1933 Virginia gubernatorial election

Last updated

1933 Virginia gubernatorial election
Flag of Virginia (1931-1950).png
  1929 November 7, 1933 1937  
  George C. Peery (3x4 cropped).jpg 3x4.svg
Nominee George C. Peery Fred W. McWane
Party Democratic Republican
Popular vote122,82040,377
Percentage73.7%24.2%

1933 Virginia gubernatorial election results map by county.svg
County and independent city results
Peery:      50–60%     60–70%     70–80%     80–90%     >90%
McWane:      50–60%

Governor before election

John Garland Pollard
Democratic

Elected Governor

George C. Peery
Democratic

The 1933 Virginia gubernatorial election was held on November 7, 1933, to elect the governor of Virginia.

Contents

Background

The 1900s had seen Virginia, like all former Confederate States, almost completely disenfranchise its black and poor white populations through the use of a cumulative poll tax and literacy tests. [1] So severe was the disenfranchising effect of the new 1902 Constitution that it has been calculated that a third of those who voted were state employees and officeholders. [1]

This limited electorate made post-disenfranchisement Virginian politics controlled by a political machine based in Southside Virginia and led by Thomas Staples Martin until his death in 1919. Progressive "antiorganization" factions were rendered impotent by the inability of almost all their potential electorate to vote. [2] Unlike the Deep South, historical fusion with the "Readjuster" Democrats, [3] defection of substantial proportions of the Northeast-aligned white electorate of the Shenandoah Valley and Southwest Virginia over free silver, [4] and an early move towards a "lily white" Jim Crow party [3] meant Republicans retained a small but permanent number of legislative seats and local offices in the western part of the state, [5] although in many areas – like in Tennessee during the same era – the parties avoided competition by an agreed division over local offices. [2]

Following the final challenge to hard lily-white control of the state GOP, the small number of black voters in the state were excluded from turning to the rival Democrats by a 1924 party ruling that only qualified whites could vote in the primary. [6] This produced a series of court cases that would see Virginia's white primary permanently invalidated in 1930 without a Supreme Court challenge. [7]

Establishment of the Byrd machine

Whilst the state's white primary was challenged in federal court, Harry Flood Byrd, first elected Democratic central committee chairman in 1922, [8] would be elected Governor in 1925 and implement significant reforms, most importantly a "short ballot" which reduced the number of elected officials to three. [a] Byrd's coattails would allow John Garland Pollard to be elected Governor despite the divisions caused by opposition to Al Smith in the 1928 presidential election. [9] Pollard's win confirmed Byrd's supremacy within Virginia politics, [10] although he had a reputation for independence and was not closely identified with Byrd and his organization. [11]

As Byrd would, except for the "Hundred Days" at the beginning of FDR's first presidential term, always cling to his belief in limited government or "pay-as-you-go", he would support as next Governor George C. Peery, [12] whom he had previously helped "redeem" the "Fighting Ninth" congressional district in 1922. Peery would overwhelm his various opponents, and this election solidified a trend for the small turnout to be even less at the general election than at the Democratic primary. [13]

Democratic primary

Candidates

1933 Virginia Democratic gubernatorial primary [16]
PartyCandidateVotes%±%
Democratic George C. Peery 116,837 61.62%
Democratic Joseph T. Deal 40,26821.25%
Democratic W. Worth Smith 32,51817.15%
Majority 76,56940.38%
Turnout 189,623
Democratic hold Swing

General election

Candidates

Results

1933 Virginia gubernatorial election [21]
PartyCandidateVotes%
Democratic George C. Peery 122,820 73.74%
Republican Fred W. McWane40,37724.24%
Prohibition Andrew J. Dunning1,1120.67%
Socialist George C. White1,1070.67%
Independent John Moffett Robinson8770.53%
Independent W. A. Rowe2740.16%
Total votes166,567 100.00%
Democratic hold

