Church Image Dates Location City, State Description Presbyterian Church of Atlanta 1895 built 2010 NRHP-listed 2 Main Street 42°33′13.79″N 77°28′23.33″W / 42.5538306°N 77.4731472°W / 42.5538306; -77.4731472 (Presbyterian Church of Atlanta ) Atlanta, New York Queen Anne, Gothic Revival First Presbyterian Church (Batavia, New York) 1854 built 2004 NRHP-listed East Main and Liberty Streets 42°59′47″N 78°10′44″W / 42.99639°N 78.17889°W / 42.99639; -78.17889 (First Presbyterian Church (Schenectady, New York) ) Batavia, New York Gothic Revival Bedford Presbyterian Church (New York) 1872 built 1973 NRHP-listed 44 Village Green 41°12′12″N 73°38′33″W / 41.2032°N 73.6425°W / 41.2032; -73.6425 (Bedford Presbyterian Church ) Bedford Village Historic District Gothic Revival First Presbyterian Church (Schenectady, New York) 1809 built 2000 NRHP-listed 115 Union Street 42°49′02.6″N 73°56′41.2″W / 42.817389°N 73.944778°W / 42.817389; -73.944778 (First Presbyterian Church (Batavia, New York) ) Schenectady, New York New England style, member of the Presbyterian Church in America Batchellerville Presbyterian Church 1867 built 2000 NRHP-listed Co. Rt. 7 43°12′33″N 74°3′21″W / 43.20917°N 74.05583°W / 43.20917; -74.05583 (Batchellerville Presbyterian Church ) Batchellerville, New York Greek Revival Central Presbyterian Church (New York City) 1821 founded 1922 built 593 Park Avenue 40°45′56.5″N 73°58′01.9″W / 40.765694°N 73.967194°W / 40.765694; -73.967194 (Central Presbyterian Church ) New York, New York Gothic Revival, current building built as Park Avenue Baptist Church by John D. Rockefeller Jr. , member of the Evangelical Presbyterian Church (United States) First Presbyterian Church (Brockport, New York) 1852 built 1999 NRHP-listed 35 State St. 43°12′52″N 77°56′14″W / 43.21444°N 77.93722°W / 43.21444; -77.93722 (First Presbyterian Church (Brockport, New York) ) Brockport, New York Greek Revival Setauket Presbyterian Church and Burial Ground 1812 built 1996 NRHP-listed 5 Caroline Ave. 40°56′45″N 73°6′41″W / 40.94583°N 73.11139°W / 40.94583; -73.11139 (Setauket Presbyterian Church and Burial Ground ) Brookhaven, New York Federal Cuyler Presbyterian Church 1892 built 2001 NRHP-listed 358-360 Pacific St. 40°41′12″N 73°59′11.3″W / 40.68667°N 73.986472°W / 40.68667; -73.986472 (Cuyler Presbyterian Church ) Brooklyn, New York Edward Sargent -designed, Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church (Buffalo, New York) 1812 founded 1891 built Buffalo, New York Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church 1894 built 2009 NRHP-listed 875 Elmwood Avenue 42°55′15.31″N 78°52′37.17″W / 42.9209194°N 78.8769917°W / 42.9209194; -78.8769917 (Lafayette Avenue Presbyterian Church ) Buffalo, New York Romanesque Revival First Presbyterian Church of Chester 1854 built 1998 NRHP-listed 106-108 Main St. 41°21′25″N 74°16′39″W / 41.35694°N 74.27750°W / 41.35694; -74.27750 (First Presbyterian Church of Chester ) Chester, New York Greek Revival, built for $10,000 Cochecton Presbyterian Church 1903 built 1992 NRHP-listed Co. Rd. 114, E of Delaware R. Bridge 41°42′25″N 75°3′52″W / 41.70694°N 75.06444°W / 41.70694; -75.06444 (Cochecton Presbyterian Church ) Cochecton, New York Late 19th and Early 20th Century American Movements, Akron Plan Silliman Memorial Presbyterian Church 1897 built 