Appropriation (art)

Last updated

In art, appropriation is the use of pre-existing objects or images with little or no transformation applied to them. [1] The use of appropriation has played a significant role in the history of the arts (literary, visual, musical and performing arts). In the visual arts, "to appropriate" means to properly adopt, borrow, recycle or sample aspects (or the entire form) of human-made visual culture. Notable in this respect are the readymades of Marcel Duchamp.

Contents

Inherent in the understanding of appropriation is the concept that the new work recontextualizes whatever it borrows to create the new work. In most cases, the original "thing" remains accessible as the original, without change.

Definition

Appropriation, similar to found object art is "as an artistic strategy, the intentional borrowing, copying, and alteration of preexisting images, objects, and ideas". [2] It has also been defined as "the taking over, into a work of art, of a real object or even an existing work of art." [3] The Tate Gallery traces the practice back to Cubism and Dadaism, and continuing into 1940s Surrealism and 1950s Pop art. It returned to prominence in the 1980s with the Neo-conceptual art and Neo-Geo artists, [3] and is now common practice amongst contemporary artists like Richard Prince, Sherrie Levine, and Jeff Koons. [4]

History

Marcel Duchamp Fountain, 1917, photograph by Alfred Stieglitz at 291 (art gallery) following the 1917 Society of Independent Artists exhibit, with entry tag visible. The backdrop is The Warriors by Marsden Hartley. Marcel Duchamp, 1917, Fountain, photograph by Alfred Stieglitz.jpg
Marcel Duchamp Fountain , 1917, photograph by Alfred Stieglitz at 291 (art gallery) following the 1917 Society of Independent Artists exhibit, with entry tag visible. The backdrop is The Warriors by Marsden Hartley.

19th century

Many artists made references to works by previous artists or themes.

In 1856 Ingres painted the portrait of Madame Moitessier. The unusual pose is known to have been inspired by the famous ancient Roman wall painting Herakles Finding His Son Telephas. In doing so, the artist created a link between his model and an Olympian goddess. [6]

Edouard Manet painted Olympia in 1865, inspired by Titian's Venus of Urbino . His painting Le Déjeuner sur l'herbe was also inspired by the work of the Old Masters; specifically, its composition is based on a detail of Marcantonio Raimondi's The Judgement of Paris (1515). [7]

Gustave Courbet is believed to have seen the famous color woodcut The Great Wave off Kanagawa by Japanese artist Katsushika Hokusai before painting a series of the Atlantic Ocean during the summer of 1869. [8]

Vincent van Gogh can be named with the examples of the paintings he did inspired by Jean Francois Millet, Delacroix, or the Japanese prints he had in his collection. [9] In 1889, Van Gogh created 20 painted copies inspired by Millet black-and-white prints. He enlarged the compositions of the prints and then painted them in colour according to his own imagination. Vincent wrote in his letters that he had set out to "translate them into another language". He said that it was not simply copying: if a performer "plays some Beethoven he'll add his personal interpretation to it… it isn't a hard and fast rule that only the composer plays his own compositions". [10] More examples can be found on Copies by Vincent van Gogh.

Claude Monet, a collector of Japanese prints, created several works inspired by these such as The Garden at Sainte-Adresse, 1867 inspired by Fuji from the Platform of Sasayedo by Katsushika Hokusai ; The Water Lily Pond series Under Mannen Bridge at Fukagawa, 1830-1831 by Hokusai or La Japonaise, 1876 likely inspired by Kitagawa Tsukimaro Geisha, a pair of hanging scroll paintings, 1820-1829. [11] [12] [13]

First half of the 20th century

In the early twentieth century Pablo Picasso and Georges Braque appropriated objects from a non-art context into their work. In 1912, Picasso pasted a piece of oil cloth onto the canvas. [14] Subsequent compositions, such as Guitar, Newspaper, Glass and Bottle (1913) in which Picasso used newspaper clippings to create forms, is early collage that became categorized as part of synthetic cubism . The two artists incorporated aspects of the "real world" into their canvases, opening up discussion of signification and artistic representation.

Marcel Duchamp in 1915 introduced the concept of the readymade, in which "industrially produced utilitarian objects...achieve the status of art merely through the process of selection and presentation." [15] Duchamp explored this notion as early as 1913 when he mounted a stool with a bicycle wheel and again in 1915 when he purchased a snow shovel and inscribed it "in advance of the broken arm, Marcel Duchamp." [16] [17] In 1917, Duchamp organized the submission of a readymade into the Society of Independent Artists exhibition under the pseudonym, R. Mutt. [18] Entitled Fountain , it consisted of a porcelain urinal that was propped atop a pedestal and signed "R. Mutt 1917". The work posed a direct challenge, starkly juxtaposing to traditional perceptions of fine art, ownership, originality and plagiarism, and was subsequently rejected by the exhibition committee. [19] The New York Dada magazine The Blind Man defended Fountain, claiming "whether Mr. Mutt with his own hands made the fountain or not has no importance. He CHOSE it. [20] He took an ordinary article of life, placed it so that its useful significance disappeared under the new title and point of view—and created a new thought for that object." [19]

The Dada movement continued to play with the appropriation of everyday objects and their combination in collage. Dada works featured deliberate irrationality and the rejection of the prevailing standards of art. Kurt Schwitters shows a similar sensibility in his "merz" works. He constructed parts of these from found objects, [21] and they took the form of large gesamtkunstwerk constructions that are now called installations.

During his Nice Period (1908–1913), Henri Matisse painted several paintings of odalisques, inspired by Delacroix Women of Algiers . [22] [23] [24]

The Surrealists, coming after the Dada movement, also incorporated the use of 'found objects', such as Méret Oppenheim's Object (Luncheon in Fur) (1936) or Salvador Dalí's Lobster Telephone (1936). These found objects took on new meaning when combined with other unlikely and unsettling objects.

1950–1960: Pop art and realism

In the 1950s, Robert Rauschenberg created what he called Combine Paintings, combining ready-made objects, such as car tires or beds, with painting, silk-screens, collage, and photography. Similarly, Jasper Johns incorporated found object imagery into his work, such as in his White Flag . In 1958 Bruce Conner produced the influential A Movie in which he recombined existing film clips.

