Rose symbolism

Last updated
Hans Simon Holtzbecker: Rosa gallica, gouache, c. 1650 (Statens Museum for Kunst, Copenhagen).
The vivid red, semi-double Rosa gallica was "the ancestor of all the roses of medieval Europe". Johannes Simon Holtzbecher - Rosa gallica - Google Art Project.jpg
Hans Simon Holtzbecker: Rosa gallica, gouache, c.1650 (Statens Museum for Kunst, Copenhagen).
The vivid red, semi-double Rosa gallica was "the ancestor of all the roses of medieval Europe".

Various folk cultures and traditions assign symbolic meaning to the rose, though these are seldom understood in-depth. Examples of deeper meanings lie within the language of flowers, and how a rose may have a different meaning in arrangements. Examples of common meanings of different coloured roses are: true love (red), mystery (blue), innocence or purity (white), death (black), friendship (yellow), and passion (orange).

Contents

In religion

Greco-Roman religion

Venus Verticordia (1868) by Dante Gabriel Rossetti, showing the goddess Aphrodite surrounded by red roses Dante Gabriel Rossetti - Venus Verticordia.jpg
Venus Verticordia (1868) by Dante Gabriel Rossetti, showing the goddess Aphrodite surrounded by red roses

In ancient Greece, the rose was closely associated with the goddess Aphrodite. [2] [3] In the Iliad , Aphrodite protects the body of Hector using the "immortal oil of the rose" [4] [2] and the archaic Greek lyric poet Ibycus praises a beautiful youth saying that Aphrodite nursed him "among rose blossoms". [5] The second-century AD Greek travel writer Pausanias associates the rose with the story of Adonis [6] Book Eleven of the ancient Roman novel The Golden Ass by Apuleius contains a scene in which the goddess Isis, who is identified with Venus, instructs the main character, Lucius, who has been transformed into a donkey, to eat rose petals from a crown of roses worn by a priest as part of a religious procession in order to regain his humanity. [3]

Judaism

In the Song of Songs 2:1-2, the Jewish people are compared with a rose, remaining beautiful amongst thorns, [7] although some translations instead refer to a "lily among thorns." [8] The Zohar uses a "thirteen-petalled rose" as a symbol for the thirteen attributes of Divine Mercy [7] named in Exodus 34:6-7. [9] The rose and rosettes were also used to symbolize royalty and Israel, [10] and were used in wreaths for the bridegroom at weddings in Biblical times. [11]

Christianity

Following the Christianization of the Roman Empire, the rose became identified with the Virgin Mary. [12] [3] The rose symbol eventually led to the creation of the rosary and other devotional prayers in Christianity. [13] [3] Ever since the 1400s, the Franciscans have had a Crown Rosary of the Seven Joys of the Blessed Virgin Mary. [3] In the 1400s and 1500s, the Carthusians promoted the idea of sacred mysteries associated with the rose symbol and rose gardens. [3] Albrecht Dürer's painting The Feast of the Rosary (1506) depicts the Virgin Mary distributing garlands of roses to her worshippers. [3]

Islam

The cultivation of geometrical gardens, in which the rose has often held pride of place, has a long history in Iran and surrounding lands. [14] [15] In the lyric ghazal, it is the beauty of the rose that provokes the longing song of the nightingale [16] – an image prominent, for example, in the poems of Hafez. [17]

In turn, the imagery of lover and beloved became a type of the Sufi mystic's quest for divine love, so that Ibn Arabi, for example, aligns the rose with the beloved's blushing cheek on the one hand and, on the other, with the divine names and attributes. [18]

Other well-known examples of rose symbolism in Sufism include:

In Europe

England

The Tudor rose Tudor Rose.svg
The Tudor rose
The rose as a heraldic symbol: the coat of arms of Ruzomberok in Slovakia. The town's name in literal translation is "Hill of roses". Coat of Arms of Ruzomberok.svg
The rose as a heraldic symbol: the coat of arms of Ružomberok in Slovakia. The town's name in literal translation is "Hill of roses".

