Medieval ecclesiastic historiography

Last updated

The Holy Bible was one of the main sources for medieval Historians and greatly influenced ecclesiastic historiography. Bibel-1.jpg
The Holy Bible was one of the main sources for medieval Historians and greatly influenced ecclesiastic historiography.

Medieval ecclesiastic historiography encompasses the historiographic production by the Clergymen of the European Middle Ages, who created their own style of developing history and passing it on to posterity. It originated with Eusebius of Caesarea, [1] who molded a new way of writing. He gathered several followers who began copying him and propagating his model, even if indirectly. [1]

Contents

It was generally characterized by the proposal of exposing the goals and methods of the Historians in their work. They sought to clarify their purpose and how they had managed to gather the necessary information for each of their texts. [2] The dominant method was narration and their main goal was to pass on the information to future times. [2] [3] There were serious problems in making the works, the principal one being the search for documents (rare) and the various inconsistencies among the works, resulting from forgeries in many cases. [4] [5]

Despite its problems, the ecclesiastic historiography of the Middle Ages had its importance in the development of History as an academic discipline, according to the French historian Bernard Guenée. [6] It also left a legacy that includes the development of auxiliary sciences such as bibliography, epigraphy, archeology, and genealogy.

Origins

Eusebius of Caesarea is considered the "father" of ecclesiastic historiography. Eusebius of Caesarea.jpg
Eusebius of Caesarea is considered the "father" of ecclesiastic historiography.

The origins of ecclesiastic historiography go back to Eusebius of Caesarea, [1] who is considered its father, [7] and to his immediate successors: Socrates, Sozomenus, Theodoret, and Gelasius, the bishop of Caesarea Maritima . [1] At first, it was possible to compare the new branch of historiography that was forming to political history, and it was possible to draw an analogy between the battles and treatises of the latter with the themes of persecution and heresy in Eusebius' work. [8]

Eusebius was the main recognizer of the importance of documents for the development of history while adopting several aspects of Jewish influence in his works. [9] The most relevant of these was "succession," which had been created through the thinking of the rabbis and developed with strong Greek influence. [9]

Another line for ecclesiastic historiographic production was that created by Philip of Side, around 430 A.D. His work Christian History began with the origin of the world (explained through the theory of creationism) and included many diverse subjects beyond history, such as geography, the natural sciences, and mathematics. [10] [note 1] However, Philip failed to garner followers and was soon forgotten. [10]

However, while ascending, ecclesiastic historiography did not end the cycles of other types of historiography. [10] [note 2] Political history, in particular, continued to be developed continuously and was recognized by all the ecclesiastic historians of late antiquity, including Eusebius of Caesarea himself. Rufinus' translation of Church History from Greek into Latin is considered the starting point of ecclesiastic writing in the Western Roman Empire, [9] since before this it had been developed only in the Eastern Roman Empire. The impact of the translation made by Rufinus was so great that the work became extremely popular. It was known that medieval historians such as Gregory of Tours, Beda, and Augustine were familiar with it. [11]

Goals and methods

One of the main characteristics of ecclesiastic historiography is the common presence of goals and methods in the prologue of the works. [2] Through the analysis of the prologues of medieval history books, it is possible to understand how the work was produced, for what purpose it was developed, to whom it was intended, and what methods were applied in its making. [2]

The key objective of the Clergymen was to transmit historical knowledge to posterity, but only events worthy of remembrance were to appear in the works produced, and they usually dealt with subjects such as biographies or wars. [note 3] As it happened with the liturgy of the Catholic Church, history would become a tool of memory. [2] [3]

The main method for conveying history was the narration of events, and it was very common to use works of history to convey examples of reputable men that should be followed by others. The work of Valerius Maximus, the Book of Memorable Doings and Sayings, is an example of this compilation made several times. [2] Therefore, it would be up to the historian to create someone's glory or infamy, and for this very reason, several works of history started to be "commissioned" by nobles in the same period (so that their names would not be forgotten). [12] [13]

Sources

Written

The written sources used by medieval historians came mainly from libraries and archives, [14] and were used especially for studies on "ancient times". [note 4] [12]

During the Middle Ages, libraries were not yet as rich as they would become during the Renaissance (to a great degree after the spread of the press throughout Europe in the 15th century). [4] Only a few books were available and in small quantities, very few being history books. The main source for many works was the Bible, which had been recommended by Cassiodorus to all libraries in the sixth century, in addition to Eusebius of Caesarea's Church History. [14] Content not covered by the Holy Bible and Eusebius' work was hardly found in ordinary libraries, and its diffusion was extremely limited. [14]

