The Airbus A380 is a very large wide-body airliner, developed and produced by Airbus. It is the world's largest passenger airliner and the only full-length double-deck jet airliner. Airbus studies started in 1988, and the project was announced in 1990 to challenge the dominance of the Boeing 747 in the long-haul market. The then-designated A3XX project was presented in 1994; Airbus launched the €9.5–billion ($10.7–billion) A380 programme on 19 December 2000. The first prototype was unveiled in Toulouse on 18 January 2005, with its first flight on 27 April 2005. It then obtained its type certificate from the European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and the US Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) on 12 December 2006.
Due to difficulties with the electrical wiring, the initial production was delayed by two years and the development costs almost doubled. It was first delivered to Singapore Airlines on 15 October 2007 and entered service on 25 October. Production peaked at 30 per year in both 2012 and 2014, with production of the aircraft ending in 2021. The A380's estimated $25billion development cost was not recouped by the time Airbus ended production.
The full-length double-deck aircraft has a typical seating for 525 passengers, with a maximum certified capacity for 853 passengers. The quadjet is powered by Engine Alliance GP7200 or Rolls-Royce Trent 900 turbofans providing a range of 8,000nmi (14,800km; 9,200mi).As of December2021[update], the global A380 fleet had completed more than 800,000 flights over 7.3million block hours with no fatalities and no hull losses. As of December2022[update], there were 237 aircraft in service with 16 operators worldwide.
Development
Background
In mid-1988, Airbus engineers, led by Jean Roeder, began work in secret on the development of an ultra-high-capacity airliner (UHCA), both to complete its own range of products and to break the dominance that Boeing had enjoyed in this market segment since the early 1970s with its Boeing 747.[3]:7McDonnell Douglas unsuccessfully offered its double-deck MD-12 concept for sale.[4][5] Lockheed was exploring the possibility for a Very Large Subsonic Transport.[6] Roeder was given approval for further evaluations of the UHCA after a formal presentation to the President and CEO in June 1990.
The megaproject was announced at the 1990 Farnborough Airshow, with the stated goal of 15% lower operating costs than the Boeing 747-400.[3]:16–17 Airbus organised four teams of designers, one from each of its partners (Aérospatiale, British Aerospace, Deutsche Aerospace AG, CASA) to propose new technologies for its future aircraft designs. The designs were presented in 1992 and the most competitive designs were used.[3]:17–18 In January 1993, Boeing and several companies in the Airbus consortium started a joint feasibility study of a Very Large Commercial Transport (VLCT), aiming to form a partnership to share the limited market.[3]:31[7]
In June 1994, Airbus announced its plan to develop its own very large airliner, designated as A3XX.[8][9] Airbus considered several designs, including an unusual side-by-side combination of two fuselages from its A340, the largest Airbus jet at the time.[3]:19 The A3XX was pitted against the VLCT study and Boeing's own New Large Aircraft successor to the 747.[10][11] In July 1995, the joint study with Boeing was abandoned, as Boeing's interest had declined due to analysis that such a product was unlikely to cover the projected $15billion development cost. Despite the fact that only two airlines had expressed public interest in purchasing such a plane, Airbus was already pursuing its own large-plane project. Analysts suggested that Boeing would instead pursue stretching its 747 design, and that air travel was already moving away from the hub-and-spoke system that consolidated traffic into large planes, and toward more non-stop routes that could be served by smaller planes.[12]
From 1997 to 2000, as the 1997 Asian financial crisis darkened the market outlook, Airbus refined its design, targeting a 15–20% reduction in operating costs over the existing Boeing 747-400. The A3XX design converged on a double-decker layout that provided more passenger volume than a traditional single-deck design.[13][14] Airbus did so in line with traditional hub-and-spoke theory, as opposed to the point-to-point theory with the Boeing 777,[15] after conducting an extensive market analysis with over 200 focus groups.[16][17] Although early marketing of the huge cross-section touted the possibility of duty-free shops, restaurant-like dining, gyms, casinos and beauty parlours on board, the realities of airline economics have kept such dreams grounded.
On 19 December 2000, the supervisory board of newly restructured Airbus voted to launch a €9.5 billion ($10.7 billion) project to build the A3XX, re-designated as A380, with 50 firm orders from six launch customers.[18][19][20][21] The A380 designation was a break from previous Airbus families, which had progressed sequentially from A300 to A340. It was chosen because the number 8 resembles the double-deck cross section, and is a lucky number in many East Asian countries where the aircraft was being marketed.[3] The aircraft configuration was finalised in early 2001, and manufacturing of the first A380 wing-box component started on 23 January 2002. The development cost of the A380 had grown to €11–14[22]billion when the first aircraft was completed.
Total development cost
In 2000, the projected development cost was €9.5billion.[23] In 2004, Airbus estimated that €1.5billion ($2billion) would need to be added, totalling the developmental costs to €10.3 billion ($12.7 billion).[24] In 2006, Airbus stopped publishing its reported cost after reaching costs of €10.2billion and then it provisioned another €4.9billion, after the difficulties in electric cabling and two years delay for an estimated total of €18billion.[23]
In 2014, the aircraft was estimated to have cost $25bn (£16bn, €18.9bn) to develop.[25] In 2015, Airbus said development costs were €15billion (£11.4billion, $16.64 billion), though analysts believe the figure is likely to be at least €5bn ($5.55 Bn) more for a €20 Bn ($22.19 Bn) total.[26] In 2016, The A380 development costs were estimated at $25billion for 15 years,[27] $25–30billion,[28] or €25billion ($28billion).[29]
To start the programme in 2000, the governments of France, Germany and the UK loaned Airbus 3.5billion euros and refundable advances reached 5.9billion euros ($7.3billion). In February 2018, after an Emirates order secured production of the unprofitable programme for ten years, Airbus revised its deal with the three loan-giving governments to save $1.4billion (17%) and restructured terms to lower the production rate from eight per year in 2019 to six per year.[30]
On 15 May 2018, in its EU appeal ruling, a WTO ruling concluded that the A380 received improper subsidies through $9billion of launch aids, but Airbus acknowledged that the threat posed to Boeing by the A380 is so marginal with 330 orders since its 2000 launch that any U.S. sanctions should be minimal, as previous rulings showed Boeing's exposure could be as little as $377million.[31] In 2018, unit cost was US$445.6million.[32]
In February 2019, the German government disclosed that it was conducting talks with Airbus regarding €600million in outstanding loans. Following the decision to wind down the A380 programme, Europe argues that the subsidies in effect no longer exist and that no sanctions are warranted.[33]
Production
Geographical logistics sequence for the A380, with final assembly in Toulouse
Major structural sections of the A380 are built in France, Germany, Spain, and the United Kingdom. Due to the sections' large size, traditional transportation methods proved unfeasible,[34] so they are brought to the Jean-Luc Lagardère Plant assembly hall in Toulouse, France, by specialised road and water transportation, though some parts are moved by the A300-600ST Beluga transport aircraft.[35][36] A380 components are provided by suppliers from around the world; the four largest contributors, by value, are Rolls-Royce, Safran, United Technologies and General Electric.[16]
For the surface movement of large A380 structural components, a complex route known as the Itinéraire à Grand Gabarit was developed. This involved the construction of a fleet of roll-on/roll-off (RORO) ships and barges, the construction of port facilities and the development of new and modified roads to accommodate oversized road convoys.[37] The front and rear fuselage sections are shipped on one of three RORO ships from Hamburg in northern Germany to Saint-Nazaire in France. The ship travels via Mostyn, Wales, where the wings are loaded.[38] The wings are manufactured at Broughton in North Wales, then transported by barge to Mostyn docks for ship transport.[39]
Drone footage of a wing being transported from its factory at Broughton, Wales, down the River Dee to Mostyn, and onwards to France, March 2020A380 components on a barge
In Saint-Nazaire, the ship exchanges the fuselage sections from Hamburg for larger, assembled sections, some of which include the nose. This ship unloads in Bordeaux. It then goes to pick up the belly and tail sections from Construcciones Aeronáuticas SA in Cádiz, Spain, and delivers them to Bordeaux. From there, the A380 parts are transported by barge to Langon, and by oversize road convoys to the assembly hall in Toulouse.[40] To avoid damage from direct handling, parts are secured in custom jigs carried on self-powered wheeled vehicles.[34]
After assembly, the aircraft are flown to the Airbus Hamburg-Finkenwerder plant to be furnished and painted. Airbus sized the production facilities and supply chain for a production rate of four A380s per month.[39]
Testing
The first completed A380 at the "A380 Reveal" event in Toulouse, France, 18 January 2005A380 prototype on its maiden flight
On 1 December 2005, the A380 achieved its maximum design speed of Mach0.96, (its design cruise speed is Mach0.85) in a shallow dive.[41] In 2006, the A380 flew its first high-altitude test at Addis Ababa Bole International Airport. It conducted its second high-altitude test at the same airport in 2009.[46] On 10 January 2006, it flew to José María Córdova International Airport in Colombia, accomplishing the transatlantic testing, and then it went to El Dorado International Airport to test the engine operation in high-altitude airports. It arrived in North America on 6 February 2006, landing in Iqaluit, Nunavut, in Canada for cold-weather testing.[47]
On 14 February 2006, during the destructive wing strength certification test on MSN5000, the test wing of the A380 failed at 145% of the limit load, short of the required 150% level. Airbus announced modifications adding 30kg (66lb) to the wing to provide the required strength.[48] On 26 March 2006, the A380 underwent evacuation certification in Hamburg. With 8 of the 16 exits randomly blocked, 853 mixed passengers and 20 crew exited the darkened aircraft in 78 seconds, less than the 90 seconds required for certification.[49][50] Three days later, the A380 received European Aviation Safety Agency (EASA) and United States Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) approval to carry up to 853 passengers.[51]
The first A380 using GP7200 engines—serial number MSN009 and flew on 25 August 2006.[52][53] On 4 September 2006, the first full passenger-carrying flight test took place.[54] The aircraft flew from Toulouse with 474 Airbus employees on board, in a test of passenger facilities and comfort.[54] In November 2006, a further series of route-proving flights demonstrated the aircraft's performance for 150 flight hours under typical airline operating conditions.[55]As of 2014[update], the A380 test aircraft continue to perform test procedures.[56]
Airbus obtained type certificates for the A380-841 and A380-842 model from the EASA and FAA on 12 December 2006 in a joint ceremony at the company's French headquarters,[57][58] receiving the ICAOcode A388.[59] The A380-861 model was added to the type certificate on 14 December 2007.[58]
