Lazarus taxon

Last updated

The takahe of New Zealand had not been seen since 1898 when it was rediscovered in 1948. Takahe and chick.jpg
The takahē of New Zealand had not been seen since 1898 when it was rediscovered in 1948.

In paleontology, a Lazarus taxon (plural taxa) is a taxon that disappears for one or more periods from the fossil record, only to appear again later. Likewise in conservation biology and ecology, it can refer to species or populations that were thought to be extinct, and are rediscovered. [1] The term Lazarus taxon was coined by Karl W. Flessa and David Jablonski in 1983 and was then expanded by Jablonski in 1986. [2] Paul Wignall and Michael Benton defined Lazarus taxa as, "At times of biotic crisis many taxa go extinct, but others only temporarily disappeared from the fossil record, often for intervals measured in millions of years, before reappearing unchanged". [3] Earlier work also supports the concept though without using the name Lazarus taxon, like work by Christopher R. C. Paul. [4]

Contents

The term refers to the story in the Christian biblical Gospel of John, in which Jesus Christ raised Lazarus from the dead.

Potential explanations

Lazarus taxa are observational artifacts that appear to occur either because of (local) extinction, later resupplied, or as a sampling artifact. The fossil record is inherently sporadic (only a very small fraction of organisms become fossilized, and an even smaller fraction are discovered before destruction) and contains gaps not necessarily caused by extinction, particularly when the number of individuals in a taxon is very low.

After mass extinctions, such as the Permian–Triassic extinction event, the Lazarus effect occurred for many taxa. However, there appears to be no link with the abundance of fossiliferous sites and the proportion of Lazarus taxa, and no missing taxa have been found in potential refuges. Therefore, reappearance of Lazarus taxa probably reflects the rebound after a period of extreme rarity during the aftermath of such extinctions. [5]

Lazarus taxa and other ghost lineages reflect the sporadic nature of the fossil record. Fossil record gaps - animals with hard body parts.svg
Lazarus taxa and other ghost lineages reflect the sporadic nature of the fossil record.

An Elvis taxon is a look-alike that has supplanted an extinct taxon through convergent evolution.

A zombie taxon is a taxon that contains specimens that have been collected from strata younger than the extinction of the taxon. Later such fossils turn out to be freed from the original seam and refossilized in a younger sediment. For example, a trilobite that gets eroded out of its Cambrian-aged limestone matrix, and reworked into Miocene-aged siltstone.

A ghost lineage is a pronounced gap in time for the fossil record of a group, indicating that the group continued evolving throughout the gap, without direct fossil evidence from within the gap. Lazarus taxa are a type of ghost lineage where extinction was originally assumed to occur within the gap, only for younger fossils or surviving members of the group to indicate otherwise.

A living fossil is an extant taxon that appears to have changed so little compared with fossil remains, that it is considered identical. Living fossils may occur regularly in the fossil record, such as the lampshell Lingula , though the living species in this genus are not identical to fossil brachiopods. [6]

Other living fossils however are also Lazarus taxa if these have been missing from the fossil record for substantial periods of time, such as applies for coelacanths.

In paleovirology, divergent clades of genomic elements from presumably extinct viruses are often known only from host genomes. However, in some cases extant viruses have later been associated with these "fossil" elements, indicating Lazarus-like taxa. For example, a clade of paleoviruses from presumed extinct filoviruses found in shrews was later found to contain an extant filovirus (Tapajós virus, TAPV). [7]

Finally, the term "Lazarus species" is applied to organisms that have been rediscovered as being still alive after having been widely considered extinct for years, without ever having appeared in the fossil record. In this last case, the term Lazarus taxon is applied in neontology.

Reappearing fossil taxa

From Quaternary (2.6 to 0 million years ago)

Chacoan peccary Catagonus wagneri 1 - Phoenix Zoo.jpg
Chacoan peccary

From Neogene (23 to 2.6 million years ago)

Monito del monte Monito del Monte ps6.jpg
Monito del monte

From Cretaceous (145 to 66 million years ago)

Coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae Latimeria chalumnae01.jpg
Coelacanth Latimeria chalumnae

From Devonian (419 to 359 million years ago)

Monoplacophora Neopilina.jpg
Monoplacophora

From Cambrian (539 to 485 million years ago)

Reappearing IUCN red list species

Plants

Cafe marron 500 x 300 Ramosmania rodriguesii (Rubiaceae).jpg
Café marron

Cultivars

  • Judean date palm, a distinct cultivar of date palm that disappeared around the 14th century, seeds dated from between 155 BC to 64 AD were found in the 1960s and were replanted in 2005.
  • Montreal melon, a common commercial plant in the 19th century that disappeared in the 1920s but was rediscovered after a couple of generations in a seed bank in 1996, replanted in 2024.

