Ventastega

Last updated

Ventastega
Temporal range: 376.1–360.7  Ma [1]
Ventastega BW.jpg
An artist's depiction of Ventastega curonica chasing prey.
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Clade: Sarcopterygii
Clade: Tetrapodomorpha
Clade: Stegocephali
Genus: Ventastega
Ahlberg, P.E, Clack, J.A, Lukševičs, E., Zupiņš, I. 1994
Species
  • V. curonica

Ventastega (Venta referring to the Venta River at the Ketleri Formation where Ventastega was discovered [2] ) is an extinct genus of stem tetrapod that lived during the Upper Fammenian of the Late Devonian, approximately 372.2 to 358.9 million years ago. [2] Only one species is known that belongs in the genus, Ventastega curonica, which was described in 1996 after fossils were discovered in 1933 and mistakenly associated with a fish called Polyplocodus wenjukovi. [2] ‘Curonica’ in the species name refers to Curonia, the Latin name for Kurzeme, a region in western Latvia. [2] Ventastega curonica was discovered in two localities in Latvia, and was the first stem tetrapod described in Latvia along with being only the 4th Devonian tetrapodomorph known at the time of description. [2] Based on the morphology of both cranial and post-cranial elements discovered (see below), Ventastega is more primitive than other Devonian tetrapodomorphs including Acanthostega and Ichthyostega, [3] [2] and helps further understanding of the fish-tetrapod transition.

Contents

Discovery

Walter Gross was the first person to collect partial Ventastega remains, collecting some teeth in addition to scales from a locality called Ketleri in a Latvian Upper Famennian formation while on a collection trip in 1933. [2] Gross attributed all remains to an osteolepiform fish named Polyplocodus wenjukov, before later in 1944 reattributing some of the fragments to a species called Panderichthys bystrowi when a piece of a lower jaw was collected from the same locality. [2] Additional remains were collected from the locality and from another locality, Pavāri, in the same formation by researchers Per Erik Ahlberg, Ervīns Lukševičs  [ lv ], and Oleg Lebedev. After this collection they realized the previously collected remains were assigned incorrectly, and were actually part of a newly discovered tetrapod, which they named and described in a paper published in 1996. [2] In the follow years, several more fragments of Ventastega curonica remains have been discovered at both the Ketleri and Pavāri localities, with all specimens residing at the Natural History Museum of Latvia. [3]

Description

Cranial elements

Lower jaw

The Ventastega holotype (LDM 81/521) is a right lower jaw ramus from Pavāri, and was described by Per Erik Ahlberg, Ervīns Lukševičs, and Oleg Lebedev. [2] The lower jaw ramus total length was estimated to be over 200mm. [2] This, combined with other cranial and post-cranial elements of Ventastega, made researchers predict that it was larger than Ichthyostega [2] . The mandible is widest anterior to the first coronoid fang. [2] The dentary is long and shallow, and has a butt joint as the contact with the coronoid series, indicating the dentary is loosely attached to the jaw. [2] Similar to some tetrapods such as Acanthostega and Tulerpeton , the dentary's lateral surface is ornamented on the dorsal side with a smooth section only on the ventral margin. [2] Another lower jaw specimen (LDM 81/552) is the only known complete Ventastega dentary, and shows Ventastega had 89 marginal teeth on each side of the jaw that are all approximately the same size, although they decrease in height as you move distally. [2] Ventastega also has a pair of fangs on each dentary that are situated close to where the two dentaries meet at the most anterior part of the lower jaw, similar to Panderichthyes and Ichthyostega. [2] On the precoronoid and intercornoid, Ventastega has fangs pairs set within the marginal row of teeth. [2] On the lower jaw, Ventastega had a surangular pit line, which is present in most Sarcopterygians but unknown in any other tetrapods. [2] A primitive characteristic on Ventastega, shared only with fish and Ichthyostega , is the presence of a fully enclosed mandibular sensory canal which opens to the external world through only a single row of pores. [2]

