Music of ancient Rome

Last updated

Trio of musicians playing an aulos, cymbala, and tympanum (mosaic from Pompeii) Scena di commedia, musici ambulanti, da villa di cecerone a pompei, 9985, 03.JPG
Trio of musicians playing an aulos , cymbala, and tympanum (mosaic from Pompeii)
Masked theatrical troupe around an aulos player (mosaic from the House of the Tragic Poet, Pompeii) Choregos actors MAN Napoli Inv9986.jpg
Masked theatrical troupe around an aulos player (mosaic from the House of the Tragic Poet, Pompeii)

The music of ancient Rome was a part of Roman culture from the earliest of times. Songs (carmen) were an integral part of almost every social occasion. [1] The Secular Ode of Horace, for instance, was commissioned by Augustus and performed by a mixed children's choir at the Secular Games in 17 BC. Music was customary at funerals, and the tibia (Greek aulos ), a woodwind instrument, was played at sacrifices to ward off ill influences. Under the influence of ancient Greek theory, music was thought to reflect the orderliness of the cosmos, and was associated particularly with mathematics and knowledge. [2]

Contents

Etruscan music had an early influence on that of the Romans. During the Imperial period, Romans carried their music to the provinces, while traditions of Asia Minor, North Africa, and Gaul became a part of Roman culture. [3]

Music accompanied public spectacles, events in the arena, and was part of the performing art form called pantomimus, an early form of story ballet that combined expressive dancing, instrumental music, and a sung libretto. [4]

History

Ancient Roman music and singing originated from Etruscan music, [5] [6] [7] and then Ancient Greek music. [8] During its early history, it was mostly used for military purposes. [9] According to Cicero, Roman musical tradition was adapted during the reign of Numa Pompilius. [10] [11] Music was initially discovered by Greek philosopher and mathematician Pythagoras[ dubious ]. Pythagoras was able to find the first 7 pitches in a scale and this knowledge carried over into the Roman Empire. [12]

Music in society

Depiction of a Roman animal sacrifice Roman sacrifice Louvre Ma992.jpg
Depiction of a Roman animal sacrifice

Music was an important aspect of Roman religious rituals. [13] It was used to set the rhythm of the ritual and invoke certain emotions. [14] Various instruments had different roles in Roman religion. Ancient Roman art displays tibicines, or players of the tibia, playing behind altars. [15] They are depicted wearing a toga with a head covering while perform an animal sacrifice. [16] [17] Some depictions show assistants holding the acerra or tankards and cups to assist the tibicen. [15] The tibia was likely the most important instrument in the Roman Imperial cult. Tibicen were also used to drown out any distracting noise. To the ancient Romans, it must have been unimaginable for a sacrifice to lack music. [18] Music, usually pipe music, would accompany public prayers. [19] Cymbals and drums were used in rituals of the cult of Cybele and rattles were important to the cult of Isis. [20] Female musicians, dancers, and singers would perform at a festival for the goddess Isis who had a temple in Rome. [21] They would also perform at a festival dedicated to the Bona Dea. [22] Several ancient Roman monuments were consecrated by musicians. [23] [24] The Salian priests would dance and sing while moving through the city in honor of Mars. [19] [25] [26] Musicians would also play the flute to worship Mars. [22] The Arval Brethren would also sing and dance to honor the goddess Ceres. [27] Titus Livius, a Roman historian, described an incident where players of the flute were barred from eating and drinking in the temples. Afterward, they retreated to Tivoli, and were allowed to continue eating and drinking in the temples when the Senate realized there were no musicians for religious services. [28] [29] Processions of trumpeters and dancers were also important to the Pompa circensis . [30] [31] Which was a parade that preceded the games before religious festivals. [27] [32]

Musicians in a detail from the Zliten mosaic (2nd century AD), originally shown as accompanying gladiator combat and wild-animal events in the arena: from left, the tuba, hydraulis (water pipe organ), and two cornua Mosaique Zliten.jpg
Musicians in a detail from the Zliten mosaic (2nd century AD), originally shown as accompanying gladiator combat and wild-animal events in the arena: from left, the tuba, hydraulis (water pipe organ), and two cornua

