Aquaculture in the Philippines

Last updated

A fish pond in Ivisan Fish roundup - panoramio.jpg
A fish pond in Ivisan

Aquaculture in the Philippines makes up a substantial proportion of the overall output of Philippine fisheries. Aquaculture has a long history in the archipelago, with wild-caught milkfish being farmed in tidally-fed fish ponds for centuries. Modern aquaculture is carried out in freshwater, brackish water, and seawater throughout the country through a variety of methods.

Contents

The most prominent farmed commodities are milkfish and tilapia. Tilapia is farmed in freshwater, while milkfish can be farmed anywhere. Other fish species are also farmed, as well as shrimp, crabs, lobsters, and molluscs. Seaweed is mostly farmed to produce carrageenan. Regulation of aquaculture generally falls to the cities and municipalities in which aquaculture farms are located, and public land and water can be rented for aquaculture from the national government.

Aquaculture has made up an increasingly large proportion of fisheries products produced in the Philippines, and there has been considerable research into improving aquacultural output. Philippine output in total makes up 1% of global aquaculture production, and the country is the fourth-largest producer of seaweed. Aquaculture products are sold alongside wild-caught products in ports. Resulting seafood products are often consumed domestically, although some high-value goods are exported.

The aquaculture industry directly employs over 230,000 individuals. While some workers own their output, many are employees of influential landowners. The creation of aquaculture ponds has destroyed large areas of mangroves, and the establishment of aquaculture in water bodies has created friction with capture fisheries. Some species imported for aquaculture have become invasive species, and aquaculture has directly introduced pollution into some ecosystems.

Resources

Philippine water resources [1] :15
AreaDetails
2,200,000 km2 (850,000 sq mi)Total ocean
184,600 km2 (71,300 sq mi)Shallow marine water (≤ 200 metres (660 ft) deep)
106,328 ha (262,740 acres)Inland watersFreshwater swamps
137,735 ha (340,350 acres)Brackish swamps
200,000 ha (490,000 acres)Lakes
31,000 ha (77,000 acres)Rivers
19,000 ha (47,000 acres)Reservoirs

Philippine marine waters include 2,200,000 square kilometres (850,000 sq mi) of ocean surrounding 36,289 kilometres (22,549 mi) of coasts. Inland waters are made up of both brackish and freshwater areas, [1] :15 and include 23 lakes over 100 hectares (250 acres). [1] :18 The Philippine fisheries in these waters include a large aquaculture component, [2] which as of 2022 produced 54.15% of total fisheries volume. [3] :26

Aquaculture is carried out in fresh, brackish, and marine water. [4] Philippine waters are highly productive due to large amounts of sunlight, and stable and warm temperatures. [5] :4–5 Aquaculture generally occurs in areas under local government (city and municipal) jurisdiction, which includes their land area and the sea up to 15 kilometres (9.3 mi) from their shoreline. Aquaculture infrastructure can be built on land, in inland waters, or in coastal and nearshore areas. [6] :1

Most brackish fish ponds are developed from mangrove areas, with agricultural land being too valuable to convert to fish ponds. Exceptions have occurred during conducive economic conditions, such as in the 1980s when sugarcane plantations were converted to shrimp ponds in Negros Occidental, amid a global slump in sugar prices and increasing shrimp prices. [7] Coastal aquaculture ponds are commonly used to rear shrimp and milkfish. [8] :60 Different species have different ideal habitat conditions for successful rearing. [6] :100–101 In total, there are 253,323 hectares (625,970 acres) of fish ponds, of which 239,323 hectares (591,380 acres) are brackish and 14,531 hectares (35,910 acres) freshwater. [1] :15

Products farmed

Milkfish have been farmed in the Philippines for centuries 0345jfSibul BiaknaBato National Park Road Madlum River Bridge San Miguel Bulacanfvf 18.JPG
Milkfish have been farmed in the Philippines for centuries

The main two fish commodities in agricultural production are the milkfish and tilapia (mainly the Nile tilapia, followed by the Mozambique tilapia). Fish farmed to a lesser extent include carps (notably Bighead carp, as well as some Eurasian carp), catfish ( Clarias species such as the walking catfish and Clarias gariepinus , as well as Pangasius species), the mudfish Channa striata , the giant gourami, barramundi, Epinephelus grouper species, rabbitfish (orange-spotted spinefoot and vermiculated spinefoot), and the Scatophagus argus spadefish. [4] [9]

The rabbitfish orange-spotted spinefoot and vermiculated spinefoot, as well as Scatophagus argus , have been farmed sporadically in Pangasinan and elsewhere. Barramundi is only desired in the Western Visayas, which combined with high costs has inhibited successful farming. Low-level Epinephelus farming, while expensive, is more successful due to high demand in Chinese restaurants. It is farmed in Capiz, where tilapia is sometimes used as feed. [10]

The shrimp species farmed include the jumbo tiger shrimp, Indian prawn, Penaeus merguiensis , whiteleg shrimp, Metapenaeus ensis , and the giant freshwater prawn. The main crabs farmed are the mudcrabs Scylla serrata and Scylla oceanica. [a] Lobsters farmed include species of the Panulirus genus and the slipper lobster family. [4] [9]

For molluscs, oysters farmed include Crassostrea species, Magallana bilineata , and rock oyster species. Abalone that have been farmed are those of the Haliotis genus, particularly Haliotis asinina . The green mussel Perna viridis is also widely farmed. [6] :100 [9] Less frequent marine aquaculture products include giant clams, nacre (pearl shell), green snails, and Trochus . [8] :60

Of seaweeds, the farming of carrageenophytes is mainly Eucheuma species such as Eucheuma denticulatum , and Kappaphycus alvarezii . Agarophytes farmed are mostly Gracilaria species and Gracilariopsis balinae . Lastly, Chlorophyceae of the Caulerpa genus such as Caulerpa lentillifera are also farmed. [9]

Tilapia, carp, and catfish are usually farmed in freshwater. Tilapia is farmed in both ponds and cages. Shrimp and crab farming usually takes place in brackish water. Saltwater farms (mariculture) are used to farm seaweed, as well as green mussels. Some fish, such as groupers and rabbitfish, are farmed in both brackish and salt water. Milkfish is farmed in fresh, brackish, and salt water. [4]

Methods

A crab pond in the Bakhawan Eco-Park Bakhawan Eco Park, Kalibo, Aklan (1).jpg
A crab pond in the Bakhawan Eco-Park

