1972 United States Senate election in Delaware

1972 United States Senate election in Delaware

←  1966 November 7, 1972 1978  →

Nominee Joe Biden J. Caleb Boggs Party Democratic Republican Popular vote 116,006 112,844 Percentage 50.48% 49.10%

County results State House district results Map key Biden:     40–50%     50–60%     60–70%     70–80% Boggs:     40–50%     50–60%     60–70%

U.S. senator before election J. Caleb Boggs Republican Elected U.S. Senator Joe Biden Democratic

The 1972 United States Senate election in Delaware was held November 7, 1972. Incumbent Republican Senator J. Caleb Boggs ran for a third term in the United States Senate. Boggs faced off against Democrat Joe Biden, a New Castle County Councilman. Though Boggs was expected to easily win a third term, Biden narrowly defeated the incumbent on election day, even while fellow Democrat George McGovern lost Delaware by 20.4% in the concurrent presidential election. Biden's victory margin of 3,162 votes made this the closest U.S. Senate election of the year.

Biden won a total of seven terms in the Senate, before being elected vice president in 2008 and in 2012 and president in 2020. At the age of 29, Biden became the youngest person to be elected senator since Rush Holt won in West Virginia in 1934 even as incumbent Republican President Richard Nixon overwhelmingly won the state for re-election on the same ballot.

This is the only time that Biden has lost Sussex County in his seven elections to the Senate, though he has lost the county in all his vice presidential and presidential elections. This would be the last time that Republicans won any counties for this seat until 2002 when Biden still comfortably won re-election. Delaware was one of fifteen states alongside Alabama, Arkansas, Colorado, Georgia, Iowa, Louisiana, Maine, Minnesota, Mississippi, Montana, New Hampshire, Rhode Island, South Dakota and West Virginia that were won by Republican President Richard Nixon in 1972 that elected a Democrat to the United States Senate.

General election

Campaign

Longtime Delaware political figure and incumbent Republican Senator J. Caleb Boggs was considering retirement, which would likely have left U.S. Representative Pete du Pont and Wilmington Mayor Harry G. Haskell Jr. in a divisive Senate primary fight. To avoid a potential primary, president Richard Nixon helped convince Boggs to run again with full party support.

Biden campaign pamphlet

Aside from Biden, a New Castle County Councilman, no Democrat wanted to challenge Boggs. ^[1] Biden's campaign had virtually no money and was given little to no chance of winning. ^[2] The campaign was managed by Biden's sister, Valerie Biden Owens (who managed his future campaigns), was staffed by other members of the Biden family, and relied upon handed-out newsprint position papers. ^[3] Biden did receive some assistance from the AFL–CIO and from Democratic pollster Patrick Caddell. ^[1] Biden's campaign focused on withdrawal from the Vietnam War, the environment, civil rights, mass transit, more equitable taxation, health care, the public's dissatisfaction with politics-as-usual, and "change". ^{[1] [3]} Biden also opposed giving amnesty to draft dodgers. Despite not supporting the legalization of marijuana, he said in a campaign ad that: "the possession of marijuana is a misdemeanor—a minor offense. The police should treat it that way, and devote the greater part of their efforts to heroin." ^[4]

During the summer, Biden trailed Boggs by almost 30 percentage points; ^[1] however, Biden's energy level, attractive young family, and ability to connect with voters' emotions gave him an advantage over the ready-to-retire Boggs. ^[5] John Marttila served as one of his consultants and had previously worked for Robert Drinan's campaign for the U.S. House of Representatives. ^{[3] [6]} Biden's campaign was described as having "no money to speak of" and relied on position papers in newspapers and a few campaign advertisements on the radio. ^[3] One notable advertisement used by the Biden campaign was a brochure printed in newspaper format that contrasted the world view of the two candidates, e.g. (full page) "To Cale Boggs an unfair tax was the 1948 poll tax"; (opposite page) "To Joe Biden an unfair tax is the 1972 income tax." ^[7] On November 7, 1972, Biden upset Boggs by a margin of 3,162 votes. ^[3]