In the early 1960s The Fluxus art movement also utilized appropriation: [25] its members blended different artistic disciplines including visual art, experimental music, and literature. Throughout the 1960s and 1970s they staged Happening Events from found objects and produced sculptural works featuring unconventional found objects and materials. Also in the early 1960s artists such as Claes Oldenburg and Andy Warhol appropriated images from commercial art and popular culture as well as the techniques of these industries with for example Warhol's Green Coca-Cola Bottles painting of Coca-Cola bottles. [26] Called Pop Artists, they saw mass popular culture as the main vernacular in culture. These artists fully engaged with the ephemera produced from this mass-produced culture while distancing themselves from the evident work of an artist's hand. Roy Lichtenstein became known for appropriating pictures from comics books with paintings such as Masterpiece (1962) or Drowning Girl (1963) and from famous artists such as Picasso or Matisse. [27] Elaine Sturtevant (also known simply as Sturtevant), on the other hand, created replicas of famous works by her contemporaries. Artists she 'copycatted' included Warhol, Jasper Johns, Joseph Beuys, Duchamp, James Rosenquist, Roy Lichtenstein, and more. While not exclusively reproducing Pop Art, that was a significant focus of her practice. [28] She replicated Andy Warhol's Flowers in 1965 at the Bianchini Gallery in New York City, for example. [29]

In France in the 60s, a group of artists called the New Realists used banal objects in their art, such as the sculptor Cesar [30] who compressed cars to create monumental sculptures or the artist Arman [31] who included everyday machine-made objects—ranging from buttons and spoons to automobiles and boxes filled with trash. The German artists Sigmar Polke and his friend Gerhard Richter, who defined the term Capitalist Realism, offered an ironic critique of consumerism in post-war Germany. They used pre-existing photographs and transformed them into paintings. Polke's best-known works were his collages of imagery from pop culture and advertising, like his "Supermarkets" scenes of super heros shopping at a grocery store. [32]

1970–1980: The Picture Generation and Neo Pop

Richard Prince, Covering Hannah (1987 Buick Grand National) Richard Prince (Fondation Francois Pinault, Venise) (3739876645).jpg
Richard Prince, Covering Hannah (1987 Buick Grand National)
Three Ball Total Equilibrium Tank (1983) by Jeff Koons, Tate Liverpool Three Ball Total Equilibrium Tank by Jeff Koons, Tate Liverpool.jpg
Three Ball Total Equilibrium Tank (1983) by Jeff Koons, Tate Liverpool

Whilst appropriation in bygone eras utilised the likes of 'language', contemporary appropriation has been symbolised by photography as a means of 'semiotic models of representation'. [33] The Pictures Generation was a group of artists, influenced by Conceptual and Pop art, who utilized appropriation and montage to reveal the constructed nature of images. [34] An exhibition named The Pictures Generation, 1974–1984 was held at The Metropolitan Museum of Art (The Met) in New York City from April 29 – August 2, 2009 that included among other artists John Baldessari, Barbara Kruger, Sherrie Levine, Richard Prince, David Salle, Cindy Sherman.

Sherrie Levine, who addressed the act of appropriating itself as a theme in art. [35] Levine often quotes entire works in her own work, for example photographing photographs of Walker Evans. Challenging ideas of originality, drawing attention to relations between power, gender and creativity, consumerism and commodity value, the social sources and uses of art, Levine plays with the theme of "almost same".

During the 1970s and 1980s Richard Prince re-photographed advertisements such as for Marlboro cigarettes [36] or photo-journalism shots. His work takes anonymous and ubiquitous cigarette billboard advertising campaigns, elevates the status and focuses our gaze on the images.

Appropriation artists comment on all aspects of culture and society. Joseph Kosuth appropriated images to engage with epistemology and metaphysics.

Other artists working with appropriation during this time with included Greg Colson, and Malcolm Morley.[ citation needed ]

In the late 1970s Dara Birnbaum was working with appropriation to produce feminist works of art. [37] In 1978-79 she produced one of the first video appropriations. Technology/Transformation: Wonder Woman utilised video clips from the Wonder Woman television series. [38]

Richard Pettibone began replicating on a miniature scale works by newly famous artists such as Andy Warhol, and later also modernist masters, signing the original artist's name as well as his own. [39] [32]

Jeff Koons gained recognition in the 1980 by creating conceptual sculptures The New series, a series of vacuum-cleaners, often selected for brand names that appealed to the artist like the iconic Hoover, and in the vein of the readymades of Duchamp. Later he created sculptures in stainless steel inspired by inflatable toys such as bunnies or dogs. [40] [41]

1990s

Fountain (Buddha) a bronze remake by Sherrie Levine, 1996 Sherrie Levine.jpg
Fountain (Buddha) a bronze remake by Sherrie Levine, 1996

In the 1990s artists continued to produce appropriation art, using it as a medium to address theories and social issues, rather than focussing on the works themselves. This typically is the case of Peruvian painter Herman Braun-Vega, in whom the appropriation of the works of the old masters is almost systematic [42] and who, after beginning by making painted commentaries of the painting of others in the late 1960s, [43] ends up putting the characters borrowed from Western painting iconography in the presence of the social and political reality of his time. [44] The great triptych from the permanent collection of the Ralli Museum in Marbella, The Informal Family (Velazquez, Goya, Picasso), [45] is an example of multiple appropriations coexisting within the same work with the painter’s contemporaries in scenes describing the social situation in third world countries where the family in the broad sense is a circle of subsistence economy. [46] Braun-Vega recontextualises appropriated works and gives them a new meaning. [47] For his part, Damian Loeb used film and cinema to comment on themes of simulacrum and reality. Other high-profile artists working at this time included Christian Marclay, Deborah Kass, and Genco Gulan. [48]

Yasumasa Morimura is a Japanese appropriation artist who borrows images from historical artists (such as Édouard Manet or Rembrandt) to modern artists as Cindy Sherman, and inserts his own face and body into them. [49]

Saulteaux First Nations artist Robert Houle gained prominence through his appropriation of historical images and documents to criticize historical violence against Indigenous peoples in Canada. [50] Houle's work Kanata (1992) utilized imagery from Benjamin West's The Death of General Wolfe (1770), forgoing color in most of the frame to instead highlight the imagery of a Delaware warrior inserted by West. [50]

