Iron and steel industry in the United States

Last updated

In 2022, the U.S. was the third-largest producer of raw steel worldwide, after China and India, and ranked sixth in pig iron production. By November 2024, the industry produced over 74 million net tons annually.[ citation needed ]

Contents

The industry produced over 74 million net tons per year as of November 2024. [1] Most iron and steel in the United States is now made from iron and steel scrap, rather than iron ore. The United States is also a major importer of iron and steel, as well as iron and steel products.[ citation needed ]

Employment as of 2014 was 149,000 people employed in iron and steel mills, and 69,000 in foundries. The value of iron and steel produced in 2014 was $113 billion. [2] As of 2020, about 0.3% of the US population is employed by the steel industry, [3] , and by 2025 steel mills were only employing 83,600 people, making the industry a relatively small portion of US manufacturing despite outsize political influence. [4]

As of 2022, major steel-makers in the United States included Cleveland-Cliffs, Carpenter Technology, Commercial Metals Company, Nucor, Steel Dynamics, and U.S. Steel. [5]

Types of steel mills

Steel mills in the U.S. fall into two categories: traditional integrated mills that process iron ore into steel and mini-mills that melt steel scrap to produce new steel. Mini-mills now dominate U.S. steel production.

Integrated steel mills

In 2017, there were 9 operating integrated steel mills in the United States (plus one idled), down from 13 in 2000. Integrated mills produced 31% of the steel produced in the US.

In an integrated steel mill, iron ore is reduced to metallic iron. In the US, this is done in blast furnaces and since 2014 again using direct reduced iron furnaces in Nucor's plant in Louisiana as well as another DRI plant (producing a compactified version of DRI called hot briquetted iron, or HBI) in Texas by Voestalpine. Some of the iron from the blast furnaces is converted to steel; today this is done in basic oxygen furnaces. Iron ore, coke, and flux are fed into the blast furnace and heated. The coke reduces the iron oxide in the ore to metallic iron, and the molten mass separates into slag and iron. Some of the iron from the blast furnace is cooled, and marketed as pig iron; the rest flows into basic oxygen furnaces, where it is converted into steel. Iron and steel scrap may be added to both the blast furnace and the basic iron furnace.

US Steel operates a number of integrated steel mills, including the Gary Works in Gary, Indiana. They also operate the Edgar Thomson Works, which is the iron- and steel-making unit of the Mon Valley Works, which includes three other related plants. The company operates the Great Lakes Works, [6] and Granite City Works. [7]

Cleveland-Cliffs operates every integrated steel mill: in East Chicago, Indiana, Burns Harbor, Indiana, and Cleveland, Ohio. [8]

In 2020, Cleveland Cliffs acquired AK Steel Corporation along with its three integrated steel mills, one in Middletown, Ohio, Dearborn, Michigan and the other in Ashland, Kentucky. The Ashland Works is no longer active and has been demolished.

Current integrated steel mills in the US

NameLocationOwnerStatus and Date
Gary Works Gary, Indiana US Steel Operating, February 2015 [9]
Mon Valley Works - Irvin Plant, Edgar Thomson Steel Works North Braddock, Pennsylvania US Steel
Indiana Harbor Works East Chicago, Indiana Cleveland-Cliffs
Burns Harbor Works Burns Harbor, Indiana Cleveland-Cliffs
Middletown Works Middletown, Ohio Cleveland-Cliffs
Cleveland Works Cleveland, Ohio Cleveland-Cliffs
Dearborn Works Dearborn, Michigan Cleveland-Cliffs One operating blast furnace ("A")

Formerly Severstal Dearborn (2004–2014)

Previously Rouge Steel (1989–2004)

Previously Ford Rouge Plant (1910–1989)

Great Lakes WorksRiver Rouge and Ecorse, Michigan US Steel Blast furnace and iron production idled December 2019. [6] Automotive finishing lines remain open as of 2024. [10]
Granite City Works Granite City, Illinois US Steel Resumed operation 2018 [11]

Idled indefinitely in 2023. [12]

Fairfield Works Fairfield, Alabama US Steel Blast furnace closed permanently in August 2015. [13] Electric arc furnace opened in 2020 and is currently operating as of 2024. [14]

Specialty steel mills / minimills

There were about 112 minimills or specialty mills in the US, which in 2013 produced 59% of US total steel production. The specialty mills use iron and steel scrap, rather than iron ore, as feedstock, and melt the scrap in electric furnaces.