Dermal skull bones

Maxillae, premaxillae, palatines, and a vomer along with large skull fragments from Pavāri have been identified as Ventastega [2] . The maxilla is long and low, and unlike some fish, the posterior third of the maxilla is the lowest part of the bone. [2] The teeth on the maxilla are approximately equal in size to each other, except for teeth in the posterior part where they shrink in size. [2] The presence of a coronoid fangs in Ventastega is a primitive feature lost in Ichthyostega, Acanthostega, and likely Tulerpeton, indicating that Ventastega was more basal on a phylogeny in comparison other tetrapods. [2] The posterolateral margin of the choana has a smooth area, which is evidence of a loose and ligamentous contact between the maxilla and premaxilla. The premaxilla itself is morphologically similar to premaxillas in Acanthostega, Ichthyostega, and Tulerpeton . [2] The region of maximum curvature along the premaxilla is approximately halfway along the bone, suggesting that Ventastega had a broad and spade-shaped snout. [2] Seventeen teeth are in each premaxilla, with the teeth increasing in size moving from the tip of the snout to the region of maximum curvature. [2] A partial Ventastega cheekplate consisting of the jugal, and parts of the lacrimal, quadratojugal, squamosal, and preopercular is convex in the vertical plane, indicating that Ventastega's skull was low in height. [2] The preopercular in this specimen and several other partial skull fragments is a primitive tetrapod character, otherwise seen only in Ichthyostega, Acanthostega, and Crassigyrinus . [2] The cephalic lateral lines in Ventastega have an intermediate morphology with the lines only being partially enclosed, between the primitive state of full enclosure of the lines in fish and Ichthyostega , and the fully open lines seen in Temnospondyls and other derived tetrapods. [2] The ventral surface of the Ventastega pterygoid is covered is covered in denticles, a feature shared by all early tetrapods except Ichthyostega [2] . Ventastega has a large spiracular notch, larger than seen in any known Devonian tetrapods. [3] The increase in spiracular notch size in Devonian tetrapods has been hypothesized to indicate an increased reliance on air breathing. [3]

Braincase

A pristinely preserved three-dimensional braincase of Ventastega has been discovered, and closely resembles the braincase of Acanthostega, except Ventastega had a uniquely large and bi-lobed nerve foramen on the anterior face of the prootic, along with an orbit-temporal region immediately dorsal to the basipterygoid processes. [3] Shared features between the two taxa were the shape of the prootic region and its location to the ventral cranial fissure and fenestra vestibuli, along with the basipterygoid processes and laterally open post-temporal fossae. [3]

Post-cranial elements

The clavicle has a broad ventral blade with a narrow stem, characteristic of early tetrapods, along with the stem having a thick anterior and thin posterior lamina that merges into the lateral rod surface. [2] In the iliac blade, there is a pronounced bend/kink approximately one third from the proximal end of the blade, with the distal part of the blade bent dorsally and mesially. [2] The interclavicle is approximately 25% smaller than the clavicle, and similar in shape in a Greererpeton interclavicle, suggesting it had a similar rhomboidal or kite shape. [2] The clavicle itself is similar to the morphology of other early tetrapod clavicles, with a tapering clavicular stem and P-shaped cross section, although it has a unique and distinct unornamented strip along the anterior margin. [2]

Classification

Ventastegacuronica belongs to Tetrapoda in accordance with the traditional definition. [2] According to a strict parsimony phylogeny that ranked 319 characters of tetrapods (defined less inclusively as a crown group) and other tetrapodomorphs, Ventastega is part of the stem-tetrapod group, with 96% bootstrapping consensus at its node (shown below). [4] The group of stem-tetrapods contains any extinct taxon that, according to morphological analysis, is more closely related to lissamphibians (living amphibians) and amniotes than to any other crown group. [4]

Tetrapodomorpha

Eusthenopteron

Panderichthys

Ventastega

Acanthostega

Ichthyostega

Tulerpeton

Colosteus

Greererpeton

Crassigyrinus

Whatcheeria

Baphetes

Megalocephalus

Crown Group Tetrapoda

Ventastega in an evolutionary tree, as recovered from an analysis by Clack et al. 2016: [5]

