Umma

Last updated • 8 min readFrom Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia
    Umma
    Iraq physical map.svg
    Archaeological site icon (red).svg
    Umma
    Shown within Iraq
    Location Dhi Qar Province, Iraq
    Region Mesopotamia
    Coordinates 31°40′02″N45°53′15″E / 31.66722°N 45.88750°E / 31.66722; 45.88750
    TypeSettlement
    Site notes
    Excavation dates1854, 1885, 1999-2002, 2017-2019
    ArchaeologistsWilliam Loftus, John Punnett Peters, Nawala Ahmed Al-Mutawalli, Drahoslav Hulínek
    Location of the city of Umma in Sumer Sumer map.jpg
    Location of the city of Umma in Sumer

    Umma (Sumerian : 𒄑𒆵𒆠) [1] in modern Dhi Qar Province in Iraq, was an ancient city in Sumer. There is some scholarly debate about the Sumerian and Akkadian names for this site. [2] Traditionally, Umma was identified with Tell Jokha. More recently it has been suggested that it was located at Umm al-Aqarib, less than 7 km (4.3 mi) to its northwest or was even the name of both cities. [3] [4] One or both were the leading city of the Early Dynastic kingdom of Gišša, with the most recent excavators putting forth that Umm al-Aqarib was prominent in EDIII but Jokha rose to preeminence later. The town of KI.AN was also nearby. [5] KI.AN, which was destroyed by Rimush, a ruler of the Akkadian Empire. There are known to have been six gods of KI.AN including Gula KI.AN and Sara KI.AN. [6]

    Contents

    The tutelary gods of Umma were Sara and Ninura. It is known that the ED ruler Ur-Lumma built, a temple to the god Enki-gal and one to the god Nagar-pa'e at Umma. [7]

    In the early Sumerian literary composition Inanna's descent to the netherworld, Inanna dissuades demons from the netherworld from taking Shara, patron of Umma, who was living in squalor. [8]

    History

    The site was occupied at least as far back as the Uruk period. A number of proto-cuneiform came from there. While most early textual sources are from Early Dynastic III, a few tablets and a plaque from ED I/II came from there. [9]

    Early Dynastic period

    Imprisoned man of Umma on the Stele of the Vultures Imprisoned man of Umma on the Stele of the Vultures.jpg
    Imprisoned man of Umma on the Stele of the Vultures

    Because the two sites were not excavated until modern times, based on the many looted texts available to them, earlier archaeologists grouped together the ancient cities during the Early Dynastic period of Gišša and Umma into the single geographic name of Umma. Modern excavation at these sites has clarified that. [2] Gišša ceased occupation after the ED and only one ruler is known, based on a lapis lazuli bead reading "To the goddess Inanna, Aka, king of Gišša (dedicated this bead)". [7]

    Best known for its long frontier conflict with Lagash, as reported c.2400 BC by Entemena, [10] [11] the city reached its zenith c.2350 BC, under the rule of Lugal-Zage-Si who also controlled Ur and Uruk.

    Sargonic period

    An Early Dynastic inscription of Lugalannatum from Umma (Collection of the Louvre Museum) Gutian inscription-AO 4783-gradient.jpg
    An Early Dynastic inscription of Lugalannatum from Umma (Collection of the Louvre Museum)

    Under the Akkadian Empire Umma was a major power and economic center rivaled only by Adab and Uruk. Eleven governors under Akkad are known as well as two who may have been under Gutium. One, Lu-Utu, reports building a temple for Ninhursag and another for Ereshkigal. Namahni, a governor from the time of Iarlagan of Gutium, records building the E-ula temple of Ninura. [12] [13] The Sargonic period ruler of Umma Lugalanatum built the temple E-gidru there.