Sherrie Levine appropriated the appropriated when she made polished cast bronze urinals named Fountain. They are considered to be an "homage to Duchamp's renowned readymade. Adding to Duchamp's audacious move, Levine turns his gesture back into an "art object" by elevating its materiality and finish. As a feminist artist, Levine remakes works specifically by male artists who commandeered patriarchal dominance in art history." [51]

21st century

Appropriation is frequently used by contemporary artists who often reinterpret previous artworks such as French artist Zevs who reinterpreted logos of brands like Google or works by David Hockney. [52] Many urban and street artists also use images from the popular culture such as Shepard Fairey or Banksy, [53] who appropriated artworks by Claude Monet or Vermeer with his girl with a pierced eardrum. [54]

Canadian Cree artist Kent Monkman appropriates iconic paintings from European and North American art history and populates them with Indigenous visions of resistance. [55]

In 2014 Richard Prince released a series of works titled New Portraits appropriating the photos of anonymous and famous persons (such as Pamela Anderson) who had posted a selfie on Instagram.The modifications to the images by the artist are the comments Prince added under the photos. [56] [57]

Damien Hirst was accused in 2018 of appropriating the work of Emily Kngwarreye and others from the painting community in Utopia, Northern Territory with the Veil paintings, that according to Hirst were "inspired by Pointillist techniques and Impressionist and Post-Impressionist painters such as Bonnard and Seurat". [58] [59] [60] [61]

Mr. Brainwash [62] is an urban artist who became famous thanks to Banksy and whose style fuses historic pop imagery and contemporary cultural iconography to create his version of a pop–graffiti art hybrid first popularized by other street artists. [63]

Brian Donnelly, known as Kaws, has used appropriation in his series, The Kimpsons, and painted The Kaws Album inspired by the Simpsons Yellow Album which itself was a parody of the cover art for the Beatles album Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band replaced with characters from the Simpsons. [64] On April 1, 2019, at Sotheby's in Hong Kong, The Kaws Album (2005), sold for 115.9 million Hong Kong dollars, or about $14.7 million U.S. dollars. [65] In addition, he has reworked other familiar characters such as Mickey Mouse, the Michelin Man, the Smurfs, Snoopy, and SpongeBob SquarePants. [66]

In the digital age

Since the 1990s, the exploitation of historical precursors is as multifarious as the concept of appropriation is unclear. An unparalleled quantity of appropriations pervades not only the field of the visual arts, but of all cultural areas. The new generation of appropriators considers themselves "archeolog[es] of the present time". [67] Some speak of "postproduction", which is based on pre-existing works, to re-edit "the screenplay of culture". [68] The annexation of works made by others or of available cultural products mostly follows the concept of use. So-called "prosumers" [69] —those consuming and producing at the same time—browse through the ubiquitous archive of the digital world (more seldom through the analog one), in order to sample the ever accessible images, words, and sounds via 'copy-paste' or 'drag-drop' to 'bootleg', 'mashup' or 'remix' them just as one likes. French curator Nicolas Bourriaud coined the neologism Semionaut – a portmanteau of semiotics and astronaut – to describe this. He writes: "DJs, Web surfers, and postproduction artists imply a similar configuration of knowledge, which is characterized by the invention of paths through culture. All three are "semionauts" who produce original pathways through signs." [70] Appropriations have today become an everyday phenomenon.

The new "generation remix" [71] —who have taken the stages not only of the visual arts, but also of music, literature, dance and film—causes, of course, highly controversial debates. Media scholars Lawrence Lessig coined in the begin of the 2000s here the term of the remix culture. [72] On the one hand are the celebrators who foresee a new age of innovative, useful, and entertaining ways for art of the digitized and globalized 21st century. The new appropriationists will not only realize Joseph Beuys' dictum that everyone is an artist but also "build free societies". [73] By liberating art finally from traditional concepts such as aura, originality, and genius, they will lead to new terms of understanding and defining art. More critical observers see this as the starting point of a huge problem. If creation is based on nothing more than carefree processes of finding, copying, recombining and manipulating pre-existing media, concepts, forms, names, etc. of any source, the understanding of art will shift in their sight to a trivialized, low-demanding, and regressive activity. In view of the limitation of art to references to pre-existing concepts and forms, they foresee endless recompiled and repurposed products. Skeptics call this a culture of recycling with an addiction to the past [74]

Some say that only lazy people who have nothing to say let themselves be inspired by the past in this way. [75] Others fear, that this new trend of appropriation is caused by nothing more than the wish of embellishing oneself with an attractive genealogy. [76] The term appropriationism [77] reflects the overproduction of reproductions, remakings, reenactments, recreations, revisionings, reconstructings, etc. by copying, imitating, repeating, quoting, plagiarizing, simulating, and adapting pre-existing names, concepts and forms. Appropriationism is discussed—in comparison of appropriation forms and concepts of the 20th century which offer new representations of established knowledge [78] —as a kind of "racing standstill", [79] referring to the acceleration of random, uncontrollable operations in highly mobilised, fluid Western societies that are governed more and more by abstract forms of control. Unlimited access to the digital archive of creations and easily feasible digital technologies, as well as the priority of fresh ideas and creative processes over a perfect masterpiece leads to a hyperactive hustle and bustle around the past instead of launching new expeditions into unexplored territory that could give visibility to the forgotten ghosts and ignored phantoms of our common myths and ideologies.

Appropriation art has resulted in contentious copyright issues regarding its validity under copyright law. The U.S. has been particularly litigious in this respect. A number of case law examples have emerged that investigate the division between transformative works and derivative works. [80]

What is fair use?

The Copyright Act of 1976 in the United States, provides a defense against copyright infringement when an artist can prove that their use of the underlying work is "fair".

The Act gives four factors to be considered to determine whether a particular use is a fair use:

  1. the purpose and character of the use (commercial or educational, transformative or reproductive, political);
  2. the nature of the copyrighted work (fictional or factual, the degree of creativity);
  3. the amount and substantiality of the portion of the original work used; and
  4. the effect of the use upon the market (or potential market) for the original work.

