Kidnapping of Evyatar David

Last updated

Kidnapping of Evyatar David
Part of the Gaza war hostage crisis
krzh hqvrAt lSHKHrvr Abytr dvd, tl Abyb, 2025.jpg
Poster in Tel Aviv calling for the release of Evyatar David
Location Eshkol Regional Council, Israel
DateOctober 7, 2023 (2023-10-07)
Attack type
Kidnapping

Evyatar David (Hebrew : אביתר דוד) is an Israeli who was kidnapped during the Nova music festival massacre of the October 7 attacks, and has been held as a hostage by Hamas since then.

Contents

Evyatar David

Evyatar David was born on December 24, 2000 to Avishai and Galia David. [1] [2] He is from Kfar Saba. [3] He has a brother Ilay, and a sister Yaela. [2]

Kidnapping

David was kidnapped from the Nova festival during the October 7 attacks. [3] He reported being shot at and trying to escape by vehicle, before the connection was lost. [4] He was taken with his childhood best friend Guy Gilboa-Dalal. [5]

Captivity

David and Gilboa-Dalal were shown in a video taken on February 22, 2025 during the 2025 ceasefire watching the release of three other hostages, Omer Shem Tov, Eliya Cohen and Omer Wenkert, after 505 days. David and Gilboa-Dalal were not freed and remained as hostages. The video was the first sign of life from David since being kidnapped, and the first of Gilboa-Dalal since June 2024. [6] The two are held with their hands and feet tied, bags over their heads, and fed very little in complete darkness, which makes it difficult to know what they are eating. They receive one shower a month with a bucket of water. David does not have his glasses and is unable to see well. [7]

Starvation

Hamas released footage of David in August 2025, showing him in an severely emaciated state and forced to dig his own grave. He stated that he had not eaten in days and received little water to drink. A similar video was released by Palestinian Islamic Jihad depicting hostage Rom Braslavski. [8] [9] Hamas claimed the hostages eat the same food as the militant group's members, but the video shows a Hamas member handing David a can of food. The captor's arm is much larger than David's, showing the former is well-fed. Other hostages noted that Hamas members would feast next door to where they were being held, and they could smell the food. [10]

An Instagram post shared by Greta Thunberg and other pro-Palestinian activists in October 2025 featured a still image of David from the August video, suggesting he is a suffering Palestinian prisoner held by Israel. The post was mocked on social media and condemned by David's sister, Yeela, and educator Aviva Klompas. Yeela David called on Thunberg to delete the post. [11] [12]

Reactions

US President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance meet with David's family and other family and hostages in September 2025. President Donald Trump meets with freed Israeli hostages (54778790193).jpg
US President Donald Trump and Vice President JD Vance meet with David's family and other family and hostages in September 2025.

David's family compared it to the Holocaust, referring to him as a muselmann. They said his life was in "immediate danger", and that he had been "deliberately and cynically starved in Hamas’ tunnels in Gaza". They also describing him as "a living skeleton, buried alive." [8] In an interview with Geoff Bennett on PBS NewsHour , David's cousin, Matan Eshet, pointed out that the Hamas captor had a much larger hand and arm than David, showing the former is well-fed. Eshet continued that the captor also is tanned, showing he has been outside regularly. [13] The Israeli foreign ministry also mentioned the contrast in a tweet. [14]

The video was also condemned by several world leaders:

The American Jewish Committee took out a full-page advertisement in The New York Times which showed side by side photos of David before his kidnapping and a still from the video, beneath the caption "Kidnapped. Starved." [17] [ non-primary source needed ] British singer Jessie J shared stills from the video of David on her Instagram account, calling them heart breaking and stated "To see the past become present is a horror. Never Again. Again" [18]

Columnist Aviya Kushner wrote in The Forward that there is a stark difference between portrayals of the video in Israeli and American media. Israeli media shows the full video, while American media shows selectively-picked stills. [19]

Release efforts

The Hostages and Missing Families Forum called on Netanyahu and the government to "expedite the negotiations and bring about the immediate return of all the hostages" when David appeared in the Hamas video in February 2025. [6]

At a United Nations Security Council discussion on the hostage crisis, Ilay David spoke about his brother's conditions and criticized the council for their silence, and what he views as complicity in the continued crisis. [20] Netanyahu spoke with the regional head of the International Committee of the Red Cross and "asked for his involvement in the immediate providing of food and medical care to our hostages". [8] The Israeli government placed an advertisement photograph of David on a billboard in Times Square, with the captions "Hamas is starving the Israeli hostages" and "Ignored by the media too busy echoing Hamas propaganda". The display was intended to highlight the ongoing Gaza war hostage crisis, in light of allegations of famine in Gaza, which Israel Consul General in New York Ofir Akunis labelled a blood libel. [21]

Ilay and Yeela David, along with former hostages Ohad and Raz Ben Ami, met with President Trump and other administration officials in September 2025. During the meeting, Trump pledged his support and commitment to bring the hostages home. Galia David and other relatives of hostages also met with French President Emmanuel Macron in Paris to reenforce the priority of freeing the hostages in any discussions. [22]