The rose is the national flower of England, a usage dating back to the English civil wars of the fifteenth century (later called Wars of the Roses), in which a red rose represented the House of Lancaster, and a white rose represented the House of York. [19] The Tudor dynasty created the Tudor rose, which united both the white and the red roses, a symbolism dramatized by Shakespeare in his play Richard III . [20] [21] The traditional ballad "The Rose of England" (Child 166) recounts the seizure of the crown by Earl of Richmond (who became Henry VII of England, the founder of the Tudor dynasty), using the "red rose" as an allegory for Henry. [22]

The England national rugby union team and Rugby Football Union adopted the red rose as their symbol in 1871, and the rose has appeared on players' kit ever since. [23]

The red rose is the symbol for the UK Labour Party. [24]

Spain

Selling roses on St George's Day in Catalonia, Spain Santjordi.jpg
Selling roses on St George's Day in Catalonia, Spain

Catalans in the north eastern of Spain have traditionally celebrated Saint George's Day (April 23) – which commemorates Saint George (Sant Jordi), the patron saint of the Catalonia region; as the dia dels enamorats ("lovers' day"), on which lovers exchange blood-red roses. [25]

In North America

United States

In 1986, the rose was adopted as the national floral emblem of the United States. [26] [27]

It is the state flower of five U.S. states and the District of Columbia.

Portland, Oregon has counted "City of Roses" among its nicknames (see roses in Portland, Oregon) since 1888, [32] and has held an annual Rose Festival since 1905. [33] The city is also known for its International Rose Test Garden. [32]

Pasadena, California  – also nicknamed the "City of Roses" – has held the annual Tournament of Roses Parade since 1890, and 1902 the Parade has been held in conjunction with the Rose Bowl Game (which is now played at the city's Rose Bowl stadium, built in 1922). [34] [35]

In April 2011, the U.S. government's space program agency, the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA), celebrated the Hubble Space Telescope's 21st anniversary by releasing an image of spiral galaxies Arp 273 positioned in a rose-like shape. [36]

The red rose is also part of the official logo of the Democratic Socialists of America (DSA), [37] being a symbol of socialism generally. [38]

Canada

In 1930, Rosa acicularis (the wild rose or prickly rose) was adopted as the official provincial flower of the Canadian province of Alberta. The suggestion that a provincial floral emblem be adopted by first made by an Edmonton newspaper editor; "the Women's Institutes took up the suggestion and passed it on to the Department of Education, and the province's schoolchildren made the final choice." [39] [40]

The Wildrose Party, a now-defunct Albertan political party, was named after the province's official flower. [41]

Mexico

The Mexican city of Guadalajara, the capital of Jalisco, is nicknamed the "City of Roses" (Ciudad de las Rosas). [42] [43]

Socialism

Emblem for "The World Order of Socialists" with a red rose, substituting the shield of arms, containing a handshake stretching a rationally devised globe under a rising sun, designed by Walter Crane, c. 1915 Walter Crane emblem for The World Order of Socialists.jpg
Emblem for "The World Order of Socialists" with a red rose, substituting the shield of arms, containing a handshake stretching a rationally devised globe under a rising sun, designed by Walter Crane, c.1915
The original version of the fist and rose emblem drawn in 1969 in the French Socialist Party. Logo du Parti socialiste belge (1945-1978).png
The original version of the fist and rose emblem drawn in 1969 in the French Socialist Party.

Since the 1880s, the red rose has been a symbol of socialism. [44] [45] The origin of the rose as a symbol of socialism relates to its association with the color red. Since at least 1848, red was associated with socialism. [46] Following the French Revolution of 1848, the socialists pushed to have the revolution's red flag be designated the national flag. [47] The republicans, however, prevailed and the French tricolor flag remained the national flag. The provisional government as a compromise decreed that: "As a sign of rallying and as a remembrance of recognition for the last act of the popular revolution, members of the provisional government and other authorities will wear the red rosette, which will also be placed at the flagstaff." [48]

During the Paris Commune in 1871, the red flag solidified its link with socialism when it flew as the flag of the Communards' short-lived government. [49] Following the collapse of the Paris Commune, German Chancellor Bismarck out of fear of the growing strength of the socialists in Germany had parliament pass the Anti-Socialist laws to suppress the activities of the Social Democratic Party. As part of the Anti-Socialist laws in 1878, the display of emblems of the Social Democratic Party were banned. To circumvent the law, social democrats wore red bits of ribbons in their buttonholes. These actions, however, led to arrest and jail sentences. Subsequently, red rosebuds were substituted by social democrats. These actions also led to arrest and jail sentences. The judge ruled that in general everyone has a right to wear any flower as suits their taste, but when socialists as a group wear red rosebuds, it becomes a party emblem. [44]

