Feminism in Pakistan

Last updated

Feminism in Pakistan refers to the movements which aim to define, establish, and defend the rights of women in Pakistan. This may involve the pursuit of equal political, economic, and social rights, alongside equal opportunity. [1] [2] [3] These movements have historically been shaped in response to the national and global reconfiguration of power in the country, including colonialism, nationalism, Islamization, dictatorship, democracy, and the War on Terror. [4] [5] [6] The relationship between the women's movements and the Pakistani state has undergone significant shifts from mutual accommodation to confrontation and conflict.

Contents

Background

According to the Global Gender Gap report of the World Economic Forum (WEF), Pakistan's parity score in the Economic Participation and Opportunity subindex is 36.2%, one of the lowest scores world-wide. Pakistan has a ranking of 142 of 146 countries overall. [7] [8] According to UNICEF, 54% of Pakistani girls become pregnant before their 18th birthday, and 46% of girls are not in education, employment or training. [9] [10] The International Monetary Fund has estimated that raising women's economic productivity and growth to that of men could boost Pakistan's GDP by 30 percent. [11]

Multiple writers have commented on the cultural expectations of women in Pakistan. For example, Zoya Rehman writes that the image of Pakistani womanhood has been a construction of the Pakistani state since its inception. Within this perception, Pakistani women are expected to guard their sexuality, are controlled, and can even be murdered by honor killings when they do not meet cultural expectations. [12] Usman Quais argues that honor killings as well as other forms of gender based and sexual violence are linked to and made worse by systemic barriers: lack of education, poverty, disrupted judicial system, and governmental negligence, which were exacerbated by years of colonial conflicts. [13] Afiya S. Ziya argues that this cultural orthodoxy is maintained by propaganda produced by the Inter-Services Public Relations, a Pakistani government agency, that purports to define what is legitimate and permissible as Pakistani culture. [14]

After independence, women in Pakistan continue to advocate for women's political empowerment through legal reforms. The Muslim Personal Law of Sharia, which recognized a woman's right to inherit all forms of property, was passed in 1948 after activists mobilized support. There was an unsuccessful attempt include a Charter of Women's Rights in the 1956 constitution. The most important socio-legal reform to be driven by feminist movements in Pakistan, 1961 Muslim Family Laws Ordinance covering marriage and divorce, is still widely regarded as empowering to women. [15] [16]

Women from minority religions face an even more severe lack of protections. The UN has expressed dismay at the continuing legal disregard for women in the Christian and Hindu communities against forced religious conversion, abduction, trafficking, child, early and forced marriage, domestic servitude and sexual violence. [17] [18]

History

According to Maliha Zia, while there are strong movements for women's equality and non-discrimination, there is no over-encompassing feminist movement. Zia divides the history of feminist movements in Pakistan into three phases: the first one beginning in 1947, the second one in the period after the Zia-ul-Haq dictatorship ended in 1988, and the third one since 9/11. [19]

First phase: 1947–1952

Muslim women were some of the most affected victims of Partition; it is reported that 75,000 women were abducted and raped during this period. Soon after, Fatima Jinnah formed the Women's Relief Committee, which later evolved into the All Pakistan Women's Association. Jinnah later founded a secret radio station, and, in 1965, came out of her self-imposed political retirement to participate in the presidential election against military dictator Ayub Khan.

Begum Ra'na Liaquat Ali Khan helped the refugees who fled India during partition and organized the All Pakistan Women's Association in 1949, [20] two years after the creation of her country. Noticing that there were not many nurses in Karachi, Khan requested the army to train women to give injections and first aid, therefore allowing women to be in para-military forces. Nursing became a career path for many girls. Khan continued her mission, even after her husband was assassinated in 1951, and became the first female Muslim delegate to the United Nations in 1952.

According to Ayesha Khan, in the initial decades after independence, women's leadership was largely elite and invested in Muslim nationalism, striving for limited rights for women. Women in civil society came into confrontation with the government when dictatorial Islamization started limiting their rights. [6]

Second phase: 1980s

In Pakistan, the military dictatorial regime of Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq gained power and initiated the Islamisation of Pakistan. These reforms replaced parts of the British-era Pakistan Penal Code, making adultery and fornication criminal offenses, and introducing the punishments of whipping, amputation, and stoning to death. The feminist movement in Pakistan highly opposed this implementation of Islam, which they believed to be based on an archaic understanding of Islamic literature, asking instead for liberal modernist interpretation. After much controversy and criticism, parts of the law were considerably revised by the 2006 Women's Protection Bill.

