The political status of the Cook Islands and Niue is formally defined as being states in free association within the Realm of New Zealand, which is made up of the Cook Islands, Niue, and New Zealand and its territories, Tokelau and the Ross Dependency. The Cook Islands and Niue do not have full constitutional independence from New Zealand but act as independent countries. Some countries have recognised them as sovereign entities and established diplomatic relations. However, New Zealand may carry out defence and foreign affairs on behalf of the two associated states when requested.
New Zealand is officially responsible for the defence and foreign affairs of the Cook Islands and Niue. The Act of the New Zealand Parliament which established self-governance mentions a role for New Zealand, but the Constitution of the Cook Islands does not. [1] However, these responsibilities confer New Zealand no rights of control and can only be exercised at the request of the Cook Islands and Niue. The Cook Islands and Niue have been recognised as sovereign states by some countries, and maintain diplomatic relations under their own name. The United States recognises the Cook Islands as a sovereign and independent state, [2] and has signed treaties with the Cook Islands government. Moreover, the Secretary General of the United Nations has determined that the admission of the Cook Islands and Niue into the World Health Assembly means that they have been accepted as states by the international community. [3] [4] [5] [6]
Although the Cook Islands and Niue behave as sovereign states in international law, their constitutional statuses within the Realm of New Zealand (i.e., for matters of New Zealand domestic law) is different from that of a fully independent state, considering that all of Niue's and the Cook Islands' nationals are automatically New Zealand citizens, and both have New Zealand's Monarch as their own head of state. While both the Cook Islands and Niue have expressed a desire to become a UN member state, New Zealand has said that they would not support the application without a change in their constitutional relationship, in particular their right to New Zealand citizenship. [7] [8] However, New Zealand has never formally opposed such application, nor has it argued that either country would not be within its sovereign right to do so. [9] The foreign minister of Cook Islands has stated that a referendum would be required to determine whether to join the UN. [10]
Some scholars have argued that a lack of separate Cook Islands citizenship places an effective limit on the ability of the Cook Islands to act as a sovereign entity, while others have argued that the participation of the Cook Islands in international organisations (such as the Pacific Islands Forum) shows that Cook Islands sovereignty is not limited by the free association arrangement. [11] [12]
Formerly dependencies of New Zealand, the Cook Islands became a state in free association with New Zealand on 4 August 1965; Niue became a state in free association on 19 October 1974, after a constitutional referendum. In 1992, the UN recognised both states' right to establish diplomatic relations with other countries. [13] Since then, both the Cook Islands and Niue have been allowed to attend UN-sponsored conferences open to "all States" as well as sign and ratify UN treaties open to "non-member states".
New Zealand has formally allowed the Cook Islands to independently conduct its own foreign affairs since 6 April 2001. [14] Niue was granted this power in 2007. [15]
The Repertory of Practice of United Nations Organs records that in 1988 "New Zealand stated that its future participation in international agreements would no longer extend to" Niue and the Cook Islands. [16] The Cook Islands and Niue were granted membership of UNESCO by 1993 and of the World Health Organization by 1994. Also by 1994, the UN Secretariat had "recognized the full treaty-making capacity ... of Niue". [16] As of 2022, the Cook Islands, Kosovo, and Niue are the only state parties that participate in UN specialised agencies, but which are not member states of the UN nor observer states with the United Nations General Assembly. Additionally, the Republic of China on Taiwan participated in the World Health Assembly as Chinese Taipei from 2009 to 2016.
