1960 United States presidential election in Virginia

Last updated

1960 United States presidential election in Virginia
Flag of Virginia.svg
  1956 November 8, 1960 1964  
  Richard Nixon official portrait as Vice President (cropped).tiff Jfk2 (3x4).jpg
Nominee Richard Nixon John F. Kennedy
Party Republican Democratic
Home state California Massachusetts
Running mate Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. Lyndon B. Johnson
Electoral vote120
Popular vote404,521362,327
Percentage52.44%46.97%

Virginia Presidential Election Results 1960.svg
County and Independent City Results

President before election

Dwight Eisenhower
Republican

Elected President

John F. Kennedy
Democratic

The 1960 United States presidential election in Virginia took place on November 8, 1960. Voters chose 12 representatives, or electors to the Electoral College, who voted for president and vice president.

Contents

The Republican ticket of then-Vice President Richard Nixon of California and running mate Henry Cabot Lodge Jr. comfortably carried Virginia over the Democratic ticket of U.S. Senator John F. Kennedy of Massachusetts and Lyndon B. Johnson, even while Kennedy narrowly prevailed nationally. In the process, Kennedy became the first Democrat to ever win the presidency without carrying the state.

For six decades Virginia had almost completely disenfranchised its black and poor white populations through the use of a cumulative poll tax and literacy tests. [1] So restricted was suffrage in this period that it has been calculated that a third of Virginia’s electorate during the first half of the twentieth century comprised state employees and officeholders. [1]

This limited electorate allowed Virginian politics to be controlled for four decades by the Byrd Organization, as progressive “antiorganization” factions were rendered impotent by the inability of almost all their potential electorate to vote. [2] Historical fusion with the “Readjuster” Democrats, [3] defection of substantial proportions of the Northeast-aligned white electorate of the Shenandoah Valley and Southwest Virginia over free silver, [4] and an early move towards a “lily white” Jim Crow party [3] meant Republicans retained a small but permanent number of legislative seats and local offices in the western part of the state. [5]

In 1928, the GOP did carry the state’s presidential electoral votes due to anti-Catholicism against Al Smith in the Chesapeake Bay region and increased middle-class Republicanism in the cities, [6] but it was 1952 before any real changes occurred, as in-migration from the traditionally Republican Northeast [7] meant that growing Washington, D.C., and Richmond suburbs would turn Republican not just in presidential elections but also in Congressional ones, [8] although the Republicans would not make significant gains in the state legislature. Opposition to the black civil rights legislation of Harry S. Truman meant that the Byrd Organization did not support Adlai Stevenson II, [9] with the result that Dwight D. Eisenhower carried the state aided by defections of the Southside Thurmond vote from 1948. [10] In 1956, Eisenhower repeated his win despite losing his Southside support due to the President’s opposition to Byrd’s “Massive Resistance” policy following Brown v. Board of Education , [11] as continuing Northern in-migration and a rapid swing to him of the modest but growing number of black voters allowed him to maintain his margin. [12]

In the following years, continuing “Massive Resistance” weakened the GOP in Virginia, as they could not develop a consistent or coherent response: Ted Dalton, who had received 45 percent of the vote in 1953 running against the Byrd Organization, won only 36 percent as his policy of “token integration” was drowned out by the state Democrats. [13]

Although Byrd again refused to endorse Democratic nominee, Senator John F. Kennedy, his former ally before the end of “Massive Resistance”, Governor J. Lindsay Almond, strongly endorsed the Massachusetts Senator against the Republican nominee, incumbent Vice President Richard Nixon. [14]

Predictions

SourceRankingAs of
The Philadelphia Inquirer [15] Tilt ROctober 3, 1960
Knoxville News Sentinel [16] Likely ROctober 23, 1960
Daily News [17] Likely ROctober 28, 1960
The Daily Item [18] Likely RNovember 4, 1960
Hattiesburg American [19] Likely RNovember 7, 1960

Results

1960 United States presidential election in Virginia [20]
PartyCandidateVotesPercentageElectoral votes
Republican Richard Nixon 404,52152.44%12
Democratic John F. Kennedy 362,32746.97%0
Virginia Conservative C. Benton Coiner4,2040.54%0
Socialist Labor Eric Hass 3970.05%0
Totals771,449100.00%12