The archives were as rustic as the libraries, and there were several problems with the conservation of manuscripts. [15] Besides the problem of conservation, there was also a great obstacle imposed by the lack of classification, [15] as well as the lack of access (many historians could only turn to the archive of the institution to which they belonged). [16] One of the best-known archives is that of Reims, which was organized as early as the 9th century by Hincmar. [15] Only from the 11th century onwards did the episcopal archives begin to be inventoried, [4] and only with the advance of royal power in the 14th century did the need for classification become clear. [4]

Oral

Isidore of Seville was the precursor of the use of oral sources in the works of ecclesiastic historiography. Isidor von Sevilla.jpeg
Isidore of Seville was the precursor of the use of oral sources in the works of ecclesiastic historiography.

The oral sources were those coming from the testimony of people who had witnessed the events narrated in the works. [17] Isidore of Seville is considered a precursor in encouraging the use of oral sources, because of the great influence he had on later historians. [17] According to Isidore's teachings, the oral tradition was followed, and the most reliable oral sources were used, which were direct testimonies. [17] In addition, the search for criticism of testimonies is notorious, since confirmation of these testimonies was sought in others (then considered "secondary"). [17] When it was not possible to use direct testimonies, historians looked for support for their books in popular beliefs, ancient traditions, and songs that circulated in the medieval world. [18]

Auxiliary

Auxiliary sources were those that came from monuments, ruins, sculptures, and buildings, for example. Although there were not yet adequate instruments for exploring the past through the legacies of other times that had already passed (archeology had not yet been developed, and only in the 14th century would epigraphy be considered an auxiliary science of history), the importance of this type of source was already considered. [19]

Among the buildings most sought after by medieval historians were the tombs of important men, for these could reveal information of the most diverse nature, from their genealogy to their biography itself. A clear example of such importance is the monastery of Saint-Denis which gathered the tombs of the kings of the Merovingian and Capetian dynasties respectively. [19]

Forgery

The falsification of documents was a recurring attitude in medieval history and, [5] for a long time, it hurt historians, especially those who did not have a very acute critical sense. [5] However, at the same time that there were historians without this skill, others were already dealing with evaluating and analyzing the sources; After comparing them with other sources, they looked for differences and similarities. [5]

This often led to an overvaluing of the "authority of the source", [20] which was the search for a "guarantor" for the evaluation of a text as a historical source. This happened several times during the Medieval Era and examples of this are the book on the history of Genoa between the years 1100 and 1152, which was elevated to the level of a highly reputable source by the consuls of the city, [20] and the chronicle of Rolandino of Padua, which vested itself with authority only when it was validated by the scholars of the University of Padua. [20]

Another major problem was the influence of copyists who, in numerous historical works, always ended up "adding" some information that was not available in the original text they used. [21] In short, the criterion for the quality of historiographical production was not the truth, [21] but rather the authenticity established by authorities who obeyed a kind of hierarchy. [note 5]

Genres

The moment history manages to gain its autonomy from the other sciences, [22] its genres (known as historical genres) emerge: annals and chronicles are known for providing brief descriptions of events and related facts by year, [22] while history sees style and rhetoric being highly valued (there is still a tendency to look to historians of antiquity such as Suetonius and Salustius). [15] [22] Later, from history, other genres would derive such as providential history (which was guided by theology), [23] scholarly history (used by clerics and chanceries), [23] political history, and "romance" history (which gains readers from social groups other than the clergy, such as the nobility). [23]

There were also a large number of works made to order, [24] which were requested by nobles who wanted to keep their memory alive for posterity. An example of this is the work that appears on the occasion of the death of William the Marshal in 1219, which was commissioned by his son (to keep his father's memory alive). [24] This genre would later also make room for works of genealogy. [24]

Acceptance

The Crusades strongly influenced the "romance" genre of history in ecclesiastic historiography. 1099jerusalem.jpg
The Crusades strongly influenced the "romance" genre of history in ecclesiastic historiography.