Sponges

Annelids

Insects

Crustaceans

Arachnids

Fish

Shark

Amphibians

Atelopus nahumae Atelopus nahumae.jpg
Atelopus nahumae

Mammals

Gilbert's potoroo GilbertsPotoroo.JPG
Gilbert's potoroo

Reptiles

Arakan forest turtle Heosemys-depressa.jpg
Arakan forest turtle

Birds

Molluscs

Discussions

Because its definition is ambiguous, some, like R. B. Rickards and A. J. Wright, reject the very concept of the Lazarus taxon. Rickards and Wright have questioned the usefulness of the concept, writing in "Lazarus taxa, refugia and relict faunas: evidence from graptolites" that anyone could argue that any gap in the fossil record could potentially be considered a Lazarus effect because the duration required for the Lazarus effect is not defined. [48] They have argued that accurate plotting of biodiversity changes and species abundance through time, coupled with an appraisal of their palaeobiogeography, is more important than using this title to categorize species. [48]

Communication and education

The lack of public engagement around environmental issues has led conservationists to attempt newer communication strategies. One of them is the focus on positive messages, of which Lazarus species are an important part. [49] One conservation outreach project that has focused exclusively on species rediscoveries is the Lost & Found project which aims to tell the stories of species once thought extinct but that were subsequently rediscovered. [50]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Hula painted frog</span> Species of amphibian endemic to Israel

The Hula painted frog is a species of frog endemic to the Lake Hula marshes in northern Israel. It is the only living member of the genus Latonia, which is otherwise known from fossils from Europe spanning from the Oligocene through Pleistocene. The Hula painted frog was thought to be extinct as a result of habitat destruction during the 1950s until the species was rediscovered in 2011.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Living fossil</span> Organism resembling a form long shown in the fossil records

A living fossil is an extant taxon that phenotypically resembles related species known only from the fossil record. To be considered a living fossil, the fossil species must be old relative to the time of origin of the extant clade. Living fossils commonly are of species-poor lineages, but they need not be. While the body plan of a living fossil remains superficially similar, it is never the same species as the remote relatives it resembles, because genetic drift would inevitably change its chromosomal structure.

In paleontology, an Elvis taxon is a taxon that has been misidentified as having re-emerged in the fossil record after a period of presumed extinction, but is not actually a descendant of the original taxon, instead having developed a similar morphology by convergent evolution. This implies that the extinction of the original taxon is real, and one taxon containing specimens from before and after the extinction would be polyphyletic.

Neontology is a part of biology that, in contrast to paleontology, deals with living organisms. It is the study of extant taxa : taxa with members still alive, as opposed to (all) being extinct. For example:

<i>Atelopus</i> Genus of amphibians

Atelopus is a large genus of Bufonidae, commonly known as harlequin frogs or toads, from Central and South America, ranging as far north as Costa Rica and as far south as Bolivia. Atelopus species are small, generally brightly colored, and diurnal. Most species are associated with mid-to-high elevation streams.

Holdridge's toad, formerly Bufo holdridgei, is a species of toad endemic to Costa Rica. In October 2008, it was declared extinct by the International Union for Conservation of Nature in its Red List since the species had not been seen since 1987, despite years of extensive searches. However, the species was rediscovered in 2010 by a Costa Rican herpetologist and is now classified as critically endangered. It is believed that the species is most threatened by the presence of the chytrid fungus in its habitat.

<i>Atelopus longirostris</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus longirostris is a species of harlequin frog, a member of the family of true toads (Bufonidae). It has been recorded only in northern Ecuador. Records from Colombia probably represent different species. Once listed as extinct by the IUCN, it was rediscovered in 2016 after more than two decade with no sightings.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Majorcan midwife toad</span> Species of amphibian

The Majorcan midwife toad is a frog in the family Alytidae. It is endemic to the Balearic Island of Majorca in the Mediterranean Sea. An example of Lazarus taxon, the species was first described from fossil remains in 1977, but living animals were discovered in 1979.

