1924 United States Senate election in Iowa

Last updated

1924 United States Senate election in Iowa
Flag of Iowa (xrmap collection).svg
  1922 (special) November 4, 1924 1930  
  Smith Wildman Brookhart.jpg Daniel Steck.jpg
Nominee Smith W. Brookhart Daniel F. Steck
Party Republican Democratic
Alliance Progressive
Popular vote447,706446,951
Percentage49.95%49.87%

1924 United States Senate election in Iowa results map by county.svg
1924 United States Senate election in Iowa by Congressional District.svg
Brookhart:     50–60%     60–70%     70–80%
Steck:     50–60%     60–70%

U.S. senator before election

Smith W. Brookhart
Republican

Elected U.S. Senator

Smith W. Brookhart*
Republican

Republican primary results by county
.mw-parser-output .legend{page-break-inside:avoid;break-inside:avoid-column}.mw-parser-output .legend-color{display:inline-block;min-width:1.25em;height:1.25em;line-height:1.25;margin:1px 0;text-align:center;border:1px solid black;background-color:transparent;color:black}.mw-parser-output .legend-text{}
Brookhart
50-60%
60-70%
70-80%
Sweet
50-60%
60-70%
70-80%
80-90% 1924 United States Senate Republican primary election in Iowa results map by county.svg
Republican primary results by county
  Brookhart
  •   50–60%
  •   60–70%
  •   70–80%
  Sweet
  •   50-60%
  •   60–70%
  •   70–80%
  •   80–90%

The 1924 United States Senate election in Iowa took place on November 4, 1924. Incumbent Republican Senator Smith W. Brookhart ran for re-election to a full term in office against Democrat Daniel F. Steck.

Contents

In the initial vote, Brookhart was certified as the victor over Steck. However, Steck became the first person to successfully challenge a popular election to the Senate in 1926, when the Senate voted to remove Brookhart from office and seat Steck in his place.

As of 2023, this remains the only instance in which a Senator was removed and replaced by his colleagues after he had already been seated for the term.[ original research? ]

Republican primary

Candidates

Results

1924 Republican U.S. Senate primary [1]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Republican Smith W. Brookhart (incumbent) 199,828 55.01%
Republican Burton E. Sweet 163,41344.99%
Total votes363,241 100.00%

Democratic primary

Candidates

Results

1924 Democratic U.S. Senate primary [2]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic Daniel F. Steck 21,318 38.98%
Democratic John D. Denison19,73836.09%
Democratic Charles R. Keyes13,63924.94%
Total votes54,695 100.00%

General election

Campaign

Brookhart, though nominally a Republican, had alienated most of the national and state party establishment by 1924. As early as 1920, he had rankled senior Republicans with his courting of blue-collar union voters and his primary challenge to senior Senator Albert B. Cummins. [3] In 1924, he demanded the withdrawal of vice presidential nominee Charles Dawes [ citation needed ] and declined to support President Calvin Coolidge for re-election, though he did not outright endorse Progressive Robert M. La Follette. [4]

During the campaign, the Republican State Central Committee withdrew support from Brookhart and one Republican organization went so far as to distribute sample ballots showing a 'x' in the Republican column with another 'x' next to Steck's name. [4]

By October, all but one of the state's Republican daily newspapers had endorsed Steck. [5]

Results

On the day of the election, some newspapers reported that Steck had won. [6] However, two days later, rural districts gave Brookhart a small lead. [7] His victory was certified and he was seated for a full term as Senator.

1924 U.S. Senate election in Iowa [8] [9]
PartyCandidateVotes%±%
Republican Smith W. Brookhart (incumbent) 447,706 49.95% Decrease2.svg13.16
Democratic Daniel F. Steck 446,95149.87%Increase2.svg12.98
Independent Republican Luther Brewer1,1240.13%N/A
Independent L.E. Eickelberg5350.06%N/A
Total votes896,316 100.00%

Aftermath and reversal

After the election, the Senate Republicans retaliated by stripping Brookhart, LaFollette, and two other progressive Republicans of their committee appointments and excluding them from the party conference. [4]

