Trochosuchus

Last updated

Trochosuchus
Temporal range: Middle Permian, Capitanian
O
S
D
C
P
T
J
K
Pg
N
Scientific classification OOjs UI icon edit-ltr.svg
Domain: Eukaryota
Kingdom: Animalia
Phylum: Chordata
Clade: Synapsida
Clade: Therapsida
Clade: Therocephalia
Family: Lycosuchidae
Genus: Trochosuchus
Broom, 1908 Nomen dubium
Species:
T. acutus
Binomial name
Trochosuchus acutus
Broom, 1908 Nomen dubium
(=Lycosuchidae incertae sedis)

Trochosuchus is a dubious genus of therocephalian therapsid from the middle Permian (Capitanian) of South Africa based on a weathered and poorly preserved undiagnostic fossil of a lycosuchid therocephalian. It includes the type and only species, T. acutus. Trochosuchus was named by palaeontologist Robert Broom in 1908 based on its supposedly unique proportions of the simulatenous 'double' functional canines thought to be characteristic of lycosuchids, with the pair in front being noticeably smaller than the second pair behind (compared to roughly equally sized in Lycosuchus ). [1]

Contents

However, later studies have shown that the 'double canines' of lycosuchids represent overlap of alternating functional and replacement canines and not distinct tooth positions. [lower-alpha 1] As such, the variation in size between the front and back canines reflects stages of growth and replacement rather than specific differences. [2] Trochosuchus therefore cannot be distinguished from other lycosuchids (i.e. Lycosuchus and Simorhinella ) by its canines alone, and consequently the genus is now regarded by researchers as a nomen dubium (dubious name) based on Lycosuchidae incertae sedis. [3] [4]

The holotype specimen, SAM-PK-1076, was collected by the Reverend J. H. Whaits at the Rietfontein 56 farm in Prince Albert, South Africa, from deposits of the middle-Permian aged Tapinocephalus Assemblage Zone. [3] It consists of the snout and lower jaws of small, possibly juvenile lycosuchid preserved up the orbits with a preserved snout length of 101 millimetres (4.0 in) that has been partially compressed top-to-bottom. [5] Like other lycosuchids, the snout is low and relatively broad with five incisors in each premaxilla (traits diagnostic of the group) with the characteristic 'double canines' on each side, though the smaller first canine is only about as large as the incisors. Although undiagnostic beyond Lycosuchidae, SAM-PK-1076 is notable amongst lycosuchids as it appears to have the roots of small palatal teeth on the boss of the pterygoid bone, which are absent in other lycosuchid specimens. [3]

In 1936, Broom tentatively referred a second therocephalian specimen collected at the same locality as the holotype to Trochosuchus. [6] However, the specimen only preserved the weathered back third of the skull, lacking the snout, and so cannot be compared with the holotype and is only discernible as a moderately large early therocephalian. [3]

Taxonomy

Although it is a nomen dubium, Trochosuchus has a convoluted taxonomic history, largely due to the instability of early therocephalian systematics during the 20th century. Trochosuchus was originally allied with other lycosuchids, typically either as their own family (i.e. Lycosuchidae) or subsumed together into what is now recognised as Scylacosauridae (such as by Haughton (1924), Boonstra (1934) and Romer (1945)). However, Trochosuchus was also sometimes split away entirely from lycosuchids into other families, namely the Akidnognathidae by Haughton and Brink (1955) (i.e. allied to Akidnognathus and Moschorhinus ) and Alopecodontidae by Romer (1966) and Kitching (1977) (an invalid family today otherwise composed of scylacosaurids). Such referrals were largely based on the size, identification and arrangement of its canines and other teeth. Tatarinov (1974) also separated Trochosuchus from lycosuchids under another taxonomic scheme, but notably retained it with other "primitive" therocephalians under Scylacosauridae in one therocephalian suborder while other lycosuchids were grouped with the "advanced" therocephalians in a different suborder, Whaitsioidea. [3]

Trochosuchus was also notably used as the name-bearer of the lycosuchid group for a time by some researchers, with Romer (1956), Watson and Romer (1956), Lehman (1961), Camp and Allison (1961), Kuhn (1961), Camp, Allison and Nichols (1964), Camp et al. (1968), and Camp et al. (1972) using the name "Trochosuchidae" for this family over Lycosuchidae, despite the latter having priority. [3]

