1904 Wisconsin gubernatorial election

Last updated
1904 Wisconsin gubernatorial election
Flag of Wisconsin (1866-1913).png
  1902 November 8, 1904 1906  
  Congressman Robert La Follette.png George W Peck by Klein & Guttenstein (1).jpg No image.svg
Nominee Robert M. La Follette George Wilbur Peck William A. Arnold
Party Republican Democratic Socialist
Popular vote227,253176,30124,857
Percentage50.55%39.22%5.53%

1904 Wisconsin gubernatorial election results map by county.svg
County results
La Follette :     30–40%     40–50%     50–60%     60–70%     70–80%     80–90%
Peck :     40-50%     50–60%     60–70%

Governor before election

Robert M. La Follette
Republican

Elected Governor

Robert M. La Follette
Republican

The 1904 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 8, 1904.

Contents

Incumbent Republican Governor Robert M. La Follette defeated Democratic nominee George Wilbur Peck and Social-Democratic nominee William A. Arnold with 50.55% of the vote.

Conventions

In the aftermath of the 1902 election, the state legislature enacted the direct primary (subject to a statewide referendum) and La Follette's tax reform bill. The new tax law, which required railroads to pay taxes based on property owned rather than profits, resulted in railroads paying nearly double the amount of taxes they had paid before the enactment of the law. [1] Having accomplished his first two major goals, La Follette next focused on regulating railroad rates, but the railroads prevented passage of his bill in 1903. [2] During this period, La Follette became increasingly convinced of the need for a direct income tax in order to minimize tax avoidance by the wealthy. [3] During his governorship, La Follette appointed African-American William Miller for a position in his office. [4]


The Wisconsin Republican party split in the run up to the election due to the incumbent governor Robert La Follette's embrace of progressive ideas such as a state income tax and greater regulation of the railroads. There were two Republican conventions for the Republican nomination, one for La Follette's and one backed by more conservative elements of the Republican party.

After the legislature adjourned in mid-1903, La Follette began lecturing on the Chautauqua circuit, delivering 57 speeches across the Midwest. [5] He also earned the attention of muckraker journalists like Ray Stannard Baker and Lincoln Steffens, many of whom supported La Follette's progressive agenda. [6] La Follette's continued movement towards progressivism alienated many Republican Party leaders, and La Follette's followers and conservative party leaders held separate conventions in 1904; ultimately, the state Supreme Court declared that La Follette was the Republican Party's 1904 gubernatorial nominee. [7]

General election

Candidates

Major party candidates

Other candidates

Results

In the general election in Wisconsin that year, La Follette won 51 percent of the vote, but he ran far behind Republican President Theodore Roosevelt, who took 63 percent of the Wisconsin's vote in the national election by comparison. In that same election, Wisconsin voters approved the implementation of the direct primary. [11]

1904 Wisconsin gubernatorial election [12] [13] [14] [15]
PartyCandidateVotes%±%
Republican Robert M. La Follette (incumbent) 227,253 50.55%
Democratic George Wilbur Peck 176,30139.22%
Socialist William A. Arnold24,8575.53%
National Republican Edward Scofield 12,1362.70%
Prohibition William H. Clark8,7641.95%
Socialist Labor Charles M. Minkley2490.06%
Scattering100.00%
Majority50,95211.33%
Turnout 449,570
Republican hold Swing
CountyRobert M. La Follette

