Tuvan language

Last updated

Tuvan
Тыва дыл
Tyva dyl
Pronunciation[tʰɤ̀ʋɐtɤ̀ɫ]
Native to Russia, Mongolia, China
Region Tuva
Ethnicity Tuvans
Native speakers
130,000 (2021)
Turkic
Cyrillic script
Official status
Official language in
Flag of Russia.svg  Russia
Language codes
ISO 639-2 tyv
ISO 639-3 tyv
Glottolog tuvi1240   Tuvinian
todj1234   Todja
ELP Tuva
  Tuha [2]
Lang Status 80-VU.svg
Tuvan is classified as Vulnerable by the UNESCO Atlas of the World's Languages in Danger
This article contains IPA phonetic symbols. Without proper rendering support, you may see question marks, boxes, or other symbols instead of Unicode characters. For an introductory guide on IPA symbols, see Help:IPA.
People Tuvan / Tyvans
Тывалар
Тувинцы
Language Tuvan / Tyvan
Тыва дыл
Country Tuva / Tyva
Тува
Тыва
A Tuvan speaker
Inscription in Kyzyl using Turkic script Kyzyl orkhon inscription.jpg
Inscription in Kyzyl using Turkic script

Tuvan, [lower-alpha 1] sometimes spelt Tyvan, [lower-alpha 2] is a Turkic language spoken in the Republic of Tuva in South Central Siberia, Russia. The language has borrowed a great number of roots from Mongolian, Tibetan and Russian. There are small diaspora groups of Tuvans that speak distinct dialects of Tuvan in China and Mongolia.

Contents

History

While this history focuses on mostly the people of Tuva, many linguists argue that language is inevitably intertwined with the socio-historical situation of a language itself. [3] The earliest record of Tuvan is from the early 19th century by Wūlǐyǎsūtái zhìlüè (Chinese :烏里雅蘇台志略), Julius Klaproth 1823, Matthias Castrén 1857, Nikolay Katanov, Vasily Radlov, etc. [4]

The name Tuva goes back as early as the publication of The Secret History of the Mongols . The Tuva (as they refer to themselves) have historically been referred to as Soyons, Soyots or Uriankhais. [5]

Classification

Tuvan (also spelled Tyvan) is linguistically classified as a Northeastern or Siberian Turkic language, closely related to several other Siberian Turkic languages including Khakas and Altai. Its closest relative is the moribund Tofa.

Although Tuvan has more speakers than endangered languages such as Seri in Mexico (est. 1000 speakers) or Nǁng in South Africa (fewer than 10 speakers), still Tuvan is endangered by global dialects around them like Russian or Mandarin. [6]

Tuvan, as spoken in Tuva, is principally divided into four dialect groups; Western, Central, Northeastern, Southeastern.

Other dialects include those spoken by the Dzungar, the Tsengel and the Dukha Tuvans, but currently these uncommon dialects are not comprehensively documented. Different dialects of the language exist across the geographic region in which Tuvan is spoken. K. David Harrison, who completed his dissertation on the Tuvan language in 2001, argues that the divergence of these dialects relates to the nomadic nature of the Tuvan nation. [7]

One subset is the Jungar Tuvan language, originating in the Altai Mountains in the western region of Mongolia. There is no accurate number of Jungar-Tuvan speakers because most currently reside in China, and the Chinese include Tuvan speakers as Mongolians in their census. [5]

Phonology

Consonants

Tuvan has 19 native consonant phonemes:

Consonant phonemes of Tuvan
Labial Alveolar Palatal Velar
Nasal m n ŋ
Plosive lenis [lower-alpha 3] p t ɡ
fortis [lower-alpha 3] k
Affricate t͡s [lower-alpha 4] t͡ʃ
Fricative voiceless f [lower-alpha 4] s ʃ x
voiced z ʒ
Approximant ʋ l j
Flap ɾ
  1. /ˈtvən/ TOO-vən; Russian:Тувинский язык, romanized:Tuvinskij jazyk, IPA: [tʊˈvʲinskʲɪjjɪˈzɨk]
  2. Tuvan: Тыва дылTyva dyl [tʰɤ̀ʋɐtɤ̀ɫ]
  3. 1 2 The distinction between initial bilabial and alveolar stops is based on aspiration for most speakers and voicing for others.
  4. 1 2 /f/ and /ts/ are found in some Russian loanwords.

