The New Freedom

Last updated

The New Freedom was Woodrow Wilson's campaign platform in the 1912 presidential election, and also refers to the progressive programs enacted by Wilson during his time as president. First expressed in his campaign speeches and promises, Wilson later wrote a 1913 book of the same name. After the 1918 midterm elections, Republicans took control of Congress and were mostly hostile to the New Freedom.[ citation needed ] As president, Wilson focused on various types of reform, such as the following:

Contents

  1. Tariff reform: This came through the passage of the Underwood Tariff Act of 1913, which lowered tariffs for the first time since 1857 and went against the protectionist lobby. [1]
  2. Labor reform: This was achieved through measures such as the Eight Hour Law for Women of the District of Columbia, the Seaman’s Act, Workmen’s Compensation for Federal employees, the Federal Child Labor Bill, [2] and the Adamson Act. During the 1912 campaign Wilson spoke in support of workers organizing into unions while endorsing "the betterment of men in this occupation and the other, the protection of women, the shielding of children, the bringing about of social justice.” [3]
  3. Business reform: This was established through the passage of the Federal Trade Commission Act of 1914, which established the Federal Trade Commission to investigate and halt unfair and illegal business practices by issuing "cease and desist" orders, and the Clayton Antitrust Act. [1]
  4. Agricultural reform: This was achieved through measures such as the Cotton Futures and Smith-Lever Acts of 1914, the Grain Standards and Warehouse Acts of 1916, and the Smith-Hughes Act of 1917. [4]
  5. Banking reform: This came in 1913 through the creation of the Federal Reserve System and in 1916 through the passage of the Federal Farm Loan Act, which set up Farm Loan Banks to support farmers. [1]

Campaign slogan in 1912

Wilson's position in 1912 stood in opposition to Progressive party candidate Theodore Roosevelt's ideas of New Nationalism, particularly on the issue of antitrust modification. According to Wilson, "If America is not to have free enterprise, he can have freedom of no sort whatever." Wilson was strongly influenced by his chief economic advisor Louis D. Brandeis, an enemy of big business and monopoly. [5]

Although Wilson and Roosevelt agreed that economic power was being abused by trusts, Wilson and Roosevelt were split on how the government should handle the restraint of private power as in dismantling corporations that had too much economic power in a large society. Wilson wrote extensively on the meaning of "government" shortly after his election.

Wilson in office

Once elected, Wilson rolled out a program of social and economic reform. Wilson appointed Brandeis to the US Supreme Court in 1916. He worked with Congress to give federal employees worker's compensation, outlawed child labor with the Keating–Owen Act (the act was ruled unconstitutional in 1918) and passed the Adamson Act, which secured a maximum eight-hour workday for railroad employees. Most important was the Clayton Act of 1914, which largely put the trust issue to rest by spelling out the specific unfair practices that business were not allowed to engage in. [6] The legislative environment was favourable to Wilson, with progressive Democratic majorities in Congress during his first term in office. [7] [8]

By the end of the Wilson Administration, a significant amount of progressive legislation had been passed, affecting not only economic and constitutional affairs, but farmers, labor, veterans, the environment, and conservation as well. The reform agenda actually put into legislation by Wilson, however, did not extend as far as what Roosevelt had called for but had never actually passed, such as a standard 40-hour work week, minimum wage laws, and a federal system of social insurance.

This was possibly a reflection of Wilson's own ideological convictions, who according to Elizabeth Warren [9] and Herbert Hoover, was an adherent of Jeffersonian Democracy [10] (although Wilson did champion reforms such as agricultural credits during his presidency, and championed the right of Americans to earn a living wage and to live and work "in sanitary surroundings" in his 1919 State of the Union Address). [11] However, despite this characterization, Wilson identified himself with progressive [12] liberal politics throughout much of his life. During his time as governor of New Jersey, a number of reform laws were passed by the New Jersey legislature and signed by Wilson. This included laws providing “for at least one-half hour meal time after six continuous hours of labor” and the appointment of commissioners on old age pensions and old age insurance, together with laws concerning working hours and health and safety. [13] Wilson also spoke out in support of legislation benefiting labor, stating in one of his annual messages:

