Basu's theorem

In statistics, Basu's theorem states that any boundedly complete minimal sufficient statistic is independent of any ancillary statistic. This is a 1955 result of Debabrata Basu. ^[1]

It is often used in statistics as a tool to prove independence of two statistics, by first demonstrating one is complete sufficient and the other is ancillary, then appealing to the theorem. ^[2] An example of this is to show that the sample mean and sample variance of a normal distribution are independent statistics, which is done in the Example section below. This property (independence of sample mean and sample variance) characterizes normal distributions.

Statement

Let ${\displaystyle (P_{\theta };\theta \in \Theta )}$ be a family of distributions on a measurable space ${\displaystyle (X,{\mathcal {A}})}$ and a statistic ${\displaystyle T}$ maps from ${\displaystyle (X,{\mathcal {A}})}$ to some measurable space ${\displaystyle (Y,{\mathcal {B}})}$. If ${\displaystyle T}$ is a boundedly complete sufficient statistic for ${\displaystyle \theta }$, and ${\displaystyle A}$ is ancillary to ${\displaystyle \theta }$, then conditional on ${\displaystyle \theta }$, ${\displaystyle T}$ is independent of ${\displaystyle A}$. That is, ${\displaystyle T\perp \!\!\!\perp A|\theta }$.

Proof

Let ${\displaystyle P_{\theta }^{T}}$ and ${\displaystyle P_{\theta }^{A}}$ be the marginal distributions of ${\displaystyle T}$ and ${\displaystyle A}$ respectively.

Denote by ${\displaystyle A^{-1}(B)}$ the preimage of a set ${\displaystyle B}$ under the map ${\displaystyle A}$. For any measurable set ${\displaystyle B\in {\mathcal {B}}}$ we have

${\displaystyle P_{\theta }^{A}(B)=P_{\theta }(A^{-1}(B))=\int _{Y}P_{\theta }(A^{-1}(B)\mid T=t)\ P_{\theta }^{T}(dt).}$

The distribution ${\displaystyle P_{\theta }^{A}}$ does not depend on ${\displaystyle \theta }$ because ${\displaystyle A}$ is ancillary. Likewise, ${\displaystyle P_{\theta }(\cdot \mid T=t)}$ does not depend on ${\displaystyle \theta }$ because ${\displaystyle T}$ is sufficient. Therefore

${\displaystyle \int _{Y}{\big [}P(A^{-1}(B)\mid T=t)-P^{A}(B){\big ]}\ P_{\theta }^{T}(dt)=0.}$

Note the integrand (the function inside the integral) is a function of ${\displaystyle t}$ and not ${\displaystyle \theta }$. Therefore, since ${\displaystyle T}$ is boundedly complete the function

${\displaystyle g(t)=P(A^{-1}(B)\mid T=t)-P^{A}(B)}$

is zero for ${\displaystyle P_{\theta }^{T}}$ almost all values of ${\displaystyle t}$ and thus

${\displaystyle P(A^{-1}(B)\mid T=t)=P^{A}(B)}$

for almost all ${\displaystyle t}$. Therefore, ${\displaystyle A}$ is independent of ${\displaystyle T}$.

Example

Independence of sample mean and sample variance of a normal distribution

Let X₁, X₂, ..., X_n be independent, identically distributed normal random variables with mean μ and variance σ².

Then with respect to the parameter μ, one can show that

${\displaystyle {\widehat {\mu }}={\frac {\sum X_{i}}{n}},}$

the sample mean, is a complete and sufficient statistic – it is all the information one can derive to estimate μ, and no more – and

${\displaystyle {\widehat {\sigma }}^{2}={\frac {\sum \left(X_{i}-{\bar {X}}\right)^{2}}{n-1}},}$

the sample variance, is an ancillary statistic – its distribution does not depend on μ.

Therefore, from Basu's theorem it follows that these statistics are independent conditional on ${\displaystyle \mu }$, conditional on ${\displaystyle \sigma ^{2}}$.

This independence result can also be proven by Cochran's theorem.

Further, this property (that the sample mean and sample variance of the normal distribution are independent) characterizes the normal distribution – no other distribution has this property. ^[3]

Notes

1. Basu (1955)
2. Ghosh, Malay; Mukhopadhyay, Nitis; Sen, Pranab Kumar (2011), Sequential Estimation, Wiley Series in Probability and Statistics, vol. 904, John Wiley & Sons, p. 80, ISBN   9781118165911, The following theorem, due to Basu ... helps us in proving independence between certain types of statistics, without actually deriving the joint and marginal distributions of the statistics involved. This is a very powerful tool and it is often used ...
3. Geary, R.C. (1936). "The Distribution of "Student's" Ratio for Non-Normal Samples". Supplement to the Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. 3 (2): 178–184. doi:10.2307/2983669. JFM   63.1090.03. JSTOR   2983669.

References

• Basu, D. (1955). "On Statistics Independent of a Complete Sufficient Statistic". Sankhyā . 15 (4): 377–380. JSTOR   25048259. MR   0074745. Zbl   0068.13401.
• Mukhopadhyay, Nitis (2000). Probability and Statistical Inference. Statistics: A Series of Textbooks and Monographs. 162. Florida: CRC Press USA. ISBN   0-8247-0379-0.
• Boos, Dennis D.; Oliver, Jacqueline M. Hughes (Aug 1998). "Applications of Basu's Theorem". The American Statistician . 52 (3): 218–221. doi:10.2307/2685927. JSTOR   2685927. MR   1650407.
• Ghosh, Malay (October 2002). "Basu's Theorem with Applications: A Personalistic Review". Sankhyā: The Indian Journal of Statistics, Series A. 64 (3): 509–531. JSTOR   25051412. MR   1985397.