2023 Utah's 2nd congressional district special election

For broader coverage of this topic, see Utah's 2nd congressional district.

2023 Utah's 2nd congressional district special election

←  2022 November 21, 2023 2024  →
Utah's 2nd congressional district
Nominee Celeste Maloy Kathleen Riebe Party Republican Democratic Popular vote 89,866 52,949 Percentage 57.1% 33.6%
County results Maloy:     50–60%     60–70%     70–80%     80–90%     >90% Riebe:      60-70%
U.S. Representative before election Chris Stewart Republican Elected U.S. Representative Celeste Maloy Republican

The 2023 Utah's 2nd congressional district special election was held on November 21, 2023, to choose a new member of the U.S. House of Representatives. The seat became vacant following Republican representative Chris Stewart's resignation on September 15, 2023, due to his wife's ongoing health issues. ^[1]

On June 7, 2023, Utah governor Spencer Cox declared that the special election would be held on November 21, 2023, with the primary being held on September 5, 2023. ^[2] This was the first congressional special election in Utah since the 2017 election in the 3rd district following the resignation of Jason Chaffetz, and only the second since 1930. ^[3]

Celeste Maloy, Stewart's legal counsel, won the Republican convention. Her victory was considered an upset, as former Utah House Speaker Greg Hughes led every round of voting except for the final. ^[4] Two other candidates, former Republican National Committee member Bruce Hough and former state representative Becky Edwards, qualified for the Republican primary via petition. ^[5] Some Republicans filed a lawsuit to remove Maloy from the ballot after it was revealed that her Utah voter registration was inactive, as she had moved to Virginia while working for Stewart; however, the lawsuit was rejected. ^[6]

Democrats nominated state senator Kathleen Riebe. ^[7] The 2nd district is considered a safe Republican seat, with a Cook PVI of R+11. Stewart was re-elected with 59.7% of the vote in 2022. ^[8] Donald Trump won the district with 56.7% of the vote in the 2020 presidential election. ^[9]

Republican primary

Candidates

Eleven candidates competed at the Republican convention on June 24. Celeste Maloy won, guaranteeing her a spot on the primary ballot. ^[10] Two candidates who lost at the convention, Becky Edwards and Bruce Hough, also qualified for the ballot by collecting signatures. ^[5]

Edwards's candidacy attracted attention due to her controversial stances; she voted for Joe Biden in the 2020 presidential election, disagreed with the overturning of Roe v. Wade , supported the second impeachment of Donald Trump, and challenged U.S. Senator Mike Lee in his 2022 primary. ^[11]

Nominee

• Celeste Maloy, counsel for then-U.S. representative Chris Stewart ^[5]

Eliminated in primary

• Becky Edwards, former state representative from HD-20 (2009–2018) and candidate for U.S. Senate in 2022 ^[5]
• Bruce Hough, former Republican National Committee member, former chair of the Utah Republican Party, and father of dancers Derek Hough and Julianne Hough ^[5]

Lost at convention

• Kathleen Anderson, communications director for the Utah Republican Party and candidate for Utah's 4th congressional district in 2020 ^[12]
• Henry Eyring, Duke University professor and grandson of LDS Church Second Counselor Henry B. Eyring ^[13]
• Scott Hatfield, congressional staffer ^[13]
• Jordan Hess, former vice chair of the Utah Republican Party (endorsed Maloy) ^[13]
• Greg Hughes, former Speaker of the Utah House of Representatives (2015–2018) from HD-51 (2003–2018) and candidate for Governor of Utah in 2020 ^[14]

Withdrew during convention

• Quin Denning, construction contractor ^[12]
• Bill Hoster, mayor of Leeds (endorsed Hughes) ^[13]
• Scott Reber, realtor and former congressional staffer (endorsed Maloy) ^[13]

Withdrew before convention

• Tyrone Jensen, political podcaster, candidate for U.S. Senate in 2018 and 2022, and candidate for this district in 2020 ^[13]

