Rank Island High point Lake Prominence [lower-alpha 1] Peak elevation Lake elevation [lower-alpha 1] Country or region High point coordinates [1] 1 Ometepe [lower-alpha 2] Volcán Concepción [2] Lake Nicaragua 1579 m 5,180 ft 1610 m 5,282 ft 31 m 102 ft Nicaragua 11°32′19″N 85°37′20″W / 11.538628°N 85.622161°W / 11.538628; -85.622161 (Volcán Concepción, Nicaragua ) 2 Teresa Island Birch Mountain [3] Atlin Lake 1393 m 4,570 ft 2062 m 6,765 ft 669 m 2,195 ft British Columbia Canada 59°25′55″N 133°49′15″W / 59.431911°N 133.820745°W / 59.431911; -133.820745 (Birch Mountain, British Columbia ) 3 Goat Island Goat Island Peak [4] Powell Lake 1264 m 4,147 ft 1314 m 4,311 ft 50 m 164 ft British Columbia Canada 50°03′52″N 124°23′48″W / 50.06455°N 124.396691°W / 50.06455; -124.396691 (Goat Island Peak, British Columbia ) 4 Ostrov Olkhon [lower-alpha 3] Gora Zhima [5] Lake Baikal 821 m 2,694 ft 1276 m 4,186 ft 455 m 1,493 ft Russia 53°14′18″N 107°42′42″E / 53.238289°N 107.711715°E / 53.238289; 107.711715 (Gora Zhima, Russia ) 5 Samosir Island [lower-alpha 4] Samosir [6] Lake Toba 806 m 2,644 ft 1713 m 5,620 ft 907 m 2,976 ft Indonesia 2°38′26″N 98°49′55″E / 2.640618°N 98.831913°E / 2.640618; 98.831913 (Samosir, Indonesia ) 6 Idjwi Island [lower-alpha 5] Idjwi Island high point [7] Lake Kivu 776 m 2,546 ft 2238 m 7,343 ft 1462 m 4,797 ft Democratic Republic of the Congo 2°07′46″S 29°04′33″E / 2.129311°S 29.075806°E / -2.129311; 29.075806 (Idjwi Island High Point, Democratic Republic of the Congo ) 7 Stansbury Island [lower-alpha 6] Castle Rock [8] Great Salt Lake [9] 751 m 2,464 ft 2028 m 6,654 ft 1276.9 m 4,189 ft Utah United States 40°50′49″N 112°29′57″W / 40.846833°N 112.499069°W / 40.846833; -112.499069 (Stansbury Island High Point, Utah ) 8 Antelope Island [lower-alpha 7] Frary Peak [10] [11] Great Salt Lake [9] 735.4 m 2,413 ft 2012.3 m 6,602 ft 1276.9 m 4,189 ft Utah United States 40°57′43″N 112°12′58″W / 40.962026°N 112.216054°W / 40.962026; -112.216054 (Frary Peak, Utah ) 9 Île René Levasseur Mont Babel [12] Manicouagan Reservoir 597 m 1,959 ft 957 m 3,140 ft 360 m 1,181 ft Quebec Canada 51°26′54″N 68°41′17″W / 51.448284°N 68.687983°W / 51.448284; -68.687983 (Mont Babel, Québec ) 10 Isla Zapatera Sierra Santa Julia [13] Lake Nicaragua 594 m 1,949 ft 625 m 2,051 ft 31 m 102 ft Nicaragua 11°44′18″N 85°49′00″W / 11.738263°N 85.81661°W / 11.738263; -85.81661 (Sierra Santa Julia, Nicaragua ) 11 Talim Island [lower-alpha 8] Mount Tagapo [14] Laguna de Bay 437 m 1,434 ft 438 m 1,437 ft 1 m 3 ft Philippines 14°20′22″N 121°13′57″E / 14.339418°N 121.232569°E / 14.339418; 121.232569 (Mount Tagapo, Philippines ) 12 Monte Isola [lower-alpha 9] Monte Isola [15] Lake Iseo 415 m 1,362 ft 600 m 1,969 ft 185 m 607 ft Italy 45°42′12″N 10°05′23″E / 45.703221°N 10.089634°E / 45.703221; 10.089634 (Monte Isola, Italy ) 13 St. Ignace Island Mount Saint Ignace [16] Lake Superior [17] 381 m 1,251 ft 565 m 1,854 ft 183.7 m 603 ft Ontario Canada 48°47′17″N 87°51′12″W / 48.788041°N 87.8532°W / 48.788041; -87.8532 (Mount Saint Ignace, Ontario ) 14 Amantaní [lower-alpha 10] Pachamama [18] Lake Titicaca 318 m 1,043 ft 4130 m 13,550 ft 3812 m 12,507 ft Peru 15°40′24″S 69°42′58″W / 15.673368°S 69.716094°W / -15.673368; -69.716094 (Pachamama, Peru ) 15 Volcano Island [lower-alpha 11] Volcano Island high point [19] Lake Taal 306 m 1,004 ft 311 m 1,020 ft 5 m 16 ft Philippines 14°00′14″N 120°59′29″E / 14.00401°N 120.99133°E / 14.00401; 120.99133 (Taal, Philippines ) 16 