In this context, the vocal Women's Action Forum (WAF) was formed in 1981. [20] [21] According to Madihah Akhter, General Zia ultimately sought to morally police the role of women in the public sphere, which brought unexpected pressure on Pakistani women. As a reaction to the form of Zia's Islamization, many Pakistani women, including writers, academics, and performers, became active in the opposition of these policies. Akhter argued that the younger generation of 1980s activists were more feminist in their outlook and approach; the Women's Action Forum, she says, used "progressive interpretations of Islam" to counter the state's implementation of religiously interpreted morality, and in doing so, gained the unexpected support of right wing Islamic women's organizations. They campaigned through various mediums such as newspaper articles, art, poetry, and song. [22]

After Zia: 1988–2008

After the end of General Zia's rule, Pakistan elected its first female prime minister, Benazir Bhutto. Under her administration, all-women police stations were founded and female judges were appointed for the first time. However, many anti-feminist laws of the General Zia era remained.

In the post-Zia era, activists have been able to produce research that has focused on strengthening the political voice of women and promoting inclusive democratic governance. [23] They have also produced some of the first Pakistani research and awareness-raising material on the sexual and reproductive rights of women, [24] environmental issues, [25] and citizen-based initiatives for peace between India and Pakistan. [26] [27]

2008–2017

This was a period when the People's Party of Pakistan (PPP) was attained political stability within the country and was able to avoid economic decline. [28] The PPP held all parts of government, the president, the prime minister, and the speaker. It became the first party to hold a 5-year term, and add a constitutional amendment that decentralized governmental power. This comes from the party's belief that the central government had been overpowering local governments but the PPP remained in opposition to the socialist leftist movement of Muttahida Qaumi Movement/MQM. [29] This was also a time period where more women of different backgrounds were getting involved in the mainstream political spear. [30] More women from marginalized and low-caste statuses were politically organizing. There was still a general lack of attention to women's rights by all mainstream political parties.

Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy

Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy is a documentarian and a filmmaker who seeks to tell the stories of marginalized voices in her community. [31] Obaid-Chinoy has worked all over the world to tell the stories of survivors who have not been given a platform. [32] One of her most notable films "Saving Face" details the experiences of Pakistani women who have survived acid attacks and their processes of physical and social recovery. She won an Oscar for this project and helped raise awareness of the realities faced by these survivors. She also produced a film about honor killings,"A Girl in the River: The Price of Forgiveness" from the perspective of a rare survivor. This film reached the prime minister who was inspired to pass a law that ended a loop-hole within the legal system for honor killings. [33] Her story telling is closely tied with activism; she believes that movies have more power in places where literacy rates are low. She explains, "[b]y bringing the voices of the ordinary people faced with extraordinary challenges to television screens around the world, I hope to affect change in one community at a time". [32] Thus Obaid-Chinoy also participates in hands-on activist efforts by running a movie truck that travels across the country bringing new movies and ideas to different communities. The truck adapts to the local cultural contexts by providing an inside screening room for women in areas that are gender segregated.

Malala Yousafzai

Malala Yousafzai is a notable activist from Swat Valley for women's and girl's right to education who came to activism during this period from her personal experiences and passion for learning. [34] When she was 10 the Taliban took over her community and banned girls from participating in public education. She and her father criticized the Taliban. Yousafzai started an anonymous blog where she spoke out about her concerns. She became internally displaced in 2009 due to the conflicts within her community. Once she returned she advocated openly for her right to education. She was awarded both the Pakistan's National Youth Peace Prize and the International Children's Peace Prize. Yousafzai was subsequently shot by the Taliban while riding the school bus. She survived the severe injury and went to study in the U.K. and earned her degree from Oxford. Yousafzai has gone on to write a book, I Am Malala, about her experiences and advocacy work. [35] Yousafzai also runs a nonprofit that focuses on advocating for the education of girls in the global south by conducting research, and connecting local activists to funds. [36]

2018 – present

The feminist movement in Pakistan was altered after 2008 with the popularization of social media. The movement gained momentum as women were increasingly able to share their ideas and beliefs. Aurat March (Women Marches) are now held in numerous cities over the country, advocating for issues such as increased political participation and representation of women, gender and sexual minorities, religious minorities, and other marginalized groups in Pakistan. The movement has also demanded for public spaces to be made safer for women and transgender people, as well as called for an end to all violence against women and transgender people.