    "Lugalannatum prince of Umma... built the E.GIDRU [Sceptre] Temple at Umma, buried his foundation deposit [and] regulated the orders. At that time, Si'um was king of Gutium." [13]

    Ur III period

    Clay tablet. Delivery certificate. Reign of Shu-Sin of Ur, 21st century BCE. From Umma, Iraq. Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin Clay tablet. Delivery certificate. Reign of Shu-Sin of Ur, 21st century BCE. From Umma, Iraq. Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin.jpg
    Clay tablet. Delivery certificate. Reign of Shu-Sin of Ur, 21st century BCE. From Umma, Iraq. Vorderasiatisches Museum, Berlin

    Under the Ur III dynasty, Umma became an important provincial center. Several governors of Umma under Ur are known, Aa-kala, Dadaga, and Ur-Lisi, all sons of one Ur-Nigar, and Ninbilia, wife of Aa-kala. [14] [15] [16] Most of the over 30,000 tablets recovered from the site are administrative and economic texts from that time. [17] They permit an excellent insight into affairs in Umma. [18] A year name of Ur III ruler Shu-Sin was "Year Shu-Sin the king of Ur built the temple of Shara in Umma". The next ruler Ibbi-Sin also had a year name of "Year Ibbi-Sin the king of Ur built the temple of Shara in Umma". The Umma calendar of Shulgi (c.21st century BC) is the immediate predecessor of the later Babylonian calendar, and indirectly of the post-exilic Hebrew calendar.

    In the following Isin-Larsa period, a ruler of Larsa, Sumuel (c. 1894-1866 BC), lists as one of his later year names "Year Umma was destroyed".

    Archaeology

    Tell Jokha

    Aerial view of Umma Aerial view of Umma, following pillage after the US invasion 1.jpg
    Aerial view of Umma

    The site of Tell Jokha was visited by William Loftus in 1854 and John Punnett Peters of the University of Pennsylvania in 1885. Peters found it to be half covered with sand dunes and found fragments of worked stone and copper fragments. [19] [20] In the early 1900s, many illegally excavated Umma tablets from the Third Dynasty of Ur began to appear on the antiquities market. [21] From 1999 to 2002 Jokha was worked by an Iraqi team led by Nawala Ahmed Al-Mutawalli, recovering a number of tablets and bullae from the Early Dynastic, Sargonic, Ur III, and Old Babylonian periods as well as an Ur III period temple and Old Babylonian residences. The cuneiform tablets are in the process of being published. [22] [23] [4] [24] [25] In 2016, a team from the Slovak Archaeological and Historical Institute led by Drahoslav Hulínek began excavations at Tell Jokha focusing on the Temple of Shara. A trench (Trench 1) excavated in 2016 showed the temple had two construction phases (Level 3 and 4). Level 4 is thought to date from the Old Akkadian period. In 2017 a square at the top (Trench 2) of the tell was opened, amidst numerous looter holes, and at Level 5 found Early Dynastic construction. In 2019 and 2020 eighteen cuneiform tablets from the Old Babylonian, Ur III, Old Akkadian and Early Dynastic periods were found in Trench 2, three in situ. A topographic survey showed that in the Early Dynastic period Umma reached an area of 400 hectares, with a 40 hectare city center. [26] [27]

    Umm al-Aqarib (Gišša)

    Map of a property belonging to the city of Ur III Umma, indicating the acreage of each parcel Map Umma Louvre AO5677.jpg
    Map of a property belonging to the city of Ur III Umma, indicating the acreage of each parcel

    The site of Umm al-Aqarib (located at 45.80°E longitude and 31.60°N latitude) lies about 6 kilometers southeast of Tell Jokha, covers about 5 square kilometers and is made up of 21 mounds the largest of which is 20 meters above the level of the plain. It is thought to be the ancient city of Gišša and was abandoned after the Early Dynastic period. The location was first visited by John Punnett Peters in the late 1800s, finding it relatively free from sand and featuring two prominent elevations of baked bricks set with bitumen. [20] It was excavated for a total of 7 seasons in 1999–2002 (led by Donny George Youkhanna and Haider A. Urebi) and 2008–2010 (led by Taha Kerim Abod) under difficult conditions. [28] [29] At Umm al-Aqarib, archaeologists uncovered levels from the Early Dynastic Period (c. 2900–2300 BC), including residences, palaces, and several monumental buildings, including two Early Dynastic temples (the White Temple and Temple H). About 70 "cuneiform sources" were also excavated. [30] [31] [32] [33] The tutelary god is thought to be Ama-usum-ga/Usumgal-ana. [34]