Michipicoten Island The Saddleback [20] Lake Superior [17] 273 m 897 ft 457 m 1,499 ft 183.7 m 603 ft Ontario Canada 47°45′21″N 85°52′56″W / 47.755788°N 85.88235°W / 47.755788; -85.88235 (The Saddleback, Ontario ) 17 Pie Island Pie Island high point [21] Lake Superior [17] 271 m 890 ft 455 m 1,493 ft 183.7 m 603 ft Ontario Canada 48°14′07″N 89°09′39″W / 48.23527°N 89.160877°W / 48.23527; -89.160877 (Pie Island High Point, Ontario ) 18 Isla del Sol Cerro Chequesani [22] Lake Titicaca 264 m 866 ft 4076 m 13,373 ft 3812 m 12,507 ft Bolivia 16°01′29″S 69°11′15″W / 16.024683°S 69.187418°W / -16.024683; -69.187418 (Cerro Chequesani, Bolivia ) 19 Isla Taquile Isla Taquile high point [23] Lake Titicaca 262 m 860 ft 4074 m 13,366 ft 3812 m 12,507 ft Peru 15°45′26″S 69°41′16″W / 15.757252°S 69.687691°W / -15.757252; -69.687691 (Isla Taquile-Punto Alto, Peru ) 20 Wild Horse Island Wild Horse Island high point [24] Flathead Lake [25] 259 m 850 ft 1141 m 3,743 ft 881.8 m 2,893 ft Montana United States 47°50′26″N 114°12′14″W / 47.840502°N 114.204001°W / 47.840502; -114.204001 (Wild Horse Island High Point, Montana ) 21 Fremont Island [lower-alpha 12] Castle Rock [26] [27] Great Salt Lake [9] 246 m 807 ft 1523 m 4,997 ft 1276.9 m 4,189 ft Utah United States 41°10′27″N 112°20′36″W / 41.174117°N 112.343272°W / 41.174117; -112.343272 (Castle Rock, Utah ) 22 Isle Royale Mount Desor [28] Lake Superior [17] 241 m 792 ft 425 m 1,394 ft 183.7 m 603 ft Michigan United States 47°57′21″N 89°00′42″W / 47.955846°N 89.011794°W / 47.955846; -89.011794 (Mount Desor, Michigan ) 23 Wizard Island Wizard Island Peak [29] Crater Lake [30] 233 m 766 ft 2113 m 6,932 ft 1879.6 m 6,167 ft Oregon United States 42°56′18″N 122°08′47″W / 42.938341°N 122.146375°W / 42.938341; -122.146375 (Wizard Island Peak, Oregon ) 24 Ukerewe Island Ukerewe Island high point [31] Lake Victoria 198 m 650 ft 1332 m 4,370 ft 1134 m 3,720 ft Tanzania 2°04′08″S 32°58′57″E / 2.068933°S 32.98262°E / -2.068933; 32.98262 (Ukerewe Island High Point, Tanzania ) 25 Anaho Island Anaho Island high point [32] Pyramid Lake [33] 175.9 m 577 ft 1335.0 m 4,380 ft 1159.1 m 3,803 ft Nevada United States 39°57′05″N 119°30′50″W / 39.95136°N 119.513925°W / 39.95136; -119.513925 (Anaho Island High Point, Nevada ) 26 Manitoulin Island Cup and Saucer [34] Lake Huron [35] 175 m 575 ft 352 m 1,155 ft 176.8 m 580 ft Ontario Canada 45°51′00″N 82°06′22″W / 45.850038°N 82.106193°W / 45.850038; -82.106193 (Cup and Saucer, Ontario ) 27 Carrington Island [lower-alpha 13] Carrington Island high point [36] [37] Great Salt Lake [9] 164.7 m 540 ft 1441.6 m 4,730 ft 1276.9 m 4,189 ft Utah United States 41°00′27″N 112°34′13″W / 41.007494°N 112.570375°W / 41.007494; -112.570375 (Carrington Island High Point, Utah ) 28 Saint Joseph Island Saint Joseph Island high point [38] Lake Huron [35] 163 m 536 ft 340 m 1,115 ft 176.8 m 580 ft Ontario Canada 46°12′17″N 83°57′12″W / 46.204675°N 83.953371°W / 46.204675; -83.953371 (Saint Joseph Island High Point, Ontario ) 29 Pigeon Island [lower-alpha 14] [lower-alpha 15] Pigeon Island high point [39] Lake Wakatipu 155 m 509 ft 463 m 1,519 ft 308 m 1,010 ft New Zealand 44°55′28″S 168°23′46″E / 44.924339°S 168.396249°E / -44.924339; 168.396249 (Pigeon Island High Point, New Zealand ) 30 Porcupine Island Porcu Benchmark [40] Iliamna Lake 155 m 509 ft 169 m 554 ft 14 m 46 ft Alaska United States 59°42′11″N 154°11′38″W / 59.702922°N 154.194021°W / 59.702922; -154.194021 (Porcu Benchmark, Alaska )