Lucier | |
---|---|
Restaurant information | |
Established | May 2008 |
Closed | December 2008 |
Owner(s) |
|
Chef | Pascal Chureau |
Food type | European |
Street address | 1910 South River Drive |
City | Portland |
County | Multnomah |
State | Oregon |
Postal/ZIP Code | 97201 |
Country | United States |
Coordinates | 45°30′29.5″N122°40′21″W / 45.508194°N 122.67250°W |
Seating capacity | 100 |
Lucier was a restaurant in Portland, Oregon, that specialized in European cuisine. [1] The business, which was described as "the most opulent restaurant space in Portland history", only operated for seven months in 2008. News outlets described the failed venture as "the most colossal faceplant in Portland dining history" [2] and the city's "greatest restaurant boondoggle". [3] Lucier was the only restaurant in Oregon that the American Automobile Association awarded with four diamonds.
Lucier was a restaurant located at RiverPlace [4] in South Portland's South Waterfront district. Martin Cizmar of Willamette Week described Lucier as "the most opulent restaurant space in Portland history". [5] The Oregonian said the "ultra-contemporary showpiece" restaurant was named after French-Canadian fur trader Étienne Lucier. [6]
The Oregonian's Michael Russell said Lucier was housed in a "prow-like building" with cantilevered windows and views of the Willamette River. [7] The 7,600-square-foot (710 m2) [8] interior had "one-of-a-kind features", including "a marble wall milled with abstract swimming designs", a "shimmering" canal that was also described as a lazy river and water channel [2] [9] lined with iridescent gold tiles, and "oversized chandeliers made from bronze tubes of varying heights". [10] According to Christina Melander of The Oregonian, Lucier had African hardwoods, custom-leather furniture made in Italy, and a "brigade-style" kitchen. [11] The restaurant had silver front doors, twenty glass sculptures by Dale Chihuly, leather-padded bathroom walls, and a bar "capped by a gold dome designed to resemble the sun". [7]
The dining room accommodated approximately 100 people. [12] [13] Lucier offered free valet parking. [14]
The menu included modern European cuisine [15] [16] and, according to The Oregonian, "[encouraged] diners to create their own three, four or five course tasting menus—mixing and matching entrees and starters at will". [17] The newspaper said:
Menus comprise a la carte, bar and a seven-course chef's tasting menu that emphasizes a few ingredients—tomatoes and the red mullet fish rouget, for example—throughout the entire meal. To encourage diners to try luxury items like Kobe beef and live scallops in the shell, the kitchen will prepare them in tiny portions, coupling, say, an ounce of Wagyu beef with a New York steak to demonstrate the difference. [11]
Lucier's executive chef said the food "[pulled] flavors from Morocco, Italy and Portugal as well as from France, and [borrowed] techniques from Japan". [11] The foie gras had coconut foam, macadamia nut "glass" similar to brittle, and a piece of pineapple. The halibut was prepared sous vide. The striped bass carpaccio had yuzu, olives, and currants. A dish called The Egg was a "lightly scrambled duck egg served in its shell topped with sevruga caviar and accompanied by teardrop-shaped brioche toasts". The butter-poached lamb was served with sweetbreads, pea shoots and fingerling potatoes. [17]
The wine list had 1,600 labels. [18] Two-hundred Champagnes were available by the glass. [11]
Lucier opened in May 2008 [19] [20] in a building that was owned by Onder Development. [8] Alvarez + Brock oversaw a $4 million design. [10] Spouses [21] Chris and Tyanne Dussin of the Dussin Group were co-owners of Lucier. [22] [23] Food writer Karen Brooks of The Oregonian said the duo "banked on a dramatic river view, a theatrical menu, a wine list with world-class aspirations and price tags bound to make value-loving Portlanders flinch". [24]
Pascal Chureau was a co-owner and executive chef. [18] [25] Top Chef: Boston contestants Doug Adams and Jeremy Niehuss were chefs at Lucier. [26] [27] [28] Kristen D. Murray, who later opened a restaurant named Maurice, was a pastry chef. [29] [30] Prior to opening Ox, Gregory and Gabrielle Quinonez were cooks at Lucier. [31] [32]
The Oregonian's Christina Melander said Lucier was Portland's most-expensive restaurant, as of September–October 2008. [33] [34]
Lucier closed in December 2008 after operating for seven months. [8] [35] Chris Dussin attributed the closure to the Great Recession. [36]
Willamette Week called the restaurant's short lifespan "the most colossal faceplant in Portland dining history" [2] and Portland Business Journal called the venture a "failure". [37] Michael Russell of The Oregonian said Lucier was "Portland's greatest restaurant boondoggle", [3] the city's "most spectacular restaurant failure" and "most notorious flop", [7] [38] and a "doomed extravagance". [39] Ted Sickinger called the restaurant an "extravaganza that became the most spectacular flameout in the pantheon of Portland eateries", [40] and David Sarasohn called Lucier a "super-expensive flop" and "a monument to odd thinking and worse timing". [41] Gregory Denton said the closure was "a low point in [his] career" and "a considerable blow to the ego and a huge disappointment after all the work that we had put into" Lucier. [32]