Variants

According to Maliha Zia, feminism in Pakistan can be found in two forms: Secular Liberal Feminism and Islamic Feminism. [19] There are many debates between these forms of activism. Both are heavily shaped by the context of Pakistan and its political system. Although these are the two emerging sects of feminist activism many scholars argue that this is a complicated topic with many gray areas.

Liberal Feminism

Liberal feminism is most prominent in leftist liberal circles, and is often supported by left-leaning political parties such as PPP. It is often characterized by liberal values of freedom, liberty, human rights and secularism. This differs from that of western Liberal Feminism that typically focuses on personal achievements and working within the pre-existing systems. Liberal or secular feminism in the context of Pakistan works outside of the pre-existing Islamic political structures and take a human-rights-centered approach to women's liberation that is not based on the rights laid out in Islamic texts. This sect focuses on and prioritizes women-specific issues, whereas other sects might prioritize issues of class or race. [37] One goal of this branch is to create secular legal reform.

Nisaism/Islamic Feminism

Nisaism/Islamic Feminism is more traditionalist in nature and supports the acquisition of women rights under an Islamic lens. [38] [39] The movement is mainly supported by centrists and the right-wing parties of Pakistan. The word Nisaism comes from Surah Nisa, a chapter of Qur'an, demonstrating the Islamic roots of the movement. The movement has faced some criticism for preaching Islamic rights; some secular feminists believe that Islam is intertwined with the patriarchy. To fully understand this approach one must understand the political and legal systems within Pakistan. Pakistan is an Islamic country making courts and judicial processes influenced by Islamic practices and teachings. [40] Thus, laws must be in accordance with the Quran in order for them to be passed by the Shariat Court, which is the only court that has constitutional power. This makes activism through Islam a more viable reality for some feminists wanting to make legal change.

Feminist art and literature in Pakistan

Pakistani feminist art and literature is often at odds with orthodox advice literature, known for imposing religious dogma through puritanical reform; [41] feminist authors often describe the journey of feminism in Pakistan as an oscillating battle, where women's movements struggle against the continued backlash of the patriarchal hegemony. [41] According to Shahbaz Ahmad Cheema, the Pakistani patriarchy produces literature and art with the ultimate goal of making women accept, internalize, and promote patriarchal discourse as an ideal. [41] Afiya S Zia identifies some of the writings she considers to be most problematic, such as those of Sir Syed Ahmed Khan; Ashraf Ali Thanawi's Bahishti Zewar; and, in post-partition times, Abu Ala Maududi's writings, which she considers to intend to create and sustain a privileged Muslim class, further facilitating and supporting patriarchal male dominance. Television and film likewise continue to present submissive and subservient Pakistani women in a male-dominated Pakistani society. [41]

S.S. Sirajuddin in the Encyclopedia of Post-Colonial Literature in English, expresses reservations about the availability of free space for feminism in Pakistan, and feels that the nation is still much affected by religious fervor. However, she admits that awareness of feminist concerns, the changing role of women, and female identity do exist in Pakistan, and these concerns are reflected in Pakistan's English literature. [42]

Major female characters can be observed in novels like Bapsi Sidhwa, and Sara Suleri's Meatless Days. Pakistani poets like Maki Kureishi, Hina Faisal Imam, Alamgir Hashmi, and Taufiq Rafat are considered to be sensitive but restrained in their portrayal. [42]

One of the first feminist films in Pakistan was called Aurat Raj (Women's Rule). [43] It was released in 1979, but failed to achieve at the box-office.

Womansplaining: Navigating Activism, Politics and Modernity in Pakistan is 2021 collection of feminist essays edited by Sherry Rehman consisting of essays by Hina Jilani, Khawar Mumtaz, Afiya Shehrbano Zia and others narrating the history of the Muslim Family Law Ordinance, Women's Action Forum and various legislative changes in Pakistan's history. Sarah Peracha publishes to encourage women of Pakistan to do business which is against the norm in Pakistan to inspire women to work. [44] Bina Shah and Fifi Haroon write about feminism and the arts, Nighat Dad tells about feminism in the digital age. [45] [46]

Ismat Chughtai

Beginning in the 1930s, Ismat Chughtai wrote extensively on themes including female sexuality and femininity, middle-class gentility, and class conflict, often from a Marxist perspective.