Results by county or independent city

County/City [21] Richard Nixon
Republican
John F. Kennedy
Democratic
C. Benton Coiner
Virginia Conservative
Eric Hass
Socialist Labor
MarginTotal votes cast
# %# %# %# %# %
Accomack 2,67647.95%2,88451.68%200.36%10.02%-208-3.73%5,581
Albemarle 3,13559.47%2,10239.87%340.64%10.02%1,03319.60%5,272
Alexandria 8,82647.58%9,66252.08%630.34%570.31%8364.50%18,608
Alleghany 1,21448.79%1,26550.84%80.32%10.04%-51-2.05%2,488
Amelia 78451.44%70846.46%312.03%10.07%764.98%1,524
Amherst 1,45538.83%2,28060.85%100.27%20.05%-825-22.02%3,747
Appomattox 95143.07%1,24056.16%140.63%30.14%-289-13.09%2,208
Arlington 23,63251.40%22,09548.06%2250.49%250.05%1,5373.34%45,977
Augusta 4,03467.36%1,91431.96%400.67%10.02%2,12035.40%5,989
Bath 64650.59%62949.26%10.08%10.08%171.33%1,277
Bedford 2,91147.87%3,15051.80%170.28%30.05%-239-3.93%6,081
Bland 84850.75%82249.19%10.06%00.00%261.56%1,671
Botetourt 2,15956.79%1,62142.64%220.58%00.00%53814.15%3,802
Bristol 1,72852.38%1,56147.32%90.27%10.03%1675.06%3,299
Brunswick 92631.58%1,94266.23%632.15%10.03%-1,016-34.65%2,932
Buchanan 2,37038.86%3,70660.76%180.30%50.08%-1,336-21.90%6,099
Buckingham 76544.37%94754.93%110.64%10.06%-182-10.56%1,724
Buena Vista 48753.05%42746.51%40.44%00.00%606.54%918
Campbell 2,90348.63%3,03050.75%370.62%00.00%-127-2.12%5,970
Caroline 86436.50%1,48362.65%190.80%10.04%-619-26.15%2,367
Carroll 3,70566.29%1,87333.51%90.16%20.04%1,83232.78%5,589
Charles City 33734.96%62364.63%30.31%10.10%-286-29.67%964
Charlotte 86732.90%1,73565.84%260.99%70.27%-868-32.94%2,635
Charlottesville 3,65155.08%2,89443.66%721.09%110.17%75711.42%6,628
Chesterfield 9,78761.71%5,98237.72%870.55%30.02%3,80523.99%15,859
Clarke 80446.31%92353.17%90.52%00.00%-119-6.86%1,736
Clifton Forge 88553.22%77146.36%40.24%30.18%1146.86%1,663
Colonial Heights 1,37253.16%1,19846.42%100.39%10.04%1746.74%2,581
Covington 1,43647.85%1,55851.92%60.20%10.03%-122-4.07%3,001
Craig 43344.78%53455.22%00.00%00.00%-101-10.44%967
Culpeper 1,63054.86%1,33244.83%80.27%10.03%29810.03%2,971
Cumberland 69154.75%55944.29%120.95%00.00%13210.46%1,262
Danville 4,96663.72%2,61133.50%1882.41%290.37%2,35530.22%7,794
Dickenson 2,20344.42%2,75655.56%10.02%00.00%-553-11.14%4,960
Dinwiddie 93534.81%1,71463.81%361.34%10.04%-779-29.00%2,686
Essex 60654.25%50945.57%10.09%10.09%978.68%1,117
Fairfax 28,00651.65%26,06448.07%1240.23%250.05%1,9423.58%54,219
Falls Church 1,52548.18%1,62951.47%70.22%40.13%-104-3.29%3,165
Fauquier 2,12351.86%1,95847.83%130.32%00.00%1654.03%4,094
Floyd 1,93370.06%81729.61%40.14%50.18%1,11640.45%2,759
Fluvanna 76354.89%61444.17%130.94%00.00%14910.72%1,390
Franklin 2,08041.47%2,92458.29%90.18%30.06%-844-16.82%5,016