Due to the Anti-Socialist laws, which banned social democratic activities, hundreds of socialists were fined, imprisoned, or exiled from Germany. [50] Subsequently, the German exiles spread the red rose symbol of socialism across Europe and to the United States. The socialist Johann Most was one of these German socialist exiles, who first went to England, and then later went to the United States and carried the red rosebud symbol with him. The red rosebud was worn in his lapel in 1887 during speeches he gave in support of the eight individuals convicted in the Haymarket Affair in a sign of socialist solidarity. [45] Similarly, the wearing of a red flower, such as a red carnation or red rose, became common during the commemoration ceremonies in France at the Communards' Wall which remembered the victims of the collapse of the Paris Commune. [51] By the 1910s, the red rose was universally identified as a symbol of the socialist movement. [52] [53]

The Tamiment Library and Robert F. Wagner Archives at New York University states that the rose "has always been an important symbol with anti-authoritarian associations." [54] The rose is used to show the end after the means, meaning "lay a rose on the grave". The rose symbol became popular as a political logo among socialist and social democratic political parties in post-World War II Western Europe. [54] The fist and rose, in which the rose is held by a clenched fist, is used by the Socialist International "and many of its member parties". [55] The French Socialist Party (PS) was the first party to adopt it in 1971, using imagery popular with left-wing movements of the era. [56] Centre-leaning and moderate parties tend to use a red rose alone, doing away with the revolutionary heritage of the raised fist. [57] The British Labour Party has used a red rose as its symbol since the late 1980s; the rose replaced the party's previous symbol, the red flag. [58] [59]

Allegorically in literature

The rose in an allegorical sense appears many times in literature. In William Blake's poem "The Sick Rose" the rose is a symbol for love or passion, it is crimson and dark but now sick, the worm has infected it. The rose in the popular 13th-century French poem "Romance of the Rose" is a personification of the woman, the object of the lover's attentions, and his plucking of the rose represents his conquest of her. In the title of William Faulkner's short story "A Rose for Emily" the rose has a number of possible meanings: as Emily's lover now dried and preserved, or a secret as per sub rosa. In a postscript to The Name of the Rose , Umberto Eco discusses the reason behind the title to his 1983 novel: "because the rose is a symbolic figure so rich in meanings that by now it hardly has any meaning left".

Relationships

A red rose is a gift primarily given to a love interest, symbolizing a marital or romantic relationship. Wedding bouquets often include white roses, symbolizing virtue. Red is traditionally seen as a symbol of passion, while white is a symbol of purity and innocence.

Other

Monument to the "Weisse Rose". Scholl-Denkmal, Munchen.jpg
Monument to the "Weiße Rose".

The "White Rose" (German die Weiße Rose) was a World War II non-violent intellectual resistance group in the Third Reich led by a group of students and a professor at the University of Munich. The group conducted an anonymous leaflet and graffiti campaign that called for active opposition to the Nazi party regime. Their activities started in Munich on 27 June 1942, and ended with the arrest of the core group by the Gestapo on 18 February 1943.

Under Gestapo interrogation, Hans Scholl gave several explanations for the origin of the name "The White Rose," and suggested he may have chosen it while he was under the emotional influence of a 19th-century poem with the same name by German poet Clemens Brentano. It was also speculated that the name might have been taken from either the Cuban poet, Jose Marti's verse "Cultivo una rosa blanca" or a German novel Die Weiße Rose ( The White Rose ), written by B. Traven, the German author of The Treasure of the Sierra Madre . Hans Scholl and Alex Schmorell had read this novel. They also wrote that the symbol of the white rose was intended to represent purity and innocence in the face of evil. [60]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Rose</span> Genus of plants

A rose is either a woody perennial flowering plant of the genus Rosa, in the family Rosaceae, or the flower it bears. There are over three hundred species and tens of thousands of cultivars. They form a group of plants that can be erect shrubs, climbing, or trailing, with stems that are often armed with sharp prickles. Their flowers vary in size and shape and are usually large and showy, in colours ranging from white through yellows and reds. Most species are native to Asia, with smaller numbers native to Europe, North America, and northwestern Africa. Species, cultivars and hybrids are all widely grown for their beauty and often are fragrant. Roses have acquired cultural significance in many societies. Rose plants range in size from compact, miniature roses, to climbers that can reach seven meters in height. Different species hybridize easily, and this has been used in the development of the wide range of garden roses.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fleur-de-lis</span> Stylized lily, heraldic symbol

