National Register of Historic Places listings in Yates County, New York

Location of Yates County in New York

List of the National Register of Historic Places listings in Yates County, New York

This is intended to be a complete list of properties and districts listed on the National Register of Historic Places in Yates County, New York. The locations of National Register properties and districts (at least for all showing latitude and longitude coordinates below) may be seen in a map by clicking on "Map of all coordinates". ^[1]

      This National Park Service list is complete through NPS recent listings posted February 28, 2025. ^[2]

Contents: Counties in New York

Albany (Albany) – Allegany – Bronx – Broome – Cattaraugus – Cayuga – Chautauqua – Chemung – Chenango – Clinton – Columbia – Cortland – Delaware – Dutchess (Poughkeepsie, Rhinebeck) – Erie (Buffalo) – Essex – Franklin – Fulton – Genesee – Greene – Hamilton – Herkimer – Jefferson – Kings – Lewis – Livingston – Madison – Monroe (Rochester) – Montgomery – Nassau – New York (Below 14th Street, 14th to 59th Streets, 59th to 110th Streets, Above 110th Street, Islands) – Niagara (Niagara Falls) – Oneida – Onondaga (Syracuse) – Ontario – Orange – Orleans – Oswego – Otsego – Putnam – Queens – Rensselaer – Richmond – Rockland – St. Lawrence – Saratoga – Schenectady – Schoharie – Schuyler – Seneca – Steuben – Suffolk – Sullivan – Tioga – Tompkins – Ulster – Warren – Washington – Wayne – Westchester (Northern, Southern, New Rochelle, Peekskill, Yonkers) – Wyoming – Yates

