This article has multiple issues. Please help improve it or discuss these issues on the talk page . (Learn how and when to remove these template messages)
|
Plugg | |
---|---|
Other names | Plug |
Stylistic origins | |
Cultural origins | Early 2010s, United States |
Typical instruments | |
Subgenres | |
Fusion genres | |
PluggnB | |
Regional scenes | |
| |
Local scenes | |
Atlanta |
Plugg (also spelled plug) is a subgenre of trap music, that stems from the production style of Zaytoven, later polished and expanded by beatmakers from Beatpluggz collective, mainly by MexikoDro, StoopidXool, PoloBoyShawty, A$att, Jaypluggz]], and Dylvinci in the mid-2010s via online distribution on platform SoundCloud. [5]
Unlike mainline trap, which is defined by bombastic production and rattling hi-hat drum patterns, Plugg is said to be dreamy, [6] laidback, atmospheric, spacey, airy, minimal and catchy, described as having overall lush and jazzy atmosphere, ethereal multi-instrumental harmonies and melodies, sparse, disjoint, and relaxed drum programming with few hi-hats, and thick basslines. [7] Instead of hi-hats in mainline trap, plugg drumming mainly employs beat skips, crash cymbals and punctuated accent snares on half-beats. As described by a critic, plugg is best intended to be heard alone, "experience[d] .. [in] the way it's intended: as a day-long trance in your isolated abode". [8]
Vocally, plugg ranges from instrumental beats without vocals, to songs with either rapping or mellow singing. Rapping flows, used in plugg, range from aggressive to relaxed and mellow.
The genre got its name from the famous "Plug!" producer tag used by the members of BeatPluggz collective since 2013. [9] [10] [11] As MexikoDro claimed, either StoopidXool or someone else from Beatpluggz recorded the vocals for the tag. [12] At first, their tag used the word "Plugs!", but later they shortened it to "Plug!" [13]
Both variants "plugg" and "plug" are used to describe the genre. Other names for the genre include descriptive terms such as "new wave" [14] and "smooth jazz" [8] (not to be confused with new wave and smooth jazz genres).
Origins of plugg music are traced to the gospel and soul-influenced production style of Zaytoven [15] and other southern rap influences, such as OutKast, [15] as well as to loosely related subgenre of hip-hop called Chicago bop, which is a euphoric, fast-paced subgenre of drill music. [3] Plugg first emerged around 2013 as a cohesive production style of the collective called Beatpluggz including Atlanta-based producers MexikoDro and StoopidXool. [15] [5] Plugg was inspired by Zaytoven, [13] Project Pat, Juicy J, Gucci Mane, the snap rap group D4L and the Paper Mario Nintendo soundtrack. [10] MexikoDro and his fellow Beatpluggz members gained viewership via the SoundCloud platform, where plugg picked up an underground following. [10] [14] Plugg has been described as "near-ambient and intoxicating", a strong departure from the popular styles of the day. [9]
From around 2014 on, rappers like Playboi Carti, [8] Rich The Kid, Diego Money, [15] Kodak Black, Lil Yachty, [14] Famous Dex, Yung Bans and Reese LaFlare [9] brought mainstream attention to plugg for the first time by working with Beatpluggz and releasing tracks such as "Broke Boi" (by Playboi Carti), [14] [8] "Plug!" (by Rich the Kid and Kodak Black), [15] "Hella O's" (by Lil Yachty), "New Wave" (by Rich the Kid and Famous Dex), "Harrassin Me" (by Kodak Black and Humble Haitian), [1] "Dresser" (by Yung Bans) [11] "No Cap" (by Yung Bans and Reese LaFlare). Around the same time, rapper Nebu Kiniza recorded his viral hit single "Gassed Up" (later certified platinum) over the same plugg beat that was used in "Plug!" by Rich the Kid. [9] Among them, Carti was the first one to appreciate the production style of Beatpluggz, and also recorded other plugg records, such as "Money Counter", "Don't Tell Nobody", "Smash Pt.2" and "Chill Freestyle" around that time. [10] [14] Despite "Broke Boi" being his breakthrough hit, Playboi Carti never actually paid back to MexikoDro for these plugg beats, [16] as MexikoDro later claimed in interviews. Whether Rich the Kid paid for the beat for his "Plug!", which also was one of the biggest plugg hits of the day, [15] song or not also remains dubious. [9]