In an unpublished PhD thesis from 1987mo, Juri van den Heever revised the taxonomy and systematics of early therocephalians, establishing the basis of its modern framework. Van den Heever concluded that SAM-PK-1076 was indeed recognisable as a lycosuchid, but that it lacks any further diagnostic features due to its poor preservation and nullification of canine size as a diagnostic trait. As such, he considered the specimen to be Lycosuchidae incertae sedis and therefore that Trochosuchus acutus is a nomen dubium. [3] This view has been upheld by later researchers of lycosuchid taxonomy. [4] [5]

Broom also named a second species of Trochosuchus in 1915, T. major. However, in 1932 he instead referred this species to a different genus also named in 1915, Trochosaurus , synonymising it with its type species (T. intermedius) as the new combination Trochosaurus major. [7] Broom was admittedly uncertain whether the two could be distinguished, and indeed Romer (1956) and Romer & Watson (1956) considered the two to be synonymous with Trochosuchus as the senior synonym. However, like Trochosuchus, Trochosaurus is dubious and based on fossils undiagnostic beyond Lycosuchidae (including T. major) representing Lycosuchidae incertae sedis. [3]

Notes

  1. The same alternating canine replacement pattern occurs in other predatory therapsids, including other therocephalians and gorgonopsians. However, in those forms the replacement grows in after the older worn canine has already fallen out, with only one canine erupted at a time. In lycosuchids, the old canine remains in the jaw as its alternate grows in, and falls out after its own direct replacement is already growing.

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Therocephalia</span> Extinct order of therapsids

Therocephalia is an extinct clade of eutheriodont therapsids from the Permian and Triassic periods. The therocephalians ("beast-heads") are named after their large skulls, which, along with the structure of their teeth, suggest that they were carnivores. Like other non-mammalian synapsids, therocephalians were once described as "mammal-like reptiles". Therocephalia is the group most closely related to the cynodonts, which gave rise to the mammals, and this relationship takes evidence in a variety of skeletal features. Indeed, it had been proposed that cynodonts may have evolved from therocephalians and so that therocephalians as recognised are paraphyletic in relation to cynodonts.

<i>Trochosaurus</i> Extinct genus of therapsids from Permian South Africa

Trochosaurus is a dubious genus of therocephalian therapsid from South Africa based upon specimens of Lycosuchidae. Three species of Trochosaurus have appeared in literature, T. intermedius, T. major, and T. dirus. The genus Trochosaurus and all three species are considered nomen dubia today, while the specimens referred to them are regarded as Lycosuchidae incertae sedis.

<i>Euchambersia</i> Extinct genus of therapsid from Late Permian South Africa

Euchambersia is an extinct genus of therocephalian therapsids that lived during the Late Permian in what is now South Africa and China. The genus contains two species. The type species E. mirabilis was named by paleontologist Robert Broom in 1931 from a skull missing the lower jaw. A second skull, belonging to a probably immature individual, was later described. In 2022, a second species, E. liuyudongi, was named by Jun Liu and Fernando Abdala from a well-preserved skull. It is a member of the family Akidnognathidae, which historically has also been referred by as the synonymous Euchambersiidae.

<i>Bauria</i> Genus of therapsids from the Early Triassic of South Africa

Bauria is an extinct genus of the suborder Therocephalia that existed during the Early and Middle Triassic period, around 246-251 million years ago. It belonged to the family Bauriidae. Bauria was probably a herbivore or omnivore. It lived in South Africa, specifically in the Burgersdorp Formation in South Africa.

<i>Moschorhinus</i> Genus of synapsid from late Permian and early Triassic South Africa

Moschorhinus is an extinct genus of therocephalian synapsid in the family Akidnognathidae with only one species: M. kitchingi, which has been found in the Late Permian to Early Triassic of the South African Karoo Supergroup. It was a large carnivorous therapsid, reaching 1.5 m (4.9 ft) in total body length with the largest skull comparable to that of a lion in size, and had a broad, blunt snout which bore long, straight canines.

<i>Pristerognathus</i> Extinct genus of therapsid from the Middle Permian of South Africa

Pristerognathus is an extinct genus of therocephalian, known from the late Middle Permian (Capitanian) of South Africa. It lends its name to the Pristerognathus Assemblage Zone of the Beaufort Group of South African geological strata. Pristerognathus was a medium-sized therocephalian with a 25 cm (9.8 in) skull and a total length up to 1.5 m.