Listings county-wide

[3]	Name on the Register	Image	Date listed [4]	Location	City or town	Description
1	Angus Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex		May 11, 1992 (#92000439)	612 NY 14 42°44′03″N76°58′29″W / 42.734167°N 76.974722°W / 42.734167; -76.974722 (Angus Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex)	Benton
2	Jonathan Bailey House		August 24, 1994 (#94000926)	Bath Rd. 42°35′22″N77°03′34″W / 42.589444°N 77.059444°W / 42.589444; -77.059444 (Jonathan Bailey House)	Milo
3	Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse	Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse More images	May 11, 1992 (#92000435)	2492 Ferguson Corners Rd. 42°45′16″N77°04′26″W / 42.754444°N 77.073889°W / 42.754444; -77.073889 (Barden Cobblestone Farmhouse)	Benton
4	Bates Cobblestone Farmhouse	Bates Cobblestone Farmhouse More images	May 11, 1992 (#92000436)	5521 NY 364 42°45′34″N77°16′25″W / 42.759444°N 77.273611°W / 42.759444; -77.273611 (Bates Cobblestone Farmhouse)	Middlesex
5	Beddoe–Rose Family Cemetery		November 19, 2014 (#14000939)	E. of W. Bluff Dr., Keuka Lake State Park 42°34′57″N77°07′55″W / 42.58249341284871°N 77.13193645908692°W / 42.58249341284871; -77.13193645908692 (Beddoe–Rose Family Cemetery)	Jerusalem	Grave sites of family involved in early settlement of area
6	Peter Bitley House		August 24, 1994 (#94000927)	W. Lake Rd. (NY Rt. 54A) 42°35′32″N77°09′11″W / 42.592222°N 77.153056°W / 42.592222; -77.153056 (Peter Bitley House)	Jerusalem
7	Thomas Bitley House		August 24, 1994 (#94000928)	Lake St. 42°35′33″N77°09′10″W / 42.5925°N 77.152778°W / 42.5925; -77.152778 (Thomas Bitley House)	Jerusalem
8	Samuel Botsford House		August 24, 1994 (#94000929)	County House Rd. 42°37′46″N77°09′41″W / 42.629444°N 77.161389°W / 42.629444; -77.161389 (Samuel Botsford House)	Jerusalem
9	John Briggs House		August 24, 1994 (#94000930)	2646 Himrod Rd. 42°38′07″N77°00′01″W / 42.635278°N 77.000278°W / 42.635278; -77.000278 (John Briggs House)	Milo Center
10	John Carr House		August 24, 1994 (#94000931)	NY 245 42°41′46″N77°16′40″W / 42.696111°N 77.277778°W / 42.696111; -77.277778 (John Carr House)	Middlesex
11	Crooked Lake Outlet Historic District	Crooked Lake Outlet Historic District More images	January 19, 1996 (#95001545)	Along the Keuka Lake Outlet Trail, from Penn Yan to Dresden 42°40′37″N76°57′49″W / 42.676944°N 76.963611°W / 42.676944; -76.963611 (Crooked Lake Outlet Historic District)	Penn Yan
12	Thomas Bennett Curtis House		August 24, 1994 (#94000932)	Shannon Corners Rd. 42°33′00″N76°55′53″W / 42.55°N 76.931389°W / 42.55; -76.931389 (Thomas Bennett Curtis House)	Starkey
13	Dundee Methodist Church	Dundee Methodist Church	January 5, 2005 (#04001445)	33 Water St. 42°31′35″N76°58′36″W / 42.526389°N 76.976667°W / 42.526389; -76.976667 (Dundee Methodist Church)	Dundee
14	Dundee Village Historic District	Dundee Village Historic District	April 10, 2007 (#07000329)	Main, Water, and Seneca Sts. 42°31′24″N76°58′37″W / 42.523386°N 76.976872°W / 42.523386; -76.976872 (Dundee Village Historic District)	Dundee
15	Jephtha Earl Cobblestone Farmhouse	Jephtha Earl Cobblestone Farmhouse	May 11, 1992 (#92000438)	Old State Rd. N of jct. with Johnson Rd. 42°45′27″N76°58′42″W / 42.7575°N 76.978333°W / 42.7575; -76.978333 (Jephtha Earl Cobblestone Farmhouse)	Benton
16	Esperanza	Esperanza	December 7, 1995 (#95001406)	NY 54A E of Keuka Lake 42°35′45″N77°08′06″W / 42.595833°N 77.135°W / 42.595833; -77.135 (Esperanza)	Jerusalem