Different species are farmed with different levels of technology, ranging from simple ponds with wild-caught fry to more complicated methods of raising genetically modified fish strains. [10] Aquaculture products are grown both from stock hatched in captivity and from wild-caught juveniles. [12] Milkfish can be bred artificially to stock ponds, although many still use wild-caught fry. The rabbitfish Siganus guttatus can be hatched in captivity. Giant freshwater prawn farms rely on seedstock grown in hatcheries or imported. [10]

Fish ponds

Fish ponds, especially in brackish water, are the historical method of aquaculture, and remain widespread. [12] Traditionally, these fishponds are tidally supplied with water and food. It has since developed into a multi-pond system, with fish, especially milkfish, shifted between ponds as they grow. The use of supplementary feed has developed from using rice waste to using commercially produced feed, allowing pond farming to become both more productive and less vulnerable to weather changes. [10]

Milkfish farming in brackish fish ponds uses a variety of techniques used in varying intensities. Shrimp, mostly jumbo tiger shrimp, are also farmed in brackish ponds, sometimes on their own, or sometimes together with or in rotation with milkfish. Scylla crabs are also taken from these ponds, with bamboo fences used to keep them inside. [4] Some strains of tilapia have been developed which can survive in brackish water, to allow them to also be farmed in the ubiquitous ponds. The presence of tilapia may also improve the quality of shrimp ponds, producing phytoplankton less likely to facilitate the growth of bacteria that cause the luminous vibriosis disease. Rabbitfish and spadefish can also be farmed in brackish and saltwater enclosures, but more slowly than milkfish. Seabass are occasionally farmed in brackish ponds. [10] As rabbitfish are herbivores, they are cheap to feed. [13]

Freshwater ponds are far less common, as they compete for land with other forms of agriculture, and freshwater fish are not as popular. Where they are used, they mostly farm tilapia, which are much easier for individual farmers to breed than milkfish. Tilapia can also grow in some brackish water, although they are usually considered pests in competition with or predating on milkfish and shrimp. There is a history of small amounts of freshwater pond farming of other introduced species. [10] A small amount of rice-fish systems function as freshwater ponds. [10] These are often unsuccessful, as pesticides may harm fish, and rice growing cycles may not align with fish growing cycles. [13]

A 1977 national study found that around 15% of fish ponds were smaller than 1 hectare (2.5 acres), although in total there were less than 1% of all fish pond areas. Over half of fishponds were officially above 5 hectares (12 acres), including 5% which were above 50 hectares (120 acres). In 1979, 70% of fish ponds in Central Luzon were smaller than 0.5 hectares (1.2 acres). However, the largest 2% of fish ponds took up 68% of total fish pond area. Such figures do not account for the area of multiple owners being operated together, or for land being operated by someone who is not the owner. Large brackish fishponds often require multiple workers, and large owners often do not work at the ponds. Of fish ponds being leased from the government, the majority are leased by individuals with addresses in different locations to those of their fish ponds. Almost all freshwater fishponds are privately owned. [14]

Fish pond land can be leased from the government for a minimum of 25 years and a maximum of 50 years under the Fisheries Code of 1998. Private land registered as being used for fish ponds can be most valuable as land in itself, and ponds can thus be underdeveloped. [14] Fish pond productivity can be negatively affected by the El Niño–Southern Oscillation. [12] Diseases such as luminous vibriosis impede shrimp farming, and some diseases have become resistant to antibiotics. [10]

Fish pens and cages

Fish pens in the Bued River 8232Bantay Insik Bulaoen West Sison, Pangasinan 24.jpg
Fish pens in the Bued River

Fish pens are enclosures in which the seabed or lakebed provides the floor. They have high capital costs but can produce large yields even without supplementary feeding. Fish cages are distinguishable from fish pens due to having an artificial bottom. This bottom means fish cages can be small, and are a cheaper alternative to fish pens. These cages can be floating, fixed to the ground, or submerged. [14] Both allow for water to naturally flow through the enclosures. [15] Fish pens can be constructed using bamboo connected with fishing net. [10] They can have high capital costs, that are greatest per unit area for smaller pens. [14] In freshwater areas, they are generally used to farm tilapia, while in marine areas they are often used to farm groupers. [14] Milkfish are farmed in both environments. [10] Different pen sizes are recommended for different species. [16] :12 Fish pens can be damaged by natural disasters, and their operation can be impeded by water hyacinth. [17]

Fish cages require more supplementary feeding and are thus more labor-intensive than fish ponds. [12] However, they have lower capital costs. Simple cages use wire mesh or fishing nets to create an enclosure around all but the top side, supported by bamboo. [14] In shallow waters fish cages are often moored to the ground, floating cages in deeper waters are more expensive to produce. [16] :11 Some fish cages have been imported from abroad, including from Norway and the United States. [14] Some of these can produce 30 tons of milkfish every four or five months. [12] Groupers are raised in marine cages, including wild-caught groupers thought too small to sell. Groupers can be fed tilapia whose growth was stunted by overcrowding. For milkfish, marine cages are more intensive and can produce higher output per unit area than in other locations. [10] Growth rates for caged tilapia vary from four months to a year depending on environmental conditions. [16] :12 In the ocean, circular milkfish cages 19 metres (62 ft) wide and 15 metres (49 ft) deep can produce between 30 and 60 tons in under 150 days, and produce larger individual fish than land-based ponds. Control of milkfish diet allows for the taste of the fish to be assured. [13] Artificial milkfish feed can be as little as around 10% fishmeal. [13] However, large oceanic cages have high capital costs, both for the cages and for effective mooring mechanisms, and are very exposed to natural hazards. [13]

Very low impact pens created in mangrove areas, with some digging where needed to ensure water is present during low tide, can be used to harvest crabs without damaging the mangrove ecosystem. [10] These usually have one crab per square meter, producing 1,400 kilograms (3,100 lb) per 1 hectare (2.5 acres). [13] Fish cages can be owner-operated, but larger sets of fish cages can be owned by an individual who hires caretakers for the cages. In some coastal areas, fish cage cooperatives have been created to manage grouper cultivation as a community. [14]

Bivalves

The basic method of mussel and oyster farming is the "broadcast" method, where these products are simply farmed off the sea floor, sometimes from naturally existing mussel and oyster beds. This method means there is no conflict with vessels traveling in the area. Most farming is carried out through simple bamboo substrates. Bamboo poles fixed into mussel beds can produce a harvestable crop in six months. These are often 1 metre (3.3 ft) apart, and can be isolated or arranged in a cone around a central pole for stability. More advanced structures suspend substrates for bivalve growth from fishing lines. Rope web substrates have also been used, as have materials such as old tires. [10] The most commonly farmed mussel is the green mussel Perna viridis , which can grow in as little as six months. Harmful algal blooms impact mussel and oyster farming, especially in Manila Bay. [10] Overall, oyster farms are more common, as oysters are more widespread, although mussels are more valuable. Mussel farms are placed in deeper water than oyster farms. For both, farms are usually smaller than 1 hectare (2.5 acres). [14]