Examples of lawsuits

Andy Warhol faced a series of lawsuits from photographers whose work he appropriated and silk-screened. Patricia Caulfield, one such photographer, had taken a picture of flowers for a photography demonstration for a photography magazine. Without her permission, Warhol covered the walls of Leo Castelli's New York gallery with his silk-screened reproductions of Caulfield's photograph in 1964. After seeing a poster of Warhol's unauthorized reproductions in a bookstore, Caulfield sued Warhol for violating her rights as the copyright owner, and Warhol made a cash settlement out of court. [81]

In 2021, the Second Circuit held that Warhol's use of a photograph of Prince to create a series of 16 silkscreens and pencil illustrations was not fair use. The photograph, taken by celebrity photographer Lynn Goldsmith, was commissioned in 1981 as an artist reference for Newsweek magazine. In 1984, Warhol used the photograph as a source to create a work for Vanity Fair along with 15 additional pieces. Goldsmith was not made aware of the series until after the musician's death in 2016, when Condé Nast published a tribute featuring one of Warhol's works. In its opinion, the Court held that each of the four "fair use" factors favored Goldsmith, further finding that the works were substantially similar as a matter of law, given that "any reasonable viewer . . . would have no difficulty identifying the [Goldsmith photograph] as the source material for Warhol's Prince Series." [82] The Supreme Court affirmed in a 7-2 decision, holding that the licensing of the Orange Prince for use as a magazine cover did not qualify as fair use of a copyrighted photo taken for use in a magazine, leaving for another day whether the painting itself could qualify as fair use. [83]

On the other hand, Warhol's famous Campbell's Soup Cans are generally held to be a non-infringing fair use of the soup maker's trademark, despite being clearly appropriated, because "the public [is] unlikely to see the painting as sponsored by the soup company or representing a competing product. Paintings and soup cans are not in themselves competing products," according to expert trademark lawyer Jerome Gilson. [84]

Jeff Koons has also confronted issues of copyright due to his appropriation work (see Rogers v. Koons ). Photographer Art Rogers brought suit against Koons for copyright infringement in 1989. Koons' work, String of Puppies sculpturally reproduced Rogers' black-and-white photograph that had appeared on an airport greeting card that Koons had bought. Though he claimed fair use and parody in his defense, Koons lost the case, partially due to the tremendous success he had as an artist and the manner in which he was portrayed in the media.[ citation needed ] The parody argument also failed, as the appeals court drew a distinction between creating a parody of modern society in general and a parody directed at a specific work, finding parody of a specific work, especially of a very obscure one, too weak to justify the fair use of the original.

In October 2006, Koons successfully defended a different work by claiming "fair use". For a seven-painting commission for the Deutsche Guggenheim Berlin, Koons drew on part of a photograph taken by Andrea Blanch titled Silk Sandals by Gucci and published in the August 2000 issue of Allure magazine to illustrate an article on metallic makeup. Koons took the image of the legs and diamond sandals from that photo (omitting other background details) and used it in his painting Niagara, which also includes three other pairs of women's legs dangling surreally over a landscape of pies and cakes.

In his decision, Judge Louis L. Stanton of U.S. District Court found that Niagara was indeed a "transformative use" of Blanch's photograph. "The painting's use does not 'supersede' or duplicate the objective of the original", the judge wrote, "but uses it as raw material in a novel way to create new information, new aesthetics and new insights. Such use, whether successful or not artistically, is transformative."

The detail of Blanch's photograph used by Koons is only marginally copyrightable. Blanch has no rights to the Gucci sandals, "perhaps the most striking element of the photograph", the judge wrote. And without the sandals, only a representation of a woman's legs remains—and this was seen as "not sufficiently original to deserve much copyright protection."

In 2000, Damien Hirst's sculpture Hymn (which Charles Saatchi had bought for a reported £1m) was exhibited in Ant Noises in the Saatchi Gallery. Hirst was sued for breach of copyright over this sculpture. The subject was a 'Young Scientist Anatomy Set' belonging to his son Connor, 10,000 of which are sold a year by Hull (Emms) Toy Manufacturer. Hirst created a 20-foot, six-ton enlargement of the Science Set figure, radically changing the perception of the object. Hirst paid an undisclosed sum to two charities, Children Nationwide and the Toy Trust in an out-of-court settlement. The charitable donation was less than Emms had hoped for. Hirst sold three more copies of his sculpture for similar amounts to the first. [85]

Appropriating a familiar object to make an artwork can prevent the artist claiming copyright ownership. Jeff Koons threatened to sue a gallery under copyright, claiming that the gallery infringed his proprietary rights by selling bookends in the shape of balloon dogs. [86] Koons abandoned that claim after the gallery filed a complaint for declaratory relief stating, "As virtually any clown can attest, no one owns the idea of making a balloon dog, and the shape created by twisting a balloon into a dog-like form is part of the public domain." [87]

In 2008, photojournalist Patrick Cariou sued artist Richard Prince, Gagosian Gallery and Rizzoli books for copyright infringement. Prince had appropriated 40 of Cariou's photos of Rastafari from a book, creating a series of paintings known as Canal Zone. Prince variously altered the photos, painting objects, oversized hands, naked women and male torsos over the photographs, subsequently selling over $10 million worth of the works. In March 2011, a judge ruled in favor of Cariou, but Prince and Gargosian appealed on a number of points. Three judges for the U.S. Court of Appeals upheld the right to an appeal. [88] Prince's attorney argued that "Appropriation art is a well-recognized modern and postmodern art form that has challenged the way people think about art, challenged the way people think about objects, images, sounds, culture." [89] On April 24, 2013, the appeals court largely overturned the original decision, deciding that many of the paintings had sufficiently transformed the original images and were therefore a permitted use. [90] See Cariou v. Prince . [91]

In November 2010, Chuck Close threatened legal action against computer artist Scott Blake for creating a photoshop filter that built images out of dissected Chuck Close paintings. [92] [93] The story was first reported by online arts magazine Hyperallergic , it was reprinted on the front page of Salon.com, and spread rapidly through the web. [94] Kembrew McLeod, author of several books on sampling and appropriation, said in Wired that Scott Blake's art should fall under the doctrine of fair use. [95]