Results by county or independent city

1933 Virginia gubernatorial election by county or independent city [21]
George C. Peery
Democratic
Fred W. McWane
Republican
Andrew J. Dunning
Prohibition
George C. White
Socialist
John M. Robinson
Independent
W.A. Rowe
Independent
MarginTotal votes cast
#%#%#%#%#%#%#%
Accomack County 91986.45%13612.79%60.56%20.19%00.00%00.00%78373.66%1,063
Albemarle County 1,22586.39%16211.42%100.71%140.99%70.49%00.00%1,06374.96%1,418
Alleghany County 53455.86%38740.48%70.73%141.46%111.15%30.31%14715.38%956
Amelia County 39673.88%13525.19%00.00%30.56%10.19%10.19%26148.69%536
Amherst County 71385.90%10913.13%10.12%40.48%20.24%10.12%60472.77%830
Appomattox County 84684.85%13113.14%171.71%00.00%30.30%00.00%71571.72%997
Arlington County 2,04168.95%84628.58%130.44%341.15%200.68%60.20%1,19540.37%2,960
Augusta County 1,63468.03%66827.81%662.75%120.50%150.62%70.29%96640.22%2,402
Bath County 32565.26%16232.53%20.40%71.41%20.40%00.00%16332.73%498
Bedford County 1,03081.81%21617.16%120.95%10.08%00.00%00.00%81464.65%1,259
Bland County 66058.93%45340.45%00.00%40.36%30.27%00.00%20718.48%1,120
Botetourt County 97467.17%41828.83%20.14%10.07%553.79%00.00%55638.34%1,450
Brunswick County 56698.61%50.87%20.35%10.17%00.00%00.00%56197.74%574
Buchanan County 77867.71%36531.77%10.09%20.17%20.17%10.09%41335.94%1,149
Buckingham County 37686.84%5011.55%30.69%30.69%10.23%00.00%32675.29%433
Campbell County 75282.28%15817.29%30.33%00.00%10.11%00.00%59464.99%914
Caroline County 49386.49%6511.40%81.40%30.53%10.18%00.00%42875.09%570
Carroll County 1,05747.83%1,11750.54%20.09%100.45%221.00%20.09%-60-2.71%2,210
Charles City County 11889.39%118.33%21.52%00.00%10.76%00.00%10781.06%132
Charlotte County 48188.10%5810.62%20.37%30.55%20.37%00.00%42377.47%546
Chesterfield County 64175.77%14917.61%344.02%151.77%50.59%20.24%49258.16%846
Clarke County 62193.81%416.19%00.00%00.00%00.00%00.00%58087.61%662
Craig County 31865.03%16633.95%30.61%00.00%10.20%10.20%15231.08%489
Culpeper County 73277.30%20321.44%70.74%30.32%10.11%10.11%52955.86%947
Cumberland County 22790.08%187.14%51.98%10.40%10.40%00.00%20982.94%252
Dickenson County 1,49374.95%48524.35%20.10%20.10%80.40%20.10%1,00850.60%1,992
Dinwiddie County 48492.72%264.98%71.34%40.77%00.00%10.19%45887.74%522
Elizabeth City County 71783.47%11112.92%131.51%121.40%00.00%60.70%60670.55%859
Essex County 20990.09%219.05%00.00%20.86%00.00%00.00%18881.03%232
Fairfax County 1,48377.16%38720.14%140.73%241.25%110.57%30.16%1,09657.02%1,922
Fauquier County 1,14390.71%1128.89%20.16%20.16%10.08%00.00%1,03181.83%1,260
Floyd County 45139.70%68059.86%00.00%20.18%20.18%10.09%-229-20.16%1,136
Fluvanna County 35786.86%4310.46%40.97%20.49%40.97%10.24%31476.40%411
Franklin County 1,41182.37%29016.93%30.18%20.12%60.35%10.06%1,12165.44%1,713
Frederick County 1,05277.64%29821.99%00.00%10.07%30.22%10.07%75455.65%1,355
Giles County 1,17065.40%60233.65%20.11%20.11%110.61%20.11%56831.75%1,789
Gloucester County 48685.87%6611.66%71.24%50.88%10.18%10.18%42074.20%566
Goochland County 34482.69%6114.66%51.20%30.72%20.48%10.24%28368.03%416
Grayson County 1,60148.44%1,67950.80%40.12%80.24%80.24%50.15%-78-2.36%3,305