During the Medieval Age, ecclesiastic production was well-received and diverse. [22] One of the genres with the greatest popular appeal was the "romance" history of the Crusades, [23] whose books recounted the adventures of the knights of Christianity in the distant lands of the Middle East. However, they were often written with little or even no historical accuracy, which may relativize their use as a source. Among the texts of this kind is the "Song of Antioch." [23]

The mendicant orders were also great recipients and repeaters of ecclesiastic historiography, adapting it according to their needs. [25] The Dominicans focused their production on scholarly manuals and were more concerned with preaching than historical research. [26] The Franciscan order, on the other hand, followed a similar line to the Dominicans and sought only "beautiful stories" for preaching in front of people of "less culture". [26]

Nowadays, the historiographical production of the Medieval Era is often viewed with contempt, [27] and those responsible for this view are the humanists of the Renaissance. [28] This is thought to be because the view held is that, until then, history was a mere "servant of religion" and auxiliary to the Catholic liturgy. [28] One of the main inaccuracies of medieval texts are the illustrations: [29] illustrators and engravers drew biblical characters as clerics and knights of the Medieval Era and thus incurred serious anachronism. [29]

Legacy

Ecclesiastic historiography has a very important legacy for the further development of history as an academic discipline. This importance can be gauged by the great presence of works created within this historiographic movement, such as the Histories of Gregory of Tours (which was a very important source for the understanding of the sixth century in the Frankish Kingdom), [3] the Ecclesiastical History of the English People by Bede and, later, Vincent de Beauvais' Historial Mirror and the Great Chronicles of France. [3] The legacy of ecclesiastic historiography is summed up in the following quote by the French historian Bernard Guenée:

It is during the Middle Ages that the techniques that we are proud to possess today began to be developed. Perhaps we deserve to be branded ungrateful for having allowed our arrogance and ignorance to mercilessly expose the gaps in medieval scholarship. If possibly today's historians are giants, perhaps those of the Middle Ages would have been dwarfs. But today's giants are sitting on the shoulders of yesterday's dwarfs.

See also

Notes

  1. ↑ In The Classical Roots of Modern Historiography, Arnaldo Momigliano compares Philip of Side's work to a "Christian encyclopedia in history format", mainly because of the inclusion of such diverse topics in the same book, but always with a Christianized view of such topics.
  2. ↑ Political history, in particular, continued to be developed continuously and was recognized by all the ecclesiastic historians of late antiquity, including Eusebius of Caesarea himself.
  3. ↑ An exception was the work of Gerard of Wales (Topographia hibernica), which was especially intended to study the customs of the peoples of present-day Ireland.
  4. ↑ Gautier Map considered "modern times" to be the period that could be covered by orality (at most one hundred years), while "ancient times" would be those that comprised all phases before this.
  5. ↑ The scale started with the author himself (if he was better known, the text had more chance of being authentic, if not, then it had less chances), then it went through the approval of princes, which was lower than the approval of kings, who in turn had less authority in approving texts than the Catholic Church, and finally, among the texts approved by the church, the most reputable was the one that was the oldest.

Related Research Articles

<i>The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire</i> 1776–89 book by English historian Edward Gibbon

The History of the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, sometimes shortened to Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, is a six-volume work by the English historian Edward Gibbon. The six volumes cover, from 98 to 1590, the peak of the Roman Empire, the history of early Christianity and its emergence as the Roman state religion, the Fall of the Western Roman Empire, the rise of Genghis Khan and Tamerlane and the fall of Byzantium, as well as discussions on the ruins of Ancient Rome.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chronology</span> Science of arranging events in order of occurrence

Chronology is the science of arranging events in their order of occurrence in time. Consider, for example, the use of a timeline or sequence of events. It is also "the determination of the actual temporal sequence of past events".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Caesarea Maritima</span> Ancient Levantine city and depopulated village site

Caesarea, also Caesarea Maritima, Caesarea Palaestinae or Caesarea Stratonis, was an ancient and medieval port city on the coast of the Eastern Mediterranean, and later a small fishing village. It was the capital of Roman Judaea, Syria Palaestina and Palaestina Prima, successively, for a period of c. 650 years, and a major intellectual hub of the Mediterranean, from the time of Herod I until the Muslim conquest of the Levant. Today, the site is part of the Caesarea National Park, on the western edge of the Sharon plain in Israel.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Antiquarian</span> Specialist or aficionado of antiquities or things of the past

An antiquarian or antiquary is an aficionado or student of antiquities or things of the past. More specifically, the term is used for those who study history with particular attention to ancient artefacts, archaeological and historic sites, or historic archives and manuscripts. The essence of antiquarianism is a focus on the empirical evidence of the past, and is perhaps best encapsulated in the motto adopted by the 18th-century antiquary Sir Richard Colt Hoare, "We speak from facts, not theory."