The fleur-de-lis, also spelled fleur-de-lys, is a common heraldic charge in the shape of a lily. Most notably, the fleur-de-lis is depicted on the traditional coat of arms of France that was used from the High Middle Ages until the French Revolution in 1792, and then again in brief periods in the 19th century. This design still represents France and the House of Bourbon in the form of marshalling in the arms of Spain, Quebec and Canada, for example.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hammer and sickle</span> Symbol of communism

The hammer and sickle is a communist symbol representing proletarian solidarity between agricultural and industrial workers. It was first adopted during the Russian Revolution at the end of World War I, the hammer representing workers and the sickle representing the peasants.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flag of Azerbaijan</span> National flag

The national flag of Azerbaijan, often referred to in Azerbaijani as üçrəngli bayraq, is a horizontal tricolour that features three equally sized bars of bright blue, red, and green; a white crescent; and a centred eight-pointed star. The flag has become the predominant and most recognizable symbol of Azerbaijan. The bright blue represents Azerbaijan's Turkic identity, the red represents progress, and the green represents Islam, which is Azerbaijan's majority religion.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red flag (politics)</span> Symbol of socialism and left-wing politics

In politics, a red flag is predominantly a symbol of left-wing politics, including socialism, communism, Marxism, labour movement, and anarchism. The originally empty or plain red flag has been associated with left-wing politics since the French Revolution (1789–1799).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flag of Yemen</span> National flag

The State flag of Yemen was adopted on May 22, 1990, the day that North Yemen and South Yemen were unified. The flag of Yemen is the Arab Liberation Flag of 1952, introduced after the Egyptian Revolution of 1952 in which Arab nationalism was a dominant theme. The Arab Liberation Flag of 1952 served as the inspiration for the flags of both North and South Yemen prior to unification, as well as for the current flags of Egypt, Iraq, Sudan, Palestine and Syria.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Political colour</span> Colours used to represent a political ideology, movement or party

Political colours are colours used to represent a political ideology, movement or party, either officially or unofficially. They represent the intersection of colour symbolism and political symbolism. Politicians making public appearances will often identify themselves by wearing rosettes, flowers, ties or ribbons in the colour of their political party. Parties in different countries with similar ideologies sometimes use similar colours. As an example the colour red symbolises left-wing ideologies in many countries, while the colour blue is often used for conservatism, the colour yellow is most commonly associated with liberalism and right-libertarianism, and Green politics is named after the ideology's political colour. The political associations of a given colour vary from country to country, and there are exceptions to the general trends, for example red has historically been associated with Christianity, but over time gained association with leftist politics, while the United States differs from other countries in that conservatism is associated with red and liberalism with blue. Mass media has driven a standardization of colour by political party, to simplify messaging, while historically the colour a candidate chose to identify with could have been chosen based on other factors such as family or regional variations.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Flag of Georgia (country)</span> National flag

The flag of Georgia, also known as the five-cross flag, is one of the national symbols of Georgia. Originally a banner of the medieval Kingdom of Georgia, it was repopularised in the late 20th and early 21st centuries during the Georgian national revival.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red star</span> Symbol associated with communist ideology

A red star, five-pointed and filled, is a symbol that has often historically been associated with communist ideology, particularly in combination with the hammer and sickle, but is also used as a purely socialist symbol in the 21st century. It has been widely used in flags, state emblems, monuments, ornaments, and logos.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">White Rose of York</span> Heraldric symbol of the House of York and Yorkshire

The White Rose of York is a white heraldic rose which was adopted in the 14th century as a heraldic badge of the royal House of York. In modern times, it is used more broadly as a symbol of Yorkshire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Red Rose of Lancaster</span> Heraldic device used by the county and House of Lancaster

The Red Rose of Lancaster was the heraldic badge adopted by the royal House of Lancaster in the 14th century. In modern times it symbolises the county of Lancashire. The exact species or cultivar which it represents is thought to be Rosa gallica officinalis.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Raised fist</span> Symbol of solidarity and support

The raised fist, or the clenched fist, is a long-standing image of mixed meaning, often a symbol of solidarity, especially with a political movement. It is a common symbol representing a wide range of political ideologies, most notably socialism, communism, anarchism, and trade unionism, and can also be used as a salute expressing unity, strength, or resistance.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Anti-Socialist Laws</span> Laws of the German Empire

The Anti-Socialist Laws or Socialist Laws were a series of acts of the parliament of the German Empire, the first of which was passed on 19 October 1878 by the Reichstag lasting until 31 March 1881 and extended four times.