<i>Lycosuchus</i> Extinct genus of therapsids from the middle Permian of South Africa

Lycosuchus is an extinct genus of carnivorous therocephalians which lived in the Middle Permian 265—260 Ma existing for approximately 5 million years. As a member of the Lycosuchidae, the genus represents one of the earliest diverging therocephalians. The type and only species, L. vanderrieti, is known from a handful of well-preserved specimens featuring the cranium and lower jaw; the holotype US D173 housed at the University of Stellenbosch, South Africa, is a near complete occluded skull. Specimen MB.R. 995, housed at the Museum für Naturkunde Berlin, Germany, consists of a near complete and isolated lower jaw, along with a partial snout and brain case. With the help of μCT data, Pusch et al (2020) described the endocranial anatomy of Lycosuchus vanderrieti.

<i>Theriognathus</i> Extinct genus of therapsids from late Permian South Africa and Tanzania

Theriognathus is an extinct genus of therocephalian therapsid belonging to the family Whaitsiidae, known from fossils from South Africa, Zambia, and Tanzania. Theriognathus has been dated as existing during the Late Permian. Although Theriognathus means mammal jaw, the lower jaw is actually made up of several bones as seen in modern reptiles, in contrast to mammals. Theriognathus displayed many different reptilian and mammalian characteristics. For example, Theriognathus had canine teeth like mammals, and a secondary palate, multiple bones in the mandible, and a typical reptilian jaw joint, all characteristics of reptiles. It is speculated that Theriognathus was either carnivorous or omnivorous based on its teeth, and was suited to hunting small prey in undergrowth. This synapsid adopted a sleek profile of a mammalian predator, with a narrow snout and around 1 meter long. Theriognathus is represented by 56 specimens in the fossil record.

Cerdodontenuidens is an extinct genus of gorgonopsian therapsids. However, some consider this genus to be a nomen dubium. The holotype skull is of a crushed skull of a small therocephalian.

<i>Eriphostoma</i> Extinct genus of therapsids

Eriphostoma is an extinct genus of gorgonopsian therapsids known from the Middle Permian of Tapinocephalus Assemblage Zone, South Africa. It has one known species, Eriphostoma microdon, and was first named by Robert Broom in 1911. It is the oldest known gorgonopsian and among the smallest and most basal members of the clade.

<i>Glanosuchus</i> Extinct genus of therapsids

Glanosuchus is a genus of scylacosaurid therocephalian from the Late Permian of South Africa. The type species G. macrops was named by Robert Broom in 1904. Glanosuchus had a middle ear structure that was intermediate between that of early therapsids and mammals. Ridges in the nasal cavity of Glanosuchus suggest it had an at least partially endothermic metabolism similar to modern mammals.

<i>Scymnosaurus</i> Extinct genus of therapsids from middle Permian South Africa

Scymnosaurus is a dubious genus of therocephalian therapsids based upon various fossils of large early therocephalians. The genus was described by Robert Broom in 1903 with S. ferox, followed by S. watsoni in 1915 and a third, S. major, by Lieuwe Dirk Boonstra in 1954. Each of these species are considered nomen dubia today and based upon specimens belonging to two separate families of therocephalians. S. ferox and S. major represent specimens of Lycosuchidae incertae sedis, while S. watsoni is Scylacosauridae incertae sedis. Broom named a fourth species in 1907 from KwaZulu-Natal, S. warreni, though he later referred it to Moschorhinus as a valid species in 1932 but now is recognised as being synonymous with M. kitchingi.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Lycosuchidae</span> Extinct family of therapsids

Lycosuchidae is an extinct family of therocephalian therapsids from the Middle Permian Beaufort Group of South Africa. It currently contains two monotypic genera, Lycosuchus, represented by L. vanderrieti, which was named by paleontologist Robert Broom in 1903, and Simorhinella, represented by S. baini, which was named by Broom in 1915. Both species are characterized by their large body sizes and short, deep snouts. Two sets of enlarged canine teeth were once regarded as a defining feature of lycosuchids, but recent studies have proposed that the front-most pair are replacements for the ones behind them, which would have eventually fallen out as individuals aged. Lycosuchids are the earliest known therocephalians and are also thought to be the most basal.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scylacosauridae</span> Extinct family of therapsids

Scylacosauridae is an extinct family of therocephalian therapsids. Scylacosaurids lived during the Permian period and were among the most basal therocephalians. The family was named by South African paleontologist Robert Broom in 1903. Scylacosaurids have long snouts and unusual saber-like canine teeth.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bauriidae</span> Extinct family of therapsids

Bauriidae is an extinct family of therocephalian therapsids. Bauriids were the latest-surviving group of therocephalians after the Permian–Triassic extinction event, going extinct in the Middle Triassic. They are among the most advanced eutherocephalians and possess several mammal-like features such as a secondary palate and wide postcanine teeth at the back of the jaws. Unlike other therocephalians, bauriids were herbivorous. They were also smaller than earlier members of the group. Two subfamilies are classified within Bauriidae: Nothogomphodontinae and Bauriinae.

