Israeli generals' plan

Last updated

Contents

The Israeli generals' plan refers to a siege strategy proposed by former Israeli general Giora Eiland during the Israel–Hamas war. The plan would force the complete evacuation of Northern Gaza by labeling all remaining civilians as military targets and blocking supplies such as food and medication from entering the area.

The plan was considered by the Israeli government, though was not officially adopted. However, there have been signs that Israel has implemented parts of the plan since October 2024, specifically during the Siege of North Gaza. The strategy has been criticized for its humanitarian impact, which some allege to be genocidal and ethnic cleansing.

Israel ultimately did not force out all the civilian population of North Gaza, and the implementation of the 2025 Israel–Hamas war ceasefire allowed displaced Gazans to return to that area. [1]

Overview

Eiland in 2004 Msc 2004-Sunday Morning-1100-1300-IMG 0020.jpg
Eiland in 2004

The plan, conceived by retired major general and former head of the National Security Council Giora Eiland and presented to the Knesset by a group of several retired Israeli generals, proposed giving approximately 300,000 Palestinians a one-week evacuation period to depart from the northern third of Gaza before designating it a military exclusion zone. Under this strategy, anyone remaining in the area would be considered a combatant. The plan would then implement a complete siege that would block essential supplies until militant surrender, denying all essential supplies including medicine, fuel, food, and water, representing a radical shift in Israeli military strategy for northern Gaza. [2] [3]

According to Giora Eiland, the plan's chief architect, this approach was intended to pressure Hamas and secure the release of approximately 100 remaining Israeli hostages held since October 7, 2023. The strategy also envisioned Israel maintaining indefinite control over northern Gaza to establish a new Hamas-free administration, effectively dividing the Gaza Strip. [2] Eiland argued that this siege strategy would be both militarily effective and compliant with international law. He specifically emphasized that the plan would target then-Hamas leader Sinwar's priorities of "land and dignity" by depriving him of both. [3] Eiland stated that Hamas would "either have to surrender or to starve," saying that "it will not be necessary" for the Israeli military to kill everyone in northern Gaza as "people will not be able to live there. The water will dry up." [4]

The Institute for National Security Studies stated that the plan arose from a perceived failure of existing military pressure to secure hostage releases and destroy Hamas's capabilities. Its architects identified a concerning gap between leadership assessments and ground reality, leading them to propose a strategy targeting Hamas's four fundamental resources: money, manpower, supplies, and motivation. [5]

The Israel Defense Forces justified operations in areas like Jabalia as necessary to combat regrouping Hamas operatives. While officially denying implementation of the siege plan, subsequent military operations followed several elements of the proposed strategy. [6]

History

Conception and government consideration

In April 2024, Giora Eiland presented a comprehensive critique of Israel's military strategy following the October 7 attacks during an interview with The Times of Israel, and proposed several amendments to perceived failures in Israel's exclusive reliance on military pressure against Hamas due to their guerrilla warfare capabilities. Identifying Gaza's dependence on external sources for basic necessities such as fuel, food, and water as key leverage points that could be used more effectively, he proposed strategies that would later develop into the completed generals' plan. These included implications of imposing a harsher blockade on the Gaza Strip and cooperating with the United States Armed Forces to prevent the reconstruction of Gaza while Hamas remained in control. [7]

In late September 2024, Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu unveiled a completed generals' plan to Israeli military and political officials during a closed session at the Knesset Foreign Affairs and Defense Committee. The plan was presented as one of several options under examination for cabinet discussion. [2] [3]

The strategy became a source of tension within the Israeli government, particularly between far-right cabinet members and military leadership. Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich and National Security Minister Itamar Ben Gvir supported the plan, viewing it as a means to achieve permanent Israeli control over Gaza. However, Defense Minister Yoav Gallant opposed its implementation. [6] Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's position appeared as ambiguous. While his office officially denied considering the proposal, political analysts suggested he may have allowed partial implementation to maintain support from his far-right coalition partners, particularly during a critical period before budget approval deadlines. [6]