Frederick 2,06153.74%1,75745.81%140.37%30.08%3047.93%3,835
Fredericksburg 1,56653.72%1,32645.49%220.75%10.03%2408.23%2,915
Galax 86762.96%50836.89%10.07%10.07%35926.07%1,377
Giles 2,03046.91%2,21451.17%781.80%50.12%-184-4.26%4,327
Gloucester 1,31050.00%1,29749.50%100.38%30.11%130.50%2,620
Goochland 85148.66%86249.29%331.89%30.17%-11-0.63%1,749
Grayson 3,89358.65%2,73841.25%40.06%30.05%1,15517.40%6,638
Greene 57364.24%31435.20%50.56%00.00%25929.04%892
Greensville 1,05738.21%1,67660.59%311.12%20.07%-619-22.38%2,766
Halifax 1,78439.57%2,67659.36%440.98%40.09%-892-19.79%4,508
Hampton 7,62351.48%7,13348.17%430.29%90.06%4903.31%14,808
Hanover 3,02059.39%2,02339.78%390.77%30.06%99719.61%5,085
Harrisonburg 2,17272.04%83627.73%70.23%00.00%1,33644.31%3,015
Henrico 19,44666.52%9,62632.93%1520.52%110.04%9,82033.59%29,235
Henry 2,32341.17%3,30658.59%120.21%20.04%-983-17.42%5,643
Highland 52756.55%40143.03%30.32%10.11%12613.52%932
Hopewell 2,16954.24%1,80545.14%210.53%40.10%3649.10%3,999
Isle of Wight 1,14135.91%2,02063.58%130.41%30.09%-879-27.67%3,177
James City 87350.49%84548.87%90.52%20.12%281.62%1,729
King and Queen 43243.95%53654.53%141.42%10.10%-104-10.58%983
King George 68548.58%71750.85%80.57%00.00%-32-2.27%1,410
King William 79351.19%74548.10%100.65%10.06%483.09%1,549
Lancaster 1,34059.56%89539.78%140.62%10.04%44519.78%2,250
Lee 3,36346.29%3,86753.23%240.33%110.15%-504-6.94%7,265
Loudoun 2,52650.99%2,39948.43%280.57%10.02%1272.56%4,954
Louisa 1,17047.60%1,24450.61%391.59%50.20%-74-3.01%2,458
Lunenburg 83835.22%1,45160.99%903.78%00.00%-613-25.77%2,379
Lynchburg 7,27159.33%4,96140.48%230.19%10.01%2,31018.85%12,256
Madison 99860.38%63638.48%191.15%00.00%36221.90%1,653
Martinsville 1,72949.16%1,69948.31%842.39%50.14%300.85%3,517
Mathews 1,06960.95%68238.88%30.17%00.00%38722.07%1,754
Mecklenburg 1,93642.70%2,53355.87%641.41%10.02%-597-13.17%4,534
Middlesex 82358.70%57440.94%50.36%00.00%24917.76%1,402
Montgomery 4,27066.25%2,15733.47%170.26%10.02%2,11332.78%6,445
Nansemond 1,34625.29%3,94474.09%240.45%90.17%-2,598-48.80%5,323
Nelson 77534.17%1,48065.26%130.57%00.00%-705-31.09%2,268
New Kent 52651.67%48147.25%100.98%10.10%454.42%1,018
Newport News 10,09853.56%8,67846.02%750.40%40.02%1,4207.54%18,855
Norfolk 3,76942.18%5,10157.08%650.73%10.01%-1,332-14.90%8,936
Norfolk City 17,17443.51%22,03755.83%2480.63%140.04%-4,863-12.32%39,473
Northampton 99541.60%1,38757.98%90.38%10.04%-392-16.38%2,392
Northumberland 1,34060.61%85838.81%110.50%20.09%48221.80%2,211
Norton 54951.02%52648.88%10.09%00.00%232.14%1,076
Nottoway 1,31940.14%1,88257.27%842.56%10.03%-563-17.13%3,286
Orange 1,41354.28%1,10842.57%783.00%40.15%30511.71%2,603