Vowels

Vowels in Tuvan exist in three varieties: long, short, and short with low pitch. Tuvan long vowels have a duration that is at least (and often more than) twice as long as that of short vowels. Contrastive low pitch may occur on short vowels, and when it does, it causes them to increase in duration by at least a half. When using low pitch, Tuvan speakers employ a pitch that is at the very low end of their modal voice pitch. For some speakers, it is even lower and using what is phonetically known as creaky voice. When a vowel in a monosyllabic word has low pitch, speakers apply low pitch only to the first half of that vowel (e.g. [àt] 'horse'). [8] That is followed by a noticeable pitch rise, as the speaker returns to modal pitch in the second half of the vowel.

The acoustic impression is similar to that of a rising tone like the rising pitch contour of the Mandarin second tone, but the Tuvan pitch begins much lower. However, Tuvan is considered a pitch accent language with contrastive low pitch instead of a tonal language. When the low pitch vowel occurs in a multisyllabic word, there is no rising pitch contour or lengthening effect: [àdɯ] 'his/her/its horse'. Such low pitch vowels were previously referred to in the literature as either kargyraa or pharyngealized vowels. Phonetic studies have demonstrated that the defining characteristic of such vowels is low pitch. See Harrison 2001 for a phonetic and acoustic study of Tuvan low pitch vowels.

In her PhD thesis, "Long Vowels in Mongolic Loanwords in Tuvan", Baiarma Khabtagaeva states that the history of long vowels is ambiguous. While the long vowels may originate from Mongolic languages, they could also be of Tuvan origin. In most Mongolic languages, the quality of the long vowel changes depending on the quality of the second vowel in the conjunction. The only exception to this rule is if the conjunction is labial. The ancient Tuvan languages, in contrast, depended upon the first vowel rather than the second to determine the long vowels. [9]

Khabtagaeva divided the transformation of these loanwords into two periods: the early layer and the late layer. The words in the early layer are words in which the Mongolic preserved the conjunction, the VCV conjunction was preserved but the long vowel still developed when it entered the Tuvan language, or the stress is on the last syllable and a long vowel in the loanword replaced a short vowel in the original word. The late layer includes loanwords in which the long vowel does not change when the word entered Tuvan. [9]

Vowel phonemes of Tuvan
Short Long Low pitch
HighLowHighLowHighLow
Front Unrounded i e ìè
Rounded y ø øːø̀
Back Unrounded ɯ a ɯːɯ̀à
Rounded u o ùò

Vowels may also be nasalized in the environment of nasal consonants, but nasalization is non-contrastive. Most Tuvan vowels in word-initial syllables have a low pitch and do not contrast significantly with short and long vowels. [7]

Vowel harmony

Tuvan has two systems of vowel harmony that strictly govern the distribution of vowels within words and suffixes. Backness harmony, or what is sometimes called 'palatal' harmony, requires all vowels within a word to be either back or front. Rounding harmony, or what is sometimes called 'labial' harmony, requires a vowel to be rounded if it is a high vowel and appears in a syllable immediately following a rounded vowel. Low rounded vowels [ø][o] are restricted to the first syllable of a word, and a vowel in a non-initial syllable may be rounded only if it meets the conditions of rounding harmony (it must both be a high vowel [y][u] and be preceded by a rounded vowel). See Harrison (2001) for a detailed description of Tuvan vowel harmony systems. [7]

Grammar

Tuvan builds morphologically complex words by adding suffixes. For example, тевеteve is 'camel', тевелерteveler is 'camels', тевелеримtevelerim is 'my camels', тевелеримденtevelerimden is 'from my camels'.