Republican

George Wilbur Peck

Democratic

William A. Arnold

Socialist

Edward Scofield

National Republican

William H. Clark

Prohibition

Charles M. Minkley

Socialist Labor

ScatteringTotal Votes
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%#
Adams 1,31774.4%36020.3%241.4%301.7%402.3%00.0%00.0%1,771
Ashland 2,92860.9%1,56132.5%1392.9%881.8%861.8%20.0%00.0%4,804
Barron 3,11267.8%1,12424.5%681.5%811.8%2004.4%80.2%00.0%4,593
Bayfield 2,51279.3%49915.8%270.9%501.6%742.3%40.1%00.0%3,166
Brown 5,02754.5%3,69240.0%2112.3%1902.1%1071.2%30.0%00.0%9,230
Buffalo 1,93361.2%1,12735.7%60.2%411.3%511.6%00.0%00.0%3,158
Burnett 1,25688.0%936.5%171.2%191.3%412.9%10.1%00.0%1,427
Calumet 1,43845.1%1,57149.3%782.4%702.2%300.9%00.0%00.0%3,187
Chippewa 3,36259.2%2,06136.3%370.7%1011.8%1152.0%60.1%00.0%5,682
Clark 2,85151.9%2,31542.1%400.7%1202.2%1673.0%20.0%00.0%5,495
Columbia 3,58050.8%3,01142.7%1111.6%1692.4%1752.5%00.0%00.0%7,046
Crawford 1,63843.7%1,99653.3%120.3%551.5%441.2%20.1%00.0%3,747
Dane 9,38853.9%7,26841.7%1540.9%2771.6%3381.9%00.0%10.0%17,426
Dodge 3,03531.5%6,16764.0%530.6%2482.6%1321.4%10.0%00.0%9,636
Door 1,38341.7%1,71651.8%240.7%962.9%952.9%00.0%00.0%3,314
Douglas 4,22167.0%1,42822.7%3866.1%1141.8%1232.0%300.5%00.0%6,302
Dunn 2,88670.6%92522.6%571.4%1112.7%1112.7%00.0%00.0%4,090
Eau Claire 3,23054.6%2,33739.5%1442.4%701.2%1372.3%30.1%00.0%5,921
Florence 30245.3%34351.5%30.5%132.0%50.8%00.0%00.0%666
Fond du Lac 5,27144.1%6,11551.1%820.7%3332.8%1611.3%10.0%00.0%11,963
Forest 90673.1%25120.2%191.5%483.9%151.2%10.1%00.0%1,240
Gates 1,20869.3%43625.0%191.1%362.1%432.5%00.0%00.0%1,742
Grant 4,44049.3%4,17046.3%460.5%1932.1%1611.8%10.0%00.0%9,011
Green 2,34648.1%2,17044.5%972.0%801.6%1873.8%00.0%00.0%4,880
Green Lake 1,61044.9%1,77849.6%250.7%962.7%732.0%00.0%00.0%3,582
Iowa 2,93156.5%2,06639.8%130.3%551.1%1212.3%00.0%00.0%5,186
Iron 89957.6%60538.8%100.6%231.5%231.5%00.0%00.0%1,560
Jackson 2,22866.2%96028.5%240.7%722.1%802.4%00.0%00.0%3,364
Jefferson 2,98238.0%4,47757.1%781.0%1712.2%1361.7%00.0%10.0%7,845
Juneau 2,64256.9%1,80638.9%280.6%1022.2%661.4%00.0%00.0%4,644
Kenosha 2,60847.7%2,27741.7%3786.9%1262.3%601.1%130.2%10.0%5,463
Kewaunee 1,47545.7%1,58649.1%993.1%351.1%351.1%00.0%00.0%3,230
La Crosse 4,28748.1%4,23947.5%830.9%1201.3%1862.1%30.0%10.0%8,919
Lafayette 2,52250.9%2,31046.6%90.2%561.1%611.2%10.0%00.0%4,959
Langlade 1,71353.1%1,41043.7%160.5%511.6%331.0%10.0%00.0%3,224
Lincoln 2,17553.6%1,67541.2%892.2%751.8%461.1%10.0%00.0%4,061
Manitowoc 3,89844.6%3,97745.5%5576.4%2132.4%1001.1%00.0%00.0%8,745
Marathon 4,78249.0%4,55646.7%1311.3%1601.6%1311.3%40.0%00.0%9,764
Marinette 3,12560.3%1,51929.3%1863.6%2094.0%1432.8%30.1%00.0%5,185
Marquette 1,16046.5%1,19247.8%70.3%582.3%753.0%10.0%00.0%2,493
Milwaukee 28,18538.6%23,14331.7%17,39423.8%3,2284.4%9181.3%910.1%00.0%72,959
Monroe 3,14653.2%2,48342.0%260.4%1081.8%1482.5%00.0%00.0%5,911
Oconto 2,56356.9%1,70337.8%431.0%1383.1%541.2%20.0%00.0%4,503
Oneida 1,42461.6%68929.8%1195.1%391.7%361.6%40.2%00.0%2,311
Outagamie 5,04253.4%3,99642.4%740.8%2162.3%1051.1%10.0%00.0%9,434
Ozaukee 1,25839.8%1,74655.2%932.9%371.2%260.8%10.0%00.0%3,161
Pepin 84860.0%49635.1%10.1%433.0%241.7%10.1%00.0%1,413
Pierce 2,90667.6%1,12426.1%210.5%1303.0%1202.8%00.0%00.0%4,301
Polk 2,83280.5%44312.6%681.9%792.2%932.6%30.1%20.1%3,520
Portage 2,93348.8%2,82547.0%300.5%1312.2%861.4%00.0%00.0%6,005
Price 1,81765.6%80228.9%521.9%321.2%642.3%10.0%30.1%2,771
Racine 4,63545.3%3,63935.6%1,23212.0%4644.5%2492.4%130.1%00.0%10,232
Richland 2,07547.3%1,92343.9%240.5%992.3%2626.0%00.0%00.0%4,383
Rock 5,24245.6%4,94043.0%3262.8%6355.5%3403.0%10.0%00.0%11,484
St. Croix 3,22655.5%2,38941.1%611.0%470.8%911.6%10.0%00.0%5,815
Sauk 3,29746.1%3,28045.8%310.4%2283.2%3194.5%00.0%00.0%7,155
Sawyer 73969.7%26424.9%100.9%212.0%252.4%10.1%00.0%1,060
Shawano 3,03359.5%1,83636.0%220.4%951.9%1062.1%20.0%00.0%5,094
Sheboygan 4,93645.1%4,59842.0%7947.3%4233.9%1671.5%180.2%10.0%10,937
Taylor 1,45657.4%96638.1%311.2%491.9%351.4%10.0%00.0%2,538
Trempealeau 3,20267.6%1,29727.4%60.1%851.8%1473.1%00.0%00.0%4,737
Vernon 4,37875.7%1,12619.5%200.3%781.3%1783.1%10.0%00.0%5,781
Vilas 1,21765.2%56630.3%301.6%351.9%181.0%10.1%00.0%1,867
Walworth 3,24648.0%2,94843.6%1041.5%2193.2%2453.6%00.0%00.0%6,762
Washburn 81262.7%39230.2%312.4%372.9%241.9%00.0%00.0%1,296
Washington 1,99940.4%2,71754.9%501.0%1362.8%410.8%20.0%00.0%4,945
Waukesha 4,17949.4%3,76744.5%1932.3%1471.7%1802.1%10.0%00.0%8,467
Waupaca 4,69068.9%1,64324.1%500.7%1822.7%2403.5%20.0%00.0%6,807
Waushara 2,66373.1%75120.6%180.5%1283.5%792.2%20.1%00.0%3,641
Winnebago 5,42243.3%6,13449.0%1951.6%5034.0%2692.1%60.0%00.0%12,529
Wood 3,24553.8%2,50641.6%1212.0%891.5%681.1%10.0%00.0%6,030
Totals227,25350.5%176,30139.2%24,8575.5%12,1362.7%8,7641.9%2490.1%100.0%449,570

