Macro-Chibchan languages

Last updated
Macro-Chibchan
Lenmichí
(controversial)
Geographic
distribution
Central America and Colombia
Linguistic classification Proposed language family
Subdivisions
Language codes
ISO 639-3
Glottolog None
Lenmichi languages.png
The Chibchan, Misumalpan, and Lencan languages

Macro-Chibchan is a proposed grouping of the languages of the Lencan, Misumalpan, and Chibchan families into a single large phylum (macrofamily).

Contents

History

The Lencan and Misumalpan languages were once included in the Chibchan family proper, but were excluded pending further evidence as that family became well established. Kaufman (1990) finds the Chibchan–Misumalpan connection convincing, if as yet unsubstantiated, though Campbell (1997) finds it doubtful. The Xincan family was once included in Macro-Chibchan, but this is now doubtful.

Constenla (2005) calls this proposed phylum Lenmichí (Lencan–Misumalpan–Chibchan) and provides 85 cognate sets which exhibit regular sound correspondences among the three families. He suggests that Chocoan may be related as well.

Greenberg proposed a broader conception of Macro-Chibchan, one dismissed by linguists working on the families in question. It included Yanomam, Purépecha, and Cuitlatec in addition to Chibchan–Misumalpan–Xinca–Lenca. Greenberg (1987) included Paezan languages in a Chibchan-Paezan stock with Barbacoan, Chibchan, Chocoan, Jirajaran, and the isolates Betoi, Kamsá (Sibundoy), Yaruro, Esmeraldeño, Mochica, Cunza, Itonama, Timucua and Yurumanguí.

An automated computational analysis (ASJP 4) by Müller et al. (2013) [1] also found lexical similarities between Chibchan and Misumalpan. However, since the analysis was automatically generated, the grouping could be either due to mutual lexical borrowing or genetic inheritance.

Reconstruction

Phylogenetic tree for Macro-Chibchan (Lenmichian) languages. Arbol Lenmichi 1.png
Phylogenetic tree for Macro-Chibchan (Lenmichian) languages.

Constenla (2005) reconstructed five vowels and eleven consonants for Proto-Lenmichian, with the following reflexes:

Vowels

Proto-Lenmichian*a*e*i*o*u
Proto-Chibchan*a*e*i*o*u
Proto-Lencan*a *e*e*i*o *u*u
Proto-Misumalpan*a*i*i*u*u

There are also a series[ clarification needed ] of nasal vowels.

Consonants

Proto-Lenmichian*b*d*t*k*ts*s*h*l*w
Proto-Chibchan*b*d*t*k*ts*s*h
Proto-Lencan*p
*m
*l
*n
*t*k*ts'*l*w
Proto-Misumalpan*b
*p
*m
*d
*n
*t*k*s*l*w

Vocabulary

Below is a comparison of selected basic vocabulary items. [2]

gloss Xinca (Guazacapán) [3] Lenca (Chilanga) [4] Proto-Lencan [5] Proto-Misumalpan [6] Proto-Chibchan [7]
headhúš̱ioso
hairmútialah*asak*ʦa
eyehurayísap*uᵐba
earmánkatokoro*tupal
nosenarínepkuru*nep*nam*ⁿdii(k)
toothrajáj (Chiquimulilla) [8] neh*nek*ⁿduʔ
tongueelahánepal*tu*kuʔ(-Ba)
mouthš̱aháiɴ-ts’ats’a*in*ta*kah-ka
handpukoʃaka*kuuʔ; *haⁿd- ~ *hat-
footwapilíwaʃaka*kihʦa ~ *kihsa
breastšékets’ukiɴ 'nipple'*kãʔ; *ʦuʔ
meatuwíwaʃa*ᵑgaʔⁿda ~ *ᵑgaʔta; *sih
bloodkámaala*a*hapi ~ *apiʔ
bonehararíʃila-ts’e*ts’ek*kãⁿd-, *ⁿdaⁿdi ~ *ⁿdaiⁿd- / *saⁿdi ~ *saiⁿd-
personšurúmu, hurákɨiʃko*ᵐbaⁿdi ~ *ᵐbaiⁿd
nameš̱a*haka ~ *akaʔ
dogčúčo (Chiquimulilla) [9] ʃuʃu*su*tau
fishsémaʃok’ín*ᵑgwa ~ *uᵑg
lousetɨmáƚitem*tem*kũʔ
treehútusuɴ*ban*ˈkàr; *kaˈri (C)
leafpíyaaw*ka
flowertúƚuʃila*sula
wateruy*was*li*ⁿdiʔ
fireuráyik’aɴ*juk’a*ᵑgi 'firewood'
stonehíš̱ike*ke*walpa*hak ~ *kaʔ
earthnáruomoɴ*taB(a)
salttíʔlats’epe*ⁿdaᵑg
roadtáƚmak’iɴ*k’in*hi
eatrúkarom-*kuⁿdi ~ *kuiⁿd
dieteróʃil-
Ininunani*unani*jam*ⁿdaH(ⁿd)
younákamanani*amanani*man*ᵐbaʔ

References

  1. Müller, André, Viveka Velupillai, Søren Wichmann, Cecil H. Brown, Eric W. Holman, Sebastian Sauppe, Pamela Brown, Harald Hammarström, Oleg Belyaev, Johann-Mattis List, Dik Bakker, Dmitri Egorov, Matthias Urban, Robert Mailhammer, Matthew S. Dryer, Evgenia Korovina, David Beck, Helen Geyer, Pattie Epps, Anthony Grant, and Pilar Valenzuela. 2013. ASJP World Language Trees of Lexical Similarity: Version 4 (October 2013) .
  2. Constenla Umaña, Adolfo (1987). "Elementos de Fonología Comparada de las Lenguas Misumalpas," Revista de Filología y Lingüística de la Universidad de Costa Rica 13 (1), 129-161.
  3. Schumann Galvez, Otto. 1966. Fonemica del dialecto xinca de Chiquimulilla. In Antonio Pompa y Pompa (ed.), Summa antropológica de homenaje a Roberto J. Weitlaner, 449-454. Mexico: Instituto Nacional de Antropología e Historia (INAH).
  4. del Río Urrutia, Ximena. 2004. El lenca de Chilanga: Léxico. Revista de Filología y Lingüística XXX. 289-313.
  5. Arguedas Cortés, Gilda Rosa. 1988. Los Fonemas Segmentales del Protolenca: Reconstrucción Comparativa. Filología y lingüística XIV. 89-109.
  6. Constenla Umaña, Adolfo (1987). "Elementos de Fonología Comparada de las Lenguas Misumalpas," Revista de Filología y Lingüística de la Universidad de Costa Rica 13 (1), 129-161.
  7. Pache, Matthias J. 2018. Contributions to Chibchan Historical Linguistics . Doctoral dissertation, Universiteit Leiden.
  8. McArthur, Harry S. 1966. Xinca [word list]. In Marvin K. Mayers (ed.), Languages of Guatemala, 309-312. 23: Janua Linguarum, series practica.
  9. Schumann Galvez, Otto. 1967. Xinca de Guazacapán. (MA thesis, Universidad Nacional Autónoma de México; 140pp.)