References

  1. David, Ilay (December 27, 2024). "A real Chanukah gift? The release of the hostages, including my brother". Jewish News Syndicate . Archived from the original on January 30, 2025. Retrieved August 6, 2025.
  2. 1 2 Hasson, Ayala; Pines, Anna (August 2, 2025). "אביו של אביתר דוד: "מחמאס אין לי ציפיות, מצפה שהמדינה טיפה תשנה משהו"" [Eviatar David's father: "I have no expectations from Hamas, I expect the state to change something a little"]. Israeli Public Broadcasting Corporation (in Hebrew). Archived from the original on August 2, 2025. Retrieved August 31, 2025.
  3. 1 2 Khoury, Jack; Peleg, Bar (August 1, 2025). "Hamas Releases Video of Israeli Hostage Evyatar David From Gaza Captivity". Haaretz . Retrieved August 6, 2025.
  4. "אביתר דוד בן 23 מכפר סבא – חטוף בעזה". Kfar Saba News (in Hebrew). November 1, 2023.
  5. "The next 24: These are the remaining hostages presumed alive in Gaza". The Times of Israel . March 7, 2025. Retrieved August 7, 2025.
  6. 1 2 Fabian, Emanuel (February 22, 2025). "Families of hostages Eviatar David, Guy Gilboa-Dalal okay publication of Hamas propaganda clip from today". The Times of Israel . Archived from the original on February 23, 2025. Retrieved February 22, 2025.
  7. Peylan, Michal (March 29, 2025). "גיא לא היה מסוגל לדבר במשך חודש, אביתר מתקשה לראות ללא משקפיו". Mako (in Hebrew).
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sutherland, Callum; Schneid, Rebecca (August 4, 2025). "World Leaders Condemn Hamas' 'Cruel' Video of Israeli Hostage Evyatar David in Gaza Captivity". Time . Retrieved August 6, 2025.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Bachega, Hugo; Moench, Mallory (August 3, 2025). "World leaders condemn videos of emaciated Israeli hostages in Gaza as Red Cross calls for access". BBC News . Retrieved August 6, 2025.
  10. Gordon, Lihi (August 2, 2025). "Revealing detail in hostage video exposes Hamas starvation hoax". Ynetnews . Archived from the original on August 25, 2025. Retrieved August 31, 2025.
  11. "Thunberg shares image of emaciated Israeli hostage in post protesting treatment of Palestinian prisoners". The Times of Israel . October 7, 2025. Retrieved October 9, 2025.
  12. Weiniger, Gabrielle (October 8, 2025). "Greta Thunberg branded a 'joke' after Israeli hostage photo mix-up". The Times . Retrieved October 9, 2025.
  13. Bennett, Geoff (August 5, 2025). "Israeli hostage shown in Hamas video is starved, tortured and 'a broken man,' cousin says". PBS . Archived from the original on August 21, 2025. Retrieved August 31, 2025.
  14. Israel Foreign Ministry [@IsraelMFA] (August 2, 2025). "Look at the arms of Evyatar David — an Israeli hostage, starved to the edge of collapse. Now look at the arm of his Palestinian Hamas captor — strong, well-fed, offering a can for show. So who's really being starved in Gaza? @nytimes @BBC @CNN @Daily_Express" (Tweet). Retrieved August 31, 2025 via Twitter.
  15. "Trump slams 'horrible' Hamas video of emaciated hostage". Agence France-Presse . August 5, 2025.
  16. Shaked, Or (August 5, 2025). ""צפיתי בסרטון, הוא נורא": טראמפ התייחס למצבו של אביתר דוד ולכיבוש הרצועה". Israel Hayom (in Hebrew).
  17. "AJC Runs Full Page New York Times Ad to Expose Israeli Hostage Suffering". American Jewish Committee (Press release). New York. August 6, 2025. Retrieved August 7, 2025.
  18. "Jessie J calls to 'end the suffering' of hostages | The Jerusalem Post". The Jerusalem Post | JPost.com. August 4, 2025. Retrieved September 29, 2025.
  19. Kushner, Aviya (August 7, 2025). "In that horrific video of a man digging his own grave, Israelis are seeing something that Americans aren't". The Forward . Archived from the original on August 14, 2025. Retrieved August 31, 2025.
  20. Eichner, Itamar (August 5, 2025). "'Your silence is the face of this monstrous cruelty,' hostage's brother tells UN Security Council". Ynetnews . Retrieved September 7, 2025.
  21. Gilson, Grace (August 5, 2025). "Israel broadcasts Hamas' video of hostage Evyatar David in Times Square". Jewish Telegraphic Agency . Retrieved August 7, 2025.
  22. Gordon, Lihi (September 10, 2025). "'Would military pressure help?': Trump meets with former hostages in Washington". Ynetglobal. Retrieved September 29, 2025.