In September 2014, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit questioned the Second Circuit's interpretation of the fair use doctrine in the Cariou case. Of particular note, the Seventh Circuit noted that "transformative use" is not one of the four enumerated fair use factors but is, rather, simply part of the first fair use factor which looks to the "purpose and character" of the use. The Seventh Circuit's critique lends credence to the argument that there is a split among U.S. courts as to what role "transformativeness" is to play in any fair use inquiry. [91]

In 2013, Andrew Gilden and Timothy Greene published a law review article in The University of Chicago Law Review dissecting the factual similarities and legal differences between the Cariou case and the Salinger v. Colting case, articulating concerns that judges may be creating a fair use "privilege largely reserved for the rich and famous." [96]

Artists using appropriation

The following are notable artists known for their use of pre-existing objects or images with little or no transformation applied to them:

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fair use</span> Concept in United States copyright law

Fair use is a doctrine in United States law that permits limited use of copyrighted material without having to first acquire permission from the copyright holder. Fair use is one of the limitations to copyright intended to balance the interests of copyright holders with the public interest in the wider distribution and use of creative works by allowing as a defense to copyright infringement claims certain limited uses that might otherwise be considered infringement. The U.S. "fair use doctrine" is generally broader than the "fair dealing" rights known in most countries that inherited English Common Law. The fair use right is a general exception that applies to all different kinds of uses with all types of works. In the U.S., fair use right/exception is based on a flexible proportionality test that examines the purpose of the use, the amount used, and the impact on the market of the original work.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Found object</span> Non-standard material used in work of art

A found object, or found art, is art created from undisguised, but often modified, items or products that are not normally considered materials from which art is made, often because they already have a non-art function. Pablo Picasso first publicly utilized the idea when he pasted a printed image of chair caning onto his painting titled Still Life with Chair Caning (1912). Marcel Duchamp is thought to have perfected the concept several years later when he made a series of readymades, consisting of completely unaltered everyday objects selected by Duchamp and designated as art. The most famous example is Fountain (1917), a standard urinal purchased from a hardware store and displayed on a pedestal, resting on its back. In its strictest sense the term "readymade" is applied exclusively to works produced by Marcel Duchamp, who borrowed the term from the clothing industry while living in New York, and especially to works dating from 1913 to 1921.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Richard Prince</span> American painter and photographer (born 1949)

Richard Prince is an American painter and photographer. In the mid-1970s, Prince made drawings and painterly collages that he has since disowned. His image, Untitled (Cowboy), a photographic reproduction of a photograph by Sam Abell and appropriated from a cigarette advertisement, was the first rephotograph to be sold for more than $1 million at auction at Christie's New York in 2005. He is regarded as "one of the most revered artists of his generation" according to The New York Times.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Elaine Sturtevant</span> American artist

Elaine Frances Sturtevant, also known professionally as Sturtevant, was an American artist. She achieved recognition for her carefully inexact repetitions of other artists' works.

<i>Fountain</i> (Duchamp) 1917 sculpture by Marcel Duchamp

Fountain is a readymade sculpture by Marcel Duchamp in 1917, consisting of a porcelain urinal signed "R. Mutt". In April 1917, an ordinary piece of plumbing chosen by Duchamp was submitted for the inaugural exhibition of the Society of Independent Artists, to be staged at the Grand Central Palace in New York. When explaining the purpose of his readymade sculpture, Duchamp stated they are "everyday objects raised to the dignity of a work of art by the artist's act of choice." In Duchamp's presentation, the urinal's orientation was altered from its usual positioning. Fountain was not rejected by the committee, since Society rules stated that all works would be accepted from artists who paid the fee, but the work was never placed in the show area. Following that removal, Fountain was photographed at Alfred Stieglitz's studio, and the photo published in the Dada journal The Blind Man. The original has been lost.

Sherrie Levine is an American photographer, painter, and conceptual artist. Some of her work consists of exact photographic reproductions of the work of other photographers such as Walker Evans, Eliot Porter and Edward Weston.

Eric David Kroll is an American photojournalist, fetish photographer, erotica historian, and book editor.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Gagosian Gallery</span> Contemporary and modern art gallery with multiple locations

The Gagosian Gallery is a modern and contemporary art gallery owned and directed by Larry Gagosian. The gallery exhibits some of the most well-known artists of the 20th and 21st centuries. As of 2024, Gagosian employs 300 people at 19 exhibition spaces – including New York City, London, Paris, Basel, Beverly Hills, San Francisco, Rome, Athens, Geneva, and Hong Kong – designed by architects such as Caruso St John, Richard Gluckman, Richard Meier, Jean Nouvel, and Annabelle Selldorf.

Twentieth-century art—and what it became as modern art—began with modernism in the late nineteenth century.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Jeff Koons</span> American sculptor and painter (born 1955)

Jeffrey Lynn Koons is an American artist recognized for his work dealing with popular culture and his sculptures depicting everyday objects, including balloon animals produced in stainless steel with mirror-finish surfaces. He lives and works in both New York City and his hometown of York, Pennsylvania. His works have sold for substantial sums, including at least two record auction prices for a work by a living artist: US$58.4 million for Balloon Dog (Orange) in 2013 and US$91.1 million for Rabbit in 2019.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Collage</span> Technique of art production using assemblage of different forms

Collage is a technique of art creation, primarily used in the visual arts, but in music too, by which art results from an assemblage of different forms, thus creating a new whole.

<i>Marilyn Diptych</i> Silkscreen painting by Andy Warhol

The Marilyn Diptych (1962) is a silkscreen painting by American pop artist Andy Warhol depicting Marilyn Monroe. The monumental work is one of the artist's most noted of the movie star.

Eric Doeringer is an artist currently living and working in Los Angeles, California. He graduated from Brown University in 1996 with a B.A. and received an MFA from the School of the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston in 1999.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Astrup Fearnley Museum of Modern Art</span> Art museum in Oslo, Norway

The Astrup Fearnley Museum of Modern Art is a privately owned contemporary art gallery in Oslo in Norway. It was founded and opened to the public in 1993. The collection's main focus is the American appropriation artists from the 1980s, but it is currently developing towards the international contemporary art scene, with artists like Jeff Koons, Richard Prince, Cindy Sherman, Matthew Barney, Tom Sachs, Doug Aitken, Olafur Eliasson, and Cai Guo-Qiang. The museum gives 6-7 temporary exhibitions each year. Astrup Fearnley Museum of Modern Art collaborates with international institutions and produces exhibitions that travel worldwide. In 2012 the museum moved to two new buildings designed by Renzo Piano in Tjuvholmen.

