1884 Major League Baseball season

Last updated

1884 MLB season
League American Association (AA)
National League (NL)
Union Association (UA)
Sport Baseball
DurationRegular season:
  • May 1 – October 15, 1884 (AA, NL)
  • April 17 – October 19, 1884 (UA)
World's Championship Series (AA vs. NL):
  • October 23–25, 1884
Number of games110 (AA)
112 (NL, UA)
Number of teams33 (12 active in AA, 8 active in NL, UA)
Pennant winner
AA champions New York Metropolitans
  AA runners-up Columbus Buckeyes
NL champions Providence Grays
  NL runners-up Boston Beaneaters
UA champions St. Louis Maroons
  UA runners-up Cincinnati Outlaw Reds
World's Championship Series
Champions Providence Grays
  Runners-up New York Metropolitans
MLB seasons
Locations of teams for the 1884 American Association season
ButtonRed.svg American Association
Locations of teams for the 1884 Union Association season
ButtonGreen.svg Union Association
*Chicago Browns moved to Pittsburgh mid-way through the season as the Pittsburgh Stogies.

The 1884 major league baseball season began on April 17, 1884. The National League and American Association's regular seasons ended on October 15, with the Providence Grays and New York Metropolitans as the NL and AA pennant winners, respectively. The newly founded Union Association regular season ended on October 19, with the St. Louis Maroons as the UA pennant winner. The postseason between the AA and NL began with Game 1 of the first World's Championship Series (the first inter-league championship game of its kind in the Major Leagues) on October 23 and ended with Game 3 on October 25, in what was a best-of-five-playoff. The Grays swept the Metropolitans in three games, capturing their first World's Championship Series.

Contents

Prior to the 1884 season, in September 1883, the Union Association was formed, in direct contravention to the reserve rule (that a ballplayer could be reserved by a team) of the 1883 National Agreement (a.k.a. Tripartite Agreement) signed between the National League, American Association, and minor league Northwestern League. [1] In response to formation of the UA, the AA expanded their league from an eight teams to twelve teams to undermine the week footing the UA had, as UA teams were mostly in cities that already had established AA and NL teams. [2]

The American Association expansion saw the minor league Brooklyn Grays of the Inter-State Association of Professional Baseball Clubs join as the Brooklyn Atlantics (today's Los Angeles Dodgers) and the Toledo Blue Stockings join from the minor league Northwestern League, as well as the establishment of the Indianapolis Hoosiers and Washington Nationals. The latter played their last game on August 2, and were replaced by the minor league Eastern League's Richmond Virginians to finish Washington's schedule.

The Union Association was largely unstable throughout its only year in existence (though confidence in the league remained high), as three of its founding teams would not make it to the end of the season. [2] The Altoona Mountain Citys folded on May 31, and were replaced by the Kansas City Cowboys on June 7. The Philadelphia Keystones folded on August 7, and were replaced by the Eastern League's Wilmington Quicksteps. The Chicago Browns relocated to Pittsburgh as the Pittsburgh Stogies following their August 21 game. The Quicksteps would fold on September 15, while the Stogies would fold just three days later. On September 27, the Milwaukee Brewers and St. Paul Apostles (now renamed the St. Paul Saints) were recruited from the Northwestern League to finish the Philadelphia / Wilmington and Chicago/Pittsburgh schedules, respectively.

Schedule

The 1884 schedule consisted of 110 games for all teams in the American Association, which had twelve active teams, and 112 games for all teams in the National League and Union Association, each of which had eight active teams. Each AA team was scheduled to play 10 games against the other eleven teams in their league, and each of NL & UA teams were scheduled to play 16 games against the other seven teams of their respective league. The National League increased its total games per team from 98 to 112, 14 games to 16 games per seven opponents. The new Union Association copied this format. Meanwhile, the American Association, expanding from eight to twelve teams, changed from the 98-game format to the 110-game format. The National League would continue to use their 112-game format through the following season, while the American Association would copy the NL format.