Timaeus of Tauromenium was an ancient Greek historian. He was widely regarded by ancient authors as the most influential historian between the time of Ephorus and Polybius. In the words of scholar Lionel I. C. Pearson, Timaeus "maintained his position as the standard authority on the history of the Greek West for nearly five centuries."

<i>Historia Augusta</i> Late Roman collection of biographies

The Historia Augusta is a late Roman collection of biographies, written in Latin, of the Roman emperors, their junior colleagues, designated heirs and usurpers from 117 to 284. Supposedly modeled on the similar work of Suetonius, The Twelve Caesars, it presents itself as a compilation of works by six different authors, collectively known as the Scriptores Historiae Augustae, written during the reigns of Diocletian and Constantine I and addressed to those emperors or other important personages in Ancient Rome. The collection, as extant, comprises thirty biographies, most of which contain the life of a single emperor, but some include a group of two or more, grouped together merely because these emperors were either similar or contemporaneous.

Quintus Fabius Pictor was the earliest known Roman historian. His history, written in Greek and now mostly lost besides some surviving fragments, was highly influential on ancient writers and certainly participated in introducing Greek historiographical methods to the Roman world. However, the work was highly partisan towards Rome, blaming the Second Punic War on Carthage and idealizing the Roman Republic as a well-ordered state loyal to its allies. Fabius probably served as praetor, was a member of the Senate, and participated in a delegation sent to the oracle at Delphi in 216 BC. Some scholars consider him one of the earliest annalists, although this conclusion has been criticized.

Angolar Creole is a Portuguese-based creole language of São Tomé and Príncipe, spoken in the southernmost towns of São Tomé Island and sparsely along the coast, especially by Angolar people. It is also called n'golá by its native speakers. It is a creole language with a majority Portuguese lexicon and a heavy substrate of a dialect of Kimbundu, a Bantu language from inland Angola, where many had come from prior to being enslaved. It is rather different from Sãotomense, the other creole language spoken on the island.

Arnaldo Dante Momigliano, KBE, FBA was an Italian historian of classical antiquity, known for his work in historiography, and characterised by Donald Kagan as "the world's leading student of the writing of history in the ancient world". He was a MacArthur Fellow in 1987.

The Eighth Dynasty of ancient Egypt is a poorly known and short-lived line of pharaohs reigning in rapid succession in the early 22nd century BC, likely with their seat of power in Memphis. The Eighth Dynasty held sway at a time referred to as the very end of the Old Kingdom or the beginning of the First Intermediate Period. The power of the pharaohs was waning while that of the provincial governors, known as nomarchs, was increasingly important, the Egyptian state having by then effectively turned into a feudal system. In spite of close relations between the Memphite kings and powerful nomarchs, notably in Coptos, the Eighth Dynasty was eventually overthrown by the nomarchs of Heracleopolis Magna, who founded the Ninth Dynasty. The Eighth Dynasty is sometimes combined with the preceding Seventh Dynasty, owing to the lack of archeological evidence for the latter which may be fictitious.

Publius Nigidius Figulus was a scholar of the Late Roman Republic and one of the praetors for 58 BC. He was a friend of Cicero, to whom he gave his support at the time of the Catilinarian conspiracy. Nigidius sided with the Optimates in the civil war between Julius Caesar and Pompeius Magnus.

Eduard Schwartz was a German classical philologist.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Galician-Portuguese lyric</span> Lyric and poetic movement

In the Middle Ages, the Galician-Portuguese lyric, also known as trovadorismo in Portugal and trobadorismo in Galicia, was a lyric poetic school or movement. All told, there are around 1680 texts in the so-called secular lyric or lírica profana. At the time Galician-Portuguese was the language used in nearly all of Iberia for lyric poetry. From this language derives both modern Galician and Portuguese. The school, which was influenced to some extent by the Occitan troubadours, is first documented at the end of the twelfth century and lasted until the middle of the fourteenth, with its zenith coming in the middle of the thirteenth century, centered on the person of Alfonso X, The Wise King. It is the earliest known poetic movement in Galicia or Portugal and represents not only the beginnings of but one of the high points of poetic history in both countries and in Medieval Europe. Modern Galicia has seen a revival movement called neotrobadorismo.

<i>Ecclesiastical History</i> (Eusebius) 4th-century Christian chronology by Eusebius

The Ecclesiastical History, also known as The History of the Church and Church History, is a 4th-century chronological account of the development of Early Christianity from the 1st century to the 4th century, composed by Eusebius, the bishop of Caesarea. It was written in Koine Greek and survives also in Latin, Syriac, and Armenian manuscripts.