During the first wave, plugg beats, mainly done by Beatpluggz, also helped to shape careers of UnoTheActivist, Thouxanbanfauni and Yung Gleesh. [9]
The first mainstream wave of plugg was mainly a fad and quickly faded away as the rappers (Famous Dex, Rich the Kid, Lil Yachty) moved on to work with other producers. [10] [9] Playboi Carti had publicized creative break-up with MexikoDro, which was described "ugly" and moved on to work with Pi'erre Bourne, who wasn't making plugg. [9] Despite the aforementioned developments, in the underground during that time, plugg maintained consistent following and evolution, mostly thankfully to the online-centric nature of the subgenre. [14] [9] [3]
The new wave of plugg started in 2017–2020 and stemmed mainly from several sources. First, a new style of plugg emerged, called PluggnB, which combined plugg production with melodic, dreamy contemporary R&B synths. [10] [17] Among the originators of this new style stood XanGang, producer collective Surreal Gang, producers CashCache, Dylvinci, [1] Milanezie [14] and various rappers, such as BBY Goyard, I$AIAH, 909Memphis, rapper-producer Neiburr, and the now-defunct artistic collective known as SlayWorld, whose roster included some of the names most associated with the pluggnb scene such as Autumn!, Summrs [8] and Kankan. [3] Many of these artists have since moved away from pluggnb in favour of more mainstream sounding trap.
At the same time, a new wave of primarily plugg-oriented rappers emerged, many of whom grew listening to plugg, namely BoofPaxkMooky, [10] [8] [3] whose style is described to be reminiscent of the Playboi Carti-MexikoDro era songs, [9] and whose 2021 mixtape produced by StoopidXool called "Four Seasons" was regarded as one of the plugg's purest, according to a critic. [3] Tony Shhnow, [10] [8] described as the one bringing the influence of the 1990s R&B and earlier Southern hip-hop into plugg, [9] 10k Dunkin [10] [9] [8] and others. A new pleiad of plugg producers also emerged closer to 2020, most notable of them being CashCache [8] and Cash Cobain. [10] CashCache was described as a "primary architect" of the plugg sound used by Mooky, Shhnow and 10k Dunkin. [9] He is also regarded as the person bringing more lounge music and more jazz [18] influences in plugg, [3] making a style of plugg dubbed "sleepy plugg". [19]
Around that time in 2020, StoopidXool and Cash Cobain collaborated on an album with a New York City plugg rapper FLEE, and that release included the viral pluggnb hit "SWISH / USE 2" recorded in collaboration with Brent Faiyaz. [10] [9]
While BoofPaxkMooky, Tony Shhnow, 10k Dunkin and FLEE were described as "bringing the most true-to-the-form plug back" into rotation, [9] Lil Tecca, Autumn!, SSGKobe and SoFaygo helped to popularize the pluggnb sound by releasing TikTok hits "Show Me Up", "Knock Knock" and "Thrax", respectively. [9]
At the same time new names kept sprawling in the scene: Summrs and Autumn! brought in influences from the sound typical for "SadBoys" lead by Yung Lean into plugg, other noted new names in the genre included Ka$hdami, 1600J and RewindRaps, tana, among others. [9]
At the same time, plugg gained attention from Drake. Drake first recorded a song called "Plug" on a plugg beat around 2017, allegedly for his Scorpion album, but the song was later removed from the tracklist and only resurfaced online in 2020. [20] Later, also in 2020, Drake included a plugg track produced by MexikoDro titled "From Florida with Love" into his Dark Lane Demo Tapes mixtape. [10] [21] The purported reason for the inclusion of a plugg song into tracklist, was speculated to be the second wave of underground plugg that Drake was aware of. [9]
In 2021, rapper RXK Nephew released over 400 songs, some of which were described as "pluggnB." [22]
In 2022, Glokk40Spaz started gaining attention for his hardcore plugg rap style. This style had been founded in the DMV area, where it was given the name dark plugg. [2] Standing in contrast to the dreamy and melodic atmosphere of plugg, dark plugg (also known as DMV plugg and evil plugg) emphasizes an ominous and aggressive sound, with widespread use of the DMV flow. [23]
