of National Liberation War

In 1948, the Communists and the British colonial government in Malaya entered a period of guerrilla fighting which has become known to history as the Malayan Emergency.

Ahmad Boestamam, or Abdullah Thani bin Raja Kechil, was a Malaysian freedom fighter, politician and was the founding president of Parti Rakyat Malaysia and Parti Marhaen Malaysia. Abdullah was an editor and reporter for several newspapers which compelled him with the Ahmad pen-name honouring Indian freedom fighter Subhas Chandra Bose.

Eu Chooi Yip was a prominent member of the anti-colonial and Communist movements in Malaya and Singapore in the 1950s and 1960s. Eu Chooi Yip was born in Kuantan, Malaysia.

Angkatan Wanita Sedar was the first nationalist women's organisation in Malaysia. It was established in 1946 as women's wing of the Malay Nationalist Party. Aishah Ghani was the first president of AWAS. The organisation was also led by Shamsiah Fakeh. At its peak, AWAS had a membership of 2000 women. The group organised, held discussions and hosted Indonesian women visitors. AWAS members, led by Sakinah Junid, participated in a six-mile protest march against the British prohibition disallowing the use of motorised vehicles in processions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Sang Saka Malaya</span> Malayan republicanism flag

The Sang Saka Malaya, sometimes shortened from Sang Pusaka Malaya, is known as the flag of the Parti Kebangsaan Melayu Malaya. It is also known as Bendera Rakyat. The flag features twelve stars arranged in three rows of four columns. It was introduced in 1947 by the combination of two political parties, Pusat Tenaga Ra'ayat (PUTERA) and the All-Malaya Council of Joint Action (AMCJA), as a proposal to the flag of an independent Federation of Malaya. According to a report by The Straits Times in 1947, The twelve stars represent the 12 states of the Malay Peninsula. It follows the concept of the American flag with 50 stars representing the 50 states that make up the United States.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parti Kebangsaan Melayu Malaya</span> Malay Nationalist Party

Parti Kebangsaan Melayu Malaya (PKMM), also known as the Malay Nationalist Party, was founded on 17 October 1945 in Ipoh, Perak. The party was the first Malay political party formed after the Japanese occupation of Malaya.

The Malayan Democratic Union was a left-wing socialist political party active in British Malaya from 1945 to 1948. It was founded by English-educated intellectuals and advocated for the independence of British Malaya as a single entity inclusive of Singapore.

References

  1. 1 2 3 Hill, Micheel (1979). The Politics of Nation Building and Citizenship in Singapore . Florence: Routledge. p.  285. ISBN   0-415-10052-6.
  2. Dupont, Jerry (2000). The Common Law Abroad: Constitutional and Legal Legacy of the British Empire. Buffalo: William S. Hein & Co. p. 1228. ISBN   0-8377-3125-9.
  3. Great Britain, Colonial Office (1946). "Malayan Union and Singapore; Summary of proposed constitutional changes" (Document). London: HMSO. Cmd 6949.
  4. 1 2 3 Hwang, InWon (2003). Personalized Politics: The Malaysian State Under Mahathir . Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies. p.  400. ISBN   981-230-185-2.
  5. 1 2 3 4 Kratoska, Paul H. (2001). South East Asia, Colonial History. London: Taylor & Francis. ISBN   0-415-24784-5.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Yeoh, Kim Wah (1973). Political Development of Singapore, 1945–1955. Singapore: Singapore University Press. p. 320. ISBN   0-8214-0486-5.
  7. 1 2 Tribune Staff Reporter (23 December 1946). "K.L. Forms New 'Action Council'". The Malayan Tribune.
  8. Government of the Malayan Union (1946). "Summary of the Report of the Working Committee appointed by a Conference of His Excellency the Governor of the Malayan Union, Their Highnesses the Rulers of the Malay States and the Representatives of the United Malay National Organisation; revised up to the 19th of December 1946". Kuala Lumpur: Malayan Union Government Press. p. 92.[ permanent dead link ]
  9. Arkib Negara: PMCJA Ditubuhkan Archived 11 June 2008 at the Wayback Machine (in Malay)
  10. 1 2 "PUTERA, CJA Constitutional Proposals Now Ready'". The Malayan Tribune. 11 September 1947.
  11. 1 2 Great Britain, Colonial Office (1947). "Federation of Malaya: Summary of revised Constitutional proposals; Accepted by His Majesty's Government, 24th July 1947" (Document). London: HMSO. p. 20. Cmnd. 7171.
  12. PUTERA-AMCJA; Edited by Ban Ah Kam (2005). The People's Constitutional Proposals for Malaya 1947 (Reprint). Kuala Lumpur: 1st Edition. p. 100. ISBN   983-40821-4-2.{{cite book}}: |author2= has generic name (help)
  13. Indian Daily Mail, 14 November 1947
  14. The Straits Times, 22 October 1947, Page 5
  15. Thompson, V (1950). The Left-wings in Southeast Asia. New York.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: location missing publisher (link)