We have done much toward securing justice and safety for the workingmen of the State in our factory laws, our tenement-house legislation, and our Employers' Liability act, but we have not done enough. Our workmen very justly demand further legislation with regard to the inspection and regulation of factories and workshops, and I recommend legislation of this kind to your very careful and earnest consideration. I recommend, moreover, the passage at an early date of an act requiring the railways operating within this State to provide their trains with adequate crews. Our sister State of Pennsylvania has adopted legislation of this kind, and the railways whose lines cross from Pennsylvania into New Jersey actually carry full crews to the border of this State, and then send their trains on through New Jersey with diminished crews, to the jeopardy, as I believe, of life and property; requiring more of the small crew than it can safely and thoroughly do. [14]

In his acceptance speech for the Democratic nomination, Wilson argued in favor of labor legislation, stating that

The working people of America, — if they must be distinguished from the minority that constitutes the rest of it, — are, of course, the backbone of the Nation. No law that safeguards their lives, that improves the physical and moral conditions under which they live, that makes their hours of labor rational and tolerable, that gives them freedom to act in their own interest, and that protects them where they cannot protect themselves, can properly be regarded as class legislation or as anything but as a measure taken in the interest of the whole people, whose partnership in right action we are trying to establish and make real and practical. [15]

Wilson was also supportive of the principle of minimum wage legislation, [16] even playing a part in a decision made by Henry Ford to introduce a $5 daily minimum wage for his female employees. [17]

In his work The State, Wilson had advocated a welfarist role for the state, arguing amongst its functions to be the provision of German-style insurance for workmen and care "for the poor and incapable." [18] Wilson was also a supporter of teacher's pensions [19] and mothers’ pensions (cash allowances for poor mothers), with he and his daughter inviting Henry Nell (“father of mothers’ pensions”) to discuss “means for spreading the mothers’ pension gospel.” [20] Wilson’s views on welfare were expressed on another occasion in his Notes for Five Lectures on Municipal Government (given at the Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences in November and December 1898), [21] in which he described various functions that he said municipal government must undertake, which included welfarist functions like Sanitation (“including parks, housing of poor and labouring classes etc.”) and “Guardianship and relief of destitute and helpless classes ruined by the city pressure”). [22] In the same notes Wilson argued that “Charities, e.g., should be taken from the sphere of private, voluntary organization and endeavour and made the imperative legal duty of the Whole. Relief of the poor, and a bettering of the conditions in which they live is as much a governmental function as Education (coming under the head, not only of human duty, but also of social sanitation). Private charities need not be prohibited.” [23]

At some point during his political career, Wilson commissioned members of the Fraternal Order of Eagles to study old age pension laws overseas to see if such laws could be introduced in the United States. As noted by one state senator in later years, “It was learned in this way that institutional care for the aged was costly.” [24] Pensions for federal civil servants were introduced in 1920, [25] but it wasn’t until 1935 when legislation was passed establishing a national system of old age pensions. [26]

While serving as governor of New Jersey, Wilson's views on welfare were arguably reflected in the platform adopted by the New Jersey Democratic Party in 1912, the authorship of which has been attributed to Wilson, [27] which included a plank calling for more intervention in the field of health and welfare:

We also favour and endorse the efforts which our State and its various institutions are making for the preservation of the public health, and for the purpose of effectually coping with the problem of tuberculosis we believe in the establishment of a system of expert medical inspection of all schoolchildren and the enlargement under expert supervision of a sanitarium for those affected with incipient tuberculosis. To those unfortunates who by reasons of defect of intellect, poverty or enforced confinement are at the present time wards of the State we favour their maintenance and the bestowal upon them of all care possible, so that their deficiencies may be remedied or their condition at least ameliorated.” [28]

Wilson expressed similar views in 1913, arguing that workers had the right to a living wage and noting:

There can be no equality of opportunity, the first essential of justice in the body politic, if men and women and children be not shielded in their lives, their very vitality, from the consequences of great industrial and social processes which they can not alter, control or singly cope with. Society must see to it that it does not itself crush or weaken or damage its own constituent parts. The first duty of law is to keep sound the society it serves. Sanitary laws, pure food laws, and laws determining the conditions of labor which individuals are powerless to determine for themselves are intimate parts of the very business of justice and legal efficiency. One of the most hopeful signs of the times is the fact that we are beginning to hear and to understand this 'solemn moving undertone of our life,' and our social legislation is showing signs of an earnest desire to alleviate the dead burden of misery under which our toilers stagger and groan. The State is gradually growing, through the development of its so-called police power, into the stature and dignity of 'parens patrae,' guardian or custodian of the public welfare. [29]

In various campaign speeches in 1912, Wilson spoke of the need for greater social justice in America. In one speech he argued how

we must see to it that there is no overcrowding, that there is no bad sanitation, that there is no unnecessary spread of avoidable diseases, that there is every safeguard against accidents, that women are not driven to impossible tasks and children not permitted to spend their energy before it is fit to be spent, that all the hope of the race must be preserved, and that men must be preserved according to their individual needs and not according to the programs of industry merely. [30]

In another speech, Wilson put forward a similar case for greater government intervention in society, arguing that

A government is intended to serve the people that live under it. Now, there are a great many ways in which to serve the people that live under it, and our government has neglected some of those ways. We are only just now beginning to learn how to take care of our people, to prevent accidents, where accidents are obviously apt to occur in a great many employments, to prevent unreasonable hours of labor, to prevent women [from] being overworked, to prevent young children from being worked at all. There are a score of things which nowadays we regard as the function of the government, but government has been neglectful of these things because it has been taking care of the particular groups of people and not thinking of the life of the people as a whole. And now the American people, high and wide, are looking directly at the government, are putting away all notions about it. [31]

Wilson also spoke of the need to lift people out of poverty, stating in a speech he made in December 1912 [30]

"God knows that the poor suffer enough in this country already, and a man would hesitate to take a single step that would increase the number of the poor, or the burdens of the poor, but we must move for the emancipation of the poor, and that emancipation will come from our own emancipation from the errors of our minds as to what constitutes prosperity. Prosperity does not exist for a nation unless it be pervasive. Prosperity is not a thing which can be consumed privately or by a small number of persons, and the amount of wealth in a nation is very much less important than the accessibility of wealth in a nation. The more people you make it accessible to the more energy you call forth, until presently, if you carry the process far enough, you get almost the zest of a creative act.” [32]

Also, while not a socialist, Wilson agreed with the socialist program the Labour Party (UK) put forward in 1918, with the exception of its call for a minimum wage due to Wilson’s uncertainty over how this would be maintained. [33] Amongst the program’s many proposals included ending joblessness and an expansion of unemployment benefit coverage. [34]

Although the role of government under Wilson did expand in a progressive direction, the New Freedom did not go as far as his rhetoric suggested it would. For instance, while supportive of benefits for workers such as pensions, injury compensation, and profit-sharing plans (noting in his book "The New Freedom" how various companies had introduced such benefits "in good faith" to their employees), [35] Wilson and his administration never pushed legislation through Congress extending these benefits to the entire workforce, while a national health insurance system of the kind advocated by Roosevelt was never established. Despite this, the New Freedom did much to extend the power of the federal government in social and economic affairs, and arguably paved the way for future reform programs such as the New Deal and the Great Society.

Legislation and programs

Note: This listing contains reforms drawn up by the Wilson Administration as part of its New Freedom program together with wartime reforms and reforms drawn up by individual Congressmen. The latter two have been included because it is arguable that the progressive nature of these reforms was compatible with the liberalism of the New Freedom.

Farmers

Labor

Health and welfare

Wartime measures

Veterans

Education

Constitutional

Environment and public works

Conservation

Books

In 1913 Woodrow Wilson's book The New Freedom was published, detailing his thoughts about the concepts and program. [99] He had previously written two other books, Congressional Government published in 1900, followed in 1901 by When a Man Comes to Himself.