Nouns

Tuvan marks nouns with six cases: genitive, accusative, dative, ablative, locative, and allative. The suffixes below are in front vowels, however, except -Je the suffixes follow vowel harmony rules. Each case suffix has a rich variety of uses and meanings, of which only the most basic ones are shown here.

RootAllomorphs
When after:voicelessnasalsvoiced/vowelAfter
Nominative -∅
Genitive (-NIŋ)-тиң (-tiŋ)-ниң (-niŋ))-диң (-diŋ)
Accusative (-NI)-ти (-ti)-ни (-ni)-ди (-di)
Dative (-KA)-ке (-ke)-ге (-ge)
Locative (-DA)-те (-te)-де (-de)
Ablative (-DAn)-тен (-ten)-ден (-den)
Allative I (-Je)-че (-če)-же (-že)
Allative II (-DIvA) [10] -тиве (-tive)-диве (-dive)
Plural
Nominative (-LAr)-тер (-ter)-нер (-ner)-лер (-ler)-дер (-der)
Oblique cases: by adding voiced variant into the plural suffix (-лерниң, -лерге, ...)
Example of declensions
CaseFormMeaning
Nominativeтеве (teve)"camel"
Genitiveтевениң (teveniŋ)"of the camel"
Accusativeтевени (teveni)"the camel" (definite direct object of verb)
Dativeтевеге (tevege)"for the camel" or "at the camel" (in the past tense)
Locativeтеведе (tevede)"at the camel" or "in the camel"
Ablativeтеведен (teveden)"from the camel" or "than a/the camel"
Allative Iтевеже (teveže)"to(wards) the camel"
Allative IIтеведиве (tevedive)

Verbs

Verbs in Tuvan take a number of endings to mark tense, mood, and aspect. Auxiliary verbs are also used to modify the verb. For a detailed scholarly study of auxiliary verbs in Tuvan and related languages, see Anderson 2004.

Syntax

Tuvan employs SOV word order. For example, теве сиген чипкен (camel hay eat-PAST) "The camel ate the hay."

Vocabulary

Name of family members in Tuvan. Family in tyvan.png
Name of family members in Tuvan.

Tuvan vocabulary is mostly Turkic in origin but marked by a large number of Mongolian loanwords. The language has also borrowed several Mongolian suffixes. In addition, there exist Ketic and Samoyedic substrata.[ citation needed ] A Tuvan talking dictionary is produced by the Living Tongues Institute. [11]

In contrast with most Turkic languages, which have many Arabic and Persian loanwords that even cover some basic concepts, these loanwords are very few, if any, in Tuvan, as Tuvans never adopted Islam like most Turkic peoples.

Writing system

Cyrillic script

The current Tuvan alphabet is a modified version of the Russian alphabet, with three additional letters: Ңң (Latin "ng" or International Phonetic Alphabet [ŋ]), Өө (Latin "ö", [ø]), Үү (Latin "ü", IPA [y]). The sequence of the alphabet follows Russian, but with Ң located after Russian Н, Ө after О, and Ү after У.

А аБ бВ вГ гД дЕ еЁ ёЖ ж
З зИ иЙ йК кЛ лМ мН нҢ ң
О оӨ өП пР рС сТ тУ уҮ ү
Ф фХ хЦ цЧ чШ шЩ щЪ ъЫ ы
Ь ьЭ эЮ юЯ я

The letters Е and Э are used in a special way. Э is used for the short /e/ sound at the beginning of words while Е is used for the same sound in the middle and at the end of words. Е is used at the beginning of words, mostly of Russian origin, to reflect the standard Russian pronunciation of that letter, /je/. Additionally, ЭЭ is used in the middle and at the end of words for the long /e/ sound.