Challenges

In January, Steck served notice of his intention to challenge Brookhart's inauguration for the new term on the grounds of election fraud. The Iowa Republican Party also challenged Brookhart's election on the grounds that he was not a Republican. [4]

Brookhart was sworn into office on March 4, 1925, without incident. [10] [4] On March 10, the Senate referred both challenges to the Committee on Privileges and Elections. [4]

Steck's challenge alleged that thousands of ballots were unlawfully counted for Brookhart while many of his own were discarded or altered. [4]

The Iowa Republican challenge alleged that Brookhart had fraudulently represented himself as a party member until the filing deadline, and then toured the state supporting the principles and candidates of the Progressive Party. The state committee argued that Republicans had in good faith voted for a person they assumed to be a regular party member, and that Brookhart had therefore committed election fraud. [4]

Investigation and recount

A subcommittee of two Republicans and two Democrats commenced the investigation of the case on July 20, 1925. By agreement of Brookhart and Steck, all of the more than 900,000 ballots were transported from Iowa to Washington for a recount. [4]

A number of disputed ballots had evidently attempted to replicate local newspaper endorsements for Steck by drawing an arrow pointing to the box marked for Steck; these ballots had been excluded from the original count under an Iowa law banning extraneous markings but were counted by the subcommittee on the grounds that it was clear the voter had meant. [4] Some ballots arrived in Washington with broken seals and there were discrepancies between the voter rolls and the number of ballots received. [4]

On March 29, 1926, the committee issued its report finding that Steck had received a plurality of 1,420 votes and should be seated. In a minority report, Senator Hubert D. Stephens protested that some ballots had not been properly examined and secured, that 3,500 fewer ballots were received than cast, and that the majority did not count 1,300 properly marked straight Republican ballots for Brookhart. [4]

Senate debate and vote

In the debate before the whole Senate, speeches focused on the conflict between Iowa state election law and the federal recount. Brookhart's supporters maintained that there was no precedent for overruling state election laws in reviewing contested elections. [4]

On April 12, the Senate voted 45 to 41 to unseat Brookhart and seat Steck.

