Phosphatodraco

Last updated

Phosphatodraco
Temporal range: Late Cretaceous, 66  Ma
O
S
D
C
P
T
J
K
Pg
N
Phosphatodraco vertebra - Longrich et al 2018.PNG
Assigned C5 cervical (neck) vertebra in multiple views
Scientific classification Red Pencil Icon.png
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Order: Pterosauria
Suborder: Pterodactyloidea
Family: Azhdarchidae
Subfamily: Quetzalcoatlinae
Genus: Phosphatodraco
Pereda-Suberbiola et al., 2003
Type species
Phosphatodraco mauritanicus
Pereda-Suberbiola et al., 2003

Phosphatodraco is a genus of azhdarchid pterosaur that lived during the Late Cretaceous of what is now Morocco. In 2000, a pterosaur specimen consisting of five cervical (neck) vertebrae was discovered in the Ouled Abdoun Phosphatic Basin. The specimen was made the holotype of the new genus and species Phosphatodraco mauritanicus in 2003; the genus name means "dragon from the phosphates", and the specific name refers to the region of Mauretania. Phosphatodraco was the first Late Cretaceous pterosaur known from North Africa, and the second pterosaur genus described from Morocco. It is one of the only known azhdarchids preserving a relatively complete neck, and was one of the last known pterosaurs. Additional cervical vertebrae have since been assigned to the genus, and it has been suggested that fossils of the pterosaur Tethydraco represent wing elements of Phosphatodraco.

Contents

Due to the fragmentary nature of the holotype cervical vertebrae, there has been controversy over their order. The describers considered them as cervicals (abbreviated as C) C5–C9 in the series, the first preserved vertebra (C5) being broken in two, but others consider them C3–C8, C3 and C4 being two different vertebrae. The interpretation followed has consequences for how Phosphatodraco is distinguished from other azhdarchids and how large it is thought to have been; the describers considered it to have had a wingspan of 5 m (16 ft); the alternate interpretation would lead to a 4 m (13 ft) wingspan. The complete neck may have been 865 mm (2 ft 10 in) long. Phosphatodraco is mainly distinguished by its C8 (or C7) vertebra being very elongated, 50% longer than the C5, and in having a prominent neural spine that is almost as tall as the centrum (the main part of the vertebra), truncated in a square shape at the top, and located far back. As an azhdarchid, it would have had a proportionally long neck, small body, and long limbs, compared to other pterosaurs.

The closest relatives of Phosphatodraco appear to have been Aralazhdarcho and Eurazhdarcho . Azhdarchids have historically been considered skim-feeders that caught prey from water in coastal settings, but it has since been suggested that the context in which their fossils are found and their morphology  such as their long, stiffened necks (informed by for example the neck of Phosphatodraco) is more consistent with them having foraged terrestrially like storks or ground hornbills, but this is still debated. Although pterosaurs were thought to have declined in diversity towards the time of their extinction 66 million years ago, the diversity in taxa, including Phosphatodraco, in the Ouled Abdoun Basin, which dates to the late Maastrichtian, right before the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event, indicates their extinction happened abruptly.

Discovery

Location of phosphate mines in Morocco (A), the Sidi Daoui mine where Phosphatodraco was found (B), and stratigraphic location of the discovery site, "couche III" (C) Phosphate mines in Morocco.PNG
Location of phosphate mines in Morocco (A), the Sidi Daoui mine where Phosphatodraco was found (B), and stratigraphic location of the discovery site, "couche III" (C)

During the late 1990s, remains of pterosaurs began to be discovered in different fossil localities of Morocco, all dating to the Cretaceous period. In 2000, pterosaur fossils were found by the Office Chérifien des Phosphates (OCP, located in Casablanca) during paleontological field work in the eastern part of the Ouled Abdoun Phosphatic Basin near the city of Khouribga in central Morocco. They were collected from "site 1" in the Sidi Daoui mine in the northern part of Grand Daoui, an area in which phosphate is quarried. The fossils were found in the upper part of the stratigraphic unit which miners called "couche III". These excavations were part of a collaboration between the OCP, the Ministère de L'Energie et des Mines, Rabat, and the French Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique , which had taken place since 1997. [1] [2]

The pterosaur material, catalogued as specimen OCP DEK/GE 111, consists of five disarticulated but closely associated cervical (neck) vertebrae and an indeterminate bone, most likely belonging to a single individual. The vertebrae are crushed and damaged, and the surface of the bone is missing in some areas, with some infilling of phosphate sediments, and the fossils have therefore not been removed from the matrix. The block containing the bones is 98 cm (39 in) long and 34 cm (13 in) wide. During mechanical preparation of the specimen fossil remains of other animals were also found in association, including of several types of fish and mosasaurs. [1]

The specimen was made the holotype of the new genus and species Phosphatodraco mauritanicus by paleontologist Xabier Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues in 2003. The genus name derives from the words phosphate and the Latin draco, meaning "dragon from the phosphates", and the specific name refers to the region of Mauretania where the fossils were found. [1] The describers gave the etymology of Mauretania as Latin for North Africa; other sources specify it as an area stretching from Algeria to Morocco. [1] [3] [4] Phosphatodraco was the first Late Cretaceous pterosaur known from North Africa (and thus the first known member of the family Azhdarchidae of this age from the region), and only the second pterosaur genus described from Morocco (the first being Siroccopteryx ). At the time it was described, it was one of the only known azhdarchids preserving a relatively complete neck (the others being Zhejiangopterus and Quetzalcoatlus [5] ), and was one of the last known pterosaurs. [1] Complete neck vertebral series are rare for azhdarchids, but such vertebrae are some of the most commonly found and best known remains of the group. [6]

Tethydraco humerus.PNG
Tethydraco ulna - Longrich et al 2018.PNG
Humerus (left) and ulnae (right) of Tethydraco , which may represent wing elements of Phosphatodraco