<i>Blattoidealestes</i> Extinct genus of therapsid from Middle-Permian South Africa

Blattoidealestes is an extinct genus of therocephalian therapsid from the Middle Permian of South Africa. The type species Blattoidealestes gracilis was named by South African paleontologist Lieuwe Dirk Boonstra from the Tapinocephalus Assemblage Zone in 1954. Dating back to the Middle Permian, Blattoidealestes is one of the oldest therocephalians. It is similar in appearance to the small therocephalian Perplexisaurus from Russia, and may be closely related.

Silpholestes is an extinct genus of therocephalian therapsids from the Late Permian of South Africa. The type species Silpholestes jackae was named by South African paleontologist Robert Broom in 1948 from the Cistecephalus Assemblage Zone.

Lycideops is an extinct genus of therocephalians from the Late Permian of South Africa. The type species is Lycideops longiceps, named in 1931 by South African paleontologist Robert Broom. Fossils of Lycideops come from the Dicynodon Assemblage Zone of the Beaufort Group. Lycideops is a member of the family Lycideopidae. Like other lycideopids, Lycideops has a long snout.

Simorhinella is an extinct genus of therocephalian therapsids from the Late Permian of South Africa. It is known from a single species, Simorhinella baini, named by South African paleontologist Robert Broom in 1915. Broom named it on the basis of a single fossil collected by the British Museum of Natural History in 1878 that included the skull and jaws forward from the eye sockets. The skull is unusual in that it has an extremely short and deep snout, unlike the longer and lower snouts of most other therocephalians. Because of the skull's distinctiveness, the classification of Simorhinella within Therocephalia is uncertain. However, a 2014 study proposed that it was closely related to the basal therocephalian Lycosuchus, placing it in the family Lycosuchidae.

<i>Ictidosaurus</i> Genus of therapsid from the Middle Permian of South Africa

Ictidosaurus was a therapsid genus found in the Abrahamskraal Formation of South Africa, which lived during the middle Permian period. Fossils of the type species were found in the Tapinocephalus, and the base of the Eodicynodon assembly zones, of the Karoo Basin. Older classifications of the species, along with many other specimens found in the Iziko South African Museum archives, were originally classified within therocephalian family names, in this case the Ictidosauridae, which has been reclassified as belonging to the Scylacosauridae. The type species is I. angusticeps.

References

  1. Broom, R. (1908). "On Some New Therocephalian Reptiles". Annals of the South African Museum. 4 (Pt. 8): 361–367.
  2. Pusch, Luisa C.; Ponstein, Jasper; Kammerer, Christian F.; Fröbisch, Jörg (2020). "Novel Endocranial Data on the Early Therocephalian Lycosuchus vanderrieti Underpin High Character Variability in Early Theriodont Evolution". Frontiers in Ecology and Evolution. 7: 1–27. doi: 10.3389/fevo.2019.00464 .
  3. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Van den Heever, J. (1987). The comparative and functional cranial morphology of the early Therocephalia (Amniota: Therapsida) (Ph.D. thesis). University of Stellenbosch.
  4. 1 2 Wyllie, Alistair (2003). "A review of Robert Broom's therapsid holotypes: have they survived the test of time" (PDF). Palaeontologia africana. 39: 1–19 via CORE.
  5. 1 2 Abdala, F.; Kammerer, C. F.; Day, M. O.; Jirah, S.; Rubidge, B. S. (2014). "Adult morphology of the therocephalian Simorhinella baini from the middle Permian of South Africa and the taxonomy, paleobiogeography, and temporal distribution of the Lycosuchidae". Journal of Paleontology. 88 (6): 1139–1153. doi:10.1666/13-186. ISSN   0022-3360. S2CID   129323281.
  6. Broom, R. (1936). "On the structure of the skull in the mammal-like reptiles of the suborder Therocephalia". Philosphical Transactions of the Royal Society (B). 226 (529): 1–42. doi:10.1098/rstb.1936.0001.
  7. Broom, R. (1932). The Mammal-like Reptiles of South Africa and the Origin of Mammals. London: H.F. & G. Witherby. p. 376.