Vote to adopt the majority report [11]
April 12, 1926PartyTotal votes
Democratic Farmer-Labor Republican
Yea2901645
Nay913141
Not Voting10910
Roll call vote on the report
SenatorPartyStateVote
Henry F. Ashurst D Arizona Nay
Thomas Bayard D Delaware Yea
Hiram Bingham III R Connecticut Nay
Cole Blease D South Carolina Nay
William Borah R Idaho Nay
Sam G. Bratton D New Mexico Yea
Smith W. Brookhart R Iowa Not Voting
Edwin S. Broussard D Louisiana Yea
William Cabell Bruce D Maryland Yea
William M. Butler R Massachusetts Yea
Ralph H. Cameron R Arizona Nay
Arthur Capper R Kansas Nay
Thaddeus H. Caraway D Arkansas Yea
Royal S. Copeland D New York Yea
James J. Couzens R Michigan Nay
Albert B. Cummins R Iowa Not Voting
Charles Curtis R Kansas Nay
Porter H. Dale R Vermont Yea
Charles S. Deneen R Illinois Yea
Clarence Dill D Washington Nay
T. Coleman du Pont R Delaware Not Voting [lower-alpha 1]
Walter Evans Edge R New Jersey Nay
Edward I. Edwards D New Jersey Yea
Richard P. Ernst R Kentucky Yea
Bert Fernald R Maine Nay
Woodbridge N. Ferris D Michigan Nay
Simeon D. Fess R Ohio Not Voting [lower-alpha 2]
Duncan U. Fletcher D Florida Yea
Lynn Frazier R North Dakota Nay
Walter F. George D Georgia Yea
Peter G. Gerry D Rhode Island Yea
Carter Glass D Virginia Yea
Guy D. Goff R West Virginia Yea
Frank R. Gooding R Idaho Nay
Frank L. Greene R Vermont Yea
Frederick Hale R Maine Nay
John W. Harreld R Oklahoma Yea
William J. Harris D Georgia Yea
Pat Harrison D Mississippi Yea
J. Thomas Heflin D Alabama Yea
Robert B. Howell R Nebraska Nay
Hiram Johnson R California Nay
Andrieus A. Jones D New Mexico Yea
Wesley L. Jones R Washington Nay
John B. Kendrick D Wyoming Yea
Henry W. Keyes R New Hampshire Yea
William H. King D Utah Yea
Irvine Lenroot R Wisconsin Nay
Earle B. Mayfield D Texas Yea
Kenneth McKellar D Tennessee Yea
William B. McKinley R Illinois Not Voting [lower-alpha 3]
George P. McLean R Connecticut Yea
William H. McMaster R South Dakota Nay
Charles L. McNary R Oregon Yea
Rice W. Means R Colorado Not Voting [lower-alpha 4]
Jesse H. Metcalf R Rhode Island Nay
George H. Moses R New Hampshire Nay
Matthew M. Neely D West Virginia Yea
Peter Norbeck R South Dakota Nay
George W. Norris R Nebraska Nay
Gerald Nye R North Dakota Nay
Tasker Oddie R Nevada Nay
Lee S. Overman D North Carolina Yea
George W. Pepper R Pennsylvania Nay
Lawrence C. Phipps R Colorado Yea
William B. Pine R Oklahoma Nay
Key Pittman D Nevada Yea
Joseph E. Ransdell D Louisiana Nay
David A. Reed R Pennsylvania Nay
James A. Reed D Missouri Nay
Joseph T. Robinson D Arkansas Yea
Arthur R. Robinson R Indiana Yea
Frederic M. Sackett R Kentucky Yea
Thomas D. Schall R Minnesota Not Voting [lower-alpha 5]
Morris Sheppard D Texas Yea
Henrik Shipstead F-L Minnesota Nay
Samuel M. Shortridge R California Not Voting [lower-alpha 6]
Furnifold M. Simmons D North Carolina Yea
Ellison D. Smith D South Carolina Yea
Reed Smoot R Utah Nay
Robert N. Stanfield R Oregon Nay
Hubert D. Stephens D Mississippi Nay
Claude A. Swanson D Virginia Yea
Park Trammell D Florida Yea
Lawrence Tyson D Tennessee Yea
Oscar Underwood D Alabama Not Voting [lower-alpha 7]
James W. Wadsworth R New York Not Voting [lower-alpha 8]
Thomas J. Walsh D Montana Nay
Francis E. Warren R Wyoming Yea
James E. Watson R Indiana Yea
Ovington Weller R Maryland Yea
Burton K. Wheeler D Montana Nay
George Howard Williams R Missouri Nay
Frank B. Willis R Ohio Nay
  1. Supported seating Steck. Paired with Shortridge.
  2. Opposed seating Steck. Paired with McKinley.
  3. Supported seating Steck. Paired with Fess.
  4. Supported seating Steck. Paired with Schall.
  5. Opposed seating Steck. Paired with Means.
  6. Opposed seating Steck. Paired with du Pont.
  7. Favored seating Steck. Paired with Wadsworth.
  8. Opposed seating Steck. Paired with Underwood.

Aftermath

Steck became the first Democrat to represent Iowa in the Senate since 1859. He served out the remainder of that term which ultimately became his. [4] He was soundly defeated for re-election in 1930, the only incumbent Democrat in the country to lose in that cycle. Though they gained eight seats nationwide, Steck's loss cost Democrats control of the Senate.[ citation needed ]

Brookhart ran for Senate again in 1926 and unseated Senator Cummins, who died shortly after the primary. He served until 1933, [4] when he was defeated by Henry Field in the Republican primary. Brookhart ran in the 1932 general election as a Progressive, but finished a distant third behind Field and the Democratic victor, Richard L. Murphy.[ citation needed ]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">William B. Allison</span> American politician (1829–1908)

William Boyd Allison was an American politician. An early leader of the Iowa Republican Party, he represented northeastern Iowa in the United States House of Representatives before representing his state in the United States Senate. By the 1890s, Allison had become one of the "big four" key Republicans who largely controlled the Senate, along with Orville H. Platt of Connecticut, John Coit Spooner of Wisconsin and Nelson W. Aldrich of Rhode Island.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Daniel F. Steck</span> American politician