Mussel and oyster farming is a small part of overall aquaculture, with limited domestic demand. They are eaten more on special occasions than as daily food items. Farming is often undertaken alongside other jobs, such as fishing. [14] Mussels and oysters are usually sold alive, [10] and their sale is threatened by red tides making their consumption risky. These algal blooms first became an issue in Manila Bay, but have spread to other mussel farming areas. The government monitors water quality, and bans the harvesting and sale of bivalves if measurements breach certain thresholds. In Manila, all bivalve sales are banned during such periods, to prevent products from affected areas being mixed in with unaffected produce. [10] The risk of red tides has led to a reluctance to encourage the development of mussel and oyster farms. While such tides cause human health risks, they do not harm the farmed bivalves. Thus, red tide-related risk is more to do with cash flow for farmers, rather than the total loss of product. [13]

Seaweed

Seaweed farming is profitable even at a small scale, to the point that the small cost of investment is exceeded by the revenue from the first harvest (105–135 days). Caulerpa and Eucheuma are the most profitable, followed by Gracilaria . Gracilaria grows better in canals with flowing water than in still ponds. [14] Eucheuma is farmed in both shallow water, often on stakes, and in deep water, where it grows on single lines, rafts, and spider web nets. [4] Lines can also be suspended between polystyrene floats in deeper water. Seaweeds are grown 30–40 centimetres (12–16 in) apart on these lines. Sometimes lines are kept within net cages, to keep wild herbivores out. Growth takes two to three months, and most farmers are small-scale. This Eucheuma farming method is used for species such as Eucheuma denticulatum , but also species that were once considered Eucheuma but are now otherwise classified, such as Kappaphycus alvarezii . Caulerpa lentillifera can be grown in milkfish ponds by propagating cuttings separated from each other by 1 metre (3.3 ft). These cuttings gain enough nutrients from pond water changes. In later stages, some fertilizer can be applied by partially submerging sacks of fertilizer above the ponds, hanging like a "teabag". Farming of Gracilaria originally used similar methods to Caulerpa, although it can also be grown in seawater in cages or along nylon lines. [10] Seaweed farms are often smaller than 1 hectare (2.5 acres), and most are operated by their owners. [14] Even a small farm can be quite profitable. Farmers can obtain new seedstock from each of their harvests, with 100 grams (3.5 oz) of seedstock producing 2,000 grams (71 oz) of final product in three months. [18]

Productivity

Aquaculture structure in a river near the coast of Bulacan 2116Clouds and blue sky in Hagonoy and Paombong river districts 41.jpg
Aquaculture structure in a river near the coast of Bulacan

Aquaculture and municipal capture fisheries combined produced 73% of all catch from 2011 to 2020. [19] In 2018, the aquaculture sector produced 826.01 thousand tons of fish, crustaceans, and mollusks, worth $1.89 billion, the 11th-largest national production in the world accounting for 1.01% of global production. [1] :9 This included 1.48 million tons of seaweed and other aquatic plants, 4.56% of 2018's global seaweed production. [1] :9 In 2020, the aquaculture sector made up 41.82% of the total value of Philippine fisheries, directly employing 233,725 people. [1] :21 In 2021, there were 1.34 million tons of seaweed produced, 3.82% of global production, 4th largest in the world. [3] :141 93% of the 913.40 tons of brackish aquaculture production in 2020 was milkfish. Most (53.34%) brackish water aquaculture takes place in Bangsamoro, with a quarter (25.18%) taking place in Region I. [1] :31 The most commonly farmed shrimp is the jumbo tiger shrimp, which made up 42,453.94 tons of the total 70,474.77 2020 shrimp production. The second most farmed was the whiteleg shrimp, of which 20,612.48 tons were produced. [1] :42

Aquaculture production in 2020 [1] :32–38
MethodTotal production (metric tons)Key regions (production in metric tons)
FreshwaterFish ponds170,939.11III (132,827.85)
Fish cages74,010.90IV-A (64,576.88)
Fish pens39,847.67IV-A (26,575.91)
Small farm reservoirs114.41Bangsamoro (37.16), XII (36.03), III (24.98)
Rice-fish systems 5.21I (2.23)
MarineFish cages149,661.38I (101,984.67)
Fish pens846.38I (309.90), VI (197.48)
Seaweed1,468,653.27Bangsamoro (711,141.33), IV-B (320,717.21), IX (202,606.31)
Oysters53,032.06III (38,880.26), VI (10,569.86)
Mussels19,228.97VI (8,534.16), IV-A (5,654.23), VIII (4,085.92)

Tilapia made up 96% of all freshwater fish pond production in 2020, with the rest including milkfish, carp, catfish, mudfish, gourami, and prawns. [1] :32 Freshwater cage aquaculture is also dominated by tilapia, which makes up 86.82% of production, with the rest being milkfish, carp, and catfish. [1] :33 Freshwater fish pens produced 42.71% tilapia, 30.21% milkfish, and 27.06% carp. Of the small amount produced in small farm reservoirs, 73% was tilapia, with the remainder being milkfish, carp, catfish, gourami, and mudfish. [1] :34 Of the very small rice-fish system production, 71.02% is tilapia. [1] :35 Milkfish dominates marine fish cages production, making up 99.91% of output. [1] :36 Milkfish similarly dominates marine fish pen production, making up 98.38% of the total. [1] :37 However, the largest mariculture product is seaweed, the production of which made Bangsamoro the most productive fisheries region in 2020. [1] :10

Fish cages in Maitum Maitumaqua.jpg
Fish cages in Maitum

The production of algae through aquaculture grew from 707.0 thousand tonnes in 2000 to around 1,500 thousand tonnes annually in the years since then. [20] :27 In 2012, the Philippines 1.75 million tons of farmed seaweed produced made the country the world's third-largest producer. [4] Carrageenan makes up 94% of seaweed exports. [1] :11 In 2022, seaweed exports were 48,491 metric tons, exported to the United States, the Netherlands, Spain, Germany, and China. [3] :xii–xiii,108,124 Seaweed and oyster farming products are often sold to exporters of high-value goods, rather than being farmed directly for local food supply. [21]

