Corruption in Malta is a persistent and systemic problem which affects various sectors of the government and public services. It does not only undermine public trust in government institutions but also adversely affects economic development and the rule of law. Corruption in the Maltese islands has significantly increased since the Malta Labour Party returned to power in 2013. [1]
An example of high-profile corruption case in Malta involved Steward Healthcare, an American healthcare company. It was awarded a €400 million contract to renovate and manage three state-owned hospitals into world-class healthcare providers within eight years. [2] Allegations of fraud and corruption emerged and this involved high-ranking government officials such as the former prime minister Joseph Muscat. It was found through leaked emails that Steward Healthcare transferred millions of euros to Accutor, a Swiss firm that paid consultancy fees to Muscat. [3] Although there is no direct evidence yet linking the payments as bribes to Muscat, Steward Healthcare's payments were passed off as consultancy payments to consultants such as the former prime minister. A criminal report later revealed that the company created a political support fund that diverted money from the hospital contract to Muscat and two other senior Maltese officials via Accutor and related firms. [3] Steward Healthcare is also accused of conducting surveillance and disinformation operations against its critics. [3]
Another corruption scandal that demonstrates the institutionalization of corruption in Malta involved the drug trafficking case of the Nigerian nationals Kofi Otule and Austine Uche in 2016. Allegations of judicial corruption stem from perceptions of inconsistencies in the evidence presented as well as questions of fairness and integrity on the part of involved authorities within the judicial system. [4] In Otule and Uche's case, the court's decision to employ unreliable witness affected the length of the litigation process and also undermined the case brought against the defendants. [5]
There is also the case of Christian Borg's acquittal for illegally hiring foreign workers. The case itself is insignificant compared to other infractions as Borg has been accused of using his car business to launder money from drug trafficking and criminal activities. None of these accusations have been refuted nor investigated. [6]
The criticism of the Maltese judicial system rests on its inefficiencies, particularly with regard to the length of time needed to resolve cases. Money laundering cases take the longest to close in the trial courts. [6] In 2018, for instance, courts took about six years to litigate these cases and several of these still remain unresolved. A 2020 Council of Europe report supported this as it highlighted that criminal cases in Malta take two to eight times longer than the EU average. [7] It is noted that court delays lessen the chances that the dispute will be justly decided and that corrupt actors evade consequences by delaying their case. [8]
Another corruption issue in Malta concerns the “revolving door” practice where individuals move from public office to private sector roles. The resulting intertwining of political and business interests perpetuates a cycle of corruption. Muscat's consultancy for companies like Steward Healthcare is an example. After he resigned due to the political fallout of the assassination of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia, he transitioned into private consulting role and reportedly earned over €480,000 a year. In the revolving door phenomenon, public officials use insider knowledge and connections for personal gain. [9]
Corruption has eroded public confidence in Malta's governmental institutions and the rule of law. Transparency International’s 2023 Corruption Perceptions Index posted a marked decline in Malta’s ranking since its high score of 60 in 2015 on a scale from 0 ("highly corrupt") to 100 ("very clean"). The country scored 51 in 2023. [10] [11] The score is close to those considered “flawed democracies”, which post an average score of 48 in the Index. [12] For comparison with regional scores, the highest score among Western European and European Union countries [Note 1] was 90, the average score was 65 and the lowest score was 42. [13] For comparison with worldwide scores, the best score was 90 (ranked 1), the average score was 43, and the worst score was 11 (ranked 180). [14]
Inefficiencies in the governmental processes also lead to economic losses. This is evident in the state's procurement processes, which are commonly marred by irregularities and conflicts of interest. These hamper Malta's economic development. [15]
There are anti-corruption measures in place that aim to curb corruption. However, there is a lack of a comprehensive legal framework that identifies and penalizes corruption. For example, to address the revolving door phenomenon, Malta instituted a policy in 2020 that bars certain public employees from engaging in profit-making activities for up to two years after leaving government service. [16] However, this policy does not cover elected officials and Cabinet ministers, allowing them to exploit their previous roles in the government for personal gain. [16]
Joseph Muscat is a Maltese politician who served as the 13th prime minister of Malta from 2013 to 2020 and leader of the Labour Party from 2008 to 2020.
Edward Scicluna is a Maltese economist and politician. Scicluna assumed the position of Governor of the Central Bank of Malta as from 1 January 2021 for a five-year term.