Daniel Frederic Steck, was the only Iowa Democrat in the United States Senate between the American Civil War and the Great Depression. He was sworn in as senator only after an extraordinary election challenge, in which his apparent defeat at the polls by a Progressive Party ally running as a Republican was reversed by a Republican-controlled U.S. Senate over seventeen months later.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Smith W. Brookhart</span> American politician

Smith Wildman Brookhart, was twice elected as a Republican to represent Iowa in the United States Senate. He was considered an "insurgent" within the Republican Party. His criticisms of the Harding and the Coolidge administrations and of business interests alienated others in the Republican caucus and led to his ouster from the Senate over an election challenge.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Albert B. Cummins</span> Politician, governor, and senator from Iowa

Albert Baird Cummins was an American lawyer and politician. He was the 18th governor of Iowa, elected to three consecutive terms and U.S. senator for Iowa, serving for 18 years. Cummins was a leader of the Progressive movement in Washington and Iowa. He fought to break up monopolies. Cummins' successes included establishing the direct primary to allow voters to select candidates instead of bosses; outlawing free railroad passes for politicians; imposing a two-cent street railway maximum fare; and abolishing corporate campaign contributions. He tried, with less success, to lower the high protective tariff in Washington.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1990 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1990 United States Senate elections were held on Tuesday, November 6, 1990, with the 33 seats of Class 2 contested in regular elections. Special elections were also held to fill vacancies. The Democratic Party increased its majority with a net gain of one seat from the Republican Party. The election cycle took place in the middle of President George H. W. Bush's term, and, as with most other midterm elections, the party not holding the presidency gained seats in Congress.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1986 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1986 United States Senate elections were elections for the United States Senate. Held on November 4, in the middle of Ronald Reagan's second presidential term, the 34 seats of Class 3 were contested in regular elections. The Republicans had to defend an unusually large number of freshman Senate incumbents who had been elected on President Ronald Reagan's coattails in 1980. Democrats won a net of eight seats, defeating seven freshman incumbents, picking up two Republican-held open seats, and regaining control of the Senate for the first time since January 1981. This remains the most recent midterm election cycle in which the sitting president's party suffered net losses while still flipping a Senate seat.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1954 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1954 United States Senate elections was a midterm election in the first term of Dwight D. Eisenhower's presidency. The 32 Senate seats of Class 2 were contested in regular elections, and six special elections were held to fill vacancies. Eisenhower's Republican party lost a net of two seats to the Democratic opposition. This small change was just enough to give Democrats control of the chamber with the support of an Independent who agreed to caucus with them, he later officially joined the party in April 1955.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1926 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1926 United States Senate elections were elections for the United States Senate that occurred in the middle of Republican President Calvin Coolidge's second term. The 32 seats of Class 3 were contested in regular elections, and special elections were held to fill vacancies. The Republican majority was reduced by seven seats.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1924 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1924 United States Senate elections were elections for the United States Senate which coincided with the election of Republican President Calvin Coolidge to a full term. The 32 seats of Class 2 were contested in regular elections, and special elections were held to fill vacancies. The strong economy and Coolidge's popularity helped Republican candidates increase their majority by three. Republicans would gain a further two seats through mid-term vacancies bringing their seat share to 56-39-1.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1912–13 United States Senate elections</span>

The 1912–13 United States Senate elections were held on various dates in various states. They were the last U.S. Senate elections before the ratification of the Seventeenth Amendment in 1913, establishing direct elections for all Senate seats. Senators had been primarily chosen by state legislatures. Senators were elected over a wide range of time throughout 1912 and 1913, and a seat may have been filled months late or remained vacant due to legislative deadlock. Some states elected their senators directly even before passage of Seventeenth Amendment. Oregon pioneered direct election and experimented with different measures over several years until it succeeded in 1907. Soon after, Nebraska followed suit and laid the foundation for other states to adopt measures reflecting the people's will. By 1912, as many as 29 states elected senators either as nominees of their party's primary or in conjunction with a general election.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">David W. Stewart</span> American politician

David Wallace Stewart served as a United States senator from Iowa from August 7, 1926, until March 3, 1927, serving out the unexpired term of a senator who died soon after he was defeated for re-election in a Republican primary.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">L. J. Dickinson</span> American politician