Page 2,70862.53%1,60837.13%100.23%50.12%1,10025.40%4,331
Patrick 1,36244.98%1,65554.66%90.30%20.07%-293-9.68%3,028
Petersburg 2,82048.60%2,95050.84%320.55%10.02%-130-2.24%5,803
Pittsylvania 3,78847.62%4,08951.41%670.84%100.13%-301-3.79%7,954
Portsmouth 6,90040.64%9,90258.32%1650.97%130.08%-3,002-17.68%16,980
Powhatan 77958.66%52839.76%191.43%20.15%25118.90%1,328
Prince Edward 1,72153.55%1,45945.40%310.96%30.09%2628.15%3,214
Prince George 72742.14%98356.99%130.75%20.12%-256-14.85%1,725
Princess Anne 4,84444.67%5,95454.91%230.41%50.09%-1,110-10.24%10,843
Prince William 2,62446.53%2,98752.97%390.36%60.06%-363-6.44%5,639
Pulaski 3,05958.75%2,10440.41%440.85%00.00%95518.34%5,207
Radford 1,66357.11%1,24042.58%90.31%00.00%42314.53%2,912
Rappahannock 42643.69%54455.79%30.31%20.21%-118-12.10%975
Richmond 80164.96%42534.47%60.49%10.08%37630.49%1,233
Richmond City 27,30760.41%17,64239.03%2450.54%110.02%9,66521.38%45,205
Roanoke 9,10967.31%4,38432.40%360.27%30.02%4,72534.91%13,532
Roanoke City 15,22962.28%9,17537.52%360.27%30.02%6,05424.76%24,453
Rockbridge 2,17060.53%1,40539.19%100.28%00.00%76521.34%3,585
Rockingham 4,82970.27%2,02629.48%160.23%10.01%2,80340.79%6,872
Russell 3,04446.44%3,49653.34%120.18%20.03%-452-6.90%6,554
Scott 4,93656.45%3,78943.33%150.17%40.05%1,14713.12%8,744
Shenandoah 4,14466.85%2,05333.12%20.03%00.00%2,09133.73%6,199
Smyth 4,25659.62%2,86440.12%160.22%20.03%1,39219.50%7,138
South Boston 80762.70%47737.06%20.16%10.08%33025.64%1,287
South Norfolk 1,34138.09%2,15561.20%240.68%10.03%-814-23.11%3,521
Southampton 1,26330.62%2,80467.98%571.38%10.02%-1,541-37.36%4,125
Spotsylvania 1,28846.02%1,48252.95%230.82%60.21%-194-6.93%2,799
Stafford 1,44748.80%1,49450.39%220.74%20.07%-47-1.59%2,965
Staunton 2,78969.17%1,23330.58%90.22%10.02%1,55638.59%4,032
Suffolk 1,40649.61%1,41950.07%90.32%00.00%-13-0.46%2,834
Surry 39727.51%1,00369.51%402.77%30.21%-606-42.00%1,443
Sussex 71335.78%1,25362.87%251.25%20.10%-540-27.09%1,993
Tazewell 3,13941.44%4,41658.30%190.25%00.00%-1,277-16.86%7,574
Virginia Beach 98642.48%1,30156.05%331.42%10.04%-315-13.57%2,321
Warren 1,84249.52%1,85049.73%250.67%30.08%-8-0.21%3,720
Washington 4,47353.59%3,83345.92%330.40%80.10%6407.67%8,347
Waynesboro 2,44469.57%1,04729.80%220.63%00.00%1,39739.77%3,513
Westmoreland 1,17653.00%1,03446.60%80.36%10.05%1426.40%2,219
Williamsburg 72159.10%48639.84%120.98%10.08%23519.26%1,220
Winchester 2,32665.61%1,20333.94%160.45%00.00%1,12331.67%3,545
Wise 3,87639.89%5,82259.92%170.17%10.01%-1,946-20.03%9,716
Wythe 2,87157.50%2,07541.56%390.78%80.16%79615.94%4,993
York 2,08554.94%1,69144.56%190.50%00.00%39410.38%3,795
Totals404,52152.44%362,32746.97%4,2040.54%3970.05%42,1945.47%771,449