    Tell Shmet

    Stone tablet re Il, king of Umma, c. 2400 BC "For ..., Il, king of Umma, son of Eandamu, grandson of Enakale king of Umma, built his/her temple" Stone tablet re Il, king of Umma, c. 2400 BC - Oriental Institute Museum, University of Chicago - DSC07155.JPG
    Stone tablet re Il, king of Umma, c. 2400 BC "For ..., Il, king of Umma, son of Eandamu, grandson of Enakale king of Umma, built his/her temple"

    The site of Tell Shmet (also Tell Schmidt and Tell Shmid) also lies nearby, around 10 kilometers to the northwest of Umma and within visual distance of Zabala. It is on the banks of the eastern branch of the Euphrates river just above the canal leading to Zabala. It was part of the Umma province in the Ur III period. The site measures 990 by 720 meters (712,800 square meters). The main Sargonic and Ur III remains of the site were destroyed by a Ministry of Agriculture program to plant trees so as to prevent sand dunes. In response to looting which began in 1994 the Iraqi State Board of Antiquities and Heritage conducted salvage excavations in 2001 and 2002 under Mohammad Sabri Abdulraheem. [35] [36] [37] [38] All of the paper records of the excavation were lost in looting of residential areas after the 2003 war. Plano-convex bricks and a residential area of the Early Dynastic III and Akkadian periods were uncovered. Finds included 67 clay cuneiform tablets, dozens of cylinder seals, and a number of stone and metal objects. The tablets mostly date ED III with the latest being Ur III. The tablets support the proposal that the ancient name of the site was Ki.anki. They mention the names of the gods Ninazu and Dumuzi-Maru. Only six of the tablets have been published. [39]

    Previous textual analysis had indicated that KI.AN was very near to Zabala. [40] During the reign of Rimush, second ruler of the Akkadian Empire, KI.AN, under its governor Lugal-KA, joined a regional revolt and was defeated. [41] In the Ur III period KI.AN had an ensi (governor). In that period it is known to have had a temple to the deified ruler Shulgi (called "e-dSulgi-ra") as well as temples to the gods Šara, Ninurra, Amarsuena, Geštinanna, Dumuzi, Gula, Ninlagaša, and Nine'e. [42] [43] [44]

    Looting

    During the 2003 invasion of Iraq, after Coalition bombing began, looters descended upon the site which is now pockmarked with hundreds of ditches and pits. The prospects for future official excavation and research were seriously compromised in the process. [45] In 2011, Global Heritage Network, which monitors threats to cultural heritage sites in developing nations, released aerial images comparing Umma in 2003 and 2010, showing a landscape devastated by looters' trenches during that time—approximately 1.12 square km in total. [46] Confiscated Umma area cuneiform tablets continue to make their way to the Museum of Iraq, including a group of 1500 in 2009. [47]

    List of rulers

    Although the first dynasty of Umma has become well-known based on mentions in inscriptions contemporaneous with other dynasties from the Early Dynastic (ED) III period; it was not inscribed onto the Sumerian King List (SKL). The first dynasty of Umma preceded the dynasty of Akkad in a time in which Umma exercised considerable influence in the region. Only a single ruler (Lugal-zage-si) from Umma was named on the SKL; however, his name appears as the sole ruler for the third dynasty of Uruk. The following list should not be considered complete:

    Portrait or inscriptionRulerApprox. date and length of reign (Middle Chronology)Comments, notes, and references for mentions
    Early Dynastic II period (c. 2700 – c.2600 BC)
    Predynastic Umma (c.2900 – c.2500 BC)
    Ak gal-ukkin.jpg (Akinana)Uncertain; this ruler may have fl.c.2900 – c.2600 BC sometime during the Early Dynastic (ED) period [48]
    • Historicity certain
    • Same person as Aga (?)
    Early Dynastic IIIa period (c.2600 – c.2500 BC)
    (Parasagnudi)
    𒉺𒉈𒅍𒃲𒌇
    Uncertain; these two rulers may have fl.c.2600 – c.2500 BC sometime during the ED IIIa period
    (Eabzu)
    Portrait or inscriptionRulerApprox. date and length of reign (MC)Comments, notes, and references for mentions
    Early Dynastic IIIb period (c.2500 – c.2350 BC)
    First dynasty of Umma / Umma I dynasty (c.2500 – c.2230 BC)
    Pabilgagaltuku
    𒉺𒉈𒅍𒃲𒌇
    r.c. 2500 BC
    Imprisoned man of Umma on the Stele of the Vultures.jpg Ush ("Ninta")
    𒍑
    r.c. 2455 BC
    • Historicity certain
    • Held the title of, "Governor of Umma"
    • temp. of Akurgal [48]
    Enakalle on the plate of queen Bara-irnun.jpg Enakalle
    𒂗𒀉𒆗𒇷
    r.c. 2445 BC
    (8 years)
    • Historicity certain
    • Held the title of, "Governor of Umma"
    • temp. of Eannatum [50]
    Ur-Lumma, king of Umma, son of En-a-Kale tablet.jpg Ur-Lumma
    𒌨𒀭𒈝𒂷
    r.c. 2425 BC
    (12 years)
    • Son of Enakalle
    • Held the title of, "Governor of Umma"
    • temp. of Enannatum I [50]
    Stone tablet re Il, king of Umma, c. 2400 BC - Oriental Institute Museum, University of Chicago - DSC07155 (orientation).jpg Il
    𒅍
    r.c. 2420 BC
    (15 years)
    • Cousin of Ur-Lumma
    • Held the title of, "King of Umma"
    • temp. of Entemena [48]
    This cuneiform text gives the city of Umma's account of its long-running border dispute with Lagash. Circa 2350 BCE. From Umma, Iraq. The British Museum, London.jpg Gishakidu
    𒄑𒊮𒆠𒄭
    r.c. 2400 BC
    (5 years)
    Me'anneduUncertain
    (29 years) [49] [51]
    Ushurdu [49] Uncertain
    (9 years)
    Edin [49] Uncertain
    (6 years)
    Lugalzagesi king of Uruk king of the Land son of Ukush.jpg Ukush
    𒌑𒌑
    r.c. 2350 BC
    Proto-Imperial period (c.2350 – c.2230 BC)
    Prisoner exiting a cage, on an Akkadian Empire victory stele circa 2300 BCE, Louvre Museum.jpg Lugal-zage-si
    𒈗𒍠𒄀𒋛
    r.c. 2340 BC
    (8 years)
    Meser.c. 2330 BC
    EnnalumUncertain
    (6 years)
    ShurushkenUncertain
    Portrait or inscriptionRulerApprox. date and length of reign (MC)Comments, notes, and references for mentions
    Gutian period (c.2230 – c.2112 BC)
    Second dynasty of Umma / Umma II dynasty (c.2230 – c.1866 BC)
    Gutian inscription-AO 4783-gradient.jpg Lugalannatum
    𒈗𒀭𒈾𒁺
    r.c. 2130 BC
    Ur III period (c.2112 – c.2004 BC)
    Ur-Nigarr.c. 2061 BC
    • Son of Girini (?)
    • temp. of Shulgi
    Ur-Lisir.c. 2038 BC
    (23 years)
    • Son of Ur-Nigar
    Aa-kalar.c. 2029 BC
    (9 years)
    • Brother of Ur-Lisi
    Dadagar.c. 2022 BC
    (7 years)
    • Brother of Ayakalla
    Ur-E'eUncertain
    • Brother of Dadaga
    Lu-HayaUncertain
    • Son of Ur-E'e
    An official of Umma, c.2400 BC
    Diorite statue of Lupad, official in town of Umma, Early Dynastic Period III, c. 2400 BC.jpg
    Upad of Umma.jpg
    Diorite statue of Lupad, an official of the city of Umma, with inscriptions recording the purchase of land in Lagash. Early Dynastic Period III, c.2400 BC. [54]