The letter ъ is used to indicate pitch accent, as in эът èt 'meat'.

Historic scripts

Draft scripts

In the past, Tuvans used Mongolian as their written language.

In 1926, the government of the Tuvan People's Republic asked Soviet scientists to develop a native Tuvan script. The first draft of a Tuvan alphabet based on Cyrillic was compiled by Roman Buzykaev (1875-1939) and B. Bryukhanov (Sotpa) in 1927. This alphabet contained the letters Аа, Бб, Вв, Гг, Дд, Ёё, Жж, Ӝӝ, Зз, Ии, Йй, Кк, Лл, Мм, Нн, Ҥҥ, Оо, Ӧӧ, Пп, Рр, Сс, Тт, Уу, Ӱӱ, Хх, Чч, Шш, Ыы. The first Tuvan primer was published using this alphabet, but this project was not developed further.

One of the many draft scripts based on Latin, Cyrillic, and Mongolian scripts was Mongolian script developed by Nikolaus Poppe to suit the Tuvan language. [12]

Tuvan Latin

Example of Latin-based alphabet on the Tuvan People's Republic coat of arms. It says "PYGY TELEGEJNI PROLETARLAR' POLGAS TARLATKAN ARATTAR' KATT'Z'AR". Emblem of the Tuvan People's Republic (1933-1939).svg
Example of Latin-based alphabet on the Tuvan People's Republic coat of arms. It says "PYGY TELEGEJNIꞐ PROLETARLARЬ POLGAŞ TARLATKAN ARATTARЬ KATTЬƵЬꞐAR".

The Latin-based alphabet for Tuvan was devised in 1930 by a Tuvan Buddhist monk, Mongush Lopsang-Chinmit (a.k.a. Lubsan Zhigmed). This project was proposed based on the German alphabet, albeit with a modified letter order. In this proposed system, all vowels were placed first (10 letters), followed by consonants (18 letters). This order is characteristic of the classical Mongolian script. Moreover, the pronunciation of several letters underwent significant alteration. [13] [14]

A few books and newspapers, including primers intended to teach adults to read, were printed using this writing system. Lopsang-Chinmit was later executed in Stalinist purges on 31 December 1941. [15]

In the USSR, Aleksandr Palmbach, Yevgeny Polivanov, and Nicholas Poppe were engaged in the development of the Tuvan Latinized alphabet. These researchers utilized the so-called New Turkic Alphabet as a foundation for their work. Yañalif was designed with the intention of facilitating unification of writing systems among all Turkic peoples. In early 1930, the Tuvan alphabet was finalized and officially introduced on June 28, 1930, by a decree of the TPR government. The approved Tuvan alphabet was as follows:

A aB ʙC cD dE eF fG gƢ ƣ
H hI iJ jɈ ɉK kL lM mN n
Ꞑ ꞑO oӨ өP pR rS sŞ şT t
U uV vX xY yZ zƵ ƶЬ ь

The letter Ɉ ɉ was excluded from the alphabet in 1931.

Examples

Pirgi tьʙa dьldьꞑ yƶykteriPYGY TELEGEJNIꞐ PROLETARLARЬ POLGAŞ TARLATKAN ARATTARЬ KATTЬƵЬꞐAR!
Бирги тыва дылдың үжүктериБүгү телегейниң пролетарлары болгаш дарлаткан араттары каттыжыңар!
First Tuvan language alphabetAll the world's workers and oppressed peoples, unite!

By September 1943, this Latin-based alphabet was replaced by a Cyrillic-based one, which is still in use to the present day. In the post-Soviet era, Tuvan and other scholars have taken a renewed interest in the history of Tuvan letters.

