Indigo Line | |
---|---|
Overview | |
Status | Canceled |
Owner | MBTA |
Locale | Greater Boston |
Service | |
Type | Hyrbid Rail / Rapid Transit / Regional Rail / Semi-metro |
System | Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority |
Operator(s) | MBTA |
Rolling stock | Diesel Multiple Units (Procurement canceled 2015) |
History | |
Opened | Proposed 2024 (Canceled) |
Technical | |
Character | Surface-level |
Track gauge | 4 ft 8+1⁄2 in (1,435 mm) standard gauge |
The Indigo Line was a proposed rapid transit service of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) that would have incorporated parts of the former Grand Junction Railroad, the Seaport District's Track 61, a spur to Riverside station and segments of other MBTA Commuter Rail lines within the Greater Boston region of Massachusetts. As proposed, the Indigo Line was planned as hybrid rail (non-commuter rail service that operates as a combination of regional rail and light rail) and would have predominately shared existing infrastructure with the MBTA Commuter Rail.
The Indigo Line was formally endorsed in 2014 during the Deval Patrick administration. The service was included within the Massachusetts Department of Transportation's (MassDOT's) 2014-2018 Capital Investment Plan which consolidated recommendations put forth by the Boston Redevelopment Authority (now the Boston Planning and Development Agency) and several other proposals by community advocates. [1] [2] The MBTA planned to procure diesel multiple units (DMUs) for Indigo Line service with full-build completion projected for 2024.
Despite initial planning efforts, the project faced financial, political, and logistical hurdles. The Baker administration blocked funding for the Indigo Line in 2015, with the project being officially canceled by the MBTA shortly after. [3] [4] In the years following the project's cancelation, lawmakers and local advocates have called for the revival and reassessment of the Indigo Line plan in relation to improvements to the MBTA Commuter Rail's Fairmount Line. [5] Several minor projects based on preliminary Indigo Line recommendations have been pursued; however, the Indigo Line project as originally proposed has been abandoned.
Conversion of underutilized rail infrastructure within the Greater Boston area into regional rail or semi-metro services has been discussed for several decades, mostly in relation to the Fairmount Line. The MBTA has traditionally extended rapid transit lines adjacent to existing suburban railroad rights-of-way to provide increased frequencies within Greater Boston (as with the Green Line Extension, Red Line Braintree Extension and the Haymarket North Extension). In the case of the Green Line D Branch, a commuter line (the Highland Branch) was fully converted into a streetcar rapid transit line. The Indigo Line proposal was intended to make the characteristics of existing commuter lines more like rapid transit than commuter rail, with increased frequency and number of stops through the use of DMUs (which operate as self-propelled railcars without the need for an auxiliary electrification system) without incurring the costs associated with extending subway or light rail lines.
Prior to the formal endorsement of the Indigo Line, several planning initiatives during the 2000s would serve as the basis for the DMU proposal. Part of the environmental mitigation negotiated by the Conservation Law Foundation (CLF) for the Big Dig was improved commuter rail service on the Fairmount Line; following advocacy for the Fairmount Corridor Coalition (later the Fairmount Indigo Transit Coalition) in 1999-2000, the MBTA pledged half of the money necessary to build additional stations along the Fairmount Line in 2002. [6] The remaining necessary funds were put into the MassDOT budget in 2005-06 following a lawsuit by the CLF for inadequate completion of Big Dig mitigation measures. The existing Uphams Corner and Morton Street stations were rebuilt, and four new stations were constructed at Four Corners/Geneva, Talbot Avenue, Blue Hill Avenue, and Newmarket in the 2010s; however, no plans were included to increase service on the line. [7] While plans for the station improvement projects moved forward, community advocates would call for the conversion of the Fairmount Line to rapid transit. [8]
Early plans to establish rapid DMU service within Boston stems from early Urban Ring planning within the Allston Multimodal Station Study (what would later become the West Station proposal) in 2007. [9] The study analyzed both commuter rail and DMU local service along the Framingham/Worcester Line corridor, with potential stops at Faneuil, Market Street, Everett Street, Cambridge Street, West (Ashford Street), and Commonwealth Avenue. [10] The final recommendation called for a commuter rail station at Everett Street with DMU stops added later at the other locations.