    See also

    References

    1. "ORACC – Umma".
    2. 1 2 Lambert, W. G. (1990). "The Names of Umma". Journal of Near Eastern Studies . 49 (1): 75–80. doi:10.1086/373421. ISSN   0022-2968. JSTOR   544410. S2CID   162374749.
    3. Bartasch, Vitali (2015). "On the Sumerian City UB-meki, the Alleged "Umma"". Cuneiform Digital Library Bulletin. 2. ISSN   1540-8760.
    4. 1 2 Almamori, H. O., "Gišša (Umm Al-Aqarib), Umma (Jokha), and Lagaš in the Early Dynastic III Period", Al-Rafidan 35, pp. 1–37, 2014
    5. Marek Stępień, "The Economic Status of Governors in Ur III Times: An Example of the Governor of Umma", Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 64, pp. 17–30, 2012
    6. Peat, J. A., "An Offering - List from the Third Dynasty of Ur", Revue d’Assyriologie et d’archéologie Orientale, vol. 69, no. 1, pp. 19–22, 1975
    7. 1 2 Frayne, Douglas, "G͂iša and Umma", Pre-Sargonic Period: Early Periods Volume 1 (2700-2350 BC), University of Toronto Press, pp. 357-368, 2008 ISBN   978-0802035868
    8. "Inana's descent to the nether world". Electronic Text Corpus of Sumerian Literature . Retrieved 2021-07-22.
    9. Uruk period proto-cuneiform tablets from Umma
    10. Carrie Hritz, "The Umma-Lagash Border Conflict: A View from Above", The Umma-Lagash Border Conflict: A View from Above, From Sherds to Landscapes: Studies on the Ancient Near East in Honor of McGuire Gibson, Studies in Ancient Oriental Civilization 71, Chicago: The Oriental Institute, pp. 109-130, 2021 ISBN   978-1-61491-063-3
    11. Cooper, Jerrold S. (1983). Reconstructing history from ancient inscriptions : the Lagash-Umma border conflict. Malibu: Undena Publications. ISBN   0-89003-059-6. OCLC   10304478.
    12. Foster., Benjamin R., "Archives and Record-keeping in Sargonic Mesopotamia", Zeitschrift für Assyriologie und Vorderasiatische Archäologie, vol. 72, no. 1, pp. 1-27, 1982
    13. 1 2 Douglas R. Frayne, "Umma", The Sargonic and Gutian Periods (2334–2113), University of Toronto Press, pp. 261-268, 1993 ISBN   0-8020-0593-4
    14. Frayne, Douglas, "Table III: List of Ur III Period Governors", Ur III Period (2112-2004 BC), Toronto: University of Toronto Press, pp. xli-xliv, 1997
    15. T. Maeda, "Father of Akala and Dadaga, governors of Umma", ASJ 12, pp. 71 - 78, 1990
    16. P. A. Parr, "Ninhilia: Wife of Ayakala, Governor of Umma", JCS 26, pp. 90 – 111, 1974
    17. I. J. Gelb, "Sargonic Texts in the Louvre Museum", Materials for the Assyrian Dictionary 4, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1970 ISBN   978-0-22-662308-5
    18. Parr, P. A. (1972-06-01). "A Letter of Ur-Lisi, Governor of Umma". Journal of Cuneiform Studies. 24 (4): 135–136. doi:10.2307/1359635. ISSN   0022-0256. JSTOR   1359635. S2CID   163250537.
    19. Loftus, William K. (1857). Travels and Researches in Chaldaea and Susiana, Travels and Researches in Chaldaea and Susiana: With an Account of Excavations at Warka, the "Erech" of Nimrod, and Shush, "Shushan the Palace" of Esther, in 1849–52. Robert Carter & Brothers.