17	First Presbyterian Church	First Presbyterian Church	September 24, 2004 (#04001058)	31 Main St. 42°31′28″N76°58′37″W / 42.524444°N 76.976944°W / 42.524444; -76.976944 (First Presbyterian Church)	Dundee
18	James Fox House		August 24, 1994 (#94000934)	750 Italy Valley Rd. 42°36′22″N77°17′54″W / 42.606111°N 77.298333°W / 42.606111; -77.298333 (James Fox House)	Italy
19	Garrett Memorial Chapel	Garrett Memorial Chapel	March 30, 2001 (#01000296)	Skyline Dr. 42°30′27″N77°07′54″W / 42.5075°N 77.131667°W / 42.5075; -77.131667 (Garrett Memorial Chapel)	Jerusalem	Norman Gothic chapel with scenic views of Keuka Lake
20	Asahel Green Farm		August 24, 1994 (#94000935)	S. Vine Valley Rd. 42°43′40″N77°18′00″W / 42.727778°N 77.3°W / 42.727778; -77.3 (Asahel Green Farm)	Middlesex
21	Uriah Hair House		August 24, 1994 (#94000936)	Water St. (Dundee-Himrod Rd.) 42°31′52″N76°58′32″W / 42.531111°N 76.975556°W / 42.531111; -76.975556 (Uriah Hair House)	Dundee
22	Hampstead		August 24, 1994 (#94000937)	3170 NY Rt. 54A 42°36′14″N77°06′48″W / 42.603889°N 77.113333°W / 42.603889; -77.113333 (Hampstead)	Jerusalem
23	Uriah Hanford House		August 24, 1994 (#94000938)	W. Lake Rd. 42°39′12″N77°04′35″W / 42.653333°N 77.076389°W / 42.653333; -77.076389 (Uriah Hanford House)	Jerusalem
24	George Hays House		August 24, 1994 (#94000939)	County House Rd. 42°40′01″N77°04′26″W / 42.666944°N 77.073889°W / 42.666944; -77.073889 (George Hays House)	Jerusalem
25	Himrod Baptist Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000940)	Himrod Rd. 42°35′22″N76°57′17″W / 42.589444°N 76.954722°W / 42.589444; -76.954722 (Himrod Baptist Church)	Milo
26	James Hobart House		August 24, 1994 (#94000941)	4646 Italy Valley Rd. 42°41′39″N77°12′47″W / 42.694167°N 77.213056°W / 42.694167; -77.213056 (James Hobart House)	Potter
27	Robert Ingersoll Birthplace	Robert Ingersoll Birthplace More images	February 11, 1988 (#88000110)	Main St. 42°41′02″N76°57′23″W / 42.683889°N 76.956389°W / 42.683889; -76.956389 (Robert Ingersoll Birthplace)	Dresden
28	Italy Valley Methodist Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000942)	Italy Valley Rd. 42°36′39″N77°17′32″W / 42.610833°N 77.292222°W / 42.610833; -77.292222 (Italy Valley Methodist Church)	Italy
29	Lake View Cemetery	Lake View Cemetery More images	February 23, 1996 (#96000137)	W. Lake Rd. 42°39′41″N77°03′51″W / 42.661389°N 77.064167°W / 42.661389; -77.064167 (Lake View Cemetery)	Penn Yan
30	Larzelere Tavern		December 19, 1997 (#97001525)	3858 County House Rd. 42°37′36″N77°09′45″W / 42.626667°N 77.1625°W / 42.626667; -77.1625 (Larzelere Tavern)	Branchport
31	Smith McLoud House		August 22, 1994 (#94000944)	Italy Tpk. 42°36′06″N77°15′51″W / 42.601667°N 77.264167°W / 42.601667; -77.264167 (Smith McLoud House)	Italy
32	Middlesex Center Methodist Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000945)	Main St. 42°42′26″N77°16′12″W / 42.707222°N 77.27°W / 42.707222; -77.27 (Middlesex Center Methodist Church)	Middlesex
33	Roderick M. Morrison House	Roderick M. Morrison House	August 24, 1994 (#94000946)	105 Highland Dr. 42°39′52″N77°03′49″W / 42.664444°N 77.063611°W / 42.664444; -77.063611 (Roderick M. Morrison House)	Penn Yan
34	William Nichols Cobblestone Farmhouse	William Nichols Cobblestone Farmhouse	May 11, 1992 (#92000437)	Alexander Rd. W of jct. with Thistle St. Rd. 42°45′33″N77°02′21″W / 42.759167°N 77.039167°W / 42.759167; -77.039167 (William Nichols Cobblestone Farmhouse)	Benton
35	John Noyes House		August 24, 1994 (#94000947)	Lakemont-Himrod Rd. 42°31′19″N76°55′33″W / 42.521944°N 76.925833°W / 42.521944; -76.925833 (John Noyes House)	Starkey