Music was a popular form of entertainment in ancient Rome. [33] It was important to ancient Roman games. [34] [35] Gladiatorial fights began with a blast of horns and were accompanied by music. [36] [37] Musicians, usually players of the tuba or large aerophones would play during triumphs. [38] The tibia was used to draw in the viewer's attention during the ceremony and a trumpet was used to announce the presence of the triumphator. [14] Music was also used to silence the crowd. [39] Music, primarily pipe music, [40] held an important place in ancient Roman theatre. [41] [42] [43] [44] During plays, the actors, pantomimes, and tragedians would be accompanied by a chorus of singers and an orchestra of wind or percussion instruments. [31] They would dance to the tune of the instruments. [31] Musicians could be driven off of the stage for even small musical errors. [45] The tune of the instruments would signify the emotions and traits of the characters and the pace of the story. [46] [47] Music was also used to ensure the story remained in the memory of audiences. [48]

Romans would sometimes hold private musical concerts known as symphoniaci. [49] These parties were associated with debauchery in ancient Rome. [50] Lucius Calpurnius Piso Caesoninus, the consul in 58 BCE, was known to hold such parties. [49] His house was described as filled with "singing and cymbals." [51] [52] Private musicians could be hired to provide entertainment during dinners or parties. Sometimes these private musicians were specially trained slaves. [53] Ancient Roman women are depicted as having sung and danced in the privacy of their homes. Women in ancient Rome had different instruments from men. They played the harp, the aulos, and smaller lyres. [54] Domitian established contests that included music, gymnastics, and riding competitions. [55] [56] [57] Nero created the Quinquennial Neronia, which was a festival involving musical competitions. [58] The Actian games, which was an ancient Roman festival of Apollo, also held musical competitions. [59] The Greeks and Romans might have held musical performances in between the meal and the drinking party during dinner. [60]

The cornu and other instruments such as the tuba were used to give signals in the ancient Roman military. [7] [61] [62] There were collegia dedicated to musicians. One collegium made up of flute and lyre players was attested for the first time in the second century CE. The collegium syphoniacorum would play at religious or official ceremonies. Another collegium, the Collegium tibicinum romanorum was dedicated to perform at public funerals. [22] Musicians' Collegia were highly respected in ancient Rome. They were used to preserve and perfect ancient Roman musical practices. [63]

Education and training

Musical training and skills were common amongst the Roman upper-class, and it may have been especially common amongst female Romans of the upper-class. [64] Singers were expected to spend large amounts of time and energy practicing their craft. [65] In ancient Rome, the term for music or speech teachers was phonascus. [65] They focused on developing the flexibility of their student's voice. [66] It also believed that a singer's neck should be soft and smooth to ensure that the voice did not sound harsh or broken. [65] [67] Marcus Tullius Cicero stated that musicians "sit for many years practicing delivery, and every day, before they begin to speak, gradually arouse their voices while lying in bed; and when they have done that they sit up and make their voices run down from the highest to the lowest level, in some way joining the highest and the lowest together." [68] According to The Twelve Caesars , Nero would train his voice by avoiding harmful fruits and drinks, purging himself with vomiting and enemas, and lying on his back with a lead sheet on his chest. [68] [69] Quintilian believed that maintaining good physical health through diet and exercise was important for maintain a proper voice. According to Quintilian, abstaining from sex was also important for a singer. [66] Other ancient texts describe singers perform warm-up exercises consisting of vocalized successive sounds before singing. [66] [70] There may have been "music schools" for musicians of low class.

