Encore was met with mixed to positive reviews,with many critics deeming it inferior to its three predecessors. Most of the album's middle portion was heavily criticized,though "Like Toy Soldiers" and "Mockingbird" were particularly highly praised and have retrospectively been ranked as some of Eminem's best songs. These two songs were released along with three other singles:"Just Lose It","Encore",and "Ass Like That". The album has sold 11 million copies worldwide and was certified quadruple platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA) on December 17,2004.
In retrospect,Eminem has stated that he believes Encore to be one of his worst albums,which he attributed to several songs intended to be part of the album being leaked prior to its official release,requiring him to hastily write and record new ones. These leaked songs were compiled into a bootleg album titled Straight from the Lab. Eminem later revealed that he was also struggling with drug addiction during much of Encore's recording.
Prior to producing Encore,American rapper Marshall Bruce Mathers III,better known as Eminem,had released several other studio albums—The Slim Shady LP (1999),The Marshall Mathers LP (2000),and The Eminem Show (2002)—each to critical acclaim. However,Eminem became addicted to a number of drugs during this time,including Valium,Ambien,and Vicodin. In Amsterdam,where a large portion of The Marshall Mathers LP was recorded,Eminem would sometimes take MDMA with his mentor and fellow producer Dr. Dre before an extended recording session.[2] In a cover story celebrating the 25th anniversary of XXL magazine,Eminem stated:"So,I'm coming off The Marshall Mathers LP and going into Encore when my addiction started to get bad. I was taking Vicodin,Valium and alcohol." Eminem specifically recalled an interview with fellow rapper 50 Cent and hip-hop group G-Unit following their performance in Black Entertainment Television's music video show 106 &Park,in which he was unable to understand any questions asked to him,requiring 50 Cent to answer for him.[3][4]
Despite his worsening drug addiction,by 2004,Eminem had won nine Grammy Awards,as well as an Oscar Award for his starring role in the 2002 film 8 Mile.[5] During the time Eminem was recording for Encore in 2003,he was also producing for artists signed to his record labelShady Records,including 50 Cent and Obie Trice. That year,50 Cent and Trice released their debut studio albums,Get Rich or Die Tryin' and Cheers,respectively,to critical acclaim and commercial success.[6][7] However,Shady Records inherited a feud between 50 Cent and rapper Ja Rule,as well as Ja Rule's record label,Murder Inc. Records,which had led to multiple diss tracks,[8] including one from Ja Rule in which he mentions Eminem,Dr. Dre,and Eminem's daughter Hailie.[9] Meanwhile,Eminem and his record label were feuding with rapper Benzino and Benzino's hip-hop magazine,The Source,resulting in additional diss tracks.[10][11][12] These events are referenced in "Like Toy Soldiers",a song on Encore.[13]
Recording and production
Encore was recorded at 54 Studio in Ferndale,Michigan,a suburb of Detroit,[14][15] though a portion of the album was recorded at Trans Continental in Orlando,Florida.[16] Eight of the twenty tracks on the album were produced by Dr. Dre,who had produced songs for all of Eminem's albums since The Slim Shady LP.[17] Songwriters Luis Resto,Mike Elizondo,and Mark Batson also produced for the album.[18]
In December 2003,seven songs recorded by Eminem were leaked online,including several songs intended to be part of Encore:"We As Americans","Bully",and "Love You More". All of these songs were compiled into a bootleg album titled Straight from the Lab.[19] The leak required Eminem to travel to Los Angeles to record new songs for Encore with Dr. Dre. Eminem's worsening drug addiction,coupled with the songs being written in a hurry,resulted in them having a more comedic tone.[5][20] Eminem has stated that Encore "would've been right there with The Eminem Show as far as its caliber" had the songs not been leaked,and revealed that "We As Americans" was supposed to be the opening track,followed by "Bully". "We As Americans" and "Love You More" were released on the deluxe edition bonus disc.[4] "Bully",a diss track toward Benzino,Ja Rule,and Murder Inc. Records,[21] ultimately would not see an official release.[22]
Actor Christopher Reeve is mentioned in several lyrics and was the namesake of an unused track that was later renamed and released on The Death of Slim Shady (Coup de Grâce).