The term "Indigo Line" dates back to The Fairmount/Indigo Corridor Collaborative (FCC) community campaign in 2004 which advocated for expanded service on the Fairmount Line; however, official development of the proposal would be established with the creation of the Fairmount Indigo Planning Initiative in 2012. [11] This study was facilitated by the Boston Redevelopment Authority which recommended transforming the Fairmount Line into a hybrid rail line. [12] Hybrid rail, which emerged during the early 2000s with systems such as New Jersey Transit's River Line, was intended to be a low cost alternative to implementing high-frequency services on existing right-of-ways through the use of FRA non-compliant DMUs. The Indigo Line concept would be further consolidated with other DMU proposals with the intent to upgrade several other lines beyond the Fairmount Line. The "Indigo" terminology for the service was intended to denote it within Boston's rapid transit network, which utilizes a color-labeled nomenclature, since it would be operationally separate from the purple-denoted MBTA Commuter Rail network.
In 2014, the Indigo Line was formally endorsed by Governor Deval Patrick. The project was included as a capital project within MassDOT's annual five-year capital plan; however, no capital funding was allocated. The proposal was further outlined within the "MBTA Vision for 2024" proposal that same year. Within the Vision for 2024 plan, the MBTA reciprocated the recommendation to operate Indigo Line services as hybrid rail, with Fairmount Line DMU service being fully operational that year with leased equipment. [13] [14] The full buildout of the Indigo Line network was projected for completion by 2024 at a total capital cost of $252 million. [15]
The Indigo Line would have functionally operated as a part of the MBTA's rapid transit network alongside the Red, Blue, Green, Silver, and Ashmont-Mattapan lines; however, DMU operations would be subjected to FRA operational requirements, not FTA, due to shared operations with conventional commuter trains. DMUs would operate with 15 to 30 minute bidirectional headways and would have implemented a pre-pay fare control system at Indigo Line stations and have fare parity with the MBTA’s subway lines. [6] In concept, the Indigo Line proposal is reminiscent of S-Bahn and other regional rail systems in Europe that often act as a faster counterparts to metro services which have more stops; however, Indigo services would have only provided coverage within Boston's urban periphery and lacks any form of through-running between lines.
DMU services would have primarily been contained to Boston's inner core, with some services extending into several adjacent suburbs and cities such as Lynn and Newton. As proposed, several inner-city Commuter Rail stations would have been converted exclusively for Indigo Line service. Conventional commuter rail would continue to serve outer stations and would run express through the new DMU lines.
The MBTA Vision for 2024 map proposed six possible lines to be upgraded for Indigo Line DMU service:
While the Indigo Line had always been planned as a DMU service, specifications would change throughout service development. Initial BRA proposals called for the use of FRA non-compliant rolling stock in order to reduce procurement and operational costs. Non-compliant DMUs are lighter than FRA compliant vehicles and often have low-floor boarding; however, they are not permitted to operate in mixed traffic with conventional rail equipment. Most hybrid rail lines operate temporally on trackage shared with freight or utilize a dedicated right-of-way; however, the MBTA had initially assumed that non-compliant railcars could operate alongside conventional commuter trains and not require modifications to existing commuter rail infrastructure.
By 2014, the MBTA determined that non-compliant DMUs would not be feasible for Indigo service due to logistical issues and FRA safety standards; DMUs would have to be compliant with FRA Tier 1 crashworthiness standards in order to operate on the existing MBTA Commuter Rail network. Additionally, DMUs would need to be compatible with high-floor boarding at stations which further increased procurement cost projections and would require the reconstruction of several stations. [1] [16] The proposed 2014 state budget included $240 million to purchase DMU railcars; the state issued a request for proposals to purchase 30 trainsets with deliveries starting in 2018. At the time, only one manufacturer offered FRA compliant DMUs in North America– the Nippon Sharyo DMU, manufactured by Nippon Sharyo, would be the only respondent to the MBTA's proposal request. The lack of additional respondents was identified as a due diligence issue, as it negated the MBTA's ability to negotiate on price and delivery. Despite these concerns, an order of Nippon Sharyo DMUs for Sonoma–Marin Area Rail Transit in 2014 included an option for 18 cars to be provided to the MBTA for the Indigo Line service. [17] [16]
Development on the Indigo Line proposal immediately stalled following its inclusion as a capital project within MassDOT's five-year plan. Other projects, such as the Green Line Extension and South Coast Rail, received planning priority during the mid-2010s. The MBTA postponed DMU procurement multiple times due to increasing costs and the lack of available manufacturers. Fiscal issues, such as budget deficits, further postponed the Indigo Line proposal. The MBTA further deprioritized investment for the Indigo Line when the Charlie Baker administration started in January 2015.