By the end of 2021, plugg sound flourished [23] and developed further, with multiple artists starting to add more digicore influences into their sound, examples of this being Daesworld's "2003" and Jaydes' "Highschool". [3] Producer Dani Kiyoko defined a darker style of plugg, dubbed "vamp plugg". Tracks such as "Xanax" by St47ic (producer by Dani Kiyoko) typify the "vamp plugg" sound. [3] This style is sometimes conflated with a demonic-sounding, hex-influenced and intentionally lo-fi style of trap known as "sigilkore" that emerged on SoundCloud, spearheaded by rappers Luci4 (previously known as Axxturel, Prynce Axxturel among other names), islurwhenitalk and their now-defunct collective Jewelxxet. [24]
In 2022, the hyperplugg microgenre began trending on SoundCloud and TikTok, when producer-artist Myspacemark started adding influences of hyperpop into his plugg sound up to the point of claiming to have invented the "hyperplugg" subgenre. It was unclear whether the subgenre was intended as an ironic meme or not, but after videos on the microgenre amassed tens of thousands views on TikTok, many fans of Myspacemark took the idea more seriously. [4]
Plugg music is typified by production style of Beatpluggz, first started by MexikoDro. According to CashCache, "simple chords, hard-hitting 808s and repetitive, thoughtful, addictive melodies" typify plugg music. [11] According to trap producer Popstar Benny, the foundation of plugg is "Zaytoven['s] 'street' Atlanta drums, and melodies, [which are] ... a little more 'internet' and little more videogamey". [11]
Multiple sources pinpoint the foundation of plugg drumming to Zaytoven's percussion style and samples. [9] [11] Zaytoven's percussion style was influenced by West Coast hip hop of the late 1990s. [25] Many drum samples used by Zaytoven were provided to him by his beatmaking mentor, JT the Bigga Figga, [25] and continue to be used by him ever since. [25]
Zaytoven's drum technique has been described as sparse, [9] bouncy [11] and swinging. [25] The sparse nature of production served the purpose to free up acoustic space for rapper's presence. [9] Zaytoven's drums are primarily centered around heavy 808 bass notes, and, as Zaytoven put it himself,
As long as the 808 was nice and bumping, everything else was just extra to me. It's almost like icing on the cake [25]
— Zaytoven
Zaytoven credits the swinging feel of his typical rhythms to the MPC2000 hardware sampler, which he uses through the career. [25] However MexikoDro and later plugg producers, while emulating Zaytoven's drums, used software drum machines to emulate them.[ citation needed ]
808 bass notes used in plugg and by Zaytoven and later plugg beatmakers have been described variously as thick, [7] hard,[ citation needed ] steady[ citation needed ], bumping [25] and deep. [26]
Typical Zaytoven's drumming is inherently polyrhythmical. Second to the 808 bass notes is usually a clap drum falling on every 2nd and 4th pulse in a measure. Another rhythmic line is usually added by several sparse lines of hi-hats, which only mark every 8th note and otherwise come and go in dense, occasional chumps. Next percussive line is formed by occasional ornamental accented snares. [26] Zaytoven also usually employs various additional percussive elements in his rhythms, such as occasional vocal "ahh" samples, bongos, shakers (the so-called "Zaytoven shaker") and so on, and according to Zaytoven, many of the later beatmakers mainly tried to emulate his drumming by re-using his percussive drum sounds. [25] The complete rhythm usually employs several minor variation throughout the song; and it might be turned on and off throughout the song, creating "beat cuts", or "beat skips". [26]
This section may need to be rewritten to comply with Wikipedia's quality standards, as Can be divided into clear subsections with better sources.(July 2022) |
Among the most recognizable traits of plugg are its catchy [12] Nintendo video-game influenced multi-layered melodies [13] with heavy use of chords [3] and xylophone, prevalence of synth pad synths and other soft synthetizer presets sparse drum programming, with frequent crash cymbals, punctuated TR-808 rimshots and other percussion samples, such as maracas, accent snares, and somewhat less frequent hi-hats, 808s in place of kick drums, [1] where kicks themselves are mostly absent. Muffled, heavily low-pass filtered claps are oftentimes used instead of snares.