Art and culture law refers to legal aspects of the visual arts, antiquities, cultural heritage, and the art market and encompasses the safeguarding, regulation, and facilitation of artistic creation, utilization, and promotion. Practitioners of art law navigate various legal areas, including intellectual property, contract, constitutional, tort, tax, commercial, immigration law, estates and wills, cultural property law, and international law to protect the interests of their clients.

<i>Cariou v. Prince</i> 2013 copyright case in the United States

Cariou v. Prince, 714 F.3d 694 is a copyright case of the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, on the question of whether artist Richard Prince's appropriation art treatment of Patrick Cariou's photographs was copyright infringement or fair use. The Second Circuit held in 2013 that Prince's appropriation art could constitute fair use, and that a number of his works were transformative fair uses of Cariou's photographs. The Court remanded to the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York for reconsideration of five of Prince's works. The Supreme Court denied Cariou's petition for a writ of certiorari, and the case settled in 2014.

<i>Orange Prince</i> 1984 painting by Andy Warhol

Orange Prince is a painting by American artist Andy Warhol of Prince, the American singer, songwriter, record producer, multi-instrumentalist, actor, and director. The painting is one of twelve silkscreen portraits on canvas of Prince created by Warhol in 1984, based on an original photograph provided to Warhol by Vanity Fair. The photograph was taken by Lynn Goldsmith. These paintings and four additional works on paper are collectively known as the Prince Series. Each painting is unique and can be distinguished by colour.

<i>Molotov Man</i> Iconic photograph by Susan Meiselas

Molotov Man is the title by which a photograph taken by Susan Meiselas during the 1979 Nicaraguan Revolution has come to be known. Famous in its Nicaraguan context as a symbol of the Sandinista revolution, it has been widely reproduced and remixed.

Andy Warhol Foundation for the Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, 598 U.S. 508 (2023), is a U.S. Supreme Court case dealing with transformative use, a component of fair use, under U.S. copyright law. At issue was the Prince Series created by Andy Warhol based on a photograph of the musician Prince by Lynn Goldsmith. It held Warhol's changes were insufficiently transformative to fall within fair use for commercial purposes, resolving an issue arising from a split between the Second and Ninth circuits among others.

<i>Blanch v. Koons</i> American copyright lawsuit

Blanch v. Koons, 467 F.3d 244, is a copyright case decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in 2006. Fashion photographer Andrea Blanch sued appropriation artist Jeff Koons for copyright infringement after he used an image of a woman's lower legs taken from one of her photographs in a collage of his own. Koons claimed fair use, arguing he had transformed it sufficiently from its original purpose through his reuse. It is considered a significant case in addressing the latter issue.