In 2018 paleontologist Nicholas R. Longrich and colleagues reported pterosaur fossils collected from "couche III" in cooperation with the Moroccan fossil industry the previous three years; until that point, only the single specimen of Phosphatodraco was known from the assemblage. At the time, the collection was the largest and most diverse collection of pterosaurs from the Maastrichtian age of the Late Cretaceous, and included two cervical vertebrae they assigned to Phosphatodraco, based on similarity with the holotype in size and proportions. One of the vertebrae, specimen FSAC-OB 12, was identified as a C5 (though stated in the description to be similar to C6 of the holotype); the other, FSAC-OB 13, was identified only as a cervical vertebra. The cervical ribs (ribs of the neck vertebrae) of FSAC-OB 12 do not appear to have yet fused to the centrum (the main part of the vertebra), so the animal may not have been completely mature. These specimens are housed at Faculté des Sciences Aïn Chock in Casablanca. [2]

In 2020 paleontologists Claudio Labita and David M. Martill described an articulated (where the bones are connected as in life) pterosaur wing from "couche III" (specimen FSAC CP 251, bought from fossil dealers), which they assigned to Tethydraco , a genus also described by Longrich and colleagues in 2018 based on a humerus (upper arm bone). Tethydraco was originally considered a pteranodontid, but Labita and Martill found it to be an azhdarchid, and to possibly represent the wing elements of Phosphatodraco. They noted that more associated and articulated pterosaur fossils were being collected from these deposits due to improving methods used by fossil diggers, and that azhdarchid fossils were becoming abundant. They also cautioned that the provenance of some of the Moroccan fossils was difficult to establish, due to the commercial nature of their collection. [7]

Interpretations of cervical vertebra order

Illustration of the holotype cervical vertebra series as preserved, with interpretation of its order by Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues, 2003 (above, C5-C9), and Kellner, 2010 (below, C3-C8) Phosphatodraco cervical interpretations.jpg
Illustration of the holotype cervical vertebra series as preserved, with interpretation of its order by Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues, 2003 (above, C5–C9), and Kellner, 2010 (below, C3–C8)

Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues originally interpreted the five preserved cervical vertebrae of Phosphatodraco as cervicals C5–C9. The frontmost preserved vertebra they interpreted as C5 consisted of two fragments; they found it unlikely that these belonged to two different vertebrae, since they lay in continuity with no sediment in between, and overlapped each other in some areas. They considered the sideways expansion at the front of this vertebra to be due to crushing, and pointed out that such preservation where fragile, yet well-preserved bones are associated with damaged material of the same individual is known from other vertebrate fossils in the same level. They identified the frontmost vertebra as a C5 because this is usually the longest cervical vertebra in pterosaurs, their length decreasing hindward. [1]

In 2007 paleontologist Alexander W. A. Kellner and colleagues noted that Phosphatodraco was one of the most interesting azhdarchids found in Africa, but used cautious language about the original interpretation of the vertebrae. [8] Kellner suggested in 2010 that interpretation of the holotype specimen had been affected by taphonomy (changes during decay and fossilisation); he instead proposed that the element originally described as a fifth cervical vertebra was actually the third and fourth vertebrae which had been compressed together, giving the impression that they were a single vertebra broken in the middle. This would shift the order of the vertebrae to C3–C8, and though this did not change the validity of the taxon (its distinctness being based on its stratigraphy, geography, and morphology), Kellner noted that the diagnosis (the suite of features that distinguish a taxon) and size estimate had to be reevaluated. [9] The frontmost cervical vertebrae which are missing from Phosphatodraco in either scheme are the atlas (C1, which connects with the back of the skull) and the axis (C2). [9] [10]

Subsequent articles from 2011 and 2015 with Kellner among the co-authorship have concurred with Kellner's interpretation. [11] [12] Paleontologist Alexander Averianov disagreed with Kellner's reinterpretation of the cervical vertebrae in 2014, and considered the original description accurate. [13] A 2015 article by paleontologist Mátyás Vremir and colleagues called the issue "controversial" and considered the specimen too crushed for proper comparison, [14] and Martill and Markus Moser concurred with this in 2018. [15] Paleontologists Darren Naish and Mark P. Witton (the co-authors of Vremir's article) followed Kellner's interpretation in 2017. [1] [16] Paleontologist Rodrigo V. Pêgas and colleagues also followed Kellner's order in 2021. [17] Though the palaeontologist Alexandru A. Solomon and colleagues noted the suggested change in interpretation of the holotype order in 2019, they stated that even if the reinterpretation was correct, the specimen was too damaged for comparison with the single known cervical vertebra of their new genus Albadraco . [18]

Description

Estimated size (upper middle in turquoise) compared to contemporary pterosaurs, birds, and a human Size disparity of late Maastrichtian pterosaurs and birds.svg
Estimated size (upper middle in turquoise) compared to contemporary pterosaurs, birds, and a human

In their 2003 description, Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues estimated Phosphatodraco to have had a wingspan close to 5 m (16 ft), based on comparison with other azhdarchids with preserved cervical vertebrae, and referred to it as a "large azhdarchid pterosaur". This is larger than azhdarchids such as Zhejiangopterus and Montanazhdarcho , and comparable to the smaller species of Quetzalcoatlus, Q. lawsoni; the larger Q. northropi is thought to have reached 10–11 metres (33–36 ft), thereby being the largest known flying animal. [1] [19] Witton grouped Phosphatodraco with "midsized" azhdarchids based on this size estimate in 2013. [20] In 2010, Kellner suggested this size estimate too large, based on his reinterpretation of the neck vertebra order. [9] Naish and Witton, who followed Kellner's interpretation, listed a neck-length of 865 mm (2 ft 10 in) for Phosphatodraco in 2017, and a wingspan of 4 m (13 ft). [16]

There were two main types of azhdarchid skulls; very long, low skulls that were up to ten times longer than wide, and some that were much shorter than that, closer to those of other pterosaurs. Some had crests and some did not. Azhdarchids had necks that were proportionally longer than those of other pterosaurs, and their vertebral column and much of the rest of the skeleton was pneumatized (filled with air-sacs that lightened it). The body skeleton of azhdarchids was small but robust, and their upper arm bones were solidly built. Their wing-metacarpals (the hand bones that connect with the fingers) were relatively the largest among pterosaurs, and the longest bones in the wings; their wing-fingers (which supported the wing-membranes) were relatively short. The pelvises were relatively robust, and the hindlimbs long. Combined, the long wing metacarpals and legs made azhdarchids relatively taller when standing than other pterosaurs, though their feet were narrow and short. [20] As a pterosaur, Phosphatodraco was covered with hair-like pycnofibers. [21]