Notable Specialty and Mini-Mills in the US

NameLocationOwnerStatus and Date
Brackenridge Works Brackenridge, Pennsylvania Allegheny Technologies
former Colorado Fuel and Iron plant Pueblo, Colorado Oregon Steel Mills Former integrated mill
Evraz Claymont Steel Claymont, Delaware Evraz Group Closed
Mississippi Steel Flowood, Mississippi Nucor
Butler Works Butler, Pennsylvania Cleveland-Cliffs, Inc. Grain Oriented Electrical Steel

Raw materials

The two main inputs into iron- and steel-making are a source of iron and a source of energy. Additional requirements are a fluxing material to remove the impurities, and alloy metals to give particular properties to the metal.

Raw materials used in US iron and steel production, 2012

Inputmetric tonsPurpose
Iron ore46,900,000Iron source
Iron and steel scrap104,100,000Iron source
Coke9,490,000Reducing agent
Lime5,730,000Flux
Fluorspar47,800Flux
Manganese382,000Alloy
Chromium251,000Alloy
Nickel194,000Alloy
Molybdenum11,800Alloy
Vanadium2,500Alloy
Tungsten123Alloy
Source: US Geological Survey, Minerals Yearbooks, 2012 and 2013. [15]

Iron ore

Iron and steel scrap

Two-thirds of the iron and steel produced in the US is made from recycled scrap, rather than from iron ore. In 2014, 81 million mt of iron and steel were produced from scrap. [16] Most steel from scrap is produced using electric arc furnaces.

Coke

Coke, derived from coking coal, reduces iron ore (iron oxides) to metallic iron.

Flux

Flux materials, like lime, are added to the furnace to lower the melting point and remove impurities as slag. Other common fluxes include dolomite, soda ash, and fluorspar.

Alloy metals

Other metals are commonly added to steel to produce alloy steels of various types. Common alloy metals are manganese, nickel, molybdenum, chromium, and vanadium. Stainless steel commonly contains a minimum of 10.5% chromium, and may also contain significant amounts of nickel or molybdenum.

Slag

Slag, a byproduct of iron and steel-making composed primarily of highly impure glass, would normally be a waste product. However, it is in demand as an aggregate in concrete, asphalt paving, and construction fill. In 2014, the industry produced and marketed about 16.0 million mt of slag, worth an estimated $270 million. [17]

International trade

Since the 1960s, the U.S. has been a major importer of steel. In 2014, it exported 11 million tons but imported 39 million tons, with net imports making up 17% of consumption. [18]

Imports by Top 10 source countries
YTD through December 2017 [19] [20] [21]
No.CountryVolume
(metric tons)
PercentValue
(k$)
Percent
1Flag of Canada (Pantone).svg  Canada 5,675,81616%5,119,94418%
2Flag of Brazil.svg  Brazil 4,665,42814%2,442,4688%
3Flag of South Korea.svg  South Korea 3,401,40510%2,785,76410%
4Flag of Mexico.svg  Mexico 3,155,1179%2,501,2269%
5Flag of Russia.svg  Russia 2,866,6958%1,431,2735%
6Flag of Turkey.svg  Turkey 1,977,8666%1,182,9984%
7Flag of Japan.svg  Japan 1,727,8445%1,657,9086%
8Flag of Germany.svg  Germany 1,380,4344%1,833,7936%
9Flag of the Republic of China.svg  Taiwan 1,128,3563%1,261,0334%
10Flag of India.svg  India 743,0212%732,4253%
Others7,750,52522%8,189,50328%
Total34,472,507100%29,138,335100%

Since the 1800s, the US steel industry has generally had a history of supporting tariffs on foreign steel imports, which Bloomberg has described as a "the reward delivered...in a patronage system" tied to a general tendency for heavy industry to favor economic protectionism. Presidents from both the Republican and Democratic parties have been known to cooperate with these demands. This has been cited as a contributing factor in Biden administration's skepticism towards the 2023-2024 proposed acquisition of U.S. Steel by Nippon Steel. [4]