1979 NRHP-listed Mohawk and Seneca Sts. 42°46′28″N 73°42′2″W / 42.77444°N 73.70056°W / 42.77444; -73.70056 (Silliman Memorial Presbyterian Church ) Cohoes, New York Fuller & Wheeler -designed, Romanesque, Richardsonian Romanesque Canterbury Presbyterian Church 1826 built 1996 NRHP-listed 41°26′7″N 74°1′53″W / 41.43528°N 74.03139°W / 41.43528; -74.03139 (Canterbury Presbyterian Church ) Cornwall, New York Federal style First Presbyterian Church Complex (Cortland, New York) 1889 built 2002 NRHP-listed 23 Church St. 42°35′57″N 76°10′41″W / 42.59917°N 76.17806°W / 42.59917; -76.17806 (First Presbyterian Church Complex (Cortland, New York) ) Cortland, New York Late Victorian, Late 19th and 20th Century Revivals Hopewell Presbyterian Church 1831 built 1998 NRHP-listed NY 302, at jct. of NY 17 41°34′14″N 74°20′8″W / 41.57056°N 74.33556°W / 41.57056; -74.33556 (Hopewell Presbyterian Church ) Crawford, New York Gothic Revival First Presbyterian Church (Delhi, New York) 1882 built 2006 NRHP-listed Clinton St. 42°16′28″N 74°55′21″W / 42.27444°N 74.92250°W / 42.27444; -74.92250 (First Presbyterian Church (Delhi, New York) ) Delhi, New York Late Victorian South Presbyterian Church 1868-69 built 2000 NRHP-listed 41°0′55″N 73°52′10″W / 41.01528°N 73.86944°W / 41.01528; -73.86944 (South Presbyterian Church ) Dobbs Ferry, New York Gothic Revival Reformed Presbyterian Church Parsonage c.1829 built 1984 NRHP-listed Duanesburg Churches Rd. 42°46′16″N 74°9′26″W / 42.77111°N 74.15722°W / 42.77111; -74.15722 (Reformed Presbyterian Church Parsonage ) Duanesburg, New York Federal, Vernacular Federal First Presbyterian Church (Dundee, New York) 1895 built 2004 NRHP-listed 31 Main St. 42°31′28″N 76°58′37″W / 42.52444°N 76.97694°W / 42.52444; -76.97694 (First Presbyterian Church (Dundee, New York) ) Dundee, New York Romanesque First Presbyterian Church of Avon 1866 built 2005 NRHP-listed 5605 Avon-Lima Rd. 42°54′35″N 77°42′24″W / 42.90972°N 77.70667°W / 42.90972; -77.70667 (First Presbyterian Church of Avon ) East Avon, New York Federal, Gothic Revival East Palmyra Presbyterian Church 1868-69 built 2002 NRHP-listed 2102 Whitbeck Rd. 43°5′2″N 77°8′52″W / 43.08389°N 77.14778°W / 43.08389; -77.14778 (East Palmyra Presbyterian Church ) East Palmyra, New York Romanesque St. Paul's German Presbyterian Church and Cemetery 1904 built 2008 NRHP-listed 525 Elmont Rd. 40°41′52″N 73°42′54″W / 40.69778°N 73.71500°W / 40.69778; -73.71500 (St. Paul's German Presbyterian Church and Cemetery ) Elmont, New York Gothic First Presbyterian Church of Far Rockaway 1908 built 1986 NRHP-listed 1324 Beach Twelfth St. 40°36′34″N 73°44′51″W / 40.60944°N 73.74750°W / 40.60944; -73.74750 (First Presbyterian Church of Far Rockaway ) Far Rockaway, New York Late Gothic Revival style church designed by Ralph Adams Cram , known also as Russell Sage Memorial Church. Grounds designed by Olmsted Brothers. Camroden Presbyterian Church 2007 NRHP-listed 43°15′12″N 75°16′55″W / 43.25333°N 75.28194°W / 43.25333; -75.28194 (Camroden Presbyterian Church ) Floyd, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church (Glens Falls, New York) 1927 built 1984 NRHP-listed 402-410 Glen St. 43°18′44″N 73°38′21″W / 43.31222°N 73.63917°W / 43.31222; -73.63917 (First Presbyterian Church (Glens Falls, New York) ) Glens Falls, New York Designed by