    20. 1 2 Peters, John P. (1897). Nippur; Or, Explorations and Adventures on the Euphrates: The Narrative of the University of Pennsylvania Expedition to Babylonia in the Years 1888–1890 (PDF). University of Pennsylvania Babylonian Expedition. Putnam.
    21. Georges Contenau, Contribution a l'Histoire Economique d'Umma, Librairie Champion, 1915
    22. Al-Mutawalli, N., "Excavation of Umma (modern Jokha), seasons 1 & 2.", Sumer 54, pp. 53-82, 2009
    23. Al-Harbi, H. Sh, N. A. Al-Mutawali, and K. M. Khaleel, "Jokha (Umma): The Excavation Results of the Third and Fourth Seasons (2001–2002)", Sumer 56, pp. 49-92, 2011
    24. Al-Mutawalli, N.. "Administrative Cuneiform Texts from Umma in the Iraq Museum Excavation of Shara Temple (1999–2000)", Sumer 55, pp. 45–86, 2010
    25. Mutawalli, Nawala Ahmed al-; Ismaʻel, Khalid Salim; Sallaberger, Walther; Harbi, Hamza Shahad al-; Otto, Adelheid (2019). Bullae from the Shara Temple = Wuṣūlāt at-tasallum (bulla) min maʻbad aš-Šārā. Harrassowitz Verlag. ISBN   978-3-447-11159-1. OCLC   1101969238.
    26. Drahoslav Hulínek and Tibor Lieskovský, "Report Archaeological project SAHI - Tell Jokha, 2016", Slovak Archaeological and Historical Institute, 2016
    27. Hulínek, Drahoslav, et al., eds., "Preliminary Report Archaeological Project SAHI-Tell Jokha, 2019: Season 3", Slovak Archaeological and Historical Institute-SAHI, 2020
    28. Almamori, H. A., "The Excavation Results of the Third and Fourth Seasons at Umm al-Aqarib (2001–2002)", Sumer 52, pp. 242–93, 2003-2004 (Arabic)
    29. Ławecka, Dorota, "Bent or Straight Axis? Temple Plans in Early Dynastic Southern Babylonia", Zeitschrift für Assyriologie und vorderasiatische Archäologie, vol. 104, no. 2, pp. 206-228, 2014
    30. Almamori, Haider Oraibi (2014). "The Early Dynastic Monumental Buildings at Umm Al-Aqarib". Iraq. 76: 149–187. doi:10.1017/irq.2014.10. ISSN   0021-0889. JSTOR   43307193. S2CID   232251022.
    31. Abid, Ameer Najim, "The architecture of white temples in the cities of ancient central and southern Mesopotamia (Uruk-Umm Al-Aqarib-Tal Al-Uqair) A comparative study", ISIN Journal 5, pp. 53-79, 2023
    32. Youkhanna, Donny George, H. O. Al-Mamori, and L. Werr, "Temple ‘H’ at Umm al Aqarib", Of Pots and Plans: Papers on the Archaeology and History of Mesopotamia and Syria presented to David Oates in Honour of his 75th Birthday. London: Nabu, pp. 379-385, 2002
    33. Oraibi, Almamori Haider Abdollwahed, "Umm al-Aqarib: an architectural and textual study of a Sumerian City", Dissertation, 2013
    34. Frayne, Douglas R., "The Struggle for Hegemony in ‘Early Dynastic II’Sumer", The Canadian Society for Mesopotamian Studies Journal 4, pp. 37-75, 2009
    35. Abdulraheem, M. S., "The final report of the excavations in Shmet – 1st season 2001", SBAH, Ministry of Culture, Rep. of Iraq (in Arabic), 2001
    36. Abdulraheem, M. S., "Prospecting at the site of Shmeet 2001–2002", Sumer 52, pp. 201–241 (in Arabic) 2003