See also

Notes

  1. 1 2 3 "Woodrow Wilson's 'New Freedom': Progressive Reforms & Their Legacy". SOCIALSTUDIESHELP.COM. 2023-10-16.
  2. "The Survey v.36 1916". HathiTrust.
  3. Clements, Kendrick A. (December 5, 1992). The Presidency of Woodrow Wilson. University Press of Kansas. ISBN   978-0-7006-0524-8 via Google Books.
  4. Jr, Arthur Stanley Link (December 8, 2015). Wilson, Volume II: The New Freedom. Princeton University Press. ISBN   978-1-4008-7582-5 via Google Books.
  5. Strum, Philippa (1987). "Louis D. Brandeis, the New Freedom and the State". Mid America. 69 (3): 105–124.
  6. Link, Arthur S. (1954). Woodrow Wilson and the progressive era : 1910-1917. New York: Harper & Row, Publishers. pp. 69–72. OCLC   475754.
  7. The Senate, 1789-1989: Addresses on the history of the United States Senate By Robert C. Byrd, Mary Sharon Hall, Wendy Wolff, 1988, p. 408.
  8. The Democratic text-book 1916, p. 132.
  9. Warren, Elizabeth (2 June 2011). Prosperity, Peace and Respect: How Presidents Manage the People'S Agenda. Xlibris Corporation. ISBN   9781462884049 via Google Books.
  10. Hoover, Herbert (1 October 1992). The Ordeal of Woodrow Wilson. Woodrow Wilson Center Press. ISBN   9780943875415 via Google Books.
  11. "Woodrow Wilson: 7th Annual Message".
  12. The Folly of Empire What George W. Bush Could Learn from Theodore Roosevelt and Woodrow Wilson By John B. Judis, 2010, P84
  13. Morning Oregonian., July 20, 1912, Page 8
  14. Railway AND Locomotive Engineering a Practical Journal of Motive Power, Rolling Stock and Appliances. XXV (1): 55.{{cite journal}}: Missing or empty |title= (help)[ title missing ]
  15. The Democratic Text-book 1912, p. 351.
  16. Evening True American 13 Mar 1913
  17. The Toledo News-Bee 25 Oct 1916
  18. Woodrow Wilson (1890): The State: Elements of Historical and Practical Politics. Chapter XV: The Functions of Government, p. 614.
  19. The Papers Of Woodrow Wilson Volume 17 1908-1908, P.510-511
  20. "Miss Wilson to Aid the Children". St. Petersburg Daily Times. March 5, 1913.
  21. The Papers of Woodrow Wilson Volume 11 By Woodrow Wilson, Arthur Stanley Link, 1971, p. 74.
  22. The Papers of Woodrow Wilson Volume 11 By Woodrow Wilson, Arthur Stanley Link, 1971, p. 77
  23. The Papers of Woodrow Wilson Volume 11 By Woodrow Wilson, Arthur Stanley Link, 1971, p. 84.
  24. "The Meriden Daily Journal". The Meriden Daily Journal via Google Books.
  25. The Federal Civil Service System and the Problem of Bureaucracy The Economics and Politics of Institutional Change By Ronald N. Johnson, Gary D. Libecap, 2007, P.91
  26. Historical Background and Development of Social Security Pre-Social Security Period Traditional Sources of Economic Security
  27. As noted by the editor(s) on p. 305 of The Papers Of Woodrow Wilson, Volume 12, 1912, Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 1978: “While there is no direct evidence about the authorship of this document, internal evidence, vocabulary, phrasing, and style all point to Wilson as the principal author.”
  28. "Trenton True American - Google News Archive Search". Trenton True American. Trenton, New Jersey. October 2, 1912.[ title missing ]
  29. The Use of Cost-of-living Figures in Wage Adjustments By Elma B. Carr, Chap. V.-Industrial agencies, p. 319, United States. Bureau of Labor Statistics 1925
  30. 1 2 John Wells Davidson (ed.). A Crossroads Of Freedom – The 1912 Campaign Speeches of Woodrow Wilson. p. 191.
  31. John Wells Davidson (ed.). A Crossroads Of Freedom – The 1912 Campaign Speeches of Woodrow Wilson. p. 165.
  32. Year Book of the New York Southern Society. New York Southern Society. p. 47.[ year needed ]
  33. THE PAPERS OF WOODROW WILSON ARTHUR S. LINK, EDITOR Volume 46 January 16 - March 12, 1918, PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS, PRINCETON, NEW JERSEY, 1984, P.435-436