Implementation

The Netarzim Corridor, which civilians have fled through from Northern Gaza NetzarimCorridor.jpg
The Netarzim Corridor, which civilians have fled through from Northern Gaza

While the Israeli government stated that they had not officially adopted the full plan, there were indications of its partial implementation in military activities. By early 2024, Israel had already launched military operations in areas such as the Jabaliya refugee camp, and the amount of humanitarian aid reaching northern Gaza had significantly decreased since October 1, 2023. Only about eighty aid trucks had entered through northern Gaza crossings during this period, compared to the previous average of sixty trucks per day. [6]

According to CNN, the Israeli military adopted a modified version of the plan in early October 2024. [8] [9] This plan was proposed by the Eiland-led Forum of Reserve Commanders and Fighters, intending to implement the full blockade and mandatory evacuation of the entire civilian population of Northern Gaza, at penalty of death for any residents or refugees who remained in the area. [10] [11]

On 6 October 2024, Israel designated all of the northern Gaza Strip, including Jabalia, as a combat zone and ordered the entire civilian population to evacuate. [12] [13]

On 7 October, the IDF issued evacuation orders for residents of Jabalia, Beit Hanoun, and Beit Lahia, instructing them to travel southwards to the al-Mawasi humanitarian zone. [14] Following these evacuation orders was made more difficult by Israel's ongoing bombardment, as well as drones pursuing and shooting at individuals attempting to flee. [15] Residents reported being trapped in Jabalia, with all roads blocked except the main highway leading out. However, they also stated quadcopters were firing at anyone attempting to leave, with one resident stating, "It’s like hell. We can’t get out." [16]

According to Israeli media, tens of thousands of Palestinians have passed through the IDF security crossing at the Netzarim Corridor to get to the southern Gaza Strip. [17] On 7 October 2024, however, UN Spokesperson Stéphane Dujarric stated many people in northern Gaza was "trapped" in their homes and that "few families have crossed Wadi Gaza heading South". [18] Doctors Without Borders stated at least five of their staff members were trapped in Jabalia, stating, "Nobody is allowed to get in or out; anyone who tries is getting shot". [19]

On 12 October 2024, the Israel Defense Forces issued specific evacuation orders through its Arabic spokesman, targeting residents in the 'D5' area of northern Gaza. These communications included detailed maps with evacuation routes towards assigned humanitarian zones which designated Salah al-Din Road as the primary evacuation corridor. The communications came with warnings of prolonged military operations with "great force". The evacuation orders affected approximately 400,000 remaining residents in northern Gaza, an area that previously housed 1.4 million people. The evacuation orders and subsequent military actions coincided with the generals' plan in their systematic evacuation orders for specific zones, the creation of one-way movement corridors southward, and implementing restrictions on returning to evacuated areas. [20]

On 5 November 2024, Israel formally announced that it would be systematically removing Palestinians from northern Gaza, with IDF brigadier general Itzik Cohen stating that residents of northern Gaza would not be allowed to return to their homes. [21] He added that humanitarian aid would not be allowed to enter northern Gaza because there were "no more civilians left." [22] [23]

Humanitarian concerns

The proposed strategy raised significant humanitarian concerns among international observers and human rights organizations. Critics argued that the plan would violate international law prohibiting use of food as a weapon as well as forced evacuation and ethnic cleansing as part of the genocide case brought against Israel at the International Court of Justice. [2] In line with the plan's outlines, food aid deliveries to northern Gaza ceased after October 1, with virtually no aid deliveries being recorded during the first two weeks of October 2024. The World Food Programme documented the closure of main crossings used for humanitarian aid delivery. [20] [24]

The humanitarian situation in northern Gaza had already deteriorated significantly, with approximately 400,000 people remaining trapped in the area, essential supplies, food, and water becoming increasingly scarce, and movement between different parts of northern Gaza being severely restricted. In addition, few Palestinians heeded evacuation orders, with many fearing they would never be allowed to return. [2]