Lester Jesse Dickinson was a Republican United States Representative and Senator from Iowa. He was, in the words of Time magazine, "a big, friendly, white-thatched Iowa lawyer." In early 1936, he dreamed of winning the presidency. However, the only race he would enter that year would be for his own seat in the Senate which he lost.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Pat Grassley</span> American politician

Patrick Grassley is the Iowa State Representative from the 57th District. A Republican, Grassley has served in the Iowa House of Representatives since 2007, and as speaker of the chamber since 2020. Grassley is the grandson of U.S. Senator Chuck Grassley.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Burton E. Sweet</span> American politician

Burton Erwin Sweet was a four-term Republican U.S. Representative from Iowa's 3rd congressional district, then a wide but short chain of counties in north-central and northeastern Iowa, in the shape of a monkey wrench.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Charles E. Pickett</span> American politician (1866–1930)

Charles Edgar Pickett was a two-term Republican U.S. Representative from Iowa's 3rd congressional district.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Claude R. Porter</span> American politician

Claude Rodman Porter was an American politician and lawyer. He served in both chambers of the Iowa General Assembly and as a United States Attorney, and was a perennial Democratic Party runner-up to Republican victors in three races for governor of Iowa and six races for U.S. senator. In an era in which the Republican Party was so dominant in Iowa that Senator Jonathan P. Dolliver remarked that "Iowa will go Democratic when Hell goes Methodist," Porter twice came closer to winning the governorship than all but one other Democratic candidate of that era. He later served as a member of the U.S. Interstate Commerce Commission for eighteen years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1932 United States Senate election in Iowa</span>

The 1932 United States Senate election in Iowa took place on November 8, 1932. Incumbent Republican Senator Smith Brookhart, a controversial progressive figure within the conservative Iowa Republican Party, was defeated in the June Republican primary by Henry A. Field. Field was in turn defeated in the general election by Democrat Louis Murphy. Brookhart also entered the general election as the candidate of the Progressive Party but finished a distant third.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1922 United States Senate special election in Iowa</span>

The 1922 United States Senate special election in Iowa took place on November 7, 1922. Republican Smith W. Brookhart was elected to complete the unexpired term of William S. Kenyon, defeating Democrat Clyde Herring.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1930 United States Senate election in Iowa</span>

The 1930 United States Senate election in Iowa took place on November 4, 1930. Incumbent Democratic Senator Daniel F. Steck ran for re-election to a full term in office, but was defeated by U.S. Representative Lester J. Dickinson.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1966 United States Senate election in Iowa</span>

The 1966 United States Senate election in Iowa took place on November 8, 1966. Incumbent Republican Senator Jack Miller was re-elected to a second term in office over Democrat E.B. Smith.

References

  1. "Our Campaigns - IA US Senate Race - R Primary". www.ourcampaigns.com.
  2. "Our Campaigns - IA US Senate Race - D Primary". www.ourcampaigns.com.
  3. "Cummins Seems Choice of Black Hawk Co. Voters". Waterloo Evening Courier. June 4, 1920. p. 1.
  4. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 "The Election Case of Daniel F. Steck v. Smith W. Brookhart of Iowa (1926)" . Retrieved March 11, 2021.
  5. "Day's Editorials". The Des Moines Capital. October 19, 1924. p. 4., reprinted from Marshalltown Times-Republican.
  6. "Steck Defeats Brookhart by Margin of 5,000". Waterloo Evening Courier. November 5, 1924. p. 1.
  7. "Brookhart Takes Lead on Recheck of Ballots". Waterloo Evening Courier. November 6, 1924. p. 1.
  8. "Our Campaigns - IA US Senate Race - Nov 04, 1924". www.ourcampaigns.com.
  9. Clerk of the United States House of Representatives (1925). "Statistics of the Congressional and Presidential Election of November 4, 1924" (PDF). U.S. Government Printing Office.
  10. "Control of the Senate in the 70th Congress". CQ Researcher. Retrieved September 18, 2018.
  11. "Senate Debate on the Brookhart-Steck Contest". Congressional Record . LXVII (7): 7301.

Further reading