  34. "Labour and the new social order; a report on reconstruction". London : Labour Party. December 5, 1918 via Internet Archive.
  35. "From Woodrow Wilson". academic.brooklyn.cuny.edu.
  36. Extension Service Review for March 1941, vol. 12. no.3, p. 44.
  37. Annual Reports of the Department of Agriculture, For the Year Ended June 30, 1916, Report of the Secretary of Agriculture, Reports of Chiefs, p. 4
  38. Eight years with Wilson's cabinet. With a personal estimate of the President by David F. Houston, volume 1, p. 207.
  39. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Nugent, Walter. Progressivism.
  40. 1 2 Encyclopedia of South Carolina. Somerset Publishers.
  41. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Congressional Record, Sixty-Fourth Congress, First Session. Volume LIII, Part 13. (Pages 12587 to 14173), p. 13317
  42. Annals of Iowa A Historical Quarterly. 1990. p. 699.
  43. Sanders, Elizabeth. Roots of reform: farmers, workers, and the American state, 1877–1917.
  44. Clements, Kendrick A. (December 5, 1992). The Presidency of Woodrow Wilson. University Press of Kansas. ISBN   978-0-7006-0524-8 via Google Books.
  45. A Brief History of Farmers Home Administration. February 1988. p. 2.
  46. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Coopers International Journal, Volumes 26-27. Coopers International Union of North America. 1916. p. 496.
  47. 1 2 Congressional Record, Sixty-Fourth Congress, First Session. Volume LIII, Part 13. (Pages 12587 TO 14173). p. 13318.
  48. 1 2 Congressional Record, Sixty-Fourth Congress, First Session. Volume LIII, Part 13. (Pages 12587 TO 14173). p. 12913.
  49. Pattern Makers' Journal, Volumes 29-31, Page 8, 1918
  50. Political Science Quarterly Volume 31, 1916, p. 3.
  51. 1 2 3 4 Labor, United States Department of (December 5, 1977). "Labor Firsts in America". The Department via Google Books.
  52. Annual Report of the Surgeon General of the Public Health Service of the United States for the Fiscal Year 1914, p. 314.
  53. McGerr, Michael E. (1 January 2005). A Fierce Discontent: The Rise and Fall of the Progressive Movement in America, 1870-1920. Oxford University Press. ISBN   9780195183658 via Google Books.
  54. States, United (December 5, 1915). "Public Statutes at Large of the United States of America". U.S. Government Printing Office via Google Books.
  55. Epstein, Lee; Walker, Thomas G. (2 October 2014). Constitutional Law for a Changing America: A Short Course. CQ Press. ISBN   9781483323930 via Google Books.
  56. "WB - Our History (An Overview 1920 - 2012)". Dol.gov. Retrieved 2013-07-15.
  57. Reef, Catherine. Working in America.
  58. "Organized Labor 26 August 1916 — California Digital Newspaper Collection". cdnc.ucr.edu.
  59. William Dunseath Eaton; Harry C. Read (March 2005). Woodrow Wilson: His Life and Work. Kessinger. ISBN   978-1-4191-7182-6 . Retrieved 2013-07-15.
  60. Van Horn, Carl E.; Schaffner, Herbert A. (2003). Work in America: A–M. Bloomsbury Academic. ISBN   978-1-57607-676-7 . Retrieved 2013-07-15.
  61. Woodrow Wilson second Edition Revised by Arthur Walwort, 1965, Chapter XXI: Reconciliation, p. 410.
  62. The Democratic Text Book 1916 By Democratic National Committee (U.S.), 1916, p. 403.
  63. The Mosquito Crusades: A History Of The American Anti-Mosquito Movement From The Reed Commission To The First Earth Day by Gordon Patterson
  64. Navigation Laws of the United States 1940 Compiled by Frederick K. Arzt, LL. B., p. 387.
  65. Public health reports United States. Public Health Service, United States. Marine Hospital Service, 1926
  66. 1 2 The National government and public health by James Alner Tobey
  67. Ellen Wilson - American First Lady, Progressive Era Activist at the Encyclopædia Britannica