In addition, several hospitals in northern Gaza reported critical shortages of fuel for generators, exacerbating casualties from ongoing Israeli bombardments. Several essential services, including bakeries and mobile kitchens, were forced to close. Due to restrictions on media access in northern Gaza caused by the plan's implementation, international journalists were largely prevented from entering Gaza. [20]

Human rights organizations strongly criticized the strategy. A coalition of Israeli civil rights groups warned against the plan's quiet implementation, arguing it violated international law. Jessica Montell of HaMoked, a Jerusalem-based civil rights advocacy group, compared the tactics to medieval siege warfare, stating they contradicted fundamental principles of the laws of war. [6]

Responses

Many Palestinian residents in northern Gaza expressed resistance to evacuation orders, choosing to remain despite deteriorating conditions, fearing permanent displacement. [6] The situation particularly affected vulnerable populations, including the elderly, sick, and those unable or unwilling to leave their homes. Many Palestinians expressed fear about moving to southern Gaza, where conditions were already dire with overcrowded tent camps and continued airstrikes on civilian shelters. [2] Other civilians decided against leaving due to needing to care for vulnerable relatives. [20]

The plan has been described by Hamas as genocidal. [25] Others have described the plan as the ethnic cleansing of northern Gaza. [26]

In Israel

Both Israeli military analysts and the Al-Mezan Center for Human Rights alleged that this[ clarification needed ] was the first stage of the "general's plan". [27] The Israeli human rights organizations Gisha, B'Tselem, Physicians for Human Rights and Yesh Din stated there were "alarming signs" that Israel was implementing the plan. [28] Three Israeli reserve soldiers in Gaza stated it was their understanding the general's plan was being practically implemented. [29] Eran Etzion, former deputy director of the National Security Council, called the plan "a war crime" and called for Israeli soldiers to disobey orders to implement the plan. [30]

Internationally

Several United Nations agencies warned of the deepening humanitarian crisis present in northern Gaza due to imposed humanitarian blockades. the Medical Aid for Palestinians organization reported strong concerns about civilian casualties in the area, while aid organizations documented difficulties in delivering essential supplies. [20]

Tamer Qarmout, a professor of public policy at the Doha Institute, stated in response to the implementation of tactics from the plan during the Siege of Jabalia: "We’re talking about another wave of displacement – another Nakba. The future of Gaza is horrifying. I still worry about what’s coming next. The demographic re-engineering of the Gaza Strip is in progress now." [31]

In October 2024, United States Secretary of State Antony Blinken and U.S. Secretary of Defense Lloyd Austin sent a letter addressed to Defense Minister of Israel Yoav Gallant and the Israeli Minister for Strategic Affairs Ron Dermer, which established a 30-day deadline for Israel to comply with U.S. requirements regarding humanitarian aid access to Gaza. This ultimatum included potential consequences, including the possibility of suspending U.S. weapons transfers to Israel if demands were not met. [2] [6]

Analysis

Effectiveness

The Israeli Institute for National Security Studies expressed the belief that the plan was based on assumptions with significant flaws. The plan's proponents drew questionable conclusions about the effectiveness of siege tactics in securing hostage releases, overlooking that previous releases were largely attributed to Arab public pressure rather than military coercion. Moreover, the strategy potentially endangered remaining hostages and failed to address Hamas's demonstrated ability to adapt and rebuild its capabilities. The institute also cited legal and humanitarian concerns, such as likelihood of incomplete civilian evacuation, questions of proportionality under international law, and risks of damaging Israel's international standing all presented significant obstacles, compounded by practical difficulties of preventing Hamas fighters from infiltrating humanitarian shelters or disguising themselves among evacuating civilians. [5]

United States involvement

Doha Institute for Graduate Studies professor Mohamad Elmasry expressed the notion that the letter sent by the U.S. government generally represented a "distraction" in attempt to conceal the administration's complicity in war crimes committed by Israel in Gaza. noted that the diplomatic intervention's timing coincided with the approaching 2024 U.S. presidential election, where Arab and Muslim American voters in swing states could play a crucial role in its outcome. [24]