Union Association Opening Day took place on April 17 featuring six teams, while American Association and National League Opening Days took place on May 1, featuring all twelve and all eight teams, respectively. The Union Association would see its final day of the regular season on October 19 featuring four teams, while the American Association and National League would see their final day of the regular season on October 15 featuring all twelve teams and four teams, respectively. [3] The 1884 World's Championship Series took place between October 23 and October 25.

Rule changes

The 1884 season saw the following rule changes:

Teams

An asterisk (*) denotes the ballpark a team played the minority of their home games at
A dagger (†) denotes a team that folded mid-season
A double dagger (‡) denotes a team joined mid-season

LeagueTeamCityStadiumCapacityManager [6]
American Association Baltimore Orioles Oxford, Maryland [A] Oriole Park 5,000 Billy Barnie
Brooklyn Atlantics Brooklyn, New York Washington Park 3,000 George Taylor
Cincinnati Red Stockings Cincinnati, Ohio American Park 3,000 Will White
Pop Snyder
Columbus Buckeyes Columbus, Ohio Recreation Park (Columbus) Unknown Gus Schmelz
Indianapolis Hoosiers Indianapolis, Indiana Seventh Street Park Unknown Jim Gifford
Bill Watkins
Louisville Eclipse Louisville, Kentucky Eclipse Park 5,860 Mike Walsh
New York Metropolitans New York, New York Metropolitan Park 5,000 Jim Mutrie
Polo Grounds*20,709*
Philadelphia Athletics Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Jefferson Street Grounds 15,000 Lon Knight
Pittsburgh Alleghenys Allegheny, Pennsylvania Recreation Park (Pittsburgh) 17,000 Denny McKnight
Bob Ferguson
Joe Battin
George Creamer
Horace Phillips
Richmond Virginians Richmond, Virginia Virginia Base-Ball Park Unknown Felix Moses
St. Louis Browns St. Louis, Missouri Sportsman's Park 6,000 Jimmy Williams
Charles Comiskey
Toledo Blue Stockings Toldeo, Ohio League Park Unknown Charlie Morton
Washington Nationals (AA) Washington, D.C. Athletic Park (Washington) 6,000 Holly Hollingshead
John Bickerton
National League Boston Beaneaters Boston, Massachusetts South End Grounds 3,000 John Morrill
Buffalo Bisons Buffalo, New York Olympic Park 5,000 Jim O'Rourke
Chicago White Stockings Chicago, Illinois Lakefront Park 5,000 Cap Anson
Cleveland Blues Cleveland, Ohio National League Park Unknown Charlie Hackett
Detroit Wolverines Detroit, Michigan Recreation Park (Detroit) Unknown Jack Chapman
New York Gothams New York, New York Polo Grounds 20,709 John Ward
Jim Price
Philadelphia Quakers Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Recreation Park 6,500 Harry Wright
Providence Grays Providence, Rhode Island Messer Street Grounds 6,000 Frank Bancroft
Union Association Altoona Mountain Citys Altoona, Pennsylvania Columbia Park Unknown Ed Curtis
Baltimore Monumentals Baltimore, Maryland Belair Lot Unknown Bill Henderson
Boston Reds Boston, Massachusetts Dartmouth Street Grounds 4,575 Tim Murnane
Chicago Browns/Pittsburgh Stogies Chicago, Illinois South Side Park Unknown Ed Hengel
Allegheny, Pennsylvania Exposition Park Unknown Joe Battin
Joe Ellick
Cincinnati Outlaw Reds Cincinnati, Ohio Bank Street Grounds 3,000 Dan O'Leary
Sam Crane
Kansas City Cowboys Kansas City, Missouri Athletic Park 4,000 Harry Wheeler
Matthew Porter
Ted Sullivan
Milwaukee Brewers Milwaukee, Wisconsin Wright Street Grounds 5,300 Tom Loftus
Philadelphia Keystones Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Keystone Park Unknown Fergy Malone
St. Louis Maroons St. Louis, Missouri Union Base Ball Park 10,000 Ted Sullivan
Fred Dunlap
St. Paul Saints Saint Paul, Minnesota West Seventh Street Park Unknown Andrew Thompson
Washington Nationals (UA) Washington, D.C. Capitol Grounds 6,000 Michael Scanlon
Wilmington Quicksteps‡† Wilmington, Delaware Union Street Park Unknown Joe Simmons
  1. ^
    In today's Barclay, Baltimore.