Production and delivery delays
Bare cabin for flight tests with water tanks as ballast
Initial production of the A380 was troubled by delays attributed to the 530km (330mi) of wiring in each aircraft. Airbus cited as underlying causes the complexity of the cabin wiring (98,000 wires and 40,000 connectors), its concurrent design and production, the high degree of customisation for each airline, and failures of configuration management and change control.[60][61] The German and Spanish Airbus facilities continued to use CATIA version4, while British and French sites migrated to version5.[62] This caused overall configuration management problems, at least in part because wire harnesses manufactured using aluminium rather than copper conductors necessitated special design rules including non-standard dimensions and bend radii; these were not easily transferred between versions of the software.[63] File conversion tools were initially developed by Airbus to help solve this problem; however, the digital mock-up was still unable to read the full technical design data.[64] Furthermore, organisational culture was also cited as a cause of the production delays. The communication and reporting culture at the time frowned upon delivery of bad news, meaning Airbus was unable to take early actions to mitigate technical and production issues.[64]
Airbus announced the first delay in June 2005 and notified airlines that deliveries would be delayed by six months.[62] This reduced the total number of planned deliveries by the end of 2009 from about 120 to 90–100. On 13 June 2006, Airbus announced a second delay, with the delivery schedule slipping an additional six to seven months.[65] Although the first delivery was still planned before the end of 2006, deliveries in 2007 would drop to only 9 aircraft, and deliveries by the end of 2009 would be cut to 70–80 aircraft. The announcement caused a 26% drop in the share price of Airbus' parent, EADS,[66] and led to the departure of EADS CEO Paul Dupont, Airbus CEO Gustav Humbert, and A380 programme manager Charles Champion.[62][67] On 3 October 2006, upon completion of a review of the A380 programme, Airbus CEO Christian Streiff announced a third delay,[62] pushing the first delivery to October 2007, to be followed by 13 deliveries in 2008, 25 in 2009, and the full production rate of 45 aircraft per year in 2010.[68] The delay also increased the earnings shortfall projected by Airbus through 2010 to €4.8billion.[62][69]
As Airbus prioritised the work on the A380-800 over the A380F,[70] freighter orders were cancelled by FedEx[71][72] and United Parcel Service,[73] or converted to A380-800 by Emirates and ILFC.[74] Airbus suspended work on the freighter version, but said it remained on offer,[75] albeit without a service entry date.[76] For the passenger version Airbus negotiated a revised delivery schedule and compensation with the 13 customers, all of which retained their orders with some placing subsequent orders, including Emirates,[77] Singapore Airlines,[78] Qantas,[79] Air France,[80] Qatar Airways,[81] and Korean Air.[82]
Beginning in 2007, the A380 was considered as a potential replacement for the existing Boeing VC-25 serving as Air Force One presidential transport,[83][84] but in January 2009 EADS declared that they were not going to bid for the contract, as assembling only three planes in the US would not make financial sense.[85]
On 13 May 2008, Airbus announced reduced deliveries for the years 2008 (12) and 2009 (21).[86] After further manufacturing setbacks, Airbus announced its plan to deliver 14 A380s in 2009, down from the previously revised target of 18.[87] A total of 10 A380s were delivered in 2009.[88] In 2010, Airbus delivered 18 of the expected 20 A380s, due to Rolls-Royce engine availability problems.[89] Airbus planned to deliver "between 20 and 25" A380s in 2011 before ramping up to three a month in 2012.[89] In fact, Airbus delivered 26 units, thus outdoing its predicted output for the first time. As of July2012[update], production was 3 aircraft per month. Among the production problems are challenging interiors, interiors being installed sequentially rather than concurrently as in smaller planes, and union/government objections to streamlining.[90]
Nicknamed Superjumbo,[91] the first A380, MSN003, was delivered to Singapore Airlines on 15 October 2007 and entered service on 25 October 2007 with flight number SQ380 between Singapore and Sydney.[92] Passengers bought seats in a charity online auction paying between $560 and $100,380.[93] Two months later, Singapore Airlines CEO Chew Choong Seng stated the A380 was performing better than either the airline or Airbus had anticipated, burning 20% less fuel per seat-mile than the airline's 747-400 fleet.[94] Emirates' Tim Clark claimed that the A380 has better fuel economy at Mach 0.86 than at 0.83,[95] and that its technical dispatch reliability is at 97%, the same as Singapore Airlines. Airbus is committed to reach the industry standard of 98.5%.[96]
Emirates was the second airline to receive the A380 and commenced service between Dubai and New York in August 2008.[97][98]Qantas followed, with flights between Melbourne and Los Angeles in October 2008.[99] By the end of 2008, 890,000 passengers had flown on 2,200 flights.[100]
In February 2008, the A380 became the first airliner to fly using synthetic liquid fuel. The fuel is processed from gas to liquid form (GTL fuel). The flight was 3 hours long, taking off from Filton, UK, and landing in Toulouse, France, and was a significant step in evaluating the suitability of sustainable aviation fuels.[101]
Improvements and upgrades
In 2010, Airbus announced a new A380 build standard, incorporating a strengthened airframe structure and a 1.5° increase in wing twist. Airbus also offered, as an option, an improved maximum take-off weight, thus providing a better payload/range performance. Maximum take-off weight is increased by 4t (8,800lb), to 573t (1,263,000lb) and the range is extended by 100 nautical miles (190km; 120mi); this is achieved by reducing flight loads, partly from optimising the fly-by-wire control laws.[102]British Airways and Emirates were the first two customers to have received this new option in 2013.[103] Emirates asked for an update with new engines for the A380 to be competitive with the Boeing 777X around 2020, and Airbus was studying 11-abreast seating.[104]
In 2012, Airbus announced another increase in the A380's maximum take-off weight to 575t (1,268,000lb), a 6t increase from the initial A380 variant and 2t higher than the increased-weight proposal of 2010. This increased the range by some 150 nautical miles (280km; 170mi), taking its capability to around 8,350 nautical miles (15,460km; 9,610mi) at current payloads. The higher-weight version was offered for introduction to service early in 2013.[105]
Post-delivery problems
During repairs following the Qantas Flight 32 engine failure incident, cracks were discovered in wing fittings. As a result, the European Aviation Safety Agency issued an Airworthiness Directive in January 2012 which affected 20 A380 aircraft that had accumulated over 1,300 flights.[106] A380s with under 1,800 flight hours were to be inspected within 6 weeks or 84 flights; aircraft with over 1,800 flight hours were to be examined within four days or 14 flights.[107][108] Fittings found to be cracked were replaced.[109] On 8 February 2012, the checks were extended to cover all 68 A380 aircraft in operation. The problem is considered to be minor and is not expected to affect operations.[110] EADS acknowledged that the cost of repairs would be over $130million, to be borne by Airbus. The company said the problem was traced to stress and material used for the fittings.[111] Additionally, major airlines are seeking compensation from Airbus for revenue lost as a result of the cracks and subsequent grounding of fleets.[112] Airbus has switched to a different type of aluminium alloy so aircraft delivered from 2014 onwards should not have this problem.[113]
Around 2014, Airbus changed about 10% of all A380 doors, as some leaked during flight. One occurrence resulted in dropped oxygen masks and an emergency landing. The switch was estimated to cost over €100million. Airbus stated that safety was sufficient, as the air pressure pushed the door into the frame.[114][115][116]
Further continuation of programme
At the July 2016 Farnborough Airshow, Airbus announced that in a "prudent, proactive step", starting in 2018, it expected to deliver 12 A380 aircraft per year, down from 27 deliveries in 2015. The firm also warned production might slip back into red ink (be unprofitable) on each aircraft produced at that time, though it anticipated production would remain in the black (profitable) for 2016 and 2017. "The company will continue to improve the efficiency of its industrial system to achieve breakeven at 20 aircraft in 2017 and targets additional cost reduction initiatives to lower breakeven further."[117][118] Airbus expected that healthy demand for its other aircraft would allow it to avoid job losses from the cuts.[119][120]
As Airbus expected to build 15 airliners in 2017 and 12 in 2018, Airbus Commercial Aircraft president Fabrice Brégier said that, without orders in 2017, production would be reduced to below one per month while remaining profitable per unit and allowing the programme to continue for 20 to 30 years.[121] In its 2017 half-year report, Airbus adjusted 2019 deliveries to eight aircraft.[122] In November 2017, its chief executive Tom Enders was confident Airbus would still produce A380s in 2027 with more sales to come, and further develop it to keep it competitive beyond 2030.[123] Airbus was profitable at a rate of 15 per year and is trying to drive breakeven down further but will take losses at eight per year.[124]
An order from Emirates for 36 A380s would have ensured production beyond 2020, but the airline wanted guarantees that production would be maintained for 10 years, until 2028: reducing output to six a year would help to bridge that period and would support second-hand values while other buyers are approached, but the programme would still be unprofitable.[125] If it had failed to win the Emirates order, Airbus claimed that it was ready to phase out its production gradually as it fulfilled remaining orders until the early 2020s.[126] In January 2018, Emirates confirmed the order for 36 A380s,[127][128] but the deal was thrown back into question in October 2018 over a disagreement regarding engine fuel burn.[129]
To extend the programme, Airbus offered China a production role in early 2018.[130] While state-owned Chinese airlines could order A380s, it would not help their low yield, as it lowers frequency; they do not need more volume as widebody aircraft are already used on domestic routes and using the A380 on its intended long-haul missions would free only a few airport slots.[131]
After achieving efficiencies to sustain production at a lower level, in 2017, Airbus delivered 15 A380s and was "very close" to production breakeven, expecting to make additional savings as production was being further reduced: it planned to deliver 12 in 2018, eight in 2019 and six per year from 2020 with "digestible" losses.As of February2018[update], Enders was confident the A380 would gain additional orders from existing or new operators, and saw opportunities in Asia and particularly in China where it is "under-represented".[132]
In 2019, Lufthansa had retired 6 of its 14 A380s due to their unprofitability. Later that year, Qatar Airways announced a switch from the A380 to the Boeing 777X starting from 2024.[133]
End of production
A6-EVS, the last A380 to roll off the production line at Toulouse, photographed at Heathrow Airport on 19 November 2022. This aircraft, serial number 272, entered service with Emirates on 16 December 2021.