Elpistostegalia

Panderichthys

Stegocephalia

Metaxygnathus

Tiktaalik

Stegocephali

Acanthostega

Ossinodus

Ventastega

Ichthyostega

Ossirarus

Ymeria

Aytonerpeton

Perittodus

Whatcheeriidae

Whatcheeria

Pederpes

Occidens

Diploradus

Doragnathus

Sigournea

Koilops

Tulerpeton

Colosteidae

Greererpeton

Colosteus

Crassigyrinus

Baphetidae

Loxomma

Megalocephalus

Baphetes

Tetrapoda

sensu Laurin, 2020
sensu Laurin, 1998

Role in fish–tetrapod transition

Ventastega has helped further research on the Fish-Tetrapod transition, the event during the Devonian when digit bearing tetrapods evolved from finned, fish ancestors. [6] Research on rates of character changes in tetrapods have shown that there were high rates of character changes in the Devonian, which led to the conflicting hypotheses of either the tetrapods had few major changes that occurred during the Devonian or had many small but rapid morphology changes. [7] The braincase of Ventastega has a mixture of fish-like and tetrapod-like characteristics, indicating that changes in the braincase during the fish-tetrapod transition occurred through a series of many small changes instead of one large change. [6] The skull morphology of Ventastega has helped informed the hypothesis that changes in skull roof pattern proportions also occurred gradually, with the snout elongating and eyes increasing in size while moving dorsally over time. [6]

Due to anoxic conditions in aquatic ecosystems during the Famennian (see Paleoenvironment below), early tetrapods such as Ventastega would have had a significant fitness advantage with the ability to exploit terrestrial environments. [6]

Locomotion

No limb remains from Ventastega have been discovered to inform researchers about its locomotion, but paleontologists have been able to infer some basic information about its limbs and locomotion due to its overall morphological similarity to Acanthostega, a limbed tetrapod with digits. [8] While no fossilized trackways from Ventastega have yet been discovered, discoveries of late Devonian trackways from closely related Ichthyostega and Acanthostega along with other early tetrapods indicate that the most stable gait for early tetrapods, including Ventastega, would a lateral-sequence walk. [9] The trackway patterns, including marks from the tetrapods dragging their tails and bellies on the ground, have both been subaerial and subaqueous, indicating that the origin of terrestrial locomotion originated in tetrapods, not in their fish ancestors. [9] Ventastega likely had subaqueous locomotion, which can be inferred from its close relation to Acanthostega , which researchers hypothesized moved subaqueously. [10]

Paleoenvironment

Graph showing the change in global oxygen concentration through time. Looking at the long term average, the graph shows oxygen concentrations in the atmosphere being lower in the Late Devonian in comparison to today. Phanerozoic Climate Change.png
Graph showing the change in global oxygen concentration through time. Looking at the long term average, the graph shows oxygen concentrations in the atmosphere being lower in the Late Devonian in comparison to today.

Paleogeologists estimate that the Famennian, the global average temperature was about 19.5 °C. [8] CO2 levels in the atmosphere during the Famennian were approximately 0.3%, higher than present, while O2 levels were lower than present, making up only 16% of the atmosphere. [8] Plants were undergoing rapid diversification during the middle and late Devonian, and beginning to occupy vast tracts of land instead of being restricted to the coastal margins, which created new terrestrial habitats, including the first forests. [8] The decomposition of these newly diversified plants would have increased nutrient concentrations in the surrounding water, creating intense algae growth, which would cause eutrophic and anoxic conditions in the water. [8] Ventastega and other early tetrapods would have been able to gulp air, giving them a significant fitness advantage by allowing them to explore the banks of the anoxic rivers and lakes where they were found. [8]