Greene County 22760.21%14638.73%00.00%00.00%30.80%10.27%8121.49%377
Greensville County 23587.36%3211.90%10.37%00.00%10.37%00.00%20375.46%269
Halifax County 1,66395.52%683.91%20.11%30.17%20.11%30.17%1,59591.61%1,741
Hanover County 70284.27%11213.45%50.60%121.44%20.24%00.00%59070.83%833
Henrico County 1,66166.47%76630.65%60.24%572.28%90.36%00.00%89535.81%2,499
Henry County 65778.40%16619.81%50.60%50.60%30.36%20.24%49158.59%838
Highland County 28052.43%24946.63%20.37%10.19%10.19%10.19%315.81%534
Isle of Wight County 52885.30%8313.41%30.48%30.48%10.16%10.16%44571.89%619
James City County 12977.25%3420.36%31.80%00.00%00.00%10.60%9556.89%167
King and Queen County 16380.30%2813.79%94.43%20.99%00.00%10.49%13566.50%203
King George County 20467.33%9230.36%30.99%00.00%00.00%41.32%11236.96%303
King William County 30581.99%6016.13%51.34%10.27%10.27%00.00%24565.86%372
Lancaster County 36478.79%9420.35%20.43%00.00%20.43%00.00%27058.44%462
Lee County 1,63870.66%63627.44%60.26%50.22%271.16%60.26%1,00243.23%2,318
Loudoun County 1,14584.44%18913.94%171.25%50.37%00.00%00.00%95670.50%1,356
Louisa County 89879.47%20317.96%80.71%151.33%40.35%20.18%69561.50%1,130
Lunenburg County 47890.02%387.16%00.00%101.88%30.56%20.38%44082.86%531
Madison County 49957.22%36441.74%10.11%10.11%70.80%00.00%13515.48%872
Mathews County 34355.32%26743.06%71.13%20.32%10.16%00.00%7612.26%620
Mecklenburg County 56890.73%436.87%121.92%10.16%10.16%10.16%52583.87%626
Middlesex County 29482.12%4011.17%154.19%20.56%51.40%20.56%25470.95%358
Montgomery County 1,33559.07%88339.07%140.62%120.53%130.58%30.13%45220.00%2,260
Nansemond County 45393.21%295.97%30.62%10.21%00.00%00.00%42487.24%486
Nelson County 1,05884.84%16713.39%60.48%20.16%110.88%30.24%89171.45%1,247
New Kent County 10669.74%4227.63%00.00%21.32%21.32%00.00%6442.11%152
Norfolk County 1,66585.43%23412.01%231.18%110.56%90.46%70.36%1,43173.42%1,949
Northampton County 56585.61%8713.18%50.76%30.45%00.00%00.00%47872.42%660
Northumberland County 28778.85%7019.23%00.00%00.00%00.00%71.92%21759.62%364
Nottoway County 53884.46%7010.99%243.77%20.31%20.31%10.16%46873.47%637
Orange County 67183.88%12215.25%30.38%10.13%30.38%00.00%54968.63%800
Page County 1,38377.22%38021.22%70.39%110.61%90.50%10.06%1,00356.00%1,791
Patrick County 1,00573.95%31923.47%30.22%20.15%282.06%20.15%68650.48%1,359
Pittsylvania County 1,50582.15%30616.70%140.76%40.22%10.05%20.11%1,19965.45%1,832
Powhatan County 25985.48%3511.55%00.00%92.97%00.00%00.00%22473.93%303
Prince Edward County 53190.77%478.03%20.34%20.34%20.34%10.17%48482.74%585
Prince George County 20280.16%3714.68%72.78%51.98%10.40%00.00%16565.48%252
Prince William County 65679.90%15018.27%80.97%10.12%50.61%10.12%50661.63%821
Princess Anne County 80281.75%15615.90%131.33%50.51%20.20%30.31%64665.85%981
Pulaski County 1,72881.47%38518.15%50.24%10.05%10.05%10.05%1,34363.32%2,121
Rappahannock County 40191.76%347.78%10.23%00.00%10.23%00.00%36783.98%437
Richmond County 19275.00%6023.44%20.78%00.00%00.00%20.78%13251.56%256
Roanoke County 1,35959.01%89138.69%190.83%180.78%150.65%10.04%46820.32%2,303
Rockbridge County 1,09276.63%31622.18%70.49%10.07%80.56%10.07%77654.46%1,425
Rockingham County 2,22862.22%1,25735.10%601.68%110.31%230.64%20.06%97127.12%3,581