Disqualified

• Remy Bubba Kush ^[12]

Declined

• Sheryl Allen, former state representative from HD-19 (1994–2011) ^[15]
• Gil Almquist, Washington County commissioner ^[15]
• Kathleen Anderson, communications director for the Utah Republican Party and candidate for Utah's 4th congressional district in 2020 ^[13]
• Robert Axson, chair of the Utah Republican Party (2023–present) ^[15]
• Brad Bonham, entrepreneur ^[13]
• Walt Brooks, state representative from HD-75 (2016–present) ^[13]
• Derek Brown, former chair of the Utah Republican Party (2019–2021) and former state representative from HD-49 (2011–2014) ^[13]
• Daniel McCay, state senator from SD-18 (2019–present) ^{[13] [16]}
• Kim Coleman, former state representative from HD-42 (2015–2021) and candidate for the 4th district in 2020 ^[13]
• Ben Horsley, chief of staff for the Granite School District ^[13]
• Victor Iverson, chair of the Washington County Commission ^[15]
• Carson Jorgensen, former chair of the Utah Republican Party (2021–2023) ^[15]
• Mike Kennedy, state senator from SD-21 (2021–present) and candidate for U.S. Senate in 2018 ^[13]
• Derek Miller, president of the Salt Lake Chamber of Commerce ^[15]
• Aimee Winder Newton, Salt Lake County councilor from the 3rd district (2014–present) and candidate for Governor of Utah in 2020 ^[16]
• Corey Norman, chief of staff to U.S. Representative John Curtis ^[17]
• Jason Perry, director of the Hinckley Institute of Politics ^[15]
• John Pike, former mayor of St. George ^[17]
• Sean Reyes, Utah Attorney General (2013–present) ^[15]
• Erin Rider, attorney, former staffer for then-U.S. Senator Orrin Hatch, and candidate for this district in 2022 ^[13]
• Adam Snow, Washington County commissioner ^[13]
• Trent Staggs, mayor of Riverton and nominee for mayor of Salt Lake County in 2020 (running for U.S. Senate) ^[13]
• Bob Stevenson, Davis County commissioner and candidate for Utah's 1st congressional district in 2020 ^[13]
• Todd Weiler, state senator from SD-08 (2012–present) ^[15]
• Thomas Wright, former chair of the Utah Republican Party and candidate for Governor of Utah in 2020 ^[15]

Endorsements

Greg Hughes (lost at convention)

Local officials

• Bill Hoster, mayor of Leeds and candidate for this seat in 2023 ^[18]

Celeste Maloy

U.S. Cabinet officials

• David Bernhardt, former United States Secretary of the Interior (2019–2021) ^[19]

U.S. representatives

• Rob Bishop, UT-01 (2003-2021) ^[20]
• Chris Stewart, UT-02 (2013-2023) ^[21]

Individuals

• Jordan Hess, former vice chair of the Utah Republican Party and candidate for this seat in 2023 (Eliminated at convention) ^[22]
• Scott Reber, realtor, former congressional staffer, and candidate for this seat in 2023 (Eliminated at convention) ^[23]

Bruce Hough

Individuals

• Scott Hatfield, former candidate for this seat (Eliminated at convention) ^[24]

Fundraising

Campaign finance reports as of August 16, 2023
Candidate	Raised	Spent	Cash on hand
Becky Edwards (R)	$678,975 [a]	$450,629	$228,346
Bruce Hough (R)	$538,700 [b]	$453,801	$84,899
Celeste Maloy (R)	$307,308	$217,563	$89,745
Source: Federal Election Commission [25]

Polling

Poll source	Date(s) administered	Sample size [c]	Margin of error	Becky Edwards	Bruce Hough	Celeste Maloy	Undecided
Dan Jones & Associates [26]	August 7–14, 2023	471 (RV)	± 4.51%	32%	11%	9%	47%