Fatima Bhutto

Fatima Bhutto is the daughter of former Minister Murtaza Bhutto. She is the author of three novels. Songs of Blood and Sword is a memoir of her father, who was assassinated. [47]

Farkhanda Shahid Khan

Farkhanda Shahid Khan is a feminist researcher, activist, and academic. She teaches contemporary English literature at Government College University Faisalabad. Her research focuses on Feminism, Marxism, Culture, and Gender & Sexuality with an emphasis on the Global South. In academic collaboration with the School of Literature, Languages & Cultures at the University of Edinburgh, Khan is currently working on a project that examines the complexities of women residing in the red-light districts and brothel quarters in Pakistan, an often-taboo subject in the country. In addition to her academic endeavors, Khan frequently writes for national and international press, providing nuanced insights into human rights issues, particularly those pertaining to women's rights in Pakistan and its neighbouring countries. She has advocated for gender equality in various forums, including UN Women, Private Members' Special Committee on Gender Equity in the Legislative Assembly of British Columbia and The City of Atlanta's Human Relations Commission. Furthermore, she leads the Pakistan chapters of The Literary Think Tank and the Edinburgh University Feminist Society. She is also the founder of Feminist Society at Government College University Faisalabad.

Feminist organizations of Pakistan

Pakistani feminists

Bibliography

See also

References

  1. "The Aurat March challenges misogyny in our homes, workplaces and society, say organisers ahead of Women's Day". Images. 2019-03-07. Retrieved 2019-03-11.
  2. "Feminism and the Women Movement in Pakistan". www.fes-asia.org. Archived from the original on 2018-04-20. Retrieved 2019-03-11.
  3. "Pakistani women hold 'aurat march' for equality, gender justice". www.aljazeera.com. 3 December 2018. Retrieved 2019-03-11.
  4. "Feminism in Pakistan: A brief history - The Express Tribune". The Express Tribune. 2014-09-23. Retrieved 2017-08-20.
  5. Talbot, Ian (1998). Pakistan, a Modern History . NY: St.Martin's Press. pp. 275, 276, 281. ISBN   9780312216061.
  6. 1 2 Khan, Ayesha (30 November 2018). The women's movement in Pakistan : activism, Islam and democracy. London: Bloomsbury Publishing. p. 3. ISBN   978-1-78673-523-2. OCLC   1109390555.
  7. Abdel-Raouf, Fatma; Buhler, Patricia M. (2020-08-21), "The Global Gender Pay Gap" , The Gender Pay Gap, Routledge, pp. 136–148, doi:10.4324/9781003003731-11, ISBN   978-1-003-00373-1, S2CID   225192849 , retrieved 2020-12-05
  8. "Global Gender Gap Report 2023". World Economic Forum. Archived from the original on 2025-06-04. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  9. "Empowering the future of Pakistan | UNICEF Pakistan". www.unicef.org. 2024-04-30. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  10. "Pakistan - Child Marriage Around The World. Girls Not Brides". Girls Not Brides. Retrieved 2020-12-14.
  11. "Women's empowerment and the IMF" (PDF). IMF. 2020-08-21. Retrieved 2020-12-05.
  12. Rehman, Zoya (2019-07-26). "Aurat March and Undisciplined Bodies". Medium. Retrieved 2020-03-04.
  13. Qais, Usman (September 30, 2023). "Contemporary Global Feminism Trends and Cultural Barriers to Women's Empowerment in Pakistan, An Islamic Perspective". Pakistan Journal of Islamic Philosophy. 5 (2): 34 via PKP.
  14. Zia, Afiya S. (2020-02-03). "The contrite gender formula of Meray Paas Tum Ho and the portrayal of women in cultural scripts". dawn.com. Retrieved 2020-03-04.
  15. Zia, Afiya S. (30 November 2017). Faith and Feminism in Pakistan: Religious Agency or Secular Autonomy?. Sussex Academic Press. ISBN   978-1845199166.
  16. Shah, Bina (2014-08-20). "Opinion | The Fate of Feminism in Pakistan". The New York Times. ISSN   0362-4331 . Retrieved 2019-04-15.
  17. "Forced marriages and forced conversions in the christian community of Pakistan" (PDF). cloudfront. Retrieved 2020-12-14.
  18. "Pakistan: UN experts alarmed by lack of protection for minority girls from forced religious conversions and forced marriage". OHCHR. Retrieved 2025-07-23.