Aftermath

During the 1904 campaign, La Follette pledged that he would not resign as governor during his term, but after winning re-election he directed state representative Irvine Lenroot, a close political ally, to secure his election to the United States Senate. [16] Shortly after La Follette delivered the inaugural message of his third term as governor, Lenroot began meeting with other legislators to assure that La Follette would be able to win election to the Senate; at that time, the state legislature elected senators. [17] La Follette was formally nominated by the Republican caucus on January 23, 1905, and the state legislature chose him the following day. [18] La Follette delayed accepting the nomination and continued to serve as governor until December 1905, when he announced his resignation. [19] [20] Throughout 1905, La Follette continued to push his progressive policies, including the state regulation of railroad rates. The state legislature passed a relatively weak regulation bill that La Follette considered vetoing, but he ultimately signed the law. [21] Lieutenant Governor James O. Davidson succeeded La Follette as governor and went on to win re-election in 1906. [22]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Robert M. La Follette</span> American lawyer and politician (1855–1925)

Robert Marion "Fighting Bob" La Follette Sr., was an American lawyer and politician. He represented Wisconsin in both chambers of Congress and served as the governor of Wisconsin from 1901 to 1906. A Republican for most of his life, he ran for president of the United States as the nominee of his own Progressive Party in the 1924 presidential election. Historian John D. Buenker describes La Follette as "the most celebrated figure in Wisconsin history".

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Edward Scofield</span> American politician (1842-1925)

Edward Scofield was an American lumberman and Republican politician. He was the 19th governor of Wisconsin (1897–1901) and served in the Wisconsin State Senate, representing Door, Marinette, and Oconto counties. Earlier in life, during the American Civil War, he served as an officer in the Union Army.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Francis E. McGovern</span> American politician, 22nd Governor of Wisconsin (1866–1946)

Francis Edward McGovern was an American lawyer and politician from Wisconsin. He served as the 22nd Governor of Wisconsin from 1911 to 1915. In 1911 especially he sponsored a major series of progressive achievements through the legislature. Originally a close ally of Senator Robert M. La Follette, the two progressive leaders held an uneasy truce for McGovern's reelection in 1912. The two became bitter enemies in 1913-1916 and McGovern lost his bids for office and retired from politics.