In September 2022, the United States announced its recognition of the Cook Islands and Niue as sovereign states during President Biden's Summit with Pacific Islands Countries (PIC) Leaders in Washington, D.C. [17] In September 2023, recognition was declared and diplomatic relations were established. [18] [19] The United States also announced it intends to open an embassy in the Cook Islands and an embassy in Niue in 2024. [20]
This section is missing information about several other countries which recognise the Cook Islands and/or Niue as self-governing and/or have diplomatic relations but are not listed below.(March 2023) |
State | Cook Islands | Niue |
---|---|---|
Malaysia | 2 May 1992 [21] | 30 January 1996 [21] |
New Zealand | 1993 [22] | 2 August 1993 [23] |
Australia | 1994 [24] | 27 February 2014 [25] |
Nauru | 1994 [24] | 9 January 2004 or before [26] |
Papua New Guinea | 1995 [24] | 9 December 2014 [27] |
China [28] | 25 July 1997 [29] | 12 December 2007 [30] [31] |
India | May 1998 [32] [33] | 30 August 2012 [34] |
Fiji | 14 July 1998 [35] | 7 November 2023 [36] |
France | 19 October 1999 [37] | 15 January 2012 or before [38] [39] [40] |
Cuba | 2 September 2002 [41] | 5 September 2014 [42] |
Italy | 9 October 2003 [43] | 12 September 2015 [44] |
Thailand | 24 May 2005 [45] | 27 August 2013 [46] [47] |
Israel | April 2008 [48] | 1 August 2023 [49] |
Turkey | 28 October 2008 [50] [51] | 7 June 2014 [51] |
Switzerland | 7 March 2011 [52] | 9 August 2023 [53] |
Japan | 16 June 2011 [54] | 4 August 2015 [55] |
Philippines | 12 December 2011 [56] | 27 September 2022 [57] |
Singapore | 6 August 2012 [58] | 6 August 2012 [58] |
South Korea | 22 February 2013 [59] | 29 May 2023 [60] |
Samoa | 30 August 2013 [61] | June 2014 or before [62] |
Tuvalu | August 2013 [63] | 11 July 2022 [64] |
Marshall Islands | 3 September 2013 [65] | 30 August 2024 [66] |
Kosovo [67] | 18 May 2015 [68] [69] | 23 June 2015 [70] |
Brazil | 21 August 2015 [71] | 2 September 2016 [72] |
Chile | 3 August 2016 [73] | 6 July 2021 [74] |
Peru | September 2017 [75] | 13 July 2020 [76] |
Indonesia | 13 July 2019 [77] | 13 July 2019 [78] |
Canada | 20 May 2023 [79] | 12 September 2023 [80] |
United States | 25 September 2023 [81] | 25 September 2023 [82] |
Norway | 18 July 1991 [83] | No relations |
Portugal | 12 August 1995 [84] | |
South Africa | 9 February 1996 [85] | |
Iran | 1996 [22] | |
United Kingdom | 4 December 1997 [86] | |
Spain | 29 January 1998 [87] | |
Holy See (Vatican City) | 29 April 1999 [88] | |
Germany | 11 September 2001 [89] | |
East Timor | 2002 [22] | |
Jamaica | 14 May 2003 [90] | |
Belgium | 6 April 2005 [91] | |
Czechia | 12 May 2008 [92] | |
Netherlands | 16 August 2011 [93] | |
Solomon Islands | 1 September 2013 [94] | |
Kiribati | 3 September 2013 [65] | |
Palau | 3 September 2013 [65] | |
Vanuatu | 2013 [22] | |
Micronesia | 24 September 2014 [95] | |
Tonga | 18 November 2014 [96] | |
Malta | 6 October 2017 [97] | |
Iceland | 13 October 2017 [98] | |
Antigua and Barbuda | 9 November 2017 [99] | |
United Arab Emirates | 5 August 2018 [100] | |
Estonia | 25 August 2018 [101] | |
Hungary | 20 September 2018 [102] | |
Greece | 20 October 2018 [103] | |
Kuwait | 8 December 2021 [104] | |
Vietnam | 26 April 2022 [105] | |
Ireland | 21 November 2022 [106] | |
Saudi Arabia | 11 April 2023 [107] | |
Ghana | 8 November 2023 [108] | |
Mexico | 21 November 2023 [109] | |
Panama | 8 March 2024 [110] | |
Bangladesh | 11 April 2024 [111] | |
Ecuador | 21 May 2024 [112] | |
Seychelles | 31 May 2024 [113] |
State | Position | Relations with | |
---|---|---|---|
Cook Islands | Niue | ||
United States | Cook Islands In 1980, the Cook Islands–United States Maritime Boundary Treaty was signed. The United States recognised the ability of the Cook Islands to negotiate a treaty on its own only after consulting the New Zealand government regarding the exact status of the Cook Islands. In response to the United States' request the New Zealand government confirmed "the competence of the Cook Islands Government to undertake the obligations and exercise the rights under the draft [bilateral] treaty". [114] Consequently, the United States signed a bilateral treaty with the Cook Islands recognizing the latter's sovereignty over the islands subject to the said treaty and its treaty-making power. [114] The Cook Islands and the United States have maintained consular relations since 1995. [115] As of 2011, the State Department included the Cook Islands under the sovereignty of New Zealand in its list of "Dependencies and Areas of Special Sovereignty". [116] As of 2014, The World Factbook listed the Cook Islands as a "self-governing territory in free association with New Zealand". [117] As of 2023, both the State Department and The World Factbook consider the Cook Islands as an independent state. [118] [119] In September 2022, the United States announced its intention to recognise the Cook Islands as a sovereign state during President Biden's Summit with Pacific Islands