Cultural views

In ancient Rome music was confined to domestic settings. [71] Plutarch praises a man named Numerius Furius, who is said to have sung when it was "appropriate." [72] Music had some negative connotations in Roman society. Cornelius Nepos, a Roman historian and biographer, in his biography of Epaminondas describes his famed skill at music and dancing as a negative characteristic. [73] He described his musical talents as: "trivial, or rather, contemptible" [74] Plutarch wrote that the prominence of the flute in Theban society was designed by their legislators to "relax and mollify their strong and impetuous natures in earliest boyhood." [75] The ancient Romans considered music to be a powerful tool and believed that it was capable of inciting strong emotions in people. [76] [77] [78] Cicero and Aristides Quintilianus believed that music was capable of ennobling the populace. Quintilian believed that music was "the most beautiful art" and that it was necessary for properly reading the work of ancient poets. [64] It was a common belief throughout the Roman world that traditional styles of music should be maintained. [79] [80] Pliny wrote that musicians would change their art based on popular demand. [40] Cicero discussed the superior quality of traditional Roman music. [81] [82] He describes archaic Roman music as civilizing the "barbaric." [83] Cicero believed that musical education could help aspiring politicians learn to better listen to other's arguments and detect imperfections. [84] Numerous ancient Roman writers such as Plato, Seneca, or Cicero believed that music could effeminize men. [85] [86] Female musicians were highly respected compared to male musicians. [87] [88] It was seen as a potential way of enhancing their attractiveness. [89] [90] However, being too skilled at music, when combined with other activities which were seen as less respectable, such as prostitution made one seem less respectable. [89] Music was also considered inappropriate for married women or older women. [91] Cicero once wrote: [92]

For I agree with Plato that nothing so easily flows into young and impressionable minds as the various notes of the musical scale; it is hard to express the extent of their power in one way or the other. For music animates the indolent and calms the excited; it causes spirits to relax at one moment and then restrains them the next. Many states in Greece considered it important to preserve the ancient style of music; yet their morals changed along with their songs and slid to decadence as a result. Either they were corrupted by the sweet seductiveness of music, as some people think, or, once the stringency of their morals was undermined by their other vices, then their ears and minds became changed, leaving room for this musical change also. For this reason the wisest and by far the most learned man in Greece was greatly afraid of this decline. For he denies that the laws of music can be changed without heralding a change in the laws of the state. However, I for one do not think that this should be feared so greatly, although it should not be overlooked either. Indeed, [we see] how the theatre, which once used to be filled with the tunes of Livius and Naevius, pleasing in their simplicity, is now filled with people who leap up and toss their heads and roll their eyes in time with the twists and turns of the music. In the old days, Greece used to punish such behaviour harshly, anticipating far in advance how the deadly plague might sink gradually into the minds of citizens and suddenly overturn entire states with evil pursuits and evil ideas—if, indeed, it is true that stern Sparta ordered the strings above the number of seven to be cut off the lyre of Timotheus.

Marcus Tullius Cicero

Instruments

Ancient Roman musicians Rilievo con corteo funebre, 20 ac-20 dc ca., da amiternum, 06 musici.jpg
Ancient Roman musicians

Roman art depicts various woodwinds, "brass", percussion and stringed instruments. [93] Roman-style instruments are found in parts of the Empire where they did not originate, and indicate that music was among the aspects of Roman culture that spread throughout the provinces.

Wind instruments

String instruments

Villa dei Misteri IV - 2.jpg
P. Fannius Synistor anagoria links.JPG
Left image:: Silenus holding a lyre, detail of a fresco from the Villa of the Mysteries, Pompeii, Italy, c. 50 BC
Right image: wall fresco of a seated woman with a kithara, 40-30 BC, from the Villa Boscoreale of P. Fannius Synistor; late Roman Republic; it most likely represents Berenice II of Ptolemaic Egypt wearing a stephane (i.e. royal diadem) on her head. [96]

Organs

Hydraulis and cornu on a mosaic from Nennig, Germany Nennig Roman Villa and Mosaics - 51134391923.jpg
Hydraulis and cornu on a mosaic from Nennig, Germany

Mosaics depict instruments that look like a cross between the bagpipe and the organ. The pipes were sized to produce many of the modes (scales) learned from the Greeks. It is unclear whether they were blown by the lungs or by some mechanical bellows.The hydraulic pipe organ (hydraulis), which worked by water pressure, was "one of the most significant technical and musical achievements of antiquity". [101] Essentially, the air to the pipes that produce the sound comes from a mechanism of a wind-chest connected by a pipe to a dome submerged in a tank of water. Air is pumped into the top of the dome, compressing the air and forcing the water out the bottom; the displaced water rises in the tank. This increased hydraulic head and the compression of the air in the dome provides a steady supply of air to the pipes [102] The hydraulis accompanied gladiator contests and events in the arena, as well as stage performances. It might also be found in homes, and was among the instruments that the emperor Nero played. [101]