<i>Atelopus varius</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus varius, the Costa Rican variable harlequin toad or clown frog, is a small Neotropical true toad from the family Bufonidae. Once ranging from Costa Rica to Panama, A. varius is now listed as critically endangered and has been reduced to a single remnant population near Quepos, Costa Rica, and has only relict populations in western Panama. Recent variation in air temperature, precipitation, stream flow patterns, and the subsequent spread of a pathogenic chytrid fungus linked to global climate change have been the leading cause of decline for A. varius. A. zeteki has been considered a subspecies of A. varius, but is now generally considered a separate species.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Starry night toad</span> Species of amphibian

The starry night harlequin toad is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae endemic to the Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta, Colombia. Its natural habitats are sub-Andean and Andean forests, sub-páramo and páramo at 2,000–3,500 m (6,600–11,500 ft) above sea level. It is named after its unique coloration, being largely black with white spots.

<i>Atelopus balios</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus balios, the Rio Pescado stubfoot toad, is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae. It is endemic to southwestern Ecuador, with records from Pacific lowlands in Azuay, Cañar, and Guayas Provinces. It is a rare species that was already suspected to be extinct, but a single specimen was discovered in 2011 by a team from Conservation International during a hunt for missing amphibians. The decline in amphibian populations is well documented. The Atelopus balios is Critically Endangered as a result of the widespread amphibian Chytridiomycosis fungus that has decimated other amphibian populations. There are only 10 known findings of the tadpole, Atelopus balios.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Guajira stubfoot toad</span> Species of amphibian

The Guajira stubfoot toad or Carrikeri harlequin frog is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae. It is about 5 cm (2.0 in) long and typically black, though some populations have orange coloration. This species is endemic to the Sierra Nevada de Santa Marta mountain range of northern Colombia. It is critically endangered because of the chytrid fungus, Batrachochytrium dendrobatidis, and habitat destruction due to agriculture. The species had not been seen from 1994 until it was rediscovered in early 2008.

<i>Atelopus chiriquiensis</i> Extinct species of amphibian

Atelopus chiriquiensis, the Chiriqui harlequin frog or Lewis' stubfoot toad, is an extinct species of toad in the family Bufonidae that was found in the Cordillera de Talamanca in Costa Rica and western Panama. Its natural habitats were stream margins in lower montane wet forests and rainforests. Its elevational range was 1,400–2,500 m (4,600–8,200 ft) asl.

<i>Atelopus coynei</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus coynei, the Rio Faisanes stubfoot toad, is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae endemic to Ecuador. Its natural habitats are subtropical or tropical moist lowland forests, subtropical or tropical moist montane forests, and rivers. It is threatened by habitat loss.

<i>Atelopus cruciger</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus cruciger, also known as the Veragua stubfoot toad or Rancho Grande harlequin frog, is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae. It is endemic to Venezuela and is known from the central Venezuelan Coastal Range. The species was already suspected to be extinct because, despite considerable effort, none had been found since 1986. However, in 2003, a small population was found, with few other locations discovered later. It is mainly threatened by chytridiomycosis. It is locally called sapito rayado.

The Guanujo stubfoot toad, known in Spanish as puca sapo, is a possibly extinct species of toad in the family Bufonidae endemic to Ecuador. Its natural habitats are subtropical or tropical moist montane forests and rivers. It is threatened by habitat loss.

<i>Atelopus ignescens</i> Species of amphibian

Atelopus ignescens, the Jambato toad or Quito stubfoot toad or Jambato harlequin frog, is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae. It is endemic to the northern Andes of Ecuador. This once abundant species was believed to be extinct until its rediscovery in 2016. The specific name ignescens means "to catch fire," presumably in reference to the orange ventral color of this species.

The Mindo stubfoot toad or Mindo harlequin-toad is a species of toad in the family Bufonidae. It is endemic to Ecuador in Pichincha, Santo Domingo and Cotopaxi Provinces. Its natural habitats are subtropical or tropical moist lowland forests, subtropical or tropical moist montane forests, and rivers. It has a unique appearance and color pattern, being green and red with white speckles, and due to this it was once considered an emblematic species of the Mindo Valley.

