Shark cage diving

Last updated
Sharks swimming outside shark-proof cage with people inside Sharks outside cage.jpg
Sharks swimming outside shark-proof cage with people inside

Shark cage diving is underwater diving or snorkeling where the observer remains inside a protective cage designed to prevent sharks from making contact with the divers. Shark cage diving is used for scientific observation, underwater cinematography, and as a tourist activity. Sharks may be attracted to the vicinity of the cage by the use of bait, in a procedure known as chumming, which has attracted some controversy as it is claimed to potentially alter the natural behaviour of sharks in the vicinity of swimmers.

Contents

Similar cages are also used purely as a protective measure for divers working in waters where potentially dangerous shark species are present. In this application the shark-proof cage may be used as a refuge, or as a diving stage during descent and ascent, particularly during staged decompression where the divers may be vulnerable while constrained to a specific depth in mid-water for several minutes. In other applications a mobile cage may be carried by the diver while harvesting organisms such as abalone.

Shark-proof cage

Great white shark cages at Isla Guadalupe, Mexico Great white shark cages at Isla Guadalupe, Mexico, November 2017. Shark cage diving with the MV Horizon. Animal estimated at 16-18 feet in length, age unknown.png
Great white shark cages at Isla Guadalupe, Mexico
White shark cage diving near Gansbaai in South Africa (2015) White shark cage diving, Gansbaai.jpg
White shark cage diving near Gansbaai in South Africa (2015)

A shark-proof cage is a metal cage used by an underwater diver, to observe dangerous types of sharks up close or to harvest seafood in relative safety. Of the various species of shark, those most commonly observed from a cage are the great white shark and the bull shark, which are both known to be aggressive at times. Shark-proof cages are built to withstand being rammed and bitten by sharks, and are intended to protect the user from injury. Cages can provide a visual and tactile deterrent to sharks.[ citation needed ] Cage-diving allows people to closely monitor sharks for scientific, commercial or recreational purposes, and sometimes interact with them.

The shark-proof cage is also used in the controversial exercise of shark baiting, where tourists are lowered in a cage while the tour guides bait the water to attract sharks or stimulate certain behavior. [1]

Early development

Shark cages were first developed by Jacques Cousteau. [2] Cousteau used a shark cage when producing The Silent World , released in 1956. [3] Australian recreational diver and shark-attack survivor Rodney Fox helped develop a shark-observation cage in the late 1960s. [4] Fox's first design was inspired by a visit to a zoo he made after surviving a near-fatal shark attack in 1963. [5] Film-maker Peter Gimbel was involved in the design of a shark-proof cage for the production of Blue Water, White Death (1971). [6]

Self-propelled version

In 1974, after several reported shark attacks on working divers in Australia, Australian abalone diver James "Jim" Ellis developed a self-propelled cage to protect abalone divers from sharks, [7] [8] which he patented in 1975. [9] [10] Mounting the motor in gimbals in the front of the cage makes the vehicle highly maneuverable. Movement and speed are controlled with a "joystick". [11] The design allowed abalone divers to work without becoming vulnerable to attack. [9] Due to the propulsion system, the divers would exert themselves less and, therefore, might be able to collect molluscs for longer periods. [9] The patent abstract details a self-propelled cage with at least one access opening and a mounting frame that carries both an air motor and a propeller. Buoyant material is attached to the frame so that the cage may be made neutrally buoyant. [12] [9] The diver can control warm water piped to the diver's suit in cold environments. [12] [13] Propulsion was later changed to hydraulics supplied from the boat through the diver's umbilical. [12] The patent expired in 1996, [9] although Ellis continued to make improvements. [14]

A 1975 version of the cage was acquired by the Australian National Maritime Museum in 1988. [15]

Shark-cage diving tourism

During the 2000s, shark-cage diving became more popular as a tourist activity. In South Australia, tourists are taken by boat from Port Lincoln to the Neptune Islands in the southern Spencer Gulf, where they view great white sharks either from a cage tethered to the back of a boat near the surface or from a cage lowered to the seabed. The government considers the activity to be one of South Australia's "iconic nature-based tourism experiences", which supports 70 jobs and contributes over $11 million to the state's economy. [16]

Shark baiting

Shark baiting is a procedure where the water is baited by chumming with fish or other materials attractive to sharks. [17] Tourists remain inside a shark-proof cage while tour guides bait the waters to attract sharks for the tourists to observe. There have been claims that this could lead to potentially aggressive behavior by the shark population. [18] Some conservation groups, scuba divers, and underwater photographers consider the practice undesirable and potentially dangerous.

