Cultural depictions of Napoleon

Last updated

Napoleon is often represented in his green colonel uniform of the Chasseur a Cheval, with a large bicorne and a hand-in-waistcoat gesture. Napoleon in 1806.PNG
Napoleon is often represented in his green colonel uniform of the Chasseur à Cheval, with a large bicorne and a hand-in-waistcoat gesture.
The Napoleon Bonaparte Monument in Warsaw, Poland Pomnik Napoleona Warszawa 00.jpg
The Napoleon Bonaparte Monument in Warsaw, Poland
A French Empire mantel clock representing Mars and Venus, an allegory of the wedding of Napoleon I and Archduchess Marie Louise of Austria. By the famous bronzier Pierre-Philippe Thomire, ca. 1810 Clock Thomire Louvre OA9511.jpg
A French Empire mantel clock representing Mars and Venus, an allegory of the wedding of Napoleon I and Archduchess Marie Louise of Austria. By the famous bronzier Pierre-Philippe Thomire, ca. 1810
Celebration of the anniversary of the birth of Napoleon Bonaparte involving historical reenactment groups in uniforms from the Napoleonic period on Napoleon Hill in Szczecin, Poland, 2008 Szczecin Wzgorze Napoleona (1).jpg
Celebration of the anniversary of the birth of Napoleon Bonaparte involving historical reenactment groups in uniforms from the Napoleonic period on Napoleon Hill in Szczecin, Poland, 2008
Monument Napoleon Monument Napoleon.jpg
Monument Napoleon
Cosplay of Napoleon Reenactment of the entry of Napoleon to Gdansk after siege - 49.jpg
Cosplay of Napoleon

Napoleon I, Emperor of the French, has become a worldwide cultural icon generally associated with tactical brilliance, ambition, and political power. His distinctive features and costume have made him a very recognisable figure in popular culture.

Contents

Few men in human history have elicited both as much hatred and admiration, and have divided opinion so much. From the beginnings of his military and political career, by seizing power through the coup of 18 Brumaire (1799), Napoleon inscribed himself in the grand historical narrative of modernity and in the memory of men through a tumultuous and exceptional destiny. His meteoric rise, initially achieved through victorious military conquests, the unprecedented scale of his final defeats, as well as his two exiles, have made this major figure in the history of France and Europe a legendary character.

He has been portrayed in many works of fiction, his depiction varying greatly with the author's perception of the historical character. On the one hand, Napoleon has become a worldwide cultural icon who symbolises military genius and political power. For example, in the 1927 film Napoléon , young general Bonaparte is portrayed as a heroic visionary. On the other hand, he has often been reduced to a stock character and has frequently been depicted as a short and "petty tyrant", sometimes comically so.

Origin and construction of the Napoleonic myth

Napoleon Bonaparte is the primary architect of his own legend. In his work "Napoléon journaliste," Antonin Périvier  [ fr ] writes: "Bonaparte, and later Napoleon, directed all the publicity at his disposal solely towards himself and for his exclusive benefit". [1] From the First Italian Campaign in 1797, he established propaganda in his favor by publishing bulletins in Italy intended to glorify his military actions and influence public opinion. On July 20, the "Courier of the Army of Italy" appeared, followed on August 10 by "France as Seen by the Army of Italy," and in Paris, the "Journal of Bonaparte and Virtuous Men," which was published under the initiative of his brothers Joseph and Lucien on February 19, 1797. In these publications, he highlighted his actions and commented on the political situation in France. They included dithyrambic epigraphs such as: in the Courier, "Bonaparte flies like lightning and strikes like thunder. He is everywhere and sees everything; he is the envoy of the great nation," and in the Journal of Bonaparte: "Hannibal slept in Capua, but the active Bonaparte does not sleep in Mantua". [2] These newspapers and the propaganda they spread in France helped distinguish Bonaparte from other generals of the Republic and contributed to the rise of his popularity in public opinion.