Atelopus vogli is an extinct species of harlequin frog in the family Bufonidae. It was endemic to Venezuela. It is known from collections in two localities: its type locality, Las Peñas near Hacienda la Trinidad in Aragua, and Montalbán in Carabobo. It was first described as subspecies of Atelopus cruciger. The specific name vogli honours Cornelius Vogl, German priest who was a missionary in Venezuela in 1925–1959. Common name Vogl's harlequin toad has been coined for it.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Golden toad</span> Extinct species of toad that was endemic to Costa Rica

The golden toad is an extinct species of true toad that was once abundant in a small, high-altitude region of about 4 square kilometres (1.5 sq mi) in an area north of the city of Monteverde, Costa Rica. It was endemic to elfin cloud forest. Also called the Monte Verde toad, Alajuela toad and orange toad, it is commonly considered the "poster child" for the amphibian decline crisis. This toad was first described in 1966 by herpetologist Jay Savage. The last sighting of a single male golden toad was on 15 May 1989, and it has since been classified as extinct by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN).

References

  1. Ryan, Gerard; Baker, Christopher (November 2016). "A general method for assessing the risks and benefits of secrecy in conserving 'Lazarus species'". Biological Conservation. 203: 186–187. Bibcode:2016BCons.203..186R. doi:10.1016/j.biocon.2016.09.022.
  2. Jablonski, David (1986). "Background and Mass Extinctions: The Alternation of Macroevolutionary Regimes". Science . 231 (4734): 129–133. Bibcode:1986Sci...231..129J. doi:10.1126/science.231.4734.129. ISSN   0036-8075. PMID   17842630. S2CID   206572747.
  3. Wignall, P. B.; Benton, M. J. (1999). "Lazarus taxa and fossil abundance at times of biotic crisis". Journal of the Geological Society. 156 (3): 453–456. Bibcode:1999JGSoc.156..453W. doi:10.1144/gsjgs.156.3.0453. S2CID   130746408.
  4. Donovan, S. K.; Paul, C. R. C. (1998). The adequacy of the fossil record. Chichester: John Wiley. ISBN   0471969885. OCLC   38281286.
  5. Wignall, P. B.; Benton, M. J. (1999). "Lazarus Taxa and Fossil Abundance at Times of Biotic Crisis". Journal of the Geological Society. 156 (3): 453–456. Bibcode:1999JGSoc.156..453W. doi:10.1144/gsjgs.156.3.0453. S2CID   130746408.[ permanent dead link ]
  6. Emig, Christian C. (2008). "On the history of the names Lingula, anatina, and on the confusion of the forms assigned them among the Brachiopoda" (PDF). Carnets de Géologie (Article 2008/08). doi: 10.4267/2042/20044 . Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 March 2016. Retrieved 24 September 2014.
  7. Taylor, Derek J.; Barnhart, Max H. (2024). "Genomic transfers help to decipher the ancient evolution of filoviruses and interactions with vertebrate hosts". PLOS Pathogens. 20 (9): e1011864. doi: 10.1371/journal.ppat.1011864 . PMC   11398700 . PMID   39226335.
  8. "3 Animals That Came Back From the Dead - Lazarus Taxa" on YouTube. Ben G Thomas. 25 February 2018; 0:32
  9. Naish, Darren (24 November 2008). "New, obscure, and nearly extinct rodents of South America, and... when fossils come alive". Tetrapod Zoology. Archived from the original on 5 December 2008. Retrieved 13 December 2008.
  10. Lost & Found. "Lost & Found - Once upon a time, there was an adventurer". lostandfoundnature.com. Retrieved 8 April 2018.
  11. "WoRMS - World Register of Marine Species - Cymatioa cookae (Willett, 1937)". www.marinespecies.org. Retrieved 3 January 2023.