Transliteration

For bibliographic purposes, transliteration of Tuvan generally follows the guidelines described in the ALA-LC Romanization tables for non-Slavic languages in Cyrillic script. [16] Linguistic descriptions often employ the IPA or Turcological standards for transliteration. [17]

Status

Tuvans in China, who live mostly in Xinjiang Autonomous Region, are included under the Mongol nationality. [18] Some Tuvans reportedly live at Kanas Lake in the northwestern part of Xinjiang, where they are not officially recognized, and are counted as a part of the local Oirat Mongol community that is counted under the general PRC official ethnic label of "Mongol". Oirat and Tuvan children attend schools in which they use Chakhar Mongolian [19] and Mandarin Standard Chinese, native languages of neither group.

Notes

  1. Although most Tuvan dialects are classified as Steppe Sayan Turkic, the Tozhu and Tere-Khöl dialects are classified as Taiga Sayan Turkic. [1]

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Turkish language</span> Turkic language of the Turkish people

Turkish is the most widely spoken of the Turkic languages, with around 90 million speakers. It is the national language of Turkey and one of two official languages of Cyprus. Significant smaller groups of Turkish speakers also exist in Germany, Austria, Bulgaria, North Macedonia, Greece, other parts of Europe, the South Caucasus, and some parts of Central Asia, Iraq, and Syria. Turkish is the 18th most spoken language in the world.

In phonology, vowel harmony is a phonological rule in which the vowels of a given domain – typically a phonological word – must share certain distinctive features. Vowel harmony is typically long distance, meaning that the affected vowels do not need to be immediately adjacent, and there can be intervening segments between the affected vowels. Generally one vowel will trigger a shift in other vowels, either progressively or regressively, within the domain, such that the affected vowels match the relevant feature of the trigger vowel. Common phonological features that define the natural classes of vowels involved in vowel harmony include vowel backness, vowel height, nasalization, roundedness, and advanced and retracted tongue root.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kazakh language</span> Turkic language mostly spoken in Kazakhstan

Kazakh or Qazaq is a Turkic language of the Kipchak branch spoken in Central Asia by Kazakhs. It is closely related to Nogai, Kyrgyz and Karakalpak. It is the official language of Kazakhstan, and has official status in the Altai Republic of Russia. It is also a significant minority language in the Ili Kazakh Autonomous Prefecture in Xinjiang, China, and in the Bayan-Ölgii Province of western Mongolia. The language is also spoken by many ethnic Kazakhs throughout the former Soviet Union, Germany, and Turkey.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kyrgyz language</span> Kipchak Turkic language of Central Asia

Kyrgyz is a Turkic language of the Kipchak branch spoken in Central Asia. Kyrgyz is the official language of Kyrgyzstan and a significant minority language in the Kizilsu Kyrgyz Autonomous Prefecture in Xinjiang, China and in the Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Region of Tajikistan. There is a very high level of mutual intelligibility between Kyrgyz, Kazakh, and Altay. A dialect of Kyrgyz known as Pamiri Kyrgyz is spoken in north-eastern Afghanistan and northern Pakistan. Kyrgyz is also spoken by many ethnic Kyrgyz through the former Soviet Union, Afghanistan, Turkey, parts of northern Pakistan, and Russia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mongolian language</span> Official language of Mongolia

Mongolian is the principal language of the Mongolic language family that originated in the Mongolian Plateau. It is spoken by ethnic Mongols and other closely related Mongolic peoples who are native to modern Mongolia and surrounding parts of East and North Asia. Mongolian is the official language of Mongolia and Inner Mongolia and a recognized language of Xinjiang and Qinghai.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Mongolic languages</span> Language family of Eurasia

The Mongolic languages are a language family spoken by the Mongolic peoples in Eastern Europe, Central Asia, North Asia and East Asia, mostly in Mongolia and surrounding areas and in Kalmykia and Buryatia. The best-known member of this language family, Mongolian, is the primary language of most of the residents of Mongolia and the Mongol residents of Inner Mongolia, with an estimated 5.7+ million speakers.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tatar language</span> Turkic language spoken by Tatars