Pre-convention debate

Pre-convention debate

No.	Date	Host	Moderator	Link	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican	Republican
Key:  P Participant  A Absent  N Not invited  I Invited  W  Withdrawn
					Kathleen Anderson	Quin Denning	Becky Edwards	Henry Eyring	Scott Hatfield	Jordan Hess	Bill Hoster	Bruce Hough	Greg Hughes	Celeste Maloy	Scott Reber
1	Jun. 20, 2023	KTVX	Rob Axson Glen Mills	YouTube (part 1) YouTube (part 2)	P	P	P	P	P	P	P	P	P	P	P

Convention results

Republican convention results [27]
Candidate	First ballot		Second ballot		Third ballot		Fourth ballot		Fifth ballot
	Votes	%	Votes	%	Votes	%	Votes	%	Votes	%
Celeste Maloy	178	24.1%	199	27.0%	210	28.6%	244	33.2%	380	52.1%
Greg Hughes	211	28.5%	240	32.6%	259	35.2%	300	40.9%	349	47.9%
Jordan Hess	149	20.1%	163	22.1%	169	23.0%	155	21.1%	Eliminated
Henry Eyring	60	8.1%	54	7.3%	46	6.3%	35	4.8%	Eliminated
Bill Hoster	47	6.4%	33	4.5%	30	4.1%	Withdrawn
Becky Edwards	37	5.0%	27	3.7%	21	2.9%	Eliminated
Kathleen Anderson	14	1.9%	13	1.8%	Eliminated
Bruce Hough	14	1.9%	8	1.1%	Eliminated
Quin Denning	13	1.8%	Withdrawn
Scott Reber	13	1.8%	Withdrawn
Scott Hatfield	4	0.5%	Eliminated

Post-convention debate

Post-convention debate

No.	Date	Host	Moderator	Link	Republican	Republican	Republican
Key:  P Participant  A Absent  N Not invited  I Invited  W  Withdrawn
					Becky Edwards	Bruce Hough	Celeste Maloy
1	Aug. 15, 2023	KSL-TV		YouTube	A	P	P

Primary results

Results by county:

Maloy

•   Maloy—70–80%
•   Maloy—50–60%
•   Maloy—40–50%

Edwards

•   Edwards—50–60%
•   Edwards—40–50%

Hough

•   Hough—30–40%

Tie

•   Three-way tie—30–40%

Republican primary results ^[28]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%
	Republican	Celeste Maloy	36,288	38.8
	Republican	Becky Edwards	30,560	32.7
	Republican	Bruce Hough	26,562	28.4
Total votes			93,410	100.0

Democratic primary

Candidates

Nominee

• Kathleen Riebe, state senator from SD-15 (2019–present) ^[7]

Lost in convention

• Guy Warner, tech executive ^[12]
• Archie Williams, heavy equipment operator and perennial candidate ^[12]

Declined

• Ben McAdams, former U.S. representative from Utah's 4th congressional district (2019–2021) ^[13]
• Kael Weston, former U.S. State Department official, nominee for this district in 2020, and candidate for U.S. Senate in 2022 ^[29]
• Nick Mitchell, inventor, small business owner, and nominee for this district in 2022 ^{[30] [31]}

Convention results

Democratic convention results [32]
Candidate	First ballot
	Votes	%
Kathleen Riebe	243	85.56%
Guy Warner	36	12.67%
Archie Williams III	5	1.76%

Fundraising

Campaign finance reports as of August 16, 2023
Candidate	Raised	Spent	Cash on hand
Kathleen Riebe (D)	$94,451	$48,548	$45,902
Source: Federal Election Commission [25]

Third-party and independent candidates

United Utah Party

Nominee

• January Walker, cybersecurity professional and nominee for Utah's 4th congressional district in 2022 ^[13]

Lost convention

• Stone Fonua, tax preparer and perennial candidate ^[33]