He also noted that the letter could serve as documentation of U.S. efforts to ensure legal compliance with international law and the U.S. Leahy Law, which governs military assistance to foreign nations, and that the letter's focus on humanitarian aid access potentially served to address immediate concerns while avoiding more contentious aspects of the conflict, such as United States weapons delivery to Israel, forced evacuations, and civilian casualties. He noted that previous U.S. recommendations were often disregarded by Israel, and that the United States had maintained significant military and diplomatic support for Israel despite broad international concerns since Gallant's October 2023 announcement of a "complete siege" on Gaza. [24]

See also

Related Research Articles

The 2004 Israeli operation in the northern Gaza Strip took place when the Israel Defense Forces launched Operation "Days of Penitence", otherwise known as Operation "Days of Repentance" in the northern Gaza Strip. The operation lasted between 29 September and 16 October 2004. About 130 Palestinians, and 1 Israeli were killed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yoav Gallant</span> Israeli politician and former military officer (born 1958)

Yoav Gallant is an Israeli politician and former military officer who served as minister of defense between 2022 and 2024. Gallant was an officer in the Southern Command of the Israel Defense Forces, serving in the Israeli Navy. In January 2015 he entered politics, joining the new Kulanu party. After being elected to the Knesset he was appointed minister of construction. At the end of 2018 he joined Likud, shortly after which he became minister of Aliyah and Integration. In 2020 he was appointed minister of education, and the following year became minister of defense. On 5 November 2024, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced that he had dismissed Gallant, effective 7 November, and sought to have Israel Katz replace him. Gallant subsequently resigned from the Knesset on 5 January 2025.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Dahiya doctrine</span> Doctrine of total leveling of civilian buildings

The Dahiya doctrine, or Dahya doctrine, is an Israeli military strategy involving the large-scale destruction of civilian infrastructure, or domicide, to pressure hostile governments. The doctrine was outlined by former Israel Defense Forces (IDF) Chief of General Staff Gadi Eizenkot. Israel colonel Gabi Siboni wrote that Israel "should target economic interests and the centers of civilian power that support the organization". The logic is to harm the civilian population so much that they will then turn against the militants, forcing the enemy to sue for peace.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Giora Eiland</span> Israeli Major General (born 1952)

Giora Eiland is a retired Major General of the Israel Defense Forces and a former head of the Israeli National Security Council. After his retirement from the public sector, he was a senior research associate at the Institute for National Security Studies (INSS).

The year 2023 in Israel was defined first by wide-scale protests against a proposed judicial reform, and then by the Hamas-led attack on Israel on October 7, which led to a war and to Israel invading the Gaza Strip.

Events in the year 2023 in Palestine.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaza war</span> Ongoing armed conflict in the Middle East

The Gaza war has been fought between Israel and Hamas-led Palestinian militant groups in the Gaza Strip and Israel since 7 October 2023. It is the fifth war since 2008 in the Gaza–Israel conflict, and the most significant military engagement in the region since the Yom Kippur War in 1973. The first day of the war was the deadliest for Israel, and it is the deadliest war for Palestinians in the history of the conflict. It sparked an ongoing Middle Eastern crisis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip</span> Israeli military operation since 2023

The Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip is a major part of the Gaza war. Starting on 7 October 2023, immediately after the Hamas-led attacks on Israel, it began bombing the Gaza Strip; on 13 October, Israel began ground operations in Gaza, and on 27 October, a full-scale invasion was launched. Israel's campaign has four stated goals: to destroy Hamas, to free the hostages, to ensure Gaza no longer poses a threat to Israel, and to return displaced residents of Northern Israel. More than a year after the invasion, fighting in the Gaza Strip halted with the implementation of a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas on 19 January 2025.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gaza Strip evacuations</span> State-ordered displacement