In early 2010, news outlets reported on a possible reopening of Lucier. [42] [43] Eater Portland's Eva Hagberg wrote; "Word is Dussin (perhaps having learned from his mistakes?) will, instead, be making the place 'little less high-end and a little more approachable'". [44] The Oregonian said "Changes in decor consistent with Lucier's downscaling will also be made". [45] Eater Portland reported on Lucier's possible acquisition by San Francisco-based Lark Creek Restaurant Group. [46] The Dussin Group put its lease on the venue on the market in October 2011. [47] Keeler Hospitality Group signed a sublease in 2012 and the Dussin Group continued to pay "part of the original lease's five-figure monthly rent". [7]
The space that had housed Lucier remained unoccupied until 2013. [48] The restaurant was replaced by Quartet [10] and later by Dough Zone. [49] [50]
Lucier was the only restaurant in Oregon the American Automobile Association awarded four diamonds. [36] [51] Writing for the San Francisco Examiner , Lisa Zimmerman described it as Portland's "most notable restaurant new comer", and praised the architecture and service while questioning the food-and-wine pairings. [52] Wendy Culverwell of Portland Business Journal wrote: "Lucier Restaurant opened and closed so quickly in 2008 that many people never had a chance to see its stunning setting". [53] Fred Armstrong of Oregon Wine Press said Lucier "seemed better suited to Manhattan than Portland". [23] Chef Pascal Chureau said criticism of the restaurant was "unfair". [54]
In June 2008, Michael C. Zusman of The Oregonian wrote: "Lucier at RiverPlace is the most elegantly appointed restaurant to open in Portland in decades, if not ever." He disliked the foie gras, which he said "[showed] an early tendency toward creativity for creativity's sake, rather than putting clean and clear flavors first". Zusman said the halibut was "inexplicably dry", and complimented The Egg, the striped bass carpaccio, and the butter-poached lamb. His review ended: "Clearly, Lucier is a place to watch". [17]
In August 2008, the newspaper's Gerry Frank wrote:
In what is arguably one of the most dramatic and attractive restaurant settings in inland Oregon, visitors to Lucier will have quite an experience. Co-owners Tyanne and Chris Dussin and executive chef and co-owner Pascal Chureau have created a magnificent room filled with gorgeous glass art pieces crowned with a striking Willamette River view. Sophisticated diners will find the menu appealing and the food delicious; meat-and-potato types may not be so enthralled. With soaring prices (the tasting menu peaks at $100) and over-the-top pretentious service, it's yet to be determined whether this venue will be more than a one-time destination. [55]
In November 2008, the newspaper's Sara Perry called Lucier a "stunning and sophisticated ... restaurant that's capturing the attention of people who want to celebrate and dine in style". [56] Karen Brooks gave the restaurant a rating of C−. [57] [58] She wrote: "after four visits and a deep exploration of the menu, I'm sorry to say that the concept is about as viable as the auto industry: a money guzzler, out of touch and running on empty ideas". She called the cooking "gimmicky" and said "Lucier feels forced and artificial, like an American Express vision of privilege". [24] She also wrote: "instead of a through-line of restrained elegance, we get Dining in Dubai, or 1980s Vegas, with fun-house mirror columns, display case after display case of gaudy blown glass and Sinatra belting out 'My Kind of Town'". [24] Her review ended: "Lucier neither improves on Portland nor feels of Portland. It doesn't even seem for Portland. It's like a spec house on the Street of Dreams, with all the upgrades but no one to answer the door." [24]
A review published by The Oregonian in December 2008 said: "Portland's most expensive restaurant goes for the glitz on the waterfront but overreaches in style and substance, delivering only with first-rate desserts. ... Look for the simplest preparations—seasonal salads, roast duck, an aged rib-eye. All desserts are good, but don't miss the changing souffle, vacherin or mille-feuille offerings." [59] The Oregonian said Lucier "never caught on. Reviews in Willamette Week, Portland Monthly and ... The Oregonian criticized the food and the prices the restaurant demanded". [22]
In 2010, The Oregonian's Roger Porter called Chureau's tenure as Lucier's first executive chef "disastrous". [60] He also called Lucier "the most overpriced and underwhelming restaurant in Portland's history, which closed to few regrets". [61] In his 2016 overview of "97 long-gone Portland restaurants we wish were still around", Grant Butler wrote:
OK, this ridiculously extravagant waterfront restaurant may have been the biggest dining belly-flop in recent years, opening and closing in a matter of months in 2008. But those views of the Willamette! And those over-the-top Dale Chihuly sculptures, which were pretty magnificent when seen up close. The expensive food may have been a mess, but the desserts put pastry chef Kristen Murray on the map, and for that we are forever grateful. [62]
Wong's King Seafood Restaurant was a chain of Chinese/Cantonese and seafood restaurants in the metropolitan area of Portland, Oregon, United States. In addition to the original restaurant in Southeast Portland, the business operated in Beaverton, Estacada, and Sandy, and specialized in dim sum.