Percussion

Pair of 1st century AD bronze cymbals from Pompeii, preserved at the National Archaeological Museum, Naples Pompei (Nimes) 44 paire de cymbalettes.jpg
Pair of 1st century AD bronze cymbals from Pompeii, preserved at the National Archaeological Museum, Naples

Dance

The Salii and the Arval Brethren were ancient Roman organizations of priests who danced at religious festivals. [104] [105] [106] Dance was used to thank the gods and it held an important place in the Dionysia. Before battles Roman soldiers could hold dances to honor the god Mars. [107] Music and dancing was also used to ensure the efficacy of sacrifices. [108] Varro, a Roman author, wrote that dance was used in religious festivals as "no part of the body should be debarred from religious experiences." [109] Dance was a popular form of entertainment in ancient Rome. [110] [111] Ovid describes drunk people dancing and singing in the streets during festivals such as the Anna Perenna. [112] The Romans would hire dancers from conquered nations or train slaves to dance. Female dancers known as crotalisterias danced using bells and clappers. [104] [113] Another popular kind of dance was tripudia, which were three-foot dances. [114] Pantomimists were popular in ancient Roman theatre. [115] They wore cloaks, masks with closed mouths, and costumes. Plutarch described ancient Roman pantomimes twisting, leaping, and standing like a statue. He also wrote that criminals may be condemned to dancing in festivals. [104] Dancing was used as way to accentuate beauty and could be erotic. [116] Private dance schools trained ancient Roman aristocrats. [117] Improper dance in ancient Rome, was defined as being un-Roman. [118] Foreign dancing styles were disliked. Elagabalus was heavily scrutinized for his usage of foreign dances. [119] Cornelius Nepos associated dance and music with ancient Greek culture, and treated it with disdain. [120] Cicero stated that no sober person would dance unless they were a "lunatic." [109] He likely did not object to the usage of dance as entertainment, but instead considered it to be beneath the upper-class Romans. Cicero may have believed that it should be relegated to only lower-class professional dancers. It is also possible he was exclusively referring to erotic or foreign dancing. Scipio Aemilianus criticized dancers for "improper display of their bodies." [121]

Discography

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lyre</span> Ancient Greek string instrument

The lyre is a stringed musical instrument that is classified by Hornbostel–Sachs as a member of the lute family of instruments. In organology, a lyre is considered a yoke lute, since it is a lute in which the strings are attached to a yoke that lies in the same plane as the sound table, and consists of two arms and a crossbar.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Oud</span> Pear-shaped stringed musical instrument

The oud is a Middle Eastern short-neck lute-type, pear-shaped, fretless stringed instrument, usually with 11 strings grouped in six courses, but some models have five or seven courses, with 10 or 13 strings respectively.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient music</span> Music that developed in literate cultures

Ancient music refers to the musical cultures and practices that developed in the literate civilizations of the ancient world. Succeeding the music of prehistoric societies and lasting until the Post-classical era. Major centers of Ancient music developed in China, Egypt, Greece, India, Iran/Persia, the Maya civilization, Mesopotamia, and Rome. Though extremely diverse, the music of ancient civilizations is frequently characterized by monophony, improvisation and the dominance of text in musical settings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Music of Mesopotamia</span>

Music was ubiquitous throughout Mesopotamian history, playing important roles in both religious and secular contexts. Mesopotamia is of particular interest to scholars because evidence from the region—which includes artifacts, artistic depictions, and written records—places it among the earliest well-documented cultures in the history of music. The discovery of a bone wind instrument dating to the 5th millennium BCE provides the earliest evidence of music culture in Mesopotamia; depictions of music and musicians appear in the 4th millennium BCE; and later, in the city of Uruk, the pictograms for ‘harp’ and ‘musician’ are present among the earliest known examples of writing.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Cornu (horn)</span> Ancient Roman brass instrument