During the Israel–Hamas war, the Israeli military ordered mass evacuations in Gaza, resulting in one of the largest displacements of Palestinians since 1948. On 13 October 2023, just one week after Hamas' attack on Israel, Israel instructed 1.1 million Gazans north of the Wadi Gaza, including those in Gaza City, to evacuate within 24 hours. This evacuation triggered a humanitarian crisis, which Palestinians have compared to the Nakba of 1948.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of Gaza City</span> Military engagement in Gaza City

The siege of Gaza City was an engagement of the Israel–Hamas war that began on 2 November 2023, when the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) surrounded Gaza City, amid the Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip, which was a counterattack to the 2023 Hamas-led attack on Israel. Gaza City is the most populated city in the Gaza Strip and the battle started on 30 October 2023, when Israel and Hamas clashed in Gaza City. According to Oxfam, about 500,000 Palestinians, along with 200 Israelis and other captives, were trapped in a "siege within a siege" in northern Gaza.

The Gaza war sparked a major diplomatic crisis, with many countries around the world reacting strongly to the conflict that affected the momentum of regional relations. At least nine countries took the drastic step of recalling their ambassadors or cutting diplomatic ties with Israel. The conflict has also resulted in a renewed focus on a two-state solution to the ongoing conflict.

Events of the year 2024 in Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Israeli government response to the 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel</span> Government and military actions

The Israeli government's response to the 7 October Hamas-led attack on Israel has multiple aspects, including a military response leading to the Israeli invasion of the Gaza Strip. In October, the Knesset approved a war cabinet in Israel, adding National Unity ministers and altering the government; Benjamin Netanyahu and Benny Gantz froze non-war legislation, establishing a war cabinet with military authority.

Events in the year 2024 in Palestine.

Brigadier General Fayeq Al-Mabhouh was the Director-General of Central Operations in the Ministry of the Interior and National Security in the Gaza Strip. He was the leader of their crisis management team. His most notable recent responsibilities related to civilian disaster management, such as coordination and enforcement of restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Siege of North Gaza</span> 2024 engagement in the Gaza Strip

The siege of North Gaza was an engagement of the Gaza war in the North Gaza Governorate, Gaza Strip, between Israel and Hamas-led Palestinian forces. It began on 5 October 2024 when the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) reinvaded Jabalia and its refugee camp for the first time in months since earlier fighting.

On 29 October 2024, the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) conducted an airstrike on a five-story residential building in Beit Lahia in northern Gaza, killing at least 55 to 93 Palestinians, including 25 children, and leaving 40 others missing.