In South Australia, abalone divers have been attacked by great white sharks, and divers believe that great white shark cage diving tourism has altered shark behavior including making them more inclined to approach boats. At least one abalone diver, Peter Stephenson has called for a ban on shark-cage diving and described it as a "major workplace safety issue". The government of South Australia claims that there is "no scientific evidence" to suggest that the general public is at elevated risk of shark attack as a result of shark cage tourism. [16]

Opponents of the cage-diving industry, such as shark-survivor Craig Bovim, who was reportedly bitten by a ragged-tooth shark [19] (a species not targeted by cage diving operators in the region, and not generally considered a hazard to divers) while snorkeling for lobster at Scarborough, on the other side of the Cape Peninsula from Seal Island, where the shark cage boats operate, believe that the repeated chumming used to lure sharks to tourist cages may alter sharks' behaviour. [20] [21] [ failed verification ] Bovim's opponents, such as marine environmentalist Wilfred Chivell, contend that there is no demonstrated correlation between shark-baiting and shark attacks against humans. [21] However, there is evidence that the baiting of sharks for tourism does alter the patterns of movement of Great White Sharks. [22]

Shark cage diving incidents

In 2005, a British tourist, Mark Currie, was exposed to a high risk of injury or death when a 5-metre (18 ft) great white shark bit through the bars of a shark cage being used during a recreational shark dive off the coast of South Africa. [23] [24] The shark circled the boat several times, and began to attack the side of the cage, then started to crush and bite through. The captain attempted to free the cage by trying to distract the shark. He did this by hitting it on the head with an iron pole. The shark bit into one of the buoys at the top of the cage, which caused the cage to begin sinking. Currie quickly swam out of the top of the cage and was pulled to safety by the boat's captain, who fended off the shark with blows to its head. [24]

In 2007, a commercial shark cage was destroyed off the coast of Guadalupe Island after a 4.6-metre (15 ft) great white shark became entangled and tore the cage apart in a frantic effort to free itself. [25] Tourists captured video of the incident, which quickly spread on the Internet.[ citation needed ]

On April 13, 2008, there was a fatal capsize of a shark cage diving boat off the coast near Gansbaai, South Africa, where three tourists died - two Americans and one Norwegian. The cage diving vessel was anchored on the Geldsteen reef near Dyer Island (South Africa) and engaged in shark cage diving viewing activities when it was capsized by a large wave estimated at 6m in a swell estimated at 4m significant wave height height. The boat engines were off while anchored over the reef, and the skipper was at the back of the vessel handling the bait line attracting sharks towards the cage. A videographer was in the cage at the time of capsize filming underwater footage for the DVDs sold as a tour souvenir. During the capsize, all of the 19 people on board were thrown overboard. [26] It was unknown at the time of the capsize how many passengers were onboard the vessel, and two American tourists were trapped underneath the capsized hull for more than forty minutes before it was realized that passengers were still unaccounted for. It was claimed by one of the defendants during the 2014 Western Cape High Court trial in Cape Town, South Africa that the wave that capsized the vessel was a freak wave, but statistically it was probably simply a larger wave in a 4 meter swell, that picked up over the reef. Since the vessel was anchored over a reef with engines off, it made a larger than normal wave more likely to break near the boat, and a capsize more difficult to avoid. There were other breaking waves shown in photos and videos which showed the increasing danger. The trial judge ruled that the skipper, cage diving operators, and boat owners were guilty of negligence. [26] Being anchored over a reef in a large sea in dangerous conditions was ruled as the primary reason for the capsize and death of the three tourists, Shark cage diving was incidental, but was the reason for the vessel to have remained anchored over a shallow reef, with engines off, despite increasing swells and breaking waves. If sharks had not been present and if the videographer had not still been in the cage filming they would have probably have already left. [27]

Another incident reported in 2016 occurred off the coast of Mexico, when a shark that lunged for the bait broke into the cage and the diver was able to escape uninjured. [28]

See also

Related Research Articles

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Aqua-Lung</span> Original name for open-circuit scuba equipment

Aqua-Lung was the first open-circuit, self-contained underwater breathing apparatus to achieve worldwide popularity and commercial success. This class of equipment is now commonly referred to as a twin-hose diving regulator, or demand valve. The Aqua-Lung was invented in France during the winter of 1942–1943 by two Frenchmen: engineer Émile Gagnan and Jacques Cousteau, who was a Naval Lieutenant. It allowed Cousteau and Gagnan to film and explore underwater more easily.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Wreck diving</span> Recreational diving on wrecks