In February 2019, Airbus announced it would end A380 production by 2021, after its main customer, Emirates, agreed to drop an order for 39 of the aircraft, replacing it with 40 A330-900s and 30 A350-900s.[134] At the time of the announcement, Airbus had 17 more A380s on its order book to complete before closing the production line–14 for Emirates and three for All Nippon Airways–taking the total number of expected deliveries of the aircraft type to 251.[135][136] Airbus would have needed more than $90million profit from the sale of each aircraft to cover the estimated $25billion development cost of the programme. However, the $445million price tag of each aircraft was not sufficient to even cover the production cost. With orders decreasing, the decision was made to cease production.[137][138] Enders stated on 14 February 2019, "If you have a product that nobody wants anymore, or you can sell only below production cost, you have to stop it."[139]
One reason that the A380 did not achieve commercial viability for Airbus has been attributed to its extremely large capacity being optimised for a hub-and-spoke system, which was projected by Airbus to be thriving when the programme was conceived. However, airlines underwent a fundamental transition to a point-to-point system, which gets customers to their destination in one flight instead of two or three. The massive scale of the A380 design was able to achieve a very low cost for passenger seat-distance, but efficiency within the hub-and-spoke paradigm was not able to overcome the efficiency of fewer flights required in the point-to-point system. Specifically, US based carriers had been using a multihub strategy, which only justified the need for a handful of VLAs (very large aircraft with more than 400 seats) such as the A380, and having too few VLAs meant that they could not achieve economy of scale to spread out the enormous fixed cost of the VLA support infrastructure.[140] Consequently, orders for VLAs slowed in the mid 2010s, as widebody twin jets now offer similar range and greater fuel efficiency, giving airlines more flexibility at a lower upfront cost.[141][142][143][144]
On 25 September 2020, Airbus completed assembly of the final A380 fuselage. Nine aircraft remained to be delivered (eight for Emirates, one for All Nippon Airways) and production operations continued to finish those aircraft. On 17 March 2021, the final Airbus A380 (manufacturing serial number 272) made its maiden flight from Toulouse to Hamburg for cabin outfitting,[145] before being delivered to Emirates on 16 December 2021.[146][147]
The A380 was initially offered in two models: the A380-800 and the A380F.
The A380-800's original configuration carried 555 passengers in a three-class configuration[148] or 853 passengers (538 on the main deck and 315 on the upper deck) in a single-class economy configuration. Then in May 2007, Airbus began marketing a configuration with 30 fewer passengers (525 total in three classes)—traded for 200nmi; 230mi (370km) more range—to better reflect trends in premium-class accommodation.[149] The design range for the A380−800 model is 8,500nmi (15,700km);[150] capable of flying from Hong Kong to New York or from Sydney to Istanbul non-stop. The A380 is designed for 19,000 cycles.[151]
The second model, the A380F freighter, would have carried 150t (330,000lb) of cargo over a range of 5,600nmi (10,400km; 6,400mi).[152] Freighter development was put on hold as Airbus prioritised the passenger version, and all orders for freighters were cancelled.
Other proposed variants included an A380-900 stretch–seating about 656 passengers (or up to 960 passengers in an all-economy configuration)–and an extended-range version with the same passenger capacity as the A380-800.[3]
The A380 is offered with the Rolls-Royce Trent 900 (A380-841/-842) or the Engine Alliance GP7000 (A380-861) turbofan engines.[153] The Trent 900 is a combination of the 3m (118in) fan and scaled IP compressor of the 777-200X/300X Trent 8104 technology demonstrator derived from the Boeing 777's Trent 800, and the Airbus A340-500/600's Trent 500 core. The GP7200 HP core technology is derived from GE's GE90 and its LP sections are based on the PW4000 expertise.[154] At its launch in 2000, engine makers assured Airbus it was getting the best level of technology and they would be state-of-the-art for the next decade, but three years later Boeing launched the 787 Dreamliner with game-changing technology and 10% lower fuel burn than the previous generation, to the dismay of John Leahy.[155]
Due to its modern engines and aerodynamic improvements, Lufthansa's A380s produce half the noise of the Boeing 747-200 while carrying 160 more passengers.[156] In 2012, the A380 received an award from the Noise Abatement Society.[157]
London Heathrow is a key destination for the A380.[3] The aircraft is below the QC/2 departure and QC/0.5 arrival noise limits under the Quota Count system set by the airport.[158] Field measurements suggest the approach quota allocation for the A380 may be excessively generous compared to the older Boeing 747, but still quieter.[159][160] Rolls-Royce is supporting the CAA in understanding the relatively high A380/Trent 900 monitored noise levels.[161] Heathrow's landing charges having a noise component, the A380 is cheaper to land there than a Boeing 777-200 and -300 and it saves $4,300 to $5,200 per landing, or $15.3M to $18.8M of present value over 15 years. Tokyo Narita has a similar noise charge.[162]
The A380 has thrust reversers on the inboard engines only. The outboard engines lack them, reducing the amount of debris stirred up during landing.[163][164] The combination of wheel braking and large spoilers and flaps reduces the aircraft's reliance on thrust reversal.[163] The reversers are electrically actuated to save weight, and for greater reliability than pneumatic or hydraulic equivalents.[165] Having reversers on only two engines also saves a great deal of maintenance expense for operators as well as avoiding unnecessary weight to the outboard engines.[163]
Wings
Planform view showing moderate wing aspect ratio and the undercarriageComposite photo of a structural loading test on the left wing box
The A380's wings are built for a maximum takeoff weight (MTOW) over 600tonnes to accommodate larger variants—the A380F freighter would require added internal strengthening.[3][166] The optimal wingspan for such an MTOW is about 90m (300ft) but airport restrictions of 80m (260ft) force the A380 to compensate with a longer chord for an aspect ratio of 7.8.[104] This suboptimal aspect ratio reduces fuel efficiency[104] by about 10% and increases operating costs several percent,[167] considering fuel costs constitute about 50% of the cost of long-haul aeroplane operation.[168] The common wing design approach sacrifices fuel efficiency on the A380-800 passenger model in particular because its lower MTOW allows for a higher aspect ratio with a shorter chord or thinner wing.