Philippine aquaculture is hampered by the lack of a "trash fish" — a cheap fish that can be used to feed farmed fish — as most fish in the Philippines are directly valuable for human consumption. This increases the cost of farming carnivorous fish. Another common impediment is access to juveniles, for fish, crabs, and shrimp. For many species farmers often rely on hatcheries to obtain stock for their ponds. [10] Milkfish fry are deliberately wild-caught as juveniles to stock aquaculture ponds. [4] Some giant freshwater prawn operations have relied on imported juveniles. [10] Shellfish farming is vulnerable to red tides, and is thus risky as a sole source of income. [13] The damage caused by the annual typhoon season means coastal aquaculture is more developed than ocean mariculture. [20] :36 Production is also affected by the El Niño–Southern Oscillation. [12]

Socioeconomic impact

A shrimp hatchery in Macabebe JfSapladDavid339ShrimpsMacabebefvf.JPG
A shrimp hatchery in Macabebe

Food security

Aquaculture contributes to food security. [12] Most aquaculture products are sold in domestic markets, often in ports where established fish markets already cater to capture fisheries. [4] Over time aquaculture has become a larger component of domestic fishery production.0 As of 2020, aquaculture products took up 0.83% of the average spend of urban populations (compared with 0.54% for wild-caught fish), and 0.80% of the average rural spend (0.67% for wild-caught fish). [22] :7

Employment and ownership

Aquaculture provides employment and export goods. In some areas, it is the dominant industry. As an example, tilapia farming is a core component of the economy of Lake Sebu, South Cotabato, in 1994 making up over 50% of total income and employing 10% of workers. [12] Riverine and marine aquaculture provide an economic opportunity for poorer individuals, as access to water is much more available than access to land, which is often the property of rich landowners. [21] Aquaculture development projects have tried by the government as a way to alleviate poverty among municipal fisherfolk. [17] [13] As of 2020, there were 233,725 individuals involved in aquaculture. [1] :21

Fish ponds are often not worked by their owners, with the workers instead being caretakers or renters. Lobbying by the fish pond industry is influential. Although initially included in the Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program, fish ponds were later exempted from this land reform effort. Meanwhile, the rental price of government land was kept at below-market rates. The possession of land is often valuable on its own, even if little effort is put into fish pond productivity. Almost all freshwater aquaculture is from private enterprise. The government has more ownership of brackish ponds, although these are often leased to private bodies on a long-term basis. [14]

Small-scale fishermen often have difficulty accessing credit, with informal loans having interest as high as 20%. Credit is sometimes provided by buyers, in exchange for a guarantee of future produce. Some formal loans are issued by the government through various funds. In addition, under Presidential Decree 717, banks must have 25% of their loanable funds restricted to agriculture and fisheries projects. Compliance with this mandate has been patchy, and most bank loans go to larger companies. [23] Fees for fish pond rental are small, and some interest-free loans are defaulted. [24] :46

A fish pen in Meycauayan city Fish pen in Meycauayan, Bulacan.jpg
A fish pen in Meycauayan city

While some aquaculture-related jobs are performed by both genders, such as fish feeding, many, particularly those requiring more demanding physical labor such as construction, are predominantly held by men. A 1995 study found women more commonly involved in oyster farms than mussel farms, possibly due to oysters being farmed in shallower water. Women play a notably prominent role in seaweed farming. They also play a role in the post-harvest processing for different types of aquaculture, as well as in product marketing. It is not uncommon for women to be owner-operators of aquaculture farms. [17]

Conflict with capture fisheries

As fish pens are capital intensive, they exacerbated inequality in Laguna de Bay. Artisanal fisheries were forced to navigate around water now occupied by fish pens, and conflict emerged due to fears of poaching. Public pressure to dismantle fish pens has not overcome the political influence of fish pen owners. [14] While the overall productivity and value of waters with fish pens in them may increase, resulting value is concentrated amongst fishpen owners rather than other users of the area. [7] In 1997, fish cages located where Laguna de Bay flows into the Pansipit River were ordered to be demolished, to allow for fish migration and to improve scenic beauty. [14] Some fish farmers have formed NGOs that serve as advocacy groups. These sometimes come into conflict with wild-fishery NGOs, due to the competing priorities of aquaculture and capture fishing. [23]

Environmental effects

Land use

The conversion of land to aquaculture use can not only affect that land, but also introduce pollutants into the surrounding environment. The replacement of sugar cane plantations with shrimp farms in Negros Occidental salinized affected land. Such conversion of agricultural land is rare, with fishpond development instead being concentrated elsewhere. In particular, mangrove forests have been widely converted into brackish ponds, often in violation of the law. This has resulted in aquaculture expansion being a major contributor to mangrove deforestation. [7] Such deforestation destroys ecosystem services that are provided to local communities by these forests, while often producing much less value in return. [25] :85 Freshwater farming has less impact on the environment, and its wastewater can be used for irrigation. [7]

Aquatic environment

Aquaculture in Taal Lake Taal in Summer.jpg
Aquaculture in Taal Lake

Fish pens and fish cages congest water bodies, divert resources from the natural ecosystem, and can affect oxygen saturation. This affects wildlife, including natural fish, crustaceans, and mollusk populations, although cages may have a lower impact on the benthic environment. The introduction of fish pens in Laguna de Bay decreased wild fish and shellfish catch. Tilapia fish cages caused the level of dissolved oxygen in Lake Sampaloc to decrease, creating a dead zone a few meters below the surface. The disturbance of such a lake, bringing deoxygenated water closer to the surface, can cause a mass fish kill, even of caged fish. [7] The presence of aquaculture infrastructure, both for ponds and for aquatic structures, can affect sediment and water flow. [8] :61

Chemicals and antibiotic compounds introduced to water systems by aquaculture can pollute the local environment. Maritime fish cages also affect nutrient deposition, creating areas of relatively concentrated organic matter. [7] Such nutrient pollution can lead to fish kills. The water quality of affected areas in the Philippines varies throughout the year. [26] Oyster, mussel, and seaweed farms are relatively low impact, both environmentally, due to the simple material requirements, and visually, due to their being mostly underwater. They cause some silt buildup and prevent some fishing gear from being used, but otherwise can coexist along small-scale fishing. [7]

Ecosystem changes

The deliberate capture of milkfish fry creates unused by-catch. [4] Other aquaculture species are mostly non-native. [27] :37 Since 1907, 169 freshwater foreign species have been introduced (not all for aquaculture purposes), of which at least 82% have formed invasive wild populations. Introduced Eurasian carp and Nile tilapia have impacted multiple native species, for example, endemic species of Mount Isarog National Park. Tilapia played a role in bringing the native sinarapan fish to the brink of extinction and greatly reduced the population of flathead grey mullet in Naujan Lake. In Laguna de Bay, walking catfish, Hypostomus plecostomus janitor fish, and clown featherback knifefish harm aquaculture and native species. The walking catfish directly outcompetes the native broadhead catfish. Sailfin molly have harmed native insect populations. The Pterygoplichthys disjunctivus janitor fish has become established in Agusan Marsh. [27] :14–15 Tilapia may have introduced the Arctodiaptomus dorsalis copepod, which competes with native copepods. [27] :16