Wreck diving is recreational diving where the wreckage of ships, aircraft and other artificial structures are explored. The term is used mainly by recreational and technical divers. Professional divers, when diving on a shipwreck, generally refer to the specific task, such as salvage work, accident investigation or archaeological survey. Although most wreck dive sites are at shipwrecks, there is an increasing trend to scuttle retired ships to create artificial reef sites. Diving to crashed aircraft can also be considered wreck diving. The recreation of wreck diving makes no distinction as to how the vessel ended up on the bottom.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Fabien Cousteau</span> Aquanaut, ocean conservationist, and documentary filmmaker

Fabien Cousteau is an aquanaut, ocean conservationist, and documentary filmmaker. As the first grandson of Jacques Cousteau, Fabien spent his early years aboard his grandfather's ships Calypso and Alcyone, and learned how to scuba dive on his fourth birthday. From 2000 to 2002, he was Explorer-at-Large for National Geographic and collaborated on a television special aimed at changing public attitudes about sharks called "Attack of the Mystery Shark". From 2003 to 2006, he produced the documentary "Mind of a Demon" that aired on CBS. With the help of a large crew, he created a 14-foot, 1,200-pound, lifelike shark submarine called "Troy" that enabled him to immerse himself inside the shark world.

Rodney Winston Fox is an Australian film maker, conservationist, survivor of an attack by a great white shark, and one of the world's foremost authorities on that species. He was inducted into the International Scuba Diving Hall of Fame in 2007. He was born in Adelaide.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">1992 cageless shark-diving expedition</span> First recorded cageless dive with great white sharks

The 1992 cageless shark-diving expedition was the world's first recorded intentionally cageless dive with great white sharks, contributing to a change in public opinions about the supposed ferocity of these animals.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Canoe and kayak diving</span> Recreational diving from a canoe or kayak

Canoe diving and Kayak diving are recreational diving where the divers paddle to a diving site in a canoe or kayak carrying all their gear in or on the boat to the place they want to dive. Canoe or kayak diving gives the diver independence from dive boat operators, while allowing dives at sites which are too far to comfortably swim, but are sufficiently sheltered.

Ronald Josiah Taylor, was an Australian shark expert, as is his widow, Valerie Taylor. They were credited with being pioneers in several areas, including being the first people to film great white sharks without the protection of a cage. Their expertise has been called upon for films such as Jaws, Orca and Sky Pirates.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shark tourism</span> Tourism industry based on viewing wild sharks

Shark tourism is a form of eco-tourism that allows people to dive with sharks in their natural environment. This benefits local shark populations by educating tourists and through funds raised by the shark tourism industry. Communities that previously relied on shark finning to make their livelihoods are able to make a larger profit from diving tours while protecting the local environment. People can get close to the sharks by free- or scuba diving or by entering the water in a protective cage for more aggressive species. Many of these dives are done by private companies and are often baited to ensure shark sightings, a practice which is highly controversial and under review in many areas.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Bob Halstead</span> Underwater photographer, author, journalist and commentator on the recreational diving industry.

Bob Halstead, has made significant contributions to the sport of scuba diving in a multitude of capacities: photographer, author of eight diving books, early innovator in the development of dive tourism, pioneer in the dive liveaboard industry, diving instructor and educator, marine-life explorer and influential diving industry commentator. An ardent diver since 1968, Halstead has over 10,000 logged dives.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Shark attacks in South Australia</span>

A total of 24 people have been killed by sharks in South Australian waters since the establishment of the colony in 1836. Prior to 2014, there had been 82 recorded shark attacks in South Australia. 20 of those have involved a single fatality. Victims were involved in a range of aquatic activities, including surfing, diving, spear-fishing, snorkeling, boating and swimming. Six of the fatalities occurred off the coast of greater metropolitan Adelaide, with the remainder distributed across South Australia's extensive coastline. Many of the fatal attacks have been attributed to great white sharks.

<i>Blue Water, White Death</i> 1971 American film

Blue Water, White Death is a 1971 American documentary film about sharks, which was directed by Peter Gimbel and James Lipscomb. It received favourable reviews and was described as a "well produced odyssey" and "exciting and often beautiful". It screened theatrically and was broadcast on television at various times during the 1970s and 1980s. The film was re-released on DVD in 2009.