Convention results

United Utah convention results
Candidate	First ballot
January Walker	81%
Stone Fonua	19%

Libertarian Party

Nominee

• Bradley Garth Green, plumbing supply store owner and son of Cedar City mayor Garth Green ^{[33] [34]}

Constitution Party

Nominee

• Cassie Easley, vice chair of the Utah Constitution Party and nominee for this district in 2022 ^[12]

Independents

Declared

• Joseph Buchman, college professor, former chair of the Utah Libertarian Party, and perennial candidate ^[33]
• Perry T. Myers ^[33]

General election

Debate

2023 Utah's 2nd congressional district special election debate

No.	Date	Host	Moderator	Link	Republican	Democratic
Key:  P Participant  A Absent  N Not invited  I Invited  W  Withdrawn
					Celeste Maloy	Kathleen Riebe
1 [35]	Oct. 26, 2023	KUED Utah Debate Commission	Mary Weaver	YouTube	P	P

Predictions

Source	Ranking	As of
The Cook Political Report [36]	Safe R	July 18, 2023
Inside Elections [37]	Solid R	June 7, 2023
DDHQ [38]	Safe R	September 4, 2023

Polling

Poll source	Date(s) administered	Sample size [c]	Margin of error	Celeste Malloy (R)	Kathleen Riebe (D)	Brad Green (L)	Other	Undecided
Lighthouse Research [39]	September 26 – October 6, 2023	528 (RV)	± 4.3%	43%	34%	6%	8% [d]	9%

Results

2023 Utah's 2nd congressional district special election

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Republican	Celeste Maloy	89,866	57.07	−2.64
	Democratic	Kathleen Riebe	52,949	33.62	−0.39
	Libertarian	Bradley Green	4,528	2.88	N/A
	Constitution	Cassie Easley	3,678	2.34	−0.62
	United Utah	January Walker	2,856	1.81	−1.51
	Independent	Perry Myers	2,276	1.45	N/A
	Independent	Joseph Buchman	1,281	0.81	N/A
	Write-in		39	0.02	N/A
Total votes			157,473	100.00
	Republican hold

By county

County Celeste Maloy Republican Kathleen Riebe Democratic Bradley Green Libertarian Cassie Easley Constitution January Walker United Utah Perry Myers Independent Joseph Buchman Independent Margin Total votes # % # % # % # % # % # % # % # % Beaver 1,428 85.56% 147 8.81% 31 1.86% 26 1.56% 9 0.54% 17 1.02% 10 0.60% 1,281 76.80% 1,668 Davis 17,221 61.10% 8,090 28.70% 512 1.82% 507 1.80% 602 2.14% 287 1.02% 240 0.85% 9,131 33.25% 27,459 Garfield 1,189 77.71% 244 15.95% 24 1.57% 27 1.76% 9 0.59% 25 1.63% 8 0.52% 945 61.93% 1,526 Iron 9,308 73.29% 1,760 13.86% 801 6.31% 410 3.23% 181 1.43% 95 0.75% 95 0.75% 7,548 59.67% 12,650 Juab 104 58.43% 47 26.40% 5 2.81% 9 5.06% 1 0.56% 10 5.62% 1 0.56% 57 32.20% 177 Kane 1,475 68.99% 500 23.39% 41 1.92% 42 1.96% 9 0.42% 58 2.71% 9 0.42% 975 45.69% 2,134 Millard 2,939 83.95% 277 7.91% 81 2.31% 92 2.63% 31 0.89% 54 1.54% 14 0.40% 2,662 76.32% 3,488 Piute 553 89.92% 38 6.18% 5 0.81% 11 1.79% 3 0.49% 4 0.65% 1 0.16% 515 83.74% 615 Salt Lake 12,239 26.86% 30,222 66.33% 880 1.93% 467 1.03% 1,060 2.33% 296 0.65% 394 0.86% −17,983 −39.47% 45,558 Sevier 4,061 83.96% 424 8.77% 98 2.03% 123 2.54% 44 0.91% 38 0.79% 34 0.70% 3,637 75.43% 4,822 Tooele 6,844 59.14% 2,628 22.71% 418 3.61% 356 3.08% 365 3.15% 737 6.37% 189 1.63% 4,216 36.54% 11,537 Washington 31,866 70.98% 8,369 18.64% 1,620 3.61% 1,594 3.55% 537 1.20% 629 1.40% 281 0.63% 23,497 52.34% 44,896 Wayne 639 70.45% 203 22.38% 12 1.32% 14 1.54% 5 0.55% 26 2.87% 5 0.55% 436 48.23% 904 Total 89,866 57.07% 52,949 33.62% 4,528 2.88% 3,678 2.34% 2,856 1.81% 2,276 1.45% 1,281 0.81% 36,917 23.45% 157,434