  19. 1 2 Zia, Maliha (2018). Feminism and it's absence in Pakistani legal discourse. Dorota Anna Gozdecka, Anne Macduff. Abingdon, Oxon: Taylor & Francis. pp. 10th page of Chapter 4. ISBN   978-1-351-04040-2. OCLC   1080201827. Thus in the Pakistani context, while there is a vibrant women's movement based on equality and non discrimination for women, it can not be said that there is an overarching feminist movement. ... It may therefore be more accurate to state that feminism in Pakistan has primarily flourished within the women's movement (Shaheed 2010, 5). ... in Pakistan, there are primarily two different ideological movements. The two movements are the Secular Liberal Feminism (SLF) and modern Islamic feminism (Serez 2017, 62). ...{{cite book}}: |work= ignored (help)
  20. 1 2 Moon Charania (2014). "Feminism, sexuality and the rhetoric of Westernization in Pakistan: precarious citizenship". In Leela Fernandes (ed.). Routledge Handbook of Gender in South Asia. doi:10.4324/9781315848501. ISBN   9781315848501. S2CID   152429755 . Retrieved 2019-04-04.
  21. Zia, Afiya Shehrbano (February 2009). "the reinvention of feminism in Pakistan". Feminist Review. 91 (1): 29–46. doi:10.1057/fr.2008.48. ISSN   0141-7789. S2CID   145073625.
  22. "Feminists…in Pakistan?". The Feminist Wire. 2012-10-15. Retrieved 2019-04-14.
  23. Shaheed et al., 2009; Zia, 2005; Bari, 2015
  24. Saeed, 1994
  25. Sadeque, 2012; Hanif, 2011
  26. Sarwar, 2007
  27. Khan Ayesha, Kirmani Nida (2018). "Moving Beyond the Binary: Gender-based Activism in Pakistan" (PDF). Feminist Dissent. 3: 151 191. doi:10.31273/fd.n3.2018.286. S2CID   126399103. Archived from the original (PDF) on 2021-06-19. Retrieved 2019-04-15 via researchcollective.org.
  28. Wu, Xiang; Ali, Salman (July 25, 2020). "The Novel Changes in Pakistan's Party Politics: Analysis of Causes and Impacts". Chinese Political Science Review. 5 (4): 513–533. doi:10.1007/s41111-020-00156-z. PMC   7382323 . PMID   40477057.
  29. Faiz, Asma (March 7, 2022). "The Peculiar Case of the Pakistan Peoples Party as an Opposition Party". Carnegie Endowment For International Peace. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  30. Ali Awan, Muhammad (October 2016). "Political Participation of Women in Pakistan: Historical and Political Dynamics Shaping the Structure of Politics for Women" (PDF). Goethe-Universität, Frankfurt.
  31. Bahr, Lindsey (June 26, 2024). "From DVF to Star Wars, filmmaker Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy charts her own path in Hollywood". Associated Press. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  32. 1 2 Asia Game Changer Awards (25 July 2017). "Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy: For eye-opening films that give voice to the voiceless". Asia Society. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  33. Obaid-Chinoy, Sharmeen (April 2019). "How film transforms the way we see the world". TED. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  34. The Nobel Prize Organization (2014). "Malala Yousafzai Biographical". The Nobel Prize. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  35. Yousafzai, Malala (October 8, 2013). I Am Malala: The Girl Who Stood Up for Education and Was Shot by the Taliban. United States: Brown and Company (published 2013). pp. 1–288. ISBN   978-0-29787-091-3.
  36. Malala Fund (2013). "Our Work". Malala Fund. Retrieved April 20, 2025.
  37. Gul Khattak, Saba (December 4, 2023). "Aurat, Azadi: Feminism and its Future in Pakistan". Progressive International. Retrieved April 21, 2025.
  38. Chaudhry, Zafar Aziz (2020-08-21). "Feminism in Pakistan". Daily Times. Retrieved 2022-04-13.
  39. Bakanova, Marina V. (2021). "Feminist Movement in Pakistan. Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow" . RSUH/RGGU Bulletin. Series Philosophy. Social Studies. Art Studies, International Care Medical Centre "Dua Hospital" (1): 306–314. doi:10.28995/2073-6401-2021-1-306-314 (inactive 12 July 2025). S2CID   239200192. Currently, the country is represented by classical European feminism (which is subject to decomposition to a certain extent), the Nisaism movement (they seek the rights for women in accordance with Islam) and individual activists.{{cite journal}}: CS1 maint: DOI inactive as of July 2025 (link)