Maurice Duverger emphasizes the importance of the propaganda orchestrated by Napoleon, the parades, and celebrations surrounding his victories in the functioning of his regime: the people and courtiers repeated that the rain would stop and the sun would appear when he showed himself. "Napoleon continues to fascinate all theorists of political power; is it not because his dictatorship appears singularly modern? His authority takes on a charismatic character that aligns with our modern cult of personality [3] ." This cult is widely propagated by the soldiers of the Grande Armée, who rely on the emperor in the most difficult moments, but also by the clergy, who, from the Concordat of 1801, present Napoleon as the envoy of providence. [4]

Fine art

Art contributes to the Napoleonic legend during the emperor's lifetime through propaganda paintings, sculptures, engravings, or prints by artists such as David or Antoine-Jean Gros, among others. Paintings created after Napoleon's life, or even long after his death, mostly express a nostalgia for France under Napoleon. For example, Édouard Detaille's "The Dream" (which is now in the Musée d'Orsay in Paris) depicted in a highly patriotic allegory French soldiers from 1870 sleeping, with the distant memory of the victorious Grande Armée in the clouds. This type of painting, showing nostalgia for a victorious and united France, is one of the foundations of the Napoleonic legend, as they all visually represent the increasingly distant memory of a mythical France.

Literature, theatre, and film

'The Memorial of Saint Helena,' a masterpiece of propaganda first published in 1823 (after Napoleon's death in 1821) by Emmanuel de Las Cases, revives the golden legend and lays the foundations of Bonapartism. [5]

Famous novelist Honoré de Balzac illustrates the admiration of the French and many Europeans by writing in "A Conversation Between Eleven O'Clock and Midnight," an excerpt from "Contes Bruns": "Who will ever explain, depict, or understand Napoleon? A man represented with his arms folded, and who did everything, who was the greatest force ever known, the most concentrated, the most mordant, the most acid of all forces; a singular genius who carried armed civilization in every direction without fixing it anywhere; a man who could do everything because he willed everything; a prodigious phenomenon of will, conquering an illness by a battle, and yet doomed to die of disease in bed after living in the midst of ball and bullets; a man with a code and a sword in his brain, word and deed; a clear-sighted spirit that foresaw everything but his own fall; a capricious politician who risked men by handfuls out of economy, and who spared three heads—those of Talleyrand, of Pozzo de Borgo, and of Metternich, diplomatists whose death would have saved the French Empire, and who seemed to him of greater weight than thousands of soldiers; a man to whom nature, as a rare privilege, had given a heart in a frame of bronze; mirthful and kind at midnight amid women, and next morning manipulating Europe as a young girl might amuse herself by splashing water in her bath! Hypocritical and generous; loving tawdriness and simplicity; devoid of taste, but protecting the arts; and in spite of these antitheses, really great in everything by instinct or by temperament; Caesar at five-and-twenty, Cromwell at thirty; and then, like my grocer buried in Père Lachaise, a good husband and a good father. In short, he improvised public works, empires, kings, codes, verses, a romance—and all with more range than precision. Did he not aim at making all Europe France? And after making us weigh on the earth in such a way as to change the laws of gravitation, he left us poorer than on the day when he first laid hands on us; while he, who had taken an empire by his name, lost his name on the frontier of his empire in a sea of blood and soldiers. A man all thought and all action, who comprehended Desaix and Fouché." [6]

The Count of Monte Cristo

Napoleon plays an indirect yet utterly important part in Alexandre Dumas' novel The Count of Monte Cristo . The novel starts in 1815 with Napoleon exiled on the island of Elba. Here we learn that he hands a letter to the protagonist Edmond Dantès to give to one of his chief (fictional) supporters in Paris - Noirtier De Villefort, the president of a Bonapartist club. Dantès is unaware that Villefort is an agent of the exiled Emperor and that the letter Napoleon handed him contained instructions and plans about Napoleon's planned return to Paris. Dantès' rivals include Mr. Danglars, his long-time unspoken rival and shipmate, who first reports Dantès to the authorities as a Bonapartist, and Gérard De Villefort, the opportunistic son of Noirtier and staunch royalist, who, in order to protect his father from being outed as a Bonapartist, burns the letter and uses its former existence to frame Dantès and have him imprisoned in the Château d'If until his escape after 14 years and seeks vengeance upon those who wronged him.