See also

• 2023 United States House of Representatives elections
• List of special elections to the United States House of Representatives

Notes

1. $300,000 of this total was self-funded by Edwards
2. $334,236 of this total was self-funded by Hough
3. Key:
   A – all adults
   RV – registered voters
   LV – likely voters
   V – unclear
4. Joe Buchanan (Ind.) and January Walker (UU) with <3%, and Cassie Easley (C) and Perry Myers (Ind.) with <2%

References

1. Talbot, Haley; Wright, David; Zanona, Melanie (May 31, 2023). "Utah Republican Chris Stewart to resign from Congress". CNN . Retrieved May 31, 2023.
2. Mentz, Sam (June 7, 2023). "Utah to hold election for retiring congressman's seat in November". ABC News . Retrieved June 7, 2023.
3. Schott, Bryan (May 30, 2023). "What happens to U.S. Rep. Chris Stewart's seat after he resigns from Congress?". The Salt Lake Tribune . Retrieved May 31, 2023.
4. Schott, Bryan (June 24, 2023). "Celeste Maloy wins Utah Republicans' nomination for special congressional election". The Salt Lake Tribune . Retrieved September 5, 2023.
5. Schott, Brian (July 12, 2023). "Three Republicans have qualified for Utah's special GOP primary election to replace Rep. Chris Stewart". The Salt Lake Tribune . Retrieved July 14, 2023.
6. Jennings, Aubree (July 31, 2023). "Lawsuit against Utah District 2 Celeste Maloy denied". ABC 4 . Retrieved September 5, 2023.
7. Schott, Bryan (June 28, 2023). "Kathleen Riebe nominated by Utah Democrats for special congressional election". The Salt Lake Tribune.
8. Schott, Bryan (May 30, 2023). "Utah's Rep. Chris Stewart plans to step down from the U.S. House, sources say". The Salt Lake Tribune . Retrieved May 30, 2023.
9. "Daily Kos Elections' 2020 presidential results by congressional district, for new and old districts". Daily Kos . September 29, 2021. Retrieved May 30, 2023.
10. "SPECIAL ELECTION CONVENTION FOR UTAH'S 2ND CONGRESSIONAL DISTRICT". Salt Lake County Republican Party. June 10, 2023. Retrieved June 15, 2023.
11. Metzger, Bryan (September 4, 2023). "A GOP former state lawmaker who voted for Biden in 2020, was against overturning Roe v. Wade, and supported impeaching Trump could soon be headed to Congress". Business Insider . Retrieved September 5, 2023.
12. Green, Bradley (June 9, 2023). "Who's in 2nd District race? Field is set for campaign to replace Rep. Chris Stewart". KSL News . Retrieved June 14, 2023.
13. Schott, Bryan (June 8, 2023). "Here's who could replace Rep. Stewart in Congress". The Salt Lake Tribune . Retrieved June 10, 2023.
14. Bates, Suzanne (June 8, 2023). "Becky Edwards, Greg Hughes officially enter the race for Chris Stewart's House seat". Deseret News . Retrieved June 9, 2023.
15. Pignanelli, Frank; Webb, LaVarr (June 1, 2023). "Opinion: Who will replace Rep. Chris Stewart in Congress?". Deseret News . Retrieved June 1, 2023.
16. Singer, Jeff (June 9, 2023). "Daily Kos Elections Live Digest: 6/9". Daily Kos . Retrieved June 9, 2023.
17. "Utah political experts mull over who will vie for Rep. Stewart's seat". June 1, 2023.
18. "Bill Hoster throws his support to Greg Hughes and withdraws #utpol".