  68. The Code of Federal Regulations of the United States of America Having General Applicability and Legal Effect in Force June 1, 1938, Volume 11, 1939 p. 300
  69. Berger, Daniel E. Dempster, Todd R. (1 January 2002). Lighthouses of the Great Lakes. Voyageur Press. ISBN   9781610604376 via Google Books.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  70. Social Security History. Ssa.gov (1923-03-05). Retrieved on 2013-07-15.
  71. Annual Report of the Secretary of the Treasury on the State of the Finances for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 1914, with Appendices, p. 159–160.
  72. Annual Report of the Secretary of the Treasury on the State of the Finances for the Fiscal Year Ended June 30, 1914, with Appendices, p. 160.
  73. Ayers, Edward; Gould, Lewis; Oshinsky, David; Soderlund, Jean (22 October 2008). American Passages: A History of the United States, Volume II: Since 1865. Cengage Learning. ISBN   978-0547166353 via Google Books.
  74. "Milestones in U.S. Food and Drug Law History - Significant Dates in U.S. Food and Drug Law History". Food and Drug Administration . Archived from the original on July 9, 2009.
  75. The Public Health Service commissioned officers orientation guide, 1984 By United States. Public Health Service. Office of Management, 1984, p. 2.
  76. Social Security Online History Pages. Ssa.gov (2005-11-26). Retrieved on 2013-07-15.
  77. Wire, Daniel E. Dempster, Elinor De (2004). Lighthouses of the South . Voyageur Press. p.  90. ISBN   9780896586031 via Internet Archive. woodrow wilson postwar pensions.{{cite book}}: CS1 maint: multiple names: authors list (link)
  78. Oberlander, H. Peter; Newbrun, Eva M. (1 November 2011). Houser: The Life and Work of Catherine Bauer, 1905-64. UBC Press. ISBN   9780774842006 via Google Books.
  79. 1 2 In Transit Volumes 27–28 1919, p. 5
  80. "Credit for Military Service Under Civilian Federal Employee Retirement Systems" (PDF). Archived from the original (PDF) on 2009-05-11.
  81. History of Nova Scotia, 2000 April 15-30 [ usurped ]. Newscotland1398.ca. Retrieved on 2013-07-15.
  82. Dubofsky, Melvyn (1 January 2013). The Oxford Encyclopedia of American Business, Labor, and Economic History. Oxford University Press. ISBN   9780199738816 via Google Books.
  83. The Institutionalist Tradition In Labor Economics by Dell P. Champlin and Janet T. Knoedler
  84. The Pendulum of Politics: Today's Politics from Yesterday's History by Craig Parkinson
  85. 1 2 The Enduring Vision: A History of the American People, Since 1865: Volume 2 by Paul S. Boyer, Joseph F. Kett, Clifford Clark, Sandra Hawley, and Andrew Rieser
  86. From Progressivism to Prosperity: World War I and American Society by Neil A. Wynn
  87. "Social Security Bulletin". Social Security Board. December 5, 1953 via Google Books.
  88. Hamowy, Ronald (1 January 2008). Government and Public Health in America. Edward Elgar Publishing. ISBN   9781847204257 via Google Books.
  89. The greatest generation comes home: the veteran in American society by Michael D. Gambone
  90. Domestic Colonies The Turn Inward to Colony By Barbara Arneil, 2017, p. 78.
  91. Federal health administration in the United States by Robert Devore Leigh
  92. War's Waste: Rehabilitation in World War I America by Beth Linker
  93. Encyclopedia of Multiculturalism: Slavery-Zoot-suit riots by Susan Auerbach
  94. Vision and aging: crossroads for service delivery Alberta L. Orr
  95. The politics of American Federalism by Daniel Judah Elazar
  96. 1 2 Time-Life Books, Library of Nations: United States, Sixth European English language printing, 1989
  97. How to draw the life and times of Woodrow Wilson by Melody S. Mis
  98. Mothers Day and Other Family Days, Volume 37 by Reagan Miller
  99. Wilson, Woodrow (1913). The New Freedom. New York, New York: Doubleday, Page & Company. Retrieved 30 January 2015.

Further reading