A cornu or cornum was an ancient Roman brass instrument about 3 m (9.8 ft) long in the shape of a letter 'G'. The instrument was braced by a crossbar that stiffened the structure and provided a means of supporting its weight on the player's shoulder. Some specimens survive in the archaeological record, two from the ruins of Pompeii.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Delphic Hymns</span> Musical compositions from Ancient Greece

The Delphic Hymns are two musical compositions from Ancient Greece, which survive in substantial fragments. They were long regarded as being dated c. 138 BC and 128 BC, respectively, but recent scholarship has shown it likely they were both written for performance at the Athenian Pythaids in 128 BC. If indeed it dates from ten years before the second, the First Delphic Hymn is the earliest unambiguous surviving example of notated music from anywhere in the western world whose composer is known by name. Inscriptions indicate that the First Delphic Hymn was written by Athenaeus, son of Athenaeus, while Limenius is credited the Second Delphic Hymn's composer.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Barbiton</span>

The barbiton, or barbitos, is an ancient stringed instrument related to the lyre known from Greek and Roman classics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pandura</span> Ancient string instrument

The pandura or pandore, an ancient string instrument, belonged in the broad class of the lute and guitar instruments. Akkadians played similar instruments from the 3rd millennium BC. Ancient Greek artwork depicts such lutes from the 3rd or 4th century BC onward It shows Iranian influences, Pandora is rooted in the Persian word.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Music of ancient Greece</span> Musical traditions of ancient Greece

Music was almost universally present in ancient Greek society, from marriages, funerals, and religious ceremonies to theatre, folk music, and the ballad-like reciting of epic poetry. This played an integral role in the lives of ancient Greeks. There are some fragments of actual Greek musical notation, many literary references, depictions on ceramics and relevant archaeological remains, such that some things can be known—or reasonably surmised—about what the music sounded like, the general role of music in society, the economics of music, the importance of a professional caste of musicians, etc.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Classical music</span> Broad tradition of Western art music

Classical music generally refers to the art music of the Western world, considered to be distinct from Western folk music or popular music traditions. It is sometimes distinguished as Western classical music, as the term "classical music" can also be applied to non-Western art musics. Classical music is often characterized by formality and complexity in its musical form and harmonic organization, particularly with the use of polyphony. Since at least the ninth century it has been primarily a written tradition, spawning a sophisticated notational system, as well as accompanying literature in analytical, critical, historiographical, musicological and philosophical practices. A foundational component of Western culture, classical music is frequently seen from the perspective of individual or groups of composers, whose compositions, personalities and beliefs have fundamentally shaped its history.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kithara</span> Ancient Greek musical instrument

The kithara, or Latinized cithara, was an ancient Greek musical instrument in the yoke lutes family. It was a seven-stringed professional version of the lyre, which was regarded as a rustic, or folk instrument, appropriate for teaching music to beginners. As opposed to the simpler lyre, the cithara was primarily used by professional musicians, called kitharodes. In modern Greek, the word kithara has come to mean "guitar", a word which etymologically stems from kithara.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of music in the biblical period</span>

Knowledge of the biblical period is mostly from literary references in the Bible and post-biblical sources. Religion and music historian Herbert Lockyer, Jr. writes that "music, both vocal and instrumental, was well cultivated among the Hebrews, the New Testament Christians, and the Christian church through the centuries." He adds that "a look at the Old Testament reveals how God's ancient people were devoted to the study and practice of music, which holds a unique place in the historical and prophetic books, as well as the Psalter."