Counties and independent cities that flipped from Republican to Democratic

Counties and independent cities that flipped from Unpledged to Republican

Senator John F. Kennedy (left) and Vice-president Richard Nixon (right), prior to their first presidential debate. Kennedy Nixon debate first Chicago 1960.jpg
Senator John F. Kennedy (left) and Vice-president Richard Nixon (right), prior to their first presidential debate.

Analysis

Unlike such states as Oklahoma, Tennessee [22] or Kentucky, Nixon’s victory in Virginia despite losing nationally did not reflect anti-Catholicism: only two counties or independent cities gave Nixon a better percentage than Eisenhower had won in 1956. [21] Nixon’s win reflected his continuing dominance of the Byrd Organization stronghold in the Shenandoah Valley, and maintaining Republican control of newly developing suburbs. Kennedy’s general gain was greatest amongst the small but slowly growing black electorate, where he reversed Eisenhower’s large gains at the preceding election.

As of the 2024 presidential election , this is the last occasion when Appomattox County, Campbell County, Lunenburg County, Mecklenburg County and Pittsylvania County have voted for a Democratic presidential candidate. [23]

Virginia, as the polls hinted, voted for Nixon over Kennedy by a clear though not overwhelming 5.47 percentage point margin, still a double-digit decline from Eisenhower’s two victories in the state. This was the first time a Democrat was elected president without carrying the state of Virginia, and the only time between 1924 and 1976 that Virginia backed the losing candidate.

References

  1. 1 2 Kousser, J. Morgan. The Shaping of Southern Politics: Suffrage Restriction and the Establishment of the One-Party South, 1880-1910. Yale University Press. pp. 178–181. ISBN   0-300-01696-4.
  2. Key, Valdimer Orlando (1949). Southern Politics in State and Nation. pp. 20–25.
  3. 1 2 Heersink, Boris; Jenkins, Jeffrey A. Republican Party Politics and the American South, 1865-1968. pp. 217–221. ISBN   1107158435.
  4. Moger, Allen. "The Rift in Virginia Democracy in 1896". The Journal of Southern History . 4 (3): 295–317. doi:10.2307/2191291. JSTOR   2191291.
  5. Phillips, Kevin P. (1969). The Emerging Republican Majority. pp. 193, 219. ISBN   0870000586.
  6. Phillips; The Emerging Republican Majority, p. 195
  7. Heinemann, Ronald L. (2008). Old Dominion, New Commonwealth: A History of Virginia, 1607-2007. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press. p. 357. ISBN   978-0813927695.
  8. Atkinson, Frank B. (2006). The Dynamic Dominion: Realignment and the Rise of Two-party Competition in Virginia, 1945-1980. Rowman & Littlefield. ISBN   9780742552098.
  9. Ely, James W. (1976). The Crisis of Conservative Virginia: the Byrd Organization and the Politics of Massive Resistance. Knoxville, Tennessee: University of Tennessee Press. p. 16. ISBN   0870491881.
  10. Strong, Donald S. (August 1955). "The Presidential Election in the South, 1952". The Journal of Politics. 17 (3). The University of Chicago Press: 343–389. doi:10.1017/S0022381600091064.
  11. See Wilhoit, Francis M. (1973). The politics of massive resistance. p. 147. ISBN   0807607002.
  12. Atkinson. The Dynamic Dominion, p. 100
  13. Atkinson. The Dynamic Dominion, pp. 103-108
  14. Atkinson. The Dynamic Dominion, pp. 125-126
  15. Hoffman, Fred S. (October 3, 1960). "How Election Looks Today". The Philadelphia Inquirer . Philadelphia. pp. 1, 3.
  16. "Populous States Are Key: Both Parties Claim Enough Votes To Win". Knoxville News Sentinel . Knoxville, Tennessee. October 23, 1960. p. A-4.
  17. Lewis, Ted (October 28, 1960). "Campaign Circus". Daily News . Jersey City, New Jersey. p. 4C.
  18. "Poll of Editors Predicts Victory for Nixon-Lodge: Republican Ticket Seen Winning in 28 States and Democrats in 19". The Daily Item . November 4, 1960. p. 3.
  19. Gould, Geoffrey (November 7, 1960). "Final Survey Shows Race a Tossup to the Finish". Hattiesburg American . Hattiesburg, Mississippi. p. 16.
  20. "Statistics" (PDF). clerk.house.gov. April 15, 1961. Retrieved July 30, 2019.
  21. 1 2 "VA US President 1960". Our Campaigns.
  22. "TN US President, November 08, 1960". Our Campaigns.
  23. Menendez, Albert J. (2005). The Geography of Presidential Elections in the United States, 1868-2004. pp. 326–331. ISBN   0786422173.