Cram & Ferguson in Late Gothic Revival Greenville Presbyterian Church Complex 1860 built 1985 NRHP-listed North St., NY 32 42°24′58″N 74°01′23″W / 42.41611°N 74.02306°W / 42.41611; -74.02306 (Greenville Presbyterian Church Complex ) Greenville, New York Sparta First Presbyterian Church 1915 built 2007 NRHP-listed 4687 Scottsburg Rd. 42°39′53″N 77°45′59″W / 42.66472°N 77.76639°W / 42.66472; -77.76639 (Sparta First Presbyterian Church ) Groveland Station, New York Late Gothic Revival; it has a crenelated tower. Hamilton Union Presbyterian Church 1886 built 1982 NRHP-listed 2291 Western Tpk. 42°42′14″N 73°54′32″W / 42.70389°N 73.90889°W / 42.70389; -73.90889 (Hamilton Union Presbyterian Church ) Guilderland, New York Stick/Eastlake Guildford Center Presbyterian Church 1817 built 2004 NRHP-listed Cty Rd. 36 42°24′23″N 75°27′53″W / 42.40639°N 75.46472°W / 42.40639; -75.46472 (Guildford Center Presbyterian Church ) Guilford Center, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church of Hector 1818 built 2001 NRHP-listed 5519 NY 414 42°30′1″N 76°52′23″W / 42.50028°N 76.87306°W / 42.50028; -76.87306 (First Presbyterian Church of Hector ) Hector, New York Federal First Presbyterian Church of Highland Falls 1868 built 1982 NRHP-listed 41°22′17″N 73°57′54″W / 41.37139°N 73.96500°W / 41.37139; -73.96500 (First Presbyterian Church of Highland Falls ) Highland Falls, New York Now is United Methodist Church of the Highlands. Frederick Clarke Withers -designed in Romanesque Revival German Presbyterian Church and Hortonville Cemetery 1860 built 2003 NRHP-listed CR 121 and CR 131 41°46′21″N 75°1′42″W / 41.77250°N 75.02833°W / 41.77250; -75.02833 (German Presbyterian Church and Hortonville Cemetery ) Hortonville, New York Sweet Hollow Presbyterian Church Parsonage 1830 built 1985 NRHP-listed 152 Old Country Rd. 40°47′33″N 73°25′5″W / 40.79250°N 73.41806°W / 40.79250; -73.41806 (Sweet Hollow Presbyterian Church Parsonage ) Huntington, New York First Presbyterian Church in Jamaica 1662 founded Jamaica, Queens, New York Organized in 1662, it is the oldest continuously serving Presbyterian church in the United States. Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex 1848 built 2001 NRHP-listed Church St. 42°16′12″N 74°18′15″W / 42.27000°N 74.30417°W / 42.27000; -74.30417 (Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex ) Jewett, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church of Le Roy 1826 built 2014 NRHP-listed 7 Clay St. 42°58′38.3″N 77°59′31.6″W / 42.977306°N 77.992111°W / 42.977306; -77.992111 (First Presbyterian Church of Le Roy ) Le Roy, New York Lima Presbyterian Church 1987 CP NRHP-listed 42°54′19″N 77°36′44″W / 42.90528°N 77.61222°W / 42.90528; -77.61222 (Jewett Presbyterian Church Complex, approximate location ) Lima, New York Included in the Lima Village Historic District United Presbyterian Church (Lisbon, New York) 1857 built 2005 NRHP-listed 26 Church St. 44°43′47″N 75°19′17″W / 44.72972°N 75.32139°W / 44.72972; -75.32139 (United Presbyterian Church (Lisbon, New York) ) Lisbon, New York H.J. Horwood-designed Lordville Presbyterian Church 1896 built 2000 NRHP-listed Lordville Rd. 41°52′11″N 75°12′57″W / 41.86972°N 75.21583°W / 41.86972; -75.21583 (Lordville Presbyterian Church ) Lordville, New York Late Victorian Lowville Presbyterian Church 