Still, Airbus estimated that the A380's size and advanced technology would provide lower operating costs per passenger than the 747-400. The wings incorporate wingtip fences that extend above and below the wing surface, similar to those on the A310 and A320. These increase fuel efficiency and range by reducing induced drag.[169] The wingtip fences also reduce wake turbulence, which endangers following aircraft.[170] The wings of the A380 were designed in Filton and manufactured in Broughton in the United Kingdom. The wings were then transported to the harbour of Mostyn, where they were transported by barge to Toulouse, France, for integration and final assembly with the rest of the aircraft and its components.[171]
Singapore Airlines describe the A380's landing speed of 130–135kn (240–250km/h) as "impressively slow".[172]
Materials
While most of the fuselage is made of aluminium alloys, composite materials comprise more than 20% of the A380's airframe.[173]Carbon-fibre reinforced plastic, glass-fibre reinforced plastic and quartz-fibre reinforced plastic are used extensively in wings, fuselage sections (such as the undercarriage and rear end of fuselage), tail surfaces, and doors.[174][175][176] The A380 is the first commercial airliner to have a central wing box made of carbon–fibre reinforced plastic. It is also the first to have a smoothly contoured wing cross–section. The wings of other commercial airliners are partitioned span-wise into sections. This flowing continuous cross section reduces aerodynamic drag. Thermoplastics are used in the leading edges of the slats.[177]
The hybrid fibre metal laminate material GLARE (glass laminate aluminium reinforced epoxy) is used in the upper fuselage and on the stabilisers' leading edges.[178] This aluminium-glass-fibrelaminate is lighter and has better corrosion and impact resistance than conventional aluminium alloys used in aviation.[179] Unlike earlier composite materials, GLARE can be repaired using conventional aluminium repair techniques.[citation needed]
Newer weldable aluminium alloys are used in the A380's airframe. This enabled the widespread use of laser beam welding manufacturing techniques, eliminating rows of rivets and resulting in a lighter, stronger structure.[180] High-strength aluminium (type 7449)[181] reinforced with carbon fibre was used in the wing brackets of the first 120 A380s to reduce weight, but cracks were discovered and newer sets of the more critical brackets are made of standard aluminium 7010, increasing weight by 90kg (198lb).[182] Repair costs for earlier aircraft were expected to be around €500million (US$629million).[183]
It takes 3,600L (950USgal) of paint to cover the 3,100m2 (33,000sqft) exterior of an A380.[184] The paint is five layers thick and weighs about 650kg (1,433lb) when dry.[185]
Airbus used similar cockpit layout, procedures and handling characteristics to other Airbus aircraft, reducing crew training costs. The A380 has an improved glass cockpit, using fly-by-wire flight controls linked to side-sticks.[191][192] The cockpit has eight 15 by 20cm (5.9 by 7.9in)liquid crystal displays, all physically identical and interchangeable; comprising two primary flight displays, two navigation displays, one engine parameter display, one system display and two multi-function displays. The MFDs were introduced on the A380 to provide an easy-to-use interface to the flight management system—replacing three multifunction control and display units.[193] They include QWERTY keyboards and trackballs, interfacing with a graphical "point-and-click" display system.[194][195]
The Network Systems Server (NSS) is the heart of A380s paperless cockpit; it eliminates bulky manuals and traditional charts.[196][197] The NSS has enough inbuilt robustness to eliminate onboard backup paper documents. The A380s network and server system stores data and offers electronic documentation, providing a required equipment list, navigation charts, performance calculations, and an aircraft logbook. This is accessed through the MFDs and controlled via the keyboard interface.[190]
Power-by-wire flight control actuators have been used for the first time in civil aviation to back up primary hydraulic actuators. Also, during certain manoeuvres they augment the primary actuators.[198] They have self-contained hydraulic and electrical power supplies. Electro-hydrostatic actuators (EHA) are used in the aileron and elevator, electric and hydraulic motors to drive the slats as well as electrical backup hydrostatic actuators (EBHA) for the rudder and some spoilers.[199]
The A380's 350bar (35MPa or 5,000psi) hydraulic system is a significant difference from the typical 210bar (21MPa or 3,000psi) hydraulics used on most commercial aircraft since the 1940s.[200][201] First used in military aircraft, high-pressure hydraulics reduce the weight and size of pipelines, actuators and related components. The 350bar pressure is generated by eight de-clutchable hydraulic pumps.[201][202] The hydraulic lines are typically made from titanium; the system features both fuel- and air-cooled heat exchangers. Self-contained electrically powered hydraulic power packs serve as backups for the primary systems, instead of a secondary hydraulic system, saving weight and reducing maintenance.[203]
The A380 uses four 150kVA variable-frequency electrical generators,[204] eliminating constant-speed drives and improving reliability.[205] The A380 uses aluminium power cables instead of copper for weight reduction. The electrical power system is fully computerised and many contactors and breakers have been replaced by solid-state devices for better performance and increased reliability.[199]
The auxiliary power comprises the Auxiliary Power Unit (APU), the electronic control box (ECB), and mounting hardware. The APU in use on the A380 is the 1,300kW PW 980A APU. The APU primarily provides air to power the Analysis Ground Station (AGS) on the ground and to start the engines. The AGS is a semi-automatic analysis system of flight data that helps to optimise management of maintenance and reduce costs. The APU also powers two 120kVA electric generators that provide auxiliary electric power to the aircraft. There is also a ram air turbine (RAT) with a 70kVA generator.[206]
Ten-abreast old economy class seating on the main deck on an Emirates A380
The A380-800's cabin has 550 square metres (5,920sqft) of usable floor space,[207] 40% more than the next largest airliner, the Boeing 747-8.[208]
The cabin has features to reduce traveller fatigue such as a quieter interior and higher pressurisation than previous generations of aircraft; the A380 is pressurised to the equivalent altitude of 1,520m (5,000ft) up to 12,000m (39,000ft).[209][3]:129 It has 50% less cabin noise, 50% more cabin area and volume, larger windows, bigger overhead bins, and 60cm (2.0ft) more headroom than the 747-400.[210][211] Seating options range from 3-room 12m2 (130sqft) "residence" in first class to 11-across in economy.[212] A380 economy seats are up to 48cm (19in) wide in a 10-abreast configuration,[213] compared with the 10-abreast configuration on the 747-400 that typically has seats 44.5cm (17.5in) wide.[214] On other aircraft, economy seats range from 41.5 to 52.3cm (16.3 to 20.6in) in width.[215]
The A380's upper and lower decks are connected by two stairways, one fore and one aft, both wide enough to accommodate two passengers side by side; this cabin arrangement allows multiple seat configurations. The maximum certified carrying capacity is 853 passengers in an all-economy-class layout,[49] Airbus lists the "typical" three-class layout as accommodating 525 passengers, with 10 first, 76 business, and 439 economy class seats.[149] Airline configurations range from Korean Air's 407 passengers to Emirates' two-class 615 seats[216] and average around 480–490 seats.[217][218]Air Austral's proposed 840 passenger layout has not come to fruition. The A380's interior illumination system uses bulbless LEDs in the cabin, cockpit, and cargo decks. The LEDs in the cabin can be altered to create an ambience simulating daylight, night, or intermediate levels.[219] On the outside of the aircraft, HID lighting is used for brighter illumination.
Airbus's publicity has stressed the comfort and space of the A380 cabin,[220] and advertised onboard relaxation areas such as bars, beauty salons, duty-free shops, and restaurants.[221][222] Proposed amenities resembled those installed on earlier airliners, particularly 1970s wide-body jets,[223] which largely gave way to regular seats for greater passenger capacity.[223] Airbus has acknowledged that some cabin proposals were unlikely to be installed,[222] and that it was ultimately the airlines' decision how to configure the interior.[223] Industry analysts suggested that implementing customisation has slowed the production speeds, and raised costs.[224] Due to delivery delays, Singapore Airlines and Air France debuted their seat designs on different aircraft prior to the A380.[225][226]
Initial operators typically configured their A380s for three-class service, while adding extra features for passengers in premium cabins. Launch customer Singapore Airlines introduced partly enclosed first-class suites on its A380s in 2007, each featuring a leather seat with a separate bed; center suites could be joined to create a double bed.[227][228][229] A year later, Qantas debuted a new first-class seat-bed and a sofa lounge at the front of the upper deck on its A380s,[230][231] and in 2009, Air France unveiled an upper deck electronic art gallery.[232] In late 2008, Emirates introduced "shower spas" in first class on its A380s allowing each first class passenger five minutes of hot water,[233][234] drawing on 2.5 tonnes of water, although only 60% of it was used.[235]
Etihad Airways and Qatar Airways also have a bar lounge and seating area on the upper deck, while Etihad has enclosed areas for two people each.[236] In addition to lounge areas, some A380 operators have installed amenities consistent with other aircraft in their respective fleets, including self-serve snack bars,[237]premium economy sections,[226] and redesigned business-class seating.[225]
The Hamburg Aircraft Interiors Expo in April 2015 saw the presentation of an 11-seat row economy cabin for the A380. Airbus is reacting to a changing economy; the recession which began in 2008 saw a drop in market percentage of first class and business seats to six percent and an increase in budget economy travellers. Among other causes is the reluctance of employers to pay for executives to travel in First or Business Class. Airbus' chief of cabin marketing, Ingo Wuggestzer, told Aviation Week and Space Technology that the standard three-class cabin no longer reflected market conditions. The 11-seat row on the A380 is accompanied by similar options on other widebodies: nine across on the Airbus A330 and ten across on the A350.[238]