The Philippines suffers from widespread corruption, which developed during the Spanish colonial period. According to GAN Integrity's Philippines Corruption Report updated May 2020, the Philippines suffers from many incidents of corruption and crime in many aspects of civic life and in various sectors. Such corruption risks are rampant throughout the state's judicial system, police service, public services, land administration, and natural resources.
Steward Health Care is a large private for-profit health system headquartered in Dallas, Texas. It utilizes an integrated care model to deliver healthcare across its hospitals and primary care locations, as well as through its managed care and health insurance services. At the start of 2024, Steward operated 33 hospitals and employed 33,000 people in the United States, however that number has decreased significantly due to the company's May 2024 bankruptcy filing. Steward's international ventures include Steward Colombia, which operates four hospitals, and Steward Middle East, which operates in Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates.
Corruption is a significant issue in Ukrainian society going back to the dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. After declaring independence from the Soviet Union, Ukraine faced a series of politicians from different sides of the political spectrum, as well as criminal bosses and oligarchs, who used the corruption of police, political parties, and industry to gain power. Despite improvements, corruption remains an obstacle to joining the European Union.
Corruption in Lithuania describes the prevention and occurrence of corruption in Lithuania.
Corruption in Cyprus is a salient concern for people in Cyprus: As of 2022, 94% considered that corruption was widespread in the country.
Levels of corruption in Luxembourg are generally said to be very low, and there a strong legal framework for combating corruption in the country. Surveys however indicate that a majority of the population believe political parties are either "corrupt" or "extremely corrupt."
Corruption in Slovenia is examined on this page.
Austria has a well-developed institutional and legal system, and most corruption cases under investigation by a parliamentary committee end with judicial trials and effective judgments. However, there are several significant Austrian corruption cases which have taken place during the past decade involving land and regional officials, high-level public officials, the central government and, in one instance, the former Chancellor.
Corruption in Slovakia is a serious and ongoing problem.
The government in Moldova has in recent years taken several steps to fight corruption, including law enforcement and institutional setups. The prosecution of officials who are involved in corruption has also increased in recent years. However, businesses consider corruption a serious problem for doing business, and the business environment continues to be one of the most challenging in the region.
Corruption in Uzbekistan is a serious problem. There are laws in place to prevent corruption, but enforcement in terms of laws regarding corruption is very weak. Low prosecution rates of corrupt officials is another contributing factor to the rampant corruption in Uzbekistan. It is not a criminal offense for a non-public official to influence the discretion of a public official. The judicial system faces severe functional deficits due to limited resources and corruption.
As of the early 2020s, Croatia has severe problems with systemic and political corruption. Among European Union member states, it is generally ranked as one of the five most corrupt states.
Christopher Fearne is a Maltese physician and politician. He was appointed Parliamentary Secretary for Health in April 2014 and Minister for Health since April 2016. In July 2017, the Labour Party elected him as Deputy Leader for Parliamentary Affairs, thus assuming the role of Deputy Prime Minister of Malta and Leader of the House.
Corruption in Bulgaria has decreased in recent years, after a series of reforms implemented through EU guidance. Among recent improvements, amendments to the constitution in 2015 brought about a reform of the Supreme Judicial Council and a stronger judicial inspectorate. Furthermore, the broader legislative framework has seen a number of reforms over the years, in particular through the amendments of the Judicial System Act in 2016 and of the Criminal Procedure Code in 2017.
Vitals Global Healthcare (VGH) was a healthcare company based in Malta. It managed public–private partnerships and worked with Barts and The London School of Medicine and Dentistry.
Corruption in Chad is characterized by nepotism and cronyism. Chad received a score of 20 in the 2023 Transparency International Corruption Perceptions Index on a scale from 0 to 100. When ranked by score, Chad ranked 162nd among the 180 countries in the Index, where the country ranked first is perceived to have the most honest public sector. For comparison with worldwide scores, the best score was 90, the average score was 43, and the worst score was 11. For comparison with regional scores, the average score among sub-Saharan African countries was 33. The highest score in sub-Saharan Africa was 71 and the lowest score was 11.
Corruption in East Timor has been described as a critical and alarming problem because it has been institutionalized in the country. It undermines the governance of the nascent state, which only obtained its independence in 2002. Corruption affects East Timorese socio-economic development and public trust in government institutions.
Corruption in Taiwan is noted for significant anti-corruption strides. Out of 180 countries, Taiwan, or the Republic of China, ranked 28th in Transparency International’s Corruption Perceptions Index (CPI) in 2023. Key issues needing improvements include graft, bribery, and unethical practices.