Cervical vertebrae

Azhdarchid neck-lengths compared to their estimated wingspans. Phosphatodraco is fourth from the top, following Kellner's interpretation. (The last preserved vertebra is not shown) Azhdarchid pterosaur neck lengths.png
Azhdarchid neck-lengths compared to their estimated wingspans. Phosphatodraco is fourth from the top, following Kellner's interpretation. (The last preserved vertebra is not shown)

The suite of features that distinguish a taxon from other related taxa is called a diagnosis, and in the case of Phosphatodraco, these features are all found in the cervical vertebrae. Since Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues considered the preserved vertebrae to be C5–C9 of the series in their description, that is the diagnosis and description followed here. [1] Note that if Kellner's suggestion that the series actually represents vertebrae C3–C8 is correct, the diagnostic features listed by Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues may possibly be inaccurate, and the following description would refer to different vertebrae in the series. [9] Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues found Phosphatodraco to differ from other azhdarchids in that the hindmost vertebra, C8 in their order, is very elongated, 50% longer than C5, and has a prominent neural spine (the spine that projects upwards from the vertebra) that is almost as tall as the centrum, truncated in a square shape at the top, and located far back. Phosphatodraco is also distinct in that the ratio between the maximum length of the vertebrae and the front width between prezygapophyses (processes at the sides of the centrum which connected with the postzygapophyses of the previous vertebrae) of the middle cervical vertebrae is about 4.3 in C5 and 4.1 in C6. [1]

The five preserved cervical vertebrae have hollow centra and their cortical bone (the outer, thick layer) is about 1 mm (0.039 in) thick. The vertebrae vary in length, the longest being the frontmost of those preserved, a C5 broken in two according to Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues (C3–C4 according to Kellner [9] ), which they estimated to have been about 300 mm (0.98 ft) long when complete. The first of these fragments is 110 mm (4.3 in), the second is about 190 mm (7.5 in). When viewed from the side, the hind end of this vertebra shows a developed left postzygapophysis, and the convex articular condyle (the condyle that connected with the following vertebra) and left postexapophysial process (which connected with the preexapophys at the front of the preceding vertebra) is in front of it, all lying in the same plane due to crushing. [1]

C3-C5 vertebrae of Quetzalcoatlus (A-C) compared with those of Phosphatodraco (D) Quetzphoswittonnaish2008.png
C3–C5 vertebrae of Quetzalcoatlus (A–C) compared with those of Phosphatodraco (D)

The C6 (Kellner's C5 [9] ) is the best-preserved of the vertebrae, and is shorter than the preceding C5, about 225 mm (8.9 in) long. It is distorted so that the front part is visible in lower side view, and the hind part is visible in left side view. Its centrum is procoelous (concave at the front surface), its prezygapophyses are horn-like, and nearly concave and parallel when seen from below. The right prezygapophys has a small tubercle (a rounded projection) at the midline, and there is no indication of additional processes at the front end of the vertebra or pneumatic foramina (holes) on the side surface of the centrum. The front cotyle (the concave front end of the centrum) is distorted, but it appears to be twice as wide as high, ovoid (or egg-shaped), and with a slightly concave upper margin. The lower margin has a prominent hypapophysis (a downwards projection), and this keel's height diminishes towards the centrum's mid-length. There is a longitudinal oval sulcus (a groove) on the right side of the lower surface, near the base of the prezygapophysis. The lower surface of the centrum is nearly flat, and the postexapophys is well-developed at the lower side of the condyle, like in the preceding vertebrae. [1]

The following C7 vertebra (Kellner's C6 [9] ) is visible in bottom view, is missing the hind part, the preserved part being 190 mm (7.5 in) long, and the complete length perhaps being the same or shorter as the preceding C6. Its prezygapophyses are similar to those of the preceding vertebra, and the cotyle is oval and compressed from top to bottom. There is a sulcus below the left prezygapophys, apparently without a ridge extending hindward. The centrum bulges slightly hindward, becoming narrower at its mid-length. The postzygapophyses are well-developed, and diverge widely from the longitudinal midline of the centrum. A small protuberance between the postzygapophyses perhaps indicates where the upper margin of the neural canal (through which the spinal cord passed) was located, though its features cannot be accurately determined. [1]

Characteristics of azhdarchid cervical vertebrae; J is the C7 of Phosphatodraco following Kellner's order (it is C8 in Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues' order) Characteristics of azhdarchid cervical vertebrae.png
Characteristics of azhdarchid cervical vertebrae; J is the C7 of Phosphatodraco following Kellner's order (it is C8 in Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues' order)

The next to last vertebra is C8 (Kellner's C7 [9] [16] ) which is visible in side view, and despite missing some of the front, the centrum is very elongated, measuring 150 mm (5.9 in). The most notable feature of this vertebra is its tall neural spine, which is placed at its hindmost part. The neural spine is 40 mm (1.6 in) high measured from the upper surface of the postzygapophys to the top, almost the same height as the centrum, which is 45 mm (1.8 in). The front and hind margins of the neural spine are vertically parallel to each other, and its top is truncated in a square shape, and perpendicular to the side edges. The left postzygapophys is located at the base of the hind end of the neural arch (which forms the arch of bone through which the spinal cord passed). It is similar to the same vertebra of Quetzalcoatlus in that the neural spine is square on top, but differs in being placed so far back. The left postexaphophyseal process is well-developed at the back and below, but does not extend past the condyle as it does in the preceding vertebrae. [1]