In the 1990s, aircraft manufacturers were planning to introduce larger planes than the Boeing 747. In a common effort of the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO) with manufacturers, airports and its member agencies, the "80-metre box" was created, the airport gates allowing planes up to 80m (260ft) wingspan and length to be accommodated.[239] Airbus designed the A380 according to these guidelines,[240][241] and to operate safely on Group V runways and taxiways with a 60 metres (200ft) loadbearing width.[242] The US FAA initially opposed this,[243][244] then in July 2007, the FAA and EASA agreed to let the A380 operate on 45m (148ft) runways without restrictions.[245] The A380-800 is approximately 30% larger in overall size than the 747-400.[246][247] Runway lighting and signage may need changes to provide clearance to the wings and avoid blast damage from the engines. Runways, runway shoulders and taxiway shoulders may be required to be stabilised to reduce the likelihood of foreign object damage caused to (or by) the outboard engines, which are more than 25m (82ft) from the centre line of the aircraft,[240][242][248] compared to 21m (69ft) for the 747-400,[249] and 747-8.[250]
Airbus measured pavement loads using a 540-tonne (595short tons) ballasted test rig, designed to replicate the landing gear of the A380. The rig was towed over a section of pavement at Airbus's facilities that had been instrumented with embedded load sensors.[251] It was determined that the pavement of most runways will not need to be reinforced despite the higher weight,[248] as it is distributed on more wheels than in other passenger aircraft with a total of 22 wheels (that is, its ground pressure is lower).[252] The A380 undercarriage consists of four main landing gear legs and one noseleg (a layout similar to that of the 747), with the two inboard landing gear legs each supporting six wheels.[252][253]
The A380 requires service vehicles with lifts capable of reaching the upper deck,[254] as well as tractors capable of handling the A380's maximum ramp weight.[255] When using two jetway bridges the boarding time is 45 min, and when using an extra jetway to the upper deck it is reduced to 34 min.[256] The A380 has an airport turnaround time of 90–110 minutes.[235] In 2008, the A380 test aircraft were used to trial the modifications made to several airports to accommodate the type.[257]
In 2005, the ICAO recommended that provisional separation criteria for the A380 on takeoff[259] and landing be substantially greater than for the 747 because preliminary flight test data suggested a stronger wake turbulence.[260][261] These criteria were in effect while the ICAO's wake vortex steering group, with representatives from the JAA, Eurocontrol, the FAA, and Airbus, refined its 3-year study of the issue with additional flight testing. In September 2006, the working group presented its first conclusions to the ICAO.[262][263]
In November 2006, the ICAO issued new interim recommendations. Replacing a blanket 10 nautical miles (19km; 12mi) separation for aircraft trailing an A380 during approach, the new distances were 6nmi (11km; 6.9mi), 8nmi (15km; 9.2mi) and 10nmi (19km; 12mi) respectively for non-A380 "Heavy", "Medium", and "Light" ICAO aircraft categories. These compared with the 4nmi (7.4km; 4.6mi), 5nmi (9.3km; 5.8mi) and 6nmi (11km; 6.9mi) spacing applicable to other "Heavy" aircraft. Another A380 following an A380 should maintain a separation of 4nmi (7.4km). On departure behind an A380, non-A380 "Heavy" aircraft are required to wait two minutes, and "Medium"/"Light" aircraft three minutes for time based operations. The ICAO also recommends that pilots append the term "Super" to the aircraft's callsign when initiating communication with air traffic control, to distinguish the A380 from "Heavy" aircraft.[264]
In August 2008, the ICAO issued revised approach separations of 4nmi (7.4km; 4.6mi) for Super (another A380), 6nmi (11km; 6.9mi) for Heavy, 7nmi (13km; 8.1mi) for medium/small, and 8nmi (15km; 9.2mi) for light.[265] In November 2008, an incident on a parallel runway during crosswinds made the Australian authorities change procedures for those conditions.[266]
Maintenance
As the A380 fleet grows older, airworthiness authority rules require certain scheduled inspections from approved aircraft tool shops. The increasing fleet size (at the time projected to reach 286 aircraft in 2020) cause expected maintenance and modification to cost $6.8billion for 2015–2020, of which $2.1billion are for engines. Emirates performed its first 3C-check for 55 days in 2014. During lengthy shop stays, some airlines will use the opportunity to install new interiors.[267]
Operational history
In February 2009, the one millionth passenger was flown with Singapore Airlines[268] and by May of that year 1,500,000 passengers had flown on 4,200 flights.[269]Air France received its first A380 in October 2009.[270][271]Lufthansa received its first A380 in May 2010.[272] By July 2010, the 31 A380s then in service had transported 6 million passengers on 17,000 flights between 20 international destinations.[273]
Airbus delivered the 100th A380 on 14 March 2013 to Malaysia Airlines.[274] In June 2014, over 65 million passengers had flown the A380,[275] and more than 100 million passengers (averaging 375 per flight) by September 2015, with an availability of 98.5%.[276] In 2014, Emirates stated that its A380 fleet had load factors of 90–100%, and that the popularity of the aircraft with its passengers had not decreased in the past year.[235]
On 16 December 2021, the largest customer Emirates received its 123rd A380 in Hamburg, which was the 251st and the last Superjumbo delivered by Airbus. The airline's strategy has enabled A380 teams to develop new innovations on an ongoing basis and improve the aircraft's operational performance by up to 99.3%, a level never seen before on a quadjet airliner. Many of the innovations developed on the Emirates A380 cabin were a first for Airbus, such as the first class showers, lighting scenarios and the recent premium economy cabin. The close collaboration has shaped the identity of the A380 over the years and continues to transform the passenger experience today.[1]
By December 2021[update], the global A380 fleet had carried over 300 million passengers to more than 70 destinations and completed more than 800,000 flights over 7.3million block hours with 99 percent operational reliability and no hull-loss accidents. Over 50% of A380 capacity is from/to/within the Asia-Pacific region, of which around 15% is on regional flights within Asia (OAG 2017).[277]
Variants proposed but not produced
A380F
The A380F, a cargo variant of the A380, was planned but postponed after 2005 and never built.
Airbus offered a cargo aircraft variant, called the A380F, since at least June 2005, capable of transporting a 150t (330,000lb) maximum payload over a 5,600nmi (10,400km; 6,400mi) range.[152] It would have had 7% better payload and better range than the Boeing 747-8F, but also higher trip costs.[278] It would have the largest payload capacity of any freighter aircraft except the Antonov An-225 Mriya.
Production was suspended until the A380 production lines had settled, with no firm availability date.[70][71][72] The A380F was displayed on the Airbus website until at least January 2013,[279][non-primary source needed] but was not anymore in April.[280][non-primary source needed] A patent for a "combi" version was applied for. This version would offer the flexibility of carrying both passengers and cargo, along with being rapidly reconfigurable to expand or contract the cargo area and passenger area as needed for a given flight.[281]
A380 Stretch, A380-900
At launch in December 2000, a 656-seat A380-200 was proposed as a derivative of the 555-seat baseline, called the A380 Stretch.[282]
In November 2007, Airbus top sales executive and chief operating officer John Leahy confirmed plans for another enlarged variant—the A380-900—with more seating space than the A380-800.[283] The A380-900 would have had a seating capacity for 650 passengers in standard configuration and for approximately 900 passengers in an economy-only configuration.[284] Airlines that expressed an interest in the A380-900 included Emirates,[285]Virgin Atlantic,[286]Cathay Pacific,[287]Air France, KLM, Lufthansa,[288]Kingfisher Airlines,[289] and leasing company ILFC.[290] In May 2010, Airbus announced that A380-900 development would be postponed until production of the A380-800 stabilised.[291]
On 11 December 2014, at the annual Airbus Investor Day forum, Airbus CEO Fabrice Bregier controversially announced, "We will one day launch an A380neo and one day launch a stretched A380".[292] This statement followed speculation sparked by Airbus CFO Harald Wilhelm that Airbus could possibly axe the A380 ahead of its time due to softening demand.[293]
On 15 June 2015, John Leahy, Airbus's chief operating officer for customers, stated that Airbus was again looking at the A380-900 programme. Airbus's newest concept would be a stretch of the A380-800 offering 50 seats more—not 100 seats as originally envisaged. This stretch would be tied to a potential re-engining of the A380-800. According to Flight Global, an A380-900 would make better use of the A380's existing wing.[294]
A380neo
On 15 June 2015, Reuters reported that Airbus was discussing an improved and stretched version of the A380 with at least six customers. The aircraft, called the A380neo, featured new engines and would accommodate an additional fifty passengers. Deliveries to customers were planned for sometime in 2020 or 2021.[295] On 19 July 2015, Airbus CEO Fabrice Brégier stated that the company will build a new version of the A380 featuring new improved wings and new engines.[296] Speculation about the development of a so-called A380neo ("neo" for "new engine option") had been going on for a few months after earlier press releases in 2014,[297] and in 2015, the company was considering whether to end production of the type prior to 2018[293] or develop a new A380 variant. Later it was revealed that Airbus was looking at both the possibility of a longer A380 in line of the previously planned A380-900[298] and a new engine version, i.e. A380neo. Brégier also revealed that the new variant would be ready to enter service by 2020.[299] The engine would most likely be one of a variety of all-new options from Rolls-Royce, ranging from derivatives of the A350's XWB-84/97 to the future Advance project due at around 2020.[300][301]
On 3 June 2016, Emirates President Tim Clark stated that talks between Emirates and Airbus on the A380neo have "lapsed".[302] On 12 June 2017, Fabrice Brégier confirmed that Airbus would not launch an A380neo, stating "...there is no business case to do that, this is absolutely clear." However, Brégier stated it would not stop Airbus from looking at what could be done to improve the performance of the aircraft. One such proposal is a 32ft (9.8m) wingspan extension to reduce drag and increase fuel efficiency by 4%,[303] though further increase is likely to be seen on the aircraft with new Sharklets like on the A380plus.[303] Tim Clark stated the proposed re-engining would have offered a 12–14% fuel-burn reduction with an enhanced Trent XWB.[304]
In June 2023, despite A380 production having ceased, Clark renewed his plea for a re-engined A380neo, suggesting that a next-generation Rolls-Royce UltraFan could give a 25% reduction in fuel burn and emissions.[305]
A380plus
The winglet (mockup) on the A380plus
At the June 2017 Paris Air Show, Airbus proposed an enhanced variant, called the A380plus, with 13% lower costs per seat, featuring up to 80 more seats through better use of cabin space, split scimitar winglets and wing refinements allowing a 4% fuel economy improvement, and longer aircraft maintenance intervals with less downtime.[306] The A380plus' maximum takeoff weight would have been increased by 3t (6,600lb) to 578t (1,274,000lb), allowing it to carry more passengers over the same 8,200nmi (15,200km; 9,400mi) range or increase the range by 300nmi (560km; 350mi).