Russell County 2,36775.19%75724.05%30.10%40.13%170.54%00.00%1,61051.14%3,148
Scott County 1,31152.95%1,11344.95%50.20%80.32%291.17%100.40%1988.00%2,476
Shenandoah County 2,13363.48%1,18935.39%100.30%120.36%110.33%50.15%94428.10%3,360
Smyth County 1,70956.85%1,26041.92%50.17%130.43%130.43%60.20%44914.94%3,006
Southampton County 51088.54%518.85%91.56%40.69%10.17%10.17%45979.69%576
Spotsylvania County 49269.49%18125.56%101.41%60.85%91.27%101.41%31143.93%708
Stafford County 28160.30%17437.34%10.21%30.64%40.86%30.64%10722.96%466
Surry County 28592.23%196.15%30.97%10.32%00.00%10.32%26686.08%309
Sussex County 28990.31%257.81%51.56%10.31%00.00%00.00%26482.50%320
Tazewell County 2,06762.92%1,17635.80%100.30%90.27%150.46%80.24%89127.12%3,285
Warren County 79980.14%18918.96%30.30%20.20%30.30%10.10%61061.18%997
Warwick County 18975.60%5522.00%10.40%52.00%00.00%00.00%13453.60%250
Washington County 2,04668.87%87529.45%120.40%80.27%230.77%70.24%1,17139.41%2,971
Westmoreland County 35285.85%5312.93%10.24%20.49%00.00%20.49%29972.93%410
Wise County 3,95883.03%77516.26%50.10%130.27%130.27%30.06%3,18366.77%4,767
Wythe County 1,49158.96%1,01340.06%50.20%40.16%140.55%20.08%47818.90%2,529
York County 20671.78%6020.91%206.97%10.35%00.00%00.00%14650.87%287
Alexandria City 2,46977.86%58418.42%280.88%391.23%371.17%140.44%1,88559.44%3,171
Bristol City 97890.72%948.72%20.19%10.09%30.28%00.00%88482.00%1,078
Buena Vista City 33771.55%12025.48%30.64%30.64%71.49%10.21%21746.07%471
Charlottesville City 74986.89%9110.56%101.16%111.28%10.12%00.00%65876.33%862
Clifton Forge City 76360.08%46636.69%80.63%131.02%181.42%20.16%29723.39%1,270
Danville City 1,58281.80%26713.81%341.76%271.40%170.88%70.36%1,31567.99%1,934
Fredericksburg City 72179.06%17218.86%60.66%30.33%40.44%60.66%54960.20%912
Hampton City 46990.89%397.56%30.58%20.39%10.19%20.39%43083.33%516
Harrisonburg City 1,11164.78%57633.59%130.76%00.00%110.64%40.23%53531.20%1,715
Hopewell City 59776.05%15319.49%20.25%283.57%20.25%30.38%44456.56%785
Lynchburg City 2,16668.87%96730.75%50.16%60.19%10.03%00.00%1,19938.12%3,145
Martinsville City 71580.88%14716.63%141.58%20.23%40.45%20.23%56864.25%884
Newport News City 2,35980.07%46615.82%150.51%772.61%150.51%140.48%1,89364.26%2,946
Norfolk City 3,93079.65%84017.02%851.72%450.91%260.53%80.16%3,09062.63%4,934
Petersburg City 87386.44%11010.89%171.68%80.79%20.20%00.00%76375.54%1,010
Portsmouth City 2,26877.41%55819.04%421.43%331.13%270.92%20.07%1,71058.36%2,930
Radford City 61860.77%39138.45%10.10%40.39%00.00%30.29%22722.32%1,017
Richmond City 6,81481.82%1,23614.84%440.53%1772.13%420.50%150.18%5,57866.98%8,328
Roanoke City 5,26467.49%2,38130.53%260.33%720.92%480.62%90.12%2,88336.96%7,800
South Norfolk City 1,06684.94%15712.51%70.56%120.96%60.48%70.56%90972.43%1,255
Staunton City 89075.74%22719.32%201.70%100.85%272.30%10.09%66356.43%1,175
Suffolk City 63389.28%689.59%60.85%10.14%10.14%00.00%56579.69%709
Williamsburg City 14588.96%169.82%21.23%00.00%00.00%00.00%12979.14%163
Winchester City 95869.88%40929.83%00.00%20.15%20.15%00.00%54940.04%1,371
Totals122,82073.74%40,37724.24%1,1120.67%1,1070.66%8770.53%2740.16%82,44349.50%166,567