  40. Aamir, Asma (March 3, 2024). "Feminist Movements In Pakistan: Challenges and Struggles". Committee for the Abolition of Illegitimate Debt. Retrieved April 21, 2025.
  41. 1 2 3 4 Zia, Afiya S. (2020-02-03). "The contrite gender formula of Meray Paas Tum Ho and the portrayal of women in cultural scripts". dawn.com. Retrieved 2020-02-04.
  42. 1 2 Benson, Eugene; Conolly, L. W. (2004-11-30). Encyclopedia of Post-Colonial Literatures in English. Routledge. ISBN   9781134468485.
  43. Aurat Raj (1979), 13 July 1979, retrieved 2017-08-20
  44. "Muslim Business Women Magazine". [Issuu]. 2017-12-07.
  45. Akbar, Hassan (August 28, 2021). "Why men should read Womansplaining". www.thenews.com.pk. Retrieved 2021-09-19.
  46. Shaheed, Farida (2021-09-12). "Anatomy of a Resistance". Dawn . Retrieved 2021-09-19.
  47. "9 Contemporary Pakistani Women Writers We Have Unearthed For You To Explore In 2018!". Women's Web: For Women Who Do. 2017-12-26. Retrieved 2020-12-05.
  48. "A tale of twisted harassment". The Express Tribune. 2017-08-10. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  49. Images Staff (2017-08-09). "How Begum Ra'ana Liaquat Ali Khan helped empower Pakistani women". Images. Retrieved 2017-08-20.
  50. Leiby, Michele Langevine (2012-07-15). "Women's rights become a fight to the death in Pakistan". The Age. Retrieved 2017-08-22.
  51. "One UN - Pakistan Annual Report 2016". ReliefWeb. 2017-07-28. Retrieved 2017-08-21.
  52. Inam, Moniza (2016-02-14). "Women empowerment: The spring of hope". dawn.com. Retrieved 2017-08-21.
  53. "Transgender community of Pakistan launches political party seeking equal rights". gulfnews.com. 23 September 2020. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  54. "How NCA broke societal barriers by redefining transgender roles in Pakistan". The Express Tribune. 2015-11-12. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  55. Fatima, Mahnoor (2020-01-08). "Akhuwat's Khwajasira Support Program". Youlin Magazine. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  56. "Pakistan's transgender community says faced pushback at general election". Reuters. 2018-07-26. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  57. "'My years with WAF' – Zohra Yusuf on the Pakistani women's movement". Journeys to democracy. 2013-02-13. Retrieved 2020-02-01.
  58. "Silver jubilee: Dastak marks 25th anniversary". The Express Tribune. 2015-03-07. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  59. Masood, Tooba (2015-12-02). "The 'fearless collective' in Lyari". dawn.com. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  60. Reporter, A. (2016-01-10). "Artists, activists join evicted I-11 residents calling for resettlement". dawn.com. Retrieved 2022-05-05.
  61. A letter received by Sayyid Husain Bilgrami in Coming out: decisions to leave Purdah, jstor.org (Early 1926)
  62. "The Sindhiyani Tehreek: Revolutionary Feminism in Sindh?". Jamhoor. Retrieved 2025-04-24.
  63. "Fahmida Riaz: Pakistan poet who dared to talk about female desire". 2018-11-27. Retrieved 2025-04-24.
  64. "Noorul Huda Shah | Karachi Literature Festival" . Retrieved 2025-04-24.
  65. "Sheema Kermani | Karachi Literature Festival" . Retrieved 2025-04-24.
  66. Pakistan based first feminist English poet https://issuu.com/muslimbusinesswomen/docs/mbwmagdec17: Muslim Business Women (Early 2017)
  67. Why Feminism A Taboo In Pakistan? | Nida Mahmoed is first Pakistani Feminist English Poet http://blogs.dunyanews.tv/24783/: Dunya News TV (Early 2019)
  68. Parshley, Lois (2015-04-28). "The Life and Death of Sabeen Mahmud". The New Yorker. ISSN   0028-792X . Retrieved 2025-04-24.
  69. "Radical new Urdu female writers using poetry to call for changes to gender roles in Pakistan, major new study shows". Mirage News. 2022-03-25. Retrieved 2022-03-26.
  70. Manzoor, Asma (7 September 2021). "Aurat Justuju aur Nisai Andaz e Fikar". Pakistan Journal of Gender Studies. 21 (2): 153–154. doi: 10.46568/pjgs.v21i2.584 .