Overall,Encore contains more comedic themes and lyrics than Eminem's previous albums,including occasional toilet humour.[25][26] As conveyed through the album's title,cover art,and certain lyrics,Encore was originally set to be Eminem's final studio album.[27] Actor Christopher Reeve (referred to as "Christopher Reeves" by Eminem),known for his portrayal of the title character in the Superman film series,is mentioned in the songs "My 1st Single" and "Rain Man";in the latter,Eminem states "And let's clear this up too;I ain't got no beef with him either" and "He used to be like a hero to me".[28] The album is interspersed with skits in which Eminem has phone calls with Paul Rosenberg,his music manager and entertainment attorney.[29]
In "Evil Deeds",the second track on the album,Eminem apologizes for being his "mother's evil seed",recounts his rejection as a youth,and notes how his relationship with his daughter Hailie has become complicated by his fame.[30] The third track,"Never Enough",features a verse from 50 Cent and a hook from Nate Dogg.[31] In the fourth track,"Yellow Brick Road",Eminem describes his early years in Detroit and apologizes for disparaging an African-American girl who broke up with him in an old mixtape unearthed by The Source.[29][25]
"Like Toy Soldiers",the fifth track on the album,interpolates the chorus of Martika's "Toy Soldiers".[25][32] The song discusses 50 Cent's feuds with Ja Rule and Murder Inc. as well as Eminem's own feuds with Benzino and The Source,[33] notes how hip-hop conflicts have turned fatal,[30] and ends with Eminem offering a truce.[34] "Like Toy Soldiers" was released as the third single from the album on March 15,2005.[35] "Mosh",the sixth track from the album,is a protest song targeting 43rd U.S. presidentGeorge W. Bush,criticizing U.S. involvement in the Iraq War and encouraging listeners to vote Bush out of office in the 2004 United States presidential election.[36][37][38]
The album's seventh track,"Puke",targets Eminem's ex-wife,Kim Scott,and includes sound effects of the rapper vomiting.[32] The eighth track,"My 1st Single",rejects being a radio-friendly single through inappropriate lyrics and scatological sound effects.[30][32] In the tenth track,"Rain Man",Eminem declares that his "new name is Rain Man",[32] compares himself to a superhero,[32] and mocks homophobia.[26][39] "Rain Man" is followed by "Big Weenie",in which Eminem attempts to hypnotize the listener,likely intended to be Benzino,and accuses him of being jealous of Eminem's success.[40]
Artwork and packaging
The first of two covers for the album features Eminem standing in front of an audience,bowing to the crowd. The tray insert features Eminem holding a gun behind his back,while the inlay shows Eminem holding the pistol in his mouth without his jacket on. The CD itself shows a suicide note written by Eminem saying "To my family &all my friends -- thank you for everything,I will always love you. To my fans,I'm sorry,Marshall" with a bullet underneath,which is also seen in the album's booklet,where Eminem is writing the note. Some pictures show Eminem shooting everyone in the audience and himself,alluding to the ending of the album's title track.[41] The second album cover,used for the Collector's Edition,features the same audience from the inlay on a black background with a blood splat on the top right.
Encore received mixed to positive reviews from critics,with more of a negative response compared to Eminem's past three albums.[45] The review aggregation website Metacritic,which assigns a normalized rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications,gave the album an average score of 64,based on 26 reviews,indicating "generally favorable" reviews.[42]
Josh Love from Stylus Magazine felt Eminem was "dying" with this album,whose concept was "end-to-end mea culpa",full of "clarifications,rectifications and excuses",revising the history of "a man who knows he doesn't have much time left".[46] Scott Plangenhoef,writing for Pitchfork called Encore a "transitional record" and "the sound of a man who seems bored of re-branding and playing celebrity games".[25]BBC Music's Adam Webb believed it starts "fantastically" but ends "abominably",writing that it has too many "low points".[47] David Browne from Entertainment Weekly said Eminem "sacrifices the rich,multi-textured productions" of his two previous albums for "thug-life monotony,cultural zingers for petty music-biz score-settling,and probing self-analysis for juvenile humor". He concluded his review by saying that Eminem has become "predictable" on Encore,something that he wasn't before.[29]
Stephen Thomas Erlewine was more enthusiastic in his review for AllMusic,calling the music "spartan",built on "simple unadorned beats and keyboard loops",and the lyrics "plain-spoken and literal".[43]Robert Christgau said Eminem still sounded "funny,catchy and clever,and irreverent past his allotted time",noting that even the bonus tracks "keep on pushing".[48] In Rolling Stone,he wrote that Encore was not as "astonishing" as The Marshall Mathers LP,but praised Eminem for maturing his lyrical abilities while retaining his sense of humor.[39] Steve Jones from USA Today also spoke positively about the album,calling Eminem's producing and lyrical skills as "top-flight" and noting that the record explores "the many sides of Marshall Mathers".[49]