1831 built 2007 NRHP-listed 7707 North State St. 43°47′28″N 75°29′47″W / 43.79111°N 75.49639°W / 43.79111; -75.49639 (Lowville Presbyterian Church ) Lowville, New York Federal Forest Presbyterian Church 1894 built 2004 NRHP-listed 4109 Center St. 43°37′5″N 75°21′41″W / 43.61806°N 75.36139°W / 43.61806; -75.36139 (Forest Presbyterian Church ) Lyons Falls, New York Shingle Style with Gothic elements First Presbyterian Church of Marcellus 1801 founded 1851 built East Main and North Streets 42°58′58″N 76°20′23″W / 42.9828°N 76.3398°W / 42.9828; -76.3398 (First Presbyterian Church of Marcellus ) Marcellus, New York First Presbyterian Church of Margaretville 1894 built 2004 NRHP-listed 42°8′57″N 74°39′6″W / 42.14917°N 74.65167°W / 42.14917; -74.65167 (First Presbyterian Church of Margaretville ) Margaretville, New York Late Victorian Presbyterian Church of McGraw 1901 built 1986 NRHP-listed 3 W. Main St. 42°35′44″N 76°5′45″W / 42.59556°N 76.09583°W / 42.59556; -76.09583 (Presbyterian Church of McGraw ) McGraw, New York Eclectic Queen Anne Mendon Presbyterian Church 2005 NRHP-listed 3886 Rush-Mendon Rd. 43°0′0″N 77°30′25″W / 43.00000°N 77.50694°W / 43.00000; -77.50694 (Mendon Presbyterian Church ) Mendon, New York Gothic Middle Island Presbyterian Church 1837 built 2005 NRHP-listed 271 Middle Country Road 40°52′49″N 72°57′48″W / 40.88028°N 72.96333°W / 40.88028; -72.96333 (Middle Island Presbyterian Church ) Middle Island, New York Federal Monsey Church 1824 founded 41°06′44″N 74°04′09″W / 41.112168°N 74.069232°W / 41.112168; -74.069232 (The Monsey Church ) Monsey, New York Greek Revival with elements of Italianate , joined the Presbyterian Church in America from the Christian Reformed Church in 2005 First Presbyterian Church of Mumford 1883 built 2002 NRHP-listed George and William Sts. 42°59′32″N 77°51′44″W / 42.99222°N 77.86222°W / 42.99222; -77.86222 (First Presbyterian Church of Mumford ) Mumford, New York Andrew Jackson Warner -designed, Gothic New Kingston Presbyterian Church 1900 built 2002 NRHP-listed CR 6 42°12′48″N 74°40′57″W / 42.21333°N 74.68250°W / 42.21333; -74.68250 (New Kingston Presbyterian Church ) New Kingston, New York Late Victorian First Presbyterian Church and Lewis Pintard House 1710 built 1979 NRHP-listed Pintard Ave. 40°54′16″N 73°47′7″W / 40.90444°N 73.78528°W / 40.90444; -73.78528 (First Presbyterian Church and Lewis Pintard House ) New Rochelle, New York John Russell Pope-designed, Colonial Revival Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church 1808 founded 1875 built Fifth Avenue at 55th Street 40°45′43″N 73°58′30″W / 40.76194°N 73.97500°W / 40.76194; -73.97500 (Fifth Avenue Presbyterian Church ) New York City Gothic Revival First Presbyterian Church of Manhattan 1716 founded 1844–46 built 48 Fifth Avenue 40°44′4″N 73°59′42″W / 40.73444°N 73.99500°W / 40.73444; -73.99500 (First Presbyterian Church of Manhattan ) New York City Gothic Revival Fort Washington Presbyterian Church 1913 built 2010 NRHP-listed 21 Wadsworth Ave. 40°50′43.35″N 73°56′16.24″W / 40.8453750°N 73.9378444°W / 40.8453750; -73.9378444 (Fort Washington Presbyterian Church ) New York, New York Georgian Revival New York Presbyterian Church 1884 built 1982 NRHP-listed 151 W. 128th St. 40°48′39″N 73°56′49″W / 40.81083°N 73.94694°W / 40.81083; -73.94694 (New York Presbyterian