While the establishment of some invasive populations was accidental, like those of janitor fish and clown featherbacks, some populations were created intentionally, like those of Nile tilapia. [27] :4 Many introductions took place from the 1970s to the 1990s. [27] :7 The release of captive native species poses risks to the genetic variability of wild populations. [8] :61 Non-fish invasive species include Pontederia crassipes water hyacinth and Chinese softshell turtles, bred ornamentally and for food respectively. These damage not only the natural environment and biodiversity, but also aquaculture operations in affected waters. [27] :11–13

Management

A fish farm in Agoo 5411Santa Rita, Agoo, La Union 10.jpg
A fish farm in Agoo

Fishery resources fall under the Department of Agriculture, which contains the Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources (BFAR), the Philippine Fisheries Development Authority (PFDA), and the National Fisheries Research and Development Institute (NFRDI). PFDA manages ports. NFRDI was created by the Fisheries Code of 1998. [23]

The Fisheries Decree of 1975 blocked the privatization of government-owned fish ponds. [14] The Local Government Code of 1991 devolved responsibility for fisheries licensing and regulation to cities and municipalities (with the exception of leasing public land for fish ponds, which remains with BFAR). RA 8435, the Agriculture and Fisheries Modernization Act, was passed on December 22, 1997, quickly followed by RA 8550, the Philippine Fisheries Code, on February 25, 1998. [23]

The Fisheries Code of 1998 has provisions that affect or are directly targeted at aquaculture. [28] This code mandates that aquaculture areas, including privately owned ones, be registered with their Local Government Unit. It maintained the block against privatization. [14] The Fisheries Code initially banned fish pens, cages, and traps, in lakes, although this provision was not included in widely debated drafts. Sea-based cages are supposedly restricted from the migration routes of wild fish populations. [28] The Comprehensive Agrarian Reform Program of 1998 includes the guarantee of water resource access for seaweed farmers. [28] BFAR's Fisheries Administrative Order (FAO) No. 214 (2001), also known as the Code of Practice for Aquaculture mandates environmental impact assessments for aquaculture projects, [27] :79 as does the more general Fisheries Code of 1998. [27] :89 The Wildlife Resources Conservation and Protection Act of 2001 and the BFAR Fisheries Administrative Order 233-1 of 2010 promote the protection of native species, including those important for aquaculture. [29]

Bodies of water are public property, and their use requires local government approval. [7] Under the Fisheries Code, while public water bodies can be leased for use, they cannot be sold. Only 10% of the surface area can be used for aquaculture. [28] Fish ponds can be under 25-year leases from BFAR, shorter leases, or on private property. [25] :85 Mangrove areas are considered forests, and fall under the jurisdiction of the national government. [7] Theoretically, mangroves are protected and cannot be converted, limiting potential fish pond area. [28] Laws regulating the use of public natural resources, such as requiring 50 metres (160 ft) of mangroves near the water's edge, are often flouted. [7] Under the Fisheries Code of 1998, all unused or underused fish farms should be restored to mangrove forests, although rent costs being so low means classifying a fish pond as underused is difficult. [25] :85

Grouper fish cages in Del Gallego Fish Cages.jpg
Grouper fish cages in Del Gallego

Local governments are responsible for licensing aquaculture structures, such as fish pens, cages, and traps. [4] Where multiple local governments share a water body, a joint Fisheries and Aquatic Resources Management Council (FARMC) can be formed. These councils include not only local government or barangay officials, but representatives from NGOs, fisherfolk groups, and the private sector. [28] BFAR is responsible for fish pond lease agreements, imports and exports, and food safety. [4]

Fisheries in Laguna de Bay are regulated by the Laguna Lake Development Authority (LLDA). The LLDA's approval is required for any construction in the lake, including aquaculture infrastructure such as fish pens and fish corrals. [30] :52 While the Laguna Lake Development Authority limits individual pens to 5 hectares (12 acres), and corporate pens to 50 hectares (120 acres), these rules have at some times been bypassed through the use of paper corporations. [14] The appearance of the invasive clown featherback in Laguna de Bay, possibly washed into the lake by Typhoon Ketsana in 2009, reduced the native populations of not only the wild Leiopotherapon plumbeus , but farmed bighead carp, milkfish, and Nile tilapia. Native species in the lake such as the climbing perch, Manila sea catfish, Celebes goby, broadhead catfish, and mudfish can also be used for aquaculture. [29]

Research has often involved government bodies. [10] The Department of Science and Technology (DOST) carries out research related to fisheries, including through its Philippine Council for Aquatic and Marine Research and Development (PCAMRD). Many colleges have fishery courses that offer majors in Inland Fisheries, Marine Fisheries, and Fish Processing Technology. The Inland Fisheries majors have a strong focus on pond aquaculture. [23] The Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center carries out aquaculture research in Iloilo. [4] A Comprehensive National Fisheries Industry Development Plan (CNFIDP) was put in place for 2006–2025, and included plans to increase aquaculture. [4] The most recent revision was issued for 2021–2025. [31]

History

The first farmed fish is thought to be milkfish, whose fry was collected from tidal waters and raised in brackish ponds. This traditional practice persisted in Mactan, Cebu, until 1921. [10] Freshwater fish ponds were likely first used sometime in the early 20th century, although there is history of small-scale rice-fish system use. Despite many species being introduced for farming, production remained limited due to competition with cropland and a cultural preference for marine fish. Oyster farming began in 1931. [10] The Fishpond Lease Agreement (FLA) system and a Fishpond Permit (FP) system were established in 1937, allowing for rental of government land for aquaculture. [14] Due to the reliance on wild catch to support traditional milkfish ponds, shrimp fry often also ended up in these ponds, and ponds were occasionally contaminated with seaweed. Shrimp and seaweed thus became initially farmed as a secondary products. [10]

A monument in San Pablo, Laguna, celebrating the introduction of tilapia to Lake Palakpakin and Lake Sampaloc Tilapia Monument, San Pablo City, Laguna.jpg
A monument in San Pablo, Laguna, celebrating the introduction of tilapia to Lake Palakpakin and Lake Sampaloc