The last vertebra is the C9 according to Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues (Kellner's C8, [9] which is visible in hind view, and its preserved part is 75 mm (3.0 in) high. Its neural arch has a large neural spine and well-developed transverse processes (which projected from the sides of the centrum and acted as attachment points for muscles and ligaments). The neural spine terminates in a blunt process above, and the hind side of the neural spine has an oval depression, which has thick vertical edges at its sides. The transverse processes are long and slender, and project to the sides and slightly downwards. The neural canal is small and nearly circular, is about 22 mm (0.87 in) in diameter, and there are no pneumatic foramina near it. Its condyle is broad, around five times wider than high, and is crescent-shaped in cross-section. The left postexapophysis is placed at the side of the condyle and almost vertical. Though none of the vertebrae preserve cervical ribs, the development of the transverse processes of the last vertebra indicates that it probably had ribs. [1] The indeterminate bone fragment associated with the two last vertebrae has a similar texture to them, is flat and crescent-shaped, and is about 9 mm (0.35 in) wide and 44 mm (1.7 in) long. [1]

Life restoration showing Phosphatodraco in terrestrial pose Phosphatodraco.jpg
Life restoration showing Phosphatodraco in terrestrial pose

Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues found that the frontmost preserved cervical vertebrae of Phosphatodraco (their C5–C7) were similar in form to those of the mid-series cervical vertebrae of other long-necked pterodactyloid pterosaurs (the group consisting of short-tailed pterosaurs). The last hindmost preserved vertebrae (their C8–C9) have some features in common with the rest of the vertebrae, including broad, ovoid cotyles and condyles, as well as postexapophyses, but they differ in their neural canal being demarcated from the centrum and in having a prominent neural spine. Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues suggested the C8–C9 could be cervicalized dorsal vertebrae, back vertebrae which have been incorporated into the neck. The total number of cervical vertebrae in pterosaurs varies between seven and nine, and the first dorsal vertebra is considered to be the first one that connects with the sternum (breast bone). Early pterosaurs like Rhamphorhynchus had eight cervical vertebrae with cervical ribs on at least C3–C8; later pterodactyloids had seven vertebrae and no ribs. In later pterdactyloid groups, nine cervical vertebrae are present, two of them being cervicalized dorsals, and adults have a notarium (a structure consisting of fused vertebrae in the shoulder-region, also seen in birds). [1]

Classification

In their 2003 description Pereda-Suberbiola and colleagues considered Phosphatodraco a member of Azhdarchidae based on features such as its mid-series cervical vertebrae being elongated, with low vestigial (almost evolutionarily lost) or absent neural spines, the presence of prezygapophyseal tubercles, a pair of lower sulci near the prezygapophyses, and the lack of oval pneumatic foramina on the lower surfaces of the centra. These features are especially similar to those of Quetzalcoatlus and Azhdarcho . Other features distinguishing the group could not be identified in Phosphatodraco due to the preservation of its fossils. [1]

Longrich and colleagues performed a phylogenetic analysis that included Moroccan pterosaurs in 2018, and found Phosphatodraco to be an azhdarchid, and the sister taxon of Aralazhdarcho from Kazakhstan. [2] A 2021 analysis by Rodrigo and colleagues also found these two genera to be sister taxa, joined in a clade by Eurazhdarcho from Romania. This clade was supported by one clear synapomorphy (a distinct, ancestrally shared feature), that the side margin of the mid-cervical vertebrae is straight when viewed from above and below, with almost parallel sides. These researchers noted that previous studies had defined Azhdarchidae as a node based clade with Azhdarcho and Quetzalcoatlus as internal specifiers, but cautioned that in their new phylogeny, Phosphatodraco, Zhejiangopterus, and Eurazhdarcho would fall outside the group. They found this undesirable, as those genera had otherwise consistently been considered azhdarchids, and that for stability's sake, Phosphatodraco should be added as a third internal specifier for the group, since this would result in all these taxa being included. [17]

In 2021 paleontologist Brian Andres and colleagues also found Phosphatodraco and Aralazhdarcho to be sister taxa, supported by the reduction of pneumatic foramina on the side of the neural canal. This clade was recovered as part of the azhdarchid subclade Quetzalcoatlinae. The cladogram below shows the placement of Phosphatodraco within Azhdarchiformes according to Andres and colleagues, 2021: [22]

Reconstructed skeleton of Quetzalcoatlus in a flying pose QuetzalcoatlusROM.JPG
Reconstructed skeleton of Quetzalcoatlus in a flying pose
Azhdarchiformes

Radiodactylus langstoni

Montanazhdarcho minor

Azhdarchidae
Azhdarchinae

Azhdarcho lancicollis

Albadraco tharmisensis

Aerotitan sudamericanus

Mistralazhdarcho maggii

Quetzalcoatlinae

Aralazhdarcho bostobensis

Phosphatodraco mauritanicus

Eurazhdarcho langendorfensis

Zhejiangopterus linhaiensis

Cryodrakon boreas

Wellnhopterus brevirostris

Hatzegopteryx thambema

Arambourgiania philadelphiae

Quetzalcoatlus lawsoni

Quetzalcoatlus northropi

Paleobiology

Feeding and ecological niche

Zhejiangopterus postcrania.png
Zhejiangopteruswittonnaish2008.png
Skeletal diagrams showing Zhejiangopterus (left, as preserved without skull, right, as reconstructed), one of the two other azhdarchids known preserved with a relatively complete neck (the other is Quetzalcoatlus)

In 2008 Witton and Naish pointed out that although azhdarchids have historically been considered to have been scavengers, probers of sediment, swimmers, waders, aerial predators, or stork-like generalists, most researchers until that point had considered them to have been skim-feeders living in coastal settings, which fed by trawling their lower jaws through water while flying and catching prey from the surface (like skimmers and some terns). In general, pterosaurs have historically been considered marine piscivores (fish-eaters), and despite their unusual anatomy, azhdarchids have been assumed to have occupied the same ecological niche. Witton and Naish noted that evidence for this mode of feeding lacked support from azhdarchid anatomy and functional morphology; they lacked cranial features such as sideways compressed lower jaws and the shock-absorbing adaptations required, and their jaws instead appear to have been almost triangular in cross-section, unlike those of skim-feeders and probers. [6]