Biden varied his messaging during campaign events throughout the state as well. For example, in the southern parts of the state his pitch was: "thirty years ago, caring for the environment meant picking up bottles and beer cans on Rehoboth Beach … and now it means saving the beach." In the northern parts of the state in the Wilmington area it was "in 1950, Cale Boggs promised to keep highways growing; in 1970 Joe Biden promises to keep trees growing." ^[4]

A few weeks later on December 18, 1972, Biden's wife and daughter died in a car crash which injured his sons. Biden contemplated resigning the Senate seat and told his brother to talk with governor-elect Sherman W. Tribbitt on his successor. Senate Majority Leader Mike Mansfield persuaded Biden to stay in the Senate for at least six months. Biden was sworn in at the hospital where his sons were recovering. Biden held the seat until his election as vice president 36 years later.

At the time of the 1972 election, Biden was 29 years old. He turned 30—the minimum age for a U.S. senator—on November 20, 1972, in time for the Senate term beginning January 3, 1973. At the commencement of his Senate term, Biden was the sixth-youngest U.S. Senator in history. ^[8]

A 2004 book contained a story, allegedly from Frank Sheeran, that in the week prior to Election Day, an unidentified lawyer approached Sheeran about preventing the distribution of the local paper because Senator Boggs was running an advertisement unflattering to Biden. Sheeran claimed that he organized a work stoppage, and that Teamsters truck drivers refused to cross a picket line, so the papers were not delivered. ^[9] The credibility of Sheeran's account has been called into question, although an article published in The New York Times on Friday November 3, 1972, does seem to confirm that a work stoppage took place four days prior to election day, preventing the delivery of a single Friday edition of local paper The Morning News. ^[10]

There were two other candidates in the 1972 Senate election: Henry M. Majka and Herbert B. Wood. Majka came from the American Party while Wood hailed from the Prohibition Party. Majka managed to receive 803 votes, or 0.3% of the vote, while Wood got 175 votes, or 0.1% of the vote. ^[11]

Biden was elected president of the United States in November 2020 at age 77. Because of mail-in voting his victory was not official until November 7, five days after conventional voting began and the 48th anniversary of his Senate election over Boggs.

Candidates

• Joe Biden (Democratic Party), New Castle County council member ^[1]
• J. Caleb Boggs (Republican Party), incumbent senator and former Governor of Delaware ^[12]
• Henry M. Majka (American Party) ^[11]
• Herbert B. Wood (Prohibition Party) ^[13]

Results

1972 United States Senate election in Delaware ^[14]

Party		Candidate	Votes	%	±%
	Democratic	Joe Biden	116,006	50.48%	+9.59%
	Republican	J. Caleb Boggs (incumbent)	112,844	49.10%	−10.02%
	American	Henry M. Majka	803	0.35%	N/A
	Prohibition	Herbert B. Wood	175	0.07%	N/A
Total votes			229,828	100.00%	N/A
	Democratic gain from Republican

County results

County [14] [13]	Joe Biden Democratic		J. Caleb Boggs Republican		Henry M. Majka American		Herbert B. Wood Prohibition		Total votes cast
	#	%	#	%	#	%	#	%	#
Kent	14,598	52.36%	13,121	47.06%	140	0.5%	21	0.08%	27,880
New Castle	85,017	50.32%	83,273	49.29%	532	0.31%	133	0.08%	168,955
Sussex	16,391	49.68%	16,450	49.86%	131	0.4%	21	0.06%	32,993
Totals	116,006	50.48%	112,844	49.10%	803	0.35%	175	0.22%	229,828