Mozambique tilapia were imported from Thailand in 1950. Tilapia were much easier to breed than milkfish, making it possible for anyone to maintain a small-scale tilapia farm. The fish was initially popular and pushed by politicians, however the resulting fish were often unwanted. [10] [17] Mussel farming began in 1955 in an existing oyster farm, as an attempt to shift the view of oyster farmers from treating mussels as a pest to treating them as another commodity. Production remained around Manila Bay until the 1970s, due to the limited natural range of Perna viridis. However, Perna viridis eventually spread to other areas, possibly as biofouling pollution in bilge water. In the 1960s, crabs of the Scylla genus, which had previously been opportunistically farmed in milkfish ponds, began to be more actively managed. In the 1960s, demand for carrageenan led to Eucheuma seaweed being commercially farmed for export. [10] Seaweed farms often served as a reliable secondary source of income. [32]

Bamboo fish cages were first introduced in 1965 to the freshwater Laguna de Bay, although their use remained limited. [14] [15] In the 1970s, bamboo and net milkfish pens were established by the Laguna Lake Development Authority, and were widely adopted. However, they proliferated to the extent the lake became oversaturated, and many were later abandoned. [10] [14]

1972 saw the crucial importation of Nile tilapia. [16] :4 These grew faster than Mozambique tilapia, [10] were resilient to poor environmental conditions, [33] :45 and were popular with consumers. [34] :16 [35] This introduction, alongside the ability to farm single-gender ponds, saw freshwater tilapia farming expand from a small-scale seasonal enterprise to widespread commercial production. [10] By the mid-1980s, tilapia were the second most farmed fish after milkfish. [16] :5

Jumbo tiger shrimp were successfully bred in captivity the 1970s. Dedicated shrimp faming began in Negros Occidental, where sugar fields were often converted into aquaculture farms. Jumbo tiger shrimp became the largest marine export of the Philippines. [10] A 1980 ban on the conversion of mangroves to aquaculture was ineffective, with conversion rates increasing in the following years. [25] :84

Fish ponds in Orion, Bataan 09575jfDaang Fields Halls Bago Poblacion Orion Bataanfvf 26.JPG
Fish ponds in Orion, Bataan

The Local Government Code of 1991 shifted seaweed licencing responsibilities from the national government, which allowed seaweed farms to have a maximum size of 1 hectare (2.5 acres), to local governments. [10] The FLA fishpond land lease system of 25 years renewable to 50 years was preserved in the Fisheries Code of 1998. [14]

Marine fish cage use become large enough to be recorded in 1993. [14] Fish cage farming spread both in inland rivers and in coastal marine water. Milkfish continued to dominate aquaculture throughout this period, being able to be farmed across varied environmental conditions. [10] In the mid-1990s, intensive shrimp farming methods were applied to milkfish when the rapid shift to industrial shrimp ponds led to market oversaturation and the spread of disease. [10] In 1998, the first commercial farming of tilapia able to survive in brackish water took place in Negros Occidental. [10]

From 1980 to 2010, capture fisheries were dominant. Since this time, aquaculture has since increased in relative prominence. [22] :8 From 2012 to 2021, aquaculture was far more productive than municipal fisheries, whose productivity was in turn slightly higher than that of commercial fisheries. [36] :27 In terms of value the difference was not as large. [36] :28 From 2013 to 2022, aquaculture production by volume fluctuated slightly, although its value increased. [3] :33

In 2022, there were 2.35 million metric tons of aquaculture products created in the Philippines, 54.15% of all fisheries products in the Philippines, with a total value of around PhP 124.00 billion. The biggest item by volume was seaweed, which made up 65.8% of aquaculture production. This created a value of PhP 16,60 billion, less than some other fishery products due to seaweed having a lower value per unit weight. The largest environment for aquaculture aside from seaweed farms was brackish ponds, followed by freshwater ponds and marine cages. By product type, the second largest by volume and highest by value was milkfish, of which 184,162.33 metric tons (47.47%) were produced in fish ponds and 180,290.27 metric tons (46.47%) were produced in fish cages. Tilapia was third by volume and third by value, with 77.19% of these tilapia being farmed in fish ponds. Shrimp was fourth by volume and second by value, with the most produced and most valuable shrimp being jumbo tiger shrimp. Seaweed farms produced the fourth-most value. [3] :30,32,39–44,48–49

Notes

  1. The Scylla genus has seen various taxonomic revisions, and Scylla oceanica is now usually considered a part of Scylla serrata. [11]

Related Research Articles

Aquaculture, also known as aquafarming, is the controlled cultivation ("farming") of aquatic organisms such as fish, crustaceans, mollusks, algae and other organisms of value such as aquatic plants. Aquaculture involves cultivating freshwater, brackish water, and saltwater populations under controlled or semi-natural conditions and can be contrasted with commercial fishing, which is the harvesting of wild fish. Aquaculture is also a practice used for restoring and rehabilitating marine and freshwater ecosystems. Mariculture, commonly known as marine farming, is aquaculture in seawater habitats and lagoons, as opposed to freshwater aquaculture. Pisciculture is a type of aquaculture that consists of fish farming to obtain fish products as food.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mariculture</span> Cultivation of marine organisms in saltwater environments

Mariculture, sometimes called marine farming or marine aquaculture, is a branch of aquaculture involving the cultivation of marine organisms for food and other animal products, in seawater. Subsets of it include, fish farms built on littoral waters, or in artificial tanks, ponds or raceways which are filled with seawater. An example of the latter is the farming of plankton and seaweed, shellfish like shrimp or oysters, and marine finfish, in saltwater ponds. Non-food products produced by mariculture include: fish meal, nutrient agar, jewellery, and cosmetics.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tilapia</span> Common name for many species of fish

Tilapia is the common name for nearly a hundred species of cichlid fish from the coelotilapine, coptodonine, heterotilapine, oreochromine, pelmatolapiine, and tilapiine tribes, with the economically most important species placed in the Coptodonini and Oreochromini. Tilapia are mainly freshwater fish inhabiting shallow streams, ponds, rivers, and lakes, and less commonly found living in brackish water. Historically, they have been of major importance in artisanal fishing in Africa, and they are of increasing importance in aquaculture and aquaponics. Tilapia can become a problematic invasive species in new warm-water habitats such as Australia, whether deliberately or accidentally introduced, but generally not in temperate climates due to their inability to survive in cold water.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fish farming</span> Raising fish commercially in enclosures

Fish farming or pisciculture involves commercial breeding of fish, most often for food, in fish tanks or artificial enclosures such as fish ponds. It is a particular type of aquaculture, which is the controlled cultivation and harvesting of aquatic animals such as fish, crustaceans, molluscs and so on, in natural or pseudo-natural environments. A facility that releases juvenile fish into the wild for recreational fishing or to supplement a species' natural numbers is generally referred to as a fish hatchery. Worldwide, the most important fish species produced in fish farming are carp, catfish, salmon and tilapia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Milkfish</span> Species of fish