Funding for the Indigo Line project was blocked by the Baker administration by late 2015, and all references to the project were omitted from MassDOT's 2015 Capital Investment Plan. [18] The abandonment of the project was attributed to high costs of acquiring specialized rolling stock along with a lack of demand for the routes it would serve. Opposition to the Indigo Line proposal cited the low ridership of the Fairmount Line, and questioned the operational logistics of the proposed routes (mainly in reference to how Track 61 service would have bypassed South Station). [16] In 2016, the MBTA stated it was no longer interested in pursuing inner-core service increases on existing Commuter Rail lines. [16]
Following the cancelation of the Indigo Line, constituencies served by the Fairmount Line within Dorchester, Mattapan, and Hyde Park condemned the decision to cancel service improvements. The Fairmount corridor currently serves mostly low-income and working-class communities that are reliant on access to public transportation, and several of the communities are defined by the Massachusetts Executive Office of Energy and Environmental Affairs as Environmental Justice Communities. The Conservation Law Foundation, which had previously negotiated conditions for the Fairmount Line Improvement Project, accused the MBTA of disproportionally depriving the Fairmount Line of service improvements. [19] The accusation came in response to a joint Department of Justice and FTA investigation of MBTA Commuter Rail operator Keolis into whether train cancelations on the Fairmount Line were in violation of Title VI in 2016. [8]
Transit advocacy groups have been established in response to the cancelation of the Indigo Line project. The Fairmount Indigo CDC Collaborative, which includes partner organizations Codman Square NDC and Southwest Boston CDC, serves the predominantly low and moderate-income neighborhoods along the Fairmount Line from Hyde Park to North Dorchester in Boston. [20] The Fairmount Corridor Transit Coalition, which had been previously established in 2004, continues to advocate for service improvements. [21] The Fairmount Indigo Network is a consortium of several advocacy organizations (including the Fairmount Indigo CDC Collaborative) that lobbies for Fairmount Line improvements at the community level.
Several elements proposed for the Indigo Line have been partially implemented on the Fairmount Line. The Fairmount Line Improvement Project adopted by the MBTA between 2012 and 2019 was based on preliminary Indigo Line plans; however, in its initial proposal the MBTA did not plan to increase service frequency to match rapid transit lines, nor to install pre-pay fare systems. The infill stations proposed by the initiative have been built; however, the line still uses conventional commuter rail equipment. [22] In January 2020, CharlieCard readers were placed at stations to provide a proof-of-payment ticket that allows a transfer to subway or bus. [23] On May 20, 2024, service on the line was increased to 30-minute headways (including weekends). [24]
The Indigo Line terminology was revived in 2023 within both Senate and House versions of a bill that would mandate the conversion of the MBTA's Fairmount Line to fully electrified operations by 2029 in order to effectively integrate the line with the MBTA’s rapid transit network under the Indigo Line banner. [25] [26] The 2023 legislation diverges from a previous MBTA proposal from 2022 that suggested the procurement of battery multiple units for the Fairmount Line as opposed to full electrification. [27] The legislation was included in a Joint Committee on Transportation hearing on May 8, 2023, which has since been referred to the House Ways and Means Committee. [28]
On March 16, 2024, MBTA Commuter Rail operator Keolis solicited a proposal that outlined the implementation of BEMU services on the Fairmount Line by FY 2027 as leverage for contract renewal; however, the MBTA has not reciprocated this motion as a formal project. [29]
Despite renewed legislative support, the Indigo Line has not been formally proposed as a MBTA project and is not in active development. [30]
The Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority is the public agency responsible for operating most public transportation services in Greater Boston, Massachusetts. The MBTA transit network includes the MBTA subway with three metro lines, two light rail lines, and a five-line bus rapid transit system ; MBTA bus local and express service; the twelve-line MBTA Commuter Rail system, and several ferry routes. In 2023, the system had a ridership of 239,981,700, or about 812,400 per weekday as of the third quarter of 2024, of which the rapid transit lines averaged 267,700 and the light rail lines 102,500, making it the fourth-busiest rapid transit system and the third-busiest light rail system in the United States. As of the third quarter of 2024, average weekday ridership of the commuter rail system was 109,300, making it the fifth-busiest commuter rail system in the U.S.
The Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) system is mostly but not fully accessible. Like most American mass transit systems, much of the MBTA subway and commuter rail were built before wheelchair access became a requirement under the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. The MBTA has renovated most stations to be compliant with the ADA, and all stations built since 1990 are accessible. The MBTA also has a paratransit program, The Ride, which provides accessible vehicles to transport passengers who cannot use the fixed-route system.
The MBTA Commuter Rail system serves as the commuter rail arm of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority's (MBTA's) transportation coverage of Greater Boston in the United States. Trains run over 394 mi (634 km) of track to 135 stations. It is operated under contract by Keolis, which took over operations on July 1, 2014, from the Massachusetts Bay Commuter Railroad Company (MBCR).
The North–South Rail Link (NSRL) is a proposed rail tunnel, or pair of tunnels, that would connect North Station and South Station in downtown Boston, Massachusetts, linking rail networks that serve the city's northern suburbs, New Hampshire, and Maine with the rest of the country. The project would build new underground stations near the existing stations, connect them with about 1.5 miles (2.4 km) of tunnels, and add other tunnels to link up with existing surface tracks.
Riverside station is a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) Green Line light rail station located in the Auburndale village of Newton, Massachusetts. It is the western terminal of the Green Line D branch service. The station is located near the interchange of Interstate 95 and the Massachusetts Turnpike (I-90) and serves as a regional park and ride station. West of the station is Riverside Yard, the main maintenance facility and largest storage yard for the Green Line. The station is fully accessible.
The Fairmount Line or Dorchester Branch is a line of the MBTA Commuter Rail system in Boston, Massachusetts, USA. Except for a short portion in Milton, it lies entirely within Boston, running southwest from South Station through the neighborhoods of Dorchester, Mattapan and Hyde Park. Weekend service began on November 29, 2014. Most trains reverse direction at the south end at Readville, but some Franklin/Foxboro Line trains use the Fairmount Line rather than the Northeast Corridor.
The Framingham/Worcester Line of the MBTA Commuter Rail system runs west from Boston, Massachusetts, to Worcester, Massachusetts, through the MetroWest region, serving 18 station stops in Boston, Newton, Wellesley, Natick, Framingham, Ashland, Southborough, Westborough, Grafton, and Worcester. It is the third-longest and third-busiest line in the MBTA Commuter Rail system. Service on the line is a mix of local and express trains serving Worcester plus short-turn Framingham locals.
The Urban Ring was a proposed project of the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority and the Massachusetts Department of Transportation, to develop new public transportation routes that would provide improved circumferential connections among many existing transit lines that project radially from downtown Boston. The Urban Ring Corridor is located roughly one to two miles from downtown Boston, passing through the Massachusetts cities of Boston, Chelsea, Everett, Medford, Somerville, Cambridge, and Brookline. The project was expected to convert 41,500 car trips to transit trips daily.
Quincy Center station is an intermodal transit station in Quincy, Massachusetts. It is a transfer station between the MBTA Red Line subway, MBTA Commuter Rail's Old Colony Lines and Greenbush Line, and a number of MBTA bus routes. It is located between Hancock Street and Burgin Parkway in the Quincy Center district. Opened in 1971, the station was covered by a large parking garage which was closed in 2012 due to structural problems and removed several years later. The station is accessible on all modes.
The Providence/Stoughton Line is an MBTA Commuter Rail service in Massachusetts and Rhode Island, primarily serving the southwestern suburbs of Boston. Most service runs entirely on the Northeast Corridor between South Station in Boston and Providence station or Wickford Junction station in Rhode Island, while the Stoughton Branch splits at Canton Junction and terminates at Stoughton. It is the longest MBTA Commuter Rail line, and the only one that operates outside Massachusetts. The line is the busiest on the MBTA Commuter Rail system, with 17,648 daily boardings in an October 2022 count.