Tatar is a Turkic language spoken by the Volga Tatars mainly located in modern Tatarstan, as well as Siberia and Crimea.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Uyghur language</span> Turkic language of the Karluk sub-branch

Uyghur or Uighur is a Turkic language written in a Uyghur Perso-Arabic script with 8–13 million speakers, spoken primarily by the Uyghur people in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region of Western China. Apart from Xinjiang, significant communities of Uyghur speakers are also located in Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, and Uzbekistan, and various other countries have Uyghur-speaking expatriate communities. Uyghur is an official language of the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region; it is widely used in both social and official spheres, as well as in print, television, and radio. Other ethnic minorities in Xinjiang also use Uyghur as a common language.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Tuvans</span> Siberian Turkic ethnic group

The Tuvans or Tyvans are a Turkic ethnic group indigenous to Siberia that live in Tuva, Mongolia, and China. They speak the Tuvan language, a Siberian Turkic language. In Mongolia, they are regarded as one of the Uriankhai peoples.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Kalmyk Oirat</span> Oirat dialects spoken in Kalmykia, Russia

Kalmyk Oirat, commonly known as the Kalmyk language, is a variety of the Oirat language, natively spoken by the Kalmyk people of Kalmykia, a federal subject of Russia. In Russia, it is the standard form of the Oirat language, which belongs to the Mongolic language family. The Kalmyk people of the Northwest Caspian Sea of Russia claim descent from the Oirats from Eurasia, who have also historically settled in Mongolia and Northwest China. According to UNESCO, the language is "definitely endangered". According to the Russian census of 2021, there are 110,000 speakers out of an ethnic population consisting of 178,000 people.

The Santa language, also known as Dongxiang, is a Mongolic language spoken by the Dongxiang people in Northwest China.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Buryat language</span> Mongolic language of Buryatia (Russia) and neighbouring areas

Buryat or Buriat, known in foreign sources as the Bargu-Buryat dialect of Mongolian, and in pre-1956 Soviet sources as Buryat-Mongolian, is a variety of the Mongolic languages spoken by the Buryats and Bargas that is classified either as a language or major dialect group of Mongolian.

The phonology of the Persian language varies between regional dialects, standard varieties, and even from older varieties of Persian. Persian is a pluricentric language and countries that have Persian as an official language have separate standard varieties, namely: Standard Dari (Afghanistan), Standard Iranian Persian (Iran) and Standard Tajik (Tajikistan). The most significant differences between standard varieties of Persian are their vowel systems. Standard varieties of Persian have anywhere from 6 to 8 vowel distinctions, and similar vowels may be pronounced differently between standards. However, there are not many notable differences when comparing consonants, as all standard varieties have a similar number of consonant sounds. Though, colloquial varieties generally have more differences than their standard counterparts. Most dialects feature contrastive stress and syllable-final consonant clusters. Linguists tend to focus on Iranian Persian, so this article may contain less adequate information regarding other varieties.

Tofa, also known as Tofalar or Karagas, is a moribund Turkic language spoken in Russia's Irkutsk Oblast by the Tofalars. Recent estimates for speakers run from 67 people to fewer than 40.

The Mongolian Latin script was officially adopted in Mongolia in 1931. In 1939, a second version of the Latin alphabet was introduced but not widely used, and was replaced by the Cyrillic script in 1941.

The Dagur, Daghur, Dahur, or Daur language, is a Mongolic language, as well as a distinct branch of the Mongolic language family, and is primarily spoken by members of the Daur ethnic group.

Ordos Mongolian is a variety of Central Mongolic spoken in the Ordos City region in Inner Mongolia and historically by Ordos Mongols. It is alternatively classified as a language within the Mongolic language family or as a dialect of the standard Mongolian language. Due to the research of Antoine Mostaert, the development of this dialect can be traced back 100 years.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Chakhar Mongolian</span> Mongolian variety of Inner Mongolia, China

Chakhar is a variety of Mongolian spoken in the central region of Inner Mongolia. It is phonologically close to Khalkha and is the basis for the standard pronunciation of Mongolian in Inner Mongolia.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Yakut language</span> Siberian Turkic language

Yakut, also known as Yakutian, Sakha, Saqa or Saxa, is a Turkic language belonging to Siberian Turkic branch and spoken by around 450,000 native speakers, primarily the ethnic Yakuts and one of the official languages of Sakha (Yakutia), a federal republic in the Russian Federation.