Lionel Gossman was a Scottish-American scholar of French literature. He taught Romance Languages at Johns Hopkins University and Princeton University, and wrote extensively on the history, theory and practice of historiography, and on aspects of German cultural history.

Arnaldo is a given name. Notable people with the name include:

The Historiography of Albania or Albanian historiography refers to the studies, sources, critical methods and interpretations used by scholars to study the history of Albania and Albanians.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Literature of Cape Verde</span>

The Literature of Cape Verde is among the most important in West Africa. It is the second richest in West Africa after Mali and modern-day Mauritania. It is also the richest in the Lusophone portion of Africa. Most works are written in Portuguese, but there are also works in Capeveredean Creole, French, and notably English.

Emilio Gabba was an Italian historian who specialised in Roman history.

<i>Dictionary of Old Tupi</i> Dictionary published in 2013 by Eduardo de Almeida Navarro

The Dicionário de tupi antigo: a língua indígena clássica do Brasil was compiled by the Brazilian lexicographer and philologist Eduardo de Almeida Navarro and published in 2013. The work was conceived with the goal of spreading knowledge of the Tupi language to a broader public.

References

  1. 1 2 3 4 Momigliano, Arnaldo (2004). As Raízes Clássicas da Historiografia Moderna (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 201. ISBN   8574602256.
  2. 1 2 3 4 5 6 LeGoff, Schmitt, Jacques, Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese) (2 ed.). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 526. ISBN   8574601489.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  3. 1 2 3 4 Baschet, Jérôme (2006). A Civilização Feudal. Do Ano 1000 à Colonização da América (in Portuguese). São Paulo: Globo. p. 326. ISBN   8525041394.
  4. 1 2 3 4 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 23. ISBN   8574601640.
  5. 1 2 3 4 LeGoff & Schmitt, Jacques, Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese) (2 ed.). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 529. ISBN   8574601489.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  6. ↑ Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 19. ISBN   8574601640.
  7. ↑ Shahïd, Irfan (1984). Byzantium and the Arabs in the Fourth Century. Dumbarton Oaks. p. 562. ISBN   0884021165.
  8. ↑ Momigliano, Arnaldo (2004). As Raízes Clássicas da Historiografia Moderna (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 197. ISBN   8574602256.
  9. 1 2 3 Momigliano, Arnaldo (2004). As Raízes Clássicas da Historiografia Moderna (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 198. ISBN   8574602256.
  10. 1 2 3 Momigliano, Arnaldo (2004). As Raízes Clássicas da Historiografia Moderna (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 200. ISBN   8574602256.
  11. ↑ Momigliano, Arnaldo (2004). As Raízes Clássicas da Historiografia Moderna (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 205. ISBN   8574602256.
  12. 1 2 LeGoff & Schmitt, Jacques. Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 527. ISBN   8574601489.
  13. ↑ Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 45. ISBN   8574601640.
  14. 1 2 3 LeGoff & Schmitt, Jacques, Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 528. ISBN   8574601489.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  15. 1 2 3 4 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 22. ISBN   8574601640.
  16. ↑ Baschet, Jérôme (2006). A Civilização Feudal. Do Ano 1000 à Colonização da América (in Portuguese). São Paulo: Globo. p. 327. ISBN   8525041394.
  17. 1 2 3 4 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 27. ISBN   8574601640.
  18. ↑ Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 28. ISBN   8574601640.
  19. 1 2 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 26. ISBN   8574601640.
  20. 1 2 3 LeGoff & Schmitt, Jacques, Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 530. ISBN   8574601489.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  21. 1 2 LeGoff & Schmitt, Jacques, Jean-Paul (2006). Dicionário Temático do Ocidente Medieval (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 531.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  22. 1 2 3 4 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 31. ISBN   8574601640.
  23. 1 2 3 4 5 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 33. ISBN   8574601640.
  24. 1 2 3 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 32. ISBN   8574601640.
  25. ↑ Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 40. ISBN   8574601640.
  26. 1 2 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 41. ISBN   8574601640.
  27. ↑ Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 17. ISBN   8574601640.
  28. 1 2 Caire-Jabinet, Marie-Paule (2003). Introdução à Historiografia (in Portuguese). Bauru: EDUSC. p. 18. ISBN   8574601640.
  29. 1 2 Baschet, Jérôme (2006). A Civilização Feudal. Do Ano 1000 à Colonização da América (in Portuguese). São Paulo: Globo. p. 328. ISBN   8525041394.

Bibliography

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.