Church ) New York, New York Served until 1918 as a Presbyterian church, then acquired by a Baptist church. Gothic, Romanesque Redeemer Presbyterian Church 1989 founded Multiple locations 40°45′07″N 73°59′17″W / 40.75190°N 73.98798°W / 40.75190; -73.98798 (Redeemer Presbyterian Church ) New York, New York Riverdale Presbyterian Church Complex 1863 built 1982 NRHP-listed 4761-4765 Henry Hudson Parkway 40°53′45″N 73°54′32″W / 40.89583°N 73.90889°W / 40.89583; -73.90889 (Riverdale Presbyterian Church Complex ) New York, New York James Renwick Jr. and Dwight J. Baum -designed; Late Gothic Revival, Stick/Eastlake First Presbyterian Church of Ontario Center 1914 built 1998 NRHP-listed 1638 Ridge Rd. 43°13′31″N 77°18′6″W / 43.22528°N 77.30167°W / 43.22528; -77.30167 (First Presbyterian Church of Ontario Center ) Ontario Center, New York Tudor Revival First Presbyterian Church of Oyster Bay 1873 built 1976 NRHP-listed 40°52′18.25″N 73°31′45.35″W / 40.8717361°N 73.5292639°W / 40.8717361; -73.5292639 (First Presbyterian Church of Oyster Bay ) Oyster Bay, New York J. Cleveland Cady -designed in Stick/Eastlake style Peekskill Presbyterian Church 1846 built 2002 NRHP-listed 41°17′19″N 73°55′27″W / 41.28861°N 73.92417°W / 41.28861; -73.92417 (Peekskill Presbyterian Church ) Peekskill, New York Greek Revival Brick Presbyterian Church 1909 built 2007 NRHP-listed 6 Church Street 42°43′14.9982″N 78°0′4.7412″W / 42.720832833°N 78.001317000°W / 42.720832833; -78.001317000 (Brick Presbyterian Church ) Perry, New York Gothic Revival Smithfield Presbyterian Church 1820 built 1994 NRHP-listed Pleasant Valley Rd. between Elizabeth and Park Sts. 42°57′56″N 75°41′17″W / 42.96556°N 75.68806°W / 42.96556; -75.68806 (Smithfield Presbyterian Church ) Peterboro, New York Italianate, Federal Childwold Memorial Presbyterian Church 1903 built 2001 NRHP-listed Bancroft Rd. 44°17′5″N 74°40′9″W / 44.28472°N 74.66917°W / 44.28472; -74.66917 (Childwold Memorial Presbyterian Church ) Piercefield, New York Queen Anne First Presbyterian Church (Plattsburgh, New York) 1868 built 1982 NRHP-listed 34 Brinkerhoff St. 44°41′50″N 73°27′16″W / 44.69722°N 73.45444°W / 44.69722; -73.45444 (First Presbyterian Church (Plattsburgh, New York) ) Plattsburgh, New York Gothic Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church 1888 built 1995 NRHP-listed Jct. of Church and S. Main Sts., NW corner, Town of Moriah 44°2′53″N 73°27′39″W / 44.04806°N 73.46083°W / 44.04806; -73.46083 (Mount Moriah Presbyterian Church ) Port Henry, New York Romanesque First Presbyterian Church of Dailey Ridge 1853 built 2002 NRHP-listed 411 Elliot Rd. 44°44′48″N 75°3′48″W / 44.74667°N 75.06333°W / 44.74667; -75.06333 (First Presbyterian Church of Dailey Ridge ) Potsdam, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church (Poughkeepsie, New York) 1905 built 1982 NRHP-listed 25 S. Hamilton St. 41°42′4″N 73°55′29″W / 41.70111°N 73.92472°W / 41.70111; -73.92472 (First Presbyterian Church (Poughkeepsie, New York) ) Poughkeepsie, New York Romanesque First Presbyterian Church Rectory (Poughkeepsie, New York) c.1857 built 1982 NRHP-listed 98 Cannon St. 41°42′4″N 73°55′31″W / 41.70111°N 73.92528°W / 41.70111; -73.92528 (First Presbyterian Church Rectory (Poughkeepsie, New York) ) Poughkeepsie, New York Second Empire First Presbyterian