Red rose may refer to:

Communist symbolism represents a variety of themes, including revolution, the proletariat, the peasantry, agriculture, or international solidarity. The red flag, the hammer and sickle and the red star or variations thereof are some of the symbols adopted by communist movements, governments, and parties worldwide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Three Arrows</span> Social democratic and anti-fascist political symbol

The Three Arrows is a social democratic political symbol associated with the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD), used in the late history of the Weimar Republic. First conceived for the SPD-dominated Iron Front as a symbol of the social democratic resistance against Nazism in 1932, it became an official symbol of the Party during the November 1932 German federal election, representing their opposition towards monarchism, Nazism, and communism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fist and rose</span> Socialist and social democratic symbol

The fist and rose, sometimes called the rose in the fist or fist with a rose, is an emblem used or formerly used by a number of socialist and social democratic parties around the world.

References

  1. Teresa McLean: Medieval English Gardens. Dover Publications, Mineola, NY 1980, p. 165.
  2. 1 2 Cyrino, Monica S. (2010). Aphrodite. Gods and Heroes of the Ancient World. New York City, New York and London, England: Routledge. pp. 63, 96. ISBN   978-0-415-77523-6.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 Clark, Nora (2015). Aphrodite and Venus in Myth and Mimesis. Cambridge, England: Cambridge Scholars Publishing. pp. 209–210. ISBN   978-1-4438-7127-3.
  4. Iliad 23.185–187.
  5. Ibycus, fragment 288.4.
  6. Pausanias, Description of Greece 6.24.7.
  7. 1 2 "Flowers and Judaism: 8 Facts". aish.com. 2021-05-09. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
  8. "Song of Solomon 2:2 Parallel: As the lily among thorns, so is my love among the daughters". biblehub.com. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
  9. "Slichot and the 13 Attributes". aish.com. 2016-09-25. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
  10. "Tudor Rose". hebrewnations.com. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
  11. "Flowers in Israel". www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org. Retrieved 2022-05-22.
  12. Cucciniello, Lisa (2008). Rose to Rosary: The Flower of Venus in Catholicism. Lexington Books. pp. 64–65.{{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  13. Cucciniello, Rose Lore, pp. 65 ff.
  14. Shirvani, Hamid (1985). "The Philosophy of Persian Garden Design: The Sufi Tradition". Landscape Journal. 4: 23–30. doi:10.3368/lj.4.1.23. S2CID   113110165.
  15. Marinus Zwemer, Samuel (1941). "The Rose and Islam". The Muslim World. 31 (4): 360–370. doi:10.1111/j.1478-1913.1941.tb00950.x.
  16. Diba, Layla S. (2001). "Gol o bolbol". In Yarshater, Ehsan (ed.). Encyclopædia Iranica. Vol. 11. London and New York: Routledge. pp. 52–57. Retrieved 15 November 2013.
  17. Julian Baldick in History of Persian Literature - Google Books;
  18. Ibn Arabi, The Tarjuman al-Ashwaq, trans. R. A. Nicholson, Theosophical Publishing House 1911 and 1978, pp. 130, 145.
  19. Peter Childs, "Places and Peoples: Region and Nation", in British Cultural Identities, eds. Mike Storry & Peter Childs (4th ed., Routledge, 2013), p. 43.
  20. George Goodwin, Fatal Rivalry: Flodden, 1513: Henry VIII and James IV and the Decisive Battle for Renaissance Britain (W. W. Norton, 2013), p. 11.
  21. Jon Robinson, Court Politics, Culture and Literature in Scotland and England, 1500-1540 (Ashgate, 2008), p. 44.
  22. Natascha Würzbach & Simone M. Salz, Motif Index of the Child Corpus (Walter de Gruyter, 1995), pp. 175 f.
  23. Rugby History: Evolution of the England Kit, Rugby Football Union.
  24. "The Red Rose of Labour". British Heritage. Retrieved 2023-07-24.
  25. Matthew Tree, "St George's Day with a Catalan twist", The Guardian (April 23, 2011).
  26. 36 U.S.C. § 303 ("The flower commonly known as the rose is the national floral emblem.").
