| Recipient | Notability | References |
|---|
| Robert Baden-Powell | Lieutenant-general in the British Army, writer and founder of the Scout Movement | [a] |
| Unknown Scout | Unknown member of the British Boy Scout Association who inspired W. D. Boyce to form the BSA | [a] |
| William D. Boyce | Publisher and entrepreneur, founder of the BSA and the Lone Scouts of America | [a] |
| Colin H. Livingstone | Financier, first president of the BSA | [a] |
| James J. Storrow | Investment banker instrumental in forming General Motors, third president of GM and second president of the BSA (posthumous award) | [a] |
| Daniel Carter Beard | Illustrator, author, social reformer, founding pioneer of the BSA and the first National Commissioner | [a] |
| Ernest Thompson Seton | Noted author, wildlife artist, founder of the Woodcraft Indians, founding pioneer of the BSA and first Chief Scout; heavily influenced Baden-Powell in his formation of Scouting | [a] |
| Edgar M. Robinson | Senior secretary in the YMCA, co-founder of the BSA | [a] |
| Lee F. Hanmer | Member of the Russell Sage Foundation, secretary of the BSA Committee of Organization | [a] [1] |
| George Wood Wingate | U.S. Army General, lawyer, and 25-year president of the National Rifle Association | [a] |
| Joseph Lee | Volunteer social worker, author, and president of the Playground and Recreation Association; father of the playground idea | [a] [2] [3] |
| Howard S. Braucher | Social worker, chair of the first committee on organization for the BSA, and Secretary of the Playground and Recreation Association | [a] [2] |
| Mortimer L. Schiff | Banker, philanthropist, vice-president of the BSA, member of the World Scout Committee, recipient of the Bronze Wolf, later president of the BSA | [a] |
| Milton A. McRae | Publisher, co-founder of the Scripps-McRae League of newspapers, later the third president of the BSA | [a] |
| Frank Presbrey | Author, editor, and dean of advertising; charter member of BSA executive board and chair of committee on Boys' Life | [a] [2] |
| George Dupont Pratt | Advocate of forest conservation and wildlife protection; charter member of BSA executive board, chair of camping committee, and vice-chair of national court of honor | [a] [2] |
| John Sherman Hoyt | Manufacturer, vice chair of war work council YMCA; charter member of BSA executive board and chair of finance committee | [a] [2] |
| Jeremiah Jenks | Political economist, educator, and author; charter member of BSA executive board and chair of educational committee; formulated the Scout oath and law | [a] [2] |
| William D. Murray | Lawyer, author and member of the YMCA boys' work committee; charter member of BSA executive board and chair of editorial board | [a] [2] |
| G. Barrett Rich | Charter member of BSA executive board and chair of the national committee on badges, awards, and Scout requirements | [a] [2] |
| James E. West | Lawyer, advocate of children's rights, first professional Chief Scout Executive of the BSA | [a] |
| George J. Fisher | Physician, leader in the fields of youth development and physical fitness with the YMCA, early proponent of volleyball, deputy Chief Scout Executive and national Scout commissioner | [a] |