Countries (PIC) Leaders in Washington, D.C. [120] [17] In September 2023, recognition was declared and diplomatic relations were established. [121] [122] The United States also announced it intends to open an embassy in the Cook Islands in 2024. [20] Niue In 1997, the United States and Niue signed a maritime boundary treaty that mentioned how "Prior to signing the treaty, the political status of Niue was addressed". [123] As of 2011, the State Department included Niue under the sovereignty of New Zealand in its list of "Dependencies and Areas of Special Sovereignty". [116] As of 2014, The World Factbook listed Niue as a "self-governing territory in free association with New Zealand". [124] As of 2023, both the State Department and The World Factbook consider Niue as an independent state. [118] [125] In September 2022, the United States announced its intention to recognise Niue as a sovereign state during President Biden's Summit with Pacific Islands Countries (PIC) Leaders in Washington, D.C. [126] [17] In September 2023, recognition was declared and diplomatic relations were established. [127] [128] The United States also announced it intends to open an embassy in Niue in 2024. [20] |
State | Position | Relations with | |
---|---|---|---|
Cook Islands | Niue | ||
France | Though the French Ambassador to New Zealand is also accredited to the Cook Islands and Niue, France still describes them as having "no international sovereignty". [129] [130] | ||
Israel | On 1 July 1994, Israel and New Zealand signed an agreement establishing diplomatic relations. The document stated: [131]
Israel established diplomatic relations with the Cook Islands in April 2008 and with Niue on 3 August 2023. [48] [132] | ||
New Zealand | Cook Islands On 11 June 2001, Helen Clark and Terepai Maoate signed an agreement establishing diplomatic relations between the Cook Islands and New Zealand. The document stated: [133]
Clark later said that if the Cook Islands wanted to be its own sovereign state, it would first need its own citizenship. [134] New Zealand believes that if the Cook Islands were to become a sovereign state, an independence referendum and constitutional change would occur. The eligibility of New Zealand citizenship would have to change. [133] Niue New Zealand has stated that Niue's free association is "a status distinct from that of full independence". [135] |
While their respective relationships with New Zealand, as well as their small size, make them rather unusual states, it has been argued that their status is far from unique. According to Zbigniew Dumienski, both the Cook Islands and Niue can be seen as microstates, which are defined as: "modern protected states, i.e. sovereign states that have been able to unilaterally depute certain attributes of sovereignty to larger powers in exchange for benign protection of their political and economic viability against their geographic or demographic constraints." Both the Cook Islands and Niue, as well as such states as Andorra, Liechtenstein, Monaco, Nauru, San Marino, and Vatican City, fit into this definition of microstates. [136]
Fiji has experienced many coups recently, in 1987, 2000, and 2006. Fiji has been suspended various times from the Commonwealth of Nations, a grouping of mostly former British colonies. It was readmitted to the Commonwealth in December 2001, following the parliamentary election held to restore democracy in September that year, and has been suspended again because of the 2006 coup, but has been readmitted a second time after the 2014 election. Other Pacific Island governments have generally been sympathetic to Fiji's internal political problems and have declined to take public positions.
Niue is a self-governing island country in free association with New Zealand. It is situated in the South Pacific Ocean and is part of Polynesia, and predominantly inhabited by Polynesians. One of the world's largest coral islands, Niue is commonly referred to as "The Rock", which comes from the traditional name "Rock of Polynesia".
The foreign relations of New Zealand are oriented chiefly toward developed democratic nations and emerging Pacific Island economies. Until the late 20th century, New Zealand aligned itself strongly with the United Kingdom and had few bilateral relationships with other countries. From the latter half of the 20th century, Australia has been New Zealand's most important cultural, economic and military partner. Today, the country participates in several multilateral political organisations, including Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation, the Pacific Community, and the Pacific Islands Forum. New Zealand has been described as an emerging power; however, such a claim needs to be considered in the context of its medium-sized economy and limited military capability. The country's major political parties have generally agreed on the broad outlines of foreign policy, and the government has been active in promoting free trade, nuclear disarmament, and arms control.