Unlike original Zaytoven's production which relied heavily on piano and organ riffs together with minimal drumming, Beatpluggz retained the airy tone, structure and minimal drumming of Zaytoven's style but in place of pianos and organs they shifted the focus from using piano and organ to more synthetic sounds and also expanded the rhythmic vocabulary of Zaytoven's work by using wider variety of types of hi-hat, snare and other percussive samples. 808s used in Beatpluggz style also became comparably harder compared to Zaytoven's style. [9]
Among other defining traits of plugg music is the use of the "Plug!" vocal sample, [20] which first appeared as a producer tag of Beatpluggz collective, but later came to be used by producers inspired by Beatpluggz who were never part of the collective themselves. [13]
Plugg performers may employ a variety of vocals styles, including aggressive rapping, mellow rapping, whispering flow, DMV flow [23] and singing. [14]
Plugg beats are produced on a fast pace and are claimed to be easy to replicate to a producer, given a sheer amount of "type beat" plugg tutorials posted on YouTube, some claiming to teach making plugg beats in as little as 6 minutes. [8] [3] Before multiple plugg beat tutorials appeared on YouTube, MexikoDro himself claimed on the interview, that it takes him 15 minutes on average to make a final beat from scratch, of which production takes 10 minutes and mixing and mastering takes around 5 minutes. [13] Zaytoven would typically also not spend more than 5 to 10 minutes writing his beats. [27] [28]
Apart from the United States, by the mid-2010s to the early 2020s plugg took root in Europe, particularly in France and the post-Soviet countries, where local plugg scenes were formed thanks to skate videos, fashion trends and growing popularity of hip-hop music. [14]
French Parisian rapper Serane [9] [15] first learnt about plugg after listening to "Broke Boi" by Playboi Carti, which changed the way he looked at music and he started producing plugg himself and formed a crew of designers and artists, who coined the local aesthetic of mixing plugg sounds with their reverence to Japanese designer clothes. [10] The crew of Serane, dubbed "#OneTruePath", was noted as somewhat resemblant to Yung Lean and his SadBoys crew from Sweden, [9] who were also largely influenced by imported American hip-hop subgenres during their time. [14]
To Serane's surprise, Atlanta plugg producers were supportive of his crew's efforts. After he collaborated with various American plugg producers and rappers, including ATL Smook, BreezyB, 10K Dunkin, Tony Shhnow, Dylvinchi and CashCache, MexikoDro and StoopidXool themselves contacted him and offered to collaborate on music. [10]
At the same time, Serane met a great deal of criticism at home in France, where, in an aggressive UK drill dominated hip-hop environment, he was oftentimes dismissed as trash, mainly for his offbeat lesser-comprehendible flow. [29]
Besides Serane, other French plugg artists include rappers Southlove, Kasper!, Prince K., Yuri Online (all belonging to No. OneTruePath), 8Ruki, Lil Sandal, producers TTDafool, Voidd, Chenfol (also from #OneTruePath) and others [10] [14] Of them, Chenfol (also variably spelled Chenpol) is described as the originator of plugg sound in France. [9]
At first, plugg was dubbed minimalistic trap in Runet. [30] Face is commonly cited to be the first rapper from Russia to start rapping over plugg beats back in 2016, with songs such as "Кот" ("Cat") (produced by MexikoDro), "Vans" (produced by MexikoDro) [30] and the "Revenge EP" (2017). Boulevard Depo was another early proponent of plugg in Russia, with songs such as "Проснись и пеки" ("Wake and Bake") and "Rare First Basement" (both produced by FrozenGangBeatz in 2016), "Burnout" and "Snake In The Snacks" [30] (both produced by NastyBoy Boo in 2018).
Big Baby Tape was also among the first rappers from Russia to put plugg into spotlight with the release of his debut EP "Hoodrich Tales" in 2018, [30] which he described as having "the essence of plugg music", according to his understanding. [31] [32]
In Ukraine, plugg was pioneered by 044 KLAN music collective, particularly by rappers 044 ROSE and 044 yakata. [30]
Rocket, another Russian rapper, further popularized plugg in Russia with his "Supreme Swings" EP in 2020. [30] [33]
From the start, many of the plugg tracks from Russia and post-Soviet countries were recorded over homemade beats, made by producers such as FrozenGangBeatz, Presco Lucci, Neyba Chap, NastyBoy Boo.