  27. Stephen Buchmann, The Reason for Flowers: Their History, Culture, Biology, and How They Change Our Lives (Simon & Schuster, 2016), p. 218.
  28. Linda Naeve, Iowa's State Flower - the Wild Rose (September 13, 1996), Horticulture & Home Pest News (Iowa State University Extension and Outreach).
  29. Wild Prairie Rose, State Historical Society of North Dakota.
  30. Georgia State Flower (Cherokee Rose), GeorgiaInfo: An Online Georgia Almanac, Digital Library of Georgia.
  31. New York State Flower - Rose, New York State Library.
  32. 1 2 Rosa Inocencio Smith, Orbital View: City of Roses, The Atlantic (May 5, 2016).
  33. "Coming Up Roses", Fodor's (2006; republished by the New York Times).
  34. Michelle Huneven, "37 Hours: Pasadena, Calif.", New York Times (September 19, 2003).
  35. "The Rose Bowl's Storied History", New York Times (December 31, 2013).
  36. NASA's Hubble Celebrates 21st Anniversary with 'Rose' of Galaxies, NASA, April 20, 2011, retrieved January 1, 2014
  37. "What Is Democratic Socialism?". Democratic Socialists of America. Retrieved December 15, 2015.
  38. n/a, n/a (2006-08-27). "The Rose and the Fist". The Fruits of Our Labour. Retrieved 2018-03-26.
  39. Alberta (AB) - Facts, Flags and Symbols, Government of Canada (accessed May 24, 2016).
  40. Wild Roses, Canadian Wildlife Federation (accessed May 24, 2016).
  41. The rise and fall of the Alberta Wildrose Party, CBC News (December 18, 2014).
  42. "The Mexican 'City Of Roses' Where Americans Feel At Home", Philadelphia Inquirer wire services (October 11, 1987).
  43. Bob Brooke, The Everything Family Guide To Mexico: From Pesos to Parasailing (Adams Media), p. 236.
  44. 1 2 "Metropolitan. v.38 1913". HathiTrust. p. 63. Retrieved 2019-03-02.
  45. 1 2 "Most's Meeting". Indianapolis Indiana State Sentinel. September 21, 1887. p. 1 Column 1.
  46. Leighton, John (1871). Paris Under the Commune. Bradbury, Evans. pp. iv.
  47. Agoult, Marie d' (1862). Histoire de la révolution de 1848 (in French). Charpentier. p. 363.
  48. Agoult, Marie d' (1862). Histoire de la révolution de 1848 (in French). Charpentier. p. 360. M. Louis Blanc, en rédigeant le décret qui déclarait que le drapeau national était le drapeau tricolore, obtint d'y ajouter la phrase suivante : «Comme signe de ralliement et comme souvenir de reconnaissance pour le dernier acte de la révolution populaire, les membres du gouvernement provisoire et les autres autorités porteront la rosette rouge, laquelle sera placée aussi à la hampe du drapeau.»
  49. Leighton, John (1871). Paris Under the Commune. Bradbury, Evans. pp.  118. red flag.
  50. Hayes, Carlton J. H. (October 1917). "The History of German Socialism Reconsidered". The American Historical Review. 23 (1): 77. doi:10.2307/1837686. JSTOR   1837686.
  51. Russell, Phillips (August 1914). "In Memory of Commune -- A Working Class Demonstration in Paris". The International Socialist Review. 15: 70.
  52. "Small Army Guarding Rockefeller Estate". Boston Sunday Post. June 14, 1914. p. 9 Column 3.
  53. The Woman Voter, Woman Suffrage Party of New York (1915). What does the red rose really mean?. Staten Island Museum. Allied Printing Trades Union Council, New York City. pp.  10.
  54. 1 2 "About Our Logo". Tamiment Library and Robert F. Wagner Archives. New York University. Archived from the original on 2017-07-02. Retrieved May 25, 2016.
  55. Historical Dictionary of Socialism (Rowman & Littlefield, 2015), p. 167.
  56. Cépède, Frédéric (January–March 1996).  Le poing et la rose », la saga d'un logo". Vingtième Siècle. Revue d'histoire (in French). 49. Paris: 18–30. doi:10.3406/xxs.1996.3481. ISSN   0294-1759 . Retrieved 20 November 2022.
  57. Cépède, Frédéric (September–December 2018).  Le poing et la rose », un symbole devenu encombrant ? Retour sur la saga d'un logo (1970-2017)". Histoire@Politique (in French). 36. Paris. ISSN   1954-3670 . Retrieved 20 November 2022.
  58. The rise and fall of New Labour, BBC News (August 3, 2010).
  59. Thomas William Heyck, A History of the Peoples of the British Isles (Vol. 3: Psychology Press, 2002), p. 312.
  60. Dumbach, Annette & Newborn, Jud Sophie Scholl & The White Rose, p. 58. 2006 One world Publications. ISBN   978-1851685363