Standings

American Association

American Association
Team W L Pct. GB Home Road
New York Metropolitans 7532.7014293323
Columbus Buckeyes 6939.63938163123
Louisville Eclipse 6840.63041142726
St. Louis Browns 6740.626838162924
Cincinnati Red Stockings 6841.624840162825
Baltimore Orioles 6343.59411½42132130
Philadelphia Athletics 6146.5701438162330
Toledo Blue Stockings 4658.44227½28251833
Brooklyn Atlantics 4064.38533½23261738
Richmond Virginians 1230.28630½515715
Pittsburgh Alleghenys 3078.27845½18371241
Indianapolis Hoosiers 2978.2714615391439
Washington Nationals 1251.190411020231

National League

National League
Team W L Pct. GB Home Road
Providence Grays 8428.75045113917
Boston Beaneaters 7338.65810½40163322
Buffalo Bisons 6447.57719½37182729
New York Gothams 6250.5542234222828
Chicago White Stockings 6250.5542239172333
Philadelphia Quakers 3973.3484519372036
Cleveland Blues 3577.3124922341343
Detroit Wolverines 2884.2505618381046

Union Association

Union Association
Team W L Pct. GB Home Road
St. Louis Maroons 9419.8324964513
Cincinnati Outlaw Reds 6936.6572135173419
Baltimore Monumentals 5847.5523229212926
Boston Reds 5851.5323434222429
Milwaukee Brewers 84.66735½8400
St. Paul Saints 26.25039½0026
Chicago Browns/Pittsburgh Stogies 4150.4514221192031
Altoona Mountain Citys 619.2404461207
Wilmington Quicksteps 216.11144½16110
Washington Nationals (UA) 4765.42046½36271138
Philadelphia Keystones 2146.313501421725
Kansas City Cowboys 1663.203611123540

Union Association eight-team standings

Union Association
Team W L Pct. GB Home Road
St. Louis Maroons 9419.83249–645–13
Cincinnati Outlaw Reds 6936.6572135–1734–19
Baltimore Monumentals 5847.5523229–2129–26
Boston Reds 5851.5323434–2224–29
Chicago Browns/Pittsburgh Stogies / St. Paul Saints 4356.4344321–1922–37
Washington Nationals (UA) 4765.42046½36–2711–38
Philadelphia Keystones / Wilmington Quicksteps / Milwaukee Brewers 3166.3205523–318–35
Altoona Mountain Citys / Kansas City Cowboys 2282.21267½17–355–47

Postseason

Bracket

World's Championship Series
     
AA New York Metropolitans 0 1 2
NL Providence Grays 637126

Managerial changes

Off-season

TeamFormer ManagerNew Manager
Cincinnati Red Stockings Pop Snyder Will White
Cleveland Blues Frank Bancroft Charlie Hackett
Columbus Buckeyes Horace Phillips Gus Schmelz
Louisville Eclipse Joe Gerhardt Mike Walsh
New York Gothams John Clapp John Ward
Philadelphia Quakers Blondie Purcell Harry Wright
Pittsburgh Alleghenys Joe Battin Denny McKnight
Providence Grays Harry Wright Frank Bancroft
St. Louis Browns Charles Comiskey Jimmy Williams

In-season

TeamFormer ManagerNew Manager
Altoona Mountain Citys Ed Curtis Team folded mid-way through the season
Chicago Browns/Pittsburgh Stogies Ed Hengel Joe Battin
Joe Battin Joe Ellick
Joe Ellick Team folded mid-way through the season
Cincinnati Outlaw Reds Dan O'Leary Sam Crane
Cincinnati Red Stockings Will White Pop Snyder
Indianapolis Hoosiers Jim Gifford Bill Watkins
Kansas City Cowboys Team enfranchised mid-season Harry Wheeler
Harry Wheeler Matthew Porter
Matthew Porter Ted Sullivan
Milwaukee Brewers Team transferred from minor league Northwestern League mid-way through the season Tom Loftus
New York Gothams John Ward Jim Price
Philadelphia Keystones Fergy Malone Team folded mid-way through the season
Pittsburgh Alleghenys Denny McKnight Bob Ferguson
Bob Ferguson Joe Battin
Joe Battin George Creamer
George Creamer Horace Phillips
St. Louis Browns Jimmy Williams Charles Comiskey
St. Louis Maroons Ted Sullivan Fred Dunlap
St. Paul Saints Team transferred from minor league Northwestern League mid-way through the season Andrew Thompson
Washington Nationals (AA) Holly Hollingshead John Bickerton
Wilmington Quicksteps Team transferred from minor league Eastern League mid-way through the season Joe Simmons
Joe Simmons Team folded mid-way through the season

