1860 United States presidential election in Pennsylvania

Last updated

1860 United States presidential election in Pennsylvania
Flag of Pennsylvania.svg
  1856
November 6, 1860
1864  
  Abraham Lincoln by Alexander Hesler, 1860-restored (3x4 cropped).png
John C Breckinridge-04775-restored (3x4 cropped).jpg Senator Stephen A. Douglas (edited).png
Fusion
Nominee Abraham Lincoln
Party People's Fusion
Home state Illinois
Running mate Hannibal Hamlin
Electoral vote270
Popular vote268,030178,871
Percentage56.3%37.5%

Pennsylvania Presidential Election Results 1860.svg
County Results

President before election

James Buchanan
Democratic

Elected President

Abraham Lincoln
Republican

A presidential election was held in Pennsylvania on November 6, 1860, as part of the 1860 United States presidential election. The People's ticket of the former U.S. representative from Illinois's 7th congressional district and the senior U.S. senator from Maine Hannibal Hamlin defeated the Fusion ticket nominated by the Pennsylvania Democratic Party.

Contents

Lincoln was nominated by the 1860 Republican National Convention and ran as the candidate of the People's Party in Pennsylvania. [1] Formed in 1858, the party united Pennsylvania Republicans and Know Nothings on a protectionist platform that appealed to antislavery and nativist constituencies in both parties. [2] The Pennsylvania Democratic party selected its state ticket in advance of the 1860 Democratic National Conventions, which resulted in a split between the supporters of Stephen A. Douglas and John C. Breckinridge. The so-called "Reading ticket," named after the city in Pennsylvania where the state convention met, was composed of 15 Breckenridge supporters and 12 Douglas supporters; the electors agreed to vote for whichever candidate stood the best chance of defeating Lincoln in the event the fusion ticket carried the state. A minority of Douglas Democrats in Pennsylvania opposed this arrangement and nominated their own ticket of 27 candidates, including the 12 Douglas electors on the Reading ticket. [3] The split in the Democratic ranks effectively conceded the state to Lincoln, ending fears that the defection of protectionist voters to the Constitutional Union Party could cost Republicans the state's 27 electoral votes. [4]

General election

Results

Pennsylvania chose 27 electors on a statewide general ticket. Nineteenth-century election laws required voters to elect each member of the Electoral College individually, rather than as a group. This sometimes resulted in small differences in the number of votes cast for electors pledged to the same presidential candidate, if some voters did not vote for all the electors nominated by a party. [5]

Twelve candidates ran on both the Fusion ("Reading") and the "Straight" Douglas tickets; the official returns compiled by the secretary of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania record the total number of votes for each candidate but do not include a full breakdown by ticket. Joseph Laubach won 194,834 votes as a Fusion–Douglas elector, the highest total for an candidate endorsed on both tickets. John Alexander Ahl received the most votes of any candidate nominated exclusively on the Reading ticket, and his statewide result is shown here as the best approximation of support for the Fusion electors. Similarly, the result shown for the "Straight" Douglas electors reflects the highest total for a candidate nominated exclusively on the Douglas ticket. [3]

1860 United States presidential election in Pennsylvania [6]
PartyCandidateVotes%±%
People's Abraham Lincoln
Hannibal Hamlin
268,030 56.26 Increase2.svg 24.28
Fusion John C. Breckinridge
Joseph Lane;
Stephen A. Douglas
Herschel V. Johnson
178,87137.54Decrease2.svg 12.55
Douglas Democratic Stephen A. Douglas
Herschel V. Johnson
16,7653.52Increase2.svg 3.52
Constitutional Union John Bell
Edward Everett
12,7702.68Increase2.svg 2.68
Total votes476,437 100.00

