Capital punishment in Michigan

Capital punishment in Michigan was legal from the founding of Sault Ste Marie in 1668 during the French colonial period, until abolition by the state legislature in 1846 (except nominally for treason). Michigan , carried out only one federal execution at FCI Milan in 1938.

Michigan's death penalty history is unusual, as Michigan was the first Anglophone jurisdiction in the world to abolish the death penalty for ordinary crimes. ^{[1] [2]} The Michigan State Legislature voted to do so on May 18, 1846, and that has remained the law ever since. ^[3] Although the death penalty was formally retained as a punishment for treason until 1963, no person was ever tried for treason against Michigan. Thus, Michigan has not executed any person since before statehood.

History

All executions in areas which are now part of the State of Michigan were performed before the state was admitted to the Union, when Michigan became the 26th State on January 26, 1837. ^[4]

About a dozen people are known to have been executed from 1683 to 1836. The area that is now Michigan was part of colonial New France from 1612 (first permanent settlement, Sault Sainte Marie, 1668) to 1763, when the Treaty of Paris (1763) transferred New France to Great Britain. It was part of British Indian Territory, 1763 to 1774 when it became part of the Province of Quebec. The Treaty of Paris (1783) legally transferred the area to the new United States of America but Lower Michigan remained under British control until 1796, and Upper Michigan until 1818 (transferred pursuant to the Treaty of Ghent of 1814). In this early period, there were a number of cases where persons who had committed a capital crime in Detroit were transported to Montreal for trial and execution.

The first person known to be executed in Michigan was an Aboriginal North American named Folle-Avoine. The first person executed under US Jurisdiction was a Native American named Buhnah. Two women were executed in Michigan, both during the British colonial period – an unnamed Native American slave (owned by a man named Clapham) in 1763, and a black slave named Ann Wyley in 1777. ^[5] By race, seven of 15 were Native Americans; seven were European-Americans; and one was an African-American. ^[6]

The 1830 hanging of a tavern keeper, Stephen Gifford Simmons, who had in a drunken fit killed his wife, generated more popular opposition to the death penalty than the prior hanging of Native Americans. ^[7] Consequently, Simmons' was the last execution under Michigan law. ^{[8] [9]} In 1840, the people of Michigan learned that an innocent man had been hanged across the river from Michigan, in what is now Windsor, Ontario, as the true perpetrator of the crime had made a deathbed confession. ^[10]

The death penalty has been unconstitutional in Michigan since the 1963 constitution took effect on 1 January 1964. ^[11]

Federal death penalty

Even though Michigan abolished the death penalty in 1846, the Federal death penalty can still be imposed. Thus, the United States was able to execute Tony Chebatoris at the Federal Detention Farm (now Federal Correctional Institution, Milan) near Milan, Michigan in 1938, for a murder he committed while robbing a federal bank in Midland, Michigan. ^[12]

The 2002 conviction of Marvin Gabrion received national attention when he was sentenced to death for the murder of Rachel Timmerman in Newaygo County, Michigan. Gabrion was also suspected of four other killings but was never tried for them, including the murder of Rachel Timmerman's 11-month-old daughter Shannon Verhage. About 22 years after he was first sent to death row, Gabrion's federal death sentence was commuted to life imprisonment without the possibility of parole by outgoing President Joe Biden, who granted clemency to 37 out of 40 inmates on federal death row. ^[13]

U.S. Attorneys (i.e. federal prosecutors) in the latter case relied on the dual sovereignty doctrine to seek a death sentence because the murder took place on federal land. ^[14] Gabrion was the first person in the United States to receive the federal death penalty for a crime committed in a non-death penalty state since the federal death penalty was reinstated in 1988. ^[15] The sentence was overturned in 2013 by a panel of the Sixth Circuit, but was later reinstated 12–4 by the full court sitting en banc. ^{[16] [17]}

See also

• Michigan portal
• Law portal

• List of people executed in Michigan
• Crime in Michigan
• Law of Michigan

Notes

1. Tirschwell, Eric A. and Theodore Hertzberg (both of Kramer Levin Naftalis & Frankel LLP). "Politics and Prosecutions: A Historical Perspective on Shifting Federal Standards for Pursuing the Death Penalty in non-Death Penalty States." Journal of Constitutional Law . October 2009. Volume 12 Issue 1. pp. 57–98. CITED: p. 61.
2. "History of the Death Penalty – Faith in Action – Working to Abolish the Death Penalty". Archived from the original on 2010-03-06. Retrieved 2007-09-08.
3. See Caitlin pp. 420–422
4. "Regional Studies The Midwest". Archived from the original on 2007-09-20. Retrieved 2007-08-16.
5. See Burton pp. 193–195 for an account of Contincineau's trial. The presiding judge Philip Dejean was subsequently indicted for the murder of Contincineau. According to the account in Burton, Contincineau's accomplice, the slave woman Ann Wyley, was freed by Dejean on the condition that she act as executioner on Contincineau. Caitlin p. 68 notes that Dejean later went back on his offer and had Wiley hanged.
6. Executions is the U.S. 1608-2002: The ESPY File, "Archived copy" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2005-09-10. Retrieved 2005-12-01.
7. America Without the Death Penalty: States Leading the Way John F. Galliher, Larry W. Koch, David Patrick Keys –1555536395 2005 Page 12 "The execution of Stephen Simmons generated considerably more outrage in Michigan than did the execution of the two Native Americans who preceded him to the gallows."
8. Richard Adler Cholera in Detroit: A History 2013 – Page 93 "Knapp was an unwilling participant in what had been the last execution under Michigan law. Stephen Simmons, a local tavern keeper, was convicted in 1830 of the murder of his wife, and was sentenced to be hanged. Knapp, as the sheriff, ..."
9. Carr, Tom (2016). Blood on the Mitten (1st ed.). Chandler Lake Books / Mission Point Press. pp. 10–11. ISBN   9781943338078.
10. Wagner, Eugene (September 2002). "Michigan Capital Punishment" (PDF). Michigan Bar Journal.
11. "Death Penalty – Mich. Comp. Laws IV § 46". Archived from the original on 2010-07-18. Retrieved 2010-05-23.
12. Veselenak, Michigan History Magazine, May 1998
13. "Biden commutes Michigan man's death penalty sentence to life in prison". CBS News . December 23, 2024.
14. "Court divided on Marvin Gabrion death penalty appeal". The Grand Rapids Press. March 14, 2008.
15. "First Federal Death Sentence in Non-death penalty state overturned". Death Penalty Information Center. Retrieved 16 May 2014.
16. Agar, John (May 28, 2013). "Marvin Gabrion's death penalty reinstated in 1997 killing of young mother". MLIVE.
17. Associated Press (May 28, 2013). "Appeals court affirms death sentence for marvin gabrion, convicted of killing Michigan woman in 1997". Holland Sentinel.

References

• Chardavoyne, David G. (2003). A Hanging in Detroit: Stephen G. Simmons and the Last Execution Under Michigan Law . Detroit, Mich.: Wayne State University Press.
• Burton, Clarence M. (2005) [1922]. The city of Detroit, Michigan, 1701–1922. Ann Arbor, Mich.: University of Michigan Library . Retrieved 2007-09-08.
• Catlin, George B. (2005) [1923]. The story of Detroit. Ann Arbor, Michigan: University of Michigan Library. Retrieved 2007-09-08.