The milkfish is a widespread species of ray-finned fish found throughout the Indo-Pacific. It is the sole living species in the family Chanidae, and the only living member of the genus Chanos. The repeating scientific name (tautonym) is from Greek khanos. They are grouped in the order Gonorhynchiformes and are most closely related to the Ostariophysi—freshwater fishes such as carps, catfish, and loaches.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fish pond</span> Man-made body of standing water used for pisciculture

A fish pond or fishpond is a controlled pond, small artificial lake or retention basin that is stocked with fish and is used in aquaculture for fish farming, for recreational fishing, or for ornamental purposes.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Integrated multi-trophic aquaculture</span> Type of aquaculture

Integrated multi-trophic aquaculture (IMTA) is a type of aquaculture where the byproducts, including waste, from one aquatic species are used as inputs for another. Farmers combine fed aquaculture with inorganic extractive and organic extractive aquaculture to create balanced systems for environment remediation (biomitigation), economic stability and social acceptability.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fishing in India</span> Major industry employing 14.5 million people

Fishing in India is a major sector within the economy of India contributing 1.07% of its total GDP. The fishing sector in India supports the livelihood of over 28 million people in the country, especially within the marginalized and vulnerable communities. India is the third largest fish producing country in the world accounting for 7.96% of the global production and second largest producer of fish through aquaculture, after China. The total fish production during the FY 2020-21 is estimated at 14.73 million metric tonnes. According to the National Fisheries Development Board the Fisheries Industry generates an export earnings of Rs 334.41 billion. Centrally sponsored schemes will increase exports by Rs 1 lakh crore in FY25. 65,000 fishermen have been trained under these schemes from 2017 to 2020. Freshwater fishing consists of 55% of total fish production.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Raceway (aquaculture)</span> Artificial channel used in aquaculture

A raceway, also known as a flow-through system, is an artificial channel used in aquaculture to culture aquatic organisms. Raceway systems are among the earliest methods used for inland aquaculture. A raceway usually consists of rectangular basins or canals constructed of concrete and equipped with an inlet and outlet. A continuous water flow-through is maintained to provide the required level of water quality, which allows animals to be cultured at higher densities within the raceway.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in New Zealand</span>

Aquaculture started to take off in New Zealand in the 1980s. It is dominated by mussels, oysters and salmon. In 2007, aquaculture generated about NZ$360 million in sales on an area of 7,700 hectares. $240 million was earned in exports.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in Australia</span> On a steady increase since 1970 accounting for 34% of seafood

Aquaculture in Australia is the country's fastest-growing primary industry, accounting for 34% of the total gross value of production of seafood. 10 species of fish are farmed in Australia, and production is dominated by southern bluefin tuna, Atlantic salmon and barramundi. Mud crabs have also been cultivated in Australia for many years, sometimes leading to over-exploitation. Traditionally, this aquaculture was limited to table oysters and pearls, but since the early 1970s, there has been significant research and commercial development of other forms of aquaculture, including finfish, crustaceans, and molluscs.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in Indonesia</span>

Indonesia ranks as the fourth most productive country in the world measured in terms of gross yearly aquaculture production with an estimated 14.4 million tons in 2014. It benefits from being an archipelago nation with an extensive coastline over 81,000 km long, situated in a tropical climate. The top aquaculture products exported include shrimp, fish and seaweed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in China</span>

China, with one-fifth of the world's population, accounts for two-thirds of the world's reported aquaculture production.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fishing industry in Pakistan</span> Overview of fishing in Pakistan

The fishing industry plays a significant part in the national economy of Pakistan. With a coastline of about 1,120 km, Pakistan has enough fishery resources that remain to be developed. Most of the population of the coastal areas of Sindh and Balochistan depends on fisheries for livelihood. It is also a major source of export earning.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in South Africa</span>

South Africa has an emerging aquaculture. It consists mainly of culture of freshwater species such as crocodiles, trout, catfish, tilapia, and ornamental fish as well as marine species such as abalone, prawns, oysters, and mussels.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in South Korea</span>

South Korea is a major center of aquaculture production, and the world's third largest producer of farmed algae as of 2020.

Saltwater aquaponics is a combination of plant cultivation and fish rearing, systems with similarities to standard aquaponics, except that it uses saltwater instead of the more commonly used freshwater. In some instances, this may be diluted saltwater. The concept is being researched as a sustainable way to eliminate the stresses that are put on local environments by conventional fish farming practices who expel wastewater into the coastal zones, all while creating complementary crops.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aquaculture in the United Kingdom</span>

Aquaculture in the United Kingdom is dominated by salmon farming, then by mussel production with trout being the third most important enterprise. Aquaculture in the United Kingdom represents a significant business for the UK, producing over 200,000 tonnes of fish whilst earning over £700 million in 2012 (€793 million).

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fisheries in the Philippines</span>

Fisheries in the Philippines consist of both capture fisheries and aquaculture. The Philippines is an archipelagic country with a large coastal population. In many areas, communities rely heavily on fisheries for subsistence and livelihoods. Both capture fisheries and aquaculture occur inland and at sea, producing various fish, shellfish, other invertebrates, and seaweed.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">History of fisheries in the Philippines</span>