Stem and crown tetrapods have been found in both freshwater environments along with estuarine and lagoonal environments of varying salinity. [11] However, the sedimentology of the Ketleri Formation, including sands interbedded with siltstones and clays, indicates that Ventastega was deposited in a low-tidal, near-shore environment in saline water. [11]

Geographic and stratigraphic range

The Ketleri Formation or Ketleri Outcrop (Latvian : Ketleru atsegumi) is located in southwestern Latvia and northwestern Lithuania. [12] Per Erik Ahlberg, Ervīns Lukševičs, and Oleg Lebedev collected Ventastega material both from the Ketleri locality where the original material was found, but also from another locality in the Ketleri formation, the Pavāri locality (Latvian : Pavāru atsegumi. [2] [13] The Ketleri locality is at the Venta river near the former Ketleri hamlet, while the Pavāri locality is across the Ciecere river from the former Pavāri hamlet. [12] The formation itself is composed of sand, sandstone, clay, and dolomitic marls, with the formation being 45m thick in Lithuania and 41-56m thick in Latvia. [12] The formation is composed of three members, the lowermost Nīgrange member which has thick clayey carbonate deposits, the Pavāri member which consists of sand and sandstone with high levels of quartz, feldspar, and mica, and the upper Varkaļi member which is composed of fine feldspar-quartz sands and sandstones with high quantities of mica. [12] The Pavāri member had a shallow erosional channel filled with well sorted sands indicating the presence of a stream in the Devonian that flowed in the channel from NNE to SSW, which is the characteristic direction of flow across the whole Ketleri formation. [12] Sand particles filled in the erosional channel, and then were followed by slow, calm intertidal streams depositing poorly sorted silts and clays. [12]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tetrapod</span> Superclass of the first four-limbed vertebrates and their descendants

A tetrapod is any four-limbed vertebrate animal of the superclass Tetrapoda. Tetrapods include all extant and extinct amphibians and amniotes, with the latter in turn evolving into two major clades, the sauropsids and synapsids. Some tetrapods such as snakes, legless lizards, and caecilians had evolved to become limbless via mutations of the Hox gene, although some do still have a pair of vestigial spurs that are remnants of the hindlimbs.

<i>Ichthyostega</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Ichthyostega is an extinct genus of limbed tetrapodomorphs from the Late Devonian of what is now Greenland. It was among the earliest four-limbed vertebrates ever in the fossil record and was one of the first with weight-bearing adaptations for terrestrial locomotion. Ichthyostega possessed lungs and limbs that helped it navigate through shallow water in swamps. Although Ichthyostega is often labelled a 'tetrapod' because of its limbs and fingers, it evolved long before true crown group tetrapods and could more accurately be referred to as a stegocephalian or stem tetrapod. Likewise, while undoubtedly of amphibian build and habit, it is not a true member of the group in the narrow sense, as the first modern amphibians appeared in the Triassic Period. Until finds of other early stegocephalians and closely related fishes in the late 20th century, Ichthyostega stood alone as a transitional fossil between fish and tetrapods, combining fish and tetrapod features. Newer research has shown that it had an unusual anatomy, functioning more akin to a seal than a salamander, as previously assumed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jenny Clack</span> English paleontologist and evolutionary biologist (1947–2020)

Jennifer Alice Clack, was an English palaeontologist and evolutionary biologist. She specialised in the early evolution of tetrapods, specifically studying the "fish to tetrapod" transition: the origin, evolutionary development and radiation of early tetrapods and their relatives among the lobe-finned fishes. She is best known for her book Gaining Ground: the Origin and Early Evolution of Tetrapods, published in 2002 and written with the layperson in mind.

<i>Acanthostega</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Acanthostega is an extinct genus of stem-tetrapod, among the first vertebrate animals to have recognizable limbs. It appeared in the late Devonian period about 365 million years ago, and was anatomically intermediate between lobe-finned fishes and those that were fully capable of coming onto land.