Winglet mockups, 4.7m (15ft 5in) high, were displayed on the MSN04 test aircraft at Le Bourget. Wing twist would have been modified and camber changed by increasing its height by 33 millimetres (1+1⁄4in) between Rib 10 and Rib 30, along with upper-belly fairing improvements. The in-flight entertainment, the flight management system and the fuel pumps would be from the A350 to reduce weight and improve reliability and fuel economy. Light checks for the A380plus would be required after 1,000h instead of 750h and heavy check downtime would be reduced to keep the aircraft flying for six days more per year.[307]
In its 2000 Global Market Forecast, Airbus estimated a demand for 1,235 passenger Very Large Aircraft (VLA), with more than 400 seats: 360 up to 2009 and 875 by 2019.[308] In late 2003, Boeing forecast 320 "Boeing 747 and larger" passenger aircraft over 20 years, close to the 298 orders actually placed for the A380 and 747-8 passenger airliners as of March 2020.[309]
In 2007, Airbus estimated a demand for 1,283 VLAs in the following 20 years if airport congestion remains constant, up to 1,771 VLAs if congestion increases, with most deliveries (56%) in Asia-Pacific, and 415 very large, 120-tonne plus freighters.[310] For the same period, Boeing was estimating the demand for 590 large (747 or A380) passenger airliners and 630 freighters.[311] Estimates for the total over a twenty-year period have varied from 400 to over 1,700.[16][312]
Frequency and capacity
In 2013, Cathay Pacific and Singapore Airlines needed to balance frequency and capacity.[313]China Southern struggled for two years to use its A380s from Beijing, and finally received Boeing 787s in its base in Guangzhou, but where it cannot command a premium, unlike Beijing or Shanghai.[314][315] In 2013, Air France withdrew A380 services to Singapore and Montreal and switched to smaller aircraft.[316]
In 2014, British Airways replaced three 777 flights between London and Los Angeles with two A380 per day.[317] Emirates' Tim Clark saw a large potential for East Asian A380-users, and criticised Airbus' marketing efforts.[318] As many business travellers prefer more choices offered by greater flight frequency achieved by flying any given route multiple times on smaller aircraft, rather than fewer flights on larger planes, United Airlines observed the A380 "just doesn't really work for us" with a much higher trip cost than the Boeing 787.[319]
At the A380 launch, most Europe-Asia and transpacific routes used Boeing 747-400s at fairly low frequencies but, since then, routes proliferated with open skies, and most airlines downsized, offering higher frequencies and more routes. The huge capacity offered by each flight eroded the yield: North America was viewed as 17% of the market but the A380 never materialised as a 747 replacement, with only 15 747s remaining in passenger service in November 2017 for transpacific routes, where time zones restrict potential frequency. Consolidation changed the networks, and US majors constrained capacity and emphasised daily frequencies for business traffic with midsize widebodies like the 787, to extract higher yields; the focus being on profits, with market share ceded to Asian carriers.[308]
The 747 was largely replaced on transatlantic flights by the 767, and on the transpacific flights by the 777[citation needed]; newer, smaller aircraft with similar seat-mile costs have lower trip costs and allow more direct routes. Cabin 'densification', to lower unit costs, could aggravate this overcapacity.[308]
Production
In 2005, 270 sales were necessary to attain break-even and with 751 expected deliveries its internal rate of return outlook was at 19%, but due to disruptions in the ramp-up leading to overcosts and delayed deliveries, it increased to 420 in 2006.[320] In 2010, EADS CFO Hans Peter Ring said that break-even could be achieved by 2015 when 200 deliveries were projected.[321] In 2012, Airbus clarified that the aircraft production costs would be less than its sales price.[90]
On 11 December 2014, Airbus chief financial officer Harald Wilhelm hinted the possibility of ending the programme in 2018, disappointing Emirates president Tim Clark.[322] Airbus shares fell down consequently.[323] Airbus responded to the protests by playing down the possibility the A380 would be abandoned, instead emphasising that enhancing the aeroplane was a likelier scenario.[324] On 22 December 2014, as the jet was about to break even, Airbus CEO Fabrice Brégier ruled out cancelling it.[325]
Ten years after its first flight, Brégier said it was "almost certainly introduced ten years too early".[326] While no longer losing money on each plane sold, Airbus admits that the company will never recoup the $25billion investment it made in the project.[327]
Airbus consistently forecast 1,400 VLA demand over 20-year, still in 2017, and aimed to secure a 50% share, up to 700 units, but delivered 215 aircraft in 10 years, achieving three produced per month but not the four per month target after the ramp-up to achieve more than 350 and is now declining to 0.5 a month. As Boeing see the VLA market as too small to retain in its 2017 forecast, its VP marketing Randy Tinseth does not believe Airbus will deliver the rest of the backlog.[308]
Richard Aboulafia predicted a 2020 final delivery, with unpleasant losses due to "hubris, shoddy market analysis, nationalism and simple wishful thinking". In 2017, the A380 fleet exceeded the number of remaining passenger B747s, which had declined from 740 aircraft when the A380 was launched in 2000 to 550 units when the A380 was introduced in 2007, and around 200 ten years later. However, the market-share battle has shifted to large single-aisles and 300-seat twin-aisles.[308]
Cost
As of 2016[update], the list price of an A380 was US$432.6million.[328] Negotiated discounts made the actual prices much lower, and industry experts questioned whether the A380 project would ever pay for itself.[90] The first aircraft was sold and leased back by Singapore Airlines in 2007 to Dr. Peters for $197million.[329] In 2016, IAG's Willie Walsh said he could add a few, but also that he found the price of new aircraft "outrageous" and would source them from the second-hand market.[308]
AirInsight estimates its hourly cost at $26,000, or around $50 per seat hour (when configured for only 520 seats), which compares to $44 per seat hour for a Boeing 777-300ER, and $90 per seat hour for a Boeing 747-400as of November2015[update].[330] The A380 was designed with large wing and tail surfaces to accommodate a planned stretch; this resulted in a high empty weight per seat.[308] The stretch never occurred to take advantage of this, and the A380's cost-per-seat is expected to be matched by the A350-1000 and 777-9.[308]
Economic aspects
With a theoretical maximum seating capacity of 853 seats, which is not used by any airline, the Airbus A380 consumes 2.4 liters of kerosene per 100 passenger kilometers. This increases with a reduced seating capacity from 555 to 3.5 l/100 pkm and is 5.2 liters of kerosene per 100 passenger kilometers in the smallest possible variant with only 362 seats.[331]
As of 2015, several airlines expressed their interest in selling their aircraft, partially coinciding with expiring lease contracts for the aircraft. Several in-service A380s were offered for lease to other airlines. The suggestion prompted concerns on the potential for new sales for Airbus, although these were dismissed by Airbus COO John Leahy who stated that "Used A380s do not compete with new A380s", noting that the second-hand market is more interesting for parties otherwise looking to buy smaller aircraft such as the Boeing 777.[332]
After Malaysia Airlines was unable to sell or lease its six A380s, it decided to refurbish the aircraft with seating for 700 and transfer them to a subsidiary carrier for religious pilgrimage flights.[333] As it started receiving its six A350s to replace its A380s in December 2017, the new subsidiary will serve the Hajj and Umrah market with them, starting in the third quarter of 2018 and could be expanded above six beyond 2020 to 2022. The cabin will have 36 business seats and 600 economy seats, with a 712-seat reconfiguration possible within five days. The fleet could be chartered half the year for the tourism industry like cruise shipping and will be able to operate for the next 40 years if oil prices stay low.[334] As they should be parked by June 2018 before reconfiguration, MAS confirmed the plans and will also use them for peak periods to high traffic markets like London.[335]
In August 2017, it was announced that Hi Fly would lease two used aircraft. The Portuguese ACMI/charter airline will use the aircraft for markets where high capacity is needed and airports where slots are scarce. The first aircraft was scheduled to begin commercial operations during the first quarter of 2018[336][337] Hi Fly was to receive its A380s from mid 2018 in a 471-seat configuration: 399 on the main deck, 60 business-class and 12 first-class seats on the upper deck, the Singapore Airlines layout.[338] Hi Fly first used one of their A380s on 1 August 2018 for a one-off flight to enable Thomas Cook Airlines to repatriate passengers from Rhodes to Copenhagen following IT problems in the Greek airport.[339] The same aircraft was then wet-leased to Norwegian to operate its evening London-New York service for several weeks in August 2018, to alleviate availability issues on its Boeing 787s affected by Trent 1000 engine problems;[340] Air Austral also signed a deal to wet-lease an A380 from Hi Fly while one of its 787s is grounded for three months of Trent 1000 inspections.[341] As of December 2019, Hi Fly has leased one used A380.