Witton and Naish instead stated that azhdarchids probably inhabited inland environments, based on the taphonomic contexts their fossils have been found in (more than half the fossils surveyed were from for example fluvial or alluvial deposits, and most of the marine occurrences also had fossils of terrestrial lifeforms), and their morphology made them ill-suited for lifestyles other than wading and foraging terrestrially, though their feet were relatively small, slender, and had pads, not suited for wading either. These researchers instead argued that azhdarchids were similar to storks or ground hornbills, generalists they termed "terrestrial stalkers" that foraged in different kinds of environments for small animals and carrion, supported by their apparent proficiency on the ground and relatively inflexible necks, for example the well-preserved neck of Phosphatodraco providing information about their morphology. Witton and Naish suggested that their more generalist lifestyle could explain the group's resilience compared to other pterosaur lineages, which were not thought to have survived until the late Maastrichtian like the azhdarchids did (pterosaurs went extinct along with the non-bird dinosaurs during the Cretaceous-Paleogene extinction event 66 million years ago). [6] [2]

Witton elaborated in a 2013 book that the proportions of azhdarchids would have been consistent with them striding through vegetated areas with their long limbs, and their downturned skull and jaws reaching the ground. Their long, stiffened necks would be an advantage as it would help lowering and raising the head and give it a vantage point when searching for prey, and enable them to grab small animals and fruit. [23] In their 2021 study that reinterpreted Tethydraco as an azhdarchid, and possibly the same as Phosphatodraco, Labita and Martill noted that azhdarchids might have been less terrestrial than suggested by Witton and Naish, since the Moroccan fossils were from marine strata, as was Arambourgiania from the phosphates of Jordan. They noted that no azhdarchids had been found in truly terrestrial strata, and proposed they could instead have been associated with aquatic environments, such as rivers, lakes, marine and off-shore settings. [7]

Pterosaurs are generally thought to have gone gradually extinct by decreasing in diversity towards the end of the Cretaceous, but Longrich and colleagues suggested this impression could be a result of the poor fossil records for pterosaurs (the Signor-Lipps Effect). Since they found multiple lineages (Pteranodontidae, Nyctosauridae, and Azhdarchidae, the latter including Phosphatodraco and others) to have co-existed during the late Maastrichtian of Morocco, this is the most diverse pterosaur assemblage known from the Late Cretaceous. Pterosaurs during this time thereby had increased niche-partitioning compared to earlier faunas from the Santonian and Campanian ages, and they were able to outcompete birds in large size based niches, and birds therefore remained small, not exceeding 2 m (6.6 ft) wingspans during the Late Cretaceous (most pterosaurs during this time had larger wingspans, and thereby avoided the small-size niche). To these researchers, this indicated that the extinction of pterosaurs was abrupt instead of gradual, caused by the catastrophic Chicxulub impact. Their extinction freed up more niches that were then filled by birds, which led to their evolutionary radiation in the Early Cenozoic. [2]

Locomotion

Haenamichnuswittonnaish2008.png
Azhdarchfeedingwittonnaish2008.png
Possible azhdarchid trackway Haenamichnus from Korea (left) and feeding posture inferred from the tracks

Witton summarized ideas about azhdarchid flight abilities in 2013, and noted they had generally been considered adapted for soaring, although some have found it possible their musculature allowed flapping flight like in swans and geese. Their short and potentially broad wings may have been suited for flying in terrestrial environments, as this is similar to some large, terrestrially soaring birds. Albatross-like soaring has also been suggested, but Witton thought this unlikely due to the supposed terrestrial bias of their fossils and adaptations for foraging on the ground. Studies of azhdarchid flight abilities indicate they would have been able to fly for long and probably fast (especially if they had an adequate amount of fat and muscle as nourishment), so that geographical barriers would not present obstacles. [24]

Azhdarchids are also the only group of pterosaurs to which trackways have been assigned, such as Haenamichnus from Korea, which matches this group in shape, age, and size. One long trackway of this kind shows that azhdarchids walked with their limbs held directly underneath their body, and along with the morphology of their feet indicates they were more proficient on the ground than other pterosaurs. According to Witton, their proportions indicate they were not good swimmers on the other hand, and though they could probably launch from water, they were not as good at this as some other pterosaur groups. [24]

Paleoenvironment

The contemporary Chenanisaurus moving along the coastline Chenanisaurus shoreline.jpg
The contemporary Chenanisaurus moving along the coastline

Phosphatodraco is known from the "couche III" phosphatic unit of the Ouled Abdoun Basin in Morocco, which was deposited during the late Maastrichtian age of the Late Cretaceous period, which ended 66 million years ago. The phosphatic series is condensed and the Maastrichtian part is only 3–5 cm (1.2–2.0 in) thick. From the bottom to the top, "couche III" consists of thin phosphatic levels and marls, a grey limestone bed containing fish fossils, yellow, soft phosphates at the lower level, a thick, yellow marly level, separating the lower and upper "couche III", and gray, soft phosphates with brown stripes overlay in a thick marl level at upper "couche III". Pterosaur fossils are found in the lower part of the upper phosphatic unit. [1] [2] The kind of fossils that are usually used in biostratigraphy are rare, which complicates attempts at dating these beds, but "couche III" has been correlated with the late Maastrichtian on the basis of shark teeth, which has also been confirmed by carbon and oxygen istope stratigraphy. [25] The phosphates were deposited in an embayment of the eastern Atlantic Ocean that flooded North Africa during the Late Cretaceous and Early Paleogene. [26] The area would have been part of the Tethys Sea at the time. [2]

The phosphatic matrix of the original Phosphatodraco specimen is gray and mottled with orange, and contained fossils including of the fish Serratolamna , Rhombodus , and Enchodus , and the mosasaur Prognathodon , as well as small nodules. The specimen was found close to skeletal remains of an indeterminate mosasaur, and remains of sharks, rays, fish such as Stratodus , mosasaurs such as Platecarpus , Mosasaurus , and Halisaurus , indeterminate elasmosaurid plesiosaurs, and indeterminate bothremydid turtles have also been found at the site. This assemblage of animals suggests the sediments were deposited in a marine environment. [1] Other contemporary pterosaurs from the Ouled Abdoun Basin include the pteranodontid Tethydraco (if it is not the same animal as Phosphatodraco), the nyctosaurids Alcione , Simurghia , and Barbaridactylus , a small azhdarchid similar to Quetzalcoatlus, and a very large azhdarchid which may be Arambourgiania. Dinosaurs are rare there, but the abelisaurid Chenanisaurus , the hadrosaur Ajnabia , and sauropod fossils are also known. Longrich and colleagues suggested in 2018 that, although the fauna was overwhelmingly marine, the presence of terrestrial dinosaurs and azhdarchids indicates the coast was nearby. [2] [7] [25] [27]