19. Bernhardt, David (August 24, 2023). "Opinion: I care about our public lands. I endorse Celeste Maloy". Deseret News.
20. Tomco, Brigham (June 24, 2023). "Celeste Maloy wins Utah Republican convention, advances in effort to replace Rep. Chris Stewart". Deseret News. Retrieved September 5, 2023.
21. Jacobson, Matthew (June 20, 2023). "Ahead of debate in special election, Rep. Chris Stewart endorses staffer to fill position". KUTV. Retrieved June 21, 2023.
22. "Jordan Hess endorses Celeste Maloy in the final round against Greg Hughes. That could spell doom for Hughes in the final round #utpol".
23. "Scott Reber just threw his support behind Celeste Maloy. Not a good development for Hughes #utpol".
24. https://twitter.com/ScottforUtah/status/1698336169292185771
25. "2024 Election United States House - Utah 2nd". fec.gov. Federal Election Commission . Retrieved August 27, 2023.
26. Dan Jones & Associates
27. "2023 CD2 Special Election Convention Results". The Utah Republican Party.
28. "US Congressional District 2".
29. Kael Weston [@KaelWeston] (June 13, 2023). "I have decided not to seek the Utah Democratic Party nomination for the upcoming special election in Utah's 2nd Congressional District" (Tweet) – via Twitter.
30. "Democratic representative Nicholas Mitchell seeks 2nd Congressional District chair in House". October 14, 2022. Retrieved November 28, 2023.
31. "Here's who could replace Rep. Chris Stewart in Congress". The Salt Lake Tribune. Retrieved November 28, 2023.
32. Anderson, Ben (June 29, 2023). "Sen. Kathleen Riebe Wins Democratic Nomination for Congressional District 2". Utah Democrats. Archived from the original on September 7, 2023. Retrieved June 29, 2023.
33. "2023 Candidate Filings".
34. Short, Barry; Lammi, Phil. "Utah Libertarian Party (UTLP) Nominates Mr. Bradley Garth Green for Utah's Congressional District-2" (PDF). Utah Libertarian Party. Retrieved June 27, 2023.
35. Poonia, Gitanjali (October 12, 2023). "Utah 2nd District debate candidates revealed as commission releases new poll". Deseret News . Retrieved October 13, 2023.
36. "While Trump Dominates the National Stage, He Hardly Registers in UT-02 Special" . The Cook Political43 Report. July 18, 2023. Retrieved August 28, 2023.
37. "Utah 2 Special: Beehive State Buzz". The Rothenberg Political Report. June 7, 2023. Archived from the original on June 8, 2023. Retrieved June 8, 2023. Politically, the district is solidly Republican. It would have voted for Donald Trump by 17 points, 56-39 percent, in 2020, and by a similar margin for Trump in 2016: 47-31 percent, with the rest going to independent candidate Evan McMullin.
38. "Special Election Results: Utah Congressional District 2". Decision Desk HQ. September 4, 2023. Archived from the original on September 5, 2023. Retrieved September 5, 2023.
39. Lighthouse Research

External links

• List of filed candidates per the Utah Elections Office

Official campaign websites

• Brad Green (L) for Congress
• Celeste Maloy (R) for Congress
• Kathleen Riebe (D) for Congress
• January Walker (UUP) for Congress