Fisheries in the Philippines have played an important role in the livelihoods of people in the archipelago throughout recorded history. Fishing is present within traditional folklore and continues to play an important role in modern livelihoods in the Philippines, both for sustenance and for commercial activities. Early coastal communities likely fished both for sustenance and for trade. Fisheries resources would have fallen under the control of local leaders. In addition to capture fishing, some communities also practiced aquaculture, farming milkfish in brackish coastal fish ponds. Spanish rule saw control over resources shift to central authorities, however, there was little actual management.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 "Philippine Fisheries Profile 2020" (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. 2020. ISSN   2704-3355.
  2. Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Introduction". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 "2022 Philippine Fisheries Profile" (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. October 2023. ISSN   2704-3355 . Retrieved August 9, 2024.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 "Fishery and Aquaculture Country Profiles Philippines". Food and Agriculture Organization. Retrieved June 9, 2024.
  5. Managing Coastal Habitats and Marine Protected Areas (PDF). Philippine Coastal Management Guidebook Series. Vol. 5. Department of Environment and Natural Resources. 2001. ISBN   971-92289-4-6.
  6. 1 2 3 Managing Municipal Fisheries (PDF). Philippine Coastal Management Guidebook Series. Vol. 6. Department of Environment and Natural Resources. 2001. ISBN   971-92289-5-4.
  7. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Wilfredo G. Yap. "Environmental Issues". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  8. 1 2 3 4 Department of Environment and Natural Resources (2001). Managing Impacts of Development in the Coastal Zone (PDF). Philippine Coastal Management Guidebook Series. Vol. 7. ISBN   971-92289-6-2.
  9. 1 2 3 4 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Resources". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  10. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Overview of Philippine Aquaculture". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  11. Clive P. Keenan; Peter J.F. Davie; David L. Mann (1998). "A revision of the genus Scylla de Haan, 1833 (Crustacea: Decapoda: Brachyura: Portunidae)". The Raffles Bulletin of Zoology. 46 (1): 217–245.
  12. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Role of Aquaculture in Development". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  13. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Recommendations for Rural Aquaculture Projects". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  14. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Socio-economic Aspects of Philippine Aquaculture". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  15. 1 2 Jovenal F. Lazaga; Leonardo L. Roa (1985). "Financial and Economic Analyses of Grow-Out Tilapia Cage Farming in Laguna de Bay, Philippines". In Ian R. Smith; Enriqueta B. Torres; Elvira O. Tan (eds.). Philippine Tilapia Economics (PDF). Philippine Council for Agriculture and Resources Research and Development. p. 108. ISBN   971-1022-18-4. ISSN   0115-4435.
  16. 1 2 3 4 5 Rafael D. Guerrero III (1985). "Tilapia Farming in the Philippines: Practices, Problems and Prospects". In Ian R. Smith; Enriqueta B. Torres; Elvira O. Tan (eds.). Philippine Tilapia Economics (PDF). Philippine Council for Agriculture and Resources Research and Development. ISBN   971-1022-18-4. ISSN   0115-4435.
  17. 1 2 3 4 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Opportunities for Further Development". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  18. Medina N. Delmendo; V. Alvarez; H.R. Rabanal (1992). "Agro-Industrial Relevance of Seaweed Farming to Rural Coastal Communities". The Evolution of Seaweed Farming Development and its Relevance to Rural Agro-Industrial Development of Coastal Communities in the Philippines. Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources.
  19. Gaea Katreena Cabico (March 5, 2023). "Prioritizing artisanal fishers' conditions crucial to sustainable Philippine fisheries — report". PhilStar. Retrieved August 8, 2024.
  20. 1 2 The State of World Fisheries and Aquaculture 2020 Sustainability in Action. FAO. 2020. doi:10.4060/ca9229en. hdl:10535/4529. ISBN   978-92-5-132692-3. ISSN   2410-5902 . Retrieved August 6, 2024.
  21. 1 2 Wilfredo G. Yap. "Discussion and Conclusion". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  22. 1 2 David Suh; Robert Pomeroy (April 16, 2020). "Projected Economic Impact of Climate Change on Marine Capture Fisheries in the Philippines". Frontiers in Marine Science. 7. doi: 10.3389/fmars.2020.00232 .
  23. 1 2 3 4 5 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "Institutional Aspects". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  24. Stuart J. Green; Alan T. White; Jimely O. Flores; Marciano F. Carreon III; Asuncion E. Sia (2003). Philippine Fisheries in Crisis: A Framework for Management (PDF). Coastal Resource Management Project. ISBN   971-92753-1-6.
  25. 1 2 3 4 Alan T. White; Roy Olsen D. De Leon (2004). "Mangrove Resource Decline in the Philippines: Government and Community Look for New Solutions". In Turbulent Seas: The Status of Philippine Marine Fisheries (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. p. 84. ISBN   971-92753-4-0 . Retrieved August 16, 2024.
  26. Maria Lourdes San Diego McGlone; Gil Jacinto; Imelda Velasquez; Daisy Padayao (2004). "Status of Water Quality in Philippine Coastal and Marine Waters". In Turbulent Seas: The Status of Philippine Marine Fisheries (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. pp. 97–98, 104–105. ISBN   971-92753-4-0 . Retrieved August 16, 2024.
  27. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 "The National Invasive Species Strategy and Action Plan 2016-2026" (PDF). Department of Environment and Natural Resources-Biodiversity Management Bureau. 2016.
  28. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Wilfredo G. Yap (1999). "National Programmes For Aquaculture Development". Rural Aquaculture in the Philippines. FAO.
  29. 1 2 Frolan A. Aya (2019). "Towards Reviving the Production of Philippine Native Aquatic Species" (PDF). Southeast Asian Fisheries Development Center. Retrieved September 24, 2024.
  30. "Development of National and Local Government Fisheries Registration and Licensing Frameworks for the Philippines: Registration and Licensing Framework for the Municipal Capture Fisheries Sector of the Philippines" (PDF). USAID. Retrieved August 30, 2024.
  31. "Comprehensive National Fisheries Industry Development Plan (2021-2025)" (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. ISSN   2815-2131 . Retrieved July 21, 2024.
  32. Medina N. Delmendo; V. Alvarez; H.R. Rabanal (1992). "Development of Eucheuma Seaweed Farming". The Evolution of Seaweed Farming Development and its Relevance to Rural Agro-Industrial Development of Coastal Communities in the Philippines. Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources.
  33. Ma. Corazon B. Gaite; Jose Noel A. Morales; Olga Criselda R. Orilla; Bernardine B. Pili (1985). "The Adoption of Tilapia Farming and Its Impact on the Community of Sto. Domingo, Bay, Laguna, Philippines". In Ian R. Smith; Enriqueta B. Torres; Elvira O. Tan (eds.). Philippine Tilapia Economics (PDF). Philippine Council for Agriculture and Resources Research and Development. ISBN   971-1022-18-4. ISSN   0115-4435.
  34. Luz R. Yater; Ian R. Smith (1985). "Economics of Private Tilapia Hatcheries in Laguna and Rizal Provinces, Philippines". In Ian R. Smith; Enriqueta B. Torres; Elvira O. Tan (eds.). Philippine Tilapia Economics (PDF). Philippine Council for Agriculture and Resources Research and Development. ISBN   971-1022-18-4. ISSN   0115-4435.
  35. Enriqueta B. Torres (1985). "Tilapia Marketing in Central Luzon and Metro Manila, Philippines". In Ian R. Smith; Enriqueta B. Torres; Elvira O. Tan (eds.). Philippine Tilapia Economics (PDF). Philippine Council for Agriculture and Resources Research and Development. p. 187. ISBN   971-1022-18-4. ISSN   0115-4435.
  36. 1 2 "Philippine Fisheries Profile 2021" (PDF). Bureau of Fisheries and Aquatic Resources. 2022. ISSN   2704-3355 . Retrieved August 9, 2024.