See also

Related Research Articles

<i>Quetzalcoatlus</i> Genus of azhdarchid pterosaurs from the Late Cretaceous

Quetzalcoatlus is a genus of pterosaur known from the Late Cretaceous period of North America ; its members were among the largest known flying animals of all time. Quetzalcoatlus is a member of the Azhdarchidae, a family of advanced toothless pterosaurs with unusually long, stiffened necks. Its name comes from the Aztec feathered serpent god Quetzalcoatl. The type species is Q. northropi, named by Douglas Lawson in 1975; the genus also includes the smaller species Q. lawsoni, which was known for many years as an unnamed species before being named by Brian Andres and Wann Langston Jr. (posthumously) in 2021.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Azhdarchidae</span> Family of large azhdarchoid pterosaurs

Azhdarchidae is a family of pterosaurs known primarily from the Late Cretaceous Period, though an isolated vertebra apparently from an azhdarchid is known from the Early Cretaceous as well. Azhdarchids included some of the largest known flying animals of all time, but smaller cat-size members have also been found. Originally considered a sub-family of Pteranodontidae, Nesov (1984) named the Azhdarchinae to include the pterosaurs Azhdarcho, Quetzalcoatlus, and Titanopteryx. They were among the last known surviving members of the pterosaurs, and were a rather successful group with a worldwide distribution. By the time of the end-Cretaceous mass extinction, most pterosaur families except for the Azhdarchidae disappear from the fossil record, but recent studies indicate a wealth of pterosaurian fauna, including pteranodontids, nyctosaurids, tapejarids and several indeterminate forms. In several analyses, some taxa such as Navajodactylus, Bakonydraco and Montanazhdarcho were moved from Azhdarchidae to other clades.

<i>Azhdarcho</i> Genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Azhdarcho is a genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the late Cretaceous Period of the Bissekty Formation of Uzbekistan, as well as the Zhirkindek Formation of Kazakhstan. It is known from fragmentary remains including the distinctive, elongated neck vertebrae that characterizes members of the family Azhdarchidae, a family that includes many giant pterosaurs such as Quetzalcoatlus. The name Azhdarcho comes from the Persian word azhdar (اژدر), a dragon-like creature in Persian mythology. The type species is Azhdarcho lancicollis. The specific epithet lancicollis is derived from the Latin words lancea and collum ("neck").

<i>Puertasaurus</i> Extinct genus of dinosaurs

Puertasaurus is a genus of sauropod dinosaur that lived in South America during the Late Cretaceous Period. It is known from a single specimen recovered from sedimentary rocks of the Cerro Fortaleza Formation in southwestern Patagonia, Argentina, which probably is Campanian or Maastrichtian in age. The only species is Puertasaurus reuili. Described by the paleontologist Fernando Novas and colleagues in 2005, it was named in honor of Pablo Puerta and Santiago Reuil, who discovered and prepared the specimen. It consists of four well-preserved vertebrae, including one cervical, one dorsal, and two caudal vertebrae. Puertasaurus is a member of Titanosauria, the dominant group of sauropods during the Cretaceous.

<i>Thalassodromeus</i> Genus of azhdarchoid pterosaur from the Early Cretaceous

Thalassodromeus is a genus of pterosaur that lived in what is now Brazil during the Early Cretaceous period, about a hundred million years ago. The original skull, discovered in 1983 in the Araripe Basin of northeastern Brazil, was collected in several pieces. In 2002, the skull was made the holotype specimen of Thalassodromeus sethi by palaeontologists Alexander Kellner and Diogenes de Almeida Campos. The generic name means "sea runner", and the specific name refers to the Egyptian god Seth due to its crest being supposedly reminiscent of Seth's crown. Other scholars have pointed out that the crest was instead similar to the crown of Amon. A jaw tip was assigned to T. sethi in 2005, became the basis of the new genus Banguela in 2014, and assigned back to Thalassodromeus as the species T. oberlii in 2018. Another species was described in 2015 based on a supposed crest fragment, but this was later shown to be part of a turtle shell.

<i>Arambourgiania</i> Genus of large azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Arambourgiania is an extinct genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of Jordan, and possibly the United States. Arambourgiania was among the largest members of its family, the Azhdarchidae, and it is also one of the largest flying animals ever known. The incomplete left ulna of the "Sidi Chennane azhdarchid" from Morocco may have also belonged to Arambourgiania.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pteranodontidae</span> Family of pteranodontian pterosaurs

The Pteranodontidae are a family of large pterosaurs of the Cretaceous Period of North America and Africa. The family was named in 1876 by Othniel Charles Marsh. Pteranodontids had a distinctive, elongated crest jutting from the rear of the head. The spectacularly-crested Nyctosaurus is sometimes included in this family, though usually placed in its own family, the Nyctosauridae.

<i>Hatzegopteryx</i> Genus of large azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Hatzegopteryx is a genus of azhdarchid pterosaur found in the late Maastrichtian deposits of the Densuş Ciula Formation, an outcropping in Transylvania, Romania. It is known only from the type species, Hatzegopteryx thambema, named by Buffetaut et al. in 2002 based on parts of the skull and humerus. Additional specimens, including a neck vertebra, were later placed in the genus, representing a range of sizes. The largest of these remains indicate it was among the biggest pterosaurs, with an estimated wingspan of 10 to 12 metres.

<i>Montanazhdarcho</i> Genus of azhdarchoid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Montanazhdarcho is a genus of azhdarchoid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of what is now the state of Montana, United States. Montanazhdarcho is known from only one species, M. minor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Ornithocheiroidea</span> Clade of pterodactyloid pterosaurs

Ornithocheiroidea is a group of pterosaurs within the extinct suborder Pterodactyloidea. They were typically large pterosaurs that lived from the Early to Late Cretaceous periods, with fossil remains found all over the world except Antarctica.