Amedeo, mainly an A380 lessor and the largest with 22, mostly leased to Emirates, wants to find a use for them after their lease expires from 2022, and study if there is a demand to wet lease them.[342] Swiss aircraft broker Sparfell & Partners plans to convert for head-of-state or VVIP transport some of Dr. Peters' four ex-SIA A380s for under $300million apiece, less than a new Boeing 777 or Airbus A330.[343] As of November 2018, Air France was planning to return five of its A380s to lessors by the end of 2019 and refurbish its other five with new interiors by 2020 for $51million per aircraft.[344] By July 2019, Air France revised this plan and intended to phase out all ten of its A380s by 2022 as part of an "accelerated" retirement plan, replacing them with no more than nine twin-engined wide-body aircraft. The A330-900, A350-900 and 787-9 were being evaluated as potential replacements.[345]
Following the cancellation of the programme in February 2019, the residual value of existing aircraft is in doubt. While Amedeo argued that cancellation should benefit the value, this will depend on whether any new airlines are prepared to adopt second-hand A380s, and how many existing users continue to operate the aircraft. Even the teardown value is questionable, in that the engines, usually the most valuable part of a scrap aircraft, are not used by any other models.[346]
Teardown and second-hand market
With four A380s leased to Singapore Airlines having been returned between October 2017 and March 2018, Dr. Peters feared a weak aftermarket and is considering scrapping them, although they are on sale for a business jet conversion, but on the other hand Airbus sees a potential for African airlines and Chinese airlines, Hajj charters and its large Gulf operators.[347] An A380 parted out may be worth $30million to $50million if it is at half-life.[348] Teardown specialists have declined offers for several aircraft at part-out prices due to high risk as a secondary market is uncertain with $30 to $40million for the refurbishment, but should be between $20 and $30million to be viable.[349]
When the aircraft were proposed to British Airways, Hi Fly and Iran Air, BA did not want to replace its Boeing 747s until 2021, while Iran Air faced political uncertainty and Hi Fly did not have a convincing business case. Consequently, Dr. Peters recommended to its investors on 28 June 2018 to sell the aircraft parts with VAS Aero Services within two years for US$45million, quickly for components like the landing gear or the APU. Rolls-Royce Trent 900 leasing beyond March 2019 should generate US$480,000 monthly for each aircraft before selling the turbofans by 2020. With a total revenue of US$80million per aircraft, the overall return expected is 145–155% while 72% and 81% of their debt had already been repaid.[350]
The fifth plane coming back from SIA, owned by Doric, has been leased by Hi Fly Malta with a lease period of "nearly 6 years".[351] Hi Fly Malta became the first operator of second-hand A380 (MSN006).[352]Norwegian Long Haul briefly leased Hi Fly Malta A380 in August 2018, which operated the aircraft following engine problems with their Dreamliner fleet.[353] Norwegian leased the A380 again in late 2018 to help deal with the passenger backlog as a result of the Gatwick Airport drone incident.
Two others returned from Singapore Airlines in the coming weeks (June 2018) but they could stay with an existing Asian A380 flag carrier.[354][355]
The teardown value includes $32–$33million from the engines in 2020 and $4million from leasing them until then, while the value of a 2008 A380 would be $78.4million in 2020 and its monthly lease in 2018 would be $929,000. The two aircraft have returned 3.8–4.2% per year since 2008 but the 145–155% return is lower than the 220% originally forecast. Of the nearly 500 made, 50 747-400s were sold in the secondary market, including only 25 to new customers.[356] These are among the first A380s delivered, lacking the improvements and weight savings of later ones.[357]
The first two A380s delivered to Singapore Airlines (MSN003 and MSN005) flew to Tarbes, France, to be scrapped. Their engines and some components had been dismantled and removed while the livery was painted over in white.[358]
As of September 2019, Emirates initiated its A380 retirement plan–which will see the type remain in service until at least 2035–by retiring two aircraft that were due for a major overhaul, and using them as parts donors for the rest of the fleet. Emirates does not see any demand in the second-hand market, but is indifferent in that the retired aircraft have already been fully written down and thus have no residual value. As further aircraft are retired, Emirates-owned airframes will continue to be used for parts, while leased airframes will be returned to the lessors.[359] One such return to lessor Doric was purchased by Emirates for £25.3million in late 2022, as spare parts.[360]
Co-branding with Airbus branding along with customer airlines' logos on an A380 fuselage during the 2011 MAKS air showOne of the three different A380 ANA 'Flying Honu' liveries (Honu: sea turtle)
Fourteen customers have ordered and taken delivery of the A380 as of April 2019. Total orders for the A380 stand at 251as of November2019[update].[361] The biggest customer is Emirates, which has committed to order a total of 123 A380s as of 14 February 2019.[361][362] One VIP order was made in 2007[363] but later cancelled by Airbus.[364] The A380F version attracted 27 orders, before they were either cancelled (20) or converted to A380-800 (7) following the production delay and the subsequent suspension of the freighter programme.
Delivery takes place in Hamburg for customers from Europe and the Middle East and in Toulouse for customers from the rest of the world.[365] EADS explained that deliveries in 2013 were to be slowed temporarily to accommodate replacement of the wing rib brackets where cracks were detected earlier in the existing fleet.[366]
In 2013, in expectation of raising the number of orders placed, Airbus announced "attractable discounts" to airlines who placed large orders for the A380.[failed verification] Soon after, at the November 2013 Dubai Air Show, Emirates ordered 150 777X and Etihad Airways ordered 50 aircraft, totalling $20billion.[367]
In late July 2014, Airbus announced that it had terminated five A380 firm orders from the Japanese low-cost carrier, Skymark Airlines, citing concerns over the airline's financial performance.[368] In 2016, the largest Japanese carrier, All Nippon Airways (ANA), took over three of the orders and the remaining two that were already produced and put into long-term storage were taken up later by the main customer, Emirates.[369]Qantas planned to order eight more aircraft but froze its order while the airline restructured its operations.[370] Qantas eventually cancelled its order in February 2019 amid doubts over the A380's future.[371]
Amedeo, an aircraft lessor that ordered 20 A380s, had not found a client for the airliner and eventually cancelled their order in 2019.[372][373]Virgin Atlantic ordered six A380s in 2001 but never took delivery and later cancelled them in 2018.[374]
In June 2017, Emirates had 48 orders outstanding, but due to lack of space in Dubai Airport, it deferred 12 deliveries by one year and would not take any in 2019–20 before replacing its early airliners from 2021. There were open production slots in 2019, and Airbus reduced its production rate in 2017–2018 at 12 per year. The real backlog is much smaller than the official 107 with 47 uncertain orders: 20 commitments for the A380-specialized lessor Amedeo which commits to production only once aircraft are placed, eight for Qantas which wants to keep its fleet at 12, six for Virgin Atlantic which does not want them any more and three ex Transaero for finance vehicle Air Accord.[375]
At its 100th delivery ceremony, Emirates CEO Ahmed bin Saeed Al Maktoum was hoping to order new A380s at the November 2017 Dubai Air Show.[376] Emirates does not need the small front staircase and eleven-abreast economy of the A380plus concept, but wants Airbus to commit to continue production for at least 10 years.[124] On 18 January 2018, Airbus secured a preliminary agreement from Emirates for up to 36 A380s, to be delivered from 2020, valued at $16billion at list prices.[377] The contract was signed in February 2018, comprising a firm order for 20 A380s and options on 16 more.[378]
In early 2019, Airbus confirmed it was in discussions with Emirates over its A380 contract.[379] If the A380's only stable client were to drop the type, Airbus could cease production of the superjumbo.[380] Emirates is at odds with Rolls-Royce over shortfalls in fuel savings from the Trent 900s, and could switch its order for 36 A380s to the smaller A350.[381] The A350 could also replace its provisional order for 40 Boeing 787-10s, placed in 2017, as engine margins on the 787 are insufficient for the hot Dubai weather.[382][383]
On 14 February 2019, Emirates decided to cancel its order for 39 planes, opting to replace them with A350s and A330neos.[134] Airbus stated that this cancellation would bring the A380's production to an end when the last unfilled orders are delivered in 2021.[134][384]
On 21 March 2019, All Nippon Airways received its first of three A380s painted with the Sea Turtle livery.[385] Called the ANA Blue, this A380 will be used for 3 flights a week, going from Tokyo to Honolulu and back.[386]
In October 2021, Emirates announced it would receive its final three A380s to be delivered with the last aircraft in December 2021, thus ending production of the A380.
There were 234 aircraft (of 251 delivered) in service with 10 operators as of March2024[update], with Emirates being the largest operator with 120 A380s in its fleet.[388]
Current operators
Emirates is the largest A380 operator, with the final two of 123 ordered units delivered in December 2021 as the last A380 deliveries overall.
Thai Airways – 6 operated from 2012 to 2020, retired due to restructuring efforts[412][413]
Aircraft on display
The fourth test A380 (MSN4) was donated to the Musée de l'air et de l'espace at Le Bourget in 2017.[414] After several months of restoration, it was put on display on the apron in 2018, near the museum's Boeing 747-100, making the museum the first in the world where both large airliners can be seen together.
Donated by Airbus at the same time as A380 MSN4, the second test A380 (MSN2), was donated to the Aeroscopia museum at Toulouse-Blagnac Airport, Toulouse, along with the first Airbus A320 and an Airbus A340, that had also previously been used by the company for test flights.[415]
Incidents
The global A380 fleet has zero fatalities and no hull loss accidents as of December2023[update],[416] but was involved in two notable incidents.[416][417][418]
On 4 November 2010, Qantas Flight 32, en route from Singapore Changi Airport to Sydney Airport, suffered an uncontained engine failure, resulting in a series of related problems, and forcing the flight to make an emergency landing. The plane safely returned to Singapore. There were no injuries to the passengers, the crew, or people on the ground despite debris falling onto the Indonesian island of Batam.[419] The damage was sufficient for the event to be classified as an accident.[420] Qantas subsequently grounded all of its A380s that day subject to an internal investigation taken in conjunction with the engine manufacturer Rolls-Royce plc. A380s powered by the Rolls-Royce Trent 900 engines were affected, while those powered by the Engine Alliance GP7000 were not. Investigators determined that an oil leak, caused by a defective oil supply pipe, led to an engine fire and subsequent uncontained engine failure.[421] Repairs cost an estimated A$139million (~US$145M).[422] As other Rolls-Royce Trent 900 engines also showed problems with the same oil leak, Rolls-Royce ordered many engines to be changed, including about half of the engines in the Qantas A380 fleet.[423] During the aeroplane's repair, cracks were discovered in wing structural fittings, which also resulted in mandatory inspections of all A380s and subsequent design changes.[106]
↑ Max. design speed: Mach0.96 (1,020km/h; 551kn; 634mph) in dive at cruise altitude[430]
Related Research Articles
Qantas Airways Limited, or simply Qantas, is the flag carrier of Australia, and the largest airline by fleet size, international flights, and international destinations in Australia and Oceania. A founding member of the Oneworld airline alliance, it is the only airline in the world that flies to all seven continents, with it operating flights to Africa, Antarctica, Asia, Europe, North America and South America from its hubs in Sydney, Perth, Melbourne and Brisbane. It also flies to over 60 domestic destinations across Australia.