Emma Forster is a South Australian television presenter, director of tourist attraction Swim with the Tuna and advisor for the company, Oceanic Victor. She lives in Port Lincoln where she has developed several properties. She has worked as a presenter on the seafood, fishing and boating television program Out of the Blue, is a friend and business advisor to multi-millionaire tuna rancher Tony Santic and is a former girlfriend of retired South Australian treasurer, Kevin Foley.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Outline of underwater diving</span> List of articles related to underwater diving grouped by topical relevance

The following outline is provided as an overview of and topical guide to underwater diving:

Diving support equipment is the equipment used to facilitate a diving operation. It is either not taken into the water during the dive, such as the gas panel and compressor, or is not integral to the actual diving, being there to make the dive easier or safer, such as a surface decompression chamber. Some equipment, like a diving stage, is not easily categorised as diving or support equipment, and may be considered as either.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Outline of recreational dive sites</span> Hierarchical outline list of articles about rereational dive sites

Recreational dive sites are specific places that recreational scuba divers go to enjoy the underwater environment or for training purposes. They include technical diving sites beyond the range generally accepted for recreational diving. In this context all diving done for recreational purposes is included. Professional diving tends to be done where the job is, and with the exception of diver training and leading groups of recreational divers, does not generally occur at specific sites chosen for their easy access, pleasant conditions or interesting features.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Scuba diving tourism</span> Industry based on recreational diver travel

Scuba diving tourism is the industry based on servicing the requirements of recreational divers at destinations other than where they live. It includes aspects of training, equipment sales, rental and service, guided experiences and environmental tourism.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Environmental impact of recreational diving</span> Effects of scuba diving on the underwater environment

The environmental impact of recreational diving is the effects of recreational scuba diving on the underwater environment, which is largely the effects of diving tourism on the marine environment. It is not uncommon for highly trafficked dive destinations to have more adverse effects with visible signs of diving's negative impacts due in large part to divers who have not been trained to sufficient competence in the skills required for the local environment, an inadequate pre-dive orientation, or lack of a basic understanding of biodiversity and the delicate balance of aquatic ecosystems. There may also be indirect positive effects as the environment is recognised by the local communities to be worth more in good condition than degraded by inappropriate use, and conservation efforts get support from dive communities who promote environmental awareness, and teach low impact diving and the importance of respecting marine life. There are also global coral reef monitoring networks in place which include local volunteer divers assisting in the collection of data for scientific monitoring of coral reef systems, which may eventually have a net positive impact on the environment.

<span class="mw-page-title-main">Valerie Taylor (diver)</span> Australian underwater photographer

Valerie May Taylor AM is an Australian conservationist, photographer, and filmmaker, and an inaugural member of the diving hall of fame. With her husband Ron Taylor, she made documentaries about sharks, and filmed sequences for films including Jaws (1975).

<i>Open Water 3: Cage Dive</i> 2017 Australian film

Open Water 3: Cage Dive is a 2017 Australian found footage survival horror film directed and written by Gerald Rascionato and released by Lionsgate as part of the Open Water film series, although the film is a stand-alone sequel and only connects to the other films in theme, not continuity. It follows a trio of Americans on vacation in Australia who are also filming an audition tape for an extreme reality TV show on a cage diving excursion. Before they know it, a rogue wave capsizes and sinks their boat leaving them stranded in the ocean. The film is presented as a mockumentary and perpetuated as true events; though most of the film is first person footage from the characters with time stamps throughout the film, in the vein of Paranormal Activity. The film bears similarities to another 2017 shark attack survival film featuring a cage dive excursion gone wrong, 47 Meters Down. The method of "cage dive disaster" in each film differs with Open Water 3: Cage Dive involving a rogue wave capsizing the boat while the former film sees a rusty winch break, trapping the protagonists underwater within the cage. The notable difference between these two films is that Cage Dive does not keep its protagonists within the cage, but rather leaves them in the open water among hungry sharks.