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Musical instrument</span> Device for making musical sounds

A musical instrument is a device created or adapted to make musical sounds. In principle, any object that produces sound can be considered a musical instrument—it is through purpose that the object becomes a musical instrument. A person who plays a musical instrument is known as an instrumentalist. The history of musical instruments dates to the beginnings of human culture. Early musical instruments may have been used for rituals, such as a horn to signal success on the hunt, or a drum in a religious ceremony. Cultures eventually developed composition and performance of melodies for entertainment. Musical instruments evolved in step with changing applications and technologies.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kollops</span>

A kollops is a tuning device for a string instrument which consists of a strip of leather wrapped around the instrument's crossbar, tightened by a wooden peg trapped in its wrap. The device is mentioned as early as the 7th century BC, used metaphorically in the Odyssey. The material itself, usually the hard material at the back of the neck of an ox, was known as "kollops" and thus the term was also used for the tuning device.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Music technology</span> Use of technology by musicians

Music technology is the study or the use of any device, mechanism, machine or tool by a musician or composer to make or perform music; to compose, notate, playback or record songs or pieces; or to analyze or edit music.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Music technology (mechanical)</span>

Mechanical music technology is the use of any device, mechanism, machine or tool by a musician or composer to make or perform music; to compose, notate, play back or record songs or pieces; or to analyze or edit music. The earliest known applications of technology to music was prehistoric peoples' use of a tool to hand-drill holes in bones to make simple flutes. Ancient Egyptians developed stringed instruments, such as harps, lyres and lutes, which required making thin strings and some type of peg system for adjusting the pitch of the strings. Ancient Egyptians also used wind instruments such as double clarinets and percussion instruments such as cymbals. In Ancient Greece, instruments included the double-reed aulos and the lyre. Numerous instruments are referred to in the Bible, including the horn, pipe, lyre, harp, and bagpipe. During Biblical times, the cornet, flute, horn, organ, pipe, and trumpet were also used. During the Middle Ages, hand-written music notation was developed to write down the notes of religious Plainchant melodies; this notation enabled the Catholic church to disseminate the same chant melodies across its entire empire.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of lute-family instruments</span>

Lutes are stringed musical instruments that include a body and "a neck which serves both as a handle and as a means of stretching the strings beyond the body".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hittite music</span> Music of the Hittite people

Hittite music is the music of the Hittites of the 17th–12th century BC and of the Syro-Hittite successor states of the 12th–7th century BC.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Parthian music</span> Music of the Parthian Empire (247 BCE – 224 CE)

The Parthian Empire, a major state of ancient Iran, lasted from 247 BCE to 224 CE, in which music played a prominent role. It featured in festivals, weddings, education, warfare and other social gatherings. Surviving artistic records indicate that it involved both men and women, who could be instrumentalists or singers. Along with the older music of the previous Achaemenids, Medians and Assyrians, Parthian music was crucial in laying the foundation for the golden age of subsequent Sasanian music.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ancient Greek harps</span> Plucked instruments

The psalterion is a stringed, plucked instrument, an ancient Greek harp. Psalterion was a general word for harps in the latter part of the 4th century B.C. It meant "plucking instrument".