Elanodactylus is a genus of ctenochasmatid pterodactyloid pterosaur from the Early Cretaceous period of what is now the Yixian Formation of Liaoning, China.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Nyctosauridae</span> Family of pteranodontian pterosaurs

Nyctosauridae is a family of specialized soaring pterosaurs of the late Cretaceous Period of North America, Africa, and possibly Europe. It was named in 1889 by Henry Alleyne Nicholson and Richard Lydekker.

<i>Alanqa</i> Genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Alanqa is a genus of pterodactyloid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of what is now the Kem Kem Beds of southeastern Morocco. The name Alanqa comes from the Arabic word العنقاءal-‘Anqā’, for a mythical bird of Arabian culture.

<i>Eurazhdarcho</i> Genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Eurazhdarcho is a genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous period of what is now the Transylvanian Basin of Romania. Its fossil remains dated back 69 million years ago.

<i>Tethydraco</i> Genus of ornithocheiroid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Tethydraco is a genus of pterodactyloid pterosaur that lived during the Late Cretaceous period of what is now the area of present Morocco, about 66 million years ago. Tethydraco was originally assigned to the family Pteranodontidae. Subsequently described material suggested that it was an azhdarchid, and possibly synonymous with Phosphatodraco. The type and only species is T. regalis.

<i>Alcione elainus</i> Genus of nyctosaurid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Alcione is a genus of nyctosaurid pterosaur from the Ouled Abdoun Basin of Morocco, dating back to the Maastrichtian stage of the Late Cretaceous period. Only one species, A. elainus, is known. This pterosaur lived in a marine environment alongside several other pterosaurs, including the nyctosaurids Simurghia and Barbaridactylus.

<i>Simurghia</i> Genus of nyctosaurid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Simurghia is a genus nyctosaurid pterosaur from the Ouled Abdoun Basin of Morocco, a basin that dates to the Maastrichtian stage of the Late Cretaceous period, about 66 million years ago. It was published in 2018 by paleontologists Nicholas R. Longrich, David M. Martill, and Brian Andres, along with two other nyctosaurids from the same basin: Alcione and Barbaridactylus. The type and only species is S. robusta.

<i>Cryodrakon</i> Genus of large azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Cryodrakon is a genus of azhdarchid pterosaur that lived during the Late Cretaceous period in what is now Canada. It contains a single species, Cryodrakon boreas, recovered from the Dinosaur Park Formation.

<i>Wellnhopterus</i> Genus of azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous

Wellnhopterus is an azhdarchid pterosaur recovered from the Late Cretaceous Javelina Formation in Texas that was previously identified as a thalassodromine. It consists of a set of upper and lower jaws, as well as some cervical vertebrae and a fragmentary long bone. In July 2021, the jaws were given the genus name "Javelinadactylus", with the type and only species as "J. sagebieli"; however, this article has now been retracted. In a paper published in December 2021, the complete holotype was independently named Wellnhopterus, with the only species being W. brevirostris. As of 2022, this is the formal name of this pterosaur.