Readville station is a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) commuter rail station located in the Readville section of the Hyde Park neighborhood of Boston, Massachusetts. It is served by the MBTA Commuter Rail Fairmount, Franklin/Foxboro, and Providence/Stoughton Lines. Readville is the outer terminus for most Fairmount service, though some trips continue as Franklin/Foxboro Line trains. The station is located at a multi-level junction, with the Attleboro Line tracks at ground level and the Dorchester Branch above. Franklin/Foxboro Line trains that run on the Northeast Corridor use a connecting track with a separate platform. An MBTA maintenance and storage yard and a CSX Transportation freight yard are located near the station.
Lansdowne station is an MBTA Commuter Rail station in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves the Framingham/Worcester Line. Lansdowne is located next to the Massachusetts Turnpike in the Fenway–Kenmore neighborhood near Kenmore Square, below grade between Beacon Street and Brookline Avenue.
Fairmount station is an MBTA Commuter Rail station in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves the Fairmount Line. It is located in the Hyde Park area, under the Fairmount Avenue overpass. Fairmount station opened in 1979 during Southwest Corridor reconstruction; intended to be temporary, it eventually became a permanent stop.
Four Corners/Geneva station is an MBTA Commuter Rail station in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves the Fairmount Line. It is located in the Mount Bowdoin section of the Dorchester neighborhood. The new station was being built as part of the Fairmount Line Improvement Project, which included four new stations as well as infrastructure upgrades. It has two full-length high-level platforms with walkways connecting them to Washington Street and Geneva Avenue. Four Corners/Geneva Ave opened on July 1, 2013, along with Newmarket.
Newmarket station is an MBTA Commuter Rail station in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves the Fairmount Line and a small number of Franklin/Foxboro Line trains. It is located off Massachusetts Avenue at Newmarket Square in the Dorchester neighborhood. The station has two 800-foot (240 m) high-level platforms and sloping walkways connecting it to Massachusetts Avenue. Originally planned to be in service in 2011, it opened on July 1, 2013, along with Four Corners/Geneva station.
Talbot Avenue station is an MBTA Commuter Rail station in Boston, Massachusetts. It serves the Fairmount Line. It is located near Codman Square in the Dorchester neighborhood. The station includes two full-length high-level platforms located north of Talbot Avenue, which are also accessible from Park Street and West Park Street. The station opened on November 12, 2012 as the first of four new stations on the Fairmount Line. Talbot Avenue was the first completely new rail station to open in the City of Boston since Yawkey opened in 1988.
Blue Hill Avenue station is a regional rail station on the MBTA Commuter Rail Fairmount Line located in the Mattapan neighborhood of Boston, Massachusetts. The station consists of a center island platform between the line's two tracks, with handicapped-accessible ramps to Blue Hill Avenue and Cummins Highway. Originally intended to open along with Newmarket, Four Corners/Geneva, and Talbot Avenue, it was significantly delayed due to local controversy. Construction began in 2017, and the station opened on February 25, 2019.
Track 61 is an industrial rail terminal track in South Boston, Massachusetts, also known as the Boston Terminal Running Track. Track 61 is the last remnant of the vast rail yards that once covered much of the South Boston waterfront. Track 61 legally begins at Summer Street, while the line from Bay Junction to Summer Street is the Boston Terminal Running Track and Terminal Yard. However, the names are frequently used interchangeably.
West Station is a planned station on the MBTA Commuter Rail Framingham/Worcester Line, to be located in the former Beacon Park Yard in Allston, Massachusetts. It was initially proposed as part of a project to straighten the Massachusetts Turnpike through the yard, allowing much of the land to be redeveloped. As of 2024, plans for the station have not proceeded beyond conceptual studies.
Chelsea station is a Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority (MBTA) intermodal transit station located adjacent to the Mystic Mall in Chelsea, Massachusetts. It is the terminus of the SL3 route of the MBTA Silver Line bus rapid transit (BRT) network, and is served by the Newburyport/Rockport Line of the MBTA Commuter Rail. The accessible station has a loop with two small platforms for the Silver Line, and two full-length side platforms for commuter rail trains.