References

  1. ↑ "Hamas wins the ceasefire, but Israel must win the war - opinion". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. 2025-01-19. Retrieved 2025-01-22.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 "Netanyahu mulls plan to empty northern Gaza of civilians and cut off aid to those left inside". AP News. 2024-10-13. Retrieved 2024-10-22.
  3. 1 2 3 Kirsh, Elana (22 September 2024). "Sep. 22: Halevi, Gallant laud strikes on top Hezbollah officials, vow evacuees will return home". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 21 October 2024.
  4. ↑ "Netanyahu mulls plan to empty northern Gaza of civilians and cut off aid to those left inside". AP News. 13 October 2024. Retrieved 13 October 2024.
  5. 1 2 Dekel, Udi; Caner, Tammy (October 15, 2024). ""The Generals' Plan"— Right Direction, Wrong Implementation". www.inss.org.il. Retrieved 2024-10-22.
  6. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Hendrix, Steve; Balousha, Hazem (16 October 2024). "Israeli siege plan for Gaza under scrutiny as U.S. demands urgent change". The Washington Post. Retrieved 21 October 2024.
  7. ↑ Horovitz, David (17 April 2024). "A top ex-general's radical strategy for tackling Iran, saving the hostages, calming the north". The Times of Israel. Retrieved 21 October 2024.
  8. ↑ Krever, Mike (12 October 2024). "After mulling siege plan, Israel ramps up military push in northern Gaza". CNN. Retrieved 13 October 2024.
  9. ↑ Bowen, Jeremy (12 October 2024). "Israeli attack on northern Gaza hints at retired general's 'surrender or starve' plan for war". BBC News. Retrieved 12 October 2024.
  10. ↑ Rapoport, Meron (17 September 2024). "A plan to liquidate northern Gaza is gaining steam". 972+ Magazine. Retrieved 14 October 2024.
  11. ↑ "North Gaza siege: Netanyahu considers plan to starve out Hamas fighters". The Jerusalem Post. 23 September 2024. Retrieved 14 October 2024.
  12. ↑ Rasgon, Adam (6 October 2024). "A new Israeli map labels nearly all of northern Gaza 'new evacuation zones". The New York Times . Archived from the original on 6 October 2024.
  13. ↑ Keller-Lynn, Carrie (6 October 2024). "Israel Launches New Offensive in Northern Gaza, Orders Mass Evacuation". The Wall Street Journal . Archived from the original on 6 October 2024.
  14. ↑ "Iran Update, October 7, 2024". Institute for the Study of War. Retrieved 2024-10-08.
  15. ↑ Mahmoud, Hani. "North Gaza suffers 'deliberate starvation' during Israeli siege". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
  16. ↑ Magdy, Samy (9 October 2024). "Israeli offensive kills dozens and threatens hospitals in hard-hit northern Gaza". PBS. Associated Press. Retrieved 14 October 2024.
  17. ↑ "Iran Update, October 13, 2024". Institute for the Study of War. Retrieved 2024-10-14.
  18. ↑ "Gazans in the north trapped with nowhere to go, as fighting intensifies". UN News. 7 October 2024. Retrieved 14 October 2024.
  19. ↑ Makary, Adam; Al-Mughrabi, Nidal. "Thousands trapped in Jabalia camp as Israel escalates deadly attacks in northern Gaza". Reuters. Retrieved 21 October 2024.
  20. 1 2 3 4 5 "Israeli attack on northern Gaza hints at retired general's "surrender or starve" plan for war". www.bbc.com. Retrieved 2024-10-22.
  21. ↑ Harel, Amos; Kubovich, Yaniv (Nov 6, 2024). "IDF's Destruction of Northern Gaza Reveals the Government's Plan: We're Here to Stay". Haaretz. Retrieved 2024-11-09.
  22. ↑ McKernan, Bethan; Christou, William (2024-11-06). "Palestinians will not be allowed to return to homes in northern Gaza, says IDF". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2024-11-09.
  23. ↑ Cordall, Simon Speakman. "Israel's new tactics in north Gaza stoke fears of ethnic cleansing campaign". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 2024-11-09.
  24. 1 2 3 Elmasry, Mohamad. "Leaked US warning to Israel to 'let aid in Gaza' is merely a distraction". Al Jazeera. Retrieved 2024-10-22.
  25. ↑ "Israel expands brutal offensive in Gaza's Jabalia under 'genocidal' General's Plan". The New Arab. 18 October 2024.
  26. ↑ Mohammad, Ibrahim; Mushtaha, Mahmoud (10 October 2024). "'Dead bodies everywhere' in Jabalia camp as Israel besieges northern Gaza". +972 Magazine. Retrieved 21 October 2024.
  27. ↑ Monks, Kieron (6 October 2024). "'Evacuate or die': Israel moves towards 'general's plan' for north Gaza". iNews . Archived from the original on 6 October 2024.
  28. ↑ Shotter, James (15 October 2024). "Israel 'starting to implement' north Gaza starvation plan, say rights groups" . Financial Times. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
  29. ↑ Harel, Amos. "On Defense and Offense, Israel Given Another Reminder of Its Reliance on the United States" . Haaretz. Retrieved 19 October 2024.
  30. ↑ "EX-NSC deputy head claims gov't secretly approved 'General's Plan,' calls on soldiers to refuse to carry out 'war crime'". The Times of Israel. 22 October 2024. Retrieved 20 October 2024.
  31. ↑ "'The demographic re-engineering of the Gaza Strip is in progress'". Al Jazeera English. Retrieved 22 October 2024.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.