<i>Thalassotitan</i> Large bodied African mosasaur

Thalassotitan is an extinct genus of mosasaur that lived in Morocco during the late Maastrichtian of the Cretaceous period, around 66 million years ago. The mosasaur's remains were found in the Ouled Abdoun Basin, where many other mosasaurs have been found. This mosasaur was described in 2022 and was assigned to the tribe Prognathodontini alongside other mosasaurs like Prognathodon and Gnathomortis. The prognathodontine mosasaurs are separated from other mosasaurs based on their massive jaws and robust teeth. This genus shows definitely that mosasaurs evolved to take over the apex predator niche in the oceans of the late Cretaceous which is now filled by sharks and orcas. Heavy wear on its teeth and fossils found in the vicinity of the holotype etched by acid wear from partial digestion suggest this mosasaur had a diet consisting of smaller mosasaur species, plesiosaurs, large predatory fish, and sea turtles.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Suberbiola, Xabier Pereda; Bardet, Nathalie; Jouve, Stéphane; Iarochène, Mohamed; Bouya, Baâdi; Amaghzaz, Mbarek (2003). "A new azhdarchid pterosaur from the Late Cretaceous phosphates of Morocco". Geological Society, London, Special Publications. 217 (1): 79–90. Bibcode:2003GSLSP.217...79S. doi:10.1144/GSL.SP.2003.217.01.08. S2CID   135043714.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Longrich, Nicholas R.; Martill, David M.; Andres, Brian; Penny, David (2018). "Late Maastrichtian pterosaurs from North Africa and mass extinction of Pterosauria at the Cretaceous-Paleogene boundary". PLOS Biology. 16 (3): e2001663. doi:10.1371/journal.pbio.2001663. PMC   5849296 . PMID   29534059.
  3. Naylor, Phillip C. (2015). Historical Dictionary of Algeria. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers. p. 376. ISBN   978-0-8108-7919-5.
  4. Weech, William Nassau; Wilson, R. J. A. (2012). "Mauretania". In Hornblower, Simon; Spawforth, Antony; Eidinow, Esther (eds.). The Oxford classical dictionary (4th ed.). Oxford University Press. p. 913. ISBN   978-0-19-954556-8. OCLC   959667246.
  5. Williams, Cariad J.; Pani, Martino; Bucchi, Andrea; Smith, Roy E.; Kao, Alexander; Keeble, William; Ibrahim, Nizar; Martill, David M. (2021). "Helically arranged cross struts in azhdarchid pterosaur cervical vertebrae and their biomechanical implications". iScience. 24 (4): 102338. Bibcode:2021iSci...24j2338W. doi:10.1016/j.isci.2021.102338. PMC   8101050 . PMID   33997669.
  6. 1 2 3 Witton, Mark P.; Naish, Darren (2008). "A reappraisal of azhdarchid pterosaur functional morphology and paleoecology". PLOS ONE. 3 (5): e2271. Bibcode:2008PLoSO...3.2271W. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0002271 . PMC   2386974 . PMID   18509539.
  7. 1 2 3 Labita, Claudio; Martill, David M. (2021). "An articulated pterosaur wing from the Upper Cretaceous (Maastrichtian) phosphates of Morocco". Cretaceous Research. 119: 104679. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2020.104679. S2CID   226328607.
  8. Kellner, Alexander W. A.; Mello, Amanda Martins S.; Ford, Tracy (2007). "A survey of pterosaurs from Africa with the description of a new specimen from Morocco". In de Souza Carvalho, Ismar; de Cassia Tardin Cassab, Rita; Schwanke, Cibele (eds.). Paleontologia: Cenários da Vida. Vol. 1. Interciência. pp. 257–267. ISBN   978-8571931848.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Kellner, Alexander W. A. (2010). "Comments on the Pteranodontidae (Pterosauria, Pterodactyloidea) with the description of two new species". Anais da Academia Brasileira de Ciências. 82 (4): 1063–1084. doi:10.1590/S0001-37652010000400025. PMID   21152777.
  10. Wellnhofer 1991, pp. 50–52.
  11. Rodrigues, Taissa; Kellner, Alexander W. A.; Mader, Bryn J.; Russell, Dal A. (2011). "New pterosaur specimens from the Kem Kem Beds (Upper Cretaceous, Cenomanian) of Morocco". Rivista italiana di Paleontologia e Stratigrafia. 117 (1). doi: 10.13130/2039-4942/5967 .
  12. Costa, Fabiana Rodrigues; Sayão, Juliana Manso; Kellner, Alexander W. A. (2015). "New pterosaur material from the Upper Jurassic of Tendaguru (Tanzania), Africa". Historical Biology. 27 (6): 646–655. doi:10.1080/08912963.2014.901314. S2CID   129851580.
  13. Averianov, Alexander (2014). "Review of taxonomy, geographic distribution, and paleoenvironments of Azhdarchidae (Pterosauria)". ZooKeys (432): 1–107. doi: 10.3897/zookeys.432.7913 . PMC   4141157 . PMID   25152671.
  14. Vremir, Mátyás; Witton, Mark; Naish, Darren; Dyke, Gareth; Brusatte, Stephen L.; Norell, Mark; Totoianu, Radu (2015). "A medium-sized robust-necked azhdarchid pterosaur (Pterodactyloidea: Azhdarchidae) from the Maastrichtian of Pui (Haţeg Basin, Transylvania, Romania)". American Museum Novitates (3827): 1–16. doi:10.1206/3827.1. S2CID   54068293.
  15. Martill, David M.; Moser, Markus (2018). "Topotype specimens probably attributable to the giant azhdarchid pterosaur Arambourgiania philadelphiae (Arambourg 1959)". Geological Society, London, Special Publications. 455 (1): 159–169. Bibcode:2018GSLSP.455..159M. doi:10.1144/SP455.6. S2CID   132649124.
  16. 1 2 3 Naish, Darren; Witton, Mark P. (2017). "Neck biomechanics indicate that giant Transylvanian azhdarchid pterosaurs were short-necked arch predators". PeerJ. 5: e2908. doi:10.7717/peerj.2908. PMC   5248582 . PMID   28133577.
  17. 1 2 Pêgas, Rodrigo V.; Holgado, Borja; Ortiz David, Leonardo D.; Baiano, Mattia A.; Costa, Fabiana R. (2021). "On the pterosaur Aerotitan sudamericanus (Neuquén Basin, Upper Cretaceous of Argentina), with comments on azhdarchoid phylogeny and jaw anatomy". Cretaceous Research. 129: 104998. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2021.104998. S2CID   238725853.
  18. Solomon, Alexandru A.; Codrea, Vlad A.; Venczel, Márton; Grellet-Tinner, Gerald (2020). "A new species of large-sized pterosaur from the Maastrichtian of Transylvania (Romania)". Cretaceous Research. 110: 104316. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2019.104316. S2CID   213808137.
  19. Andres, Brian; Langston, Wann (2021). "Morphology and taxonomy of Quetzalcoatlus Lawson 1975 (Pterodactyloidea: Azhdarchoidea)". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 41 (sup1): 46–202. doi:10.1080/02724634.2021.1907587. S2CID   245125409.
  20. 1 2 Witton 2013, pp. 249–255.
  21. Witton 2013, pp. 51–52.
  22. Andres, Brian (2021). "Phylogenetic systematics of Quetzalcoatlus Lawson 1975 (Pterodactyloidea: Azhdarchoidea)". Journal of Vertebrate Paleontology. 41 (sup1): 203–217. doi:10.1080/02724634.2020.1801703. S2CID   245078533.
  23. Witton 2013, pp. 257–258.
  24. 1 2 Witton 2013, pp. 255–257.
  25. 1 2 Longrich, Nicholas R.; Pereda-Suberbiola, Xabier; Jalil, Nour-Eddine; Khaldoune, Fatima; Jourani, Essaid (2017). "An abelisaurid from the latest Cretaceous (late Maastrichtian) of Morocco, North Africa". Cretaceous Research. 76: 40–52. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2017.03.021.
  26. Longrich, Nicholas R.; Jalil, Nour-Eddine; Khaldoune, Fatima; Yazami, Oussama Khadiri; Pereda-Suberbiola, Xabier; Bardet, Nathalie (2022). "Thalassotitan atrox, a giant predatory mosasaurid (Squamata) from the upper Maastrichtian phosphates of Morocco". Cretaceous Research. 140: 105315. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2022.105315. S2CID   251821884.
  27. Longrich, Nicholas R.; Suberbiola, Xabier Pereda; Pyron, R. Alexander; Jalil, Nour-Eddine (2021). "The first duckbill dinosaur (Hadrosauridae: Lambeosaurinae) from Africa and the role of oceanic dispersal in dinosaur biogeography". Cretaceous Research. 120: 104678. doi:10.1016/j.cretres.2020.104678. S2CID   228807024.

Bibliography

  • Wellnhofer, P. (1991). The Illustrated Encyclopedia of Pterosaurs. Crescent Books. ISBN   978-0-517-03701-0.
  • Witton, M. P. (2013). Pterosaurs: Natural History, Evolution, Anatomy (1st ed.). Princeton University Press. ISBN   978-0-691-15061-1.