In 2020, Russian plugg producer хабип мацуевич (habip matsuevich) recorded ironic track called "убер" ("uber"), referencing the абу бандит ("abu bandit") Russian youth subculture, centered around gopniks from Dagestan and their slang. Later in 2020 the song was uploaded on TikTok accompanied by video of LADA drifting, a common abu bandit leisure activity. On TikTok, the song unexpectedly became a viral hit and thus the oper plugg (опер плаг) subgenre was created. The name "oper plugg" references the оперстайл ("operstyle"), which is used to describe toned-down and lowered black LADAs abu bandits prefer to drift on. In 2021, "oper plugg" was further popularized by кумар рекордс (kumar records), a music collective consisting of джугмейн178рус (dzugmeyn178rus), ЭрикМеф (ErikMef), лилбойтага (lilboytaga) and also by rappers SberbankShawty, xanaxrehabclub, Валюта Скуратов (Valyuta Skuratov), uglystephan, and others.
Electro is a genre of electronic music and early hip hop directly influenced by the use of the Roland TR-808 drum machines, and funk. Records in the genre typically feature drum machines and heavy electronic sounds, usually without vocals, although if vocals are present they are delivered in a deadpan manner, often through electronic distortion such as vocoding and talkboxing. This is the main distinction between electro and previously prominent genres such as disco, in which the electronic sound was only part of the instrumentation. It also palpably deviates from its predecessor boogie by being less vocal-oriented and more focused on electronic beats produced by drum machines.
A drop or beat drop in music, made popular by electronic dance music (EDM) styles, is a point in a music track where a sudden change of rhythm or bass line occurs, which is preceded by a build-up section and break.
Hip hop production is the creation of hip hop music in a recording studio. While the term encompasses all aspects of hip hop music creation, including recording the rapping of an MC, a turntablist or DJ providing a beat, playing samples and "scratching" using record players and the creation of a rhythmic backing track, using a drum machine or sequencer, it is most commonly used to refer to recording the instrumental, non-lyrical and non-vocal aspects of hip hop.
Boom bap is a subgenre and music production style that was prominent in East Coast hip hop during the golden age of hip hop from the late 1980s to the early 1990s.
Project X is the debut studio album by American rapper Ken Carson, released through Opium and Foundation Media on July 23, 2021. The album serves as a sequel to Carson's Teen X EP and its Relapsed deluxe edition. In addition, the album and its artwork are named after and pay tribute to the 2012 film Project X. The album was executively produced by producers Star Boy and Outtatown, who produced a majority of the album. Upon release, the album received mixed reviews from critics, who praised the production but found fault with the songwriting and negatively compared Ken to other rappers.
Trap is a subgenre of hip hop music that originated in the Southern United States in the 1990s. The genre gets its name from the Atlanta slang term "trap house", a house used exclusively to sell drugs. Trap music uses synthesized drums and is characterized by complex hi-hat patterns, tuned kick drums with a long decay, and lyrical content that often focuses on drug use and urban violence. It utilizes very few instruments and focuses almost exclusively on snare drums and double- or triple-timed hi-hats.
Drill is a subgenre of hip hop music that originated in Chicago in the early 2010s. It is sonically similar to the trap music subgenre and lyrically similar to the gangsta rap subgenre. Early drill artists are noted for their explicit, aggressive style of lyricism and association with crime in Chicago, especially the Black Disciples and Gangster Disciples. The genre progressed into the American mainstream in 2012 following the success of pioneering rappers like Chief Keef, Lil Reese, Lil Durk, Fredo Santana, G Herbo, Lil Bibby and King Louie who had many local fans and a significant internet presence alongside producer Young Chop. Other rappers, such as LA Capone and RondoNumbaNine also contributed to the early drill scene. As the audience grew, media attention and the signing of drill musicians to major labels followed.
Jordan Terrell Carter, known professionally as Playboi Carti, is an American rapper. Carter was initially signed to local underground label Awful Records before signing with ASAP Mob's AWGE Label under Interscope Records. After gaining a cult following early in his career, Carter garnered mainstream attention in 2017.
Playboi Carti is the debut mixtape by American rapper Playboi Carti. It was released on April 14, 2017, by AWGE Label and Interscope Records. The mixtape features production from Pi'erre Bourne, Southside and others, and guest appearances from American rappers Lil Uzi Vert, ASAP Rocky, and Dutch singer Leven Kali. The physical version of the mixtape was released on October 6, 2017, and a vinyl edition was released on November 17, 2017.