Wildwood Restaurant and Bar, or simply Wildwood, was a Pacific Northwest and New American restaurant in Portland, Oregon, in the United States. Operating from 1994 to 2014, the restaurant earned owner and founding chef Cory Schreiber a James Beard Foundation Award nomination in the Best Chef: Northwest category. Wendy Culverwell of Portland Business Journal described Wildwood as "a pioneer in the farm-to-table food movement".
Irving Street Kitchen was a restaurant serving American cuisine in Portland, Oregon's Pearl District, in the United States. Conceived by Doug Washington, Mitch Rosenthal and Steve Rosenthal as their interpretation on American cuisine with a Southern influence, it opened on May 6, 2010. With executive chef Sarah Schafer, Irving Street Kitchen added to their serving hours over the years, opening up for lunch and brunch. The restaurant also shifted towards casual dining in 2019, revamping its menu and ambiance. Irving Street Kitchen ultimately closed during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Bluehour was a Mediterranean restaurant and bar located in the Pearl District of Portland, Oregon, United States. The business began operating in September 2000. Bruce Carey and Joe Rogers co-owned the business with Kenny Giambalvo, who also served as an executive chef until 2011.
Clyde Common was a restaurant and market in Portland, Oregon, United States. The business opened in 2007. In 2020, Clyde Common closed temporarily due to the COVID-19 pandemic, reopening in July with outdoor dining and as a market. The bar and restaurant became known as Clyde Tavern, and the part of the former dining area was called Common Market. Clyde Common closed permanently in January 2022.
Dóttir was a restaurant in Portland, Oregon's KEX Hotel, in the United States. The restaurant closed on January 1, 2022.
Grassa is a restaurant with multiple locations in the Portland, Oregon metropolitan area, in the United States. The original restaurant opened in Southwest Portland in 2013; subsequent locations have opened in Northwest Portland's Northwest District, in Southeast Portland's Buckman neighborhood, and in Vancouver, Washington.
XLB is a Chinese restaurant in Portland, Oregon, United States. Second-generation Chinese chef Jasper Shen opened the original restaurant along North Williams Avenue in the Boise neighborhood in January 2017. He and new business partner Linh Tran opened a second in northwest Portland's Slabtown district in 2019. The Slabtown restaurant closed in 2021.
Tin Shed Garden Cafe, often abbreviated as Tin Shed, is a restaurant in Portland, Oregon's King neighborhood. Co-owned by Christie Griffin and Janette Kaden, the dog-friendly cafe opened in 2002 and serves American cuisine.
Han Oak is a restaurant serving Korean cuisine in Portland, Oregon's Kerns neighborhood, in the United States. Owned by chef Peter Cho and partner Sun Young Park, Han Oak was The Oregonian's Restaurant of the Year in 2017.
Ataula was a Spanish and Catalan restaurant in Portland, Oregon, in the United States. The restaurant earned Jose Chesa a James Beard Foundation Award nomination in the Best Chef: Northwest category.
Genoa was an Italian restaurant in Portland, Oregon, in the United States. Housed in the Genoa Building, the restaurant closed permanently in 2014. Laurie Wolf said Genoa "was at the forefront of Portland's changing food scene".
Ping was an Asian restaurant in Portland, Oregon. Chef Andy Ricker and restaurateur Kurt Huffman opened the original restaurant in Old Town Chinatown in 2009. In 2010, Ping was a semifinalist in the Best New Restaurant category at the James Beard Foundation Awards. It was also named a best new restaurant by GQ and earned a Rising Star award from The Oregonian.
Beast was a restaurant in Portland, Oregon. The business earned chef and owner Naomi Pomeroy a James Beard Foundation Award for Best Chef: Northwest in 2014.
La Bonita: Food for the People, or simply La Bonita, is a small chain of Mexican restaurants in Portland, Oregon, United States. The family-owned business operates three locations in north, northeast, and southeast Portland, serving burritos, chilaquiles, tacos, tamales, and other traditional cuisine. The restaurant has a good reputation, and has been included on two Thrillist lists of the country's best burritos.