Retrospectively,in a ranking of all 12 of Eminem's studio albums,Billboard magazine's Damien Scott placed Encore ninth,criticizing the songs on the back half of the album as "some of the worst [Eminem]'s ever committed to tape",though he singled out "Like Toy Soldiers" and "Mockingbird" as "some of Em's strongest and most personal songs to date" and wrote that "Encore works as an earnest rumination on the things that really make Eminem tick".[50]Stereogum's Christopher R. Weingarten placed Encore last in a 2019 ranking of Eminem's first 10 studio albums,calling it "a rambling disaster",which he partially attributed to Eminem's drug addiction at the time.[51] Kemet High of XXL magazine placed Encore seventh in his 2021 ranking of Eminem's first 11 studio albums,believing that it "has aged better with time" despite being "a step back in comparison to the three-album run of The Slim Shady LP,The Marshall Mathers LP and The Eminem Show that preceded it".[52]HotNewHipHop's Paul Barnes placed Encore second to last in his 2023 ranking of all of Eminem's studio albums except Infinite,deeming many of the songs "incoherent".[53]
Controversies
Encore provoked some controversy over anti-Bush lyrics and lyrics that parodied and targeted Michael Jackson,who criticized Eminem's depiction of him in the video for "Just Lose It" and threatened to sue him.[54] On December 8,2003,the United States Secret Service stated it was "looking into" allegations that Eminem had threatened the President of the United States,George Bush,[55] after the song "We As Americans",in an unreleased bootleg called Straight From The Lab,circulated with the lyrics "Fuck money,I don't rap for dead presidents. I'd rather see the president dead." This line was eventually used as a sample in Immortal Technique's single "Bin Laden",which featured Mos Def and Chuck D. The incident was later referenced in the video for his song "Mosh" as one of several news clips on a wall,along with other newspaper articles about other unfortunate incidents in Bush's career. The song eventually appeared on the album's bonus disc,with the word "dead" being reversed.
Eminem's thoughts on the album
In retrospect,Eminem stated numerous times that he considers Encore as one of his worst albums. He described its reception,"I'm cool with probably half that album. I recorded that towards the height of my addiction. I remember four songs leaked and I had to go to L.A. and get Dre and record new ones. I was in a room by myself writing songs in 25,and 30 minutes because we had to get it done,and what came out was so goofy. That's how I ended up making songs like 'Rain Man' and 'Big Weenie'. They're pretty out there. If those other songs hadn't leaked,Encore would've been a different album."[56] In an interview with Sway Calloway for his album Kamikaze,he stated that although "Encore... [is] not what I would consider one of my better albums",he considered it better than its follow-up Relapse.[57] He reiterated his statement about Encore in 2022 for the 25th anniversary issue of XXL:"It became a misstep and I struggled to get over the fact that I didn't do my best. My best would've been good enough if the leaks hadn't happened. But I released what I had at that point in time,and I feel that put a kind of a mark on my catalog. Encore did some decent numbers,but I was never that concerned with numbers. I was more so worried about what people think about the album. Critics and fans were important to me,and they were always at me about that project."[3][4]
Commercial performance
Encore was released on November 12,2004.[58] The release date was moved up from the originally planned November 16 to countermeasure leaks.[59] The album sold 710,000 copies.[60] The following week,the album's first with a full seven days,it moved 871,000 copies,bringing the 10-day total to 1,582,000.[61] It was certified quadruple-platinum that mid-December.[62] Nine months after its release,worldwide sales of the album stood at 11 million copies.[63] The album made digital history in becoming the first album to sell 10,000 digital copies in one week.[64] As of November 2013,the album had sold 5,343,000 copies in the US.[65]
Encore sold 125,000 copies in two days in the United Kingdom,[66] and has been certified quadruple-platinum.
"Curtains Down" is a skit at the end of "Encore", in which Eminem shoots everyone at his concert and then shoots himself, followed by a robotic voice saying "See you in hell, fuckers." Some of the pictures in the booklet make reference to this.
The robotic voice heard on "Em Calls Paul" and in the "Curtains Down" skit is Eminem speaking with an electrolarynx.
* Sales figures based on certification alone. ^ Shipments figures based on certification alone. ‡ Sales+streaming figures based on certification alone.
↑ Bry, Dave; Ornah; Ahmed, Insanul; Callahan-Bever, Noah; Kenner, Rob; Mr. Wavvy; Hobbs, Thomas; Lavin, Will; Sanfiorenzo, Dimas (October 17, 2024) [December 18, 2017]. "Eminem's Projects, Ranked From Worst to Best". Complex Networks. Archived from the original on January 18, 2025. Retrieved February 11, 2025.
1 2 3 4 5 6 Cashmore, Pete (September 12, 2005) [December 10, 2004]. "Eminem: Encore". NME. Archived from the original on November 27, 2024. Retrieved August 18, 2013.
↑ "年間 アルバムランキング 2004年度"[Oricon Year-end Albums Chart of 2004] (in Japanese). Oricon. Archived from the original on July 13, 2019. Retrieved January 11, 2021.
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