Church (Preble, New York) 1831 built 2002 NRHP-listed Courtland Cty Rd. 108B 42°44′6″N 76°8′47″W / 42.73500°N 76.14639°W / 42.73500; -76.14639 (First Presbyterian Church (Preble, New York) ) Preble, New York Federal, Colonial Revival Brick Presbyterian Church Complex 1860 built 1992 NRHP-listed 121 N. Fitzhugh St. 43°9′27″N 77°37′1″W / 43.15750°N 77.61694°W / 43.15750; -77.61694 (Brick Presbyterian Church Complex ) Rochester, New York Colonial Revival, Early Romanesque Revival Emmanuel Presbyterian Church 1915 built 2001 NRHP-listed Jefferson Ave. at 9 Shelter St. 43°8′19″N 77°37′47″W / 43.13861°N 77.62972°W / 43.13861; -77.62972 (Emmanuel Presbyterian Church ) Rochester, New York Late 19th and Early 20th Century American Movements First Presbyterian Church (Rochester, New York) 1871 built 1973 NRHP-listed 101 S. Plymouth Ave. 43°9′10″N 77°36′56″W / 43.15278°N 77.61556°W / 43.15278; -77.61556 (First Presbyterian Church (Rochester, New York) ) Rochester, New York Gothic, designed by Andrew J. Warner Roscoe Presbyterian Church and Westfield Flats Cemetery c.1884 built 2001 NRHP-listed Old NY 17 41°55′56″N 74°54′47″W / 41.93222°N 74.91306°W / 41.93222; -74.91306 (Roscoe Presbyterian Church and Westfield Flats Cemetery ) Roscoe, New York Late Victorian Old Whaler's Church (First Presbyterian Church of Sag Harbor) 1766 founded 1844 built 1994 NHL-designated 44 Union Street 40°59′50″N 72°17′38.66″W / 40.99722°N 72.2940722°W / 40.99722; -72.2940722 (Old Whaler's Church ) Sag Harbor, New York Minard Lafever -designed in Egyptian Revival style, with Greek Revival elements Union Presbyterian Church (Scottsville, New York) 2004 NRHP-listed Church St. 43°1′18″N 77°45′7″W / 43.02167°N 77.75194°W / 43.02167; -77.75194 (Union Presbyterian Church (Scottsville, New York) ) Scottsville, New York Exotic Revival; also known as First Presbyterian Church of Wheatland First Presbyterian Church (Smithtown, New York) 1825 built 1977 NRHP-listed 175 E. Main St. 40°51′24″N 73°11′18″W / 40.85667°N 73.18833°W / 40.85667; -73.18833 (First Presbyterian Church (Smithtown, New York) ) Smithtown, New York First Presbyterian Church (Spencer, New York) 1915 built 2005 NRHP-listed 75-77 N. Main St. 42°12′50″N 76°29′33″W / 42.21389°N 76.49250°W / 42.21389; -76.49250 (First Presbyterian Church (Spencer, New York) ) Spencer, New York Gothic Revival St. Peter's Presbyterian Church and Spencertown Cemetery 1771 built 2002 NRHP-listed 42°19′23″N 73°32′46″W / 42.32306°N 73.54611°W / 42.32306; -73.54611 (St. Peter's Presbyterian Church and Spencertown Cemetery ) Spencertown, New York Federal Seneca Presbyterian Church 1838 built 1973 NRHP-listed 42°48′20″N 77°3′5″W / 42.80556°N 77.05139°W / 42.80556; -77.05139 (Seneca Presbyterian Church ) Stanley, New York Calvary Presbyterian Church (Staten Island, New York) 1894 built 2002 NRHP-listed 909 Castleton Ave. 40°38′6″N 74°6′46″W / 40.63500°N 74.11278°W / 40.63500; -74.11278 (Calvary Presbyterian Church (Staten Island, New York) ) Staten Island, New York Romanesque, Tudor Revival First Presbyterian Church of Ulysses built NRHP-listed Main St. 42°32′29″N 76°39′34″W / 42.54139°N 76.65944°W / 42.54139; -76.65944 (First Presbyterian Church of Ulysses ) Trumansburg, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church of Tuscarora 2004 NRHP-listed 8082 Main St. 