36	Overackers Corners Schoolhouse	Overackers Corners Schoolhouse More images	August 24, 1994 (#94000948)	Vine Valley Rd. 42°44′21″N77°16′49″W / 42.739167°N 77.280278°W / 42.739167; -77.280278 (Overackers Corners Schoolhouse)	Middlesex
37	Penn Yan Historic District	Penn Yan Historic District More images	March 14, 1985 (#85000591)	Roughly bounded by Water, Seneca, Elm, Wagener, Court, Clinton, North and Main Sts. 42°39′49″N77°03′08″W / 42.663611°N 77.052222°W / 42.663611; -77.052222 (Penn Yan Historic District)	Penn Yan
38	Ezikial Perry House		August 24, 1994 (#94000949)	287 Sherman Hollow Rd. 42°40′01″N77°05′57″W / 42.666944°N 77.099167°W / 42.666944; -77.099167 (Ezikial Perry House)	Jerusalem
39	Arnold Potter House		August 24, 1994 (#94000950)	1445 Voak Rd. 42°41′22″N77°07′44″W / 42.689444°N 77.128889°W / 42.689444; -77.128889 (Arnold Potter House)	Potter
40	Miles Raplee House		August 24, 1994 (#94000951)	Randall Rd. 42°37′03″N76°55′25″W / 42.6175°N 76.923611°W / 42.6175; -76.923611 (Miles Raplee House)	Milo
41	Sampson Theatre	Sampson Theatre More images	November 7, 2008 (#08001035)	130-136 E. Elm St. 42°39′41″N77°03′08″W / 42.661511°N 77.052258°W / 42.661511; -77.052258 (Sampson Theatre)	Penn Yan	New listing; refnum# 08001035
42	Sill Tenant House		August 24, 1994 (#94000952)	3232 Co. Rt. 54 42°36′08″N77°07′18″W / 42.602222°N 77.121667°W / 42.602222; -77.121667 (Sill Tenant House)	Jerusalem
43	Dr. Henry Spence Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex	Dr. Henry Spence Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex	May 11, 1992 (#92000441)	Lakemont-Himrod Rd. N of jct. with Shannon Corners Rd. 42°33′21″N76°56′48″W / 42.555833°N 76.946667°W / 42.555833; -76.946667 (Dr. Henry Spence Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex)	Starkey
44	Spicer-Millard House		August 24, 1994 (#94000953)	Crystal Springs Rd. (NY 230) 42°30′03″N77°02′43″W / 42.500833°N 77.045278°W / 42.500833; -77.045278 (Spicer-Millard House)	Barrington
45	St. Luke's Episcopal Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000954)	W. Lake Rd. (Co. Rt. 54A) 42°35′48″N77°09′11″W / 42.596667°N 77.153056°W / 42.596667; -77.153056 (St. Luke's Episcopal Church)	Jerusalem
46	Starkey United Methodist Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000955)	Lakemont-Himrod Rd. 42°32′11″N76°56′04″W / 42.536389°N 76.934444°W / 42.536389; -76.934444 (Starkey United Methodist Church)	Starkey
47	Daniel Supplee Cobblestone Farmhouse		May 11, 1992 (#92000442)	4420 Dundee-Himrod Rd. 42°33′04″N76°58′22″W / 42.551111°N 76.972778°W / 42.551111; -76.972778 (Daniel Supplee Cobblestone Farmhouse)	Starkey
48	William Swarthout Farm		August 24, 1994 (#94000956)	Bath Rd. 42°38′03″N77°03′35″W / 42.634167°N 77.059722°W / 42.634167; -77.059722 (William Swarthout Farm)	Milo
49	William Swortz House		August 24, 1994 (#94000957)	Dundee-Himrod Rd. 42°32′53″N76°58′24″W / 42.548056°N 76.973333°W / 42.548056; -76.973333 (William Swortz House)	Starkey
50	US Post Office-Penn Yan	US Post Office-Penn Yan More images	May 11, 1989 (#88002403)	159 Main St. 42°39′44″N77°03′16″W / 42.662222°N 77.054444°W / 42.662222; -77.054444 (US Post Office-Penn Yan)	Penn Yan
51	Vine Valley Methodist Church		August 24, 1994 (#94000958)	Robeson Rd. 42°43′26″N77°19′29″W / 42.723889°N 77.324722°W / 42.723889; -77.324722 (Vine Valley Methodist Church)	Middlesex
52	Abraham Wagener House	Abraham Wagener House	August 24, 1994 (#94000959)	Skyline Rd. 42°30′36″N77°08′15″W / 42.51°N 77.1375°W / 42.51; -77.1375 (Abraham Wagener House)	Jerusalem