<i>Panderichthys</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Panderichthys is a genus of extinct sarcopterygian from the late Devonian period, about 380 Mya. Panderichthys, which was recovered from Frasnian deposits in Latvia, is represented by two species. P. stolbovi is known only from some snout fragments and an incomplete lower jaw. P. rhombolepis is known from several more complete specimens. Although it probably belongs to a sister group of the earliest tetrapods, Panderichthys exhibits a range of features transitional between tristichopterid lobe-fin fishes and early tetrapods. It is named after the German-Baltic paleontologist Christian Heinrich Pander. Possible tetrapod tracks dating back to before the appearance of Panderichthys in the fossil record were reported in 2010, which suggests that Panderichthys is not a direct ancestor of tetrapods, but nonetheless shows the traits that evolved during the fish-tetrapod evolution

<i>Hynerpeton</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Hynerpeton is an extinct genus of early four-limbed vertebrate that lived in the rivers and ponds of Pennsylvania during the Late Devonian period, around 365 to 363 million years ago. The only known species of Hynerpeton is H. bassetti, named after the describer's grandfather, city planner Edward Bassett. Hynerpeton is known for being the first Devonian four-limbed vertebrate discovered in the United States, as well as possibly being one of the first to have lost internal (fish-like) gills.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rhizodontida</span> Extinct order of tetrapodomorphs

Rhizodontida is an extinct group of predatory tetrapodomorphs known from many areas of the world from the Givetian through to the Pennsylvanian - the earliest known species is about 377 million years ago (Mya), the latest around 310 Mya. Rhizodonts lived in tropical rivers and freshwater lakes and were the dominant predators of their age. They reached huge sizes - the largest known species, Rhizodus hibberti from Europe and North America, was an estimated 7 m in length, making it the largest freshwater fish known.

<i>Eusthenodon</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Eusthenodon is an extinct genus of tristichopterid tetrapodomorphs from the Late Devonian period, ranging between 383 and 359 million years ago. They are well known for being a cosmopolitan genus with remains being recovered from East Greenland, Australia, Central Russia, South Africa, Pennsylvania, and Belgium. Compared to the other closely related genera of the Tristichopteridae clade, Eusthenodon was one of the largest lobe-finned fishes and among the most derived tristichopterids alongside its close relatives Cabonnichthys and Mandageria.

Livoniana is a genus of prehistoric tetrapodomorphs which lived during the Devonian period.

<i>Spathicephalus</i> Extinct genus of tetrapods

Spathicephalus is an extinct genus of stem tetrapods that lived during the middle of the Carboniferous Period. The genus includes two species: the type species S. mirus from Scotland, which is known from two mostly complete skulls and other cranial material, and the species S. pereger from Nova Scotia, which is known from a single fragment of the skull table. Based on the S. mirus material, the appearance of Spathicephalus is unlike that of any other early tetrapod, with a flattened, square-shaped skull and jaws lined with hundreds of very small chisel-like teeth. However, Spathicephalus shares several anatomical features with a family of stem tetrapods called Baphetidae, leading most paleontologists who have studied the genus to place it within a larger group called Baphetoidea, often as part of its own monotypic family Spathicephalidae. Spathicephalus is thought to have fed on aquatic invertebrates through a combination of suction feeding and filter feeding.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Stegocephali</span> Clade of tetrapodomorphs

Stegocephali is a clade of vertebrate animals containing all fully limbed tetrapodomorphs. It is equivalent to a broad definition of the superclass Tetrapoda: under this broad definition, the term "tetrapod" applies to any animal descended from the first vertebrate with four limbs each with five digits in the extremity (pentadactyly), rather than fins of their sarcopterygian relatives.

<i>Ossinodus</i> Genus of the first four-limbed vertebrates and their descendants

Ossinodus is an extinct genus of stem tetrapod. Fossils have been found from the Ducabrook Formation in Queensland, Australia dating back to the middle Visean stage of the Early Carboniferous (Mississippian). It was originally placed within the family Whatcheeriidae, but the absence of an intertemporal bone as suggested by a recent reconstruction of the skull based on fragmentary material may prove it to be stemward of all whatcheeriids.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ichthyostegalia</span> Paraphyletic group of tetrapodomorphs

Ichthyostegalia is an order of extinct amphibians, representing the earliest landliving vertebrates. The group is thus an evolutionary grade rather than a clade. While the group are recognized as having feet rather than fins, most, if not all, had internal gills in adulthood and lived primarily as shallow water fish and spent minimal time on land.