Ya Hala Lebanese Cuisine, or simply Ya Hala, is a Lebanese and Middle Eastern restaurant in Portland, Oregon, United States. The business was established as a deli counter in 1999.
Kenny's Noodle House is a Chinese restaurant in Portland, Oregon.
RingSide Fish House was a seafood restaurant in Portland, Oregon. The business operated in southwest Portland's Fox Tower from 2011 to 2018.
Fenouil was a French and Pacific Northwest restaurant in Portland, Oregon. The business operated from 2005 to 2011.
Aviary was a restaurant on Alberta Street in northeast Portland, Oregon's Vernon neighborhood, in the United States. Sarah Pliner was a co-owner and head chef.
We just learned that Lucier, a 7,600-square-foot, 100-seat waterfront restaurant, plans to open in November just south of RiverPlace in a stand-alone glass-and-steel building set among a new trio of condo towers called The Stand.
He moved to Portland in 2008 and took a job at Lucier, the doomed South Waterfront restaurant, where he first met Greg Denton (Ox, SuperBite), whom he credits with inspiring his love of cooking. From Lucier, Adams went to Metrovino, then joined Paley at his Northwest Portland restaurant, Paley's Place.
Adams, a Texas native, amateur fly fisherman and bluegrass aficionado, attended school in Montana, then moved to Portland for culinary school, landing his first fine-dining gig at Lucier just in time to watch the famed South Waterfront restaurant implode.
Plans include dinners with executive chef Jeremy Niehuss, formerly of In Good Taste, Fenouil and Lucier; canning classes; and urban gardening programs.
Yet, for the past seven years or so, as she has stood at the top of Portland's pastry heap during successive posts at Lucier, Fenouil, Paley's Place and more, Kristen D. Murray has found occasions to sprinkle crumbs in interviews, clues that her future might hold something more personal, something less formal, something that embraces passion over perfection.
But when they relocated here, they faced the ordeal of cooking at Lucier, the most spectacular failure in recent Portland restaurant history, reminding them that a restaurant has to be about what diners want.
A short while later he took a job as executive sous-chef at Lucier. The story of that ill-fated restaurant has been recited often enough. For Denton, Lucier's brief, disappointing run ended with unemployment just before the holidays in 2008. He says the closure was 'a considerable blow to the ego and a huge disappointment after all the work that we had put into it. It was definitely a low point in my career.'
Chris Dussin, president of the Dussin Group, which operates Old Spaghetti Factory restaurants, Fenouil, Lucier and others, said earlier that poor financial performance because of the recession prompted the closure of Lucier. Dussin says he hopes to reopen Lucier --the only Oregon restaurant accorded four diamonds by the American Automobile Association --when the economy improves, perhaps next spring. Whether it reopens, Lucier's shooting-star arc is a symptom of the constellation of troubles facing Portland's vaunted restaurant scene.
The short-lived Lucier, a multimillion-dollar gamble on destination south waterfront dining, is set to reopen early this summer at 1910 S.W. River Drive. From the day it opened in May 2008, Lucier was one of the most talked about restaurants in Portland history, with its luxe interior and grand ambitions{{subst:mdash}}and then its high-profile closure seven months later. Chris Dussin, whose Dussin Group owns the handsome, contemporary, stand-alone building, said the new incarnation will be a "little less high-end and a little more approachable" than the original. Decor changes will be made consistent with Lucier's downscaling, Dussin said, and a new chef will be hired to run the reimagined restaurant.
Nothing could be more emblematic of the rising tide than the announced summer reopening of the former Lucier space on the RiverPlace waterfront by its owner, the Dussin Group. Lucier was a foray at the high end that flamed out in December 2008 after only seven months amidst recessionary pressure and poor reviews. Little is known about the new incarnation other than it will be less ambitious{{subst:mdash}}and presumably less expensive --than the original.
Lucier restaurant on downtown Portland's waterfront has been named Oregon's only 2009 four-diamond restaurant by AAA.
Lucier, which attempted to emulate the kind of fine dining experience found in New York or Paris, received poor reviews in The Oregonian, Portland Monthly and Willamette Week, all of which blasted the restaurant's over-the-top aesthetic and underwhelming menu. Food critic Karen Brooks, then writing for The Oregonian, critiqued a dissonance between the upscale decor and the poor food in a C- review published just before the restaurant closed. 'The feeling of disconnect peaked one night while sitting in an oversized leather chair, hunched over an undersized—but glitzy!—table, trying to eat caviar from a hollowed-out egg served on a pedestal with a fancy silver spoon,' Brooks wrote. 'Maybe it worked for the shah of Iran.' Head chef Pascal Chureau called the criticism "unfair" in a 2010 interview with The Oregonian, though he acknowledged Lucier was a poor concept for Portland.