42°38′3″N 77°52′12″W / 42.63417°N 77.87000°W / 42.63417; -77.87000 (First Presbyterian Church of Tuscarora ) Tuscarora, New York Greek Revival First Presbyterian Church (Utica, New York) 1920 built 1988 NRHP-listed 43°5′29″N 75°15′1″W / 43.09139°N 75.25028°W / 43.09139; -75.25028 (First Presbyterian Church (Utica, New York) ) Utica, New York Ralph Adams Cram -designed First Presbyterian Church (Valatie, New York) 1878 built 1979 NRHP-listed Church St. 42°24′55″N 73°40′36″W / 42.41528°N 73.67667°W / 42.41528; -73.67667 (First Presbyterian Church (Valatie, New York) ) Valatie, New York Gothic Wanakena Presbyterian Church 1903 built 2007 NRHP-listed 32 Second St. 44°8′9″N 74°55′18″W / 44.13583°N 74.92167°W / 44.13583; -74.92167 (Wanakena Presbyterian Church ) Wanakena, New York Late Victorian First Presbyterian Church (Waterloo, New York) 1850 built 1996 NRHP-listed E. Main St., E of jct. with NY 96 42°54′14″N 76°51′39″W / 42.90389°N 76.86083°W / 42.90389; -76.86083 (First Presbyterian Church (Waterloo, New York) ) Waterloo, New York Romanesque West Charlton United Presbyterian Church c.1880 built 1998 NRHP-listed 1331 Sacandaga Rd. 42°58′22″N 74°1′50″W / 42.97278°N 74.03056°W / 42.97278; -74.03056 (West Charlton United Presbyterian Church ) West Charlton, New York Late Victorian West Delhi Presbyterian Church, Manse, and Cemetery 1892 built 2008 NRHP-listed 18 and 45 Sutherland Rd. 42°18′0.41″N 75°0′25.29″W / 42.3001139°N 75.0070250°W / 42.3001139; -75.0070250 (West Delhi Presbyterian Church, Manse, and Cemetery ) West Delhi, New York Late Victorian West Kortright Presbyterian Church 1850 built 2002 NRHP-listed 49 W. Kortright Church Rd. 42°24′8″N 74°51′8″W / 42.40222°N 74.85222°W / 42.40222; -74.85222 (West Kortright Presbyterian Church ) West Kortright, New York Late Victorian First Congregational and Presbyterian Society Church of Westport 1837 built 1988 NRHP-listed Main St./CR 10 44°13′50″N 73°27′33″W / 44.23056°N 73.45917°W / 44.23056; -73.45917 (First Congregational and Presbyterian Society Church of Westport ) Westport, New York Federal Centre Presbyterian Church 1835 built 1979 NRHP-listed Main and Church Sts 42°18′24″N 74°15′9″W / 42.30667°N 74.25250°W / 42.30667; -74.25250 (Centre Presbyterian Church ) Windham, New York Greek Revival, Federal First Presbyterian Church (Wolcott, New York) 1883 built W. Main St. 43°13′12″N 76°48′58″W / 43.22000°N 76.81611°W / 43.22000; -76.81611 (First Presbyterian Church (Wolcott, New York) ) Wolcott, New York Romanesque Revival; polychrome masonry; one of three contributing buildings in Wolcott Square Historic District First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown 1840 built 2880 Crompond Road 41°17′39″N 73°48′33″W / 41.2943°N 73.8091°W / 41.2943; -73.8091 (First Presbyterian Church of Yorktown ) Yorktown, New York Listed on the APRHS #4, founded 1730, burned by the British 1779, rebuilt 1785 [7] Caldwell Presbyterian Church mid-1850s built 71 Montcalm St. 43°25′30″N 73°42′54″W / 43.425083°N 73.714925°W / 43.425083; -73.714925 (Caldwell Presbyterian Church ) Lake George, New York NRHP listed Listed 4/12/2016, number 16000164 Redeemer Presbyterian Church (New York, New York) 1989 150 West 83rd Street New York, New York A PCA church, one of the most influential Presbyterian churches in America founded by Tim Keller