<i>Ymeria</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Ymeria is an extinct genus of early stem tetrapod from the Devonian of Greenland. Of the two other genera of stem tetrapods from Greenland, Acanthostega and Ichthyostega, Ymeria is most closely related to Ichthyostega, though the single known specimen is smaller, the skull about 10 cm in length. A single interclavicle resembles that of Ichthyostega, an indication Ymeria may have resembled this genus in the post-cranial skeleton.

<i>Occidens portlocki</i> Extinct species of tetrapodomorph

Occidens is an extinct genus of stem tetrapod from the Early Carboniferous (Tournaisian) Altagoan Formation of Northern Ireland. It is known from a single type species, Occidens portlocki, named in 2004 on the basis of a left lower jaw described by British geologist Joseph Ellison Portlock in 1843.


Innovations conventionally associated with terrestrially first appeared in aquatic elpistostegalians such as Panderichthys rhombolepis, Elpistostege watsoni, and Tiktaalik roseae. Phylogenetic analyses distribute the features that developed along the tetrapod stem and display a stepwise process of character acquisition, rather than abrupt. The complete transition occurred over a period of 30 million years beginning with the tetrapodomorph diversification in the Middle Devonian.

<i>Parmastega</i> Extinct genus of tetrapodomorphs

Parmastega is an extinct genus of tetrapod from the Devonian, dated to the earliest Famennian age, in contrast to later fossils known from late Famennian. These later fossils are considerably younger, by about 30 million years, than the earliest recorded tetrapod footprints, which presented a mystery that Parmastega's more recently described morphology from a three dimensional reconstruction has helped provide light on.

Brittagnathus is an extinct genus of four-limbed vertebrate ("tetrapod") from the Late Devonian of Greenland. It contains a single species, Brittagnathus minutus, which is based on a complete lower jaw recovered from an Acanthostega bonebed in the Britta Dal Formation. It is the fourth named genus of "tetrapod" from the Late Devonian of Greenland, after Ichthyostega, Acanthostega, and Ymeria.

The Zachelmie trackways are a series of Middle Devonian-age trace fossils in Poland, purportedly the oldest evidence of terrestrial vertebrates (tetrapods) in the fossil record. These trackways were discovered in the Wojciechowice Formation, an Eifelian-age carbonate unit exposed in the Zachełmie Quarry of the Świętokrzyskie Mountains (Holy Cross Mountains]. The discovery of these tracks has complicated the study of tetrapod evolution. Morphological studies suggest that four-limbed vertebrates are descended from a specialized type of tetrapodomorph fish, the epistostegalians. This hypothesis was supported further by the discovery and 2006 description of Tiktaalik, a well-preserved epistostegalian from the Frasnian of Nunavut. Crucial to this idea is the assumption that tetrapods originated in the Late Devonian, after elpistostegalians appear in the fossil record near the start of the Frasnian. The Zachelmie trackways, however, appear to demonstrate that tetrapods were present prior to the Late Devonian. The implications of this find has led to several different perspectives on the sequence of events involved in tetrapod evolution.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ciecere River</span> River in Courland, Latvia

The Ciecere River is a right-bank tributary of the Venta River, flowing through the Saldus and Kuldīga districts. The basin is mostly located in the East Curonian Spit, where the 50 m-deep Lake Ciecere has formed in subglacial deposits, from which the Ciecere flows. The Mazupe River, a tributary of Lake Ciecere, is sometimes considered to be the origin of the Ciecere, which flows westward.