Emirates is one of the two flag carriers of the United Arab Emirates. Based in Garhoud, Dubai, the airline is a subsidiary of The Emirates Group, which is owned by the government of Dubai's Investment Corporation of Dubai. It is the largest airline in the Middle East, operating more than 3,600 flights per week from its hub at Terminal 3 of Dubai International Airport. It operates in more than 150 cities in 80 countries across six continents on its fleet of nearly 250 aircraft. Cargo activities are undertaken by Emirates SkyCargo.
A wide-body aircraft, also known as a twin-aisle aircraft and in the largest cases as a jumbo jet, is an airliner with a fuselage wide enough to accommodate two passenger aisles with seven or more seats abreast. The typical fuselage diameter is 5 to 6 m. In the typical wide-body economy cabin, passengers are seated seven to ten abreast, allowing a total capacity of 200 to 850 passengers. Seven-abreast aircraft typically seat 160 to 260 passengers, eight-abreast 250 to 380, nine- and ten-abreast 350 to 480. The largest wide-body aircraft are over 6 m (20 ft) wide, and can accommodate up to eleven passengers abreast in high-density configurations.
The Engine Alliance GP7000 is a turbofan jet engine manufactured by Engine Alliance, a joint venture between General Electric and Pratt & Whitney. It is one of the powerplant options available for the Airbus A380, along with the Rolls-Royce Trent 900.
Singapore Airlines operates a predominantly widebody fleet, until the second re-introduction of the Boeing 737 in March 2021 following the merger with SilkAir. The airline also operates Boeing 747-400F and Boeing 777F freighters. As of April 2024, there were 160 aircraft registered in the Singapore Airlines fleet, comprising 150 passenger aircraft and 12 freighters.
The Rolls-Royce Trent 900 is a high-bypass turbofan produced by Rolls-Royce plc to power the Airbus A380, competing with the Engine Alliance GP7000. Initially proposed for the Boeing 747-500/600X in July 1996, this first application was later abandoned but it was offered for the A3XX, launched as the A380 in December 2000. It first ran on 18 March 2003, made its maiden flight on 17 May 2004 on an A340 testbed, and was certified by the EASA on 29 October 2004. Producing up to 374 kN (84,000 lbf), the Trent 900 has the three shaft architecture of the Rolls-Royce Trent family with a 2.95 m (116 in) fan. It has a 8.5–8.7:1 bypass ratio and a 37–39:1 overall pressure ratio.
The competition between Airbus and Boeing has been characterized as a duopoly in the large jet airliner market since the 1990s.
The Airbus A380 features two full-length decks, each measuring 49.9 metres. The upper deck has a slightly shorter usable length of 44.93 metres due to the front fuselage curvature and the staircase. The widths of the main deck and upper deck are 6.50 metres and 5.80 metres respectively. Passenger capacity depends on the seat configuration chosen by the airline.
The Emirates fleet is composed of three wide-bodied aircraft families, the Airbus A350, Airbus A380, and Boeing 777. The airline also has the Boeing 777X and Boeing 787 aircraft on order.
Qantas is Australia's largest airline. Qantas was founded in Winton, Queensland, on 16 November 1920 as Queensland and Northern Territory Aerial Services Limited by Paul McGinness, Sir Hudson Fysh and Sir Fergus McMaster, the latter of whom was chairman. Arthur Baird was employed as a chief aircraft engineer. McGinness left QANTAS for other interests, and Hudson Fysh remained with the company as General Manager & Managing Director. He retired as Sir Hudson Fysh KBE DFC, Chairman of QANTAS in 1966.
Qantas Flight 32 was a regularly scheduled passenger flight from London to Sydney via Singapore. On 4 November 2010, the aircraft operating the route, an Airbus A380, suffered an uncontained failure in one of its four Rolls-Royce Trent 900 engines. The failure occurred over the Riau Islands, Indonesia, four minutes after takeoff from Singapore Changi Airport. After holding for almost two hours to assess the situation, the aircraft made a successful emergency landing at Changi. No injuries occurred to the passengers, crew, or people on the ground, despite debris from the aircraft falling onto houses in Batam.
Qantas Flight 7 (QF7/QFA7) and Qantas Flight 8 (QF8/QFA8) are flights operated by Australian airline Qantas between Sydney Airport and Dallas/Fort Worth International Airport, which, from 2013 to 2016, were the longest regularly scheduled non-stop commercial flights in the world. As of July 2024, they are the 13th longest regularly scheduled non-stop commercial flights in the world as measured by great-circle distance—13,804 kilometres, which is over one third of the distance around Earth.
A four-engined jet, sometimes called a quadjet, is a jet aircraft powered by four engines. The presence of four engines offers increased power and redundancy, allowing such aircraft to be used as airliners, freighters, and military aircraft. Many of the first purpose-built jet airliners had four engines, among which stands the De Havilland Comet, the world's first commercial jetliner. In the decades following their introduction, their use has gradually declined due to a variety of factors, including the approval of twin-engine jets to fly farther from diversion airports as reliability increased, and an increased emphasis on fuel efficiency.
This article explores the history of Singapore Airlines, the flag carrier of the Republic of Singapore and based at the Singapore Changi Airport. Singapore Airlines, also known by its abbreviations of SIA or SQ, has often been ranked throughout its history as either amongst the best or the best airline in the world.
First class is a travel class on some passenger airliners intended to be more luxurious than business class, premium economy, and economy class. Originally all planes offered only one class of service, with a second class appearing first in 1955 when TWA introduced two different types of service on its Super Constellations.
Qantas operates a fleet of Airbus A330, Airbus A380, Boeing 737 and Boeing 787, with a total of 125 aircraft. This list excludes subsidiaries Jetstar, QantasLink and Qantas Freight.
British Airways operates a fleet of Airbus and Boeing aircraft. It operates a single-aisle fleet of Airbus aircraft, including the Airbus A320-200 and the Airbus A320neo. It also operates a twin-aisle aircraft fleet of the Airbus A350-1000, Airbus A380, Boeing 777 and 787.
Emirates, the world's fourth-largest airline by scheduled revenue passenger-kilometers flown and number of international passengers carried, was founded in 1985 by the royal family of Dubai. The airline's first flight was from Dubai to Karachi, Pakistan and Mumbai, India in October of that year. Its first aircraft were provided by Pakistan International. The airline grew rapidly through partnerships and investment to become one of the world's leading air carriers.
1 2 Morales, Jesus. "Archived copy"(PDF). Archived(PDF) from the original on 17 October 2013. Retrieved 7 February 2016.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link) "The A380 Transport Project and Logistics – Assessment of alternatives", p. 19, Airbus, 18 January 2006. Retrieved 15 April 2012.
↑ Flottau, Jens (21 November 2012). "Emirates A350-1000 Order 'In Limbo'". Aviation Week & Space Technology. Retrieved 22 November 2012. Clark points out that "the faster you fly [the A380], the more fuel-efficient she gets; when you fly at [Mach] 0.86 she is better than at 0.83."
↑ Is Airbus Finally Ready To Shut Down A380 Production? (Forbes, by Michael Goldstein, 27 December 2017) Quote: "...the A380 has been a consistent money-loser for Airbus. " "The estimated $20 to $25 billion in research and development costs of the A380 have long since been written off."
↑ "A380 Superjumbo", A Documentary broadcast on the Smithsonian Channel in the series Planes that changed the world
↑ Lamiroux, F (2005). Trailer truck trajectory optimization: the transportation of components for the Airbus A380. IEEE Robotics and Automation Magazine. pp.14–21.
↑ "Integrated Modular Avionics: Less is More". Aviation Today. 1 February 2007. Archived from the original on 24 November 2011. Retrieved 26 October 2009. Some believe the IMA concept originated in the United States with the new F-22 and F-35 fighters and then migrated to the commercial jetliner arena. Others say the modular avionics concept, with less integration, has been used in business jets and regional airliners since the late 1980s or early 90s
↑ "Rafale". Dassault Aviation. 12 June 2005. Archived from the original on 4 March 2009.
1 2 "Thales technologies onboard the A380". Thales Group. 30 October 2009. Archived from the original on 8 March 2012. The A380 is the first aircraft ever to be fitted with the Integrated Modular Avionics (IMA) suite, a major technical evolution of global importance for airlines and operators. Designed by Airbus and co-developed with Thales and Diehl Aerospace, the IMA is a leap-ahead technological innovation, with all onboard computing modules networked and able to support different applications. The result is a substantial improvement in computing power, reliability, maintainability, volume, weight and scalability.
↑ Andriulaitis, Robert (December 2005). "B747-8F VS A380F"(PDF). InterVISTAS Consulting Inc. Archived from the original(PDF) on 3 March 2016. Retrieved 29 September 2012.
↑ Andreas Sperl (19 October 2006). "A380 financial update"(PDF). EADS. Archived from the original on 3 November 2006.{{cite web}}: CS1 maint: bot: original URL status unknown (link)
This page is based on this Wikipedia article Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply. Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.