References

  1. ↑ Chilvers, Ian & Glaves-Smith, John eds., Dictionary of Modern and Contemporary Art, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2009. pp. 27–28
  2. ↑ "MoMA | Glossary of Art Terms". www.moma.org. Retrieved 2020-08-17.
  3. 1 2 Wilson, Simon; Lack, Jessica (2008), The Tate Guide to Modern Art Terms, London: Tate Publishing Ltd, pp. 20–21, ISBN   978-1-85437-750-0
  4. ↑ Tate. "Appropriation – Art Term". Tate Etc. Retrieved 2020-08-18.
  5. ↑ Tomkins, Duchamp: A Biography, p. 186.
  6. ↑ "1856 – Jean-Auguste-Dominique Ingres, Madame Moitessier | Fashion History Timeline". fashionhistory.fitnyc.edu. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  7. ↑ "Le Dejeuner Sur L'Herbe (The Luncheon on the Grass) by Edouard Manet". thehistoryofart.org. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  8. ↑ "Japonism: This Is What Claude Monet's Art Has in Common with Japanese Art". TheCollector. 2020-09-01. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  9. ↑ "The artist whom Van Gogh most admired—and whose work fetched record prices". theartnewspaper.com. 4 October 2019. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  10. ↑ "816 (818, 613): To Theo van Gogh. Saint-Rémy-de-Provence, on or about Sunday, 3 November 1889. - Vincent van Gogh Letters". vangoghletters.org. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  11. ↑ Covenantarthistory (2016-04-23). "Talking Objects: Claude Monet and the Rise of Japonism". Talking Objects. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  12. ↑ "How Japanese Art Influenced and Inspired European Impressionist Artists". My Modern Met. 2017-12-14. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  13. ↑ "Japonisme". metmuseum.org. October 2004. Archived from the original on 2004-10-14. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  14. ↑ "Exploring the Cutting-Edge History and Evolution of Collage Art". My Modern Met. 2017-07-14. Retrieved 2019-09-25.
  15. ↑ Elger, D. (2006). Dadaism. Koln: Taschen, pp. 80
  16. ↑ Evans, D (ed.).(2009). Appropriation: Documents of contemporary art. London and Cambridge: Whitechapel Gallery and the MIT Press, pp. 40
  17. ↑ Cabanne, P., and Snowdon, P. (1997). Duchamp & Co. Paris: Terrail, pp. 105
  18. ↑ Cabanne, P., and Snowdon, P. (1997). Duchamp & Co. Paris: Terrail, pp. 114
  19. 1 2 Plant, S. (1992). The most radical gesture: The Situationist International in a postmodern age. London and New York: Routledge, pp.44
  20. ↑ Arturo Schwarz, The complete works of Marcel Duchamp, New York, Delano Greenidge, 2000
  21. ↑ The Collages of Kurt Schwitters, Dietrich, Cambridge University Press 1993, p6-7
  22. ↑ Gotthardt, Alexxa (2018-09-10). "Understanding Eugène Delacroix through 5 of His Most Provocative Artworks". Artsy. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  23. ↑ Eisenman, Stephen F. (2018-11-01). "Delacroix's Modernism". ARTnews. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  24. ↑ "Henri Matisse (1869–1954)". metmuseum.org. Archived from the original on 2004-10-25. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  25. ↑ artincontext (2022-02-28). "Appropriation in Art - An Overview of Artistic Appropriation in the Art World". artincontext.org. Retrieved 2023-07-15.
  26. ↑ "Andy Warhol | Green Coca-Cola Bottles". whitney.org. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  27. ↑ "Roy Lichtenstein Foundation – Roy Lichtenstein Foundation". lichtensteinfoundation.org. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  28. ↑ Cotter, Holland (2014-11-13). "Taking Copycatting to a Higher Level". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2021-06-01.
  29. ↑ Hans Ulrich Obrist (19 May 2014). "Elaine Sturtevant obituary". The Guardian.
  30. ↑ "César | French sculptor". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  31. ↑ "Arman | French-American artist". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  32. 1 2 "The Art of Copying: Ten Masters of Appropriation". Artsy. 2014-02-11. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  33. ↑ Linden, Liz (Winter 2016). "Reframing Pictures: Reading the Art of Appropriation" (PDF). Art Journal. 75 (4): 40–57. doi:10.1080/00043249.2016.1269561. JSTOR   45142821. S2CID   193684743.
  34. ↑ "The Pictures Generation Movement Overview". The Art Story. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  35. ↑ "Sherrie Levine Paintings, Bio, Ideas". The Art Story. Retrieved 2021-04-04.
  36. ↑ Cohen, Alina (2018-03-02). "Who Actually Shot Richard Prince's Iconic Cowboys?". Artsy. Retrieved 2020-03-06.
  37. ↑ Welchman, John (2013). Art After Appropriation: Essays on Art in the 1990s. Routledge. pp. 33, 190. ISBN   978-1-136-80136-5.
  38. ↑ Meigh-Andrews, Chris (2013). A History of Video Art (2nd ed.). London: Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 194. ISBN   978-0-85785-188-8.
  39. ↑ "Richard Pettibone – 88 Artworks, Bio & Shows on Artsy". artsy.net. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  40. ↑ "Jeff Koons Biography, Life & Quotes". The Art Story. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  41. ↑ "Jeff Koons | Biography, Art, & Facts". Encyclopædia Britannica. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  42. ↑ Román, Élida (2003-01-05). "Herman Braun-Vega: Arte de apropiación". El Comercio (in Spanish). Lima: 29. 'Apropiación' es el primer término que aparece al querer categorizar o clasificar la obra de Herman Braun-Vega. [...] Efectivamente, el autor se 'apropia' de las imágenes que otros crearan. Pero se trata de una utilización que no busca el reemplazo, la reedición o el acoplamiento, sino que ejerce su libertad de darle un contenido nuevo en un contexto creado por él.
  43. ↑ Ramón Ribeyro, Julio (1981-05-17). "Herman Braun". Marka (in Spanish). Lima: El Caballo Rojo: 14. Que un pintor utilice como temas de sus cuadros obras de otros pintores no es una novedad. Lo novedoso es ahondar este procedimiento y hacer de él, forzando un poco el término, un sistema. Tal es el caso de Herman Braun. [...] Se podría pues hablar [...] de una metapintura, en la medida en que sus cuadros son comentarios pictóricos de otros cuadros. Pero esta definición resulta estrecha, si se tiene en cuenta la evolución de su obra.
  44. ↑ "Herman Braun: trato de ofrecer un testimonio de la situación social" [Herman Braun: I try to offer a testimony of the social situation]. El Comercio (in Spanish). Lima: 16. 1984-11-30. [...] a lo largo de estos quince años, he trabajado con la iconografía de occidente, tratando de ofrecer un testimonio [...] de la situación social.
  45. ↑ "La familia Informal | Obra destacada Colección Ralli Braun-Vega". Museo Ralli Marbella.
  46. ↑ "Artista en Familia". Caretas (in Spanish). 1995-09-14. pp. 90–91. la pieza central de la muestra es "La familia informal", un gran tríptico que [Braun-Vega] preparó para las celebraciones españolas del V Centenario del llamado encuentro entre dos Mundos, aludiendo tanto a las economías de subsistencia en que viven los habitantes más pobres del tercer mundo, como al mestizaje cultural que este intercambio posibilita