Results by county

1860 United States presidential election in Pennsylvania by county [6]
CountyAbraham Lincoln
Republican
John C. Breckinridge
Stephen A. Douglas
Fusion
Stephen A. Douglas
Douglas Democratic
John Bell
Constitutional Union
Total
#%#%#%#%
Adams 2,72450.06%2,64448.59%360.66%380.70%5,442
Allegheny 16,72568.15%6,72527.40%5232.13%5702.32%24,543
Armstrong 3,35560.80%2,10838.20%50.09%500.91%5,518
Beaver 2,82462.66%1,62135.97%40.09%581.29%4,507
Bedford 2,50551.87%2,22446.06%140.29%861.78%4,829
Berks 6,70941.64%8,84654.91%4202.61%1360.84%16,111
Blair 3,05061.48%1,27525.70%2394.82%3978.00%4,961
Bradford 7,09176.17%2,18823.50%90.10%220.24%9,310
Bucks 6,44352.82%5,17442.41%4873.99%950.78%12,199
Butler 3,64060.60%2,33238.82%130.22%220.37%6,007
Cambria 2,27754.81%1,64339.55%1102.65%1242.99%4,154
Carbon 1,75850.97%1,30137.72%36910.70%210.61%3,449
Centre 3,02155.07%2,42344.17%260.47%160.29%5,486
Chester 7,77158.68%5,00837.81%2631.99%2021.53%13,244
Clarion 1,82946.67%2,07853.02%00.00%120.31%3,919
Clearfield 1,70247.80%1,83651.56%00.00%230.65%3,561
Clinton 1,73656.88%1,24440.76%722.36%00.00%3,052
Columbia 1,87343.17%2,36654.53%861.98%140.32%4,339
Crawford 5,77965.49%2,96133.56%620.70%220.25%8,824
Cumberland 3,59351.71%3,18345.81%260.36%1472.12%6,949
Dauphin 4,53162.18%2,39232.83%1952.68%1692.32%7,287
Delaware 3,18162.12%1,50029.29%1522.97%2885.62%5,121
Elk 40743.76%52356.24%00.00%00.00%930
Erie 6,16070.02%2,53128.77%170.19%901.02%8,798
Fayette 3,45449.82%3,30847.71%240.35%1472.12%6,933
Forest 10769.48%4730.52%00.00%00.00%154
Franklin 4,15156.37%2,51534.15%6228.45%761.03%7,364
Fulton 78845.05%91152.09%10.06%492.80%1,749
Greene 1,61437.34%2,66561.66%260.60%170.39%4,322
Huntingdon 3,08964.52%1,62233.88%551.15%220.46%4,788
Indiana 3,91074.07%1,34725.52%00.00%220.42%5,279
Jefferson 1,70459.81%1,13439.80%60.21%50.18%2,849
Juniata 1,49455.23%1,14742.40%20.07%622.29%2,705
Lancaster 13,35267.93%5,13526.12%7283.70%4412.24%19,656
Lawrence 2,93777.86%78820.89%160.42%310.82%3,772
Lebanon 3,86865.58%1,91732.50%100.17%1031.75%5,898
Lehigh 4,17049.28%4,09448.39%1451.71%520.61%8,461
Luzerne 7,30051.76%6,80348.24%00.00%00.00%14,103
Lycoming 3,49456.59%2,40238.91%1873.03%911.47%6,174
McKean 1,07764.49%59135.39%00.00%20.12%1,670
Mercer 3,85559.75%2,54639.46%20.03%490.76%6,452
Mifflin 1,70156.53%1,18939.51%832.76%361.20%3,009
Monroe 84435.21%1,26252.65%29112.14%00.00%2,397
Montgomery 5,82646.18%5,59044.31%5094.03%6905.47%12,615
Montour 1,04348.65%78636.66%31114.51%40.19%2,144
Northampton 3,83944.02%4,59752.71%1151.32%1711.96%8,722
Northumberland 2,42249.46%2,30647.09%971.98%721.47%4,897
Perry 2,37157.00%1,74341.90%80.19%380.91%4,160
Philadelphia 39,22350.78%21,61927.99%9,27412.01%7,1319.23%77,247
Pike 38131.41%83168.51%00.00%10.08%1,213
Potter 1,54574.78%52125.22%00.00%00.00%2,066
Schuylkill 7,56857.78%4,96837.93%4223.22%1391.06%13,097
Snyder 1,67863.25%91034.30%602.26%50.19%2,653
Somerset 3,21873.07%1,17526.68%10.02%100.23%4,404
Sullivan 42946.28%49753.61%00.00%10.11%927
Susquehanna 4,47063.62%2,54836.27%20.03%60.09%7,026
Tioga 4,75478.57%1,27721.10%110.18%90.15%6,051
Union 1,82468.31%81230.41%281.05%60.22%2,670
Venango 2,68057.96%1,93241.78%60.13%60.13%4,624
Warren 2,28467.67%1,08732.21%40.12%00.00%3,375
Washington 4,72453.69%3,97545.18%80.09%911.03%8,798
Wayne 2,85752.16%2,61847.80%00.00%20.04%5,477
Westmoreland 4,88750.33%4,79649.40%130.13%130.13%9,709
Wyoming 1,28650.81%1,23748.87%80.32%00.00%2,531
York 5,12843.60%5,49746.74%5624.78%5744.88%11,761
Total268,03056.26%178,87137.54%16,7653.52%12,7762.68%476,442

Analysis

Pennsylvania voted for the Republican candidate, Abraham Lincoln, over the fusion ticket. Lincoln won Pennsylvania by a margin of 18.72%. Lincoln's victory was the first of eighteen out of nineteen Republican victories in the state, as Pennsylvania would not vote Democratic again until Franklin D. Roosevelt in 1936, and would not vote for a different candidate again until Theodore Roosevelt’s third-party bid in 1912. Lincoln fashioned his victory in Pennsylvania out of Yankee and some Scots-Irish support.

Pennsylvania in the election was one of the four states that had a fusion ticket for the Democratic Party. The other three states were New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island.

The 1860 presidential election in Pennsylvania began a trend in which the state would vote the same as nearby Michigan in presidential elections, as the two states have voted for president in lockstep with each other on all but three occasions since Lincoln's victory – 1932, 1940, and 1976.

See also

References

  1. Holt 2017, p. 154.
  2. Foner 1995, p. 255.
  3. 1 2 Dubin 2002, p. 188n10.
  4. Holt 2017, pp. 154–55.
  5. Dubin 2002, p. xi.
  6. 1 2 Dubin 2002, pp. 180–81.

Bibliography