League leaders

Any team shown in small text indicates a previous team a player was on during the season.
Any team shown in italics indicates a team a player was on from a different league. Any stat from said different league is not calculated to determine the league leader.

American Association

Hitting leaders [7]
StatPlayerTotal
AVG Dave Orr (NYM).354
OPS John Reilly (CRS).918
HR John Reilly (CRS)11
RBI Dave Orr (NYM)112
R Harry Stovey (PHA)124
H Dave Orr (NYM)162
Pitching leaders [8]
StatPlayerTotal
W Guy Hecker 1 (LOU)52
L Larry McKeon (IND)41
ERA Guy Hecker 1 (LOU)1.80
K Guy Hecker 1 (LOU)385
IP Guy Hecker (LOU)670.2
SV Thomas Burns (BLO/ WIL )
Frank Mountain (COL)
Hank O'Day (TOL)
1
WHIP Guy Hecker (LOU)0.868

1 American Association Triple Crown pitching winner

National League

Hitting leaders [9]
StatPlayerTotal
AVG King Kelly (CHI).354
OPS Dan Brouthers (BUF).941
HR Ed Williamson (CHI)27
RBI Cap Anson (CHI)102
R King Kelly (CHI)120
H Jim O'Rourke (BUF)
Ezra Sutton (BSB)
162
Pitching leaders [10]
StatPlayerTotal
W Charles Radbourn 2 3 (PRO)60
L John Harkins (CLE)32
ERA Charles Radbourn 2 (PRO)1.38
K Charles Radbourn 2 (PRO)441
IP Charles Radbourn (PRO)678.2
SV John Morrill (BSB)2
WHIP Charlie Sweeney (SLM/ PRO )0.824

2 National League Triple Crown pitching winner
3 All-time single-season wins record

Union Association

Hitting leaders [11]
StatPlayerTotal
AVG Fred Dunlap (SLM).412
OPS Fred Dunlap (SLM)1.069
HR Fred Dunlap (SLM)13
RBI Unavailable
R Fred Dunlap (SLM)160
H Fred Dunlap (SLM)185
Pitching leaders [12]
StatPlayerTotal
W Bill Sweeney (BLM)40
L Jersey Bakley (KC/ WIL/PHK )30
ERA Jim McCormick (COR/ CLE )1.54
K Hugh Daily (WSU/ CHB-PIS )483
IP Bill Sweeney (BLM)538.0
SV Billy Taylor (SLM)4
WHIP Jim McCormick (COR/ CLE )0.786

References

  1. Terrell, Barney. "1883-84 Winter Meetings: The Union Association – Society for American Baseball Research" . Retrieved February 10, 2025.
  2. 1 2 Andrews, Davy. "The Union Association War of 1884 – Society for American Baseball Research" . Retrieved February 10, 2025.
  3. "1884 Major Leagues Schedule". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 8, 2025.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: url-status (link)
  4. "MLB Rule Changes | Baseball Almanac". www.baseball-almanac.com. Retrieved January 28, 2025.
  5. "Baseball History: 19th Century Baseball: The Field: The Pitcher's Area". www.19cbaseball.com. Retrieved February 10, 2025.
  6. "1884 Major League Managers". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  7. "1884 American Association Batting Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  8. "1884 American Association Pitching Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  9. "1884 National League Batting Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  10. "1884 National League Pitching Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  11. "1884 Union Association Batting Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.
  12. "1884 Union Association Pitching Leaders". Baseball-Reference.com. Retrieved February 5, 2025.