References

  1. "†Ventastega Ahlberg et al. 1994". Paleobiology Database. Fossilworks. Retrieved 17 December 2021.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 Ahlberg, Per Erik; Luksevics, Ervins; Lebedev, Oleg (1994-02-28). "The First Tetrapod Finds from the Devonian (Upper Famennian) of Latvia". Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B: Biological Sciences. 343 (1305): 303–328. doi:10.1098/rstb.1994.0027. ISSN   0962-8436.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Ahlberg, Per E.; Clack, Jennifer A.; Lukševičs, Ervīns; Blom, Henning; Zupiņš, Ivars (June 2008). "Ventastega curonica and the origin of tetrapod morphology". Nature. 453 (7199): 1199–1204. Bibcode:2008Natur.453.1199A. doi:10.1038/nature06991. ISSN   0028-0836. PMID   18580942. S2CID   4344417.
  4. 1 2 RUTA, MARCELLO; COATES, MICHAEL I.; QUICKE, DONALD L. J. (May 2003). "Early tetrapod relationships revisited". Biological Reviews of the Cambridge Philosophical Society. 78 (2): 251–345. doi:10.1017/s1464793102006103. ISSN   1464-7931. PMID   12803423. S2CID   31298396.
  5. Jennifer A. Clack; Carys E. Bennett; David K. Carpenter; Sarah J. Davies; Nicholas C. Fraser; Timothy I. Kearsey; John E. A. Marshall; David Millward; Benjamin K. A. Otoo; Emma J. Reeves; Andrew J. Ross; Marcello Ruta; Keturah Z. Smithson; Timothy R. Smithson; Stig A. Walsh (2016). "Phylogenetic and environmental context of a Tournaisian tetrapod fauna" (PDF). Nature Ecology & Evolution. 1 (1): Article number 0002. doi:10.1038/s41559-016-0002. PMID   28812555. S2CID   22421017.
  6. 1 2 3 4 Clack, Jennifer A. (2009-03-17). "The Fish–Tetrapod Transition: New Fossils and Interpretations". Evolution: Education and Outreach. 2 (2): 213–223. doi: 10.1007/s12052-009-0119-2 . ISSN   1936-6426.
  7. Ruta, Marcello; Wagner, Peter J; Coates, Michael I (2006-05-16). "Evolutionary patterns in early tetrapods. I. Rapid initial diversification followed by decrease in rates of character change". Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences. 273 (1598): 2107–2111. doi:10.1098/rspb.2006.3577. ISSN   0962-8452. PMC   1635524 . PMID   16901828.
  8. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Clack, J. A. (2007-10-01). "Devonian climate change, breathing, and the origin of the tetrapod stem group". Integrative and Comparative Biology. 47 (4): 510–523. doi: 10.1093/icb/icm055 . ISSN   1540-7063. PMID   21672860.
  9. 1 2 Clack, J.A. (May 1997). "Devonian tetrapod trackways and trackmakers; a review of the fossils and footprints". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 130 (1–4): 227–250. Bibcode:1997PPP...130..227C. doi:10.1016/s0031-0182(96)00142-3. ISSN   0031-0182.
  10. Coates, M. I.; Clack, J. A. (July 1991). "Fish-like gills and breathing in the earliest known tetrapod". Nature. 352 (6332): 234–236. Bibcode:1991Natur.352..234C. doi:10.1038/352234a0. ISSN   0028-0836. S2CID   4340202.
  11. 1 2 Clack, Jennifer A. (March 2006). "The emergence of early tetrapods". Palaeogeography, Palaeoclimatology, Palaeoecology. 232 (2–4): 167–189. Bibcode:2006PPP...232..167C. doi:10.1016/j.palaeo.2005.07.019. ISSN   0031-0182.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Luksevics, Ervins; Zupins, Ivars (2004-01-01). "Sedimentology, fauna, and taphonomy of the Pavāri site, Late Devonian of Latvia". Acta Universitatis Latviensis. 679: 99–119.
  13. "Pavāru atsegumi | Dabas aizsardzības pārvalde". www.daba.gov.lv (in Latvian). Retrieved 2021-04-01.