Soyot is an extinct and revitalizing Turkic language of the Siberian Sayan branch similar to the Dukhan language and closely related to the Tofa language. Two dialects/languages are spoken in Russia and Mongolia: Soyot in the Okinsky District of the Republic of Buryatia (Russia) and Tsaatan in the Darkhad valley of Mongolia.

References

  1. 1 2 Elisabetta Ragagnin (2011), Dukhan, a Turkic Variety of Northern Mongolia, Description and Analysis, Harrassowitz Verlag, Wiesbaden
  2. Endangered Languages Project data for Tuha.
  3. Nettle, Romaine; Daniel, Suzanne (2000). Vanishing Voices: The Extinction of the World's Languages. New York, New York: Oxford University Press.
  4. Todoriki (2011) , pp. 234–230
  5. 1 2 Mawkanuli, Talant (2001). "The Jungar Tuvas: Language and National Identity in the PRC". Central Asian Survey. 20 (4): 497–517. doi:10.1080/02634930120104654. S2CID   143405271.
  6. "What Is Lost When A Language Goes Extinct?". Dictionary.com. 12 August 2012. Retrieved 2 April 2024.
  7. 1 2 3 4 Harrison (2001)
  8. Anderson, Greg; Harrison, K. David (2002). A Grammar of Tuvan. Gaithersburg, MD: Scientific Consulting Services International. pp. 3–5. ISBN   9781584900450.
  9. 1 2 Khabtagaeva, Baiarma (2004). "Long Vowels in Mongolic Loanwords in Tuvan". Turkic Languages. 8: 191–197.
  10. Obsolete or dialectal version of current allative I
  11. see Tuvan Talking Dictionary
  12. Cf. Otgonbayar Chuluunbaatar: Einführung in die mongolischen Schriften. Buske Verlag, Hamburg 2008, ISBN   978-3-87548-500-4, S. 70. "Daher wurde der Sprachforscher Nikolaus Poppe von der tuwinischen Regierung mit der Entwicklung eines für die eigene Sprache geeigneten Alphabets beauftragt. "
  13. Бичелдей, Каадыр-Оол (2010). "80 лет тувинской письменности: становление, развитие, перспективы". Новые исследования Тувы (in Russian) (4): 221. ISSN   2079-8482 . Retrieved 6 October 2024.
  14. For an image of the alphabet, see article Доржу, Зоя; Монгуш, Игорь (2023). "ТРАГИЧЕСКАЯ СУДЬБА УЧЕНОГО ЛАМЫ ЛОПСАН-ЧИНМИТА". Социально-экономический и гуманитарный журнал Красноярского ГАУ (4): 141. Retrieved 6 October 2024., Figure 1
  15. Mänchen-Helfen (1992) , p. 133n
  16. "Non-Slavic languages (in Cyrillic Script)" (PDF). Library of Congress . Archived from the original (PDF) on 3 November 2021. Retrieved 31 March 2022.
  17. Harrison, K. David; Anderson, Gregory D.S.; Ondar, Alexander. "Tuvan Talking Dictionary" . Retrieved 31 March 2022.
  18. Mongush (1996)
  19. "Öbür mongγul ayalγu bol dumdadu ulus-un mongγul kelen-ü saγuri ayalγu bolqu büged dumdadu ulus-un mongγul kelen-ü barimǰiy-a abiy-a ni čaqar aman ayalγun-du saγurilaγsan bayidaγ." (Sečenbaγatur et al. 2005: 85).

Sources

Further reading