Doctor Who

Napoleon features prominently in the BBC Doctor Who Past Doctor Adventure World Game , in which the Second Doctor must avert a plot to change history so that Napoleon is victorious. In an alternate timeline created by the assassination of the Duke of Wellington prior to Waterloo, Napoleon is persuaded to march on to Russia after the victory at Waterloo, but he dies shortly afterwards, his empire having become so overextended that the various countries collapse back into the separate nations they were before, thus degenerating into a state of perpetual warfare. (This situation is made worse due to the intervention of the Doctor's old enemies the Players).

In 2013, Applied Mechanics produced Vainglorious, an epic, 26-actor immersive performance with Mary Tuomanen portraying Napoleon. [7]

Depictions of Napoleon in literature include:

In film:

Computer and video games

Culinary

Mille-feuille Mille-feuille francais 1.jpg
Mille-feuille

Film, radio and television

Albert Dieudonne as Napoleon in Napoleon Choumoff - Albert Dieudonne Napoleon.jpg
Albert Dieudonné as Napoleon in Napoléon

Film

Radio

Television

Places

Geography

Hospitality

Military

Music

Comics

Although no masterpieces have emerged from the Napoleonic adventure in the realm of comics or bandes dessinées, unlike painting or cinema, the comic book remains an art form quite inspired by the character of Napoleon. Notable works dedicated to the Emperor include those by Roger Lécureux and Guido Buzzelli, which recount Napoleon's entire life in a realistic drawing style and with great sobriety in the storyline. Other comics of the same genre narrate the life or periods of Napoleon's life, such as "Napoléon Bonaparte" by Guy Hempey (script) and Pierre Brochard (artwork), as well as the three albums in the series "Napoléon" by Belgians Liliane Funcken and Fred Funcken: "The Sultan of Fire," "The Fall of the Eagle," and "Waterloo (Battle) (1815)."

However, the myth of Napoleon is often caricatured, featuring megalomaniacs who believe themselves to be the Emperor. This is the case with Jean-Marc Rochette, who achieved certain commercial and critical success (winning awards at the Angoulême International Comics Festival) with "Napoléon et Bonaparte," which tells the burlesque adventures of two madmen, both believing themselves to be the famous military leader. Also worth mentioning, in the realm of comedy, is the work of Gotlib, who featured Napoleon Bonaparte in his "Rubrique-à-brac," as well as the series "Godaille et Godasse," which depicts his family stories.

Other

Napoleon's hat is a cultural icon. DHM - Zweispitz Napoleon.jpg
Napoleon's hat is a cultural icon.

Napoleon's height

A British political cartoon depicting Napoleon as short Evacuation of Malta.jpg
A British political cartoon depicting Napoleon as short

British political cartoons of the period depicted Napoleon as a short man and the image of him as being short continues to be widespread today. [23] Confusion has sometimes arisen because of different values for the French inch ( pouce ) of the time (2.7 cm) and for the Imperial inch (2.54 cm).; [24] he has been cited as being from 1.57 metres (5 ft 2 in), which made him the height of the average French male at that time, [25] and up to 1.7 metres (5 ft 7 in) tall, which is above average for the period. [note 1] [27] British Rear-Admiral Frederick Lewis Maitland, who had daily contact with Napoleon on Maitland's ship for twenty-three days in 1815, states in his memoirs that he was about 1.7 metres (5 ft 7 in). [28] Some historians believe that the reason for the mistake about his size at death came from use of an obsolete French yardstick. [25] Napoleon was a champion of the metric system (introduced in France in 1799) and had no use for the old yardsticks. It is more likely that he was 1.57 metres (5 ft 2 in), the height he was measured at on St. Helena, since he would have most likely been measured with an English yardstick rather than a yardstick of the Old French Regime. [25]

