| School | Nickname | Division | Conference |
|---|
| University at Albany, State University of New York | Great Danes | I | America East Conference (most sports)
CAA Football (football) |
| United States Military Academy (Army) | Black Knights | American Athletic Conference (football)
Patriot League (most sports)
Atlantic Hockey America (men's ice hockey) |
| State University of New York at Binghamton | Bearcats | America East Conference |
| State University of New York at Buffalo | Bulls | Mid-American Conference |
| Canisius University | Golden Griffins | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference (most sports)
Atlantic Hockey America (men's ice hockey) |
| Colgate University | Raiders | Patriot League (most sports)
ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey) |
| Columbia University | Lions | Ivy League |
| Cornell University | Big Red | Ivy League (most sports)
ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey) |
| Fordham University | Rams | Atlantic 10 Conference (most sports)
Patriot League (football) |
| Hofstra University | Pride | Coastal Athletic Association |
| Iona University | Gaels | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference |
| Le Moyne College | Dolphins | Northeast Conference |
| Long Island University | Sharks | Northeast Conference (most sports)
New England Women's Hockey Alliance (women's ice hockey) |
| Manhattan University | Jaspers/Lady Jaspers | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference |
| Marist College | Red Foxes | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference |
| Niagara University | Purple Eagles | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference/Atlantic Hockey America |
| St. Bonaventure University | Bonnies | Atlantic 10 Conference |
| St. John's University | Red Storm | Big East Conference |
| Siena College | Saints | Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference |
| Stony Brook University | Seawolves | Coastal Athletic Association
CAA Football (football) [b] |
| Syracuse University | Orange | Atlantic Coast Conference (most sports)
Atlantic Hockey America (women's ice hockey) |
| Wagner College | Seahawks | Northeast Conference |
| Daemen University | Wildcats | I/II | Northeast Conference (men's volleyball)
East Coast Conference (other sports) |
| Dominican University | Chargers | East Coast Conference (men's volleyball) [c]
Central Atlantic Collegiate Conference (other sports) |
| D'Youville University | Saints | Northeast Conference (men's volleyball)
East Coast Conference (other sports) |
| Roberts Wesleyan University | Redhawks | East Coast Conference [c] |
| St. Thomas Aquinas College | Spartans | East Coast Conference [c] |
| St. Lawrence University | Saints | I/III | ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey)
Liberty League (other sports) |
| Clarkson University | Golden Knights | ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey)
Liberty League (other sports) |
| Hobart and William Smith Colleges | Statesmen/Herons | Atlantic 10 Conference (men's lacrosse)
Liberty League/ECAC West/Independent |
| Rochester Institute of Technology | Tigers | Atlantic Hockey America (men's and women's ice hockey)
Liberty League (most sports) |
| Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute | Engineers/Red Hawks | ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey)
Liberty League (other sports) |
| Union College | Dutchmen/Dutchwomen | ECAC Hockey (men's and women's ice hockey)
Liberty League (other sports) |
| Adelphi University | Panthers | II | Northeast-10 Conference |
| Mercy University | Mavericks | East Coast Conference |
| Molloy University | Lions | East Coast Conference |
| New York Institute of Technology | Bears | East Coast Conference |
| Pace University | Setters | Northeast-10 Conference/Eastern College Athletic Conference |
| Queens College | Knights | East Coast Conference |
| College of Saint Rose | Golden Knights | Northeast-10 Conference |
| College of Staten Island | Dolphins | East Coast Conference |
| Alfred University | Saxons | III | Empire 8 |
| Alfred State College | Pioneers | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference |
| Bard College | Raptors | Liberty League/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| Baruch College | Bearcats | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Brooklyn College | N/A | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Buffalo State University | Bengals | State University of New York Athletic Conference/New Jersey Athletic Conference/ECAC West |
| Cazenovia College | Wildcats | North Eastern Athletic Conference |
| City College of New York | Beavers | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Elmira College | Soaring Eagles | Empire 8/ECAC West/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| Hamilton College | Continentals | New England Small College Athletic Conference |
| Hartwick College | Hawks | Empire 8 |
| Hilbert College | Hawks | Allegheny Mountain Collegiate Conference |
| Houghton University | Highlanders | Empire 8 |
| Hunter College | Hawks | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Ithaca College | Bombers | Liberty League/Eastern College Athletic Conference |
| John Jay College of Criminal Justice | Bloodhounds | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Keuka College | Wolves | Eastern College Athletic Conference/Empire 8 |
| Lehman College | N/A | City University of New York Athletic Conference/Eastern College Athletic Conference |
| Manhattanville University | Valiants | Skyline Conference/MAC Freedom/ECAC West/ECAC East |
| Medgar Evers College | Cougars | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| United States Merchant Marine Academy | Mariners | Skyline Conference/New England Women's and Men's Athletic Conference |
| Mount Saint Mary College | Blue Knights | Skyline Conference |
| University of Mount Saint Vincent | Dolphins | Skyline Conference |
| Nazareth University | Golden Flyers | Empire 8/ECAC West/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| New York City College of Technology | Yellow Jackets | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
| New York University | Violets | University Athletic Association/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| Pratt Institute | Cannoneers | Coast to Coast Athletic Conference |
| University of Rochester | Yellowjackets | Liberty League/University Athletic Association |
| Russell Sage College | Gators | Eastern College Athletic Conference/Empire 8 |
| Skidmore College | Thoroughbreds | Liberty League |
| Saint John Fisher University | Cardinals | Eastern College Athletic Conference/Empire 8 |
| St. Joseph's University (Brooklyn) | Bears | Skyline Conference |
| St. Joseph's University (Long Island) | Golden Eagles | Skyline Conference |
| Sarah Lawrence College | Gryphons | Skyline Conference |
| State University of New York at Brockport | Golden Eagles | State University of New York Athletic Conference/ECAC West |
| State University of New York at Canton | Roos | North Atlantic Conference |
| State University of New York at Cortland | Red Dragons | New Jersey Athletic Conference/State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Delhi | Pioneers | American Collegiate Athletic Association/North Atlantic Conference (five sports) |
| State University of New York at Farmingdale | Rams | Skyline Conference |
| State University of New York at Fredonia | Blue Devils | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Geneseo | Knights | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York Maritime College | Privateers | Skyline Conference |
| State University of New York at Morrisville | Mustangs | North Eastern Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at New Paltz | Hawks | State University of New York Athletic Conference/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| State University of New York at Old Westbury | Panthers | Skyline Conference |
| State University of New York at Oneonta | Red Dragons | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Oswego/ECAC West | Lakers | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Plattsburgh/ECAC West | Cardinals | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Potsdam/ECAC West | Bears | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| State University of New York at Purchase | Panthers | Skyline Conference |
| State University of New York Institute of Technology | Wildcats | State University of New York Athletic Conference |
| Utica University | Pioneers | Empire 8/ECAC West |
| Vassar College | Brewers | Liberty League/United Volleyball Conference (men's) |
| Yeshiva University | Maccabees | Skyline Conference |
| York College (New York) | Cardinals | City University of New York Athletic Conference |