The Progressive Party was a political party created as a vehicle for Robert M. La Follette, Sr. to run for president in the 1924 election. It did not run candidates for other offices, and it disappeared after the election. The party advocated progressive positions such as government ownership of railroads and electric utilities, cheap credit for farmers, the outlawing of child labor, stronger laws to help labor unions, more protection of civil liberties, an end to American imperialism in Latin America, and a referendum before any president could lead the nation into war.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Republican Party of Wisconsin</span> Wisconsin affiliate of the Republican Party

The Republican Party of Wisconsin is a conservative political party in Wisconsin and is the Wisconsin affiliate of the United States Republican Party (GOP). The state party chair is Brian Schimming. The state party is divided into 72 county parties for each of the state's counties, as well as organizations for the state's eight congressional districts.

The Democratic Party of Wisconsin is the affiliate of the Democratic Party in the U.S. state of Wisconsin. It is currently headed by chair Ben Wikler.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1922 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1922 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 7, 1922.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1928 United States presidential election in Michigan</span> Election in Michigan

The 1928 United States presidential election in Michigan took place on November 6, 1928, as part of the 1928 United States presidential election. Voters chose 15 representatives, or electors, to the Electoral College, who voted for president and vice president.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1920 Illinois gubernatorial election</span> 1920 election for governor of Illinois

The 1920 Illinois gubernatorial election was held on November 2, 1920.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1936 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1936 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 3, 1936.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1932 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1932 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 8, 1932. Incumbent Republican Governor Philip La Follette was defeated in the Republican primary, and in the midst of the Great Depression and nationwide voter dissatisfaction with the Republican Party, Democratic nominee Albert G. Schmedeman defeated Republican nominee Walter J. Kohler Sr. and Socialist nominee Frank Metcalfe with 52.48% of the vote. Schmedeman became the first Democrat to win a gubernatorial election in Wisconsin since George Wilbur Peck in 1892. 2 years later, in 1934, La Follette would run for governor again and defeated Schmedeman, this time running with the Progressive Party.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1934 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1934 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1934.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1888 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span>

The 1888 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1888.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1894 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1894 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1894.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1900 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> 1900 Wisconsin election

The 1900 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1900.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1902 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1902 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 4, 1902.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1906 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1906 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 6, 1906.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1910 Wisconsin gubernatorial election</span> Election

The 1910 Wisconsin gubernatorial election was held on November 8, 1910.

Theodore C. Froemming was an American building contractor and Republican politician from Milwaukee, Wisconsin. He represented northern Milwaukee County in the Wisconsin State Senate during the 1905 and 1907 sessions.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">47th Wisconsin Legislature</span> Wisconsin legislative term for 1905–1906

The Forty-Seventh Wisconsin Legislature convened from January 11, 1905, to June 21, 1905, in regular session, and re-convened for a special session from December 4, 1905, through December 19, 1905. During this term, legislative business was largely held in the north wing of the Wisconsin State Capitol, which was the only part of the capitol to remain intact after the 1904 fire.

References

    • Thelen, David P. (1976). Robert M. La Follette and the Insurgent Spirit. Boston: Little, Brown. ISBN   978-0-316-83927-3. OL   5198113M., pp. 29, 39.
  1. Thelen (1976), pp. 39–40.
  2. Thelen (1976), p. 47.
  3. La Follette and the Negro; A Consistent Record of 35 Years, From 1889 to 1924
  4. Thelen (1976), p. 41.
  5. Thelen (1976), pp. 43–44.
  6. Thelen (1976), pp. 42–44.
  7. "A Stunner". Wausau pilot. Wausau, Wis. October 11, 1904. p. 4. Retrieved 6 August 2021.
  8. "Doings in Wisconsin". The Wisconsin tobacco reporter. Edgerton, Wis. October 28, 1904. p. 6. Retrieved 6 August 2021.
  9. "Arnold heads ticket". The Manitowoc pilot. Manitowoc, Wis. September 8, 1904. p. 2. Retrieved 6 August 2021.
  10. Thelen (1976), pp. 44–45.
  11. Congressional Quarterly 1998, p. 87.
  12. "WI Governor, 1904". Our Campaigns. Retrieved 6 August 2021.
  13. Wisconsin Blue Book 1905, pp. 366.
  14. Glashan 1979, pp. 340–341.
  15. Margulies, Herbert F. (1976). "Robert M. La Follette Goes to the Senate, 1905". The Wisconsin Magazine of History. 59 (3): 214–225. JSTOR   4635046., pp. 214–217.
  16. Margulies (1976), pp. 218–219.
  17. Margulies (1976), pp. 220–221.
  18. Margulies (1976), pp. 221–225.
  19. Encyclopædia Britannica (1922)
  20. Thelen (1976), pp. 45–46.
  21. Margulies (1976), pp. 223–225.

Bibliography