Notes

References

  1. 1 2 Kousser, J. Morgan (1974). The Shaping of Southern Politics: Suffrage Restriction and the Establishment of the One-Party South, 1880-1910. Yale University Press. pp. 178–181. ISBN   0-300-01696-4.
  2. 1 2 Key, Valdimer Orlando (1949). Southern Politics in State and Nation. pp. 20–25.
  3. 1 2 Heersink, Boris; Jenkins, Jeffrey A. (March 19, 2020). Republican Party Politics and the American South, 1865-1968. Cambridge University Press. pp. 217–221. ISBN   978-1107158436.
  4. Moger, Allen (August 1938). "The Rift in Virginia Democracy in 1896". The Journal of Southern History . 4 (3): 295–317. doi:10.2307/2191291. JSTOR   2191291.
  5. Phillips, Kevin P. (1969). The Emerging Republican Majority. Arlington House. pp. 193, 219. ISBN   0870000586.
  6. Schneider, Mark Robert (2002). We Return Fighting: The Civil Rights Movement in the Jazz Age. Northeastern University Press. p. 279. ISBN   9781555534905.
  7. Bliley v. West , 42F.2d101 (4th. Cir.June 13, 1930).
  8. Tarter, Brent. "Byrd Organization". Encyclopedia Virgina. Virginia Humanities.
  9. Hall, Alvin L. (July 1965). "Virginia Back in the Fold: The Gubernatorial Campaign and Election of 1929". The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography. 73 (3). Virginia Historical Society: 280–302.
  10. Barker, Stephanie (November 1996). Harry Flood Byrd: Conservative Leader of Virginia (Honors thesis). Longwood University. pp. 26, 40–41.
  11. Heinemann, Ronald L. (1983). Depression and New Deal in Virginia: The Enduring Dominion. University of Virginia Press. p. 3. ISBN   9780813909462.
  12. Barker (November 1996). Harry Flood Byrd (Honors thesis). pp. 18, 59.
  13. Heinemann, Ronald (August 4, 2023). "Prelude to Revolution: The Rise and Fall of the Byrd Organization, 1925–49". In Rozell, Mark; Milliken, John G. (eds.). The New Dominion: The Twentieth-Century Elections That Shaped Modern Virginia. Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press. ISBN   9780813949727.
  14. Sabato, Larry. "Chapter 6: The Organization's Convention Affair". The Democratic Party primary in Virginia: Tantamount to election no longer (Institute of Government report). University of Virginia. pp. 54–55.
  15. Evans, A. Judson (May 2, 1933). "Candidate List Sifted Down to Peery, Smith – Layman, Mapp Indicate Support for Machine Man as Least Wet Aspirant". Richmond Times-Dispatch . p. 1.
  16. "1933 Governor Democratic Primary". Historical Elections Database. Virginia Department of Elections.
  17. "Dry Leader Asks Removal of Police; Heads for Wet Stand at State Meeting". Daily Press . Newport News. September 28, 1933. p. 1.
  18. "Party's Choice for Governor: Fred W. McWane – G.O.P. Nominee, Lynchburg Native". The News and Advance . Lynchburg, Virginia. p. 1.
  19. "John Moffatt Robinson to Run for Governor as Independent". Danville Register and Bee. July 6, 1933. pp. 1, 3.
  20. "W.A. Rowe Enters Race for Governor". The News and Advance . April 12, 1933. p. 5.
  21. 1 2 "1933 Governor General Election". Historical Elections Database. Virginia Department of Elections.