References

  1. Habinek 2005.
  2. Habinek 2005, p. 90.
  3. Scott 1957, p. 404.
  4. Franklin 1987, p. 95.
  5. Hagel & Lynch 2015, p. 408.
  6. Ulrich & Pisk 1963, p. 25.
  7. 1 2 3 Ginsberg‐Klar 1981, p. 314.
  8. Landels 1999, p. 172.
  9. Ardelean 2022, pp. 8–9.
  10. Cicero, p. 2.38.
  11. Morgan 2018, p. 124.
  12. "Physics of Music - Notes". pages.mtu.edu. Retrieved 14 September 2023.
  13. Lössl & Baker-Brian 2018, p. 611.
  14. 1 2 Rüpke 2007, p. 259.
  15. 1 2 Rüpke 2007, p. 257.
  16. Vincent 2017, pp. 153–154.
  17. Lössl & Baker-Brian 2018, p. 612.
  18. Rüpke 2007, p. 258.
  19. 1 2 Rüpke 2007, p. 237.
  20. Rüpke 2007, p. 249.
  21. Bleiberg et al. 2005, p. 218.
  22. 1 2 3 Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 27.
  23. Rüpke 2007, p. 252.
  24. CIL VI, 40334
  25. Cary 1950, pp. 515–519.
  26. Livius 1919, p. 120.
  27. 1 2 Rüpke 2007, p. 253.
  28. Mainzer 2014, p. 64-65.
  29. Livius 1919, p. 930.
  30. Cary 1950, p. 371.
  31. 1 2 3 Rocconi 2015, p. 90.
  32. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 582.
  33. Ardelean 2022, p. 9.
  34. Vincent 2017, pp. 151–152.
  35. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 578.
  36. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 469.
  37. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 25.
  38. Vincent 2017, pp. 157–158.
  39. Rüpke 2007, p. 260.
  40. 1 2 Morgan 2018, p. 81.
  41. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 385.
  42. Sachs 1943, pp. 272–273.
  43. Marshall 2006, p. 204.
  44. Landels 1999, p. 183.
  45. Moore 2021, p. 238.
  46. Marshall 2006, p. 205.
  47. Marshall 2006, p. 224.
  48. Moore 2021, pp. 235–236.
  49. 1 2 Morgan 2018, p. 117.
  50. Morgan 2018, p. 119.
  51. Morgan 2018, p. 118.
  52. Clark 1909.
  53. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 29.
  54. Bleiberg et al. 2005, p. 217.
  55. Tranquillus 1907, p. 349.
  56. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 533.
  57. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 26.
  58. Christesen & Kyle 2013, p. 536.
  59. Morgan 2018, p. 144.
  60. Lössl & Baker-Brian 2018, p. 613.
  61. Vincent 2017, p. 155.
  62. Landels 1999, p. 180.
  63. Rüpke 2007, pp. 252–253.
  64. 1 2 Hagel & Lynch 2015, p. 409.
  65. 1 2 3 Ardelean 2022, p. 10.
  66. 1 2 3 Ardelean 2022, p. 12.
  67. Quintilianus 1922, p. 255.
  68. 1 2 Ardelean 2022, p. 11.
  69. Tranquillus 1907, p. 117.
  70. Cicero 1860, p. 251.
  71. Morgan 2018, p. 116.
  72. Morgan 2018, p. 115.
  73. Morgan 2018, p. 111.
  74. Nepos, p. 2.
  75. Perrin 1917, p. 388.
  76. Rocconi 2015, p. 81.
  77. Morgan 2018, p. 93.
  78. Varro 2013, p. 61.
  79. Morgan 2018, p. 92.
  80. Morgan 2018, p. 73.
  81. Morgan 2018, p. 83.
  82. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 36.
  83. Morgan 2018, p. 126.
  84. Morgan 2018, p. 103.
  85. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 31.
  86. Landels 1999, p. 198.
  87. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 82.
  88. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 92.
  89. 1 2 Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 105.
  90. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, p. 113.
  91. Lindgren Liljenstolpe 2015, pp. 116–119.
  92. Morgan 2018, p. 71–72.
  93. Ginsberg‐Klar 1981, p. 313.
  94. 1 2 Bonanni 1964, p. 2.
  95. Pierce 1983, p. 45.
  96. Pfrommer & Towne-Markus 2001, pp. 201.
  97. 1 2 Bonanni 1964, p. 3.
  98. Maas 2001, p. 185.
  99. Higgins & Winnington-Ingram 1965, pp. 62–71.
  100. Spring 2001, p. 1.
  101. 1 2 Ginsberg‐Klar 1981, p. 316.
  102. Williams 1903, pp. 13–14.
  103. Marcuse 1975, pp. 137–304.
  104. 1 2 3 Kassing 2007, p. 59.
  105. Naerebout 2009, p. 147.
  106. Rüpke 2007, p. 255.
  107. Kassing 2007, p. 61.
  108. Dillon & Garland 2013, p. 131.
  109. 1 2 Kiefer 2000, p. 179.
  110. Fernández 2020, p. 177.
  111. Dillon & Garland 2021.
  112. Toner 2013.
  113. McGeough 2004, p. 277.
  114. Lawler & Spawforth 2015.
  115. Ermatinger 2015, p. 44.
  116. Fleiner 2020.
  117. Kassing 2007, p. 53.
  118. Naerebout 2009, p. 148.
  119. Naerebout 2009, p. 155.
  120. Fernández 2020, p. 178.
  121. Eyben 2003, p. 85.

Bibliography

Primary Sources

Secondary sources

Further reading