References

  1. "Maui not biting on toxic shark feeder bait". Cyber Diver News Network. July 10, 2009 Archived November 16, 2012, at the Wayback Machine
  2. Townsend, Allie (2011-08-01). "Top 10 Unforgettable Shark Moments". Time. ISSN   0040-781X . Retrieved 2017-07-22.
  3. "5 things you won't believe Jacques Cousteau put into the ocean". Trivia Happy. Retrieved 2017-07-22.
  4. "'White Death' film maker optimistic". Port Lincoln Times . Vol. XLIII, no. 2262. South Australia. 15 January 1970. p. 26. Retrieved 30 July 2023 via National Library of Australia.
  5. "The Shark Cage Was Invented By A Shark Attack Survivor". curiosity.com. Retrieved 2017-07-22.
  6. "Special diving elevators used in "Blue Water, White Death" (1971)". Abilene Reporter-News. 1971-08-08. p. 36. Retrieved 2017-07-22.
  7. "DEVICE MAY PROTECT FROM SHARK ATTACK". Port Lincoln Times . Vol. XLV, no. 2515. South Australia. 6 March 1975. p. 3. Retrieved 30 July 2023 via National Library of Australia.
  8. "SHARK-PROOF DIVER'S VEHICLE IS TESTED". Port Lincoln Times . Vol. XLVII, no. 2523. South Australia. 1 May 1975. p. 7. Retrieved 30 July 2023 via National Library of Australia.
  9. 1 2 3 4 5 "Patent 4166462" Archived 2012-10-07 at the Wayback Machine www.patentstorm.us
  10. McCarthy, Erin (6 August 2013). "8 Patents for Inventions that Purport to Protect You From Sharks". Mental Floss . Retrieved 25 June 2023.
  11. Australia. Fisheries Division (1975-10-01), "Fear of shark attack haunts abalone divers (1 October 1975)", Australian Fisheries, 34 (10), Fisheries Branch, Dept. of Primary Industry]: 4, ISSN   0004-9115
  12. 1 2 3 Jateff, Emily (12 September 2019). "Covering your tail: Inventing the self-propelled shark-proof cage". Signals Magazine. No. 127. Australian National Maritime Museum. pp. 58–61.
  13. "Answer found to shark menace". Evening News. Dunedin, New Zealand. 27 September 1977.
  14. "Inventions make for diver safety". Port Lincoln Times . Vol. 51, no. 2839. South Australia. 23 May 1980. p. 10. Retrieved 30 July 2023 via National Library of Australia.
  15. "Self-propelled shark proof cage | Works | The Collection | Australian National Maritime Museum". collections.anmm.gov.au. Australian National Maritime Museum. 2021-06-07. Archived from the original on 2021-06-06. Retrieved 2023-07-30 via National Library of Australia.
  16. 1 2 Shepherd, Tory (2017-05-01). "Spencer Gulf abalone divers warn cage diving is putting sharks in a feeding frenzy and risking lives". The Advertiser. Retrieved 2017-07-22.
  17. Zenato, Christina (18 May 2012). "Shark Diving, Shark Feeding, and Common Sense". Shark Savers. WildAid. Retrieved 26 March 2018.
  18. Bruce, Barry (Nov 2015). "A review of cage diving impacts on white shark behaviour and recommendations for research and the industry's management in New Zealand" (PDF). CSIRO Marine & Atmospheric Research. Retrieved 14 October 2016.
  19. Thiel, Gustav (27 December 2002). "I fought him off with my knees - shark victim". www.iol.co.za. Retrieved 9 February 2021.
  20. "Bathing banned after Cape Town shark attack". The Irish Times. 31 December 2002. Retrieved 25 March 2018.
  21. 1 2 "Stop Shark Cage Diving Say South Africa Shark Attack Victims". Cyber Diver News Network
  22. Bruce, B. D.; Bradford, R. W. (2013). "The effects of shark cage-diving operations on the behaviour and movements of white sharks, Carcharodon carcharias, at the Neptune Islands, South Australia". Mar Biol . 160 (4): 889–907. Bibcode:2013MarBi.160..889B. doi:10.1007/s00227-012-2142-z. S2CID   85411201.
  23. "He Almost Became Shark Food". CBS News . February 11, 2009. Retrieved 10 September 2012.
  24. 1 2 Jones, Sam (25 March 2005). "It was a real thrill, says tourist nearly eaten by 18ft great white shark". The Guardian. Retrieved 26 March 2018.
  25. Gabe and Garrett (13 October 2016). "Great White Shark Cage Breach Accident". Archived from the original on 2021-12-21 via YouTube.
  26. 1 2 "Tallman v MV "Shark Team" and Others (AC 40/2009) [2014] ZAWCHC 202 (23 December 2014)". www.saflii.org. Retrieved 2023-10-20.
  27. "Tallman v MV "Shark Team" and Others (AC 40/2009) [2014] ZAWCHC 202 (23 December 2014)". www.saflii.mobi. Retrieved 2021-03-27.
  28. "Shark cage breach diver escaped out of a hole at the bottom, but faced two more sharks". Stuff. 15 October 2016. Retrieved 2018-05-11.

Further reading