Napoleon's nickname of le petit caporal has added to the confusion, as some non-Francophones have mistakenly interpreted petit by its literal meaning of "small". In fact, it is an affectionate term reflecting on his camaraderie with ordinary soldiers. Napoleon also surrounded himself with the soldiers of his elite guard, required to be 1.83 m (6 ft) or taller,[ citation needed ] making him look smaller in comparison.

Napoleon's name has been lent to the Napoleon complex, a colloquial term describing an alleged type of inferiority complex which is said to affect some people who are physically short. The term is used more generally to describe people who are driven by a perceived handicap to overcompensate in other aspects of their lives. [29]

The Napoleon Delusion

Napoleon Bonaparte is one of the most famous individuals in the Western world. As delusional patients sometimes believe themselves to be an important or grandiose figure (see delusion), a patient claiming to be Napoleon has been a common stereotype in popular culture for delusions of this nature.

This cliché has itself been parodied:

See also

Notes

  1. Napoleon's height was 5 ft 2 French inches according to Antommarchi at Napoleon's autopsy and British sources put his height at 5 foot and 4 British inches: both equivalent to 1.4 m. [26] Napoleon surrounded himself with tall bodyguards and had a nickname of le petit caporal which was an affectionate term that reflected his reported camaraderie with his soldiers rather than his height.