53	Charles Wagener House	Charles Wagener House	August 24, 1994 (#94000960)	351 Elm St. 42°39′39″N77°03′46″W / 42.660833°N 77.062778°W / 42.660833; -77.062778 (Charles Wagener House)	Penn Yan
54	H. Allen Wagener House		August 24, 1994 (#94000961)	367 W. Lake Rd. 42°37′35″N77°05′33″W / 42.626389°N 77.0925°W / 42.626389; -77.0925 (H. Allen Wagener House)	Jerusalem
55	Myron Weaver House		August 24, 1994 (#94000962)	21 S. Main St. 42°35′39″N77°09′17″W / 42.594167°N 77.154722°W / 42.594167; -77.154722 (Myron Weaver House)	Branchport
56	Solomon Weaver House		August 24, 1994 (#94000963)	7 S. Main St. 42°35′53″N77°09′22″W / 42.598056°N 77.156111°W / 42.598056; -77.156111 (Solomon Weaver House)	Branchport
57	Whitaker House		August 24, 1994 (#94000964)	Benton-Torrey Town Line Rd. 42°42′16″N77°01′03″W / 42.704444°N 77.0175°W / 42.704444; -77.0175 (Whitaker House)	Benton
58	Jemima Wilkinson House (Friend's Home)	Jemima Wilkinson House (Friend's Home)	August 24, 1994 (#94000965)	3912 Friend Hill Rd. 42°39′12″N77°09′54″W / 42.653333°N 77.165°W / 42.653333; -77.165 (Jemima Wilkinson House (Friend's Home))	Jerusalem
59	Sherman Williams House and Fruit Barn		August 24, 1994 (#94000966)	Co. Rt. 54A 42°37′22″N77°05′48″W / 42.622778°N 77.096667°W / 42.622778; -77.096667 (Sherman Williams House and Fruit Barn)	Jerusalem
60	Christopher Willis House	Christopher Willis House More images	August 24, 1994 (#94000967)	57 Seneca St. 42°41′05″N76°57′03″W / 42.684722°N 76.950833°W / 42.684722; -76.950833 (Christopher Willis House)	Dresden
61	Milton Wilson House		August 24, 1994 (#94000968)	28 Gilbert St. 42°45′37″N77°13′47″W / 42.760278°N 77.229722°W / 42.760278; -77.229722 (Milton Wilson House)	Rushville
62	Abner Woodworth House		August 24, 1994 (#94000969)	Flat St. 42°41′30″N77°03′14″W / 42.691667°N 77.053889°W / 42.691667; -77.053889 (Abner Woodworth House)	Benton
63	Dr. James Wrightman House		August 24, 1994 (#94000970)	48 W. Lake Rd. 42°35′28″N77°09′04″W / 42.591111°N 77.151111°W / 42.591111; -77.151111 (Dr. James Wrightman House)	Branchport
64	Yates County Courthouse Park District	Yates County Courthouse Park District More images	June 19, 1979 (#79001652)	Main, Court and Liberty Sts. 42°39′54″N77°03′28″W / 42.665°N 77.057778°W / 42.665; -77.057778 (Yates County Courthouse Park District)	Penn Yan
65	Yatesville Methodist Church		August 25, 1994 (#94000971)	Yatesville Rd. 42°40′18″N77°08′16″W / 42.671667°N 77.137778°W / 42.671667; -77.137778 (Yatesville Methodist Church)	Potter
66	Young-Leach Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex		May 11, 1992 (#92000440)	2601 NY 14 42°38′16″N76°56′21″W / 42.637778°N 76.939167°W / 42.637778; -76.939167 (Young-Leach Cobblestone Farmhouse and Barn Complex)	Torrey

See also

• National Register of Historic Places listings in New York

References

1. The latitude and longitude information provided in this table was derived originally from the National Register Information System, which has been found to be fairly accurate for about 99% of listings. Some locations in this table may have been corrected to current GPS standards.
2. National Park Service, United States Department of the Interior, "National Register of Historic Places: Weekly List Actions", retrieved February 28, 2025.
3. Numbers represent an alphabetical ordering by significant words. Various colorings, defined here, differentiate National Historic Landmarks and historic districts from other NRHP buildings, structures, sites or objects.
4. The eight-digit number below each date is the number assigned to each location in the National Register Information System database, which can be viewed by clicking the number.