Tariffs instituted during the first term of President Donald Trump starting in 2019, which some of the biggest corporate steel buyers in the country criticized for their inclusion of exemptions, succeeded at increasing investment in the country's steel industry, but did not fare well in terms of job creation. Bloomberg has also argued that evidence suggests those tariffs led to a recession in the US manufacturing industry as a whole via rising prices. [4]

Following the 2024 U.S. presidential election, the U.S. steel industry actively advocated for stronger trade protections, including reimposing tariffs on steel imports from the United Kingdom, European Union, and Japan to address trade-distorting practices. The industry argued that steel tariffs imposed in 2018 boosted steel prices, profits, and employment. They have also publicly called for stricter enforcement of trade laws and increased tariffs on steel-intensive products from China and Southeast Asia. [22]

Lobbying

Groups that lobby for the US steel industry in Washington include The Coalition for a Prosperous America and the Alliance for American Manufacturing [4]

History of US iron- and steel-making

Graph of US iron and steel production, 1900-2014, data from USGS USGS Iron-Steel 1900-2014.png
Graph of US iron and steel production, 1900–2014, data from USGS

The US iron and steel industry has paralleled the industry in other countries in technological developments. In the 1800s, the US switched from charcoal to coke in ore smelting, adopted the Bessemer process, and saw the rise of very large integrated steel mills. In the 20th century, the US industry successively adopted the open hearth process, then the basic oxygen furnace. Since the American industry peaked in the 1940s and 1950s, the US industry has shifted to small mini-mills and specialty mills, using iron and steel scrap as feedstock, rather than iron ore.

See also

References

  1. "Industry Data". American Iron and Steel Institute. Archived from the original on 2024-11-07. Retrieved 2024-11-07.
  2. Iron and Steel, Mineral Commodities Summaries.
  3. Rickard, Stephanie J. (2020). "Economic Geography, Politics, and Policy" (PDF). Annual Review of Political Science. 23: 187–202. doi: 10.1146/annurev-polisci-050718-033649 .
  4. 1 2 3 4 Donnan, Shawn (March 10, 2025). "Steel Sits at the Core of Trump's Tariff Ideology". Supply Lines Newsletter. Bloomberg. Retrieved 10 March 2025.
  5. US Department of Commerce, [ Steel industry executive summary], June 2015.
  6. 1 2 Deaux, Joe (2019-12-20). "U.S. Steel to cut 1,545 Michigan jobs as weakness overwhelms Trump's protection". Los Angeles Times . Retrieved 2019-12-21.
  7. US Steel Corp., Facilities Archived 2016-02-16 at the Wayback Machine , accessed 1 August 2015.
  8. 2014 ArelorMittal USA Factbook Archived 2015-09-15 at the Wayback Machine .
  9. "US Steel closes Gary Works coke plant," Chicago Tribune, 26 Feb. 2015.
  10. "Steel mill at Zug Island still operating with a fraction of the workforce it once had". Detroit Free Press. 2021-01-05.
  11. "USW Welcomes News of Restart at U.S. Steel Granite City Works".
  12. "U.S. Steel idles steelmaking at Granite City Works indefinitely". fox2news. 2023-11-28. Retrieved 2024-02-01.
  13. "U.S. Steel to End Operations at Alabama's Fairfield Works Mill". NPR.org.
  14. "U.S. Steel's Fairfield Works launches new, advanced electric arc furnace facility".
  15. US Geological Survey, Minerals Yearbook, 2012 and 2013.
  16. Michael D. Fenton, Iron and steel scrap, US Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summary 2015, Jan. 2015.
  17. Hendrik G. van Oss, Iron and Steel Slag, US Geological Survey, Mineral Commodity Summaries, Jan. 2015.
  18. US Geological Survey, , 2015.
  19. "Steel Imports Report: United States" (PDF). International Trade Administration. December 2017.
  20. "Imports of Steel Products". United States Census Bureau.
  21. "Exhibit 4. U.S. Imports For Consumption of Steel Products From Selected Countries and Areas" (PDF). United States Census Bureau.
  22. Tita, Bob (2024-12-02). "Why This U.S. Industry Is Pushing Trump for Even More Tariffs". The Wall Street Journal . Retrieved 2024-12-02.