Results by state representative district

District [15]	Joe Biden Democratic	J. Caleb Boggs Republican	Henry M. Majka American	Herbert B. Wood Prohibition	Total votes cast
District 1	3,398	3,481	17	10	6,906
District 2	2,044	1,052	12	4	3,112
District 3	1,804	1,039	6	2	2,851
District 4	2,112	1,129	4	4	3,249
District 5	3,549	1,357	18	2	4,926
District 6	3,200	3,798	17	9	7,024
District 7	2,836	3,772	25	13	6,646
District 8	2,943	2,911	31	6	5,891
District 9	2,735	2,781	26	7	5,549
District 10	2,835	4,325	11	0	7,171
District 11	2,980	5,280	21	9	8,290
District 12	2,696	4,394	19	4	7,113
District 13	2,420	5,010	29	8	7,467
District 14	3,423	3,589	16	3	7,031
District 15	3,826	2,072	13	0	5,911
District 16	3,127	2,816	20	7	5,970
District 17	2,620	1,662	20	4	4,306
District 18	2,580	1,532	19	5	4,136
District 19	3,295	2,703	11	5	6,014
District 20	3,224	2,209	28	2	5,463
District 21	3,012	2,481	13	3	5,509
District 22	3,248	3,381	23	4	6,656
District 23	3,141	3,108	20	5	6,274
District 24	3,339	2,885	20	2	6,246
District 25	3,369	3,347	11	2	6,729
District 26	2,202	1,927	17	2	4,148
District 27	3,430	4,066	27	5	7,528
District 28	2,575	2,562	24	3	5,164
District 29	3,054	2,604	14	3	5,675
District 30	2,794	2,482	32	2	5,310
District 31	2,633	2,642	32	3	5,310
District 32	2,534	2,792	16	2	5,344
District 33	2,507	2,074	26	5	4,612
District 34	1,141	1,037	9	1	2,188
District 35	2,989	2,094	25	8	5,116
District 36	2,965	2,537	43	9	5,554
District 37	2,882	3,853	20	3	6,758
District 38	2,598	2,432	22	2	5,054
District 39	2,746	2,711	21	3	5,481
District 40	2,617	2,436	11	2	5,066
District 41	2,583	2,481	14	2	5,080
Total	116,006	112,844	803	175	229,828

See also

• 1972 United States Senate elections

References

1. Moritz, Charles, ed. (1987). Current Biography Yearbook 1987. New York: H. W. Wilson Company., p. 43.
2. Broder, John M. (October 23, 2008). "Father's Tough Life an Inspiration for Biden". The New York Times . Retrieved October 24, 2008.
3. Naylor, Brian (October 8, 2007). "Biden's Road to Senate Took Tragic Turn". NPR . Retrieved September 12, 2008.
4. Newell, Jim (June 11, 2019). "When Joe Biden Was the Candidate of the Young". Slate . Retrieved September 18, 2021.
5. Barone, Michael; Cohen, Richard E. (2008). The Almanac of American Politics. Washington: National Journal Group. ISBN   978-0-89234-117-7., p. 364.
6. Schudel, Matt (November 10, 2018). "John Marttila, political strategist for Biden, Kerry and other Democrats, dies at 78". The Frederick News-Post (published November 11, 2018). Retrieved September 18, 2021.
7. Erickson, Bo (June 4, 2019). " "When a young Joe Biden used his opponent's age against him". CBS News .
8. "U.S. Senate: Youngest Senator".
9. Brandt, Charles (June 29, 2016). "I Heard You Paint Houses": Frank "the Irishman" Sheeran and Closing the Case on Jimmy Hoffa. Steerforth Press. ISBN   978-1586422387.
10. "Wilmington Paper Halted In Strike by Truck Drivers". The New York Times. November 3, 1972. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved September 17, 2022.
11. Politics in America. Congressional Quarterly, Inc. 1979. p. 169. ISBN   9780871871480 – via Google Books.
12. "Biographical Directory of the U.S. Congress - Retro Member details". Biographical Directory of the United States Congress. Archived from the original on August 27, 2020. Retrieved September 10, 2021.
13. "Our Campaigns - DE US Senate Race - Nov 07, 1972". www.ourcampaigns.com. Retrieved September 7, 2021.
14. "Statistics of the Presidential and Congressional Election of November 7, 1972" (PDF). Clerk of the House of Representatives. p. 8.
15. Willis, Burton. "STATE OF DELAWARE: Official Results of General Election" (PDF). Delaware Department of Elections (PDF). Archived (PDF) from the original on December 3, 2016. Retrieved September 8, 2021.