    37. Abdulraheem, M. S., "The site of Shmet in the light of archaeological excavations", Unpublished Ph. D. thesis submitted to the Dept. of Archhaeology, College of Arts, University of Baghdad (in Arabic), 2014
    38. Abdulraheem, M. S. and B. K. Abboodi, "The final report of the excavations in Shmet – 2nd season 2002", SBAH, Ministry of Culture, Rep. of Iraq (in Arabic), 2002
    39. Salman Fahad, Sa’ad and Abdul-Qadir Abbas, Raghad., "Cuneiform Tablets from Shmet from the Excavation Season of 2001", Zeitschrift für Assyriologie und vorderasiatische Archäologie, vol. 110, no. 1, pp. 1-13, 2020
    40. Molina Martos, Manuel, Amir Zamani, and Sina Abaslou. "Two cuneiform tablets in the Four Seasons Museum of Arak, Iran", in Sentido de un empeño. Homenatge a Gregorio del Olmo Lete, pp, 369-373, 2021
    41. Douglas R. Frayne, "Akkad", The Sargonic and Gutian Periods (2334–2113), University of Toronto Press, pp. 5-218, 1993 ISBN   0-8020-0593-4
    42. R. McC. Adams and H. Nissen, "The Uruk Countryside: The Natural Setting of Urban Societies", Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1972 ISBN   0-226-00500-3
    43. Steinkeller, Piotr, "Babylonian priesthood during the third millennium BCE: between sacred and profane", Journal of ancient near eastern religions 19.1-2, pp. 112-151, 2019
    44. Maeda, Tohru, "Royal Inscriptions of Lugalzagesi and Sargon", Orient 40, pp. 3-30, 2005
    45. "Simon Jenkins: In Iraq's four-year looting frenzy, allies the vandals". the Guardian. 2007-06-07. Retrieved 2021-07-23.
    46. "Satellite Imagery Briefing: Monitoring Endangered Cultural Heritage Sites" (PDF). Global Heritage Fund . Retrieved 2021-07-23.
    47. Saadoon, Abather Rahi, "Sumerian Texts from the Archive of the Princess Šāt-Eštar in the Collections of the Iraq Museum", Iraq 80, pp. 213-231, 2018
    48. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 Marchesi, Gianni (January 2015). Sallaberger, Walther; Schrakamp, Ingo (eds.). "Toward a Chronology of Early Dynastic Rulers in Mesopotamia". History and Philology (ARCANE 3; Turnhout): 139–156.
    49. 1 2 3 4 5 6 Sallaberger, Walther; Schrakamp, Ingo (2015). History & Philology (PDF). Walther Sallaberger & Ingo Schrakamp (eds), Brepols. pp. 74–80. ISBN   978-2-503-53494-7.
    50. 1 2 3 Van De Mieroop, Marc (2004). A History of the Ancient Near East: Ca. 3000-323 BC. Wiley. pp. 50–51. ISBN   9780631225522.
    51. Armando Bramanti, "Three Administrative Texts from the Time of Me’annedu", Journal of Cuneiform Studies, vol. 69, pp. 33–47, 2017
    52. "Stele of Ushumgal". www.metmuseum.org.
    53. "Site officiel du musée du Louvre". cartelfr.louvre.fr.
    54. I. J. Gelb, P. Steinkeller, and R. M. Whiting Jr, "OIP 104. Earliest Land Tenure Systems in the Near East: Ancient Kudurrus", Oriental Institute Publications 104 Chicago: The Oriental Institute, 1989, 1991 ISBN 978-0-91-898656-6 Text Plates

    Further reading