  47. ↑ Guerrero Zegarra, María Alexandra (2021-06-01). "El poder se nutre de dogmas. El apropiacionismo en la obra de Herman Braun‑Vega" [The Power is Nourished by Dogmas. The Appropriation in the Work of Herman Braun‑Vega]. LETRAS, revista de investigación científica de la Facultad de Letras y Ciencias Humanas de la Universidad Nacional Mayor de San Marcos (in Spanish). Vol. 92, no. 135. Lima. pp. 177–190. doi:10.30920/letras.92.135.13. ISSN   0378-4878. the appropriation of the image makes a new meaning in the work, while it is recontextualized and reinterpreted, because the appropriations in the work of this artist has the intention of make a rearticulation of the memory (individual, sociopolitical and historical).
  48. ↑ Graf, Marcus (October 6, 2013). "Self Portrait? by Genco Gülan". Visual Art Beat. Archived from the original on August 30, 2019. Retrieved November 1, 2013.
  49. ↑ Rosenberg, Karen (15 January 2015). "Yasumasa Morimura". The New York Times.
  50. 1 2 Madill, Shirley (2018). Robert Houle: Life & Work. Toronto: Art Canada Institute. ISBN   978-1-4871-0170-1.
  51. ↑ "Fountain (Buddha) - Sherrie Levine | The Broad". www.thebroad.org. Retrieved 2020-08-18.
  52. ↑ "Upcoming: Zevs – "The Big Oil Splash" @ Lazarides Rathbone « Arrested Motion". ArrestedMotion. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  53. ↑ "The Story Behind Banksy". Smithsonian. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  54. ↑ "Banksy Street Art in Bristol – VisitBristol.co.uk". Visit Bristol. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  55. ↑ Madill, Shirley (2022). Kent Monkman: Life & Work. Toronto: Art Canada Institute. ISBN   978-1-4871-0280-7.
  56. ↑ Parkinson, Hannah Jane (2015-07-18). "Instagram, an artist and the $100,000 selfies – appropriation in the digital age". The Guardian. ISSN   0261-3077 . Retrieved 2020-03-06.
  57. ↑ Plaugic, Lizzie (2015-05-30). "The story of Richard Prince and his $100,000 Instagram art". The Verge. Retrieved 2020-03-06.
  58. ↑ "Damien Hirst's latest artworks 'done exactly like my people's story', Indigenous artist claims". Australian Broadcasting Corporation. 2018-03-28. Retrieved 2020-09-13.
  59. ↑ "The art of appropriation". THE ETHICS CENTRE. 2018-05-14. Retrieved 2020-09-13.
  60. ↑ "Did Damien Hirst Rip Off Aboriginal Australian Artists's Work? | Frieze". frieze. 3 April 2018. Retrieved 2020-09-13.
  61. ↑ "'Uncanny similarity': new Damien Hirst works in spot of bother in Australia". The Guardian. 2018-03-29. Retrieved 2020-09-13.
  62. ↑ Geoghegan, Kev (2012-08-03). "Mr Brainwash makes UK show debut" . Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  63. ↑ "Mr. Brainwash – "life is beautiful" Exhibition". Obey Giant. 2008-06-16. Retrieved 2019-09-06.
  64. ↑ Adair, Torsten (2019-11-19). "Syndicated Comics". The Beat. Retrieved 2020-02-28.
  65. ↑ Armstrong, Annie (2019-04-01). "$14.7 M. KAWS Painting Smashes Auction Record in Hong Kong". ARTnews. Retrieved 2020-02-28.
  66. ↑ "10 things to know about KAWS | Christie's". www.christies.com. Retrieved 2020-02-28.
  67. ↑ Hedinger J.; Meyer, T. (2011). "000|1 Vorwort Band I" [Preface]. whtsnxt (in German and English). Retrieved 15 February 2016.
  68. ↑ Bourriaud, Nicolas (2002). Postproduction. Culture as screenplay. How art reprograms the world. New York: Lucas & Sternberg.
  69. ↑ cf. Toffler, Alvin (1980). The third wave. The classic study of tomorrow. New York: Bantam.
  70. ↑ Bourriaud, Nicolas (2005). Postproduction: culture as screenplay: how art reprograms the world. Caroline Schneider, Jeanine Herman (2nd ed.). New York: Lukas & Sternberg. p. 19. ISBN   0-9745688-9-9. OCLC   63165534.
  71. ↑ Djordjevic, V.; Dobusch, L., eds. (2014). Generation Remix. iRights Media. Archived from the original on 2016-05-16. Retrieved 2016-05-16.
  72. ↑ Download Lessig's Remix, Then Remix It on wired.com (May 2009)
  73. ↑ Hardy, S. (11 June 2013). "Rip!: A Remix Manifesto". Creative Generalist. Retrieved 15 February 2016.
  74. ↑ cf. Reynolds, Simon (2011). Retro Mania Pop Culture's Addiction To Its Own Past. London: Faber & Faber. ISBN   978-0-86547-994-4.
  75. ↑ Benjamin Franzen; Kembrew McLeod (2009). Copyright Criminals (documentary film).
  76. ↑ cf. Diedrichsen, Diedrich (September 2008). "Showfreaks und Monster". Texte zur Kunst. Artists' Artists (71): 150.
  77. ↑ Aden, Maike (April 2016). "Let's dance like we used to.... A critical intervention on a new trend of Appropriationism" (PDF). Kunstchronik (4): 201.
  78. ↑ Aden, Maike (Summer 2016). "Ulises Carrión Carries On!". Journal of Artists' Books (JAB) (40, in prep).
  79. ↑ cf. Virilio, Paul (1992). Rasender Stillstand. München: Hanser.
  80. ↑ Meiselman, Jessica (2017-12-28). "When Does an Artist's Appropriation Become Theft?". Artsy. Retrieved 2019-09-25.
  81. ↑ "Andy Warhol's Flower Paintings".
  82. ↑ Andy Warhol Found. for Visual Arts, Inc. v. Goldsmith, 11 F.4th 26, 54 (2d Cir. 2021)
  83. ↑ Supreme Court. "Andy Warhol Foundation for Visible Arts v. Goldsmith" (PDF). Supreme Court of the United States. Retrieved 31 May 2023.
  84. ↑ as quoted in Grant, Daniel, The Business of Being an Artist (New York: Allworth Press, 1996), p. 142
  85. ↑ "top-10-appropriation-artworks". artlyst.com. Retrieved 2019-12-08.
  86. ↑ Whiting, Sam (February 4, 2011). "Jeff Koons' balloon-dog claim ends with a whimper". The San Francisco Chronicle.
  87. ↑ ALLEN, EMMA (January 21, 2011). "6 Hilarious Zingers From the Balloon-Dog Freedom Suit Filed Against Jeff Koons". BlouinArtinfo.
  88. ↑ Corbett, Rachel; "A Win for Richard Prince in Copyright Case", Artnet Magazine, 2011
  89. ↑ Pollack, Barbara, "Copy Rights", ARTnews LLC, March 22, 2012.
  90. ↑ RANDY KENNEDY (April 25, 2013). "Court Rules in Artist's Favor". The New York Times . Retrieved 2013-04-26.
  91. 1 2 "Seventh Circuit Criticizes Second Circuit's "Transformative Use" Approach to Fair Use | Publications | Proskauer". www.proskauer.com. Retrieved 2015-12-12.
  92. ↑ Masnick, Mike. "Chuck Close Succeeds In Stifling A Creative Homage... But Only For Another 100 Years Or So!", Techdirt , July 16, 2012. Retrieved January 27, 2018.
  93. ↑ Doctorow, Cory. "Letter to Chuck Close from the digital artist whom he threatened with a lawsuit", BoingBoing , July 11, 2012. Retrieved January 27, 2018.
  94. ↑ Vartanian, Hrag. "The Most Popular Hyperallergic Posts of 2012", Hyperallergic , December 26, 2012. Retrieved January 27, 2018.
  95. ↑ Dayal, Geeta. "How the Artist Who Built the 'Chuck Close Filter' Got Slammed by Chuck Close", Wired , July 10, 2012. Retrieved January 27, 2018.
  96. ↑ "Fair Use for the Rich and Fabulous? | The University of Chicago Law Review | The University of Chicago". lawreview.uchicago.edu. Retrieved 2015-12-12.

Sources

Further reading

This page is based on this Wikipedia article
Text is available under the CC BY-SA 4.0 license; additional terms may apply.
Images, videos and audio are available under their respective licenses.