"Summer Bummer" is a song by American singer and songwriter Lana Del Rey featuring American rappers ASAP Rocky and Playboi Carti featured on her fifth studio album Lust For Life. The song was released for digital download on July 12, 2017, alongside "Groupie Love" featuring ASAP Rocky, as a promotional single with the pre-order of the album. The song was written by the artists, alongside producers BigWhiteBeatz., Boi-1da, Jahaan Sweet, and T-Minus, with additional production credits going to Rick Nowels.
The discography of American rapper Jordan Terrell Carter, known as Playboi Carti, formely Sir Cartier, consists of three studio albums, two EPs, one collaborative EP, four mixtapes and fifteen singles.
Jordan Timothy Jenks, known professionally as Pi'erre Bourne, is an American record producer, audio engineer, beatmaker, and rapper. He is best known for producing the singles "Magnolia" by Playboi Carti and "Gummo" by 6ix9ine, entering the Top 30 of the US Billboard Hot 100.
"Shoota" is a song by American rapper Playboi Carti featuring American rapper Lil Uzi Vert. It was released from Carti's debut studio album Die Lit on May 11, 2018. The song was produced by Maaly Raw.
"Baguettes in the Face" is a song by American record producer Mustard featuring Canadian rapper Nav and American rappers Playboi Carti and A Boogie wit da Hoodie. Written by the artists alongside co-producer Larry Jayy, it was released through 10 Summers and Interscope Records as the fourth track from Mustard's third studio album, Perfect Ten, on June 28, 2019.
Whole Lotta Red is the second studio album by American rapper Playboi Carti. It was released on December 25, 2020, by Interscope Records as well as ASAP Rocky's AWGE label. Work on the album commenced in late 2018 and concluded in November 2020. The album consists of 24 tracks and features guest appearances from Kanye West, Kid Cudi, and Future. The album was executively produced by West, who also appears on the song "Go2DaMoon". Production was also handled by Carti's frequent collaborator and producer Pi'erre Bourne, along with Maaly Raw, Wheezy and F1lthy, among others.
Dark Lane Demo Tapes is the fourth mixtape by Canadian rapper and singer Drake. The mixtape is a compilation of songs that were released on SoundCloud or leaked on the internet, as well as new songs, and is considered a "warm-up" to Drake's sixth studio album Certified Boy Lover (2021). It was released on May 1, 2020, by OVO Sound and Republic Records. Production was handled by Drake's longtime collaborator 40, among others. Featured guest appearances include Future, Young Thug, Chris Brown, Playboi Carti, Giveon, Fivio Foreign, and Sosa Geek.
Kenyatta Anand Lee Frazier Jr., known professionally as Ken Carson, is an American rapper, singer, and record producer. He is known for his second studio album X (2022) which peaked at number 115 on the Billboard 200 and for being signed to Opium, the record label belonging to Playboi Carti.
Rage rap is an energetic microgenre of trap music. Distinguishing features of rage rap include short repeating stereo-widened EDM-influenced and future bass-influenced looped synthesizer lead hooks and a basic trap rhythm. Among the pioneers of rage rap are rappers Playboi Carti, Lil Uzi Vert, Trippie Redd, and Yeat, although the subgenre is primarily centered around its production style, which has been defined by producers like F1lthy, Loesoe, Pi'erre Bourne and Star Boy.
Deante Adam Johnson, known professionally as Summrs, is an American rapper, singer and songwriter from Louisiana. He is known as one of the pioneers and is a prominent rap figure of the pluggnb genre. Summrs was also one of the main members of the Slayworld collective during its active years. His 2023 album Stuck In My Ways peaked at number 13 on the Billboard Top Heatseekers chart.
Carrington Jaylenandrew Wilson, known professionally as Tony Shhnow, is an American rapper and songwriter from Atlanta, Georgia. He is recognized as a pioneer of the plugg subgenre of trap music and as a veteran of the hip hop underground scene.
Arshan Jawid: "I mean, you created the plugg sound [...]" MexikoDro: "[...] I am not finna say that I created this [plugg] sound. You gotta tell people. Pluggz created this sound. [I mean] BeatPluggz: me, StoopidXool, PoloBoyShawty and all that were doing this sound. I ain't even gonna take full credit"
{{cite web}}
: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)