  12. Valentich-Scott, P; Goddard, JHR (7 November 2022). "A fossil species found living off southern California, with notes on the genus Cymatioa (Mollusca, Bivalvia, Galeommatoidea)". ZooKeys (1128): 53–62. Bibcode:2022ZooK.1128...53V. doi: 10.3897/zookeys.1128.95139 . PMC   9836502 . PMID   36762233.
  13. Freiwald, André; Lavaleye, Marc; Heugten, Bart Van; Beuck, Lydia; Hoffman, Leon (4 June 2019). "Last snails standing since the Early Pleistocene, a tale of Calliostomatidae (Gastropoda) living in deep-water coral habitats in the north-eastern Atlantic". Zootaxa. 4613 (1): 93–110. doi: 10.11646/zootaxa.4613.1.4 . ISSN   1175-5334. PMID   31716426.
  14. Weston, Peter H.; Kooyman, Robert M. "Botany and Ecology of the 'Nightcap Oak', Eidothea hardeniana". Australian Plants Online. Archived from the original on 6 August 2012. Retrieved 21 October 2017.
  15. Approved NSW & National Recovery Plan: Eidothea Hardeniana, Nightcap Oak (PDF). Hurstville: Department of Environment and Conservation (NSW). 2004. pp. 1, 3. ISBN   0-7313-6781-2.
  16. Wild, Alexander L.; Cuezzo, Fabiana (2006). "Rediscovery of a fossil dolichoderine ant lineage (Hymenoptera: Formicidae: Dolichoderinae) and a description of a new genus from South America" (PDF). Zootaxa. 1142: 57–68. doi:10.11646/zootaxa.1142.1.4.
  17. Anita Srikameswaran (15 June 2006). "Retired professor tracks down rodent thought to be extinct". Pittsburgh Post-Gazette . Retrieved 29 April 2015. Dr. Dawson and her colleagues... determined that the rock rats belonged to a family called Diatomyidae, whose members were thought to have died off more than 11 million years ago.
  18. Ziegler, Reinhard (2003). "Bats (Chiroptera, Mammalia) from Middle Miocene karstic fissure fillings of Petersbuch near Eichstätt, Southern Franconian Alb (Bavaria)". Geobios. 36 (4): 447–490. Bibcode:2003Geobi..36..447Z. doi:10.1016/S0016-6995(03)00043-3.
  19. Ruedi, Manuel; Csorba, Gábor; Lin, Liang-Kong; Chou, C-H (20 February 2015). "Molecular phylogeny and morphological revision of Myotis bats (Chiroptera: Vespertilionidae) from Taiwan and adjacent China". Zootaxa. 3920 (2): 301–342. doi:10.11646/zootaxa.3920.2.6. PMID   25781252.
  20. "Wollemia nobilis W.G.Jones, K.D.Hill & J.M.Allen". Kew Gardens. Retrieved 3 July 2017.
  21. "Coelacanths, Coelacanth Pictures, Coelacanth Facts – National Geographic". National Geographic. 10 May 2011. Archived from the original on 14 January 2010. Retrieved 3 July 2017.
  22. Lemche, Henning (1957). "A new living deep-sea mollusc of the Cambro-Devonian class Monoplacophora". Nature. 179 (4556). London: 413–416. Bibcode:1957Natur.179..413L. doi:10.1038/179413a0. S2CID   4173823.
  23. Gabriele Kühl; Derek E. G. Briggs & Jes Rust (2009). "A great-appendage arthropod with a radial mouth from the Lower Devonian Hunsrück Slate, Germany". Science . 323 (5915): 771–773. Bibcode:2009Sci...323..771K. doi:10.1126/science.1166586. PMID   19197061. S2CID   47555807.
  24. Platt, John R. (17 November 2011). "Amazing Neptune's Cup Sponge Rediscovered in Singapore". Extinction Countdown blog. Scientific American . Archived from the original on 18 November 2011. Retrieved 5 July 2017.
  25. Miller, Craig J. (September 1997). Occurrence and ecology of the Open Bay Islands leech, Hirudobdella antipodium (PDF). Science for Conservation. Vol. 57. Wellington, N.Z.: Department of Conservation. ISBN   0-478-01932-7. ISSN   1173-2946.
  26. "APNewsBreak: Idaho Scientists Find Fabled Worm," The New York Times, 27 April 2010.
  27. Dorey, James B. (25 February 2021). "Missing for almost 100 years: the rare and potentially threatened bee, Pharohylaeus lactiferus (Hymenoptera, Colletidae)". Journal of Hymenoptera Research. 81: 165–180. doi: 10.3897/jhr.81.59365 . ISSN   1314-2607. S2CID   233952830.