The member states of the United Nations comprise 193 sovereign states. The United Nations (UN) is the world's largest intergovernmental organization. All members have equal representation in the UN General Assembly.
Papua New Guinea's foreign policy reflects close ties with Australia and other traditional allies and cooperative relations with neighboring countries. Its views on international political and economic issues are generally moderate.
Nauru became a sovereign, independent republic on 31 January 1968, following the passage of the Nauru Independence Act 1967 by the Parliament of Australia and the end of its status as a United Nations Trust Territory. Nauru has established diplomatic relations with a number of nations, including most of its Pacific neighbors with which it maintains economic, cultural and administrative ties.
An associated state is the minor partner or dependent territory in a formal, free relationship between a political territory and a major party—usually a larger nation.
From 1916 to 1975, Tuvalu was part of the Gilbert and Ellice Islands colony of the United Kingdom. A referendum was held in 1974 to determine whether the Gilbert Islands and Ellice Islands should each have their own administration. As a consequence of the referendum, the separate British colonies of Kiribati and Tuvalu were formed. Tuvalu became fully independent as a sovereign state within the Commonwealth on 1 October 1978. On 5 September 2000, Tuvalu became the 189th member of the United Nations.
The Realm of New Zealand is the area over which the monarch of New Zealand is head of state. The realm is not a federation but is a collection of states and territories united under its monarch. New Zealand is an independent and sovereign state that has one territorial claim in Antarctica, one dependent territory (Tokelau), and two associated states. The Realm of New Zealand encompasses the three autonomous jurisdictions of New Zealand, the Cook Islands, and Niue.
The Cook Islands maintains diplomatic relations with various countries and is a member of multilateral organisations. While the country is in free association with New Zealand, which can act on the Cook Islands' "delegated authority [...] to assist the Cooks Islands" in foreign affairs, the Cook Islands nevertheless enters into treaty obligations and otherwise "interacts with the international community as a sovereign and independent state."
The Sovereign Military Order of Malta (SMOM) is a sovereign entity maintaining diplomatic relations with 113 sovereign states. Additionally, it has observer status or representation at multiple intergovernmental organisations. The Order has non-diplomatic official relations with five more states: France, Belgium, Switzerland, Luxembourg, Canada and the United Kingdom. The Order exchanges ambassadors with the European Union and the State of Palestine.
Niue maintains diplomatic relations with various other countries and multilateral organizations.
China-Niuean relations are relations between China and Niue.
The Holy See has long been recognised as a subject of international law and as an active participant in international relations. It is distinct from the city-state of the Vatican City, over which the Holy See has "full ownership, exclusive dominion, and sovereign authority and jurisdiction".
India–Niue relations are the bilateral relations between India and Niue.
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)The question of whether the Cook Islands and Niue were 'independent' entities, i.e. – States, with full treaty making capacity was also considered. The Cook Islands and Niue maintained the status of self-governing territories in free association with New Zealand. In view of this special relationship with New Zealand, which discharged the external affairs and defense of the Cook Islands and Niue, neither the Cook Islands nor Niue could invoke the 'all States' clause to participate in treaties deposited with the Secretary-General unless specifically invited to participate in a treaty.
Since 2001, the Cook Islands have complete sovereignty in managing their Foreign affairs according to the common declaration of 6 April 2001.
Niue started its own foreign policies in 2007, when they established official diplomatic relationships with China. New Zealand allows this evolution of autonomy by the island.
The two Governments have agreed to develop friendly relations and cooperation between the two countries on the basis of the principles of mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity...
The two Governments have agreed to develop friendly cooperation between the two countries on the basis of the principles of mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity...
History will note though that China is the first country to recognise Niue diplomatically formally and I thank the Chinese Government for that honour. I acknowledge the former Premier Hon Young Vivian and his Government who initiated and finalised these arrangements in December last year.
Ambassador of France in New Zealand, Mrs Jeanblanc-Risler is also accredited to Cook Islands, Niue and Samoa.