References

  1. Antonin Périvier, "Napoléon journaliste", 1918, p. 37.
  2. Jean Tulard, "Le mythe de Napoléon", Paris, Armand Colin, coll. « Mythes » (no 2), 1971 ISSN   0588-2540, pp. 32–33.
  3. Maurice Duverger, Dictatures et légitimité, PUF, 1982, https://www.google.fr/books/edition/Dictatures_et_l%C3%A9gitimit%C3%A9/9q92DwAAQBAJ?hl=fr&gbpv=1&dq=culte+de+la+personnalit%C3%A9,+napol%C3%A9on&pg=PT300&printsec=frontcover
  4. Maurice Choury, Les grognards et Napoléon, Perrin, 1968https://www.google.fr/books/edition/Les_grognards_et_Napol%C3%A9on/l8dXDwAAQBAJ?hl=fr&gbpv=1&dq=culte+de+la+personnalit%C3%A9,+napol%C3%A9on&pg=PT39&printsec=frontcover
  5. Frédéric Bluche, Le bonapartisme, coll. «  Que sais-je ?  », éd. Presses universitaires de France (PUF), 1981, p. 48.
  6. https:// Another study of woman, Honoré De Balzac. Translated by Ellen Marriage and Clara Bell, Project Gutenberg, www.gutenberg.org/files/1714/1714-h/1714-h.htm
  7. "Talleyrand Ho! - Free Online Library". www.thefreelibrary.com. Retrieved 2021-02-24.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 Daniel D. McGarry, Sarah Harriman White, Historical Fiction Guide: Annotated Chronological, Geographical, and Topical List of Five Thousand Selected Historical Novels. Scarecrow Press, New York, 1963 (pp. 255–70)
  9. Gladir, George  ( w ), Ruiz, Fernando  ( p ), Lapick, Rudy  ( i ), Grossman, Barry  ( col ), Yoshida, Bill  ( let ),Goldwater, Richard ( ed )."Hungry Hurried and Harried"Jughead,vol. 1,no. 338(Feb 1985).Archie Comics Group.
  10. Gladir, George  ( w ), Ruiz, Fernando  ( p ), Lapick, Rudy  ( i ), Grossman, Barry  ( col ), Yoshida, Bill  ( let ),Goldwater, Richard ( ed )."Hungry Hurried and Harried"Jughead's Double Digest Magazine,no. 90,pp. 37–42/6(Jan 2003).Archie Comic Publications, ISSN   1061-5482 .
  11. A featured book in Norris, Jill (2005). How to Report on Books, Grades 3–4. Monterey, California: Evan-Moor. ISBN   978-1-59673-085-4.
  12. Dear Napoleon (review). Booklist. Retrieved 15 June 2014.
  13. Valve. "Napoleon Complex on Team Fortress 2 Wiki" . Retrieved August 16, 2024.
  14. "Scaramouche (1952) - IMDb". IMDb .
  15. Cavett, Dick (Presenter) (January 6, 2020). Sir Laurence Olivier on the 'Genius' of Marlon Brando (YouTube video). Global ImageWorks. Archived from the original on 2021-12-21. Retrieved September 20, 2020 via YouTube.
  16. "The_Scarlet_Pimpernel".
  17. "The_Scarlet_Pimpernel".
  18. "The_Scarlet_Pimpernel".
  19. Succession, "Connor's Wedding" 3/3/23 Final Shooting Script
  20. "Things named after Napoleon" commons.wikimedia.org
  21. "Monuments and memorials to Napoleon I of France" commons.wikimedia.org
  22. "Bogeyman Archived 2007-06-09 at the Wayback Machine ", "Period glossary", Napoleon.org . Retrieved 07-03-2007.
  23. Napoleon's height was put at just over 5 pieds 2 pouces by three French sources (his valet Constant, General Gourgaud, and Francesco Antommarchi at Napoleon's autopsy) which, using the French measurements of the time, equals around 1.69m. ( "La taille de Napoléon Bonaparte (Napoleon Bonaparte's height)". www.1789-1815.com. 2002-11-25. Retrieved 2008-05-28.) Two English sources (Andrew Darling and John Foster) put his height at around 5 ft 7 ins, equivalent, on the Imperial scale, to 1.70m. This would have made him around average height for a Frenchman of the time. ( "La taille de Napoléon (Napoleon's height)". La Fondation Napoléon. Retrieved 2008-05-30. "How tall was Napoleon?". La Fondation Napoléon. Retrieved 2005-12-18.) Nonetheless, some historians have claimed Napoleon would have been measured with a British measure at his autopsy, since it took place in St Helena, implying the 5 ft 2 ins is an Imperial measure, equal to about 1.58 meters. On the other hand, Francesco Antommarchi, Napoleon's personal physician, due to his hostility to the British, may never have used their yardstick to measure his emperor. (Antommarchi, F. G (1826). The Last Days of Napoleon: Memoirs of the Last Two Years of Napoleon's Exile. London: H.Colburn. pp.  p157 . Retrieved 2007-11-01.)
  24. "Weights and Measures". historydata.com. Archived from the original on 2008-05-21. Retrieved 2008-05-30.
  25. 1 2 3 Owen Connelly (2006). Blundering to Glory: Napoleon's Military Campaigns. Rowman & Littlefield. p. 7. ISBN   9780742553187.
  26. Dunan 1963
  27. "Sarkozy height row grips France". BBC. 8 September 2009. Retrieved 13 September 2009.
  28. The Surrender of Napoleon at Project Gutenberg
  29. Sandberg, David E.; Linda D. Voss (September 2002). "The psychosocial consequences of short stature: a review of the evidence". Best Practice & Research Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism. 16 (3): 449–63. doi:10.1053/beem.2002.0211. PMID   12464228.
  30. Garza, Janiss, Allmovie. "Mixed Nuts (1925)", Review Summary, The New York Times . Retrieved 09-25-2006.
  31. "Napoleon Bunny-part", Scripts, Delenea's Bugs Bunny Page. Retrieved 07-18-2007.
  32. French, Philip ( The Observer ). "The Emperor's New Clothes", The Guardian , 02-04-2004. Retrieved 07-19-2006.