  28. Messer, A. C. (1984). "Chalicodoma pluto: The World's Largest Bee Rediscovered Living Communally in Termite Nests (Hymenoptera: Megachilidae)". Journal of the Kansas Entomological Society. 57 (1): 165–168. JSTOR   25084498.
  29. Miguel Carles-Tolrá, Pablo C. Rodríguez & Julio Verdú (2010). "Thyreophora cynophila (Panzer, 1794): collected in Spain 160 years after it was thought to be extinct (Diptera: Piophilidae: Thyreophorini)". Boletín de la Sociedad Entomológica Aragonesa (S.E.A.) 46: 1–7.
  30. Emberson, R. M.; Early, J. W.; Marris, J. W. M.; Syrett, P. (1996). Research into the status and distribution of Chatham Islands endangered invertebrates (PDF). Wellington, N.Z.: Dept. of Conservation. pp. 1–27. ISBN   978-0-478-01833-2 . Retrieved 30 August 2016.
  31. Batman loach returns: fish feared extinct found in Turkey
  32. 1 2 Castaño, Alberto (23 July 2018). "La desaparición de las ranas arlequín en Colombia y la carrera por conservarlas" (in Spanish). Archived from the original on 26 July 2018. Retrieved 25 July 2018.
  33. "If the frogs should win". theecologist.org. 11 January 2021. Retrieved 14 February 2023.
  34. "First-ever images prove 'lost echidna' not extinct". 10 November 2023. Retrieved 25 November 2023.
  35. Jackson, Stephen M (28 July 2011). "Petaurus gracilis (Diprotodontia: Petauridae)". Mammalian Species. 43 (882): 141–148. doi:10.1644/882.1. S2CID   35166232.
  36. van Dyck, Steve (June 1991). "Raising an old glider's ghost". Wildlife Australia. 50 (3): 32–35.
  37. Gates, Sara (4 June 2014). "Presumed Extinct Bat Found in Papua New Guinea After 120 Years". Huffington Post. Retrieved 29 April 2015.
  38. Posa, Mary Rose C. (March 2008). "Hope for threatened tropical biodiversity: lessons from the Philippines". BioScience. 58 (3): 231–240. doi: 10.1641/b580309 via Gale.
  39. Fessenden, Marissa. "This Kangaroo Rat Was Just Spotted For the First Time in 30 years". Smithsonian. Retrieved 16 August 2018.
  40. De Vosjoli, Phillipe; Repashy, Allen; Fast, Frank (2003). Rhacodactylus: The Complete Guide to their Selection and Care. Advanced Vivarium Inc. ISBN   978-0-9742971-0-1.
  41. "Not seen for 100 years, a rare Galápagos tortoise was considered all but extinct – until now". USA TODAY. Retrieved 21 February 2019.
  42. Smethurst, Annika (25 June 2023). "Earless dragon rediscovery like finding the Tasmanian tiger". The Sydney Morning Herald. Retrieved 27 June 2023.
  43. Gehrman, Elizabeth (2012). Rare Birds: The Extraordinary Tale of the Bermuda Petrel and the Man Who Brought It Back from Extinction . Boston: Beacon Press. ISBN   978-0-8070-1076-1.
  44. BirdLife International. "Brave efforts pay off in doubly-successful project to restore colonies of Chinese Crested Tern". BirdLife. Retrieved 21 November 2019.
  45. Ghost Bird 2009.[ full citation needed ]
  46. "Scientists Rediscover Venezuelan Bird Not Seen in 60 Years".
  47. Briggs, Helen (13 June 2019). "The snail that 'came back from the dead'". BBC News.
  48. 1 2 RICKARDS, R. B.; WRIGHT, A. J. (2002). "Lazarus taxa, refugia and relict faunas: evidence from graptolites". Journal of the Geological Society. 159 (1): 1–4. Bibcode:2002JGSoc.159....1R. doi:10.1144/0016-764901058. S2CID   84293885.
  49. Veríssimo, Diogo. "Will optimistic stories get people to care about nature?". The Conversation. Retrieved 8 May 2017.
  50. "'Lost & Found': Telling the stories of rediscovered species". news.mongabay.com. 21 April 2017. Retrieved 8 May 2017.