In his letter, the dignitary referred to the strengthening and deepening of the ties of friendship between the two countries since the establishment of diplomatic relations in 2002...
Cuba has diplomatic relations with 190 countries, orders and institutions. With this signing, Niue becomes the 191st State with which Cuba has ties at the highest level.
The two Governments have agreed to develop and strengthen friendly relations and cooperation between the two countries and peoples in accordance with the principles of equality, mutual respect for sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity and non-interference in each other's internal affairs.
Being desirous of promoting and reinforcing friendly relations between the two countries and peoples in accordance with the principles of equality, mutual respect for sovereignty, independence, territorial integrity and non-interference in each other's internal affairs...
Diplomatic relations between Turkey and Cook Islands were established on 28 October 2008.
He said a Joint Declaration on the Establishment of Diplomatic Relations with the Pacific island country of Niue was signed at the meeting. 'With Niue added, we have diplomatic relations with all Pacific Island Forum countries,' he said. ... The Pacific Small Island Developing States (PSIDS) include the Cook Islands… Niue…
Singapore has established diplomatic relations with Cook Islands, ... Niue, ...
The Cook Islands will mark the 190th country with which Korea has forged diplomatic relations.
The Joint Communiqué outlines the agreement of the two governments to develop friendly relations and cooperation on the basis of the principles of mutual respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, non-aggression, non-interference in each other's internal affairs, equality and mutual benefit, and peaceful coexistence.
It considers Queen Elizabeth as head of state, while this recognition is important as Niue is a sovereign member with full voting rights in UN agencies such as UNESCO, WHO, WTO, which Kosovo intends to join.
Joint communiques play a significant role in relations between states, as they are affirmation of recognition by each state of each other's political and economic sovereignty as states and signify commitment by both states to promote cooperation on the basis of equality, mutual respect for each other's sovereignty, independence and territorial integrity as well as non-interference in the internal affairs of each other, guided by the principles and purposes of the Charter of the United Nations and the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations 1961.
Der völkerrechtliche Status der Cookinseln ist besonderer Natur. Die Cookinseln sind ein unabhängiger Staat in 'freier Assoziierung mit Neuseeland'.
Reaffirming their commitment to the principles of: sovereign equality, respect for each other's territory...
One issue that had to be addressed during the negotiation of this treaty was the political status of the Cook Islands Government. The Cook Islands is in free association with New Zealand. On internal matters it is self-governing and it may unilaterally declare its independence from New Zealand at any time. The Cook Islands conducts its foreign affairs in conjunction with New Zealand. The Cook Islands declared and does manage a 200-nautical-mile zone. During the negotiations the question arose whether it was legally possible for the United States to enter into a treaty relationship with political entity other than a fully sovereign and independent state.
Prior to signing the treaty, the political status of Niue was addressed. Niue is in free association with New Zealand. On internal matters it is self-governing. Niue conducts its foreign affairs in conjunction with New Zealand. Niue has declared and does manage its exclusive economic zone. The United States requested, and received, confirmation from New Zealand that the Government of Niue had the competence to enter into this agreement with the United States. The text of New Zealand's note is reproduced at Annex 2 to this study.
Subsequently the Cook Islands has no international sovereignty.
Niue has no international sovereignty, although the island has begun establishing its own foreign policies.
The maturity of the Cook Islands' international personality does not mean that the Cook Islands is, in constitutional terms, and independent sovereign state. In New Zealand's view, a constitutional change of that significance would have implications in terms of Cook Islanders' eligibility for New Zealand citizenship, and would require formal constitutional acts including a referendum and changes to the Cook Islands Constitution.
She said she had pointed out New Zealand citizenship implications for Cook Islanders if the Cooks sought sovereignty, enabling them to be a member in their own right.
If the Cooks wanted to become a sovereign nation, it needed its own citizenship. Cook Islanders would remain New Zealand citizens but "if they want to change it, they can."
Ms Clark said: "If they want to exert full independence, New Zealand will not stand in their way."
New Zealand and Niue have a special relationship founded on close historical ties, unique constitutional arrangements and a common citizenship and currency. Niue became a British protectorate in 1900 and was annexed by New Zealand in 1901. In 1974, following an act of self-determination under United Nations auspices, the people of Niue adopted a Constitution providing for full self-government in free association with New Zealand, a status distinct from that of full independence.